how kpop idols makeup always look dimensional I

[@JaveriaYousuf]

wait a minute, the result is actually so good??

[@lilyis_]

no gatekeeping here (:

[@Yizhuo1st]

We love a non gatekeeping queen 👑 👑 ​@@lilyis_

[@Netherite0_0]

This is very helpful!

[@Kkkk590]

whait a minute- ikkimotchi ILLIT

[@bdancestars]

I never realized flat face is an issue

[@siggis_]

Wow this is actually one of the times where I can see the difference! I wonder how one comes up with this trick😂

[@lilyis_]

thank you so much!! there are several similar tricks like this but i also did my own research and took a look at a bunch of idols makeup to see whats similar and tried to imitate it/put my spin to it! i also was told some tips from actual kpop idol makeup artists when i went to get my makeup done from them before so that helped alot with this video as well~~ glad u see a difference!!

[@Lizzyd789]

Frr

[@siggis_]

@@lilyis_ I can tell research has been put in to this, well done!! I love your series about kpop muas and their tips and tricks🫶

[@essennagerry]

​@@lilyis_ That's fascinating, I love that kind of deep dive into the intricacies of how stuff works. And I like that your video has nothing to do with fawning over or pouring out one's obsession over how certain people or their makeup looks, I feel like I'm becoming sensitive over that kind of thing cause it seems like unhealthy idolization. But videos like this one where you explore, analyze, experiment, showcase, that's very interesting. I'm interested in many things kpop but it's hard to filter out the idolization. It's refreshing to see for example makeup in kpop talked about just as a normal thing. Hope my rant isn't annoying! And yeah I want to say if you enjoy making this kind of content know that there is an audience for it. 😊 Thank you for a well crafted, interesting and insightful video.

[@Piaprika]

Well it is replicating light placement. I guess they tried to replicate a specific light placement that appeared on someone else using this or these persons as reference, same process as painting or doing art, referencing is a good way to go!

[@kriskaneki8112]

You can actually see so much of the difference just from one side of the face to the other is crazy

[@KittyD859]

It’s cause she covered her dark circles which are pretty pigmented on her. No one would want you as a friend the way you lie otherwise 😅

[@resafux9373]

Of course the difference is huge ... when one side has no makup at all.

[@Momoolein]

​@@resafux9373 who hurt you?

[@Silenttreatment44]

@@MomooleinWho hurt YOU?

[@senzatieee]

Meh looks mostly the same, you have to work hard to aee the difference 😆

[@SKZFAME]

makeup is literally real art edit: started a war in the comments but keep going ig 😂

[@lilyis_]

literallyy

[@roodietoodieshow6771]

I’m a painter and illustration student and my side hustle is doing makeup for editorials lol

[@tansy2279]

​@@roodietoodieshow6771 Oh that's really cool!

[@jisooo_]

kinda disrespectful to others

[@StrawbeLia_Solos]

Makeup isn't real art. Sorry to break your bubble.

[@TheBananaMilkClub]

Damn buddy Korean makeup is a whole new science class lol particularly to someone like me who just slaps on some tinted moisturizer and calls it a day.

[@lilyis_]

LOL!! when i go my makeup done by several kpop idol makeup artists, the tricks i see are actually insane!

[@amarawinchester963]

I’m glad I’m not the only lazy person who just applies BB creams and call it a day But seriously, we should do more

[@aleena_rose19]

Omg yes .. I also do the same.. what I actually do is apply sunscreen mixed with bb cream and that's it 😂 ... but yeah we should do more

[@daHottie222]

@@aleena_rose19I hope you aren’t actually mixing the two formulations together🙏🏻🙏🏻 it will affect the efficacy of your sunscreen greatly as it’s very, intricately formulated to stabilize the UV filters. You won’t be getting the actual SPF it states on the bottle if you are mixing. Just a lil wisdom cuz I care frfr but yesss you on it protect your skin boo!!!

[@aleena_rose19]

@@daHottie222 Oh okay.. I didnt know about it... thank youu so much ☺️

[@Chichilllive]

I use this to draw faces, just like in makeup it gives far more direction and depth.

[@ellyie_n]

I was thinking of that, does it work well?

[@Chichilllive]

@@ellyie_n it helps with positioning of the face and where the facial features should go, but generally I would recommend adding more guidelines. It works for me ^^

[@ellyie_n]

@@Chichilllive ohh ok, thanks

[@Aot1768]

@@Chichilllivewhat do you by adding more guidelines? can you explain a bit more?

[@ellevictor474]

Was just about to point out how close art and make up can be... its all about shading and perspective 😊

[@marissamarshall1889]

Incredibly subtle but I definitely see the difference. Thank you!

[@Genevieve1023]

This is called "the magic line" in western makeup techniques. It was used a lot in the 20s.

[@MaidenShyWhiteWolf]

is it? As a person of a flatter face i always hated taking pictures from the side

[@NormieNeko]

I wonder why, if most westerners have angles and depth to some degree. Asiatic and Asian style faces may dramatically benefit from this on the other hand. I guess any round face could use this as well.

[@MaidenShyWhiteWolf]

@@NormieNeko Sadly i have a round face from the front but flat from the side. Deep set eyes didnt help at all with that. But its nice theres stuff to help for everyone!

[@kkilljoy3588]

Is this used much on those of white/causasian/western European descent in makeup??

[@Genevieve1023]

@@kkilljoy3588 Apparently it was when the western ideal was a rounder face. Now that we prefer the more lifted angles look, not so much.

[@lavenderorchid5501]

That’s genuinely so cool! Your makeup tips are really helpful!

[@lilyis_]

thank you so much!!

[@bcrain2733]

The way my jaw dropped at how subtle but MASSIVE the difference was

[@Mrrp_huh]

The subtle difference but it’s there. I noticed it 🎉

[@dontbemean]

I'm 40 and this is the first make up tutorial that I've seen in a while that shows a legitimately unique and interesting way of contour/highlighting in years. Maybe it's not so new, but it's new to me. Well done! 👍

[@violetviolet888]

@dontbemean: Look up videos by Makeup Artist Rae Morris from Australia. She's someone you would like.

[@ScuffKinn]

Old head

[@8jaime8]

This type of makeup was done in silent European and Hollywood films back in the 1920s and early 1930s.It’s not new.

[@dontbemean]

@@8jaime8 I'm vaguely familiar with Max Factor techniques for black and white film, but have not seen any that look like the one in this video. Can you name the pamphlet or film where this is shown? I've only seen macro level contouring, not such fine detail. I haven't seen any of the historical MUA's cover it either. Any references of your sources at all would be appreciated. I love learning and my vintage makeup textbook is in storage. Much obliged!

[@Call-me-Al]

​@@8jaime8 Not being new doesn't mean that it's still trendy in the same country it used to be heavily used...

[@cramdoodles]

bruh it's content like this that makes it worth the sub/follow, thanks for another banger analysis

[@parteed]

Right? 👍

[@thickmint5875]

Yep I only needed to see this one short and I'm definitely subscribing so I don't miss another gem like this

[@RockyNate_]

I can spot the difference!! Very cool and helpful wish I'm not too lazy for this 👍

[@tylociraptor8131]

Man ppl who are good at makeup is like wizards

[@lusss.m]

Wow, I tried, it really makes a difference. Thanks for a working lifehack

[@lilyis_]

yay!!! glad it helped!!

[@EmiUwaa]

This is why I love Korean makeup tips/tuts. So detailed!

[@marquistf1996]

Wow wasn't expecting that to look significant but it did make a real difference.

[@kaymarham5486]

"this is going to be super detailed, so try to follow along"...😂😂😂

[@blake9033]

See now this where precise makeup techniques and experience can be applied. I love it!! It actually gives such a subtle but notable difference to the face. I feel like this idea could be applied to other face shapes/ethnicities in different ways.

[@malielanijoy]

You can legit see the difference. Sometimes I can't with other people's vids, but this one is so good.

[@Gurseeratkaurdhillon]

K pop industry: wait hey hey hey gurrrlllll who taught ya this u just revealed our secrettttt…

[@AmbienceBakery]

You're a real one for this!

[@Nikartsy]

I can't notice the difference while she applies the make-up but then she shows the comparison and it makes sense 🤯

[@Kurdoffic]

Gurl ur the Korean makeup stylist 😭 ur sooooooo good

[@Jeycel-R.]

That's amazing! Very subtle but definetly works ❤

[@fairiesarefair]

Girl ,that actually made a big difference!!

[@n4h354]

This is some pythagoras ass shit howtf did they come up with euclidean makeup omg i am in awe, the results are phenomenal and I'm going to use this video to my students whenever they ask when they'll ever use geometry in real life

[@kkilljoy3588]

I wish I understood how this was Euclidean makeup….

[@norm.]

What do you mean euclidean, is this comment like ai generated or some shit

[@peachtea2526]

I was really expecting to not see much of a difference at the end, but it actually works so well!! impressive! 😮💖

[@the_originative_author3893]

Best kbeauty KZbinr! Practical, Clear, Concise, and Accurate Tips! 🐐

[@Lampey22]

If i did that with my European ahh face i’d look like the giraffe from Madagascar😭

[@abbysmith5933]

LOL STOP I HAD THIS SAME THOUGHT. i was like why am i watching this with my pointy ass face

[@EdonaComadahoutie]

Same with me I am European and my face is to wide and rectangled😢

[@Ri57490]

Most kpop idols get plastic surgery to look more European.

[@YumeraChauque]

Yes,the irony 😂😂​@@Ri57490

[@Call-me-Al]

​@@abbysmith5933 I have a pointy and bony face and this still helped me by figuring out what I need to do, better. This plus otherwise brightening where others contour will help my face look rounder and healthier instead of looking like a Tim Burton movie extra.

[@Jasmera]

I've been drawing for years, but I don't really pay attention to make up because it didn't interest me. But ever since I binge watch make up video, I realized it's all is just like drawing, so it spark my interest in make up! And honestly, learning make up help with my drawing too! Now I know how to draw super pretty girls 😊

[@Bunny11344]

I’m excited to give this a try this weekend 🙊

[@lilyis_]

oooo let us know how it goes!

[@yourfavturkkorean]

omg please lmk how it’ll look!

[@Xni3]

wow i see it even as a man it’s so amazing

[@aktobos]

Wait this made such a huge difference for what looked like not that much makeup. Wow

[@qwertyuiopasdfghjkl4607]

THE DIFFERENCE IS CRAZY!! THANK YOU FOR SHARING QUEEN

[@janinebean4276]

I wish I needed makeup to make me look like I have undereye circles 😂 mine are just LOUD AND PROUD lmao

[@Black0bsidian]

Nice! So subtle!!

[@tifKh]

This was amazing, thank you ❤

[@lilyis_]

thank you for watchingg!

[@mlb_lois]

This is THE BEST beauty advice i’ve seen in a while tysm!!

[@babalala32131]

She’s so beautiful is she Korean for some reason I love that facial structure on females so much

[@earthlyarns]

it looks so good!

[@Star-z4h1f]

This is so helpful! Keep up the great work and thanks!! 🙏 ❤

[@lilyis_]

thank you for your support!!

[@neokhohlooa5573]

I didn't think I would actually see any difference but I did! It's subtle yet very visible!!

[@prettyfoxy2288]

Girl thank u for not gatekeeping, im sharing this with my besties. thank u so much, also it looks great, u r great💕

[@Amyqwer]

You're so genius i love your videos so much😊

[@atthecore04]

You are 1 st make up artist whom i suscribe ❤..... This trick Really Works and add Value to the Make Up....love you for presenting such informative and effective make up tips❤ I always question how idols make up are so dimensional and perfect.....and without make up they don't have defined facial features... Thanks Sister for your Research 💗🥀

[@tenyharyati9355]

No wonder i love kpop idols makeup so much. It is more than contour, it is real art.

[@michex2081]

I love your videos - thank youuu!

[@lilyis_]

thank you for your support as well!!

[@cynTH95i]

Honestly in most videos like this I don't see any difference but this time it's clearly visible! Loved the tip!

[@waterdashlily]

your tips are crazy, good content once again 🙏

[@lilyis_]

thank you for your support!!!

[@Angiepewpew]

THIS is the kind of shading I was looking for. Not something snatched like I'm painting on a canvas, but something that makes shading look like it's my real face

[@ibtihal_saouli18]

This is beautiful ❤

[@lilyis_]

thank you for watchingg!

[@OhMyMiaX3]

makeup is like art, makeup IS art. a lot of tips makeup artists give is what artists do when painting :)

[@Menkuna]

I love these videos but with this specific makeup I wonder if it would even work for me since I'm not Asian.

[@YumeraChauque]

I think that is more to do with similar features than ethnicity,(ethnicity plays a role tho) but I think if you want to know if some makeup style,trend or trick is gonna work on you,see if you have similar features to the people who are rocking with that trick,if they are completely diferent, you can still try to see if works or not. E.g: I have soft features (low visual weight +rounded features) so I search for celebrities that share similar features too,like many kpop idols or random people on internet with similar traits,since I am often darker then them(I am african) I just ajust the colors,opting for deeper tones to show up in my skin(not soo deep to the point that starts becoming too heavy) and it works really well,I have my own version of heavy makeup (is not the same way the westerners do) my fav makeup isnpo are: wonyoung, Jennie from blackpink, IU,Nayeon, Danielle from New Jeans, etc.

[@non-ug3wv]

Kpop be hiring mathematicians to do their makeup

[@LizOnlinee]

I love how you say "Your dark circles" and "Your smile lines" like you implying that your entire audience has them, it's a good way to normalise them and show just about everyone has them, both of those things have insecuritys of mine on the past. Good job!

[@sibanimajhi]

smile lines shouldn't even be an insecurity. even kids have them. so weird of these beauty influencers and kpop idols to make it look like an insecurity.

[@sugar-rice]

It’s so subtle but makes such a difference

[@SaintShion]

Man its wild how dofferent i do my make up just being half Japanese. I have a high bridge and high cheekbones in comparison.

[@onceuponanightsky11]

She's gorgeous

[@peacelife]

Nice thx. I think their face shape also help

[@Angelina_amber]

Girl u r sooo good at ur art ❤

[@ZenRegalia]

I ussually dont like girls with make up, but how she explain make me like it like I Love Art

[@net.catcher]

I dont see a difference

[@abeleva_vera]

I were finding this comment

[@bonsadie1425]

I want to learn this but I really don't see the difference 😢

[@DoItWrightRo]

Your skin is gorgeous

[@windfleur]

what products do u use? love the tutorial!😊

[@Elizabeth.Tate3]

Thank you queen your the best 🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@aselle1709]

I don't see any difference. And I'm an artist; I sketch and draw people.

[@aselle1709]

And even IF there is a difference, it is so minor, it is barely worth wasting time on this makeup, IMHO.

[@ChooseTruthAlways]

Bestadvice i ve heard in a really ling time! 🙏🙏🙏❤💐

[@farinahmed2593]

Step-1: get a plastic surgery Step-2: get a plastic surgery Step -3: get a plastic surgery

[@II2NII]

You are so beautiful 🎀🫶🏻 Make-up needs you😌 I was impressed by the grades of the fundation and the concealer is very suitable for your skin.

[@buffpathfinder3607]

ok now show us without the studio lighting

[@8channim]

This is the first time that i can ACTUALLY SEE the difference on this kind of videos😳😳😳 WOW

[@shiraki8327]

I cant see the difference Guess im just dumb...

[@redmoonrise6507]

im learning makeup to improve my cosplays. i cant wait to try this!!! thank you so much lily!!!

[@maea9106]

I think you have the right thought but need to work on the makeup. I do believe you but i want to see the transformation

[@QuLaSi]

This video is so good! This needs to blow up!!

[@MinPinSteve]

What is the concealer pencil you are using? Thx

[@visitinghours420]

This is phenomenal advice

[@ashakhan5218]

Is this only for asian face shapes or it can be used for other ethnicities as well?

[@xvimie4210]

I'm guessing it usually works more for asian face cuz other ethnicities have more defined face structure like cheekbones high eyebrows etc while asian faces are usually kinda flat and round with straight brows u know? Just my opinion 😅 (btw i know not all people from same race are similar)

[@kjdunjg2929]

​@@xvimie4210asian have higher cheekbone actually, they just normally have more face fat especially female so it covers the structure

[@xvimie4210]

@@kjdunjg2929 i see i didn't know that, I'm asian with round face and full cheeks even tho I'm skinny while my friend who is arab has a very defined features as if she has natural contour

[@YumeraChauque]

Mmm some africans have flat faces too, I think it depends more if you have similar features.

[@karenbenavente1124]

Wow! Is all I can say! Amazing 🤩 really great tips

[@Athato_Brahmajijnasa]

Stay natural, that's enough

[@SaarGaladriel]

Loved it, thank you!!

[@baddie1shoe]

I appreciate you representing for helping people with special needs look more cool.

[@B1tchwow67]

what does that have to do with makeup?

[@twixbarrr]

this video isnt even abt that what r u sayinggggg

[@H_Anam]

get a life no need for random topics that don’t make sense i think u should get that checked by the doc xx

[@Keichan2501]

So basically make your face look different from what you actually look like.

[@hennywong238]

I still confused😮~~~❤❤❤

[@kate8705]

Tiny amounts make huge difference, just WOW

[@shivkumar0810]

ARE YOU PAINTING???

[@mzgranger]

Your sweater is really cute.

[@mishbum]

what if i have no eyebrows

[@icecream4355]

Seriously??

[@yellowtulip4105]

Smart! Suits that face configuration so well.

[@christianconrad5200]

They look like pancakes from the front.

[@H_Anam]

what are u even talking abt

[@christianconrad5200]

@@H_Anam she talks about the depth they give themselves with their makeup when in reality, they look like flat pancakes.

[@H_Anam]

@@christianconrad5200 i’ll be honest it’s prolly the lighting she has then and besides south asians often have flat faces so she’s right abt that and dimension is only rlly seen with the correct lighting

[@asherscott3151]

It's so subtle. Really neat video!

[@unknown_me00]

Look same.. don't see the difference 😂

[@zhe_eee]

before and before😍 wow!!

[@aditipandey5899]

Wow...this is real art

[@primordial994]

Also plastic surgery

[@user-nl4rj3oc7lfengminiunai]

like your mom did

[@watermelon7535]

They can't do plastic surgery within a turning of their face from the side profile to the front... lol.

[@reemabiswaschowdhury1887]

Me who cant even apply lipstick 👁👄👁😭

[@widxchange]

People are so weird

[@Maya_hee]

How so?

[@gaius5901]

This is one the least weird things found on youtube tho

[@widxchange]

@@Maya_hee who cares about the shape of your face in certain angles? That's so silly