Vocal Coach Reacts to Madonna 'Bad Girl' Celebration Tour Opening Night

*Georgina Vlog Channel: / honestvocalcoachvlog
*Crystals & Psychic Products Shop:
spiritpsychiccrystalhealing.com
*Request a Reaction: honestvocalcoach.co.uk/reacti...
*Cameo - Personal Messages, Happy Birthdays etc
www.cameo.com/honestvocalcoac...
*TikTok: / honestvocalcoach
*Instagram: / thehonestvocalcoach
*My linktree: linktr.ee/honestvocalcoach
*Website: www.honestvocalcoach.co.uk
#honestvocalcoach #vocalcoachreacts #madonna
*FAIR USE*
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research.

[@mlvc82]

Can we all just appreciate and LOVE her finally? After 40 years on top..after almost losing her this past year can we just LOVE HER FOR ONCE! For all the incredible work/performances/music/art she’s given us?

[@agnesm_23]

We always have

[@Lauralootoyou]

What are you talking about?! Love her for once?! Are you for real?! This amazing woman has had a hell of a lot of love & support from her subscribers on here & other platforms so please get your facts right first before you make your comments. She will always have love & support from her subscribers as well as her family & friends.

[@Lauralootoyou]

​@Strikeapose21 yes we have, thank you!

[@luispineda9255]

I totally agree with your comment. She is and will always be a trail blazer no matter what negative people say.

[@PlantioDaddio]

Madonna was, is, and always will be amazing!!! ❤

[@moodyseb]

She actually performed the song live at SNL in 1993

[@sarge9733]

And it was amazing. With a proper live band too, which wasn't even the case on the record.. Iconic performance, that I just happened to watch earlier tonight! Still love it.

[@michaelmoody2278]

Spoken like a true fan!

[@jamieconiam760]

And she struggled then

[@vistaprime]

@@jamieconiam760 I thought she was fine. but wasn't that 1992.

[@DJLORX]

​@@jamieconiam760that's the reason why she's now singing this song in a lower key

[@rafaelli5852]

She’s singing live more than in other tours, that’s perfectly enough for me. She’s singing Bad Girl and Rain!!! That makes it for me, don’t care if she does it all live or not.❤

[@trevorbayers2175]

No shes not

[@FelipeGarciaQuintino]

​@@trevorbayers2175yes she is, like It or not

[@kumada84]

​@@FelipeGarciaQuintino No, he's right, but not for the reason he thinks - she isn't singing live "more" than she has in other concerts because she's rarely ever not sung live in any of her shows. (I think I can count on one hand the number of times she's lip synced songs in her shows.)

[@lauras3612]

It's all pretaped and lip-synched

[@framch30]

@@lauras3612did you attend any of these concerts? I attended 4 and multiple times I heard her voice go, get a bit hoarse, not sound the best at certain moments etc it was live with pre recorded live vocals

[@richardhutchings4324]

This song live and her unfiltered look is a real highlight of the show!

[@Neonlike0]

Except it wasn't live.

[@jamieconiam760]

No, it’s partly live, partly mimed

[@robinshaul4069]

😂😂😂

[@AlexeBriand2002]

@@jamieconiam760she sings over her own vocal guide

[@FelipeGarciaQuintino]

​@@Neonlike0except u wish that

[@johnramirez2917]

Whether she's singing completly live or not I'm quite sure fans don't really care. She's fabulous, her show is to die for and she's doing the best that she can. Let's do not forget she's 65 and she's been sick so we only should have respect for this incredible living legend.

[@kbhprinsesse]

"She's doing the best she can"? Ok. So people should just fork out very high prices for her tickets without any demands?

[@brcorreia77]

Easy ...dont see or listen. The fans will appretiate

[@banbbc2921]

@@kbhprinsesseyou definitely don’t buy her tickets;) people who bought tickets expected half live half lip syn for this concert, at least I did , and also go to watch the performance and Madonna . If you watch Britney spear , you expected full lips sync . Since you don’t even buy the tickets why do you say a thing on that ;) Many concerts are half live half lips sync , it’s super normal

[@aidenplaysyt2613]

You inhumane HUMAN! WTF @@kbhprinsesse

[@RDrRD1989]

Madonna is amazing!❤ And she is singing live!

[@cizar2000]

The vocals are so incredible for Madonna.

