HONEST REACTION to [MV] 마마무(MAMAMOO) - Wind flower

[@CINDYJCABRERA]

And the best thing of Mamamoo is that they’re even better singing live. You can feel the pasion in their singing, they’re amazing

[@abner3857]

For me, this song makes me feel nostalgic, sad and happy at the same time, it's a masterpiece.

[@Genera1007]

This is a high quality mv. It was filmed in Hong Kong. A lot of the scenes were homages to a famous Hong Kong movie producer(not famous enough that I remember the name). The song is a breakup song, and each of the girls display different was to cope/react. Until the end where the get together with friends. So well put together.

[@alicealiencat]

the Hongkong producer's name is "wong kar wai"director, screenwriter, and producer.Wong consolidated his worldwide reputation with the 1997 drama Happy Together, for which he won Best Director at the Cannes Film Festival.

[@Genera1007]

thanks Alice

[@michellep3183]

@@alicealiencat I swear I was gonna mention him because I’m a big cinephile and a sucker for Wong kar especially fallen angels,Chungking express,first love,in the mood for love and so much more ,the vivid cinematography,the bold saturation and whole mood of this mv reminded me of him 😭😭

[@alicealiencat]

@@michellep3183 me 2,

[@commander_fangirl1638]

@@michellep3183 Exactly! He's one of my favourite directors and I absolutely love all his movies. MAMAMOO and Song Yuqi's MVs lead me to him and I ended up downloading all his movies and watching one every weekend.

[@kh4ks927]

MAMAMOO is having a COMEBACK this 15th with the song "mumumumuch" as the title track, the album is a collection of their hit songs and songs loved by the fans (re-recorded on new version) + 2 new songs (mumumumuch and Happier than ever), the album has a total of 23 songs to celebrate their 7 years as a group

[@melissacan54]

yesss can’t wait

[@mariaup537]

Wind Flower is one of the re recorded songs!! I'm sooo happy!!

[@kpopism5949]

Yesss!!

[@alleydungeon]

For me, rather than each of them facing the breakup in different ways I read it more like how each member represent different stages. 1. Solar was really upset and hurt over the breakup. Just right after it happens, the brokenness. 2. Moonbyul pretending to be fine - just like her rap lyrics 3. Wheein - stage of letting go. you see how she smash that flower onto the fence real hard and trying to get back with life 4. Hwasa - being able to finally let go, move on and celebrate from it. That's also the sequence of the whole taxi scene. Solar getting onto the car, byul appeared in it and solar leaning against her. Then moonbyul looking out of the window, transitioning to Wheein and lastly, Hwasa getting off the car. Representing the end of the journey. Wind flower is very special to many moos and to MMM as well. not forgetting the actual 'windflowers' serves as a reminder to enjoy the moment in order to take in opportunities at the right time. And also the arrival of spring breeze - just like a new start. love love love the song!

[@kidcaptainwembri]

Oh I love your take! 💙

[@lightwaffle9016]

Woah it actually makes sense like that👏🏻

[@rafikrahali9235]

It's an underappreciated song sadly got no wins It's really my fav song of Mamamoo

[@yooahae]

This was filmed in Hong Kong! I heard it's a tribute for Hong Kong filmmaker/director Wong Kar-wai. most of his films have this color and vibe.

[@shekinaheve442]

This is one of the rare songs where it sounds happy when you are happy and it sounds sad when you are sad (just like Happening by Akmu)

[@platypusbear-v2b]

Interesting observation! It does have a bittersweet vibe - melancholy tinged with something like optimism?

[@GavinFox2028]

This was my uncle’s favourite Mamamoo song. He always play it every night.

[@wheesamoonsun3388]

Ur uncle got good taste in music

[@GavinFox2028]

@@wheesamoonsun3388 thank you 🙏

[@daniellxnder]

Hello fellow cultured men!

[@dewiayuritonga6588]

Vocal Queens. Unmatched. Authenticity is their game. Doesn't really follow the industry. Stand out at their own sound. Four distinct fabulous voices with great musicality. True artists.

[@michellep3183]

Period . No 🧢

[@williammatheus2685]

"Decalcomanie" needs to be next! Is so good

[@loliaa9112]

I think all of us waiting to killing voice😂💜

[@ELmayberry]

true... also that reaction(if he does react to it) would be over an hour long 😆

[@loliaa9112]

That's right😂😂

[@loliaa9112]

But every time i saw video to reaction to mamamoo i get excited thinking that's the killing voice😂

[@loliaa9112]

Please aaron do it as fast as you can💜💜💜

[@solar_n_mmm]

We got immortal songs medley too

[@moodishmememoo4028]

Hi Aaron. The Mv location is filmed in Hong Kong.

