How Karachi is being destroyed by the Real Estate Mafia - Hafeez Baloch -

Hafeez Baloch is an activist, and a part of the Awaami Workers Party and the Indigenous Sindh Rights Alliance.
Hafeez Baloch comes on The Pakistan Experience for a brave and daring episode of podcast, where we discuss Climate Change, Indigenous Rights of Sindh, Bahria Town, the Real Estate Mafia, the Baloch History of Karachi, and more!
The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan through conversations.
Please consider supporting us on Patreon:
/ thepakistanexperience
To support the channel:
Jazzcash/Easypaisa - 0325 -2982912
Patreon.com/thepakistanexperience
And Please stay in touch:
/ thepakistanexp1
/ thepakistanexperience
/ thepakistanexpeperience
The podcast is hosted by comedian and writer, Shehzad Ghias Shaikh. Shehzad is a Fulbright scholar with a Masters in Theatre from Brooklyn College. He is also one of the foremost Stand-up comedians in Pakistan and frequently writes for numerous publications.
shehzadghiasshaikh
Facebook.com/Shehzadghias/
Twitter.com/shehzad89
Chapters:
0:00 Introduction
1:32 Climate Change, failings of the system and govt, real estate mafia, identity politics,the Muhajir Identity, Karachi and its place in Sindh
15:12 The constitution, Social contact, institution using divide and rule & the need to strengthen the constitution
28:00 Struggles of the Indigenous people in Sindh, Gentrification, history of Karachi, origins of area names in Karachi
45:21 History of the Indigenous lands Bahria town is built on, Sassi Pannu, Kirthar National Park
1:00:00 Biparjoy, removal of Mangrove trees, River Systems and flooding, Malir Expressway, SEPA, Bahria Town's Land Grabbing,
1:23:23 Criticism, implementation of laws, assassinations, illegality and political influence of Bahria Town, Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Jr.,
1:36:34Sindhi and Balochi identities, Feudal system, electables, creating a new system and Social Contract, resilience of Balochi culture in Lyari

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Apologies for the audio for the first 40 minutes, light chali gayee toh we lost the Rodecaster audio. Its fine after 41 minutes.

[@HindariSyirik]

Here I share Muhammad Qasim's dream about 3 Mighty Castles of Islam: 3 Mighty Castles of Islam, 2 of Them Will Be Destroyed by Dajjal 2014-2015 بسم اللہ الرّحمٰن الرّحیم As-Salaam Alaikum In this video I am unfolding some of the shocking truths through my divine dreams. There is no doubt that all of these events will happen soon one after another. In many of my dreams I saw Islam like three main powerful buildings which look just like castles. These castles are protecting Islam. Recently Allah well defined all 3 castles to me through the Divine dreams. According to my true dreams; first castle is Turkey and the second castle is Saudi Arabia and the third is Pakistan. In all of my dreams, I've seen that two out of three castles were destroyed by non-believers. In one of my dreams on December 2015, the last Prophet Muhammad ﷺ mentioned to me that the last castle of islam is Pakistan. On December 4, 2014 Allah showed me that two out of three castles were destroyed by the wicked Illuminati forces and they faced not much resistance. Muslims were anxious when they saw the first castle get destroyed but they failed to resist them. Muslims got shaken heavily when the second castle was destroyed and they said that, it was a devastating loss to Islam. Then they move towards Pakistan, the third and final castle of Islam. I saw myself in the third and last castle of Islam. I saw that the three castles are located one after the other in a row and two of them got attacked by the enemies with weapons. I was very intimidated and I wanted to make the people aware but no one paid attention and they lost the two castles. Then I saw the enemy started to move towards the third and last castle of Islam. Muslims tried to run and hide themselves and ran around with fear. I told them that whether you fight or hide you will be killed. Then I decided to fight and die while saving Islam. Allah helped the Muslims in the third castle of Islam with His powers and also by the powerful black jet fighters. With the help of Allah Muslims defended the third and last castle of Islam successfully. Also by the help of Allah Muslims from the east will spread the true Islam around the whole world and the whole world was filled with peace and Justice until the appearance of the Dajjal. May Allah save all castles of Islam. Please spread these true dreams do not live in darkness and perceive the meaning of these divine dreams. The game of these wicked enemies is soon going to end. Glad tidings to the true Muslims. Jazakallahu (may Allah reward you)

[@rohitrohra]

Abhi tak tum logi ki captial city mein light issue hai🤣

[@zeshanaslam3992]

No prob shehzad bhai as long as we can hear your voice ❤

[@tauqeerhussain8499]

No worries, you are still doing very good job. Love from Germany. :)

[@shahzaibahmed5059]

karachi capital nai hai. mazak uranay se pehle thori research to krliya kro rohra saab

[@radhika7387]

Shahzad please invite Divik Kumar. He is a Pakistani Hindu. He has appeared on several Pakistani reaction channels. Divik has a great understanding on subcontinent geopolitics and international relations. It's a humble request.

[@MukeshPanicker]

How would you feel if he invited a Indian Muslim to talk about Muslim in condition in india ?? You would call him a hate monger.

[@radhika7387]

@@MukeshPanicker Just watch Divik's interviews... he does not play the minority victim card.

[@radhika7387]

​@@Mr-Anuraj He is so well read. Wish people like him can hold top positions in Pakistan's politics.

[@amit9023]

​@@MukeshPanickerthere are many Indian Muslims talking with pakistani... U can see... Problem is your hindu hatred

[@amit9023]

He will not call.. Even no major pakistani KZbinr will give him any space.. Bcoz they know till now they were hiding Hindu genocide.. They deliberately cry about Indian Muslims so we Indian Hindus keep defending those.. That's their strategy to engage us with Indian Muslims on cost of pakistani Hindu genocide.... Short answer... : This guy will not call him on his channel.. Bcoz he is also part of same group..

[@rohitrohra]

Those who say karachi was nothing my grandparents parents use to live in karachi there were clubs,cafe even tram use to run in karachi just search karachi 1950 you will get european vibes also foreigners use to visit karachi, karachi was far developed city. I'm sindhi hindu my grandparents use to live in karachi,sindh that time people who came from hindustan started attacking the hindus just to loot their property we have to leave sindh because they were killing sindhi hindu karachi use to come in bombay presidency mumbai and karachi use to be called sister city but now mumbai is one of the richest city in India and karachi is the 6 worst city in the world .

[@Zubair-Khan]

Karachi isnt on worst list , Delhi and Lahore on top

[@rohitrohra]

@@Zubair-Khan go search top worst city to live in karachi is on 6th spot.

[@zulfiqarali971]

Exactly, karachi was much better before partition. Than ppl from poor parts of india came and destroyed it.

[@rohitrohra]

@@zulfiqarali971 that what I'm saying before partition only sindhi use to live in sindh, sindhi hindus used to be 51.1% before partition muhajir's and punjabi had destoryed sindh, jiye sindh ♥️ free sindhudesh 🚩

[@mylord3003]

​@@rohitrohracall it genocide on sindhis by Muslims....why you are not explicit?

[@fahadsaeed8499]

Bhai apki Baki batain theek hain, me Multan sy hu, DHA Multan sy apko masla hu rha ha lekin Multan me hazaro nahi tu 100s me colonies bani hain , wo Sab Bagh cut krky hi bany hain. You have your mind stuck at a point. I truly admire your work and most of the times it makes sense but still have a heart

[@tjay8433]

Not an expensive production still this show is so real and straight to the point. Shehzad is sooo underrated podcaster hats off,❤from padosi.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤

[@ghazanfarhussain5032]

Every institution will work independently within its space 🌌 32:58

[@ghazanfarhussain5032]

Cowsjee school 🎒🏫 Has educational.Lyri ?

