How Tibetans “Ruled” Mongols For Centuries (until NOW...)

[@yacinechaker2687]

I can’t believe I am watching this for free. This is such high quality content, it felt like a big production documentary, I can only imagine how much work went into it. Thank you so much please don’t stop! You are probably the only one covering these unknown but fascinating topics.

[@aaeehhlove]

Thank you. Thank you! I'm a Han Chinese but never was I introduced the relationship between Tibetan and Mongolian in my history and culture education in schools. But I always heard an old saying 'Zang Meng Yi Jia' 藏蒙一家 which means Tibetans and Mongolians are of a one family. And in Beijing there're many Tibetan and Mongol remnants and artifacts left from previous dynasties. Now I came to know it. How wonderful! May God bless Tibetans and Mongolians around the world!

[@Jingwushow]

Pleasure is all mine, glad you find my work interesting and thank you for your kind wishes!

[@KevinSirup]

Tibet will be free.

[@teamjupeter9451]

Actually, Korean also belongs to that family.

[@ttsundo]

tibetans and Mongolians should come together once again

[@风暴Z典狱長]

@@KevinSirupjoker😂😂😂😂

[@confucius_confused]

Watching from Bhutan. I didn't realize that I watched an hour long video; it felt like 10 minutes of power packed details and well researched facts. Well done!

[@Jingwushow]

Thanks for watching my show! Glad you enjoyed it!

[@Ihomahomay]

🙏🏳️‍🌈🇲🇳♥️🇧🇹🏳️‍🌈🙏

[@OneNationProd]

What a fascinating history! As a Bangladeshi, I've visited Nepal and met many Tibetans over the years and have always been fascinated by the complexity and depth of Tibetan Buddhist teachings. You've given me a lot of context through a geopolitical lens that was missing. Thank you for telling this history beautifully and enriching my understanding of these cultures.

[@Jingwushow]

You are welcome, friend! Glad my work could be of use!

[@mangalbodele9775]

Tibetan is tantrayan practice of vajrayan bhuddhism which is taught in sompura n uddantapuri bhuddhist University which is now situated in Bangladesh...tantrayan bhuddgism major religion of Bangladesh in pala dynasty

[@OneNationProd]

@@mangalbodele9775 yes, I am aware of that and the significant history of Buddhism and Somapura Mahavihara in Badalgachhi, Bangladesh. The site has been preserved well and I hope more research will be done about this very important site.

[@abrahamnabam7287]

you take ur rohingya back from our Northeast India

[@aljazeelchannel]

Kashmir is free and Muslims are the original rulers of India. ​@@abrahamnabam7287

[@तामाडभासाकाही]

As a Bhutanese originally ethic to Tamang people of Mountains of Himalayan region, I really felt how far we were influenced by Tibetan Buddhism. We practise Tibetan Buddhism , we speak perhaps the oldest language of Tibetan but at present mostly influenced by Nepali language , I am worried where Buddhism we learnt from Tibet will head , and Tamangs are rapidly converting to Christianity and other religions recently . And thank you for wonderful presentations.

[@55jigme]

Tamang's were not influence by Tibetan culture , they were Tibetans who settle in Nepal centuries ago (circa 650AD ) no wonder tamang speaks oldest forms of Tibetan language .

[@rigzinwangchuk5529]

"Tamangs are one of the major Tibeto-Burmese speaking communities in Nepal. They believe that they originally came from Tibet.The historical and legendary account of the Tamangs shows that they originally came from the Tibet. It is said that they were horse traders. "Ta" in Tibetan means horse; "Mang" means traders." Hence Tamang

[@AnelSyangdan]

I'm too Tamang from east part of Nepal I'm Buddhist some northen side of Nepal Tamang convert to christianity for money i hate them they are not Tamang i always proud to be Buddhist

[@greenscenery1974]

Jesus is the true God. In him there is eternal life ❤️✝️

[@yeshig9]

I’m not 100% historian but I heard Tamang means”horse-war, warrior” or cavalry in Tibetan which I could say it’s true. I heard during Tibetan empire era, Songsten Gonpo set up Tibetan military camp near Nepal, India, Bhutan frontier which eventually became Tamang. #onelovebrother

[@TemuulTK]

As a Mongolian I watched it with both intensity and perhaps little sadness. I usually get offended by the videos made by non Mongols talking about our history as it entails with personal bias. But your videos are truthful, factual and honest. Thank you for that and I really liked the fact that you visited Mongolia to really understand the essence of the people you are narrating about. Btw do you have any Mongol in you? Interesting to know.

