How Phil & Holly Tricked This Morning Viewers

[@cungie]

Marina censoring mother but dropping f bombs hahaha

[@xixXxxXxix]

I came straight to the comments 😂

[@GreenyWolf]

I proper lol'd at that one :D

[@stevecatterson6920]

Oh. I should perhaps have had a look at the comments before posting on this myself. Meh... great minds & all that.

[@oneworldfamily]

Gave me a good chuckle! You can't beat a good chuckle sometimes 😁

[@vVvnNnbBb]

Not suprised, seems the trendy thing to be doing these days, if not censoring #Mother then questioning what is a #Woman 🙄 wonder why? 🤔

[@luxurychoccie]

Your editors should note that subscribers might end up unsubbing if they feel mislead by the video titles, this one is dreadful.

[@mattgreene01]

Agreed. The only way they tricked us really was by Schofield being a n-once and Willoughby being his cover, who ran for her reputation as soon as it came out. But I don’t really expect that subject to feature in the RIE podcast.

[@julierogers1155]

Really with the 'Phil & Holly" clickbait?!! Disappointing.

[@perry0547]

Yeah, did I miss something there?

[@stummj99]

Completely agree. Poor decision Goal hanger.

[@hughanthony2001]

I think it's a mistake. The podcast has a completely different title.

[@marshmallonman]

Good pod but had to leave a dislike because of the awful clickbait title & thumbnail, pretty shocking and off brand for the podcast where we are supposed to feel like insiders to the tricks of the industry rather than being caught out by them

[@thebagelsproductions]

Did Holly and Phil trick viewers with clickbait titles? 😂

[@horacephistbump]

Yes. Utter rubbish. Phil Scholfield should complain.

[@davidadams3408]

Another Channel 5 doco from Phil coming up 😂

[@andremp03]

@@davidadams3408 *BRACES SELF* 😂

[@ianr4222]

"Spoiler alert" please I haven't reached that part yet.

[@masterlinkace]

Really stretching it thin on the subject you decided to title the whole episode around. I get that you did mention it briefly but it wasn't even the topic of that one question 🙈

[@vivevers3357]

Agree. Very annoying and deceitful click bait. Thought you two were better than that.

[@savyjett]

Its a little thing, but “see you next tuesday” makes me AT LEAST smile every time. 😊

[@dannyellis8030]

Always think they are aiming it at us 😳🤣

[@nickbreeze50]

Look up "See you in the Northern Territory" ads

[@sarahbarringer9526]

I like to think Marin doesn’t know

[@davidevans3227]

C U Next Tuesday?

[@savyjett]

@davidevans3227 yep! 😄

[@sayeager5559]

M-Fucking will have me laughing for quite a while, and I cant wait to start using this.

[@Ryanneey]

How funny would it have been if one of the main characters on The Office had to be blurred the entire time because they didn't sign the fictional release form? 😅

[@Montycat78]

If Ricky Gervis blured himself in his own comedy? That would have made no sense.

[@lewiscuthbert2790]

Arrested Development almost did that gag.

[@aotea6983]

​@Montycat78 he doesn't mean the main character, he means some bit part character. And yes it would've been hilarious

[@Ryanneey]

@aotea6983 yes, that's what I meant 😄

[@Ryanneey]

@@lewiscuthbert2790 Andy Richter? 😅

[@dageshi]

Rise up editor, you have the power! No bleeping the the bleeping bleeping!

[@Woofersgalore]

the Thursday Club Murder books are totally brilliant….beautifully crafted, clever plotting with humour woven through the dialogue of the characters who in themselves are so wonderfully molded. An absolute must read…

[@TheWilliamBogart]

The jump cuts are horrendous, can we please just watch two people having a natural conversation? "Back in my day.." etc.

[@sighmo]

Loved that Marina self-bleeped 'mother' and fired out the f bomb - my kind of censorship

[@CreatePerform]

You are better than this clickbait title 🙄

[@user-fn4qw8yk6y]

M-fucking awesome podcast.