[@khipksy1888]

One thing to correct, uptill bhuttos regime, the Muhajir term wasnt common here, it was ethnic Biharis, UPs, Memons, Rajhastanis and others along with ethnic Sindhis, Balochs and Pathans. The muhajir political identity was created after Bhuttos rigime. Also why you ask only urdu speakers to call themselves Sindhi? Lyari natives still call themselves Baluch after 200+ years of living here, even Asif Ali Zardari refers to himsellf as Baluch. You cant change ethnicity of people based on where they live. I see this Irony very clearly when people belonging to organisation such as SANA, (Sindhi Association of North America), make similar comments which is laughable. They named their organisation a Sindhi one in USA, while criticising others for doing the same in Sindh. Wow!! Also pakistan as a country should apply for Guinness book of world records, because we have among the largest and most population provinces in the world. Like the Wazir e Baldiat is sitting in Karachi, while taking decision of streets in a city that he can only reach after driving 7-8 hours(if nonstop). Dude here in Germany within 8 hours you can enter the country from one side and exit on the other. And Germany is one of the bigger countries of europe.

[@B95RWBR]

Brilliant as always. Thank you for this. More power to both of you!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@ubaidhunts]

@@ThePakistanExperienceaudio chudi vi ha boss is podcast me :(

[@hanipolpolehani670]

What is more beautiful and pure than human relationships? The bonds we share with our parents, spouses, siblings, children, and grandparents are truly extraordinary. From the moment we open our eyes, they surround us with love, nurturing us and shaping who we become. However, what surpasses even these powerful connections? What compels us to overcome such strong bonds without hesitation, as if in the blink of an eye, to embark on a journey that requires immense courage? There must be something beyond those relationships. Is it madness or love? Can love truly be called love if it doesn’t drive you to the point of madness, if it doesn’t make you restless for your beloved, if it doesn’t take you to the pinnacle of intensity, and above all, if it doesn’t allow you to touch the precipice of death? Are these individuals who leave everything behind considered crazy? Their homes, families, personal lives, and all they hold dear? Are they driven solely by a love that defies words, carrying the dreams of a free land within their eyes, never looking back? Their sacrifice is indescribable, and it is beyond our capacity to speak of or critique. Those who believe themselves to be intellectually superior by discussing or criticizing them are, in truth, fools. Who are they on Earth to pass judgment on those who possess nothing but mountains and have no choice but to live and die for freedom? If you cannot worship these sacred individuals, refrain from speaking about them. Those who choose war are not crazy, nor are they provoked or forced into it. Let me reiterate this a thousand times: no one can compel you to take your own life. It is a conscious and intellectual choice, a national duty that every man and woman should fulfill because freedom demands it. Rather than lose their national identity and land, it is better to fight for their identity, land, and culture. As Frantz Fanon wrote in his book “The Wretched of the Earth,” “For a colonized people, the essential value, because the most concrete, is first and foremost the land: the land which will bring them bread and, above all, dignity.” This war of independence revolves around the dignity of our identity, land, and people, and hundreds of precious lives have been sacrificed for it. We must understand that the Baloch people have been at war not for a day, not for a few years, but for over 70 years since the State of Pakistan colonized this sacred land. Throughout this time, the Baloch have fought against colonial powers to preserve their existence in the face of a world that has looked the other way. Colonization brings consequences and oppression; it does not offer flowers or open skies to roam freely. Under that open sky, the colonizer kills you on your own land. Colonizers have always been cunning, employing various tactics to occupy land and manipulate the minds of the colonized people. Sometimes, our people shake hands with them and collaborate in the massacre of our land and people. Others oppose the war of independence, but they operate silently, working towards a single agenda. This reminds me of the words of Chinua Achebe in his novel “Things Fall Apart”: “The white man is very clever. He came quietly and peaceably with his religion. We were amused at his foolishness and allowed him to stay. He has won our brothers, and our clan can no longer act like one. He has put a knife on the things that held us together, and we have fallen apart.” In the end, when we have fallen apart, we find the resonance of the title ‘Things Fall Apart’ by Chinua Achebe. After being colonized, the strength of their clan derived from unity, but the colonizer cunningly exploited them, turning their people against one another and leading to their ultimate fragmentation. It is in this shattered state that the profound meaning of the title becomes evident. Unity, which once held them together, was severed by the colonizer’s manipulation, causing their world to crumble. Unfortunately, today, not only do state-sponsored individuals propagate opposition to the war of independence, but even those who are part of the struggle themselves. While you may consider yourselves intellectually superior, it will take you decades to reach the level of those who actively participate in this war. History has no place for hypocrites who sit and critique while smoking their cigarettes, attempting to undermine the sacrifices of our national heroes. I have nothing to say about the Baloch who have abandoned their conscience and work openly on the state’s agenda, participating in the genocide of Baloch people. However, I will speak about those who are somehow involved in this national struggle and consider themselves highly intellectual when they are not. They should study the history of warfare, past and present, as the world has modernized and so have warfare tactics. Regardless of what they say or do, this war will never cease. In conclusion, this war of independence is the foundation that sustains our identity and existence. Without it, we would have faced the same fate as the Native Americans, vanishing into the annals of history. Today, the mere notion of being Baloch strikes fear into the enemy’s heart, not due to our population size, but because the state trembles at the thought of our active participation in the fight for independence. While it is not my intention to romanticize war, as it is a deeply painful and arduous endeavor beyond human imagination, it is important to recognize that this war is a matter of our survival, a fight for our existence. Baloch people must wholeheartedly engage in this struggle, as it is through the sacrifices of thousands of brave individuals that our land has been nourished with their blood. Their unwavering ideology inspires countless others, ensuring that brave souls are always ready to serve and protect our beloved motherland. These freedom fighters are our national heroes, with heads held high like mountains and visions as vast as the ocean. They are the ones who will ensure the existence of Baloch identity and secure Baloch independence. Their mission, dedication, sleepless nights, hunger, raids, and the loss of comrades on the battlefield embody the unwavering spirit that keeps the fire of independence burning. Every Baloch man and woman should join this war of independence, for it is the time to pay homage to our land. By Ganjal Baluch #FreeBaluchistan #BaluchistanIsNotPakistan #BaluchistanIsNotIran #BaluchistanIsNotAfghanistan

[@shaantanuasthana5942]

he is a baloch and connected to his land as he and his community are a legacy bearers of mehergarh civilisation thats why he loves his land salute bhaijan

[@faizansohail2504]

Strongly disagree with Hafeez sahab's notion that the land on which a group of people reside defines their ethnicity. Human migration has gone on for millennia, however even after generations of a particular ethnic group reside in a geographic area, they still continued with their original traditions. The Muhajir identity is distinct from the Sindhi identity and it's important for that identity to be preserved. If generations of Pashtuns reside in Karachi, they won't start calling themselves Sindhi. Why should Muhajirs give up their identity? Diversity is our strength, not our weakness, if we stop letting political forces exploit it for their personal gain

[@zamanzeb1281]

Nobody told you to give up your language and customs. Everyone has adopted urdu in Pakistan though its Sindhi, punjabi, baloch or pakhtun that shows the acceptance but urdu speakings are politicaly misguided and used at the hands of establishment are being taught to be superior over the other locals and for same do not accept others and this is where the divide is created and establishment is beneficiary

[@n.s.1170]

@@zamanzeb1281excellent analysis

[@muhammadhamzaaijazi2976]

He said mai sindh mai rahne wala balochi hoo jo balochi bolta hoo and aur hum log sindh mai rahne waale muhajir log hai jo urdu bolte hai aur Jin ke khandaan waalo ne sab se ziyada struggle kiya British🇬🇧 ke against

[@KarachiPodcast]

Sindh Province is not the same as Sindh dharti. The province was created in 1936, and nobody had a problem when it was called Bombay. Sindh dharti is the land surrounding Sindhu river, and includes most of Pakistan. In fact, instead of naming the country Pakistan, I would have named it Sindhudesh to connect with the history of thousands of years, at least after Bangladesh separated.

[@abhijitmaisuria5703]

My friend, you acknowledge the history of the Sindh region. But the leader who came from outside, who brought their own culture & didn't respect the culture of that land & rubbed it in your eyes would really name the whole nation Sindhudesh? Most didn't even know how many languages existed before they butchered their culture.

[@KarachiPodcast]

@@abhijitmaisuria5703 It wasn't named such because that would be injustice to East Pakistan, but after Bangladesh separated, we should have renamed the country to Sindhudesh.

[@abhijitmaisuria5703]

@@KarachiPodcast With majority of punjab, i dont think so.. Also their ego was so high, instead of accepting their mistake, they fed lie that Bangladesh betrayed you.

[@abhijitmaisuria5703]

@@KarachiPodcast By "their ego" I meant, ego of ruling class not by punjab.