[@AnnaS-sl7sf]

Mamamoo's entire discography is so diverse that every song is such a different experience. I really recommend (for newer fans especially) to get/listen to the I SAY MAMAMOO: THE BEST ALBUM. Out on September 15. It's a remastered compilation album that consists of 23 songs including their best hits. I think what makes Mamamoo different from your typical girl group is their musicality and if you're someone who appreciates music you will surely love the album! 👏🏻

[@steph66062]

Not sure if you noticed, but the ice cream scene at the end of the Where Are We Now MV was a reference to the end of this video!

[@krysivory493]

I just can't imagine how far they'd go if RBW promotes them better. They deserve better.

[@to0muchtoan]

This song should have gotten more exposure than it did. It's so freaking good and easily top 5 MMM track for me.

[@Ketchu-p]

It's not Tokyo, that's definitely Hong Kong.

[@sofichinipalli7848]

Wind flower is one of my favorite songs by Mamamoo and is a hard choice. The feeling of classic movies. They filmed in Hong Kong, you should see the live stages, is unique and nostalgic :)

[@thursdayschildhasfartogo]

man it makes me sad how underrated this song is :(

[@yaroyaro9533]

Pd-nim reacted to this before, you can check out their MV analysis! Also, this is no joke one of their bests, but it's very underappreciated. People might be a bit underwhelmed because this was the comeback after Egotistic (if I'm not mistaken), but it's still top tier 👑👑

[@gustavonascimento7036]

one of the best songs of mamamoo

[@absenci]

mamamoo is a very versatile group

[@mmmysd4389]

Wind Flower is the best song of Mamamoo but is ignored for the fandom ;( Is a masterpiece

[@majejavier161]

MAMAMOO Introduction part 1 and 2 please..

[@puhl9480]

This is my favorite song by Mamamoo. It’s so nostalgic and I don’t even know what or who I miss when I listen to it

[@geniusarmystaymidzyshawool1848]

The neon socks in the introduction actually reminded of them wearing neon clothes to IU's concert because her light stick is of neon colour 😍

[@dasc0yne]

The aesthetic is actually designed to conjure look of Hong Kong cinema in 1990's. Take a look at films of Wong Kar-wai and John Woo from the 1990's and you will see the influence. The HK noir of the 1990's has a beautiful urban solitude that was perfect for this song. Check out Wong Kar-wai's Chunking Express.

[@L0VEST4Y]

I was literally SO HAPPY to see another Mamamoo reaction

[@SapiaNt0mata]

happy for what? he didn't like the song.

[@L0VEST4Y]

@@SapiaNt0mata I know but that’s fine. I just want Mamamoo to get more exposure. He has such a large following, so people are bound to see them. Just because he doesn’t like it doesn’t mean others won’t. It’s always good for people to react to them. I have faith that once someone gets into them, it’s really hard to get out :)

[@SapiaNt0mata]

@@L0VEST4Y mate, if Mamamoo don't do live shows, etc in the West they won't get exposure. even though these videos bring some people, their youtube channel is stuck at 6 million subscriber for over 1 year. Blackpink made a live show in Coachella and got millions of subscribers. the exposure comes from live shows, etc and not from youtube reactors. he has big following, but from these views almost all are already Mamamoo fans. as you can see he's not into Mamamoo. he likes a few songs here and there but he will never be a fan cause Mamamoo is not for him. he said he prefers songs like Where Are We Now, and these songs are very very very few compared to the whole discography of Mamamoo.