[@Jingwushow]

Yeah, I’m Mongolian Chinese. Glad you enjoyed my video! Mongolia is beautiful, and I’ll have to visit it again!

[@TemuulTK]

@@Jingwushow Glad to know you are a Mongolian decent and thank you for these awesome videos again. I am becoming a fan.

[@enkheenatsag513]

I dislike Buddhism.Mongolians paid back .Buddha was India.Instead of Chinese Indian Buddhism spreaded through even Siberia asian country except of Chinese

[@chogyal7]

​@@enkheenatsag513Buddha was born in Nepal.

[@TemuulTK]

@@DamianKnox11 Yes I know about Hazara Mongols. One of the direct descendants of Genghis Khan according to the recent DNA testing. Mongols, Kazakhs, Hazaras, Uzbeks and Kalmyks.

[@chiranjiv1361]

As an indian , it felt like a journey through centuries!! Its one of the finest documentaries i have seen. I lived in Nainital, in the state of Uttarakhand which has a large Tibetan population. Really fascinating.

[@Jingwushow]

Glad you enjoyed it, neighbor! Thanks for watching!

[@devyanilimaye8560]

​@@Jingwushowloved your work, much appreciated from India, again

[@Tashi4951]

This guy is works for CCP spreading hate and lies ..

[@pratikking2272]

The tibetians will chase you out if your own homes.

[@whyamihere2250]

@@pratikking2272 nope we are not like the chinese

[@chitru1983]

Love from the Philippines! There is so much to learn from Asian history. Listening to your storytelling is like watching a historical cdrama - so many plots, subplots and conspiracies. An hour passed by in a breeze.

[@Jingwushow]

Glad this video reached you! Thanks for watching, friend!

[@Tashi4951]

This guy work for Chinese CCP.. he is putting out propaganda.. don’t fall for it..

[@peacelover.9881]

Woww such a wonderful History. Thank you so much for sharing beautiful history.

[@despro8088]

Tibet and mongol are two treasures underrated of east asian cultures. I lived in a family which influenced a lot by tibetan buddism culture without any tibetan blood, i hoop i would have the talent, skill and ability like you to make a video or words whatever. By the way, the romance of the land of this part of continent was so fasinating. Thank you very much for your incredible work, it is already like a masterpiece, great job!

[@Jingwushow]

My pleasure! Thank you for watching my show!

[@nareshshingote8081]

How Tibet comes in east Asia

[@Tashi4951]

This guy is a CCP propagandist..

[@Tashi4951]

@@JingwushowCCP Agent spotted

[@hejksbwvxjajvfuxuwhevixnqvdjx]

@@Tashi4951 filthy uncivilized cannibals 😅

[@silenciothequiet3471]

Sir, I am lost for words. This one of the best historical documentary I ever watched, everything is on point: narrative, delivery, relevance and graphics. I feel more informed and still want to know more, keep up the good work. You are really providing high quality content.

[@Jingwushow]

So nice of you! Thank you! I strive to tell minority stories, even though they are not mainstream, but they are important to me. I'm super glad to hear that you enjoyed my work!

[@bobmorane4926]

Thank you for bringing life and excitement to a piece of history that many are barely familiar with. You're doing an amazing job !!!

[@Jingwushow]

I think it’s a bit too little known lol. Maybe people are not too into this. :(

[@bobmorane4926]

@@Jingwushow Well it so happens you seem to be the perfect guy to change that !! Keep up the good work !