[@shockalockabocka]

I noticed she sings most of the ballads live bc her, naturally deepened from age, voice still works with them. I even synced them up w the original recordings to double check. It’s so moving, bc I love and I know she loves her ballads. Live to Tell and Rain got me emotional! They’re some of my faves.

[@LENCARTER2003]

I love those two and they get me chocked up as well!

[@deantailor357]

I think people get really hung up (see what I did there?) on comparing the tour version with the single/album "recording". It's not about that. Once Madonna decides what songs she wants to perform, and the order and interludes she wants to perform, they go to a sound stage or aircraft hanger and literally put the show together, including "live" recording all of the tracks. It's these that are then blended with her on the night mic vocal so what you hear coming out of the speakers is sometimes what she puts in on the night, and sometimes what she puts in on the night mixed with the pre-recorded tour vocal. Also, what you hear as an audience member is significantly different to what you would hear in these videos because those are recorded from the crowd, so you pick up all the reverb and ambient noise. This is just the way it's done now, but nobody talks about it. The last truly "live" show she did was Blond Ambition. Most of Drowned World was too, but by then you had the technology to do so much more and she used it. Ultimately, it doesn't matter as you go for the performance and not the vocal. This isn't an operatic recital nor does it claim to be. Yes, I was there, yes it sounded live, but with everyone singing (badly), it's very hard to hear.

[@blakey2408]

I went to opening night and was pretty close. I would say that this video wasn’t the best quality to be able to truly hear her vocals… you could even hear people having a convo 😂 But what I can tell you is that it was absolutely phenomenal 🤩 Vocally she was better than she has been in a long time, which I was worried about following her illness. There was an issue with the sound during “Burning Up” and you could hear the track was faster than her live vocals, so 100% she’s singing live. They had to restart the sound and she spoke about her days struggling in her band for 10 mins! It was fab!! ❤ No live band, apart from the odd guitar and the piano during Bad Girl played by her daughter Mercy. All tracks from original recordings, but do include the backing vocals. Which there’s always been. She sounded awesome. Long live the queen👑

[@skygazer6898]

She had a bacterial infection, I can almost guarantee it was a UTI and they can be a killer when it gets into the bloodstream

[@kriswintle9453]

❤❤❤❤❤

[@lespaulx]

I was there front row and it was definitely live vocals during the whole Bad Girl performance, her lips, breath and moves matched perfectly the vocals, regardless if it was the bridge or other parts of the song

[@mpinchi3433]

The was her daughter playing piano too. Madonna is the Queen!!

[@anonymouslee8287]

That word "Queen" is overrated!!!….

[@martinanugent5045]

Not when you're talking about Madonna,she's known at Queen of Pop. Beyonce calls her Queenother.

[@marion6319]

@@martinanugent5045 Queen Mother

[@marion6319]

@@anonymouslee8287 She's the queen of popular music, first than all those young women that are out nowadays.

[@scarahjolielaide]

Lourdes was playing piano?? Nooooo

[@Miguel-dy4if]

She is killing it on this tour . Thanks a lot for reacting to this.

[@AppleCinnamon1]

To me being a best singer means being in touch with the strength of one's voice qualities. She is a great storytelling performance singer. She has her own rules and doesn't follow other's choir school rules.

[@detoxmuscle]

This is such a sophisticated, sexy and adult ballad. One of the most very best. ❤

[@michaelmcdonald2326]

I've always thought she lip-synced the rap/spoken part in Vogue but the other night in Antwerp she was having audio issues and during that part she says "I can't hear myself" to her team instead of singing the lyrics. I was actually shocked that it was live. Anyway, I've seen the Celebration Tour three times now and it's just so good. She's coming back to London in December for two shows, you should try and get a ticket!

[@WhatsInAN8me]

The spoken word part in Vogue where she names all the Icons has been live this tour which I was surprised as I think this is the first tour where that has happened.

