How Protestants and Catholics can Dialogue Fruitfully (w/ Keith Nester)

In this episode I am joined by Keith Nester, a former Protestant pastor who was in ministry for more than 20 years before converting to Catholicism. In this video, Keith shares his conversion story, and we dialogue about Protestant and Catholic misconceptions, how Protestants and Catholics can dialogue productively and fruitfully, as well as what Protestants and Catholics can learn from one another. This was an absolute blast, and I think you're going to love it. Whether you're Protestant, Catholic, somewhere in between, or you have no skin in the game, I think you'll benefit from hearing Keith's powerful story and gaining insight into how we can disagree civilly, while not giving up our convictions.
After watching this, I'm sure you're asking, "how can I learn more about Keith and what he's up to?" I get it. Me too. Use the link below to stay up to date with Keith's ministry and to check out his new book:
Keith's KZbin: / @keithnester
Keith's Book:
www.amazon.com/Converts-Guide...
Keith's Website:
www.keithnester.com
Support me through Patreon:
www.patreon.com/gospelsimplicity
Buy Merch:
teespring.com/stores/gospelsi...
Send me books:
Austin Suggs
820 N. La Salle Dr.
CPO 123
Chicago, IL 60610
About me:
Hey! My name is Austin, and I'm a 21 year old guy with a passion for people. I believe the good news is that God is better than we could've ever hoped, and I love sharing this message of grace and love with anyone that will listen. I'm the former Digital Marketing and Video Production Coordinator at a large, evangelical church in Frederick, MD, and I'm currently a student at Moody Bible Institute in Chicago, IL. When I'm not writing papers or making KZbin videos, I do freelance work as a Wedding Photographer/Videographer and social media consultant. On any given day you can find me with my nose in a book or a guitar in my hands. Want to get to know me more? Follow me and say hi on Instagram at: @austin.suggs
Video Stuff:
Camera: Canon 80d
Lens: Sigma 17-50 F2.8
Edited in FCPX

[@Lepewhi]

I hadn't prayed the rosary in 40yrs until I prayed with Keith on his channel.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Wow! I'm sure he'd be delighted to hear that

[@danielwey]

My family is catholic and I was baptized a few days after I was born. But I came to understand my faith much more after reading conversion stories, mainly from protestants to catholicism. I love the way they discover so many beautiful things like the mass, Eucharist, the life of saints, and so on. As Scott Hamn once mentioned, sometimes we need an immigrant to make us realize the beauty of our country, and sometimes Catholics need converts to remember them the beauty of their faith.

[@briandelaney9710]

This works also for Orthodox Christians both cradle and convert My priest wisely tells us that the “cradles “ teach us how to be Orthodox

[@GospelSimplicity]

Well said

[@GospelSimplicity]

That makes a lot of sense

[@GrandmaLynn]

I agree 100% with your comment @Daniel Wey. I began watching The Journey Home on EWTN with Marcus Grodi. Ever since then, I have searched for more conversion stories. That’s how I came to find Keith. And about immigrants, it’s a very true fact! People would rather travel out of the country instead of visiting our beautiful Canadian sites. The same goes for Catholics who leave the Church. They see what isn’t in the Catholic Church in other denominations and end up believing it’s better than the Catholic Church.

[@Featherfinder]

I completely relate to what you said :) I’m a cradle Catholic too but now I am a somewhat-more-clued-in, intentional Catholic...who is completely distraught by what’s been going on in her Church. But that’s a topic for another post..... Great to hear from you, though, Daniel Wey :)

[@erint6540]

Keith was instrumental in bringing me and my husband into Catholicism last year. I have so much respect for both of you, thank you for having him on. Great dialogue!

[@GospelSimplicity]

I'm sure he would be delighted to hear that. He's a great guy, and I was so excited to get the opportunity to chat with him. Thanks for your kind words!

[@kuyajosephtutorials9709]

Amen

[@tony1685]

i've chatted with him on email - he doesn't follow Bible Truth, but a nice man. i pray he comes to Christianity soon.

[@crobeastness]

@@tony1685 catholics are christian though. i think you mean that he comes to protestantism

[@tony1685]

@@crobeastness afacts.convio.net/site/DocServer/Insertfinal.pdf?docID=322 Bible is clear my friend.

[@TheJewishCatholic]

Amazing video! I hope we can chat together. I’m a Jewish Believer in Yeshua (Jesus) and I’ve been feeling a strong pull towards the Catholic Church. Through my study of Scripture, history and Jewish literary works I’ve become more and more convicted everyday!

[@GospelSimplicity]

Glad you enjoyed it! That would be fun

[@TheJewishCatholic]

Gospel Simplicity fantastic! Let’s set something up. My email is [e-mail]

[@saraalbert3403]

Hi, you may look for Mother Mirian of the Lamb of God , formerly Rosalind Moss. She was born and raised Jewish, converted to Protestantism and later to Catholicism. She is now a wonderful Benedictine nun. Her story will inspire you brother. God bless you and may He bring you home soon.

[@ohmightywez]

It’s funny, one of the things my mom told me and I passed on was the sentiment of “if you don’t marry a good, practicing Catholic, find yourself a solid, practicing Jewish person”. So many of the traditions were transferred and transmuted. If you ever want to listen to an interesting pair of stories, on the Coming Home program on EWTN there are the conversion stories of a Jewish brother and sister to Catholicism . The brother is actually a Catholic priest.

[@taylorcanon8890]

I’m praying for your conversion to the Holy Roman Catholic Church! Follow God’s pull on your heart and NEVER look back! 🙏😇

[@johnalexander4940]

I love my Christian brothers and sisters. I listen to Catholic and Protestant podcasts and can say thank God the Catholics are tradition centric, thank God they've preserved the traditions of the early church fathers etc. Catholic Mass may not be my cup of tea but I don't frown upon Catholics as the seeds of love were planted in me at an early age by Catholic nuns. So when the proud hearts surrender the hope of fighting for false supremacy, and seek to love the brethren as commanded. Then the true work of the Holy Spirit will finish the work in the vineyard. Amen ✝️

[@marcia7904]

I’m part of The Crew. Keith’s Rosary 📿 crew. Love Keith!