[@ChrisZ901]

This is such a well researched work. I have always been fascinated about Tibetam and Mongolian history and this documentary has such an educational value. Congratulations bro, you did it again!

[@Jingwushow]

Thanks for coming back and liking my content again!! Glad you enjoyed it!

[@pckdriod9938]

Www❤❤❤9 pp œ😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊09😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤9 pp pp

[@AnelSyangdan]

As a Nepali Buddhist we are also smilar to tibetan cultures and religion ❤

[@sonamlonden7574]

True

[@gliu1431]

May I ask is Buddha a mongoloid as depicted in a Buddha portrait in London museum. I have this impression he is and he looks similar to mongoloid Nepali or Bhutanese.

[@Chakgo]

Just like Jesus, the modern day depiction of JESUS is straight hair white guy but in reality Jesus had brown skin and curly hair more like the modern day middle eastern people. Buddha was Indian origin and depicted by Buddhist in China and Nepal to look more like us than how he actually looked in reality. @@gliu1431

[@diponic3344]

@@gliu1431the Buddha was an indo-Aryan not a mongoloid “His face was elongated with a protruding head called the Ushnisha, well formed nose, Buddha's ears were long, and hair was fine, black with soft curls. The eyes of the Buddha are claimed to have been wide and bluish in color.”

[@gliu1431]

@@diponic3344 I don’t know where your source comes from. Nepal natives are Mongoloid include people migrated to south from Tibets.

[@constantinejohn8433]

Amazing video! Although I have to say that for Mongols living under Russian rule (Kalmyks, Buryads and Tuvans) Tibetan Buddhism was a blessing that saved us from massive christianisation. Russian imperial government tried to convert the ethnic minorities to Christianity but Buddhism served as the stronghold of native identity for Mongols. So, I'm glad Tibetan missionaries reached us earlier than Christians

[@joyjoy-tc1zj]

实话 不如皈依基督教

[@PK-se2jh]

@@joyjoy-tc1zj 我们传统的佛教文化对我们有好处。

[@dreamadventure8220]

​@@joyjoy-tc1zjTBH buddhism as philosophical is very helpful for individuals life and society compared to Christianity, Islam , hinduism who ideologically based on to justify existance of God's .

[@vajraheart6052]

Exactly very good point. Long time ago most of the land conquered (3/4) by the great Mongol Khan rulers have now become Islamic and people converted including many Mongolians become Muslims. There is absolutely no trace of Mongolian in them as they became Islamic Eg Hazari and many others. However Tibetan Buddhism or Mongolian Buddhism is now very much part of Mongolian culture and identity.

[@sund4562]

Буддизм и вера кочевников на самом деле очень похожи

[@leonesea32]

Amazing!! I am a Tibetan. Really enjoyed learning more about my history and also what was happening on the other side (Mongol and Chinese...). I wanted to add 2 things. 1. The Golden Urn to decide the next Dalai Lama. How is that still in China. Because The Dalai Lama continued to this day. Current Dalai Lama being 14th in the lineage. Tibetan did use golden urn to find Dalai Lama. 2. Potala was not built entirely by the 5th Dalai Lama. Potala was originally built King Songtsen Gampo in ~7th Century. 5th Dalai Lama later added the red structures of Potala today. So White part is King Songtsen Gampo and red apart is done by 5th Dalai Lama.

[@thewanderingrey8830]

1. There are 2 Golden urns; one in Jokhang Temple, Lhasa - one in Yonghe Temple, Beijing. 13th Dalai Lama was exempted from the Golden Urn process (and was granted by the Qing government) and the 14th Dalai Lama did not use this process. 2. Songtsen Gampo's palace had already become a ruin by the time of the 5th Dalai Lama - that the Potala Palace was established on its grounds was true but it required an entirely new construction on site, which is why it takes a while to build it.