[@L0VEST4Y]

@@SapiaNt0mata mate, the reason why they have a stagnant following for the past year is because of the fandom wars that happened LAST YEAR which made them lose many fans and also become out of radar for a while. I don’t wanna go in too deep (you can check the entire thing on twitter and stuff) but they were accused of being racist - which is totally untrue. This is because Hwasa wore a pocahontas dress for dinga’s halloween version, which made ppl hate on her. Before that, a few years back, there was a blackface incident where they wore dark skin makeup while singing bruno mars for their audience. All of these incidents which stemmed from their ignorance resulted in a loss of international fans, which made their youtube have a stagnant subscription. So sure, a part of this may be because they haven’t been doing lives (which is really not their fault but their agency’s and covid’s) but also the amount of hate they received over the past year. Especially Hwasa who was constantly hated on by Blackpink fans as Jennie’s “copycat” which is SO untrue considering their different styles and music. BUT ANYWAY, I still don’t get your point. Sure, I see this reaction and Aaron doesn’t like it. But the fact that it has so many views and likes makes me HAPPY because yes, although Mamamoo may have made a mistake with culture appropriation, they are innocent due to their ignorance. They have timely apologized and deleted all these clips, but HATERS KEEP HATING on them, which has vastly affected their popularity. So yeah, excuse me if I feel happy knowing that there are still moomoos left in this world 🙃

[@sitisarah5137]

this song is very special to me, its help me go through the breakup phase and comfort me ~ its the song tht get me to Mamamoo❤️

[@tillywilson6038]

My favourite MMM song, besides waggy of course

[@sweetmimosamommysaranghae3163]

^

[@prakharjyoti9033]

I would highly recommend you to react to their live performances. They just go wild live. Some of my favs- Immortal Songs Medley. Destiny Queendom performance. I Miss You Queendom performance. MAMA 2018 Japan and 2019 as well. And yes they are also having a comeback on 15th this month.

[@alexakie3433]

The MV represents different ways to experience a heartbreak to moving on in different people. Hehehe In my interpretation: Solar - your lost Whee in - may be in next life Hwasa- have fun/ life continues Moon byul - really sad/ depress

[@alexakie3433]

Their songs are timelesss

[@stivenmartinezsoto5677]

ART!!

[@abgailramos4584]

MAMAMOO Introduction part 1 and 2 please..by purple hawker

[@johanmat2112]

Wind Flower is the best title track by Mamamoo & somehow the most underrated as well.

[@smbfor1769]

The song has strong autumn vibe. I love it.

[@rantmachine2245]

Yay! Windflower one of my faves. ♥️ Don't forget to put on your list: -I miss you, Queendom live performance -Immortal Songs medley

[@sulagnadasgupta8415]

ONE OF MY FAVOURITE MAMAMOO SONGS THE CHOREOGRAPHY IS TOO CUTEE 🥺

[@mistrae7]

Wind flower is one of the best songs to ever exist

[@fouraces3761]

You have reacted most of the killing voice medley songs Aaron! I think at this point, it's fine if you straight away react to the medley~ You can always react to the MVs afterwards ~ But maybe you can react to gogobebe first to complete all their 4 season 4 colors title tracks! Mr. Ambiguous Egotistic✅ Decalcomanie Starry Night✅ Wind Flower✅ I Miss You HIP✅ gogobebe Dingga✅ AYA ✅

[@SapiaNt0mata]

and he only liked Aya. he didn't like Egotistic, Hip, Dingga, Starry Night, Wind Flower. his reaction to Killing Voices won't be what you want when he doesn't like most of the songs it has.

[@bengisu1182]

Pleeasee react to their Killing Voice! It's completely live you need to hear their vocals!

[@SapiaNt0mata]

he didn't like Egotistic, Hip, Dingga, Starry Night, Wind Flower that are in Killing Voices. his reaction to Killing Voices won't be what you want when he doesn't like most of the songs that it has.

[@bengisu1182]

@@SapiaNt0mata i know... You are right but the point of the killing voice is to hear their vocals and harmony live

[@SapiaNt0mata]

@@bengisu1182 but he doesn't like their songs. if he doesn't like their songs what's the point to hear him say they have good voices? don't you already know this? why you want him to validate something you already know? if he liked their songs it would be a different case, but he doesn't.

[@bengisu1182]

@@SapiaNt0mata dude can you just keep calm😂 why are so mad? It is just a simple recommendation. If he doesnt like it is ok. At least he is not acting like he loves every song like some reaction channels. Thats why i love honest reactions. People dont have to like every song from a specific artist.

[@SapiaNt0mata]

@@bengisu1182 who said i'm mad? get real. trying to make me look like the bad guy by saying i'm mad? this tactic ain't working to me. he dislikes 6 songs of Mamamoo and likes 2. he prefers the girlish concept with high pitch vocals like Twice. Mamamoo that do the exact opposite is not for him so he does these reactions for the views. i don't like this group of people.

[@maulisasarasiyaputri1293]

This song is my Favorite as soon i heard it

[@lillerin__4666]

This is my favorite Mamamoo song and what made me a true fan.