[@GospelSimplicity]

Keith’s great!

[@cjr4497]

There is nothing more freeing than a great confession. I have balled my eyes out to a priest over a matter that is about as serious as it can get. When he spoke some since into me and prayed over me in forgiveness I felt my cross vanish. I felt the Lord that time like no other. It was amazing.

[@julianpiezas]

"One of the biggest problems we all face.. is this medium, beige mindset of Christianity that says, 'Jesus Christ came to enhance my life and just sort of to fit into what I'm doing. He would never require of me anything that would hurt, or that would change my trajectory.' There's sort of that built-in mindset that it's all about me." wow! 15 minutes in and this is great work. Thank you for speaking Truth, brothers!

[@GospelSimplicity]

Keith was speaking some serious truth right there. So grateful to have him on the channel. Glad you're enjoying the interview! God bless

[@tony1685]

@@GospelSimplicity actually the topic of 'Truth' is what makes Keith not care to discuss the Bible with me. he avoids Truth, thus keeping him catholic.

[@xxFairestxx]

@@tony1685 you’re wrong.

[@tony1685]

@@xxFairestxx wow - that was stunning. how about this very short/interesting page: afacts.convio.net/site/DocServer/Insertfinal.pdf?docID=322 enjoy!

[@Mark-yb1sp]

“You don’t need me to make a way, you just need ME.” That’s all I needed to hear. Thank you! 😭

[@GospelSimplicity]

That was so good

[@coondogbob]

Two great gentlemen!

[@GospelSimplicity]

Harvester1867 thanks! Hope you enjoy it!

[@andrewdrew677]

@@GospelSimplicity thank you for doing this video . Have you read the book FAR FROM ROME NEARER TO GOD ? Here’s a preview of the book see link , most interesting .

[@bestrong1854]

Introduction is enough to like the guest.never heard about him before

[@richardbenitez7803]

Austin did bring up an aspect he noticed about catholics. They do not seem to make an effort or have a regard for evangelizing as the gospel asks. This is a rather complex aspect to understand. How to answer this so that protestants understand .... catholics are taught from day one that we must imitate Jesus Christ in his love and charity and participate in Christ’s suffering and death at the cross. Catholics engage in deep prayer to reflect on who Christ is and how our mind and body can be emptied of sin and ego. In this way, the church as the Body of Christ is a saving activity. This means our life as Christians is meant not for ourselves but for others at the same time. So ... what do catholics do ... they are constantly actualizing their faith by soup kitchens, giving shelter, caring for the sick, etc etc. St Francis and Mother Teresa were severe care givers to the point of their own deep starvation and suffering. What do catholic kids do to learn about christ and about their faith. They volunteer to help others. What this means is if someone attends mass, shows for lecture, sleeps in the back of the church (the homeless) or hangs out at all the soup kitchens and soaks up all the goodies for 10 years catholics just don’t think of evangelizing in terms of preaching or asking for converts or demanding a secular catholics attend mass. Catholics know their discipleship is their example as a good Christian.

[@GospelSimplicity]

I would agree that evangelism is more than preaching, but I don't think preaching is less than real evangelism. I think it's a case of both/and not either/or

[@davetabuyan2172]

We in the church as a whole has different lay obligations. Even though we are one Church, each of us has different responsibilities. Not everyone is responsible for evangilization or preaching. Even Paul himself has been clear about this issue. 1 Corinthians 1:17 "For Christ sent me not to baptize, but to preach the gospel: not with wisdom of words, lest the cross of Christ should be made of none effect." St. Paul was sent to preach therefore that was his duty. Some are given with other responsibilities Ephesians 4:11 "And he gave some, apostles; and some, prophets; and some, evangelists; and some, pastors and teachers;" Therefore not everyone is entitled for preaching. St. Paul even clarify this Romans 10:15 "And how can they preach unless they are sent?" Again, catholics are not obliged to preached the gospel. We all have different calling and vocation. Some for pro-creation, some for temporalities, some for ministries and so on. But one thing we should always bear in our minds. Despite this different callings, we are all united as one, bounding together in prayers, faith, hope and love..

[@caroldsouza3634]

@@GospelSimplicity, You're right... Just want to add Catholics are Eucharistic Vessels, to give Jesus to others out of the Body of Christ. He becomes one in us and uses our humanity to touch others. ( We are bad at that because the spiritual warfare is too great).. but even a simple faithful catholic, just being faithful gives a lot to the world. This idea I heard in the talks of Marino Restrepo from Colombia who is considered as St. Paul of our century.. He had an Illumination of Conscience in a cave during his near death experience when he was kidnapped by guerrillas and he reverted back to faith. If possible, please do check out his talks. Thanks!

[@tessa7413]

I think that the Catholics who are knowledgeable about the faith are a lot more confident in sharing it. The problem is that there are so many Catholics (especially cradle Catholics) who don't understand the faith near as well as they should. Another thing is that I think a lot of Catholics are timid because of all of the anti-Catholicism we encounter, especially when we are open about our faith.

