How Many Man City Players Make The ALL TIME Man Utd x Man City Combined XI? 👀 | Saturday Social

SUBSCRIBE ► bit.ly/SSFootba...
PREMIER LEAGUE HIGHLIGHTS ► bit.ly/SkySport...
Joe and Smithy are joined by Flex & Kyle Walker this week on Saturday Social. Ahead of this weekend’s Manchester Derby, we get our guests to decide on an all time Manchester United & Manchester City combined XI.
#SaturdaySocial #SkySports
Watch Premier League LIVE on Sky Sports here ► bit.ly/WatchSkyPL
►TWITTER: / skysportsfootball
►FACEBOOK: / skysports
►WEBSITE: www.skysports.c...
MORE FROM SKY SPORTS ON KZbin:
►SKY SPORTS CRICKET: bit.ly/Subscri...
►SKY SPORTS BOXING: bit.ly/SSBoxingSub
►SOCCER AM: bit.ly/SoccerAMSub
►SKY SPORTS F1: bit.ly/Subscrib...

[@user-of8zx3dt4z]

This show would be so much better if football knowledge was a pre requisite for appearing on it

[@keshav7428]

Who doesn’t have the football knowledge of these 4?🤔

[@franzreyes846]

@@keshav7428 Yeah this was one of the most balanced discussions on sat social ever, I'd say

[@muzammil_babar]

@@franzreyes846 It's criminal to put in Kompany over Vidic or Stam. Cantona, Rooney, or Van Nistelrooy should be put before Aguero. We can argue over Silva but still Giggs should be in there

[@murphymoe753]

and more balanced if we can play with 15 players

[@keshav7428]

@@franzreyes846 Yes it was. I’m glad you agree too mate

[@Liam-eh2wp]

It’s sad to see how people have forgot how good vidic was

[@MGWA6891]

I'd take Vidic or Terry over Kompany. Kompany shouldn't be in the discussion.

[@Liam-eh2wp]

@@MGWA6891 terry no question is the best in prem history and vidic in his prime was the best cb in the world at one point

[@civildiscourse7626]

@@Liam-eh2wp Rio and vidic better than terry

[@welbornpakma3563]

Same hea kompany is no were near vidic n terry these two are one of the best premier league defender in the world......in their prime

[@hornylorney8150]

Stam was better than all of them

[@TW-us2pj]

It’s actually surreal how underrated Rooney is.

[@Liam-eh2wp]

Criminal

[@tris421]

Not as underrated as Cantona.

[@Liam-eh2wp]

@@tris421 cantona isint underrated only people who shouldn’t have a opinion on football don’t think he’s one of the best to grace the league

[@mediacenterman8583]

It’s actually surreal how many times people use misuse 'underrated'. One of the most decorated players of his generation, he was highly rated, even as a bloody teenager. Catch yourself on!

[@kMerz_]

@@mediacenterman8583 with being the only pl player with 200+ goals and 100+assists, he is underrated for what he was able to do with the ball and for the team. If he was more selfish he probs woulda won the ballon d'or but he was a very good team player

[@christianluker649]

KDB not even discussed for midfield is outrageous!😂

[@MarkWeston-h8e]

When u have Keane and scholes in midfield of cause he doesn’t and stupid if u think he would

[@teamrainbow7674]

Maybe Cancelo hasn’t been at City long enough, but in a few years he’ll have that LB spot in the City all-time XI

[@cai_1235]

Go watch Dennis irwin then com back

[@pedley04]

@@cai_1235 he’s talking about the City team not the Combined

[@pedley04]

@Luke Curtis Knox he’s talking about the City team not the Combined

[@theunitedopinion1757]

Doesn’t take long to become a city legend. That’s true

[@asianwarrior2193]

wow so it really takes 2-3 decent seasons to become a city legend, says everything really

[@greetings702]

Love how they had to do an all time 11 instead of a current 11 because it would just be City players

[@jasonc8352]

Eh you could throw de gea in there but I agree for the most part haha

[@Spiinellii]

i was just about to comment this lol, deserves to be top comment

[@covert9819]

Eh, only Man Utd player that can be in the Combined XI is Varane.

[@jd6069]

@@covert9819 Ronaldo?

[@gazgazclan4454]

@@jd6069 he would have been two years ago but i dont think rn he is having a great season

[@andrewharmon9720]

Schmeichel was a pioneer of goalkeeping distribution in this country. The nation was in shock at how he could comfortably throw the ball to either wing from his own area, it was unheard of at the time. His kicking was also well above average at the time for a keeper.

[@CoolDude-jp1kj]

Bruce Grobbelaar was doing that back in the 80s for Liverpool. Football didn't start in 1992 fella

[@andrewharmon9720]

@@CoolDude-jp1kj I'm old enough to remember Bruce "brown paper bag" Grobbelaar don't worry there 😉 he was decent at distributing the ball though his throwing ability was nowhere near Schmeichel's level. Comparing Bruce to Barthez would be more accurate than Schmeichel. Now if were talking 80s, big Nev the bin man was the keeper of the times.

[@reportaccounthcc2463]

His distribution from his area was great but then he seemed to lose his bearings as soon as he stepped outside of it, never seen a keeper lobbed so much from being in no man's land

[@liamnaughton9505]

Peter Bonetti was doing all the time in the sixties and seventies.

[@James-tz8qe]

He also pioneered that 'starfish' save when he was 1 on 1 with an opponent

[@danielwhite7201]

Toure massively underrated, had one of the best seasons of all time in 13/14 not just for a midfielder but for any player and had the ability to do everything on the pitch. Watching him was like watching a fully grown man playing against primary school kids and I can never understand why he’s looked past so easily in these conversations? Dominance personified as a player and even though his premier league career wasn’t massively long I think it was plenty long enough for his name to be up there with the best of the best

[@nottheonefromearth]

I wonder why

[@OKJOB]

@@koteletten84 when did Keane score over 15 goals a season???

[@Lfceva]

He was amazing only thing I can think why his talent is forgotten by so many is because how his career ended with all that stupid bday cake stuff when people think of him maybe being a diva is first thing that’s comes to mind over what he was on pitch which was a midfield master

[@civildiscourse7626]

Wasn’t long enough

[@aesir1ases64]

He was indeed great but his prime was short and he was not a very good team player. I cant swap Scholes, Keane and neither Silva for him.