[@Upgraydez]

Would you happen to know why the surrendering Tibetan soldiers were sticking out their tongues when the were being captured? I assume the other soldiers were making them do it or it was a sign of surrender or something. I was just curious. Thx. 36:42

[@JonathanKumar-zp9fv]

@upgraydez all these small clips don’t represent the actual seen some of them clips are remdomly thrown in or nothing to with topic. In Tibetan Buddhist culture, Darma U Dum Tsen was said to be the incarnation of Gośīrṣa, the Ox-Head and Horse-Face guardian of hell, thus he got the nickname, Langdarma, literally, "Darma killer” Last king of Tibet Langdarma was said to have had "a black tongue", and a common gesture of Tibetans briefly sticking out their tongues is interpreted to show agreement, and as a sign of respect. When they demonstrate that they do not have black tongues, they show they are not guilty of evil deeds, and that they are not incarnations of the malevolent king.

[@Upgraydez]

@@JonathanKumar-zp9fv oh ok. That makes sense. Thanks for your help. I was kind of thinking it had a cultural significance, and that explains it perfectly to me.

[@ArvoSvensson]

原来是朗达玛……每个中国人都从历史课上学到了他灭佛未遂的故事，但不知道在后代的文化中有这样负面的形象@@JonathanKumar-zp9fv

[@tenzind4175]

To realize that mongols follows Buddhism (Tibetan Buddhism) so deeply but doesn't speak a word nor read Tibetan alphabetics although.. But the faith and devotion they had for First Dalai lama even to this present day Dalai Lama is unbelievable 🙏

[@mitakpa77]

Mongolian monks can read and write tibetan text.

[@siewbengwee4530]

The Entire documentary just explained that mongolians were so effectively tibetanised that they almost lost ability to speak Mongolian language. Didnt you watch properly?

[@JonathanKumar-zp9fv]

@siewbengwee4530 no mongols speak Tibetan as a way of their daily Communication. for example to practice islam they have to know Arabic correct? Does Indonesian, Malaysian Russian Muslims speak Arabic as a way of Communication or their mother tongue ? Tibetan Muslim pray and read Quran in Arabic but when communicate with Tibetan Muslim no Arabic straight tibetan the Mother tongue

[@GL7000-b5u]

@@JonathanKumar-zp9fv well said, I think only reason of this KZbin is Inner Mongolia and Tibet in part of China since ancient times which not true. Actually history really complicate.

[@JonathanKumar-zp9fv]

@@GL7000-b5u correct.. smh some these Tibetan don’t understand the agenda behind this. Trying to start a bs between Tibetan and mongols. Even if that’s the case but it wasn’t Tibetan who conquered their land it was other way around they conquered Tibet and their Khan probably forced mongols a Buddhist.. Buddhism was a blessing for the Mongolia and Mongolian people. When you look around today only Tibetan Buddhism brings them together and United from Buryatia, kalmykia , Southern Mongolia even Turkic origin Tuvas. On the other side the Mongol that accepted Islam have no connection with them today beside nomadic culture?

[@Ldy755]

Though I am not Tibetan Buddhist but because of my love for history n geography, I saw your vlog. Very interesting and well researched video 👏 👍

[@Jingwushow]

I love history and geography too! Thanks for watching!

[@asshai1377]

As a Chinese Mongolian, I really appreciate your work, and hope to know more about the history.

[@blu9371]

A true Yuan.

[@NgawangTashi-s3e]

What is chiness Mongolian.??is it different like mom is from China n dad from mongol???

[@alexhu5491]

​@@NgawangTashi-s3eChinese Mongolian ethnicity, 7.1 million Chinese ethnic Mongolians live in China, they represent 70% of the Mongolians in the world, China is a large country made up of 56 ethnic groups, this concept cannot happen to small countries like yours

[@SwetPotato]

​@@NgawangTashi-s3e Ethnic Mongolian with Chinese citizenship or in the other around

[@njszhzwlllllllllll]

​​@@NgawangTashi-s3eChinese=56 ethnic groups,mongolian is one of them

[@nyamgavaabayasgalan4603]

As a Mongolian watching this video, well done. Speechless.

[@Jingwushow]

Thanks, buddy! Glad you find it interesting!