[@thebestofmae]

@@tessa7413 totally true! I'm a cradle Catholic. And you were just describing who I was like for 21 years. Thank God for Apologetics, Fulton Sheen, Steubenville Conferences, Peter Kreeft and all the Saints that helped me revive my faith in a more beautiful and glorious ways. As I continue to read the life of the Saints, I now understand more fully why the Church highly regarded them. As Peter Kreeft said once in his talk, (non-verbatim) the Saints know the Scriptures better than the theologians because they're so close to the heart of Christ which is what the entire Scripture is all about. At that time when I heard it I could understand it intellectually but not yet fully. As I recall my own conversion of the heart (if you will), the reason that I got so interested to dive deeper into what really the Church teaches and the richness of the deposit of faith aside from Sunday masses and occasional confession was the witness of the people that I met when I moved to another city for work. There I met amazing people who were living the faith passionately, talking about Jesus as if they're so close to each other, they get His humor in certain situations, and the boldness of how they live their Christian life in the midst of the secular corporate world. That is what awakened my heart from lukewarmness. I can't help but be curious on how they've come so close to Jesus and so brave in this modern world of relativism where you just shut up to not offend anyone or not get into arguments. So when I see people discounting the Saints' witness because "we idolize them" I feel so sad because they're missing a lot.

[@peacemungtsa]

It's awesome that a Catholic and a protestant can dialogue with so much respect for eachother's believe.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@caritamundo9316]

Watching from the Philippines. We are celebrating our 500 years of Christianity this year.

[@jacksonhstudios4421]

One cool thing Catholics and Protestants (and people of other religions could do) to foster discussion without getting at each other all the time would be (I know this would cheesy, it's just an idea) community meals between churches. That way you could get to know each other better and break down barriers.

[@GospelSimplicity]

That's a wonderful idea!

[@mikeoconnor4590]

When I converted to Catholicism over 25 years ago - the Latin Mass wasn’t so readily available. At that time I loved going to Mass - but preferred traditional liturgy and frequently worshipped in the eastern rites of the Church. Now that the Latin mass is so much more readily available, I currently attend the traditional Latin rite on a weekly basis. I find worshiping in the Latin rite which is saturated with scripture - completely draws my soul to the trinity like nothing I’ve ever experienced. The excellence and holiness of the rite Is difficult to put into words. Simply put it’s the most beautiful thing this side of heaven!

[@rmader1997]

Good Idea. But how do you pull it off. I wouldn't count on the Pastours af Any Church. Catholic or Protestant. To much Baggage to even consider the idea.

[@taylorwillis2478]

I really love this idea. I am a Protestant (non-denom) in a predominantly Catholic area. I love my Catholic Brothers and Sisters in Jesus Christ ❤️ there always seems to be so much hatred, almost, between a lot of people on both sides. Personally, I have been told by Catholics that I am going to Hell for not being apart of the Catholic Church (which hurt me very deeply). I would love to meet and have simple dialogue with my Brothers and Sisters in Christ ❤️

[@saintejeannedarc9460]

@@taylorwillis2478 It's really too bad that too many Christians don't understand that Christ saves us. Not a church, not an elite belief system. It's all about his sacrifice for us. We are promised that nothing, not height nor depth, nor anything above or below can separate us from the love of God.

[@mcspankey4810]

Hi there, if you’d to see Catholicism from the spiritual side and not the intellectual aspect, I highly suggest reading the life of a saint- St. Theresa of Avila, St. Terez (I know I spelt that wrong), St. Gemma Galgani or St. Faustina -

[@GospelSimplicity]

Thanks for these recommendations!

[@Danaluni59]

Also St. John of the cross, specifically Dark Night of the Soul. It helps to comprehend the reality of purgation, that of sin and rebellion from God in general and for dealing with “dryness” in prayer and the reality that good people suffer.

[@srourfamily]

reading the life of saints makes my life more valuable, spiritual, and the love of Jesus, and with works of virgin mary intercession makes a strong case for catholicism, i always wonder why somes different protestants groups now that is so difficult to understand especailly in USA

[@srourfamily]

@@Danaluni59 read dante inferno book

[@rosaenriquez4921]

@@eireannemerald1382 My favs are Saint Padre Pio , Saint John Bosco !!!

[@ruthjacobson2761]

Brilliant interview Austin! If you want to grow more in your understanding of Catholicism, you might want to consider sitting or praying in front of the Blessed Sacrament for an hour at least once a week. You’ll learn a ton about Catholicism without any words. Seriously, this is more edifying than reading Summa Theological. For me an hour of adoration became so peaceful that I had to give up being Lutheran. Prayers for your future and the gifts you give through your videos

[@GospelSimplicity]

Glad you enjoyed it! Thanks for the recommendation

[@srourfamily]

praying in blessed of sacrament, and learning about the saints life is truly enhance understanding my faith in Catholicism, as i travel the world many Catholics open their homes and we pray and mediate for many without discussion and let Jesus make his way for his family be bless and live with him truly in him, thank god for the many people of faith who truly care for their neighbor as i am a witness that carrying my Rosary.

[@taylorcanon8890]

I really loved this interview with you both and Keith inspires me to be more zealous in my Faith in hard times! I’m a former evangelical Protestant who became a Roman Catholic around two years ago. I’m praying for your conviction and conversion to the Catholic Faith Austin! Please keep making more videos like this about Catholics/Protestants and our we can understand each other better!

[@GospelSimplicity]

Glad you enjoyed it! Keith is great. Thanks for your prayers! God bless

[@beautifulspirit7420]

If Protestants and Catholics came together it would be so powerful. All the wisdom of community building and fellowship that Protestants have learnt would be an amazing gift to the Church, their emphasis and knowledge of Scripture and Evangelization. Catholicism has the Real Presence in the Eucharist, Scripture and the Church and the full truth and richness. I agree with Keith's critique of how those exploring the Catholic Church need much more active support and guidance. We are a family and should always behave as a loving and welcoming family. I pray the Lord brings us all back together ❤ 🙏

[@GospelSimplicity]

There really is much to be learned from one another

[@tony1685]

_'If Protestants and Catholics came together it would be so powerful.'_ - Amos 3:3 see friend, a sincere Bible Christian can't agree with catholic theology because it's not based upon Truth. most of protestantism doesn't realize what it is they are 'protesting' and haven't studied the background to what the roman 'church' has actually done throughout history and will again in the future. in short - catholicism is truly of Satan and the Bible proves it. _'Catholicism has the Real Presence in the Eucharist....'_ - uh no. Jesus established the Lord Supper and He isn't a cookie - see John 6:63, Gen 9:4, Lev 11, lev 17 and Deut 14. it is symbolic. *Happy Sabbath!!!* - i pray the Lords day is a blessing for you and yours!