[@abhijitmaisuria5703]

@@KarachiPodcast Those people are still ruling!

[@RiyaKaur414]

This podcast is very delightful. A very humble request to Pakistan experience podcast team to invite Varun Grover Sahib , Salman Aktar Sahib , Acharya Prashant ji . Respect and Namaste 🙏 from India .

[@KarachiPodcast]

His comparison of Sindh's right on River Indus to Balochistan is contradictory. In Balochistan's case, their resources are distributed to other provinces and Baloch's don't get their due share. The headworks of River Indus are in northern areas. If Balochistan is allowed to decide who will get their resources and at what cost, then the northern areas should also decide who will get the water and at what cost.

[@zulfiqarali971]

What the hell is a karachi sooba? Kabhi mumbai sooba, delhi sooba, lahore sooba, new york sooba, london sooba suna hai? Nonsense naam rakha hai. Change karo isko shabash.

[@hanipolpolehani670]

The problem of Occupied Balochistan is not about Shareholding، Baloch are fighting for freedom. If the resources are ours, why should we beg from someone else? If you are a slave for generations, don't compare yourself with the Balochs. And Kalachi @ Karachi, Jacobabad, Dadu Qamber, Shahdadkot, Kashmore, Kundkot, Shikarpur are historical areas of Balochistan. And some areas are in Punjab, Dera Ghazi Khan, Rajanpur, Rahim Yar Khan, Leh Bhakkar, Muzaffargarh. And one area is in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Dera Ismail Khan. All these areas of Balochistan were separated from Balochistan during British imperialism and Fascist Bhutto's rule and put into Sindh Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. No one should be under this illusion, Karachi will be made a province. Karachi is an integral part of Occupied Balochistan. And you people have no idea that Karachi will become the center of the Baloch independence movement. We are not Sindhi Smart, remember this is a national struggle. Anyway, you guys couldn't handle a gang war Uzir Baloch, then how will you handle the Baloch nation, we don't want a fight with anyone, but we won't give even an inch of our land to anyone. When we can fight a nuclear nation, fighting a business nation is a left handed game for us. #FreeBalochiatan #LongLiveBalochFreedomFighters

[@sadiakhatri5397]

fantastic, so good, so important, thank you.

[@Shrimpspiration]

Just started listening again, I thought my car speakers were broken, when I was listening through the podcast app. Thanks using great mics, it add so much to the listening experience. I will comment on the video later, once I have gone through it 😊

[@noorulbasar37]

One of the best podcasts based on real issues. These are such issues that are always put under the carpet so the common man does not understand what their rights are and how a social contract works. Thank you Shehzad. This country can only rise if it could produce another dozen of the kinds of Hafeez Balochs. The societies business trends is killing agriculture, environment, industrialisation and rights of the people whose lands were abducted. It will destroy not only Karachi but the whole Punjab as well that is the agriculture life line. I am not an environmentalist or agriculturist, but I understand where the future of upcoming generations will end if it is not done so.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@noorulbasar37]

@@ThePakistanExperience 🙌👏👏

[@Zubair-Khan]

Punjab is food basket of Pakistan, destroying its cultivated land means inviting more hunger in Pakistan

[@Alikhan-yu5jx]

There are a lot of Hafeez Baloch around you and there was many Hafeez Baloch who was declared as traitor and blasphemous.

[@noorulbasar37]

@@Alikhan-yu5jx I agree bro.

[@nikhilsakpal7559]

Dalmiya is a famous Marwadi surname in India... mostly traders from Rajasthan , Kutch . Maybe some influential Dalmiyas pre independence .... hence the road could hage been named that way.

[@rohitrohra]

You always talk about the bengalis muhajir but you never mentioned how pakistan one identity had destroyed sindhi culture and language, gm syed who vote for pakistan after partition he saw how sindhi identity is getting destroyed he also demanded for sindhudesh also Karachi population was 51.1% hindu before partition .

[@xshapegraphic3084]

Great Hafeez Baloch very interesting person and so much knowledge about karachi

[@mubashirlatif9238]

Classic man classic this man doing the very very excellent job for all karachites

[@najmussaharbangash6924]

Thank you for a brilliant vlog.

[@iamarxalan]

Forget about Karachi , which is only 5% area of Sindh talk about the rest of 95% of your Sindh , Like what you people have done to develop it ?

[@osamasaeed7800]

One of the best podcast, bring him once again

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@hotice31]

Ok let’s ask the great intellectual Shehzad - Who was in Israel first? Jews or Palestinians?? What came first - the temple of Solomon near the wailing wall or the Mosque of Aqsa?

[@sobanghani2373]

Are there any time stamps for the video?

[@TheDartholiver]

So, I'm a punjabi/ urdu speaking sindhi!

[@luckysingh2231]

Hello, in one of your videos you talked about medieval era attacks on India. Regarding attacks on India. I want to share few things. Hardly people know what actually happened with India from the times of Arabs to british. Let me tell you in short and summarised way (in below comments rest will include) : PART 1 - Prologue PART 2 - Arabs Vs Indians PART 3 - Why we failed to counter the Turks PART 4 - Ray of hope called Chatrapati Shivaji and rise of The Maratha Empire PART 5 - Decline of Maratha Empire infront of British PART 6 - Period 1818-1857 & 1857 war against british PART 7 - British rule between 1857 -1947 PART 8 - Some books recommendations to read PART 1 - Prologue 1. Turkic are those who came from & belong to people of modern day Kyrgyztan, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, & Tajikistan.And they invaded Anatolia and renamed it as Turkey. Otherwise Anatolia was originally and actually the part of Greece. This is the reason why people of modern day Turkey looks like European and not like Uzbekis, Tajiks or Turkmenistanis , better to say Turks. The actual name of modern day turkey is Anatolia. It was a part of Byzantine Empire. The turks are actually people of Central Asia that is modern day Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan, Tajikisatan, Kyrgyztan. kazakhstan. The Ottoman was founded by Osman I and he comes from a tribe called - Oghuz Tribe which is actually a tribe of turkmenistan (a Turk tribe). Ottoman Turks belonged to the Kayı Oghuz Turkic clan, who, according to Ottoman traditions, fled their native homeland in Central Asia, during the early 13th century, due to the Mongol invasions. The clan settled in Anatolia and later on as the Byzantine Empire got weaken, these turkic tribes defeated Byzantine and islamised their people and enslaved the people of modern day turkey. This is the reason why people of modern day Turkey looks like European and not like Uzbekis, Tajiks or Turkmenistanis , better to say Turks. By the way this Oghuz Tribe also enslaved the arabs too and forcefully took the title of caliphate from arabs. The Ottoman tyranny against the Arabs was an extended reality. Let me tell you few incidents among many. At Hama, in the Levant, Ottoman Empire sent a campaign in 1685 to discipline Arabs and punish them because they ejected the Ottoman governor due to his increasing prejudice. In 1698, a campaign was sent to burn the Lebanese town of Ghazir and, a year later, the Ottoman governor of Damascus sent an army to Nablus to kill its people and capture 700 women. This injustice and tyranny forced the poor Arabs of the Levant to emigrate. Another example of the brutality of the Ottoman governors was the impalement of men and the putting of women into sacks with some lime and dumping them in rivers. Moreover, they used to burn villages. It is noteworthy that the horrific methods of torture, such as impalement, were not known to the Arabs before the arrival of the Ottomans. The person who impaled and killed the Arab slowly was rewarded. Also, they used to enjoy mutilating the dead bodies of the Arabs and cutting off parts of their bodies, especially the ears, and the leaders boasted of collecting the largest numbers of them. They also fought the Arabic language with a policy of Turkification, through publications and jobs, imposing the Turkish language on all government transactions. This is the reason why Arabs hates the Ottoman Empire. I would suggest u to read the article by Arab News, titled - Turkey repeating Ottoman Empire’s crimes against Arabs. Here is the link - arab.news/m8vfq By the way, the Indian troops under the command of Dalpat Singh Shekhawat fought and defeated the Ottoman Empire in Battle of Haifa (1918) and after this battle onwards the downfall of Ottoman Empire started. This defeat sealed the fate of the Ottoman Empire and led to its demise. 2. When I say Hindus it comprises modern day Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhist and Jains. They all belong to one Dharmic Traditions. British made division in order to divide the Dharmic society & later on further divided Hindus into castes. They made division and classification among hindus bcos they were constantly facing the revolts from hindus even after 1857, and it was getting difficult to control India & they thought if this continues then they might lose the control over India. So in order to keep the hindus in check, they made those division and classification. I would suggest you to check out Puneet Sahani's talks on KZbin.He has exposed these things with facts, esp regarding how sikhs were separated from Sanatan Dharm (Hinduism) by the british. And by the way, caste is actually derived from Portuguese word 'Casta' . So it is actually a European concept not even an Indian concept & in order to break our spirit & make us feel inferior & embarrased of ourselves with loser mindset, they distorted & manipulated our history. And all these things are documented in 1871 British India Census Documents, Mcaulay writings, etc. Infact during the british era, there were more than 500 princely states, among them over 400 princely states belong to Shudra (SC caste) Kings. I suggest u to watch a documentary of Channel - Prachyam , video titled - Sahebs Who Never Left (Documentary) . 3. Regarding Indian History,which unfortunately we r not taught correctly bcos of distortion by British which was designed in such a way that to make us feel inferior. As George Orwell said - “The most effective way to destroy people is to deny and obliterate their own history'. There is a proverb that says, “Until the lion tells the story, the hunter will always be the hero.” No wonder instead of reading History of Indians, We read history of outsiders. And till now we read history which was designed by british. And it is a big shame for all of us. Like for eg - one fact that over 1380 years have been deleted from the Indian history in order to adjust it into biblical timeline which is limited in nature i.e 2000-4000 years. Prof Vedveer Arya has written books on this & has given challenge to western historians on this.Vedveer Arya has given his talks on KZbin. OR Aryan Invasion Theory, which was designed to create animosity between North India Vs South India. Infact it has been proven wrong by many people. And this theory now has been debunked many people now. So, there are plenty of things like this. PART 2 - Arabs Vs Indians.

