How speedrunners beat Club Penguin Thin Ice Perfectly - History of World Records

[@ChrisHendricks]

I wasn't expecting this level of professionalism put into a video like this. Well done! And very interesting!

[@chilsie]

yooooo its chris himself!

[@FloridianFool]

I love the "Lothjon was spared from eating his shoe". No further elaboration was needed

[@ryanandrews7109]

This seems like an incredibly niche topic I would never actively search for, and I will now watch the entire thing

[@idontwantahandlethough]

those are the best YT videos honestly. It's so cool getting to learn about a whole new topic that you didn't even know about before that moment! You can almost feel your brain sprouting a new region (note: probably not how brains work)

[@hxaza]

the fact that i didn't realize nhaar was the uploader until i finished the video is crazy. very well put together. i actually just watched the entire length of this and i don't do that a lot lol. respect

[@idontwantahandlethough]

normally I'd be really quite embarrassed about watching (and tbh.. thoroughly enjoying) a video about Club Penguin, but this was so well done that I think it'd be weirder if I _didn't!_ 😂

[@ShayyTV]

Thanks for inviting me to voice this video! Was a lot of fun to learn about Club Penguin stuff :D

[@troublemonkey1_626]

I just discorvered this and i had no clue you voiced this video. the energy is completely different than your sterams lol

[@sillypinkmoth]

o:

[@Kristhegoober]

I knew that voice sounded familiar!

[@mrhalfsaid1389]

Thought the voice was familiar

[@blueclouds315]

That voice sounded so familiar.

[@OryxTheMadGod3]

I love when runners refer to themselves in 3rd person in these kind of videos. It makes it less "look at me, look at me" and more "look at all these people who contributed to the community"

[@gyroninjamodder]

That didn't happen in this video though

[@ianto3453]

@@gyroninjamodderyeah its just that nhaar is a really common name so the speedrunner and the youtuber are totally different nhaars. Total and utter coincidence. Definitely not that there was one nhaar who knew all about this niche speedrun because he did it himself and then made a video on it. It was a different nhaar who stumbled upon this and did a ton of research spanning multiple years of discord discussions.

[@thenachostudios]

Nhaar is not the narrator here so its not a speedrunner talking about himself in 3rd person @@ianto3453

[@schwarzonia]

​@@ianto3453look in the vid description

[@Snailsxd]

​@@ianto3453the video is voiced by another youtuber, so uhhh lmaoo

[@PVMNHaar]

Hello new people! To all the people talking about the background music: Yes, you are right, the music is way too loud. I only noticed this once the video started premiering, since I was rushing to get it done for the anniversary and didn't have time to make changes after rendering. This always bothered me so much because I couldn't watch the documentary and enjoy it. In the first day I released a different, more audible version (you can still find it in the comments here), but I didn't want to erase this one because I really loved everyone's reception (back when the video had

[@PVMNHaar]

Looks like YT just removed my ability to pin comments, so this will likely get lost, thanks YT

[@Gekoloudios]

nah bro I found ya, here ima like it so it gets top comment lol

[@hellbach8879]

Comment for algorithm boost (also the way you pronounced Fallheit and occasionally said Loth-John kinda triggered me haha)

[@PVMNHaar]

@@hellbach8879 PS: Faulheit was pronounced correctly, he isn't german or anything, it's just a nickname. The "Loth-John" incident was because we started correcting that after the first takes, but some ended up not getting replaced :P

[@artoria4085]

very nice video, well done!

[@dojelnotmyrealname4018]

Arguably in ASM all routes are equally fast in the limit because of how thin ice works, so the only thing routes can really change is how easy it is to do them perfectly. So unless some teleporter-less route gets discovered I don't think this can go any faster.

[@GoombaNL]

Fantastic video, loved the general history and background on the community and such rather than a sole focus on time improvement. Very much enjoyed it :)

[@sticks_stuff]

its my sleepover and i get to pick the movie

[@keysmcgees5375]

This was really well made! It's so crazy how optimised some speedruns can get, congrats to both of you :D!