[@beautifulspirit7420]

@@tony1685 Do you understand Tony how extremely uncharitable you are being to fellow Christians? The ancient Church that compiled the Bible and who thousands of martyrs for the faith swore allegiance to? There was only ONE Church, the Great Church, for 1,000 years which split into the Western Church using Latin in their liturgies and the Eastern Orthodox who use Greek. Both lungs of the Church have continued to preach and live the Gospel, taking the message and reality of Jesus to the ends of the earth. When you reject Catholicism & Orthodoxy you reject the historic Apostolic Church that Jesus founded. You can never say you love Christ when you harbor such ill will to sincere, devout followers of the Gospel. Both Catholics and Orthodox believe in the Real Presence as Jesus told us to in John 6. Our belief is completely biblical. May God continue to bless you 🙏

[@tony1685]

@@beautifulspirit7420 without meaning to offend, inspiring others to actually dig into why they believe what they believe is my aim! now lets look at what you're alleging - you stated _'The ancient Church .....There was ONE Church.....When you reject...you reject the historic and Apostolic Church that Jesus founded.'_ - ok, lets stop right there. time for you to do an integrity check my friend and answer this: did Jesus' church know God, love Jesus and walk in Truth? also - did Jesus' church keep Holy the 7th day Sabbath - or pretend the 1st day is now Holy? did Jesus' church pray to God Alone - or pretend it's ok to pray to humans (even dead ones = necromancy like 'Hail Mary')? _'You an never say you love Christ when you harbor such ill will ....'_ - you don't know my will so man up and open the Bible please. we have Truth to discover and it's not going to be pretty to those who live in denial and don't believe in the Word of Truth (John 17:17). former (35 yr) catholic, now Christian. and am anxious to hear your reply - as this is what the Word of our Creator encourages us to do!

[@beautifulspirit7420]

@@tony1685 Since writing my comment I saw your comments under other discussions and I know you are not open to sincere debate so I will keep you in my prayers friend 🙏 ❤ may the Holy Spirit fill your life. Amen.

[@tesschavit3009]

Keith Nester is on fire for the Lord

[@damarisortiz2856]

I born as a Catholic, and I get marriage in the catholic church, and I had all my sacraments, but I never had the connection whit Jesus, until I had marriage issues, then I saw all the mistakes in my faith, (I had experienced the new age and I was blind about it) So right now, I meet Jesus, I am convert to catholic really learning about all!, So I really enjoy your perspective, thank you for yours videos. Regards

[@tony1685]

perhaps you can still come to Christianity! this 'church' (rcc) isn't Jesus' church - Bible proves it.

[@xxFairestxx]

@@tony1685 wrong.

[@tony1685]

@@xxFairestxx good! care to do what the Word says and prove your point or can you not do so?

[@Christiannerichard]

Great interview 😊 As a cradle Catholic - I benefit so much from these types of conversations. My generation received poor catechesis (soon after Vatican 2) and subsequently find myself continuing to learn. I’ve definitely benefited from the hard work that converts to Catholicism have endured in their journey to the faith including Steven Ray, Scott Hahn, Jimmy Aiken, Keith 😊 and others. It helps to have the internet and easy access to such. Yup - as Catholics, we can be unto ourselves … really lacking in our love to evangelize, welcome newcomers and freely communicate about the Lord & our Catholic faith. Now that parishes are using Alpha, Renew and other great programs - hopefully we can begin to shift and demonstrate the type of zeal that we all love so much in many of our Protestant brothers & sisters.

[@HeavnzMiHome]

For me too. When I realized that Jesus WAS there in the Eucharist, there was no other choice. At first it was very painful, but now I have nothing but gratitude.

[@GospelSimplicity]

I appreciate you sharing your story!

[@emtedee985]

What a beautiful story that Steve Ray was there to greet you, Keith, on your reception into the Catholic Church 3 years ago - that story brought tears to my eyes and I am glad that Austin heard your conversion story too - I am sure it will add to the reasons which will one day bring him running towards the Catholic church, rather than away from it. Austin brother, as Keith said, don't worry about how your life would be messed up if you followed Keith; Jesus will take care of you and find you an important role and provide you with a living. One day I'll tell you about some married Catholic priests I know of - nothing is impossible with the Lord our loving and compassionate God. I'm happy to send love to both of you, I am convinced that God is working miracles in you and through you, you've certainly given my faith a good firm nudge in the right direction

[@GospelSimplicity]

That really was a beautiful story. Grateful that he shared it. Thank you for that advice and encouragement. I really appreciate that. God bless.

[@sophamad650]

Great video. It makes me love my Catholic upbringing even more. I was a lukewarm Catholic but now I'm on fire for Jesus and it makes me happy to hear such a great dialog without all the verbal battling. Thanks for your video and keeping it classy.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@tony1685]

are you really _'...on fire for Jesus'_ ? soph? if so, then how about going to a church which loves Him. read John 14:15 please.

[@xxFairestxx]

@@tony1685 lol written by the Catholic Church

[@tony1685]

@@xxFairestxx _'lol written by the Catholic Church'_ Bible was written by the Jews - save Nebuchadnezzar and Luke. Bible was written to the Jews - until the Gentiles were grafted in. Bible is about the evils of the roman empire and the roman counterfeit 'church' - care to dig into that info? just let me know, Sir.

[@gusbeau1]

Just a thought as I was taking this lovely testimony into my heart. Each time I hear theAve Maria ( Mario Lanza when a child , I loved this hymn ). Sung at every Catholic wedding I’ve ever attended. Then, I began to hear it at Protestant weddings, too. Shortly. I had the thought (oh, it’s always sung in Latin). ‘’Do they know we are praying (twice) The Hail Mary prayer ?”