[@gpvelev]

I believe this is the first time she doesn't lip-sync the spoken part in Vogue. Even on Sticky & Sweet it was pre-recorded

[@Mark-zb3ow]

Surprised me too I’ve never heard her sing that part live either

[@robertfraser9873]

Stuart Price has confirmed that M is singing live throughout the show. There is a vocal recording for the spoken word parts of Erotica (she sings the chorus live) and Justify my Love is pre recorded. He said that people have come up to him after the show at the mixing desk and said "come on she's mining" and he said I swear every part is live (with the exception of the previous mentioned). He confirmed that she has 🐝 working with her vocal coach again for this tour. For the first time since 2004's Re-Invention Tour. ❤️❤️ It would be great to get your perspective of the Live to Tell performance. She sounds great and the staging is just heartbreaking. ❤️❤️

[@CarlosAcosta-tk4vh]

I agree! Her ballads are completely underrated. She has morphed her voice in so many ways to show vulnerability and have a distinct conviction, it’s really telling of her workmanship, vision and beautiful voice. Maybe not the strongest voice, but we have opera singers for that! Madonna goes above and beyond just a voice. She’s an artist of magnificent multitudes! Also, you can still go see her! Where do you live? Isn’t she going back to London?

[@Chelaxim]

Both Bad Girl and Bedtime Stories are two songs she only sang once on TV and never in a set list until now.

[@chocolatnoir1108]

correctly. I think we should add Nothing Really Matters -never been in a tour.

[@Aleksandr017]

@@chocolatnoir1108I haven’t fact-checked it but wasn’t Nothing Really Matters on the Drowned Tour?

[@riyad8862]

@@Aleksandr017Nope, she only did it once at the Grammy’s. And btw Drowned World was my first ever Madonna’s tour.

[@HenryCLHarries]

Love the love for Madonna this tour, love the Erotica era representation too it's like THE HITS tour but with a difference , a hits your only Madonna could do , so fab hearing her do Bad Girl, Rain, In This Life from Erotica and also Bedtime Story which looks so srty , excellent stuff. So proud of her

[@Mariejjjj]

I love her voice no matter what. Madonna is the best. Queen forever! ♥️👑

[@lamusiclover2264]

Ive watched various tapes of this tour. I can tell you that she is not lip syncing. She cant move or dance much due to her knee, so she is singing live, but there is an optional backing track that occasionally accompanies her, but to me this is mostly live. There is no live band, Stuart Price said he created the prerecorded entire concert track, with occasionally has some background vocals recorded as well. I think she gave the best live vocals since " Blind Ambition". Yes, she lio synced plenty in the past, but I think she's using her inability to move as much as an opportunity to do more good live vocals. There are so many concert videos posted. Watch the Ines that are from up close where you can see her lips. This is cell phone sound. Now I'm sure they'll mess with and re-do her vocals in the studio for the concert video or film, and it will not sound as life because they always make it sound too perfect.

[@monikel]

When it's not lipsinked, it's autotuned.

[@georgegeorgiev3946]

Mate, most of the songs are lipsynched on her tour. I've been a musician for years...the vocal coach is a true professional. We can pick up these things. She was flat when she sang live. She only sang a few phrases live.

[@MartinSmith156]

​@@monikelhuh? You can't autotune live vocals . Also autotune didn't come out until 1998, it didn't start to be widely used until the mid 2000s

[@MartinSmith156]

​@@georgegeorgiev3946so you saw this concert which only did about 5 performances so far live? Madonna only lips on occasion, I've seen plenty of live vocals from her towards the end of her tours and she sounds bad but it's still LIVE

[@user-vd9ml5jz8y]

Has the vocal coach sold over 300 million albums? @@georgegeorgiev3946

[@arthurdaniels3559]

I think Madonna has shown from this tour that she doesn't have to sing all upbeat songs full of dancing...I always wondered how enjoyable a slowed down show with more slower songs would go with Madonna - but very happily I can say that she really impressed me when I was at the o2 watching her live. Great stage presence. I saw Rebel Heart tour live and also madam x tour live too. Im a huge fan and loved all the ballads in Celebration tour ... loved the whole show 🎉❤🎉

[@b.k8051]

I saw Madonna in concert during her Reinvention tour. One thing I can say about Madonna is that she's obviously a perfectionist. Her tour was like a Swiss clock. And her vocals appeared to be all live and sounded very good

[@mpinchi3433]

lucky!! ive only seen rebel heart.. it was spectacular

[@davidcrazyrides]

That was back in 04 when she was on her game now she not

[@jamieconiam760]

No, it wasn’t live. She re-records the vocals for concerts so they sound different to the original recording

[@cody7378]

@@davidcrazyrides but u r still here watching tho aren't cha🤔

[@jamieconiam760]

@@cody7378 Yeah, I think she’s great, but facts are important too. 😂

[@DIETRICHCICCONE]

I saw the third London show and the first in Copenhagen. Her voice has never sounded so good - I guess it's because she's now letting her dancers do the heavy-lifting ❤️

[@johnpaulward8749]

I love when you review Madonna! You’re always fair and honest even if it slightly dents the pride of us Madonna lovers. I’d love to see more of your reactions from her past eras. She had such an interesting vocal range and style trajectory from the 80s to the late 90s. You’re correct, it’s an intricate mix of live vocal and backtrack/ lip sync that’s tailored to her current abilities. She’s given us years and years of amazing and inspirational dance music and live performances. At this point in her career I just want her to have fun and enjoy herself on the stage. If momma wants to catch her breath and lip sync a number, GO FOR IT!

[@cookiedais]

I was there & it was a real fun show , u could definitely tell that she was lip syncing at parts & when she was REALLY singing over a backing track . I also think as long as people don’t expect Blonde ambition levels of high energy dancing for hours like young Madonna then they will enjoy it . I had a great time .P.S. I wasn’t going to go as I had become less of a fan over the last few years , however my ticket was gifted to me & I’m so glad I went as it takes u back to your childhood listening to the old hits & it is much better in person than when u see phone clips . If u get the chance to go please do as it was just so much fun , the mixes were fab , she sang well for the most part & of course her dancers are the best in the business as usual x

[@michaelmoody2278]

She was 34 during Blond Ambition! She's such an amazing human being.

[@vistaprime]

@@michaelmoody2278 it was 1990 she was 32 and was 31 when it kicked off. She was 34 during the Girlie Show.

[@skygazer6898]

perfectly summed up.

[@capboy2104]

I went to this tour in Copenhagen few weeks ago and she was actually singing LIVE in most of her songs, and in this song in particular, she was LIVE.

[@thejordyjoansofficial]

I saw this live and it was unbelievably good, raw and one of my faves. I was so surprised she did it, the proper die hard Madge fans were singing along. 😍I think it was also beautiful she had one of her kids playing the piano!

[@escapingboredom6958]

I cant wait to see her

[@jurgenparys8209]

I absolutely love this song and her performance. The concert was phenomenal. Loved every second of it. Madonna is a legend

[@ns9352]

I adore this song - always been one of my faves. So nice to see her singing it live after so long!

[@thelanguageworker1616]

For 36 years I have been living and breathing this woman's work. Thank you so much for this - it's so refreshing to hear people who know what they are talking about. It's not 100% live, but going to a Madonna show is a full-circle experience, being a Madonna fan is a full-circle experience - Thank you so much for looking at what is relevant, interesting and real. RESPECT

[@rtncg]

Such a powerful song. I don't know if it's full live or not but it feels amazing. She sounds more exciting than her last 4 tours. I'm very happy not to hear any autotune in this tour yet.

[@davidm823]

I attended the show last night in Montreal. It was a show-stopping spectacle! ❤🎉 very story telling, she never fails to amaze me with her creativity and energy on stage. Definitely worth every penny 💰

[@michellepearsonW3]

I’ve been to every show since 2004 including The Celebration Tour. Bad girl was a really stunning part of the show. She most definitely sang live on this and throughout the show. There is bound to be a lot of production, it’s a massive show. Bad girl was a stripped back part & for me was beautiful. It’s a live show as far as I’m concerned. If she was to have assistance in places I really couldn’t care or feel cheated ect.. Shes Madonna! Forever in awe!

[@sheisveryfamous]

She was BRILLIANT ❤❤

[@LucasFerreira-ep3pl]

I love Madonna with every beat of my heart!

[@MADONNASTHUNDERPUSS]

Loved loved the Celebration Tour - it was amazing brilliance ❤❤❤

[@richardgalloway4857]

I love Madonna’s vocals and her voice.

[@vbell25]

I can't wait to see her in January!! Madonna is 👑

[@luizribeirooo]

Madonna has always sung with a musical base underneath. This leaves her freer to perform.

[@marklola12]

yet she is not preforming other than walking...very slow

[@dan_leo]

Not always. The Who’s that girl tour was totally live, with no musical base at all. She started using it and lipsync from the Blond Ambition tour onwards.

[@skygazer6898]

A lot of the time she sings to a backing track and she does lipsynch. Elton John has called her out on this

[@skygazer6898]

@@marklola12 I was surprised she was moving so slowly, I am a year older than her and I can still move faster around a dance floor. As for the knee brace she been wearing one of those for a long time, its possible the wear and tear has taken its toil, after all she is now a fabulous 65

[@pappin1961]

Have your seen a musical at all, live orchestra and the cast singing life and dancing, no tracks ever.

[@ScottGuest-zb1fk]

She was amazing 2 hrs singing live ❤

[@CoryMatthew87]

Not even close to 2 hrs live lol...

[@bmw3842]

Just back from the Antwerp show. Majority of the vocals were absolutely live, with some pretty subtle backing track support. The spoken word parts in Justify My Love and Erotica were lipsynced, and in absolutely fine with that.

[@susanreid9857]

papa dont preach open your heart to name a few were not live

[@josephprovencher6345]

​@susanreid9857 I've seen a couple clips from Open Your Heart and it WAS live.

[@susanreid9857]

@@josephprovencher6345 grow up

[@user-fo4hr2bd2f]

Georgina always lovely to see you. Madonna has been my favorite artist since I was 6! I’ve seen her 3 times live and will be seeing her this tour in February. Even my sister was made a Madonna fan seeing by her live. In her sticky and sweet tour Madonna had her female dancers dress up in different styles of her when she performed She’s Not Me it was great. And I’m with you Breathless Madonna is my favorite and her ballads: crazy for you, lice to tell, you’ll see. I would love to see you react to some of her older stuff like the blonde ambition tour when she was in her prime. I’ve always thought she’s been underrated as a singer. I think she has a phenomenal voice. This tour will be the celebration of her career and I love seeing her sit down some and wearing a knee brace. It’s reality and I don’t want to see her hurt herself for us. ❤ I’m always excited when you react to her! Best with your new shop you are a go getter!

[@grazmsp2473]

Even though I’m a huge Madonna fan, I can admit Madonna isn’t the strongest singer, she’s no Whitney Houston. However, what surprised me is that she still sings live, atleast 90% of the time. And the fact that she’s still dancing and singing at 65. Best concert I’ve ever went too!

[@thedeetzes]

Do glad you mentioned the Dick Tracy album “I’m Breathless” because it soooo underrated and so damn good.

[@iomintonoconte]

Love Madonna! She is a Legend! 🔝👏🏻❤️

[@yuridiagarcia460]

Madonna’s voice is really unique and has its own beauty. Not just a singer but also a very good performer. ❤❤❤

[@roccodelmar8321]

I love Madonna and she always be the Queen.

[@claudeghanimeh1728]

MADONNA IS THE QUEEN OF POP 🎉 THANK YOU GEORGINA ❤

[@nerddetaubate]

Every time I see a video of yours about Madonna you talk about her with great affection and respect. It's a pleasure to see. Greetings from Brazil!

[@lb340]

Hiii, great video, she did actually do a live performance of Bad Girl on SNL in 1993, which is in the original key, seemingly 100% live and I think is very good :) even if some parts are a bit strained

[@chocolatnoir1108]

yep that was GREAT and once in a lifetime, I just love how she sounded during pre-Evita training, as you said, a bit strained but to me it sounds sexier ʜᴇ ₕₑ ʰᵉ ᕼE😁

[@adelaney537]

Madonna is fabulous.

[@Geemeel1]

SO glad your back , SO fun to watch ! Congrats with the shop. The abundance of the universe is going for you ✨

[@vekkstar]

The vocals are much better than in past shows

[@robertarthur6470]

Thank you so much for this clip. I have been wanting you to cover a clip from this tour. I really value your honest critique. I’m a lifelong Madonna fan too. ❤🌈

[@jordike98]

I saw her this Saturday in Antwerp and it was an incredible night. I had such a blast. This was actually my favourite bit. The piano, the way it was set up, the lighting, her daughter playing the piano and the fact that she played this song. I love love lovee the Erotica album and this was such a surprise to hear her play. It was all so beautiful. I did think she sounded really good, but after your analysis Im starting to think that she might have mixed it up with syncs. Great night regardless. Love your videos, much love 💛💛💛

[@IpodAdvance]

What does her daughter think of listening to a song she made when she didn’t have kids. Is she saying I’m not happy about her lonely life like it’s really true.

[@scarahjolielaide]

Which daughter is playing?

[@MusicHorrorFanatic]

Great reaction!!! Always so nice to hear your insight on these types of videos. Rock on!!! 🥳🎉

[@MisterCiccone]

I was there and she sings live, although there are moments where the backing track is blending in more. It's very well done in my opinion. And I don't care because Madonna is more than a singer, I'm not there for a singing contest, at least she sounds better than ever and you mostly hear her live. Her show is amazing and she is telling her story with her songs. She is meeting her incarnations and younger selves on stage, talks to them, kisses and embraces them. At the end all dancers are dressed Madonna in one of her iconic looks. The show is unique and sometimes emotional. Bad girl is actually a highlight for me.

[@GLopezMad]

Please…

[@pete7230]

Saw the show on Tuesday!! Seeing it again in December! Best show I’ve ever seen🪩

[@konstantinosconstantine]

This song is sooo good! And the album vocals are so ethereal

[@steselectrah]

I was there live 2 times … i can tell you het voice was impressive live

[@drewcassavetes5726]

“Put your phones down, love. Just enjoy the moment.” Hear, hear!

[@bondskanselier4453]

Let's agree she is a great performer...and the song suits october

[@mirkostrokes5982]

Hi Georgina I think Madonna's vocals in this tour are absolutely stunning.

[@HOGARTHSGLOBALASTROLOGY]

She's clearly singing it all live. She's just in great voice. Her voice is much deeper and richer. The fact there were changes just shows it was live. She did a great job.

[@dubmoyet]

😂

[@CoryMatthew87]

Nah, it was definitely NOT all live, I'd say 40% live at best... for the reasons Georgina gave. Very obvious to anyone who knows music.

[@GiulioMalatestaMusic]

The show is amazing

[@davidklmx]

Me too, I always loved her ballads and all "I'm Breathless" album. And I agree with you about the live and pre-recorded parts in the concert. Keep on giving us your honest reviews

[@richardprofe]

Its always a pleasure to see you, and hear our opinion! Love ! :)

[@alessiorabatti8163]

I will see her in Milan and I can’t wait to hear this beautiful song from my favorite album Erotica. This is not an easy song to sing and I am very happy she decided to finally perform it

[@AmentaEnterprises]

Thanks for giving Madonna props on her vocals. She always gets dinged on that, but I've always loved the clarity, strength and simplicity of her voice.

[@oscaralbertoperezpena8713]

I saw recently in Barcelona , on november 1st. and she really sang this one and all live. Is not lip synced. I was on first line. She sounds beautiful and with her real hability and ver well vocals.!!!

[@RebelHe4rt]

This show was everything live. I seen 2 nights at the o2 and then 1 last weekend in Antwerp. There is definitely backing vocals (I don’t think there are any backup singers) I think they have used vocal stems as back up. She sang along with herself I think. Not so much lipsync but a mix of her own vocal stems with live vocal. Regardless, the show was EPIC

[@stevencurtis6802]

Not everything. The everybody vocal was mixed. And if you were at opening night youd know the backing track was there during burning up.

[@jonatanmarklund7473]

I'm watching this from the subway on my way to working Madonna the celebration tour Stockholm, stage teching

[@sharpfantasy9572]

So happy to know you love I'm Breathless! Really great album.

[@RussellHarrison-qs7ve]

I'm 48 and I would hate to know I had to sing about 40 songs in two hours. LOL. Ugh!! Bravo to Madonna!!!

[@BB-qm1iw]

She hasnt done 40 songs on this tour yet. First 3 shows she had a curfew. Not sure if it was the same reason in Belgium.

[@MartinSmith156]

And dance and play instruments

[@jamieconiam760]

Playing a prerecorded few strings from the opening of Papa Don’t Preach is considered 1 of the 40 songs. 😂

[@Jogokio]

She doesnt sing 40 songs. Just like 20songs and not one of them in its full version

[@nouriciolz]

Love you Geroginaaaaa following you for years!!

[@furbl4345]

I met someone who worked on her MDNA tour and he confirmed that Madonna did sing live. But she did have a backup singer show sounded very similar to her voice that backed her vocal.

[@jimiweir923]

i went to all 4 shows & she was amazing i cant wait to go again in December

[@brentholcomb7842]

Saw Madonna live for the MDNA tour and it was a trip! One of the most memorable concerts I've seen. Hoping to get a ticket for the Celebration tour...

[@slate49]

Definitely a light track playing in the background to help the vocals but she is singing

[@gregoryglenos2383]

I sent you a video from up close, and she’s clearly singing. Love you

[@magaliedeconto1682]

Yes you're right : her ballads are her best songs. So underrated !

[@damienjonesmusic]

Thanks for doing this one! I’m Not sure if it’s live either. I went to three shows and you could defo hear the backing track running through. Some songs were more obvious than others. The show is so good. A real treat for fans. So many classic hits.

[@arturl4019]

I think she sang mostly live, but yes, on top of the pre-recorded backing track. As I've always been saying, Madonna sings live whenever she can, and we can't be comparing her vocal skills to Mariah Carey or Celine Dion. Madonna is not just about her singing abilities, but I think she does just fine with what she has. I'll probably have more comments after I've watched the show. So excited!

[@Andrei-sg7lu]

People think the only way to be a good singer is to have some huge belting voice. That's not the only way to sing. Janet doesn't sing like that. Many artists don't sing like that.

[@youreale]

It's a fun fact that before the internet, no one cared about Madonna singing on key or not. Everyone just had lots of fun and her tracks has set the pace of our youth in 80's and 90's. I have lot of respect for her, still on stage and doing her thing even better.

[@alisejankovska9125]

😊went to Berlin - show was amazing..... I didn't sit for a minute - just sang and danced!!! Great song choices in this tour🎉🎉🎉🎉!

[@dylena68]

I've been to Antwerp waiting for Milano November 23. MADONNA IS THE ICON , IS THE LEGEND, IS THE QUEEN even if She's not Whitney Houston. She's Absolutely the best ever, 40 years of stunning career and 3 months ago She could die! She's MADONNA Y'ALL ❤️👑❤️

[@timc6251]

She sang this particular song live. I was there. She was actually taking vocal lessons before this tour. Yes, she did lipsync some songs, for example, Ray of Light, Vogue, Justify my Love and others. But this song was 100% live.

[@bryanpwo3085]

I just watched a better quality video of this song in th O2 in London and she sings live of course with a backing track. In that video you can even see the "famous" Madonna throat and neck muscle strain whilst she is singing. I am a Madonna fan since '84 and I also passed on buying a ticket for this tour. (I have to pay my energy bill..)😉 But seeing footage from the concert my heart is crying a bit for not going. I think this concert tour is her best vocal, and we all know she isn't a pure vocalist, performance since the Girlie show where the emphasis also was on her vocal performance. Finally a real live singing Madonna show and I certainly don't mind she is holding back on the dancing. As I said, she isn't a pure vocalist but she sure puts emotion in her singing and I love that. For that reason my fave performances are The look of love from the Who's that girl tour and Rain from the Girlie show. Technically not the best vocal performance but it makes it up with her presence and the emotions she poors in. Also, I still think she needs at least Donna De Lory as her backing vocalist during live performances. Donna's voice helps to boost Madonna's voice, which completes the sound.

[@RDrRD1989]

Rain from The Girlie Show❤❤❤❤

[@bryanpwo3085]

@@RDrRD1989 Indeed!!!!

[@ladylisaromance8129]

And this is one of my favorites of hers. I remember blasting this in my car as a young woman. ❤ it. Edit: Yes, Georgina! Put your phones away and enjoy being in the magical moment!

[@ashleyfrost8906]

Your hair color looks nice, making your eyes even bluer.

[@borghetto75]

I just returned from Madonna's concert in Milan and I followed your advice: a few photos and videos and the most of time I enjoyed the moment singing and screaming, without paying attention to the fact that those around me didn't do the same.

[@martinanugent5045]

Plus it's so beautiful live,Mercy is fantastic on the piano.

[@bucknaked905]

This is live vocals, Stuart Price has confirmed this past week. Madonna underwent extensive vocal training for this tour. I'd love to see you react to her MET Gala performance of Hallelujah!

[@Shane.C.]

All the best on your new shop! I love crystals and all that spiritual jazz! We have a great shop here in Poole called “Happy Buddha”. Madonna also does another of my faves on this tour, “Rain” Well worth checking out :)

[@gavinballin2323]

Welcome back!🎉

[@roccodelmar8321]

Excellent critic as usual by the way 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@r.j4449]

what an amazing song. A classic.

[@niko81680]

The queen!!! Love her