[@Booskop.]

This really went into detail about a game I never played, watch streams or speedruns of, and made me feel I've been part of the community since yesteryear. This is great content! Great stuff nhaar, this was really, really good!

[@e.than.b]

Incredible video! I miss the days of coming home from school to play Club Penguin for hours with friends. Thin Ice was always one of the trickiest games (along with Mancala because us 10 year olds could NOT wrap our heads around it). I sunk a lot of time and trial and error into beating it. It's nice to reminisce on these memories, so thanks for that. I miss this game so much haha. All those songs are so nostalgic too. Truly a special game to grow up on.

[@jasmidotormythrilaon]

never thought id see kyu from huniepop in a club penguin speedrunning video

[@coelophysisbauri4070]

The idea for the two runners to race each other was genius. Really exciting

[@PVMNHaar]

If you are having issues hearing the narrator, here is an alternate version: kzbin.info/www/bejne/jHeoladqfquIrNU

[@ketchupmkw]

this video was amazing! it's so incredible that you and andru managed to get the perfect run on asm, this video was so well-scripted, it felt like I was there live

[@GrachiPlays]

I was surprised to see less than a couple thousands views only on this video, its incredibly well made and interesting to see. I really hope to see more from you if you enjoy making it, I could easily see you racking up the views and subscribers in no time. You definitely have potential to become one of those specialised speedrunning channels like ItsMaximum or Msushi that focus their videos mostly on one or a couple of games, that end up drawing a ton of outside attention to their communities and showing people how interesting they can be.

[@marsmartis2697]

this was surprisingly engaging. who knew i'd be so invested in a 43 minute video on the history of the speedrunning of a minigame. its something about the different characters and their constantly clashing goals leading to intensifying conflict. im on the edge of my seat seeing who will get the shortest time. great video.

[@wizardhwk]

KZbin randomly recommended me this, and I loved it! This video deserves more views, great work! ... Saudades desse game...

[@superboeyt]

just had this pop up on my feed at 3am, never would have looked for it on my own but I had to see this entire thing through and ohmyGOD!! absolutely incredible how much time and effort went in to making thin ice fair, accessible and practical for speed running, on top of how much healthy sportsmanship was exhibited between the top runners!! It didn’t seem hostile or aggressive, just a bunch of people who love the game coming together and seeing just how fast they can reach perfection. this was so worth the watch, so so wholesome.

[@Misschocoluvr]

Crazy this video is gaining traction 2yrs after being published 🤯

[@GuitaristChase]

Sick video! I always knew there was players who would speedrun this but I never knew the history. loved learning about it!

[@Marcox385]

My favorite words on this kind of videos are "But then..."

[@Meriba]

I didn't realize it was you in the video until half of it, mad respect for your efforts in this. E ótima representação do Brasil, jogou muito

[@PVMNHaar]

tamo junto

[@Firegroupfugl]

Amazing video! Incredibly well scripted, making it very fun and to the point. The music choices were great, and I have to give credit to the terrific voice! ;) Very informative. I learned a lot of new and interesting things about Thin Ice speedrunning and the history of the Club Penguin leaderboards in general! Huge shoutout to everyone who worked on this, and Andru for being an absolute champion! (and you too nhaar) Oh btw, Andru, I love your desktop background at 29:30 You got a great taste in games! B)

[@commander-fox-q7573]

I had completely forgotten about this mini game from my childhood but honestly now I kinda want to play it again. Good video!

[@AzureSkyBeta]

took me watching a 3rd of the video before realizing that nhaar was the one who made this video lol

[@Comandobunny]

I seriously hope that this video blows up, it's actually really entertaining!

[@jblen]

What a fun speedrun. This is one of those runs that makes me go 'hey I could do that' but then the runners start approaching frame perfect times and I could no longer do that, then they go the final step and get THE frame perfect time.