[@echodvc4543]

Excited every time I see you post a new Mamamoo reaction! Wind Flower is definetly one of my favorite MVs.

[@SapiaNt0mata]

from the 8 songs he reacted he only liked 2. dunno how you're excited.

[@echodvc4543]

@@SapiaNt0mata I think he likes 3 or 4 actually. But I'm excited every time because they're my favorite group and he's one of my favorite reactors. Simple 🙂

[@SapiaNt0mata]

@@echodvc4543 nope. he only liked Aya and Where Are We Now. the 1st he did was Egotistic, and he didn't like it to the point he deleted the video.

[@echodvc4543]

@@SapiaNt0mata and he mentioned in the past that he heard Hip and liked it, and in this video he likes Wind Flower as well. Thus 4.

[@SapiaNt0mata]

@@echodvc4543 he didn't like Hip, and he doesn't like Wind Flower. he said he likes the visuals of the MV. not the song.

[@lauraelena_]

Thank you for reacting to MAMAMOO! ❤️

[@roz200r9]

more Mamamoo please 🥺

[@maheeneatazaz4872]

I didn't like this song at first AT ALL but believe me when I say I fell in LOVE after 5 to 6 listens and this song is now one of my absolute favs

[@custardeggcream822]

This is Hong Kong, scenes in the mv are inspired by Wong Kar-wai's movies

[@lowlife_princess]

Been waiting for this one

[@luciaratih6485]

Love your reaction 🤩 yes more mamamoo ❤️❤️

[@johannacusmecampos8125]

This song is beautiful, my fav

[@khol1239]

Thank u for ur reaction Mamamoo is coming with a knew album "I say Mamamoo " 15 September

[@priyanshichauhan9604]

Introducing Mamamoo by Purple Hwake 💜

[@tinggarpradipta4486]

Get better day by day 🌬️🌹

[@bangtwicemoo2590]

Hey Aaron, aside from MV's please react also to MAMAMOO Introduction Part 1&2. Thank you

[@joet.7980]

My favorite Mamamoo song and video. Actually it's filmed in Hong Kong, not Tokyo

[@martina3562]

Even if i have never been in a relationship , this lyrics always hits hard.

[@yoocs9670]

Wind Flower 'The Best' version (Live concert ver.) is very special impressive, It would be nice reacting together🙏🙏 (same as AYA traditional ver.)🤗

[@absenci]

my fav mv

[@1ananas2bananes]

This was one of the first mamamoo songs I ever listened to around November of 2019. It has been my fave ever since then ❤️❤️

[@Riux-o6i]

I miss you will give you chillss😗😗😗😗

[@allx2226]

I say mamamoo the best ✨💯

[@김주현-e8w]

mamamoo greatest vocals 👍💜💚❤

[@swastikcat]

Now only Decalcomanie and gogobebe are left before u can react to mamamoo killing voice We can leave Mr.Ambiguous and I Miss You as a surprise

[@Sunny-ll3nc]

thank u!!!

[@BSXENO]

12:24 I watched this MV super many times and watched reaction VDO of this MV from many channels, but this is my first time recognising 1theK were there!!!!

[@rarodri5410]

Sameeee

[@Sam-fp4sh]

Please react to MAMAMOO killing voice on Dingo pleaaase I'M BEGGING YOU 😭😭

[@SapiaNt0mata]

he didn't like Egotistic, Hip, Dingga, Starry Night, Wind Flower that are in Killing Voice. his reaction to Killing Voice won't be what you expect when he doesn't like most of the songs that it has.

[@Sam-fp4sh]

@@SapiaNt0mata I am shooked 😱😢 all these songs are so catchy & amazing ... he doesn't have taste 😂😂 ( & I'm sorry to say that) everyone has his own type of music that he likes

[@SapiaNt0mata]

@@Sam-fp4sh me too. i didn't expect to not like any of these, and he also didn't like Wanna Be Myself. i didn't mention it in the previous comment cause it's not in Killing Voice song list. btw, when he reacted to Egotistic he didn't like it to the point he deleted the reaction videos.

[@Sam-fp4sh]

@@SapiaNt0mata Omg 😱😱 that's horrible ! But what can we do is just respect his opinion. I suggested "killing voice" to him so that he can discover the power of Mamamoo's VOICES & to see that they are different from other bands.