[@joeshmoe0136]

😂😂😂

[@andycain4351]

I found the 'm' bit ridiculously entertaining. It was just like something I'd do 🤣

[@ebismusic8813]

Guys guys the short cuts are getting irritating

[@EastyyBlogspot]

The mine craft movie may be a block buster......

[@tomjones1506]

Get out now 😂

[@keithsquawk]

@@tomjones1506 digging his own grave

[@jonno209]

Overly click bait title, you're better than that!

[@TheTrueCyberpig]

I want to thank Marina and Richard for mentioning and putting me onto The Franchise. It's amazing. Only on episode 3, but loving it.

[@Peadar2000]

I love the peek behind the curtain these two give me. They have great chemistry.

[@CoastersandPop]

Great Q&A as always, loving The Franchise so far, very very funny. Also I’d be interested to hear about how you go about choosing the right literary agent please? How do you know when you’ve got the right spark!

[@SpringZing]

Can we stop with the Millennial editing. I thought Richard was going to turn into Max Headroom at one point.

[@davidjames579]

What do you mean?

[@SpringZing]

Making edit cuts in the same shot to cut out words or pauses that make the presenter sporadically jump around, in a vain attempt to speed up the delivery.

[@davidjames579]

@@SpringZing I didn't see any

[@artyb27]

Is it sped up too? I swear they were talking far more slowly on an earlier episode I watched last night

[@johningham1880]

Watched the first episode of Day of the Jackel last night. Eddie Redmayne plays the character of an assassin who uses a bespoke collapsible rifle. I want to call his character “Newt Scaramanga”.

[@sianwarwick633]

Did you know there's a fabulously expensive organic resto-farm that will cart out food to you online, called The Newt

[@tartansinatra]

Even my kid thought he'd heard The Day of the Jackal theme before... from a Bond film. Are there no new ideas?

[@johningham1880]

@@tartansinatra The Man with the Golden Gun (the book) was written well before The Day of the Jackal (book), though it was very different from the film. TDOTJ (film) was made before TMWTGG (film). I think there has probably been some cross-pollination of ideas as time has gone on.

[@callummc1988]

In 1989 Grandstand had the shot where people were working in the background behind Des Lynam, and for April fools day they had a mass brawl break out while he just carried on reading the introduction (easily found on KZbin)

[@michael1]

Easily found on youtube in 1989? I don't think so. April fool yourself!

[@leecal5774]

@@michael1 Nope, he’s right it is on KZbin (don’t get fooled again 😂) kzbin.info/www/bejne/iGXJc6WQn5aojq8si=COnaMRYmG543qMm1

[@leecal5774]

@@michael1 Nope, he’s right! The clip of it is on KZbin. Just search for ‘BBC Grandstand fight’ (don’t get fooled again 😂).

[@leecal5774]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/iGXJc6WQn5aojq8si=COnaMRYmG543qMm1

[@leecal5774]

@@michael1 Hope, Callum is right. The clip is on KZbin. Just search for ‘BBC Grandstand fight’. Don’t get fooled again 😅

[@nikiTricoteuse]

I love it when the algorithm throws me a bone like this. Am currently reading and very much enjoying the Thursday Murder Club so, it's lovely to 'meet' the author and to now learn it's also a film and there's a sequel. Yes, l realise l'm a few years behind but, it's a busy life. 😊 Thank you Marina Hyde for, among other things, m f*cker. Subscribed. Wasn't going to cos, l was starting to suspect a click bait title and thumbnail but, you did eventually give phil and Holly a micro mention and l enjoyed the rest.

[@karencooper334]

Please don’t use click bait, I believe you are better than that

[@andycain4351]

Is it true that Richard is so tall that he has to be carried horizontally like a roll of carpet into any studio he is working in before he is put into a sitting position? If this isnt true, how do we make it be true ? Thanks

[@Shane-ln5zz]

Another brilliant episode

[@evakatz6351]

I’m so glad Richard’s also obsessed with Below Deck!

[@jamesmaybrick2001]

I remember seeing a Revenge of the Jedi poster. I was a bit confused when shortly after that i went to see Return of the Jedi. I still love that film, sociopathic Ewoks included.