[@puffyhowler615]

Got this recommended to me and i only just now realized that nhaar actually made it after finishing the video lol

[@oofy404]

This is a great video! Love it when I get recommended Club Penguin videos, and a speed running scene I had no clue about with a rich history. Keep up the great work!

[@trash__queen]

This made me want to start speedrunning

[@wesleymaster1233]

Wow! I’m impressed by the video congrats, such an amazing production. É orgulhoso ver brasileiros se destacarem tanto num meio que ainda somos meio invisíveis ❤

[@bbeanli]

Hey man, sick vid! For the run I did I no joke practiced 2 times before recording b/c i needed to know the levels LOL. I didn't know ppl actually ran this until the current record holder commented on my video. Glad to be a part of this in some small way :).

[@xandrey64]

absolute legend

[@onyxiris]

I love seeing videos like this and then going to the channel and realising that it's one of the runners who made it

[@alisona.4166]

Did you know the penguins in club penguin were going to be seals? This was changed due to how "Club Seal" sounded.

[@aguywhosbi7671]

this is such a cute and heartwarming video... i cannot explain why. its just so well-written. you deserve more views 💖

[@CillmaCuvas]

Congrats on the algorithm, and ty for making such a fun video.

[@vicentereyes8463]

bro, this shit ruled, i never thought i could get this invested on a club penguin minigame, but here i am.

[@august59001]

Very well done. If ysomeone wonders, to this day there are 20people with perfect runs in any% and only those 2 in 100%. Makes me want to play it again, club penguin was a good time. Thanks for the video!

[@xaviersavard6343]

Wow. This nhaar guy is so good, i wonder what he thinks of this video...

[@El-Mikey]

Got this recommended, very well structured and explained

[@LilyLewis771]

Oh man I miss these games so bad. This video (and the game music especially!) brought back so many memories, thank you!

[@brelouum]

that music just BLASTED me with NOSTALGIA AHHGHGG i miss cluppenguin sm

[@miguel_aquatico]

my mans really just made a documentary about himself in the 3rd person

[@PVMNHaar]

hey, the documentary isn't about me!

[@kevindhir]

amazing video i stayed glued to it the whole time

[@samtrixOutHands]

"Just go fast" - Andrew "I never thought about that"

[@huhneat8908]

"stick presented the final solution" very unfortunate wording lol good video btw!

[@Fox-983]

“Stick presented the final solution” beg pardon?

[@austinfletchermusic]

This is a really coop video! Shame it's been a while since the upload, but who knows! Maybe he'll have more speedr- THIS IS THE SUPA HOT FIRE CHANNEL?!?!?

[@Luqsbrt]

Não sei o que mais me impressionei, se foi a qualidade do vídeo e de contar história, ou de saber que você é Brasileiro KKKKKKKKKK. Parabéns mano, vídeo muito bom, mesmo lançado a 2 anos atrás, ele envelheceu muito bem, assim como essa obra prima chamada club penguin.

[@jpbalikian671]

Nossa sim, ficou perfeito mesmo kkkkkk

[@xaropevic7918]

I love how you showed at the start you saying "This is gonna be my last run" and the last Andrew's run, he said the very same thing! Ah, brasil mencionado 8:54 ! Parabéns pro seu inglês, é ótimo btw

[@SunfallMelancholy]

This video reminds me of that "blue yourself Speedrun history" video since it was made by the guy who ran it like a madman from the beginning and fought till the end. Love to a fellow Brazilian brother. Also, credits to Shayy for narrating for all of the video. Must've taken "at least" a couple takes.

[@thejynxedlynx5570]

'I'm going to kill nhaar.'

[@AngelDANSHI]

This video was really well made and needs more views!!

[@juanokug4]

watching all of this only to notice that the channel it's posted to is nhaar and it's actually shayy voicing it gave me whiplash

[@noahlane6382]

Honestly I really hope this guy makes more videos. This was great. Maybe on some of the other mini games?

[@Otacanthus]

IT'S NOT A RED PUFFLE?