[@diego9314]

Amigo, u put a simple video, why i.stayed as catholic and I did not change to Christianity. I love Mary, pope, and everything in the Catholic church. God bless u all.

[@itachigothenachi8425]

I've never seen so much respect between a Catholic person and a Protestant person to be honest I have been bullied on KZbin and I wanted to cause suicide but I disided to go to go on a stand still. I was Tramatise by the comments and it was like I was born to go to death. People were asking me if I was baptized and I said yes and they treated me like I signed a illuminati contact at birth so I can relate to Keith. I'm 15 years

[@GospelSimplicity]

I'm so sorry to hear about the experiences you've had on KZbin. If you are still, or anyone else is, having suicidal thoughts, please reach out to a professional for help. For you, or anyone reading this, you can always contact the suicide hotline: [phone]. God bless

[@Lola-kv6fx]

I totally respect the Protestant community. Our priest have about 5 masses on Sundays which most of them are packed. You can imagine how many people to one priest and all the responsibilities they have on the daily preparing for mass, the anointing of the sick, daily mass, confessions etc… As a long life Catholic I understand how they cannot drop everything and call someone who wants to come into the Catholic faith. Most of the priest not only in my parish but in my town are sleep walking most of the time. So please understand them.

[@mariastefani1772]

I love this so much. Respect the both of you!

[@GospelSimplicity]

Glad you enjoyed it! Thanks for taking the time to watch and comment. That really means a lot

[@CatholicBossHogg]

The confession thing is very true. I always use the words "I accuse myself of x." That way, after it is over, I know the devil has no accusations he can use against me because I've already been accused and forgiven.

[@GospelSimplicity]

That’s really interesting how you do that. Glad you’re finding it impactful

[@beautifulspirit7420]

Jesus understand that as embodied souls we need physical realities to help us. Confessing to a priest not only means we are reconciled with God but we are reconciled with God's family, the Church. Our sins whether by commission or omission hurt others and damage the body of Christ. So we need forgiveness from God and from His people for healing to occur.

[@Paulo_Sa_Pereira]

Two fantastic gentleman. Awesome interview and very helpful

[@GospelSimplicity]

Thanks! I'm so glad that you enjoyed it. Thanks for taking the time to watch and leave this comment!

[@TracyW-me8br]

Christians, it’s time to get it together. We, even in the United States, will face persecution (of some type) because of our aggressively anti-religious, secular culture. They will know us by our love.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Amen on them knowing us by our love.

[@aGoyforJesus]

Catholicism still denies the gospel. Nazis persecuted the Jehovah's Witnesses.

[@bigdog1106]

@@aGoyforJesus "Catholicism still denies the gospel" where is the world did you learn that? If a person attends every Sunday and Holiday for three years then they would have heard all four gospels read aloud.

[@aGoyforJesus]

Big Dog you’re confusing the gospel that Paul told the Judaizers they were denying by adding works to faith with the four books we call “the Gospels”

[@bigdog1106]

@@aGoyforJesus The Four books were gathered together by the Catholic Church in 397 at the Council of Carthage. Therefore, Paul never had them.

[@aileenbordelon7884]

So many great points brought up in this video! I feel like Catholics & Protestants get too caught up in the “us vs them” mindset.

[@GospelSimplicity]

So true!

[@beautifulspirit7420]

So unChristian of us!

[@Kitiwake]

Who is the protester? Catholics?

[@aileenbordelon7884]

@@Kitiwake what?

[@Onniesprairiegarden]

It does help to have open minded people like Austin!!!!!

[@josephgoemans6948]

Yay! Excited for this one 😊😊

[@GospelSimplicity]

It’s a fun one! Keith is great

[@Vivi-uy1hr]

Thank you for the nice and enjoyable dialogue.

[@GospelSimplicity]

My pleasure!

[@geneparadiso6258]

There is so much emotional capital invested in the faith we were born into that conversion is a monumental undertaking either way.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Gene Paradiso truly

[@ladytiamat]

I connect so much with Keith's description of Confession. The verbal release of acknowledging my sins has such a freedom that occurs that it simply transcends all other forgiveness seeking other than asking someone I've sinned against to forgive me. It's such a great connection to God.

[@paschallyngdoh8728]

Praise God for you Keith. I will share your testimony with my Protestant friends. May God help them to see the truth and be the answer to the prayer of Jesus to be one.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Keith is fantastic. Really grateful that he was willing to come on the channel for this interview

[@fsnicolas]

Very nice! Let's keep the dialogue going! Watching from the start. I love Keith Nester's testimony. Very moving, very courageous. Praise God!

[@GospelSimplicity]

Thanks! I'm all for keeping the dialogue going. His story is certainly powerful

[@emtedee985]

Dear Austin at 7 minutes Keith said "It just clicked" - I'm praying that will happen for you one day. You have talked to Scott Hanh, Keith Nester and many other Catholics. I wonder if you've heard of Bishop Barron - his talk about Saint Cardinal John Henry Newman might be someone else to influence you. I also think you'd find Father Casey Cole (Breaking in the Habit) has many interesting and influential videos. As Jesus said so often "Don't be afraid" to follow the Way, the Truth and the Life. With Christian love and blessings - Mark

[@GospelSimplicity]

I've heard of all of those folks! I'd love to chat with Fr. Casey some time. His videos are great

[@maryannvalmores6515]

@@GospelSimplicity kzbin.info/www/bejne/jqmYfaxuoJ2qjtE Bishop Barron talking about the Church Fathers, you might find it useful :)

[@chiaracorsini2427]

Hi Austin! I really want to thank you for making this amazing video! There are so many angry and hateful videos on this topic I'm Italian and obviously Catholic and six years ago I came to the u.s. as an exchange student. Since my host family was protestant, I attended service for a whole year in their Methodist church and it was one of the best experiences of my life! After that I obviously questioned my faith and my believes but I decided to remain Catholic! Coming back to Italy though I felt the need to fight for Christian unity because the love for God that we share is greater than any theological difference that divides us! So I joined a local taizè community and by going to a couple of their international youth events I was finally able to have discussions with people of different Christian professions and to find common ground! So again thank you for doing the same here on KZbin!!