[@stevecatterson6920]

Marina impersonating Samuel L Jackson at 06:33 : "I'm done with these M fucking snakes on this M fucking plane" - hang on... did you just censor the word "mother"??? 🤣

[@bobs8783]

Videos uploaded to KZbin with the MF word can run the risk of being demonitized. 'Fuck' in moderation is fine in a video, but for whatever reason adding 'mother' is far far more offensive.

[@julierogers1155]

At WHAT TIME is the Phil & Holly piece?

[@themightywrighty]

it's a little bit at 21:55

[@sophiedereans]

​@@themightywrightyWhy thank you - started to think it was clickbait...oh hang on...

[@davidjames579]

6 AM

[@sipepguru]

​@@sophiedereans Hahaha it is clock bait

[@Tiger20001]

The loss of the ITV franchises was the single worst decision in the history of British TV.

[@rog2224]

Unless you worked in the upper end of Carlton.

[@leica0001]

Were they referring to a programme about the history of ITV franchising?

[@monkeytennis8861]

I see that and raise you the commissioning and broadcasting of Mrs Brown's Boys and anything with David Walliams

[@kkhera3730]

M-f**king great as always 😂

[@Amazonwarrior777]

Did i zone out and miss Holly and Phil discussion??

[@macsmiffy2197]

It was a brief aside about them pretending they were live on Christmas Day.

[@KevinClairSoutham]

Classic KZbin clickbait I’m afraid.

[@wonderwoman5528]

21:57

[@cipherhex]

The ferver that Phil & Holly / This Morning stories generate is out of control

[@julierogers1155]

SAME QUESTION!!

[@gavinneedham2013]

I don’t know about the differences between the UK and Canada but here in Canadian that is not how the Airport Customs show ran here. They had to get a release of anyone appearing in the show and the show ultimately got pulled because it wasn’t obtaining proper consents.

[@asedition8847]

Richard Osman has a very relaxing voice.

[@Cchogan]

Bidding for local radio licences was just the same. But we also had to do things like say what frequency we wanted, where we would put a mast, and all the rest. But they asked for far too much redundancy (had to have a spare studio which ended up used as a cupboard) and insisted on back up finances and all the rest. It made it stupidly expensive and restrictive. As a result, at the end of the 70s there were like 30 IRS (independent radio stations) and in the 80s they added another 30 or so. In the US, where to open a station you bought a licence from the mayor, there were twenty-eight THOUSAND stations!!!!

[@jonathanmcstay]

I love watching Marina listening - it’s utterly compelling

[@steveader]

Can someone please give a time stamp for the Holly and Phil section. I've searched through this back and forth and heard or seen no hint of that discussion.

[@guypenrose5477]

22:00 try this.

[@steveader]

​@@guypenrose5477 Cheers. Does make me wonder though ... why on EARTH was that few seconds mention in passing, deemed worthy of the headline for this. Click bait springs to mind. Do better, TRIE 😠

[@wonderwoman5528]

21:57

[@andycain4351]

Is it true that Richard is so tall that he has to be carried horizontally like a roll of carpet into any studio he is in before being put into a sitting position ? If this isn't true, how do we arrange for this to be true ? Thanks 👍

[@davidjames579]

You'd have to be part of The Thursday Murder Club to find it.

[@ossirioth]

The Thursday Mordor Club 🤣🤣🤣 I'm using that one!

[@philippoulston2565]

Clickbait title

[@CaesarTjalbo]

I'm now concerned about Marina's children, do they know how to swear properly?

[@billykay2064]

That shanty Town would make a great setting for a tv show

[@nickbreeze50]

Have to say the title of this episode is somewhat click-batey, Marina spend 30 seconds talking about it. And before anyone says anything, no it's not the reason I clicked - long time subscriber here, well months anyway.

[@tonythetyger99]

Went to an auction once when they were doing filming and the auctioneer said 'if you're cheating on the tax man or cheating on the wife and don't want to be filmed sit in this area at the front'

[@stephenhough4957]

What if you’re cheating on the taxman’s wife? Double dilemma! 😂

[@WhitbyStuff]

That's a really strange edit at 13:33. Was someone named?

[@Elwaves2925]

Yeah that was odd, you can see Richard's hand jump.

[@slapshot0074]

When selling rights to a book,do the authors get any say or control over casting? So many films/series have been ruined by terrible casting, either by simply poor choices or agendas taking priority over art and storytelling.

[@carolineskipper6976]

I think that probably depends on how fierce the competition for the rights is. I seem to remember JK Rowling was able to specify that the film(s) were to be British, with a British cast right from the get-go, because Harry Potter was a very hot property, much in demand.

[@finneganwoolley6557]

'How Phil and Holly Tricked This Morning Viewers'. Boy, was that a 'B' shit buy line

[@ktkee7161]

Can you summarise? Can't be bothered to listen to the whole thing.

[@deanusw]

6:54 love that marina didn't say mother

[@fraserjackson]

A bit disappointed in the discussion on people working in the background of the news, as neither of you mentioned the memorable episode of World of Sport where they staged a fight in the background as a prank!

[@TheRagzzz]

It was April Fools Day on Grandstand fronted by Des Lynam.

[@euansmith3699]

I wonder if there are four Daily Mail "journalists" panicking after their editor learns that the BBC News background is a loop. This is a great episode; so many rabbit holes.

[@shondellsb604]

Marina thinking 'mother' is the worst part of that phrase :-D

[@Vectrex-pi5ib]

6:38 - Blanking out the Mother-part of that word is hilarious. :D

[@danielkarmy4893]

People in Brighton do tend to be far more willing to chance their arm than in most other places I've been! Simultaneously one of the most endearing, and most utterly irritating, things about the place...

[@philipwhiuk]

I'm in the background of Sky News 24 I think (a long time ago) - I went for an interview and we toured the set on the way to the interview process (I think Kay Burley was presenting at the time). Can guarantee the background offices are (or at least were and I doubt it's changed) real for the studio set. We signed a release form.

[@yaekmon]

The Thursday Murder Club film cast is incredible. Worth inking the deal just to meet them!

[@oneworldfamily]

It just occurred to me that Marina and Richard's set is the same as Rob Brydon's.

[@FireflySt4rs]

ITV news is a virtual studio background and its a ‘living background’, which means it changes each bulletin depending on the stories in the programme or world wide events… several press releases online if folks want the nerdy trivia

[@LongStoryShortTelly]

I don't think Richard has ever watched ITV News!

[@videoeditorbloke]

The newsroom in the background on the BBC News channel is definitely real - you can see the different angles / perspectives in the wide and moving shots. I assume Marina was talking about the main bulletins on BBC 1?

[@EzraTaylor1]

I think she's talking about when they're not filming in the glass studio. That background is a loop.

[@gdr1174]

Those mother hugging snakes 😂

[@clairefuller4947]

Really interesting to learn that films sell books because of the trailers, and TV doesn't sell (many) books.

[@currykevuk]

Please stop the harsh editing. It may be ok for audio but not for the viewer.

[@davidjames579]

What harsh editing?

[@whomanbeing]

I’m gonna say it….prepare yourself…..MOTHER!

[@ticketyboo2456]

Marina is so sheltered from real life. Thank eff Richard is there to balance out her obvious privilege...

[@PaulHaigh072]

21:09 exactly the reason Emmerdale moved from the village of Esholt to the custom built village.

[@streamingscreens9931]

Rivals is bloody BRILLIANT !!

[@petermaguire2632]

Rivals sounds like you could create a board game.

[@shyft09]

2:00 if that madame ever writes a book, I'd love to read it

[@Victoria-wd6kr]

The Bridgerton series hugely boosted sales of the books

[@wonderwoman5528]

I thought you meant holy and Phil tricked the viewers into believing they were both nice people

[@stephenhough4957]

A difficult task!

[@elementaryFlame]

The video is jump cutting so much it's disconcerting.

[@rach97134]

'm fucking' reminds me of Miranda when her on screen mum censored the wrong words 🤣

[@deanyoung1980]

9:43 “This episode is bought to you by…” A rare misspeak by Richard. Marina would have been pulled up for that one!

[@barbararowley6077]

Don’t forget the middle ground that is the miniseries. I don’t agree with all the changes they made in the adaptation of China Mieville’s ‘The City & The City’, but it did work well in the miniseries format.

[@faffrin5216]

Important clarification on the first question that the presenters chose not to make: there are no international journalists in Gaza because Isreal won't let them in. The only journalists there are Palestinians who are subject to famine just like the rest of the population.

[@David-j9h9g]

Loved "Drop the dead donkey"!!!!!!

[@MarceldeJong]

8:36 I wish that were true for every movie and TV show where the existing fan base and even the author or their estates rejects the show as part of canon. I'm looking at you, BBC's The Watch, you're not part of Discworld!

[@gobmarley3]

2:20 there's three jump cuts on Richard for some reason

[@fightthepowerman]

Omg this has got to be the worst thing that Philly Sco ever did? What? He did _what?_

[@christianstanding]

On the whole people working in the background shot of newsrooms, I recall there was an incident in one of the Australian news stations where, well, let's just say they weren't using the computer for work purposes.

[@russellandrews1177]

The Devil's Candy is awesome

[@TinaJesse859]

Why are they sitting so far apart? Not sure that table is suitable for their podcast.

[@michael5265]

My friend works behind the scenes on below decks, 😂

[@megansmith3535]

Anyone else obsessed with Marina? I want to know her opinion on everything.

[@CdotB_]

I'm a bit late to this one but Marina's take on the minecraft movie feels way off base. Firstly she implies that the negativity is exclusive to some kind of toxic gamer culture, when fans of any media get up in arms if their adaptation isn't right. Books, comics, even existing movie franchises get hate like this. She also seemingly belittles people's grievances saying they'll "cgi in whatever weapon or something is deemed acceptable by the fanbase". Fans of that property aren't mad over some insignificant detail that the production got wrong, they're mad because the film looks utterly horrendous both visually and conceptually. I'm not fussed about it personally but I usually like Marina's views and that conversation seemed really reductive.

[@Elcrisso1]

Terrible title. An incredibly brief mention of the topic a lot of people clicked on this video to find out more about. It definitely feels like clickbait. Either speak more about the topic as it’s clearly of interest to a lot of people, or title the episode something else instead. Do better.

[@SJSpode114]

How about an episode on entertainment video podcasts using unnecessary Clickbait headlines…. Let us know if you need some examples… or just look in the mirror….

[@andypammenter8528]

Is it true that this podcast was originally going to be called "the return of entertainment"? 😂😂

[@anthowarth801]

Any 'Coming of Rage' stories??

[@stewartbrodie1720]

If the BBC News background is just a loop, are the people in the shot racking up repeat fees? :)

[@macsmiffy2197]

If Thursday Murder Club would be 6 hours of TV, by that measure, Strike should last about 20! I’ve given up reading Galbraith in paperback; it’s way too heavy at c1200 pp.

[@dibdab101]

try the audiobooks. Narrated by Robert Glenister, who does an excellent job!

[@DevilboyScooby]

Well Phil certainly tricked us all into thinking he was a decent human being...

[@beakittelscherz5419]

Phil&holly click bait doesn't make your rambling any better or interesting... 🙄🙄🙄👎👎👎

[@hazelj-lfc]

Where is the bit that fits the title?

[@harrietj8835]

I remember seeing trailer fir Cowboys and Aliens and thinking, 'Genius, why hasn't this been done before, can't wait!' What a chronic disappointment that was....dreck!

[@ellapyper4108]

Are Phil and Holly in the room with us???

[@andycain4351]

There was probably a point in time when it became popular to hate on film trailers but what was it, what film was the first hated trailer for and why did it happen ?

[@daviebananas1735]

It’s usually when beloved properties, like computer games etc are turned into films. The first one I can remember is sonic.