[@lyanporto]

what a hype race, amazing video

[@natasha0599]

NO WAAAAAY usually these videos dont keep my attention or i play them in the background, but when i saw Xandruuu being from Costa Rica i was SAT in my chair and cheering on for him, congrats to Xandru for beatingthe WR! POTENCIA MUNDIAL PURA VIDAAAAAAAAA

[@xandrey64]

🇨🇷🇨🇷🇨🇷🇨🇷🇨🇷

[@fel3310]

as club penguin private servers began dying i always challenged myself to get all the thin ice stamps and it was hard as hell, speedrunning the whole thing is insane. mad respect to everyone involved

[@kay8379]

thanks for making this video, love that type of stuff

[@brucetaion8201]

This amazing, please make more

[@KamesJerr]

Bloody hell hearing that old Club Penguin music felt like I was getting CIA sleeper cell activated

[@matheusboaron_]

this is nostalgic af

[@ianemerson2704]

Didn't even realize that nhaar had posted this video. Great job!

[@austinfletchermusic]

Here comes the algo!!!

[@PVMNHaar]

bless random youtube algorithm

[@Aspharon]

Aww, this is a great video. Hits different after the CPR shutdown. Great work.

[@armandbier2502]

took me 12 minutes to realize the channel is nhaar

[@mmorpg1094]

Great video

[@MintyCodes]

Really well-made video!

[@Bluestk]

Great video Nhaar! Really neat to see you start doing content like this.

[@yea4309]

Aw this video was so cool. So cool how niche communities like this can exist

[@alainxde]

was already half into the video till i realised the legend himself was who made the video

[@KMK11001]

You have the perfect voice for this kind of video. Amazing job, please do more!

[@NasuNanu]

Great video, and congrats to everyone involved! But the background music was quite loud and ended up being distracting in some parts of the video

[@Riokaii]

dope video, music was quite loud though, hard to hear narration throughout.

[@ketchupmkw]

it was fine for me

[@emilyofjane]

The sled racing music over the streaming race was the perfect touch lol

[@aliteralmonkeyy]

I MISS CLUB PENGUIN

[@stratiks]

Came here for supahotfire but ended up watching this video and it was fire

[@Harrison_801]

Wow I just spent 43 minutes watching a video on a speedrun I didn't even know existed until now. Great video

[@Autumn-Leafeon]

Genuinely an amazing video on par with Summoning Salt, but even having personal club penguin music was even better for this. Hearing the "I've been delayed" song at the very end got me a little bit. Good job!

[@AngelLuvr]

Maybe the real thin ice was the friends we made along the way ♥️

[@leugimkm]

Cara, que vídeo incrível tava torcendo pra vc ser o primeiro a conseguir a run perfeita

[@liliasoleil]

i was so damn good at ish fishing!!

[@pbchocot4800]

I see andrew is a fellow SPM fan

[@charlotte42688]

I loved this mini game so much omg

[@Firegroupfugl]

Check out my sick All Missions run btw!

[@12...]

iirc you could originally play the entire game as a non-member and that restriction was added later

[@PVMNHaar]

Yeah, around 2010 when they added stamps. That was way long after any speedruns came about though

[@12...]

@@PVMNHaar ah i mostly played around 2008 i think

[@dekutony]

thin ice

[@henriquepacheco7473]

Lawful good: speedrunning thin ice Chaotic evil: speedrunning banned%

[@granberyacademia]

Cara, adorei os seus videos! Você deveria fazer mais! Parabens

[@ChopieTheCat]

Watching the video and then seeing who posted it made me laugh, well done.

[@jeksewnoleeray1020]

Tying the ASM TAS is crazy

[@shpirtlockman5253]

oh how i love watching random, professional speedrunning historical videos

[@charastar_]

it took me a moment to realise that you were nhaar yourself. that aside this is incredibly impressive

[@b1xssom838]

After you said nhaar I looked at the uploaded and was genuinely perplexed

[@elliot7922]

oh my god i didnt realize until a solid 40 minutes in this was posted by nhaar

[@Sibley_]

i love brasilian thin ice