[@luckysingh2231]

PART 2 - Arabs Vs Indians When Arabs were at their peak and till that time whole Persia Iraq,Syria ,Egypt have fallen in front of Arab Caliphate and expanding their faith , they were defeated by the Indians. Abu Bakr was made caliph after Muhmmad died. 634: Two years later, Umar I became caliph after Abu Bakr's death. Umar I reigned till 644. 636/637: During Umar I's reign, the first ever battle between Arabs Vs Indians took place, It was a naval battle b/w Indians Vs Arabs but the arabs were defeated by Chalukya Pulakeshin II. The Indians under the command of Pulakeshin 2 thrashed the Arab army which was under the Caliph Umar. The attack was repelled with Indians victory over Arabs. 637-643: Another attack on Bharuch was made by Arabs on al-Hakam's orders. Bharuch was then ruled by probably Dadda 2 Gurjara( Lāṭa)/Vijayarāja Chalukya, depending on exact year of attack. This attack was also a Gurjara/Chalukya victory for Indians. 643 : al-Hakam ordered invasion of Sindh,Chachnama declares it Indians victory. Sindh was then ruled by Chach of Alor (Aror). Arabs didn't gain anything by this naval attack on the port of Debal (Karachi), the Indians won. The news of Arab defeat in Sindh was a serious anomaly for the Caliph's ears, which were habituated to hearing of victories in whichever direction the Arab armies went. Such was the demoralisation, that even the next Caliph Uthman, didn't dare attack India till his death. 663: In the reign of Caliph Ali, al-Harith raided the area of Kikanan (Kalat-Sibi area in Pakistan).The Arab commander was killed & Arabs were repelled. During ~660-680, 6+ Arab attacks took place on Kikanan. But, the Indians resisted and Arabs didn't gain any territory despite frequent attacks. Thereafter till 705 CE, the Caliphate experienced multiple civil wars. Kabul & Zabul Indian rulers defeated Arabs twice during this period. 708-711 CE : In the reign of Caliph al-Walid I, al-Hajjaj (Governor of Iraq) sent two Arab armies to attack Raja Dahir of Sindh. Raja Dahir first defeated the Arabs near Debal & killed Ubaidullah.Al-Hajjaj sent another commander, Budail, from from Oman to attack Sindh.Budail fought with Jaisimha, Dahir's son & was killed by Jaisimha. Arabs were again defeated at the frontiers of India & many are not aware before Raja Dahir got defeated, there were many battle between many battle between Arabs Vs Indians & those wars were won by Indians. The battle Arab won was of Mohammad Bin Qasim bcos Raja Dahir of Sindh have given refuge to some Arabs when there was Civil war between Arab & they betrayed him. But later on when the news reached to the ears of Bappa Rawal & he not only thrashed Arabs from Sindh but also thrashed & chased the Arabs upto Iran & made check posts all the way from Iran to India. Probably this is the reason why Iranian r not fully Arabised & they still celebrate Pre Islamic festivals like Nauroz etc. Later on Arabs were defeated by Indians under The Great Indian Emperor Samrat Lalitaditya Muktapida, whose dominance extended right from Bay of Bengal to Caspian Sea. The defeat of Arabs by The Great Lalitaditya was very humiliating for Arabs. After defeating Arabs, Lalitaditya ordered left over Arab soldiers to shave off half their heads as a symbol of their submission to Lalitaditya. Then Arabs were again thrashed by Indians under Mihir Bhoj & Rawal Khuman 2. How Arabs Described Mihir Bhoj - Arab chronicle of Suleiman states that - Mihir Bhoj king of Jurz. Among the princes of India,there is no greater foe of there is no greater foe of Muhammadan faith than he. And Rawal Khuman II fought the arabs and defeated the Abbasid Caliph army led by Al-Ma’mun . It was kind of a final encounter between Arabs Vs Indians. Khuman II fought the arabs & defeated Abbasid Caliph army led by Al-Ma’mun. It was kind of a final encounter between Arabs Vs Indians. Rawal Khuman II defeats arabs & captures their general Mahmud. Khuman’s victory over Mahmud was conclusive & since it was the army of the Caliphate ,it completely demoralised the Arabs. Mahmud was held captive by Khuman.He was let go after extracting heavy penalties from Arabs. So Indians didn't face any problem while dealing with Arabs. The problem Indians faced was actually against Turkic people & Turkic are people belonging to central Asia that is modern day Kyrgyztan ,Uzbekistan, Tajikistan & Turkmenistan. The mughals actually came from Uzbekistan. So they were all Uzbekis. *NOTE -Turks are those who belong to people of modern day Kyrgyztan, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, & Tajikistan.And they invaded Anatolia and renamed it as Turkey. Otherwise Anatolia was originally and actually the part of Greece. This is the reason why people of modern day Turkey looks like European and not like Uzbekis,Tajiks or Turkmenistanis better to say Turks. So against the Arabs , Indians did not face problems but it was actually against the Turks, we faced problems that too bcos of our own foolishness. PART 3 - Why we failed to counter the Turks

[@luckysingh2231]