[@SapiaNt0mata]

@@Sam-fp4sh he already knows that Mamamoo are different than other groups. in 1 of his reaction videos of Mamamoo songs he said they're voices are more mature and not high pitched like the girlish high pitch concept. and that's why he doesn't like Mamamoo songs. he prefers the girlish concept with high pitch vocals like Twice for example. and what's the point to hear him say about their voices when he doesn't like the songs? why you want this validation from someone that doesn't like Mamamoo? the only good thing he said about Wind Flower is for the MV. it's obvious that Mamamoo songs are not for him.

[@sakm1164]

MAMAMOO COMEBACK 15 september 💚💚💚

[@rihanna.arabic]

Mamamoo comeback on September 15 !💙

[@letiziacoriat8429]

yeiiiiiiii more mamamoo love you aron

[@lightwaffle9016]

One of my fav MAMAMOO song AND mv!! This song never gets old, i can play it everyday and sing along&dance along to it, whether i'm or sad👍🏻

[@vn4934]

This song is sooo beautiful ✨🤗... You need to Reach to Um oh ah ya... By mamamoo it's MV is soooo good, you will literally fall from your seat while watching... It's hilarious 😂.. Please react to it..

[@WendyXIA-qg6zg]

This mv was made in HongKong~ Beautiful city^ ^

[@marinateixeira3637]

i love that i always bark for moonbyul in this mv, like- i can't with her

[@taliversx5877]

BEST MV EVERRRRR

[@lascrea8828]

more Mamamoo please

[@Riux-o6i]

Or mamamoo killing voice 💖💖💖

[@lvehaerin]

I'm getting a feeling Solar is gonna be Aaron's bias😁

[@laxxyd7447]

It's a sad but hopeful song for me

[@adiriawaruwu6860]

You should def check their recent album, it's fiiiireeeeeeeee

[@박시랑-r3n]

5:21 it's got an old fashioned barber shop vibe, with the lights and tiles. Both men and women can get haircuts at the same hair salon now, but there still are men (ex.my dad) who would just go to the barber for many reasons. I'm pretty sure barber shop's not a Korean thing though the interior design could differ..

[@mamamoohwasa9314]

omg yes!!

[@kavook9803]

React to all MVs and then live performance of dingo

[@lesliemorales2951]

como siempre me encantan tus reacciones debes seguir siempre

[@moomoofromindia496]

Thanks for the reaction !!! MAMAMOO is coming back on 15.09.2021 6PM KST with "I SAY MAMAMOO : THE BEST" album which comprises of rearranged versions of 21 of their hit & popular songs + 2 new songs Title track "MUMUMUMUCH" This is to commemorate their 7th anniversary.... Please react to the full album if possible !!! Thanks again..

[@melissacan54]

please more mamamoo reaction video

[@kevinchang4827]

To Aaron, it was shoot in HONG KONG

[@Riux-o6i]

React to mamamoo I miss you💗💗💗

[@nevan1778]

Not Tokyo,this mv was shot in hong kong

[@johannacusmecampos8125]

PLEASE AARON REACT TO INTRODUCING MAMAMOO Its HILARIOUS!!!!!!!!!

[@luzdemilagrosbarbaranguerr8591]

Yes I am, next video, please.

[@plsfia4363]

💚💚💚

[@gymnopedie1438]

🎶MAMAMOO COMEBACK🎶 I SAY MAMAMOO : BEST ALBUM OUT ON 15TH SEPTEMBER 6PM KST 🔥 #MAMAMOO #HWASA #WHEEIN #SOLAR #MOONBYUL

[@rarodri5410]

Well according to your taste I think you should react to songs like: I miss you Paint me Destiny I love too Angel Those are some of my favorites where they show their vocals and has mv or performance videos Then B-sides I personally love Hello Mama ♡ Also I think you may like Moonbyuls eclipse since it has a darker concept ... Anyway I will suscribe to check your other reactions

[@cloudiaxu1673]

This mv was filmed in China Hong Kong~

[@minaliskiemelia2248]

Please check out Paint Me

[@ganyumain7408]

Not him not once complimenting their godly voices and vocals,im so disappointed. He only appreciated tge video

[@SapiaNt0mata]

from the 8 songs of Mamamoo he has reacted he only likes 2 and dislikes the other 6. he do it for the views.

[@jeonjungkookluvalukook388]

Favourite girl group FOREVER #mamamoo 😙queen of voice Please make a reaction video about wheein's s """ Water colour ""💔🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏😘