How it Should Have Ended Should Have Ended

[@bevloy7517]

New intro goes incredibly hard.

[@CelestialWitch]

blah.. 👅

[@YoShockwaver]

Never realised how much I tied eras of the cast to my own life because the amount of nostalgia this is giving me without ever seeing it before is crazy

[@aceman0000099]

Nahhh you can't be getting nostalgia for like 5 years ago 😭

[@BilliesPetRock]

​@@aceman0000099pre pandemic nostalgia hits hard ngl

[@YoShockwaver]

@@aceman0000099 Pre-covid feels like 10 years ago at this point 😭😭

[@aceman0000099]

@@YoShockwaver nahh not for me man sounds like shit happened tho

[@Red-nl4lk]

This reminds me of back when I used to live in my old house. Just a simple high schooler still learning to drive. playing bioshock in the evening. Listening to the wall every day. It was a simple time.

[@seemantable3985]

Its crazy how this is now a bonus episode to an older JAR era. Feels like a Deluxe edition of an album

[@racoobi]

I remember when HISHE first hit the scene in the late 2000s, I believe around 06 or 07. Back then, the title actually meant something and they had new jokes every video. I think it was around the time the MCU started kicking off that they declined rapidly and went stale fast.

[@aceman0000099]

Clearly you went to the Prometheus school of running away from things 🙄

[@gamingscrudley5118]

HISHE is like watching an Angry Joe video but it’s only the skits

[@zachflag6506]

That’s a blistering indictment of both channels

[@adamadam6351]

LMAO real

[@linkvegeta2]

love angry joes skits.

[@MusicLover-dg3wg]

Seeing that this wasn't too long after nostalgia critic's "The Wall," I genuinely think his review angered JAR to the point where they needed to bring all of their greatest enemies down

[@meurigjenkins]

I feel like I've been in a fugue state since late 2019

[@stick-em-up2904]

Fuuuuuu I feel that man

[@NeoAya]

No way, IHE making I Hate How It Should Have Ended

[@realainsmcf]

A video from before the world ended, amazing

[@_-Lx-_]

How The World Should've Ended

[@iwanriley8047]

James is so much more quiet in the early casts! I never noticed before but Im so grateful for how involved James is in the later episodes

[@videogamenostalgia]

In the early 2010s if you and your buddies were watching videos you'd be PRAYING that someone wouldn't suggest a HISHE. Just having to do polite fake laughs so your friend doesn't feel bad for what felt like hours.

[@Twy87]

You can tell it's old and shit because it predates 'The Normal Episode' by nearly a month. Alex literally still hates everything!

[@whysitthat3515]

Omg this is bizarre. I know people don’t always like this era but this was one of my favorites of JAR - and it’s kinda awesome getting new content from an era I thought i’d never see again. Weird feeling but cool

[@alpharoo2581]

2018-2019 was peak JAR

[@MichaelMan2000]

Why would people not like this era of jar?

[@Hellol-po7eq]

Huh? Id say this set and era are considered peak jar by many gooners

[@whysitthat3515]

@@UserUser-pc9xu imagine being so chronically online that your immediate response to this innocent ass comment on a channel with less than 100k subs is that i’m trying to ‘fArM enGagEMeNt.’ This is literally called the crackhead era for christ sake

[@LiamTolentino]

This was the era I started listening to JAR, so seeing this set again made me so nostalgic :')

[@milkmedia1657]

I fw the new intro

[@TheBattlesword]

I never watched a single video of HISHE growing up outside of their cameo in an Honest Trailers episode and never will. It was one of the best decisions I ever made at the time.

[@verytired1310]

this was the set from when i started listening back in late 2019 so seeing it again is crazy

[@etalex7074]

same, that was the time I first started listening frequently and regularly, I have so much nostalgia from that time period so this is such a weird feeling

[@Jam-oi4so]

the whole review i was thinking "this isn't too mean-spirited" and then it cut you saying the creator of HISHE pushed an old man in front of a bus

[@buibuich775]

just three lads having a laugh, analysing satire and comedy... what more could you ask for, honestly?

[@Lreldge]

exactly!

[@alexanderwaring2176]

Alex's voice has definitely got lower and less nasally since 2019

[@Kino-K]

Makes sense, since he got the nasal surgery later

[@downspiral]

@@Kino-K Interesting. No wonder his voice would sound different from 2016 to 2019

[@ryguy1928]

In retrospect, it's clear that HISHE'S target audience is middle school age kids who are still developing their sense of humor.

[@CaJoel]

every video from 2019 has ample amounts of normal energy

[@doctorbobcat7123]

Seeing that HISHE still makes videos and regularly gets over 500K is the same feeling as when you find out Annoying Orange is still raking in millions. (At least with the Annoying Orange, the views are explained by toddlers on Ipads. I genuinely do not understand who is still watching HISHE)

[@profilefeather]

Hey I cant help it, I have diarrhea like 12 times a day, I gotta watch something considering each plop takes about an hour, but I dont want to relate something thats good to my own liquid shit sub consciously. So I watch HISHE, Watch mojo, Cinema sins and top 15s.

[@jamesstanley792]

Wait the Annoying Orange is still a think?

[@jamesstanley792]

Thing sorry.

[@rmn070]

I feel the exact same with Nostalgia Critic. People still enjoy him for whatever reason.

[@jamesstanley792]

Damn I’m suddenly nostalgic for the old jar setup after watching that. Nothing beats a good attic window. As for HISHE I can safely say it’s a part of my foolish youth that I (and many others) can bury and never think about ever again.

[@georgereinhardt3027]

woah.... i am only 1:16 into the video rn... but boys this is bizarre. i frequently go back and listen to old casts as just something to listen and laugh too while i am doing whatever, so the old set and younger cast is nothing weird for me. what IS weird is seeing something from the past that i have never seen before, throwing me through a complete loop and i love it. about to watch the rest. thank you for putting this out. game on.

[@westide3050]

The first HISHE was made 16 years ago

[@Albino_Basilisk]

Wow, that’s crazy dedication, that this was edited to have the original background jazz music. A JAR lost episode

[@greatoverlordchikonmaster7226]

If you hate how it should have ended, does that mean you hate how yourself should have ended?

[@bruhgator]

can't wait for how the normal episode should have ended

[@LiamTolentino]

Truth is, the normal episode never should have ended and should have kept going throughout every episode of the JARcast. In that timeline, the pandemic never happened because the sheer normality of JAR prevented anyone from getting a non-normal virus.

[@BensonDunwoody-p1l]

Time Travel does exist after all

[@HOTD108_]

I've been time traveling into the future one second at time for my entire life. Get on my level.

[@_-Lx-_]

​@@HOTD108_ Pathetic, I do so with a tiny fraction of a nanosecond at a time, get on my speed.

[@bigweld6792]

hilarious that after looking at current hishe, the on thing in this video that aged in the nearly 4 years of time since this was recorded was that Jim saying "new spiderman movie" doesn't apply to far from home anymore

[@Crashpunk]

God. I remember How It Should Have Ended. My friend kept showing me it like it was the funniest and smartest thing on YT. It's so awful

[@aceman0000099]

It's great when you're 14

[@MrTheevilmage]

@@aceman0000099 When I was 14 I fucking hated it, stop acting like every teenager thought this was funny

[@majora56]

the nostalgia is killing me gents, I once again feel like a broke university student with no career aspirations and zero social skills!

[@chain12bb]

i honestly cannot put into words how bad the comedy is. theres a joke in the spiderman homecoming one where when Ned says he wanna be "the guy in the chair", Thanos suddenly appears and is like "no, im the guy in the chair" and then thats the joke

[@twolessba1087]

The point of channels like hishe and cinimasins is the capitalise over search engine optimization, basically whenever a new super hero movie or whatever is released or whatever 1000s of view bots scour the internet to click on anything related to the movies in question, the point is that when the movies come out there is content and a space to discuss the movie for "fans" many years ago cinimasins actually did a video talking about search engine optimization it was eye opening to be honest

[@harveyrice8504]

Now the exact same thing has happened with that pitch meeting guy

[@thegmanofEAP]

"Because I'm Batman!" Damn that shit wasn't funny the first 10,000 times.

[@lachesis1541]

HISHE is only useful if you want to find out what plot holes everyone is talking about with recent blockbusters, but you can do the same by scrolling through twitter for 5 minutes

[@drifter402]

Plotholes which they probably 'discovered' through HISHE or cinema sins that they're actually wrong about.

[@greyfells2829]

That's an abuse of the word "useful"

[@dabatman5187]

HISHE is much better for your mental health tho

[@Rav_Ram]

Jar sliders eating good recently 🐻 🐻

[@pepepoopsonthefarright7531]

going back to randy's silver age is quite the nostalgia trip

[@Flubby-wubby]

Used to love it as a kid - ngl especially the reoccurring batman stuff but grew out of it

[@yeahey5947]

Wow, I can’t believe jar media is using their platform to attack and send harassment towards such a small, uncreative, pathetic channel.

[@downspiral]

There's probably a reason why I haven't watched HISHE in years

[@thatsallreviews]

The peak of my HISHE watching was so long ago, back when the first Guardians of the Galaxy one came out. I was pretty limited in my internet usage (especially KZbin) so seeing something like that back then really blew my mind. Now I can see all of the flaws in it but can't deny there's almost faint nostalgia to it.

[@RoshDroz]

The part where he said because I'm batman made me squeal with glee and excitement and it was very funny

[@BigBossMan538]

The best JAR set

[@vorake]

Easily

[@sionsonorism]

holy fuck they've been running since 2005. nearly 20 years

[@PolyverseCube]

The title of the video is missing an additional "How"

[@BSBSDerivative]

Not necessarily

[@kiklonio]

never realised how much I missed the old set till now...

[@coolvidguy08]

that's legit my favourtie set and era of the cast

[@JKSmith-qs2ii]

Was this filmed right before or after the Normal episode? This is important information for the Jar lore.

[@JurassicReptile]

These should be on the podcast feed. I adore these angry JAR boys

[@burblingbarbacoa4944]

finna get goofy stoned to this one

[@downspiral]

They tried to do another version of the Best Picture Summary which was originally from Harry Potter and brought to Spider-Man, except for how the joke in Harry Potter is how they got nominated for easy awards, but the joke doesn't work with NWH because it was for VFX, which people know sucks. Defiunitely not wrong in that their jokes get more vapid because it's only for references and fourth wall breaks.

[@michaelmcfarland5903]

Perfect timing, I just got a bong hit ready

[@Augustus334]

Hishe have been dreading this day 😳

[@noarmsnolife6665]

I thought 2019 was like 4 months ago

[@rayunwired]

Ah ha! I still remember hearing you guys talk about this video back in 2019 like it was yesterday. Great to finally see it surface

[@dishboypodcasts]

Is Redlettermedia as GOOD as they say?

[@medhros]

I remember this age of KZbin when everything that was nerdy and full of references got so much success even if the videos were this bad. They are quite simillar to the Nostalgia Critic's videos, with the ongoing jokes, the stupid humour made for children and about referencing stuff and being edgy. I recall that loads of friends of mine loved this. They'd always send me some of these videos and I'd never find it funny, it was like a pandemic of how things should have ended.

[@Dreamhouse533]

While I wouldn't say it's entirely 'mean-spirited' they do really lay into the channel, like gohdam they HATE this guy. But also HISHE is and shitting on it is a big piece of JAR history, especially for veteran viewers

[@Hoodied]

Im guessing this intro is only gonna be used for spinoff content that isnt the main cast cus alex said he wanted to use it as an outro instead, but it still allows for so many cool gags. That silly mouth can say absolutely anything

[@HumansBornFresh]

You’re absolutely right, the cast intro is staying the same, but this intro works great for other content!

[@aliveslice]

@@HumansBornFresh who did the sound?

[@AGamingEntity]

Damn, the old set brings me back

[@robertdegiorno8690]

New intro is a 10/10

[@thisisawsome34253212]

This video was a long time coming because I have been wondering why Alex can't stand HISHE for almost a decade now. One thing I disagree with is: You can't compare South Park's animation to what you see in How It Should Have Ended. South Park has way more effort, variety, and expression. HISHE is just lazy.

[@teddydancona7237]

Is Epic Rap Battles of History as EPIC as they say?

[@nman551]

No and it never was

[@thesapphireone]

I would say yes, since the first season had weak lyrics and didn’t look good from a production standpoint, but after Season 1, the rapping was better, the effects improved, and EpicPeter and NiceLloyd genuinely improved as actors and lyricists.

[@alcoholicgoat]

I miss the old set

[@markw110]

Same! Looks like such a "cozy space". 😃

[@watermullins42]

I think the major appeal is that it is reliably very family friendly where most pop culture referency content out there is not

[@heis147]

Finally Beast can unleash his inner rage against HISHE!!!

[@nib1448]

I watch like one of their vids every 6 months and it’s “enjoyable” in that sense

[@Hellol-po7eq]

Ohhh this gonna be a good one

[@randomnerd3402]

When I was like 8-10 I found HISHE funny and watched it fairly consistently (same with Nostalgia Critic). But the years following that, up to being 14 now, my sense of humor has changed a lot and I've explored critical thinking and how to apply it to different forms of media.

[@TheRedSpore]

Gives me normal episode vibes idk why

[@cybermexi-8100]

The only HISHE I've seen was their Pulp Fiction video. And that was a enough for me to never look at them again

[@cameron2069]

I’m sure the people behind HISHE are nice, but their videos always felt like they went into Nostalgia Critic/Cinemasins levels of wince-worthy in-jokes and anti-criticism. I also don’t really care for the art style or quality of the animation, with all due respect, it’s outdated compared to something like Cas van de Pol. I haven’t really kept up with them though.

[@aliveslice]

There's no reason to be sure they are nice.

[@korvo3427]

They are probably despicable.

[@sock3715]

I love this channel

[@derekpayneszubliminals7723]

Am I the only one who thinks How it Should have Ended's artstyle kind of looks like Tony Moore's artstyle, the artist who did the artwork for the early issues of the Walking Dead comics?

[@kolonarulez5222]

I just noticed 3 Dick the Heads on that coffee table! Back in the day I tried so hard to find something similar for my own but no luck.

[@fromvault801]

Its funny how for years JAR can say things are for Babies. But theres been all these complaints of YMS considering something For Babies. Im a huge fan of both channels (and Ralph) so seeing how different people take criticism is really interesting.

[@Lofirainbows]

I hope how it should have ended do a video on this

[@korvo3427]

How "How it Should Have Ended Should Have Ended" Should Have Ended

[@unwillingly_will]

HOLY NEW INTRO BATMAN

[@retinas2001]

Alex sounds so different

[@irllaura]

As someone who started watching during corncast this is crazy 👀

[@lasercustard4467]

As someone who started watching before corncast this is… normal?

[@irllaura]

@@lasercustard4467 not the content (which is very normal) just how different the set is and being 4 years younger

[@erik8936]

how it should have ended shan't end

[@TrendingFrog]

More like shat 😭

[@mattforbes3670]

Might it have made more sense to be titled "How 'How It Shouldve Ended' shouldve ended" lmao

[@Chromaticana]

I remember being like 13 and going to my friends house and he kept hyping up hishe and played a bunch of the videos for me and I just didnt really understand them

[@attackofthecopyrightbots]

how im just now finding out alex has another channel

[@falafelfreak]

Algorithm boost for the lads

[@VoidSmoker97]

2019 was like the last really good year I can remember, also it was around the time I wasn’t watching/listening to the posdacts as much but I’ve been caught up for a bit now, this shit is fun to listen to while gaming

[@_-Lx-_]

2023 has been a fantastic year for me, been lots of good media and overall my actual life is better than ever. I'd definitely say 2022 and 2023 have been colossal improvements to what was the worst 2 starting years of a decade I'm aware of, the pandemic is pretty much entirely over, and the world seems to be restoring itself and improving in a lot of ways. Best wishes to anyone in a bad state, but 2023 have been LEAGUES better than 2019 for me.

[@paperlemming]

i remembering them referencing them not uploading this video years ago glad to see i get to see how shit it is

[@Hellol-po7eq]

Thanks AI alex

[@kie2]

wow i've never seen James slap Alex before

[@Evadooker]

this is the first video ive watched on this channel so it doesn't bother me it was from 2 years ago

[@aviadd]

HISHE started before youtube in 2004.

[@duskplains1235]

Epic

[@TrendingFrog]

Batman Alex is so scary you should put a trigger warning i literally shat myself 😢

[@chasethecringewolf2195]

Tbf its hard to say they should just quit when its your main source of income. Hishe isnt really meant to be taken serious (unlike what cinemassins thinks of his content) The animation is decent for a channel of that type idk how they’d branch out at this point.

[@JaredGriffiths2000]

I love the title of this video, hahaha!!!

[@cholo2215]

2019 jar was the best jar

[@tsofficial7290]

"High-sh"

[@kiptelgat]

9:50 omg I died