PART 3 - Why we failed to counter the Turks *NOTE -Turks are those who belong to people of modern day Kyrgyztan, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, & Tajikistan.And they invaded Anatolia and renamed it as Turkey. Otherwise Anatolia was originally and actually the part of Greece. This is the reason why people of modern day Turkey looks like European and not like Uzbekis,Tajiks or Turkmenistanis better to say Turks. *By the way, all these Ghori were Tajiks (Turks), Gznavi, Khilji , Tughlaq etc were all belonged to Khallaj Tribe which is actually a Turk Tribe. They islamised the whole Afghanistan after the fall of last Hindu King of Afghanistan , Jaypal. The first serious Turk settlement happened in 1206 with start of Slave Dynasty in Delhi. And all other later dynasties after them were called Delhi Sultanates. And their actual rule was just limited to Delhi and nearby areas and later on they were overtaken by Mughals who came from Uzbekistan. And mughals were Turks too. Initial Turkic attack happen in Afghanistan in Battle of Peshwar (1001), King Jayapal wid Bhatti Rajputs fought against these turkic invaders though first SERIOUS Turk attack happen in 1025 & King Suheldev defeat these Turk led by Salar Maqsud in 1025. But later on why we failed to counter them in later years esp from 1200s onwards.Bcos of following reason a) Over dependence on Horses - 50% (b) Not understanding the islamic ideology - 30% -> A common reason for others too (c) Not being united - 10% (d) Miscellaneous Reasons - 10% 1. Bcos our Kings were over confident & not united. 2. This is the most important reason which comprises of 50% reason as i mentioned. It all started with mistakes by Hindu Shahi Dynasty of Afghanistan when they lose their grip over Central Asia particularly over Southern part of Central Asia & they didn't bother to establish their influence over their again.And why Central Asia was so important bcos all the Indian Kings used to get their majority horses from there. As Central Asian Horses were considered the best. In mediaeval time horses were the engine of any army.And unfortunately the Indian Kings from 500 A.D. onwards have started shifting their military tactics slowly, from being Infantry to cavalry that is horse based.And with each new century years passed,this dependency process speeds up. Its not that horses are not there in India. There are Indian breed horses. But Central Asian Horses were far more superior as compare to Indian horses. So Indian Kings used to have horses even the Indian breed horses,but they never depended on them on the primary level when it comes to military. Horses were always seen as an additional strength for the military. And infantry was the strength of Indian Kings from the Ancient Vedic times ,this is the reason why infantry marital art was developed in India. The natural military strength of the Indians was always - Infantry, Elephants & Naval Power. Even though there are several reason why they did that by shifting military tactic from infantry to cavalry. But if I have to choose one reason among many,then in short they did bcos - dusre ki thaali hamesha achi lagti hai. This happened bcos when Indian Emperor Skandgupta defeated Huns* & we Indians have established our supremacy over Eastern Hun Empire,esp Central Asian Region.And from their onwards Indians started shifting their military tactic from infantry to cavalry. It's not that people didn't caution them not to have over dependence on Horses & infact also stick to your natural strength that is infantry.And one can use cavalry as additional military method but dont let go off your natural strength that is infantry. But no one really bothered. And once the grip was lose over Central Asia. It created problem. And there was sudden collapse in the military structure & everything fall like a pack of cards. And the dynasties which didn't shifted their 100% strength to Cavalry & stick to their natural strength,those dynasties survived & defeated these invaders like Vijayanagar Dynasty, Gajapati dynasty, Ahom dynasty etc. Infact Ahom Dynasty of North East India defeated mughals more than 17 times. Both Vijayanagar & Gajapati Dynasty were got destroyed bcos of some other reason which I will explain later. *Huns = Huns were considered a dangerous force in the world at one point of time. The Huns were nomadic warriors who terrorized much of Europe and the Roman Empire in the 4th and 5th centuries A.D. The terror which the Huns caused over the Europe and the Roman Empire is something un-imaginable. Its was the Huns, who were responsible for the annihilation of Roman Empire. And with invasion of their Capital Rome in 452 AD, the Roman Empire was wiped out. But the force, which used to terrorize whole europe was defeated by Indian Emperor Skandgupta. The Hunas, under the leadership of Toramana, suffered a crushing defeat by the Indian Emperor Skandagupta in 458 AD 3. They all failed to understand religious ideology of invaders.Bcos even after loosing grip over Central Asia. We still won many battles like - Taimur Lang was defeated by Jograj Singh Gurjar in 1398. And the defeat was so devastating for Taimur that he literally fled India OR Ruler of Gajapati Empire (Eastern Ganga Dynasty) defeated these invaders in 1248 & many more etc. So Indians still won many battles but they were so naive that they didn't understand that enemies they are facing. They all failed to understand the religious ideology of invaders. Bcos even after loosing grip over Central Asia. The Kings still won many battles but they were so naive that they didn't understand that enemies they are facing are not your typical enemies. They are all driven by ideology of Islamic Zealotry.

[@luckysingh2231]

4. Over Confidence, being naive & foolishness. Even though there are so many examples but I will give you few examples among many examples : Queen Naiki Devi defeated Ghori in 1178 but instead of chopping his head she let him go free OR Another eg : After defeating & capturing Mohmad Ghori in 1191, Prithviraj Chauhan releases Mohammad Ghori in 1191. And this proved to be a heavy mistake for Prithviraj Chauhan OR King Vidyadhara Chandela defeated Mahmud Ghazni but let him go free but due to code of honour King Vidyadhara let the retreating invader Gazni go OR Alaudin Khalji was defeated in battle in 1488 by Badal-Gora OR another eg - Rana Hammir Singh defeats Muhammad bin Tughluq in 1326 and captured Mohammad bin Tughlaq & jailed him for 6 months and then let him free. Another eg - Rana Sanga defeated invaders like Ibrahim Lodhi, Sultan of Delhi in Battle of Khatoli (1517) and Battle of Dholpur (1518) . And Rana Sanga also defeats & capturs Malwa Sultan Mahmud Khilji II in 1519.Later on he defeats Gujarat Sultan Malik Hussain in 1520. Malik Hussain surrender in front of Rana Sanga & he later took all the wealth of Gujarat. Later in the same year, Rana Kumbha defeats the coalition army of two sultanate of Gujarat and Malwa. And with this Rana Sanga became the supreme power in the Northern India. After Babur (Founder of Mughal Dynasty) capturing Delhi, Babur decided to attack Rana Sanga as soon as possible. In a two months long battle between the Turko Mongol army of Babur & Rana Sanga took place in Bayana (near Agra). The Mughals got defeated & & were forced to retreat to Agra. This time Rana Sanga didn’t follow the policy of wiping out the invading enemies as he did against the Sultans of Malwa & Gujarat. He was sure that from this defeat Babur will not attack him and this gave Babur enough time to recover & to recover & prepare for the final climax at Khanwa, which was the first and the last defeat of Rana Sanga. The undefeated Rana Sanga had finally made a miscalculated move and this proved to be a heavy mistake on his part. Another eg : Maharana Pratap when he defeated 3rd Mughal King Akbar in Battle of Dewair (1582) ,he had the golden opportunity to grab the Delhi Throne and when everything was going in his favour, he just let that idea go away. Maharana Pratap not understanding that they are not your typical enemies, infact the aim is Jihad & expand their ideology. And there are many examples like this. And there are many examples like these. Not understanding islamic ideology has been a big problem of Indian Kings. Stupidity like many of mughal expansion was done by some Indian Kings bcos many Indians kings had ego tussle & internal conflict between them. So it was obvious, outsiders will take advantage of this. Like - it was Raja Man Singh who expanded Mughal Empire by defeating & subduing old kingdoms of Bengal, Bihar and Odisha and also conquered Kabul for 3rd Mughal King Akbar. Infact, in mughal empire, the land right from from Kabul to Bengal was actually conquered by Indian King Raja Man Singh when he allied with 3rd Mughal King Akbar as there was ego tussle between Raja Man Singh and Maharana Pratap. That's a different story altogether. There was also a big issue with Indian Kings that once they have given their word to someone, they always maintain that at any cost. And these invaders always took advantage of this. And this has been a big problem of Indian Kings esp from 13th century onwards, when they have given their word to someone they fully respected it & maintained it as it was a matter of pride for them and it was seen as a manly thing, a sign of masculinity. But whenever the enemy got a chance to violate it & defeat the Indian Kings, they always did. 5. Another example : When Humayun (Father of 3rd Mughal King Akbar) was leaving they get refuge in Amarkot in Sindh by King Rana Prasad. He gave refuge to Humayun and his family who were struggling at that time. Not understanding the islamic ideology. Later on these were the same Mughals who butchered the people in order to spread islam. * You gave invaders one chance, they will come and annihiliate you. Like people of Anatolia gave one chance to Turks and Turks captured Anatolia, destroyed them and islamised them completely. And unfortunately our ancestors gave invaders multiple chances to revive and attack us

[@luckysingh2231]

6. Indians were fighting among themselves too. Like the downfall of Gajapati Empire was bcos of continous attacks by Vijayanagar Dynasty from the south.Gajapati Empire (Formerly knownn as Eastern Ganga Dynasty). It defeated the invaders multiple times & later on decided to march towards Delhi & finish this mess once & for all. But it got attacks from its southern part from The Vijayanagar Dynasty. This diverted Gajapati Empire's attention & they got busy in fighting the Vijaynagar Dynasty. And this gave Foreign Invading Army of Delhi Sultanate to revive itself and attack when they saw the opportunity. With the decline of Eastern Ganga Dynasty (later on came to be known as Gajapati Empire) , The Vijaynagar Dynasty captured the Southern part of Gajapati Empire (Eastern Ganga Dynasty 7. Employing these Central Asian people in their Army as commanders and generals. Best eg - Vijayanagar Empire. The capital of Vijayanagar Empire was considered the finest capital in the whole world. And they were very powerful Kingdom. But in Battle of Talikota which was a fight between Vijayanagar Empire Vs Bahamani Sultanate and outsiders like Gilani brothers, who were appointed as commanders of Vijayanagar Army & betrayed King Rama Raya in the name of jihad against kafir & supporting the invader islamic army and boom , the Empire Collapsed. 8. And most shocking the Indians were fighting the Indians. Like during the initial period of Mughal time, the many warriors in army of mughals were actually Indians. And there is a problem with a Polytheists culture like Hinduism , Greeks, Pagan culture etc that they all easily accept the belief system of others bcos in their own Polytheists culture there are many gods and belief system so accepting a new system is not an issue for them. And this is here problem arise with monotheistic religion like Islam and Christianity that says our God is the only true God & your God is fake. And this is here Polytheists failed to understand their ideology. 9. Finally, among all invaders, mughals establish themselves as the supreme power in India. Mughals came from modern day Uzbekistan. Mughals had turkic - Mongolian genes and they came from Central Asian region, specifically from modern day Uzbekistan. From 1526 onwards, From 1526 onwards, Mughal Empire gets founded by Babur when Babur captures Delhi but later on his son Humayun (2nd Mughal King) was forced into exile when he lost battles in 1539 & 1540. He then gets shelter & refuge by Sindh King Rana Prasad. With arrival of Akbar (son of Humayun & 3rd Mughal King) , at that time Vikramaditya Hemu was sitting at Delhi Throne and he controlled an area right from Bengal to Delhi and some areas beyond it. Abul Fazl (court historian of Akbar) noted that prior to battle of panipat,Hemu had fought & won all 22 battle & never lost any battle. Akbar fights Hemu & defeats Hemu in 2nd Battle of Panipat (1556) & finally establish mughals as supreme power esp. in the northern India. And with the help of Raja Man Singh of Jaipur, mughal empire established themselves as the strongest empire of North India. It was Raja Man Singh who expanded Mughal Empire from Kabul-Kandahar in the North West to Bengal in the east by defeating & subduing old kingdoms of Bengal, Bihar and Odisha and also conquered Kabul-Kandahar for 3rd Mughal King Akbar. Infact, in mughal empire, the land right from from Kabul to Bengal was actually conquered by Indian King Raja Man Singh when he allied with 3rd Mughal King Akbar as there was ego tussle between Raja Man Singh and Maharana Pratap. That's a different story altogether. And the exact geographical area of Mughal Empire was - Kabul Kandahar in the North West to Bengal in the east and to Satpura range in the frontiers of deccan. And below mughal empire, there was Ahmednagar Sultanate, Bijapur Sultanate and Golcondas. And below them there was scattered areas which were left, after the fall of Vijayanagar Empire. Part 4 : Ray of Hope called Chatrapati Shivaji & Rise of The Maratha Empire

[@luckysingh2231]

PART 4 : Ray of Hope called Chatrapati Shivaji & Rise of The Maratha Empire 1. In Indian History if there is any hero then that title should be given to Legend Chatrapati Shivaji. Why?Bcos this legend literally saved whole civilisation,against all odds,when all other civilisation were wiped out by Abrahamic Faiths & Islamist & there was no hope left. 2. Chatrapati Shivaji was born in 1630. At that time, mughals have completely invaded half of India. And mughal army was standing at the door of Deccan. 3.Rapid islamisation was being done by invaders,with temples being destroyed,women were abducted,raped & forcefully converted,people were massacred just bcos they refused to accept islam etc. Many horrible things were done. And these things are documented in mughal texts. 4. It was a very horrible time for Indians. No hope left. Infact, it was said at that time, if this continues then within 50 years India would completely become Islamised & lose its culture and identity. 5. Seeing all this, then a 15 year old boy, Shivaji takes a vow in a temple to establish an Indegenious Empire once again, establish a Hindavi Swaraj (self rule of Hindus/Indians) which later came to be known as also known as The Maratha Empire. Shivaji takes blessing from his mother,Jijabai & gave her, his word of defeating these invaders & establishing an Indian Empire once again.He starts his military career at a tender age of 15 year,with no support of any indian kings. He did not have any regular army with trained soldiers, not much wealth to maintain etc. 6. So he builds his army with civilians, like farmers, ironsmiths, tribals etc & not with some trained soldiers. And trains them, gives them hope. Shivaji knew that he cannot face his enemies directly, as they were much stronger than him. So he devised a tactic called - guerilla warfare & since Shivaji army comprised of farmers & tribals, so he uses their geographical & climate knowledge to his full advantage. And he smartly devised his military tactics.He captures first fort called Torna Fort in 1646 at a young age of 16. And later on Shivaji killed General Afzal Khan. And this gave confidence to people under Shivaji that we can turn the tide. And Shivaji also revived the Indian Naval power once again & by 1680, Shivaji had over 380 forts. And with that he established his dominance over the Southern part of India & also re-captured the coastal areas from invaders. 7. This gave confidence to other Indians that we can bounce back,then mughals had face off with the hindus from other frontiers too apart from just deccan. And this gave rise to The Epic 27 Year Long War between Mughals Vs Hindus, which started from 1680(approx.) to 1707. -> Mughal Vs Maratha (1680-1707),which starts with the arrival of Aurangzeb in deccan in 1680. -> Mughal Vs Rajput (1680-1707), which starts under Durgadas Rathore from the western frontier of mughal empire to fight the mughals. -> Mughal Vs Jats (1681-1707), which starts under Rajaram Jat, Ramchehra Jat, & Churaman Jat to fight the mughals which started with the Jat revolt broke out in Agra in 1681. -> And from 1691 onwards, Guru Gobind Singh & Bhim Chand from North also started attacking mughal forces This 27 Year long War was a make or break for hindus.With the collective efforts of hindus,mughals lost their supremacy & with the death of Aurangzeb in 1707, the mughal dominance was practically over. And after that onwards,The Maratha Empire became the dominant force over India replacing mughals and At its peak Maratha Empire stretched from Attock to Peshawar in the North West to Tanjore(Tamil Nadu) in the south & to Cuttack to influence reaching Bengal in east with Nawabs of Bengal handed over Orissa & agree to pay Rs 1.2 million of chauth(annual taxes) from revenue of Bengal & Bihar to Maratha Empire. 9. People don't realise the fact that British did not conquered India from mughals but from The Hindu Maratha Empire, which was established by Chatrapati Shivaji. *My Personal opinion - This is something which i dislike about our ancestors that when The Maratha Empire became the dominant force, they had the golden opportunity to finish this cult once and for all. And bring back everyone to Sanatana Dharma. But unfortunately they did not made any serious efforts regarding this. And this is a common mistake which our ancestors have been making for past many centuries. And this is a thing with hindus that they accomodate multiple belief system without analysing that belief system of another. Infact among 6-8 major school of Sanatana Dharma (Hinduism) , one of them is based on atheism & they are called Charvaks. Infact Sanatan Dharm is the only culture, which allows atheism to practise. And Many great sages of Hinduism were actually Charvaks. And there are many things like this. PART 5 : Decline of The Maratha Empire infront of British

[@fayazmengal8670]

Enormous hafeez baloch 👍🏻

[@zeenathjahan7782]

Fantastic... as always!!!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@rohitrohra]

​@@ThePakistanExperienceYou always talk about the bengalis muhajir but you never mentioned how pakistan one identity had destroyed sindhi culture and language, gm syed who vote for pakistan after partition he saw how sindhi identity is getting destroyed he also demanded for sindhudesh and those who say karachi was nothing my grandparents parents use to live in karachi there were clubs,cafe even tram use to run in karachi just search karachi 1950 you will get european vibes also foreigners use to visit karachi, karachi was far developed city also before partition the population of the city of Karachi was 51.1% Hindu, 42.3% Muslim, with the remaining 7% primarily Christians (both British and native), Sikhs, Jains, with a small number of Jews.I'm sindhi hindu my grandparents use to live in karachi,sindh that time people who came from hindustan started attacking the hindus just to loot their property we have to leave sindh because they were killing sindhi hindu karachi use to come in bombay presidency mumbai and karachi use to be called sister city but now mumbai is one of the richest city in India and karachi is the 6 worst city in the world we sindhis left our motherland sindh everyday we miss our motherland I hope one day we sindhis return to our motherland, you're sindhi even you can't read and write in sindhi because of pakistan forced identity it sad you never mentioned what sindhis had to suffer from 20.5% hindu population only 2% are remaining in sindh still many are coming to India every year because of force conversion being a sindhi it's your duty to raised the issue how sindhi identity is getting destroyed.

[@SumitKumar-em7qp]

Yes, 1:05 all small meetha nala which is natural has been blocked or encroached. So he knows it but still living within issues 😊

[@osamasaeed7800]

44:57 He is referring to "James Strechen" who made the first well in Dumlotte to supply water to Karachi for the first time in 1886

[@abdulqayyum910]

bro parts q ni show ho rahy???

[@salmandrin]

Thank you so much for binging Hafeez to your podcast, the destruction is unstoppable, there are laws, but not being enforced, we have constitution but not imposed, we are already crying on international stage for climate justice and practically, govt is big provoker of climate change, the game to earn money by using various slogans. Karachi is at risk and if we will not united on environmental issue, soon we will face the affects of climate change more harshly

[@KarachiPodcast]

Commerce 101: I bought a third-hand car from Aslam. Is Aslam still the owner of the car? Should I return the car to the first owner since he owned it historically? Can the first owner say: "marsu marsu, Civic na dhesu"?

[@ThePakistanExperience]

You didn't buy it. You stole it.

[@khipksy1888]

​@@ThePakistanExperience According to the agreement signed between Pakistan and Indian govts in 1947, the properties of migrants were supposed to be exchanged. Properties of people who migrated in India were supposed to be alloted to ones arriving in Pakistan and vice versa based on the size of the ones left behind. This was implemented in India. But in Pakistan very few got the allotment, and in alot of cases these properties were occupied by locals rather than migrants. So the stollen ones are those that were occupied by locals, not the migrants.

[@noorulbasar37]

@@khipksy1888 what u said is true. But buying by force is steeling.

[@KarachiPodcast]

@@noorulbasar37 the ownership of properties is ratified by the public representatives of the supposed victims (Sindh Government / PPP). I am from Nazimabad which was bought by Government of Pakistan from a local landlord and named after Khwaja Nazimuddin. Even if any malice was involved in the process, that does not change the fact that I own my property. If we are so concerned about historical ownership, why not name and shame the Baloch Talpur occupants? Pakistan was also India before independence. Why not return the property to their rightful owners in India?

[@noorulbasar37]

@@KarachiPodcast Ratification does not make the wrong right. SC ratified BTK and imposed 460B penalty. Not the displaced people were compensated and not even the ones who had paid BTK and got nothing, but just a piece of paper. I am sorry you did not understand the core. And its not just Bahria its a bunch of 1000s of Such society schemes if not stopped from expanding no one will do agriculture and the time is not far when pakistan is going to be a food security state and hit by disasters like last year floods. leave alone the default. God forbid you wont find wheat kilo per 5000 then we can’t eat concreted buildings.

[@ammaryasir3841]

Please do another podcast with this guy

[@kishwerchaudary1340]

VERY TRUE, IN INDIAN PUNJAB LOCALS STOPPED CUTTING OF TREES.

[@Dhanupkram]

Muhajir changed the dynamics of karachi..

[@abuaarib]

Glad you steered the conversation away from the reasons-why-muhajir-identity direction it was taking.

[@deathslayer5813]

No timestamps?

[@tauqeerhussain8499]

Big fan. Dadi suthi lagi tawan ji podcast. Love from Germany.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤

[@sayyedzohaibrizvi2573]

Good Podcast. People deserve their rights and a good life. Kindness to Animals and Trees is part of our Faith. We should always do that. But the name of Hazrat Abdullah Shah Ghazi (RahmatUllah Alayhim) should be taken respectfully. Aal e Rasol (SAWW) Mein Say Hain. ❤ May Allah give peace, prosperity, and progress to everyone. Ameen.

[@wolf_crusher]

Time stamps?

[@bilalhashim3840]

sound main issue hai?

[@Alikhan-yu5jx]

The point on Balochistan is contradictory with the last 5 minutes portion. Baloch has been trying for their rights throught Parliament but they didn't get anything and now they are force to fight against Army and FC for Independent Movement and it is only last option for Baloch people.

[@A_qbal]

1:27:39 2 Nation Theory Bahria Town Bani Gala ho tu Fine laga k Regularise krdo Ghareeb ka Nasla tower ho tu Gira do

[@hemantpoonia8426]

Bro please reupload this with better audio quality... Voice is low

[@Houth10]

Waja Hafeez Baloch ❤️

[@muddi900]

The audio is messed up

[@Hamadsamadkalmati]

Shahzad bhai great to see you comrade Hafeez baloch On your podcast taking about Karachi and malir❤ Know waiting for podcast on Balochistan issues

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤

[@pbh7329]

Spineless society 😂 one might ask what infrastructure was built in 75 yrs bas India India karke timr nikaldia ..it has become worse than Somalia and Syria

[@sanamwaganwagan-vl5kf]

Pakistanis only talk about India when they ralk about history. Otherwise you will hardly see Pakistan Tv shows giving shit about India. Its habit of Indian tv shows including your politicicians who have Pakistan Phobia .

[@KarachiPodcast]

Shehzad: If a biological male identifies as a female then we should respect her choice. Also Shehzad: Muhajir is just a political identity that was created out of necessity.

[@Hassan-ki4un]

Liberal hota hi hypocrite ha. Inki kisi chez ki logic nahi hoti

[@zulfiqarali971]

​@@ChefbyMistakeaur ap kya ho mqm ke target killer?

[@allaboutknowledge6069]

Yes sir shezad hypocrisy at its peak. Such a hypocrite.

[@zulfiqarali971]

@@ChefbyMistake rao sach sach bata tum indian ho na? Lol. Apne desh ki chinta kar bhai, pakistan ki chinta chor do. Khalistan ban raha hai, uski chinta karo, upar se china ne dabaya hua border pe. Lol. Sahi line pa aja farrukh raw. Lol.

[@vineetkashyap7885]

The audio of this podcast is different from other podcast.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Karachi Electric kee waja say!

[@shortinformation6073]

Dr. Istiaq ahemed now days in india. When he returned from india and go to swedan. Its good to do podcast with him . subjects like future of south asia 👍

[@Mr-Anuraj]

Future of South Asia 🤔🤔🤔 Tu apna dekh (Lord puneet)

[@shortinformation6073]

@@Mr-Anuraj if india not settled south asia then its hard to be superpower or third poler

[@huzaifa2772]

awaz nai ari bhai ,awaz dado isk.

[@sobanghani2373]

I think people outside Balochistan dont seem to understand that Balochistan has had its political roots in progressive thought and many of the early nationalists were also staunch leftists. That progressive streak reared its head in both parliamentary struggles as well as militant ones. Yet, everybody thinks the Baloch, Pashtuns and Hazaras of Balochistan are a backwards people. I am sorry but the most progressive movements and politics has always been from the peripheries and not Punjab and the centre. Also shehzad add the time stamps😭

[@Pakistaniibnebatuta]

Urdu speaker has never been CM of Sindh speaks alot who is more at fault. Secondly SIndh should be first identity for Urdu speakers now is not wrong either.

[@Adbhut-sharma]

Poore Karachi main jaanwar base hain uske lie national park ki zarurat nahin aur yun bhi karachi rehne laayak nahi main toh din raat dua maangta hoon zalzale ki

[@SuyashRajendraTiwari]

Voice has issues. You should re upload the video

[@lenith222]

Hafeez sahab ne apna gamcha ekdum lucknowi awadhi style me liya hai

[@hajihanif4617]

Shahzad please Invite adv jalila haider the iron lady of Balochistan.