[@GospelSimplicity]

Hi Chiara! It’s truly my pleasure. I loved how you said “Italian and obviously Catholic.” That just made me laugh a bit. I totally get that. I have some Italian relatives. I’m so glad you had a positive experience staying with Protestants, and I’m glad it’s inspired you to work for unity! That’s wonderful to hear. God bless!

[@sillybearss]

Keith and his iconic convert tee.

[@GospelSimplicity]

It really is iconic at this point

[@emiliotorres9303]

Friends of mine, Christians in earnest who belong to a Baptist congregation, began addressing our divergent approaches to Christ in the Eucharist, against the Baptist communion view. One thing that helped us to engage freely was the reminder that, no matter where we end up following this conversation, to follow the truth and where the truth would lead us 'is' to follow Christ, and so we should not be fearful of letting the proverbial cards fall where they will.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Sounds wonderful!

[@Atyo81]

My version of the future in the good relationship of Catholics and Protestants...we need to work togheter, double the hardwork with NGO to help the poor ones, the ones that are in jail, the ones with no clothes, the ones that are thirsty. Mattew 25, 31-46. If we has Christians (protestants and catholics) reduct this issues, we are going to make Jesus proud. Im catholic. Greetings from Mexico. Great interview Austin. Glod bless you.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Well said

[@polishmehappy]

I love these two💜 Austin, I don't know why this keeps bouncing inside my brain, but I will not be surprised if someday you have a sit down with Fr Casey. We may never know, but a "wind" says you'll remember😊 blessings to both of you 💜

[@GospelSimplicity]

Thanks! I would love to sit down with him. I'll have to reach out at some point and see if he'd be interested

[@Southernromanist]

I’ve really enjoyed your videos. After watching a few of them I thought, “I like this guy. He is sincere, honest, and acts in good faith.” And those three things are the most you can ask of someone. I’d encourage you to read Louis Bouyer’s “Spirit and Forms of Protestantism”. Bouyer was a convert from Lutheranism and one of the most influential theologians of the 20th century., In the book, he argues that the Reformers’ critiques were sincere and can only be fulfilled in the Catholic Church.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Wow, thank you so much for your kind words. I really appreciate that. Sounds like a good read! I’ll put it on my list. Thanks!

[@culturecoroner]

Wow. Thank you for this suggestion. I’m going to look into it.

[@coondogbob]

Very good and healthy dialogue, as a revert to catholisism i can appreciate especially the part about evangelism

[@GospelSimplicity]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@anthonyclarke1707]

You are doing an amazing job with your channel. I appreciate your inquisitive mindset. We are one body in Christ. God bless you my friend from a Catholic.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Anthony Clarke thank you so much! God bless you too

[@gwendolynnorton6329]

Beautiful!

[@justinfuller8481]

Yes! I love this. So hyped

[@GospelSimplicity]

Think you’re going to enjoy it!

[@jacintapatton9862]

Thank you so much for making these types of videos!

[@GospelSimplicity]

It’s my pleasure!

[@rebekahklein3982]

Keith Nestor describes Catholicism so truthfully. As a convert from Presbyterian/Lutheranism, I can give testimony that all my anti-Catholic indoctrination was so false and unfounded. I was never taught apostolic church history, about the church founders and that many customs in the Catholic Church also nod to Jewish Worship customs as ordered by God to the Israelites in the Old Testament. I do think we have to recognize that church practices do evolve through time. Individuals do study the Bible which has become more significant in the past few decades. Mary is not worshiped, but she is recognized as being important to Christ himself. The Saints are Christian examples for us that can enhance our faith in God. And the term Born Again was offensive to me as a Protestant-objecting to judgement from Born Again Christians who accuse people who do not have “that moment”. Thank goodness Catholic Mass weekly and daily in some parishes, enables us to refocus upon our Personal Savior, Jesus Christ.

[@kathleenc.3259]

Loved this conversation and both of your perspectives!

[@GospelSimplicity]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@kuyajosephtutorials9709]

Keith, proud Catholic here... Amen

[@GospelSimplicity]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@christophergrillo5099]

Awesome! I really enjoy Keith Nester's conversion story, and his channel is great too.

[@GospelSimplicity]

He’s great!

[@joeythemonk007]

One of the best conversations I have heard. God bless both of u guys. I must admit there were so many useful insights for me.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Wow, thank you! So glad that you enjoyed it and found it helpful

[@faithhopecharity1037]

I truly enjoyed and learned much through this. Thank you to both!

[@GospelSimplicity]

Our pleasure!

[@chicoromantic10]

Beautiful! Good job brother.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Thank you!

[@paracleteknight8422]

good dialogue. Praying for both of you as you pray for all of us and those who are in journey of their faith.

[@samanthasantos4649]

Thank you so much for this video. My husband is Baptist and watching this has really helped me to embrace him and his faith even more. I had bad experiences with Protestants in the past that made me resentful towards Protestants and this video made me realize that not everyone is protesting. Thank you! God Bless!

[@GospelSimplicity]

So glad it was helpful!

[@saintejeannedarc9460]

That's why we prefer to call ourselves Christians. Most of us are just following Christ and not protesting anything.

[@vinsvalentin]

Nice conversation 😊

[@GospelSimplicity]

Thanks!

[@TracyW-me8br]

I love the positive ecumenical conversations on this channel. Great video! More of this please.

[@GospelSimplicity]

So glad that you're enjoying it! More are coming! The next interview I have coming up is with Bojan from Bible Illustrated, a great Orthodox KZbinr. More after that!