[@sibldave]

Fair to put kompany, Silva and aguero in there. City wouldn't be where they are now without those three. 3 exceptional players.

[@reebok7317]

Bro Vidic>>Kompany

[@sp3ckedout224]

Let’s be honest they just put them in there so it wouldn’t be an United team😂 we all know really it’s an all united team

[@sibldave]

@UCwwfsj9rehB3zmGiv0yhLpA best in the world is a stretch but all three are exceptional and their achievements deserve credit.

[@Mcbikey24]

@@reebok7317 Kompany> Rio

[@moedoe188]

@@sp3ckedout224 who’s we?😂😭

[@kennysperling5495]

Recency bias or not, I think De bruyne gets in this team. Vision, finishing, technically almost untouchable. Also underrated strength and work rate defensively. Take out Scholes or silva depending on what balance you want, but I think he brings the best attacking threat with little sacrifice defensively. Also Vidic makes it ahead of either Kompany ot Ferdinand.

[@hc2155]

Completely agreed, I think De Bruyne was a level or two above Silva who gets more recognition because of better players that played with him for Spain. I also think that Foden will be better than Silva but not as good as De Bruyne. De Bruyne was also stronger and faster than Silva.

[@HowTo98778]

No vidic

[@r2zdena]

Okay, I agree they should put de bruyne in because he is alongside modric the best middlefielder the last 5 years and silva was never top 3-4 in the world, but you can't take scholes out

[@hc2155]

@@r2zdena Scholes was a great player but not the GOAT some people seem to think. He played very, very well in great teams but Gerrard and De Bruyne (both very similar players in a number of ways) were better than him.

[@jocklazer5526]

@@hc2155 absolutely not the legend midfielders themselves thought highly of scholes more than gerrars

[@archiewall124]

The fact that Dias is already in an all time Man City XI tells you everything

[@zentubeMusic1046]

Tell you everything about City past...

[@JTCSMadhavan]

tells u city have no history . all made up history

[@PumpedTesco]

He really shouldn’t be tho

[@humkadumka]

That maybe true in the premier league era, but I don't think man utd's all time 11 will change for a while. Two clubs at the opposite ends of the spectrum: one winning trophies and looking forward to the future, and the other constantly looking to the past and remembering what great teams they had.

[@itdenelll]

That fact that 10 out of 11 players in the Man Utd all time XI are retired tells you everything.

[@husseinkanteh2084]

I won't ever put Rooney on the bench during his prime. To me he's the best overall forward in the premier league. I think people tend to forget that for the most part of his career he was played as a winger or behind the striker. 2nd all time scorer and assist and won every single trophy on club level.

[@The_Digital_Dolphin]

Utd's most important player for a decade.

[@Allyphant2909]

He was punted into centre midfield at times, too. It's not just the brilliance of his forward play, either. It's his work rate, the work he does with younger members of a squad etc. Absolute asset.

[@hornylorney8150]

Problem is his prime was 2004

[@The_Digital_Dolphin]

@@hornylorney8150 daft patter

[@lk7923]

It’s actually gotten to a point where he was overrated now

[@davidgardiner47]

Also Roy Keane was box to box. More so in his younger days he’d get forward score goals. Became more a dm later. Best prem captain ever

[@arcticdynamite2977]

Yes he is easily the best captain ever. But overall it can be argued that the others bring more

[@Chidi_jc]

JT bro

[@sussybaka7532]

Stevie G

[@kieranm2514]

@@sussybaka7532 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@kieranm2514]

@@Chidi_jc Nope

[@varunkapoor04]

I would’ve gone for Zaba over Kyle and Kolarov over Clichy personally

[@tswelopeleseleka9641]

thank you

[@CasualJaack]

Cancelo is better than both Kolarov and Clichy

[@Chidi_jc]

@@CasualJaack longevity

[@ctrlaltdeligt]

Zabaleta’s service for many years can’t go unnoticed

[@CasualJaack]

@@ctrlaltdeligt I appreciate longevity, but Ronaldo was only at Man U for 6 years and hes in and hes an icon for man u fans. If you're good, you get in, and Cancelo is not only better than them, but levels ahead of them.

[@stevenmusicreilly2217]

Roy Keane should be the first name on the sheet he brings something not one other brings the greatest captain ever he is the Man !!! David Silva is a must he has everything Roy doesn't what a pair for the middle

[@JohnSmith-mf2nn]

Yep Keane scholes silva was spot on choice

[@stevenmusicreilly2217]

@@JohnSmith-mf2nn I would have to go 442 Giggs Ronaldo,Scholes dropping to the bench as good as he was 👍

[@otrkoddndn12]

give over mate roy keane nowhere near any of the midfielders in that team

[@stevenmusicreilly2217]

@@otrkoddndn12 who would you put in instead of Keane what team do you support are you a man or a boy

[@otrkoddndn12]

@@stevenmusicreilly2217 jesus u want my life story or sommet ?

[@MatchesMalone1183]

How can you not have Cancelo in ahead of Clichy in an all time Citeh team.

[@crabdabo1825]

Love Cancelo buts he's been amazing for about two seasons if that

[@arhaan2004]

Cancelo ain’t a city legend

[@ogviewer009]

Even Kolarov was an option

[@shussshshusssh4483]

Cancelo has only been there for 2 or 3 seasons. He's been brilliant since joining city but he's been there for quite a short time

[@u2emotional4yt]

I don't understand where Shaun goater is he was the top scorer for city when they won the league in 02

[@Batemann1980]

I do enjoy that they make it “all time” just to make the United fans feel better 😂

[@deangreen2567]

I enjoy the fact that Ruben Dias makes the ‘all time 11’ despite being there for a year. Tells you how much history City have

[@CoolDude-jp1kj]

@@deangreen2567 They've been better than you for the last 10 years and you wanna talk about history. Denis Law scored a backheel goal for city against Utd at old trafford to relegate them lol

[@deangreen2567]

@@CoolDude-jp1kj Mate Alex Ferguson had more European trophies before joining Manchester United than Manchester City currently have with billionaire owners and Pep Guardiola 😅😅

[@Hito833]

@@deangreen2567 dude United spent more than City and still nothing so your point is invalid

[@joshcox3941]

Dias isn't close to Vidic or Rio 😂

[@suzimorley9176]

I’m surprised that Kyle took ederson over joe hart

[@crabdabo1825]

I love Ederson but he rushes out way too much

[@makcine6870]

Hart is crap thats why

[@arhaan2004]

@@crabdabo1825 it’s closing down the defender and making it harder to get a shot

[@crabdabo1825]

@@arhaan2004 And half the time if costs us,e.g the most important match in our history back in May

[@crabdabo1825]

@@makcine6870 Have to be 8 to say that

[@jpa_fasty3997]

Honestly, I would've dropped Silva and had Keano Scholesy and Yaya. For me those are the 3 highest quality midfielders they had to choose from. Loved Silva but Yaya was an absolute machine in his prime.

[@WebbedShark]

I agree

[@Swayaaa]

Vidic is literally our greatest defender ever

[@jaredloveys9617]

He isn't but okay it's defo rio

[@Seth5_]

I don't think he is only our greatest defender ever i believe he is also the best defender premier league has ever seen

[@Rafiq07]

Rio and Stam are both ahead of Vida

[@brunofernandez2906]

@@Seth5_ Vidic doesn't hold candles to Van dijk and Dias though.

[@Seth5_]

@@brunofernandez2906 are you being serious?

[@suthir_nadar]

😂😂 The Roy Keane Effect...The opposition is like go on you can have the league, you can have the cup just don't leave this guy with us 😂😂

[@lukesheehan3989]

This was fun to watch because they heard each other out and were actually lenient towards putting their rivals legends in the team instead of just thinking all of their own players were the best.

[@nextguy709]

My man Maguire is not even in the conversation. Truly underrated 😭😭😭

[@diarghorbat2010]

😂😂

[@dios.9586]

Ederson, Irwin, Kompany, Vidic, Walker Keane, De Bruyne, David Silva Ronaldo, Aguero, Rooney. Some controversial but I don’t care, I believe these are the best.

[@niamh9500]

Did you start watching football in 2015 or something

[@dios.9586]

@@niamh9500 Nope, I just watch football with my eyes open. The only player that should be in who isn’t is Scholes but I prefer David Silva. Ederson is better with his feet than Schmeichel and there’s isn’t too much between them with their hands. Walker is better than Neville was. Kompany or Ferdinand is close.

[@jmac575]

For once can not argue with the selections. Well balanced team and what a spine to a team kompany, silva and aguero are.

[@footballfanar7848]

No KDB is a joke tho

[@adampotter3054]

I’d of taken cantona over ronaldo

[@adampotter3054]

@@oldaccount51 I’m going on time at United not overall obvs overall I’d take him but for United cantona

[@1987simple1987]

@@adampotter3054 Come off it Ronaldo is considered by many the best player to. ever play football for any team.

[@bullboy13]

No George best, Bobby Charlton or Denis Law is a joke

[@petejones1942]

Van Nistelrooy for me was the most deadly finisher inside the box.

[@danielwebb8402]

Proper number 9

[@masterwesty]

For United. For United right?

[@Kazekou]

Yea, just absolutely useless everywhere else. If you could put it on a plate for Van within 9 yards of goal. No-one else was better. Legitimately. But literally couldn't do anything in any other scenario. Put him in a bad team, and he'd be worthless

[@SirSoppyBalls]

@@masterwesty i see what u did there...

[@yass8849]

Van Nistlerooy finished top scorer in 3 leagues and is guaranteed to get you 30 plus goals a season so he should have been in that squad.

[@thatguywithglasses4421]

Did all time so they could fit some old united players in

[@Ronniexfu1y]

Yeah sadly

[@thatguywithglasses4421]

@@Ronniexfu1y I’m a United fan myself

[@Ronniexfu1y]

@@thatguywithglasses4421 we should get 2 cdms in the summer and get the fridge out and buy kounde or something I love ronaldo but he doesn't have the legs anymore.

[@SniperkingGaming-us6rv]

True but I don’t think there’s a single city player that would make the all time combined and that’s facts.

[@futwilko2417]

@@Ronniexfu1y I think we should only sign one because in my opinion Mctominay is very underrated I think he only looks bad because of Fred but we should sign another cdm

[@TwoFootball1998]

My 11: Schmeichel Neville Vidić Kompany Irwin CR7 Scholes De Bruyne Giggs Rooney Agüero

[@unitedtoast162]

My guy said de bruyne. Are you 5. Keane >>>>>>>, but only if you were stiil a kid would you think de bruyne is better

[@CristanioPeweyyy]

@@unitedtoast162 Keane isn't doing what KDB is doing.

[@BoxingB0oda]

Yaya doesnt get the respect he deserves, most talented player ive ever seen at city, 20 goals in the league he got one season, ridiculous. Freekick pens, insane

[@shaneoballs]

Terrible attitude, dumped by Pep twice. Cried because he didn’t get a birthday cake

[@BoxingB0oda]

@@shaneoballs does it matter if he performs on the pitch?

[@fndjufri]

As a United fan I'd rate prime Vidic over prime Stam, not by much though. Two no-nonsense defenders but Vidic just edged it for the goals and longevity. The partnership he had with Rio was one of the best in Premier League history. Keane could run the midfield on his own in his prime but having Toure alongside him they would be a rock solid unit. Silva gets my vote over my favourite united player, Scholes. He was simply a magician. Put him in a team with the other little magicians, Xavi, Iniesta and Messi, they would be unstoppable. The front three works for me. Aguero's numbers are staggering and he could have gone on to break all records if not for the injuries. Highest goalscorer for both club and country while not being the main striker for most of his career? Rooney is so underrated. And sometimes underappreciated. He sacrificed so much for the teams he played for, and for CR7.

[@arturzathas499]

silva over scholes?! i think a keane, yaya and scholes is a more formidable midfield than otherwise. keane as a 6, yaya bombing up and down and scholes being scholes. i'd play them 3 up front lol

[@siam9914]

Stam = vidic. I would say stam was even better after he left united for milan

[@Murdocke89]

Vidic was a much better defender than Ferdinand. Madness

[@JimBob-lz1gy]

No

[@lalalalllanrnrbrbr]

Defo better than Stam Ferdinand is debatable

[@camjay8637]

Not a single city player gets in there imo

[@crabdabo1825]

Sergio and De Bruyne get in there for sure

[@looneylogic6479]

@@crabdabo1825 not even a man United fan but no they do not unless it’s on the bench

[@crabdabo1825]

@@looneylogic6479 Nostalgia factor and Bias.Aguero is one of if not the best Premier League strikers of all time,only trumped by Henry and De Bruyne is probably the top 3 Prem midfielders of all time,Maybe even No.1 his passing is something else

[@jacklee1766]

Deluded I think 3 or 4

[@looneylogic6479]

@@crabdabo1825 not really I’d have Roy Keene and Paul scholes over Kdb all day long and I’d have Rooney over Sergio and if you think differently your a mug or under the age of 16

[@jacksandler5695]

Is Kyle okay?? Can’t believe he’s out Clichy ahead of Zabaleta and Ali Bernabia in there 😂😂

[@dylanmulroe9978]

Zabaleta was a right back lad

[@jacksandler5695]

@@dylanmulroe9978 can play him at left back for the sake of an all time PL XI

[@Mikejames1080]

You obviously never watched Ali play. He was a genius. He was french player of the year just before he joined us. And even though he was 32 when he joined, I think he got at least 20 assists in his first season.

[@matthewchampion8214]

@@jacksandler5695 No that's not how it works at all. LB and RB are two unique positions and a player has to be proven in a specific one to get in. It's not like midfield 3s or front 3s where you can interchange because the positions are fluid.

[@prod.maskedman]

@@Mikejames1080 wasnt his first season in the championship tho or something (could be wrong)

[@mrhussain9008]

Man United fan unbiased as I can be. 433 Manager: Sir Alex Ferguson Schmeichel Walker Ferdinand Kompany Denis Irwin Scholes Keane KDB Ronaldo Aguero Rooney Second team is incredible too. 442 Manager: Pep Guardiola Ederson Neville Stam Vidic Patrice Evra Beckham Yaya Toure Fernandinho Giggs Cantona Van Nistlerooy Edit whilst watching the video 🤣 3rd team can probably win the league. These two teams have been so dominant in PL era. 442 Manager: Roberto Mancini De Gea Zabaleta Dias Pallister Cancelo David Silva Carrick Robson Sterling Tevez Van Persie Thank you.

[@antonioruella377]

aguero has to be in

[@Coys87]

A lot of people forget about georgie kinkladze for the best man City team

[@TomJ_3]

Who?

[@Coys87]

@@TomJ_3 played for them in the 90s amazing player and that's from a spurs fan

[@barry2924]

This guy was simply brilliant, I was talking to a guy in maybe his 50s says kinkladze was there best ever player , played in a poor team and still was brilliant, says alot

[@Coys87]

@@barry2924 I can remember him taking on players and scoring 1 of the best goals I have seen!it must be on KZbin some were! I always wanted him to play for spurs a gifted player

[@Coys87]

@@barry2924 I'm in my 30s but one player I always remember

[@stuartgould4819]

I’m so happy you’ve argued yayas case , he’s the best player we’ve ever had , Yaya did things that I’ve still never seen done before and since , yaya walked that cdm at Barca also , what a crazy twist at the end , joke

[@antonioruella377]

aguero is your greatest not even debatable, yaya a beast tho

[@joshdawson5850]

Yaya is literally the only City player that could get in lol

[@Dan-kb9vr]

Aguero no Brainer

[@ironheade22]

Walker, Kompany, Fernandinho, De Bruyne, David silva and Aguero also get in

[@joshdawson5850]

@@ironheade22 don’t need Kompany with Vidic and Rio, Man U have GOATed midfield as it is (Scholes, > KDB, Keane > Fernandinho). As for strikers… maybe Aguero gets in on second thoughts, but it’s very tight.

[@jacklee1766]

Scheimechel Neville Vidic Kompany Irwin Keane Toure Scholes Silva Ronaldo Agüero

[@kieranm2514]

Just no

[@jacklee1766]

@@kieranm2514 deluded

[@jacklee1766]

@@kieranm2514 rooney is debatable but your just biased because you don’t appreciate the talent of david silva

[@kieranm2514]

@@jacklee1766 Rooney isn’t debatable at all and no I just watched football before 2012 unlike you ya plastic

[@jacklee1766]

@@kieranm2514 your just nostalgic ya pillock yes rooney was amazing at everton aswell but his later years made me put silva above him and also david silvas consistency, humble attitude, important assists, important goals, overall satisfaction to watch as a footballer he is a work of art FACT

[@glandmajor5430]

”Ryan giggs the most decorated player” no Flex, its Dani Alves

[@kieranm2514]

Forgot Dani alves played in the premier league

[@glandmajor5430]

@@kieranm2514 he did not say the most decorated player in the premiere league you melt

[@glandmajor5430]

@@kieranm2514 matter of fact he said “the most decorated footballer” fullstop

[@mural1884]

United fans are saying “city’s players are all from the past few years” if you look at uniteds all time 11 the majority of them played in the same team because that was the clubs best period so lost of them players will get in that team. City is having the best moment in the clubs history so obviously many players are going to be recent because they’re still dominating football

[@mocathain]

Keane has to be in that team ffs

[@flucazade]

I genuinely believe people forget how good Roy keane was

[@Butterpants1987]

i think flex was just playing nice. no city player gets into this 11.

[@Joshuawhu]

@@Butterpants1987 Sergio aguero?

[@mocathain]

@@Butterpants1987 what age is flex he was probably in nappies when Keane was one of the best midfielder in the world

[@abrahamlunchtime5421]

Okay but scholes,kdb and yaya should be there

[@doubledable]

Keane not only goes into all time prem team he captains it!!

[@Hadar1991]

To be honest there is also a lot to say about Kompany to captain. Kompany was way more level headed, but also I thing he would prefer not to captain it that would help to avoid conflicts. But Roy and Vincent could have excellent bad cop - good cop dynamic (regardless who would be captain and who vice captain).

[@dontwannaname]

Title says "ALL TIME". Content: "1992 onwards" What a surprise!

[@ardakz4867]

Duncan edwards gets in my team

[@ant292uk]

Football didn't exist until 92. Ask any rag

[@gazgaz5765]

@@ant292uk For City fans it is 2012, ain't it?

[@ant292uk]

@@gazgaz5765 nooooo, we had the good ol' days of yo-yoing up and down. The days when city were the team I knew. This isn't city in the traditional sense, but at the minute it does for me

[@raveninnsbruck9166]

*A BETTER COMBINED XI* Manager: Sir Alex Ferguson GK: Peter Schmeichel RB: Kyle Walker RCB: Vincent Kompany LCB: Nemanja Vidic LB: Patrice Evra RM: Kevin De Bruyne RCM: Roy Keane LCM: Yaya Toure LM: David Silva RS: Sergio Aguero LS: Wayne Rooney

[@ben-ne5rq]

Schmeichel - Zabaleta Rio Kompany Irwin - Yaya KDB Keane - Ronaldo Rooney Giggs Liverpool fan

[@spade5752]

First time people given Rooney the importance he deserves. He is the most complete athlete, super aggressive and gosh that stamina!

[@Azzi_0161]

Notice how every player from City is the last 10 years. What a joke of a history City have 🤭😭🤣🤣

[@abrahamlunchtime5421]

They're catching up

[@arhaan2004]

lol you guys are a joke now they’re making history while you guys are living in it

[@space1734]

I rather keep making history than living in past history

[@aks99-4]

@@space1734 All your trophies are tainted with Arab blood money, joke club

[@zirbto5749]

And most of United's players are from 20 years ago what a joke of a history United had

[@javiismael1480]

Their 11 is discarded when they left Cantona out of team …. 5 season 4 premier league at United

[@Ethan-tb6nu]

Aguero is so clear of cantona

[@ChristopherWhite-yg4hh]

@@Ethan-tb6nu not even close

[@kevinconway2965]

If this was Specs arguing Arsenal's XI v Man Utd XI, there would be 13 Arsenal players up on that board.

[@casparlinsell5284]

What this got to do with arsenal

[@isaaclacquiere7468]

Hahahhaha

[@kevinconway2965]

@@casparlinsell5284 Because these kinda spots never work with Specs because of how biased he is. I'm saying I enjoyed this because both sides gave respect.

[@liamclarke5275]

All this proves is some people didn't see Keane play before his hip injury & he went from being the best box to box midfielder in the league to the best defensive midfielder in the league.

[@abbey810g]

Having watched Premier league from 1995 onwards keane never really had a season with a lot of assists or goals. I remember keane even playing centre back in Europe in 1996 and playing well so defensive qualities keane did have. I would argue Vieira scored more long range goals and more headers from corners in a tougher era also.

[@1987simple1987]

I saw Keane even before his United days and he was an amazing warrior and leader but he wasnt a great player on talent. If the team lacked leaders we can make a case for him but with Kompany, Schmeichel, Irwin, Neville, Ferdinand and even Ronaldo he was not needed. I respect what he achieved but as far as a all time combined great that can not happen. I suspect he wouldnt even make the grade at any premier league club these days.

[@liamclarke5275]

@@1987simple1987 Possibly 1 of the worse comments I've seen on this site. The top teams in the Premier league were literally fighting it out to sign a young Roy Keane from a relegated Nottingham Forest. He was arguably the best centre midfielder in the world in the early 2000s. A genuine great player on & off the ball.

[@1987simple1987]

@@liamclarke5275 No he was bullied by Viera regularly. Keane is nothing special he only got where he did because of him leadership and mentaility. Every club was fighting for Todd Cantwell a couple of years ago and Giles Barnes when he was at Derby and Jermain Pennant and countless others. Look I respect what Keane brings to the table but as far as footballing talent goes he was nothing special. He wasnt missed at United and was replaced by Carrick who couldnt get into the England squad. Keane in his prime would not of got into France's midfield with Zidane and Viera and Makelele and so on.

[@muhammadaziz6359]

De bruyne goes in that midfield easily!

[@matiyaskebede8743]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@sufamidan1006]

Mate, Bruno is better than him.

[@henrywilde8468]

@@sufamidan1006 your having a laugh

[@tb3616]

@@sufamidan1006 🤣🤣🤣🤣 you made my day.

[@muhammadaziz6359]

@@sufamidan1006 hahaha that sums up your footballing knowledge. Compare what he has achieved over the years including silverware and Individual honours to bruno's nothing, its an insult. Typical utd fan who can't bear reality!

[@sussybaka7532]

As a Liverpool fan it's pretty much a United sweep besides aguero and maybe de bruyne or kompany

[@jazzbazz3003]

Walker gets in

[@apetorsson1740]

@@jazzbazz3003 holy....hahahhaha

[@chalesbergca3754]

Got to have De Bruyne in there for me

[@jamieevers4300]

Init

[@kingrobert7246]

He’s rubbish always shooting never passes

[@TheJonSadler1]

As a neutral… Schmeichel Neville Kompany Vidic Evra Scholes Keane Ronaldo Rooney Giggs Aguero

[@k17nopasi]

That’s actually insane how Jaap Stam wasn’t even talked about. At their best, Staam is a better defender than Kompany

[@SeriousBartYT]

Keen Observation : Smalling, Jones, Evans, McNair, Blackett, Blind, Lindelof, Bailly,Axel,Mengi,Varane,Rojo, Maguire is the list of players that have played at center-back during the last dozen years. People go on and on about City's investment in full-backs but Man United's on CBs is staggering too.

[@kennymitchell4361]

Mengi mcnair evans tuanzebe blackett all came through academy and blackett was a fullback same as rojo they are not cb's smalling and jones cost 26 million and at time where touted to be 2 of the best up and coming cb's at the time. The rest is fair enough

[@SeriousBartYT]

@@kennymitchell4361 admit it that Liverpool have had a HUGE role in Man United's success in the past half of a century.

[@jackcollins1]

I’d pick kdb over silva in the combined 11

[@taylorjames14]

Both better than Scholes and zabaleta was way better than neville and walker. Just overrated English bias

[@Klassj4343]

@@taylorjames14 both Kdb and silva better than scholes? Both are really talent but scholes is just outrageous in all honesty.

[@CristanioPeweyyy]

@@Klassj4343 Nah, Paul is a goat, but he does get overrated.

[@newstreetbridge834]

Jaap Stam was better than Vincent Kompany surely but maybe his time and service for City helps to swing it.

[@TS-xf3fw]

Agreed Stam low-key United best ever cb

[@matthealey187]

Schmeichel pioneered delivery from the back when it comes to premier league keepers - unlike modern keepers who play out from the back though Schmeichel would start deadly counter attacks with his long throws out to the wings.

[@FootballLatestOfficial]

How does de Bruyne not make the team? He is one of the best passers in premier League history

[@gladiatorscoops4907]

I would've gone nuts if I didn't see Irwin in as LB and I'm an Arsenal fan! He was mustard, so consistently good going forward and defending and his delivery was excellent. As for the Toure debate, that one season Toure had - You could argue he reached a level that no other CM had ever reached, arguebly surpassed what Vieira, Keane and Gerrard in that utter physical dominance of a central midfield pov. But he only reached that level for one season and although had other strong seasons he never quite hit that level of consistently excellent that the 3 mentioned reached.

[@robertpowell3634]

Did he really say that Kyle Walker could go down as one of Englands greatest ever right backs? Can I have some of whatever he has been smoking please? one of the funniest things I have heard ini a long time.

[@joshrickards4431]

Hes not wrong

[@tomyflowers5391]

Not wrong

[@palashrawat401]

He is absolutely correct. I don't think England has seen a specimen like Walker ever. And the flex was WRONG about Walker at Spurs because Walker was essentially what made Poch's Spurs so intensive and aggressive.

[@nikos208]

English Roberto Carlos

[@joshrickards4431]

@@nikos208 wouldnt go that far

[@vidvukelic9515]

Embarrassing Vidic is miles clear of Stam and Rio too

[@Liam-eh2wp]

People forget vidic was better than Rio

[@blank1933]

Stam is better than Vidic, Vidic is better than Ferdinand

[@jacklee1766]

Vidic clear

[@bendohber4937]

ALL TIME ARSENAL AND TOTTENHAM XI Seamon Dixon ,Adams, Campbell(arsenal), Cole Vieira , Petit Pires , Ljungberg Bergkamp ,Henry

[@martinkane5403]

Schmeichel Walker - Kompany - Vidic - Evra KDB - Keane - D Silva Marez- Agureo - Ronaldo

[@incognito20xx23]

The guy in blue looks like he’s going through a divorce and has to live with his nephew and his friends

[@benzzimo3011]

Liverpool fan so I’m neutral and didn’t get to see the likes of Keane, Beckham etc so my team is De Gea Walker Rio Kompany Evra Yaya Silva De Bruyne Ronaldo Rooney Aguero

[@badreddineouladaarab3605]

Walker???. You trippin real hard

[@Josh-pj7tq]

De Gea over Schmeichel? Walker over Zabaleta? Evra over Irwin?

[@jackcarter05]

All time mate not past 10-15 years

[@ondutyz7905]

silva for yaya and then we good

[@benzzimo3011]

@@jackcarter05 read the comment again mate

[@alphabetadams1024]

They shouldn’t have used Cristiano’s new picture, only his first stint warrants being in the team.

[@nickolauskanzki5332]

Man the midfield should’ve been Silva, Scholes and de Bruyne. You have two who can control the midfield and an agressive forward passer who can guarantee you 3-5 big chances per game

[@ayushghimire4806]

KDB must be in there. Greatest pl midfilder ever. Deep down people know that.

[@wingnut2900]

Yaya should be in. He wasn’t there long but he was unplayable, he could do everything. Roy Keane was amazing but both playing there peak yaya still bosses him in a game for me

[@deftonesenthusiast]

behave

[@aneeshparnerkar1310]

FINALLY AN INFORMED, FUN AND NOT AN IRRITATING DISCUSSION!!!!

[@adamedworthy8655]

Irony alive and well I see!

[@BenCreaven]

@@adamedworthy8655 no as a fan of neither teams this was a balanced and fair team

[@diyasawhnyglazerout70]

For me: Schmeichel G.Nev Vidic Kompany Irwin Keane Scholes Rooney Beckham Cantona Ronaldo

[@jackninetynine5036]

Wonder who u support 😂

[@kino6395]

Calm down united fan The fact your playing Rooney at AMF and missing Sergio Aguero shows your bias. you should drop Beckham and Cantona and put Silver and Aguero in. I also think the argument between Walker and G.Nev is getting close and is 1 major trophy such as a WC, Euros or CL for Kyle and he will take the spot but 2 of them are really unlikely as when does England actually win anything. And finally Ronaldo he makes it in my view but wasn't really at United long enough when compared to the other names in the team if when he went to Real Madrid then he became crap would he be in this team? ill also take your word on Vidic over Ferdinand Schmeichel G.Nev Vidic Kompany Irwin Keane Scholes Silver Rooney Aguero Ronaldo

[@diyasawhnyglazerout70]

@@kino6395 lol that probably is it. Yeah Aguero gets in But dont you think some city players are so forced to come into this 11? Theyve gotten 3-4 legends who have come within the last 10 years. How can they manage to get ahead of everyone in the united position. eg- In midfield, u cud put silva. But I could name Keane, scholes, robson, rooney tbf, beckham, giggs... Is silva clear of them? I would argue not. Also, Kyle Walker imo is extremely overrated. Its just his pace that makes managers like him...

[@diyasawhnyglazerout70]

@@jackninetynine5036 as obvious as who you support lol 😅

[@kino6395]

@@diyasawhnyglazerout70 how many of those United legends came from the same length of time as the City legends? They just happed a decade earlier. With City you have to remember that those 3 players are City's class of 92 or a more similar case would be Wenger's french signings during the late 90s early 2000s. Measuring quality of players across generations is impossible and City's are newer so they usually take the fore front in people's lists. The perfect example is Rooney, during his youth people rated him higher than Ronaldo. Then Ronaldo exploded over 2 seasons for United then went off to Real Madrid while Rooney stayed and even had a few more outstanding seasons. Yet in these lists you see people snub Rooney for Ronaldo. Rooney did far more for United yet is forgotten due to the fact the Rooney hasn't really been relivent for years. People over rate the now and it will never change.

[@alfieshanks6555]

Schmeichel, zabaleta, Rio, vidic, evra/irwin, keane, scholes, David silva, giggs, aguero, rooney

[@londzale3163]

This is why I never listen to people when they say Man City buy all the best players. Look at how lop sided this 11 is. People never rate man city players when it’s time to pick their fav 11. But that same day they claim man city is dominating the league because they have the best players. The hypocrisy is real.

[@DYL2020]

Schmeichel Walker Ferdinand Vidic Irwin Keane Scholes De bruyne Ronaldo Aguero Giggs Sir Alex

[@georgeflores2410]

Look I love Yaya but I cannot see this team without de bryune. I know he’s still has more years to play but you got to say de Bruyne can run a game just a little more than Yaya. Yaya was a monster but de Bruyne has power and arguably the best passing ability ever seen in the history of the league.

[@1987simple1987]

Yaya for Keane and De Bruyne for Rooney problem solved.

[@mandem2362]

Nope KDB isn't better than Rooney.

[@1987simple1987]

@@mandem2362 What????? Rooney was thrown to the wing every time United had a decent striker because he was never the main man even at his club let alone all time teams. Remove his penalties, how many goals did Rooney score as a striker for a team dominating the league???? Rooney is bang average hence him never ever being linked to top clubs abroad. Madrid and Barca and co wouldn't dream of signing such a player. Yet every team in the world would sign De Bruyne given the chance even at his current age.

[@gingerbob14]

I’m a Liverpool fan and I genuinely think that a maximum number of 3 city players get in the United side.

[@danielskelton1757]

who would you be thinking?

[@guledm349]

Man I swear people think historically, in todays age. This city side would've smashed 2007 utd side by a lot.

[@gingerbob14]

@@danielskelton1757 I’d probably put Walker in there, and depending on formation, david Silva. People would argue Aguero and I get that but I don’t think he was better than Rooney or Cantona.

[@gingerbob14]

@@guledm349 yeah, cause the game has changed but I’d say man for man, those United players are unreal. It pains me to say it but they truly are

[@arjunsunil05]

@@guledm349 In your dreams.....

[@CB-ms2cq]

Walker Kompany Vidic Irwin Yaya David Silva KDB George Best Ronaldo Aguero If anyone can name a better side try your best?

[@AdamT-mv3ok]

Based on this eleven, switch to a 4-2-3-1, put Silva on the Right and Rooney as the 10.

[@markcoughlan2233]

Keane should be the first player on the team. If he was english he would have been

[@Vanguardkl]

Maybe Beckham over Scholes. He was always underrated because he's a celebrity.. and Scholes is a legend, but Beckham did better than most people think

[@Mufc479]

What on earth did I just read 🤣

[@jworadech5195]

Well, Scholes won 11 titles 😂

[@lalalalllanrnrbrbr]

Go watch football

[@jacklee1766]

Scholes clear of beckham

[@Vanguardkl]

Proves my point. Becks has a higher goals and assists per game ratio vs Scholes, he has 80 assists vs 55 for Scholes. Go watch football.

[@jimmorrison3756]

Eyal Berkovic would also walk into that City team he was brilliant with Benarbia. And also Kinkladze should be there too.

[@RoomAtTheTopStudio]

You're reading my mind. I loved Berkovic when he played for us. He controlled the midfield and created so much chances for Goater. To me he was David Silva before David Silva lol

[@jimmorrison3756]

@@RoomAtTheTopStudio He sure was mate a top player, and he also reminded me of David Silva very similar even their passing of the ball etc he even ran like him a little! Great player Berkovic his solo goal from the left side vs Norwich at Maine Road was immense.

[@jimmorrison3756]

David White and Paul Lake were both class too and should be in this team. Even Ian Bishop could be in there amongst other's i haven't mentioned.

[@captaincharisama94]

Who remembers when Shaun Goater ripped Neville a new one?

[@98091238]

Nemanja Vidic's CV - * 5 Premier League titles * 3 League Cups * 1 Champions League * 1 FIFA World Club Cup * 4 PFA EPL teams of the year * 2 EPL Player of the Year Awards (Henry and CR7 are the only other players to win it twice) * 2 FIFA World XIs * EPL 20 Seasons Awards fantasy XI * 3 European Sports Media team of the year selections * Manchester United's Matt Busby as well as Players Player of the Year in 2009 * Captain of Manchester United ahead of the likes of Rooney, Ferdinand, Van Der Sar, Carrick, Evra etc. but the potential of Stam never leaving United gets him in Flex's best United XI of the EPL era... seems legitimate

[@antsy93]

Not a fan of both but for me, this line up would be a nightmare Schmeichel Walker - Vidic - Kompany - Irwin Keane - Silva - Toure Rooney - Aguero - CR7

[@jamiecook4288]

Agreed. That is a frightening team.

[@aodhanmccrudden8973]

I don’t know how Flex didn’t say Keane because any United fan will say the only player United have never replaced is Keane.

[@eddielasowsky7777]

Keane left in 2005 and Utd still won leagues and a European cup. They didn't miss him.

[@aodhanmccrudden8973]

@@eddielasowsky7777 ask any United fan about Keane, they’d say the never replaced him, any United fan I hear anyway. Any player who played with him said if they done a combined 11 he’d be the first name on it

[@aodhanmccrudden8973]

@@eddielasowsky7777 or even best 11

[@connoryoung3012]

We never replaced scholes he's arguably one of most naturally gifted England has produced, came back from retirement and won the leauge again and we havnt won 1 since, fergie left too, for me scholes & fergie are irreplaceable

[@aodhanmccrudden8973]

@@connoryoung3012 do think they should have put Scholes and Keane in that team and left out a city player

[@Legenda20SLO]

Lmao making best Man UTD eleven without D. Beckham. HAHAHAHHAAHA. That's all im gonna say.