[@ibrahim75ful]

Please invite Bakshal Thalho next time. Hafeez Balouch was great addition. Bakshal would be different because most of the leftist Inhave seen here are urbanised and belong to mega cities, they are wonderful people and give their labour and work towards equal society but I think person Like Bakshal will give you more insight about rural side as well as leftist/Sufi and peasent struggles

[@rajivramanjani8706]

Disappointed that none of my questions were asked

[@muhammadhamzaaijazi2976]

Part 2 kab ayega Best podcast on mafias and land criminals like malik riaz and gumnaam beghairat log

[@madhuchaturvedi9323]

Mike ki quality thodi khrab h shyd se

[@mirza1221]

Enjoy all your episodes but this one was a unique, Gr8 show

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@ShadesFN]

Audio quality isn't good Shahzad bhai

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Sorry. Its fine after 40-50 minutes.

[@paintbrush112]

Karachites are sleeping. They need to be on the street protesting against Zardari and MQM rule.

[@shashankethane]

Please add timestamps

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Waiting on them

[@umertaimuri9260]

Sir insaan ki shanaqkt uski zubaan say hoti hai...

[@jasimmosavi3010]

🎤 on nahi tha kiya ??

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Light chalee gayee thee beech mai so we lost the rodecaster audio. Its fine after 45 minutes.

[@vg82]

@@ThePakistanExperience Bhai matlab tum logo ka standard bhi inverter / generator wala nahi hai … Average Pakistani to Stone Age Ka hoga … bilkul adimanav…

[@mrsidnan2206]

Why dont call Sahil Adeem on Topic ' Family social issues ' in pakistan?

[@adityakumar_0616]

Bhai audio sahi ker le , awaz nhi aa rhi

[@fadyNUFC]

Audio quality is poor… need to improve

[@SimranDhillon186]

Malik riyaaz the king of karachi✌️

[@Outofthisworld794]

Stay safe Shehzad❤ Awam zindabad

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤

[@dipakggupta5933]

LOGIC QUESTION. kya maharastra Mumbai ko alag state acept karega nhi kabhi nhi. ESI tarah har state mein 1 ya 2 badi Citi hoti hai jo state ka growth ka engine hote hai.

[@KarachiPodcast]

Then why was Haryana separated from Punjab? In the recent local bodies elections, PPP won with 300k votes while JI/PTI alliance lost with 900k votes (600k of which were of JI). This was because of blatant gerrymandering. Karachi is so disenfranchised from the politics of Pakistan that the turnout rate in 2018 was 40% compared to 51% in entire Pakistan. Mind you, this is not some ignorant city that does not want to participate in voting.

[@rohitrohra]

​@@KarachiPodcastohh bhai konsa madarsa se history padhte ho tum log punjab was separated on language basic to protect punjabi language and both punjab and haryana share the same captial chandigarh to support their economy.

[@dipakggupta5933]

@@KarachiPodcast hariyana Punjab se Sikho ki demand par alag huwa tha. Hariyana state koe financial City nhi thi. Jyada nhi thoda Google search+map dekh lo pata chal jayega

[@dipakggupta5933]

@@KarachiPodcast dusri baat KMC lo power do Karachi area lagbhag 30% hi hai KMC paas. Baki army,Navy, frontier force

[@KarachiPodcast]

@@dipakggupta5933 1595 billion tax was collected from Karachi in 2022, but KMC's recent annual budget was 32 billion.

[@Rahul_20000]

Love u brother u are very well read and very objective with no biases .

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@ChidiyaSethi]

Shehzad - Can you please invite some modern day Urdu Shayar and discuss Urdu Poetry ,plzzzz🙏I have been hankering after it for awhile,after all Rooh ki ghiza hai shayari 🤪🤪🥳🥳😇😇😇 🇮🇳

[@hammadnasim9236]

Invite Prof. imran from Ned Karachi. He is a water expert. Working all over Pakistan as well. With experience with ames Nasa.

[@Tsuphian]

"Mujhay laga kisi biwi ne rkha hai" xD lmaoo

[@ThePakistanExperience]

😅

[@rohitrohra]

Matlab???

[@Tsuphian]

@@rohitrohra the origins of Dalmia acc to shehzad. It was a joke 😂

[@abdulqayyum369]

😂

[@maryamsukaynah559]

I like most of the points Mr Baloch shed light on, but the Mohajirs were forced to adopt an identity as they were called by this name. An identity has some truth behind its title. The guest still has the Baloch identity, not a Sindhi one

[@adeelakif814]

excellent discussion, abbb no one will call you jiyallla

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Trust me, they still will

[@usazar]

Ah so Malik Riaz = Adani of Pakistan

[@aftabhassan7387]

Its was such a good podcast and You Shehzad asked very good questions. But I disagree with your guest in some points. He was claiming that Karachi's history from 200 years is with Sindh, what it really means! Does he want to say that before 200 years it was connected with Baoluchistan or something else. Some other things he is saying and intentionally wants to connect it with Balochi tribes. Kindly make it clear that basically Sindh owns the history of thousands of years and these Baloch tribes are migrants who have become parmanent residants now of Sindh which we respect but its humble respect that kindly dont play games with history.

[@seemashah849]

kindly aware people about the facts and capture on their land interacting with the indigenous people of the land

[@rajmd01]

Everything is fine with Pakistan 😢

[@kishwerchaudary1340]

RESERVE A PLOT FOR MY GRAVE.

[@toobamazhar4311]

although I appreciate your podcasts and the topics you focus on, but please go ahead of Karachi. I am from Abbottabad now I know more of Sindh and Karachi then my own region and city through you, so please bring new things.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Listen to the podcast please, what he is saying is true for all of Pakistan. We are seeing the Bahria Townization of the country.

[@Zahaav-]

Audio is bad

[@RedditMysticismVideos]

Shehzad if you put great emphasis on how national identity of people in different province's should not be suppressed for a superficial and concocted Pakistani identity and Urdu language on them then this right of self determination should also be universal and available to muhajirs. Saying Muhajir word is an insult or such and not correcting the guest when he said that they could've used it for some time and they shouldn't now was wrong. If you really think conservation of national identity is important to people and their right to do this should be protected then muhajirs should also be able to practice this. We call ourselves muhajirs because we want to that's it we don't want the identities of Sindh or any other national identity shoved down our throats. We are Muhajir not Urdu speaking, muhajirs and then Pakistani

[@shahjhanwagarpal7120]

blkol jb tk karachi ka development rokega nhe pakistan ke kisi hesa me bhe development nhe ho paegy ?

[@wali9378]

17:45

[@mylord3003]

This guest is a typicak jihadi. Why not he be explicit. Who is that indigenous people of Sind before islamic invaders came. Why he not mention about Raja Dahir name?

[@shahjhanwagarpal7120]

narmala bachao andolan protest delhi me meha patekar ke leadership me Me ne bhe hesa liya .....

[@najmussaharbangash6924]

Could Mr Hafeez Balooch write a book with a map on which he identifies various areas; I have read elsewhere that there used to ship sailing in this area. Please don't let this information get lost thanks

[@Tk-cf2ip]

He is bullshiting

[@shahjhanwagarpal7120]

there can be no dialog between 2 antagonists ? vo apne ko hamlaawar fateh smjte hai ye ke pakistan banaya hum ne hai looto ese har lehaz se yre 🙂

[@Tk-cf2ip]

Shazad sb we need progress. Please get some intellectuals to discuss a solution of this country not some outdated guy who wants to live in the past and doesn’t want to see any growth want to go back to backward lifestyle.

[@NiazHJafri]

What an eye opener!!! 👏👏👏 More & more power to this guy & Thank you Shehzad for unearthing Hafeez Baloch 👍👍👍

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Baray salon say unearthed hain bus baqi platforms kay parr jaltay hain inko bulanay say

[@NiazHJafri]

That's what makes your podcast so very special !!! Continue doing the great work & keep introducing people like him & the likes of him.

[@zubairdawood5887]

Call ane wali hai is podcast ko bhi.. Be careful! You are sharing things that "they" have been fighting to destroy. Also, I used to hear words like "dei" as a child, now I fully understand the meaning.

[@joydeepmukherjee3889]

Why no videos on imran Khan or on the Army's crackdown. Aur aap logon intellectual ban kar bolte ho ki India main free speech nahi hai....