[@RGTomoenage11]

Awesome, been watching keith for a while. Watching you too, good job guys.

[@GospelSimplicity]

He's great. Grateful you'd take the time to watch and comment. God bless!

[@GrandmaLynn]

As Christians, we can learn from each other so that Jesus’ Church can be what He intended it to be. Catholics have the garden, protestants have the tools.

[@GospelSimplicity]

That's a beautiful analogy!

[@tony1685]

Amos 3:3, Ma'am. if it were all based upon Truth (John 17:17) then there would be no catholicism.

[@milietesolomon7659]

It is great to lissen to your conversation to learn from our differences.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Glad you think so!

[@duals-growthofculture2085]

Good dialogue here. Keith gave an awesome testimony, I hope you really ruminate and pray on what he spoke to you here. God bless both of you, Love & Light

[@GospelSimplicity]

It was great getting to sit down with Keith. God bless!

[@aliszhinchaenz]

I don't watch anything more than 20 minutes on KZbin but I watched your vid till the end. I love it.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Wow, I’m honored. Thank you so much!

[@siena4ever751]

Welcome Home, Keith. God bless you both.

[@anstashiaghanaa3752]

God bless you paaa Keith anytime I hear you talking or teaching I feel increase in my faith thanks may our Jesus Christ take over and bless your family Amen paaa

[@jgalang1881]

Very healthy conversation.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Thanks!

[@rustyg.sembrano2966]

hello Keith I really admire your conversion. Miracle in faith really works.

[@TrollsFormers05]

Amazingly civil discussion in the comments. I'm impressed! Good job!

[@GospelSimplicity]

Israel Siqueira thanks! That’s how we do it on this channel😁

[@jovialmoshahary1556]

Lovely discussion.

[@erinb8260]

I’m loving these videos. Prayers for you on this journey, Austin! Thank you for your open-mindedness and effort to learn more about Catholicism! I’m a cradle Catholic (poorly catechized as a child), who fell in love with my faith as an adult, especially after my Protestant husband (now a Catholic convert!) challenged me on my beliefs. He and I learned the depths of the Catholic faith together (still learning all the time!) and are now raising our 5 precious children in the fullness of the faith! Thank God for our unity and conversion of heart! God bless you Austin!

[@GospelSimplicity]

Glad you're enjoying them! It's absolutely my pleasure. Thanks for sharing a bit of your story! God bless

[@mungzou5878]

Keith I love the thing you mentioned about welcoming attitude we should have for new comers.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Such a good point

[@christinacastillon6439]

May God bless you Kieth and Austin. I really believe God is using both of you to bring souls to Him.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Thanks!

[@christelrascon4708]

BEAUTIFUL!!!! :’)

[@GospelSimplicity]

Thanks!

[@christelrascon4708]

Very sadly, I have a cousin who does adhere closely to those caricatures in attempting to dissuade me from my Catholic faith ~ she can be overtly hurtful and entirely closed off to any healthy dialog. It’s terrible because I can’t even have a normal relationship or conversation with her without it becoming tense and even combative on this issue. Even on social media..... she’s quite hurtful, blasting the Catholic Church with those same tired misconceptions ~ she’s told me that I “have nothing to prove” when I share things personally from my Catholic faith in social media .... I don’t see it as having anything to prove, but everything that I am desirous to share ~ it once bated me into a response that I am not proud of, but I snapped and said that Protestantism is a heresy.... oh I feel terrible for slinging that; it was a low moment for me for certain. here’s what I have seen: many Protestants, in my experience, are perfectly at home ... with overt attacks against Catholicism, but they are often sharply taken aback by any criticism in the reverse ~ I admire deeply that the two of you can model what it’s like to foster healthy, productive, and loving dialog as a Catholic and a Protestant ~ as brothers in our One Savior ~ I cannot thank you both enough ~

[@GospelSimplicity]

I’m sorry to hear about the strained relations with your cousin. That can be a very difficult thing to navigate. I pray that God will give you both wisdom and love in learning how to relate to one another best. I’m glad that this video could provide some inspiration on what those conversations can look like. God bless!

[@rmader1997]

Forget it for now. She only wants to hurt you. Don't talk about religion with her. Tell her why. Lack of Charity. Someday you might be surprised. The things you have brought up may one day sink in and whe will look at them with a logical and respectful eys. Until then, she is doing satan's job for him.

[@hemantapegu1053]

Nice to watch your conversations.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Glad you like them!

[@ojodugbomiogbaje6800]

I thank God for you two.

[@GospelSimplicity]

It's our pleasure to get to do what we do

[@barbaragonzales5944]

Re: which saints to read -- The Interior Castle by St. Terese of Avila, and Summa Theologia by St. Thomas Aquinas (the ultimate argument for objective truth & the fact that the RCC embodies that). Also try the Didache from the early church fathers, and the (secular) writings of historian Joe Cephus, which solidify the RCC claims of history. It will blow. your. mind. 🤯

[@GospelSimplicity]

Thanks!

[@jacobrahe8726]

I wish more protestants and catholics had more conversations like this this is awesome

[@GospelSimplicity]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@agihernandez7846]

The more I listen to your videos and see you come around im very amazed from your humility and willingness to find unity between Christianity. Keep doing that, this saids a lot from you for your love to Jesus. ❤️😌

[@GospelSimplicity]

Wow, thank you so much for your kind words. God bless!