[@chinchu7000]

Cristiano Ronaldo was a complete upgrade from in every shape and form David beckham wake up lol

[@Legenda20SLO]

​@@chinchu7000 I've been watching football from 98. I know how good Becks was, you have Scholes, Keane and Giggs in Man UTD dream team, but the whole Man Utd midfield was lost without D.Beckham back then. I assume you're a millennial and you didn't watch any Man Utd game in the 90s, if this is the case I recommend you to start watching highlights and you will quickly figure out that every attack started from the right wing, Becks made so many assists from the right side and it didn't even matter who was a forward, either Solskjaer, Yorke, Cole, Sheringham or later on Ruud V. Nistelrooy.

[@TW-us2pj]

David Beckham was nothing special. He was a great crosser set piece player and had a good 40-50 yard pass on him. That’s it.

[@ogviewer009]

Who would u leave out to make room for Beckham tho??

[@Legenda20SLO]

@@chinchu7000 Another thing I want to say. In 2000 his teammate G. Neville said D. Beckham is the most fit player in Man Utd team. He was running like crazy up and down, maybe he was not the fastest player but his stamina was unbelievable. Take a look how many times he saved the team in the dying seconds of the game.

[@liamrogers445]

roy keane not even getting in😭😭

[@Jurmeytobgyevideos]

Should've been: schmeichel Walker Ferdinand Kompany Irwin Scholes Silva Yaya Rooney Ronaldo Aguero Bench: Joe Hart (4x Golden glove winner), Neville, Keane, Giggs, KDB, VIDIC, Giggs, Tevez, Beckham, Ji sung Park

[@mandem2362]

Scholes and Silva should be swapped positionally

[@Always-Hustle]

Lies - all time city v United is just United

[@kentro900]

Deluded

[@nomad350]

If you’re being really honest, none of the city players would get into the team except maybe Silva. Stam was an absolute unit. And although aguero was amazing but Cantona definitely better. If it’s a 4-4-2 there’s no hope for any city players to get in

[@mjmdable]

Rooney and aguero up front > Rooney cantona in a 442

[@CristanioPeweyyy]

Aguero is better, his goal records don't lie.

[@franzreyes846]

That's just old time bias and nostalgia is clouding your judgement if you seriously think Aguero doesn't make into this team. Cantona is the man for the big moment and his aura was awesome but Aguero is the most consistent striker ever as shown by his goal scoring ratio and a better player talent-wise.

[@franzreyes846]

@Tahmid Ahmed But Rooney is good enough to play on the wing so Aguero can play ST. VP and VN are great but you can't seriously say that you have them over Aguero. They don't have his wide array of shots from the delicate dinks, predatory inside the box instincts, and outrageous outside the box strikes

[@michaelduckett7688]

Aguero is 5 times the player of cantona. Cantona is below yorke, Cole, sheringham, Van Nistelrooy, let alone Rooney.

[@jacksharkey562]

Loved this. Respectable debate with mature discussion and balanced opinions, with bias taken out. More of this please

[@as8603]

Kyle Walker & maybe aguero are the only city players that should be in the conversation

[@joeverecondi8096]

If it's only premier league era don't call it all time

[@unaxlarreta]

I hope they do this with liverpool and united before they face each other at anfield, it would be interesting to see an all time combined XI of arguably the 2 most succesfull teams in english football....

[@mmm9682]

It’s not an argument it’s a fact. Liverpool and United are the most successful teams in England by a distance.

[@alfieshanks6555]

I agree. The thing is with the premier league Liverpool have only won it once. Only Suarez, gerrard and mo salah would have a chance getting into that team…

[@unaxlarreta]

@@alfieshanks6555 but we're talking about all time, and in that we'd have to take to consideration king kenny, rush, all the greats... Both clubs have been so successful that it would be really tough to pick an eleven🤣🤣

[@MGall_Channel]

@Alfie Shanks Trent would get in over Neville for me.

[@unaxlarreta]

@@MGall_Channel if he has the consistency neville had, definitely. Trent will defo end his career as one of the best if not the best rb in prem history. He has the talent & the mentality for it🤷

[@TheMasculinistPOV]

Garry is literally the best English right back... The walker conversation is silly

[@diyasawhnyglazerout70]

agree

[@onepain2217]

No one bully walker

[@jakebeck-power6312]

The best got bullied off goater in the last Maine road derby

[@Johndoe-gf7eu]

@Jake Beck-Power you can find an example of any player in the world having a bad game. I don’t remember shaun goater winnimg anything 🤣🤣🤣

[@Johndoe-gf7eu]

@Jake Beck-Power that was shauns cup final bless him, gary had already won the league that year😂

[@MrSimonson]

I mean I haven’t watched this yet and I know I’ll be angry unless I see giggs, scholes, Keane, Ronaldo, Rooney, Irwin, Rio.

[@randomsimpsonsquotes6033]

Calm down, it's not real.

[@andrewmartin2103]

@genesis giggs was but as a person he is most decortated British player of all time but the guy is a but nice as a person hes not.

[@MrSimonson]

@@randomsimpsonsquotes6033 😢

[@MrSimonson]

@genesis suppose he’s technically British but ye welsh

[@MrSimonson]

@@andrewmartin2103 doesn’t about what kind of person he is we are judging his ability

[@LukasOfTheLight]

Schmeichels Walker - Kompany - Ferdinand - Evra Keane De Bruyne - David Silva Beckham - Aguero - Rooney

[@MotionFlix101]

Beckham over Cristiano Ronaldo are you mad🤣🤣

[@icemanire5467]

Not bad, but Stam over Ferdinand. Irwin over Evra Ronaldo over Beckham

[@icemanire5467]

@@MotionFlix101 to be fair, it was a tough choice. Ronaldo went on to be debatably the best player of all time, but he was a kid at United learning his trade. Beckham contributed more at his time at United.

[@JKnight23]

Most City fans don’t even know who Bernarbia is 🤣🤦🏽‍♂️