[@scrpynlover12]

God bless you Austin. A wonderful interview. I admire you for your honesty in seeking out truth. Keep at it, keep asking questions, and in the fulness of time you will discover the answers you are seeking . There's a old Chinese proverb that says, " the journey of a thousand miles begins with one step. " You are on a journey of discovery, take the next step,keep going and continue to be an honest seeker of truth. In my thoughts and prayers. Your brother in Christ.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Thanks for the encouragement

[@mminlovewithflo]

Hi Austin! I'm one of your catholic followers. I watched your conversation with Keith yesterday and it gave me some points to think about. So probably you were in the background of my mind since yesterday. Today as I was praying the rosary you came to my mind, so I prayed for you too. And I felt a desire for your conversion but (!) not because I think Catholicism is superior or more correct than Protestantism, but simply because, while reciting a communal prayer with the whole church and thinking of how many of us praying were praying for other brothers and sisters, I realized that the true beauty of Catholicism is the universal community it creates. At the same time I had an opposite thought, interestingly. At the same time I realised that if the most beautiful and important part of being Christian is being together and being united, then creeds and denominations don't count. I still contemplate these contradictory thoughts, it doesn't bother me at all, they can be both true :) just wanted to share an episode that may be interesting to think about denominations and ecumenism. Of course, thank you for your work. Melissa, Italy Possa il Signore custodirti nella Sua pace. May the Lord guard you in His peace!

[@GospelSimplicity]

Thanks for sharing this experience with me! I'm so grateful for your prayers. God bless!

[@muxugrad]

Great stuff! Really enjoyed the video. I can very much relate to Keith’s story except for the pastor part. I agree with his comment on holiness and being more aware of sin as a Catholic. Protestants would benefit from doing an Examination of Conscience before asking God for forgiveness. It makes you more aware of the sin in your life. Thanks again!

[@GospelSimplicity]

My pleasure! Thanks for watching!

[@BlackDew747]

Keith, I am hearing about your experience and when you mention people at the door of the church waiting for newcomers, it really strike a cord in me. I was raised Catholic on a Latin American country, so we are very different than the US Catholics and do not feel at home. But I enjoy the service as the Holy Mass is the same and rituals unite us all asa community. During the service I feel the sense of belonging. Thank you for sharing

[@GospelSimplicity]

Glad you enjoyed that!

[@kuyajosephtutorials9709]

Jesus said, CARRY YOUR CROSS AND FOLLOW ME... You have to make your own steps to follow Him...

[@GospelSimplicity]

This is true

[@christinahernandez9763]

Me encanta Keith Nester. I love his conversion to catholicism

[@JohnShaw]

Great video!

[@GospelSimplicity]

Thanks!

[@joecastillo8798]

I am just watching this episode with Keith. Excellent points regarding the need for hospitality and follow up of people who seek to be part of our faith. The fact of our apparent passivity towards posible newcomers is the ever present understanding of the presence of our Lord and the movement of the Holy Spirit who inspires and guides the individual graced with inspiration to move towards the Catholic Church. I've seen it so many times as a Catholic apologist and as one time member of an evangelization commission. Nonetheless, hearing your conversation brings up the urgency, these days, of being proactive in helping fellow Christians know the truth in the one Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church, founded by Christ. God bless.

[@GospelSimplicity]

Thanks for sharing these thoughts!

[@AsmountZion]

Austin, you are such a gracious and open minded host. It truly amazes me. You're leagues ahead of many of us. 10 years ago, when I was a severely anti-Catholic fundamentalist Protestant, it took forever to learn how to put down my guard and question things/myself in a critical way. Becoming Catholic doesn't happen over night, like you both mentioned; in fact, anyone who's honest with themselves will admit they're constantly learning. There's 2,000 yrs of rich history and tradition to absorb, little by little. That includes growing in humility and grace (one of the hardest things). Steve Ray was 100% correct, you'll never turn back :). I highly recommend his book, Upon This Rock. Wish I discovered that book years ago, it answers so many questions!

[@GospelSimplicity]

Wow, thank you so much for your kind words. I really appreciate that. Thank you for sharing a bit of your story as well. I agree fully that we should all be continually learning, and there certainly is a lot to sift through. Thanks for the book recommendation! God bless

[@biancabianca4118]

I love you guys😊

[@GospelSimplicity]

Thanks! Grateful for your support

[@Christine-vb5be]

We are one in His spirit. The more I am in union with God, the more I realise how vast He is. Everyone is like a blind man trying to understand how an elephant is like. Some say the elephant has a long trunk, some say the elephant has big ears, some say the elephant has a long tail. Protestant, catholics, Greek Orthodox don’t try to convince or argue with each other. Let each other enrich our knowledge of the Lord. Our saviour, our life and our hope. Just put our time and effort in deepening our relationship with the Lord and help each other to do so. May peace be with you all.

[@abetaledon2266]

Wonderful dialogue to Bro.Keith Nester I cried while saying His testimony...and it's true Jesus is the Way...the Truth... and the Life.And He build His "Church" not churches.Under Peter His Apostle.Glad to come home bro.keith & your family🤗Gospel Simplicity To God be the Glory☝️

[@TheDroc1990]

Jesus Christ is absolutely and truly present in the Euchrist. Very happy to have become Lutheran.

[@anniechang7611]

Love the wine analogy. He’s had the Wedding at Cana experience.

[@rosepetalmemories8934]

As a cradle Catholic, I have too often come upon Protestants who attack the idea of Mary and of Catholics for honoring Mary. I've heard Protestants call her horrible names, say that she wasn't important that Jesus could have just as easily been birthed by a cow. Really Mary bashing! I even have a good Protestant friend who told his elderly mother that she would burn in he'll because she said the rosary! I guess my point is that it's not just Catholics that have misconceptions or who can be so intolerant toward another faith. I always say that that kind of angst and anger doesn't come from righteousness or from God, it comes from below, from the master of lies. I love how open you are to talking through our differences. I appreciate your ability to have an open mind. How polite and courteous you always are to everyone. Thank you and God bless you.

[@soniarivera5016]

Keith you had the courage to go to the right way to find the truth faith. That’s we need to do follow the only one church.

[@GospelSimplicity]

I'm sure he would appreciate you saying that

[@RetepOdaged]

This guy is amazing!

[@GospelSimplicity]

Thanks!