[@arunhanglimbu]

Mongolian race people are also in Nepal known as KIRAT☀️🏹

[@whyamihere2250]

@@arunhanglimbu no bro they came from tibet

[@moomullermoothomas6336]

@@arunhanglimbu " mongoloid "is the race and 'mogolian' is an ethnicity within "Mongoloid ". So every "Mongoloid" are not Mongolian.

[@max-cs9ko]

You literally provided a documentary on youtube, really great work

[@Jingwushow]

Thanks, friend! Welcome back!

[@otgontamirnyamdavaa6315]

Astonishing high quality content. Thank you my fellow Mongolian

[@Jingwushow]

Glad you enjoyed it, friendo!! Cheers!

[@HeshigtenMongol]

I have never seen a Chinese who speaks like him! He paid so much effort, research and enthusiasm into his work. What he says is non-biased, so much on point. Hope someone could sponsor him and let him be a director to make more videos! Thank you for your effort!

[@Jingwushow]

Thank you, neighbor! That day will come! Cheers!

[@AbduvohidOdiljonov]

He is mongol, I think.

[@endeanfang2544]

In fact, Buddhism did not only exert a huge influence in Mongolia and Tibet. In the south, the struggle between Buddhist Cambodia/Thailand and Vietnam with Chinese culture has also become the keynote of the history of Indochina. Three hundred years ago, Saigon, the economic center of modern Vietnam, belonged to the Buddhists of the Lower Khmer. History is always so interesting that we can often find surprising similarities between different cultures, and your videos are the best medium! With fantastic talents, one day you will be able to have your own professional team and produce perfect documentaries! Thank you again for such a great video!

[@Jingwushow]

I will make a video on Buddhism in Indochina in the future! Thanks for sharing your thoughts with us!

[@mysmartieteevee3036]

@@Jingwushow Yes, please do....... great job by the way with this video. Thanks so much for the effort.....

[@bl5608]

Tibet Buddhism is different . They eat meat

[@laotailaodurres]

Before there was TIBETAN BHUDISM RELIGION ☯️☯️. THERE WAS -----. BONN RELIGION ☯️☯️ BONN.... BONN = WAS ANCIENT MONGOLIAN TIBETAN RELIGION ☯️ A SHAMANISTIC RELIGION ☯️ CALLED 🧬 BONN.... EVENTUALLY BONN RELIGION ☯️ WOULD EMERGE WITH BHINDU BHUDISM FROM BINDIA OR INDIA what ever you want to call 🤙 it AND BTIBETAN EMPIRE WAS BORN THAT LASTED FOR A GOOD 1200 YEARS.... WITH 14 DALAI LAMAS....

[@hordendawa6296]

Save Tibet 😢❤❤❤❤

[@ОляГаврилова-б8ф]

Wow very impressive video! We, buryats, i guess, never were really introduced to a well researched documentation of how did we started to follow buddism, how did all it stаrted deep in history. Btw we still name our children with Tibetan names. Thank you for your work!!

[@Nenet-rj9yr]

Actually buryads are turkic but the language is mongolian

[@Kuselo]

Not quite sure why this video doesn’t have much more views… even though it maybe oversimplified, you told the story of the Tibetanization of the Mongols so well, very well done. Also you sound so different when you speaking Mandarin… languages are so interesting 😅

[@Jingwushow]

Thanks for watching! Honestly, it is a bit too long for most viewers to click, and I am aware of that :(

[@SHGames97]

I want to again express my support & gratitude for your coverage! It is best to get any/every angle possible on such things & your track record has been incredible. This show deserves more recognition. Much love & appreciation from the United States Utah Oblast!

[@Jingwushow]

Thank you so much! Glad you enjoyed it!

[@ShadowbanTheHedgehog]

Utah oblast lol

[@s_MEd2]

Thank you for this film! I am a Buryat Mongolian from Russia. Unfortunately, we do not study our history or the history of the Mongols, so I know very little about it. Come and visit us at Baikal; we will be very happy to see you.

[@Jingwushow]

Glad you enjoyed it, mate! I've visited Baikal five years ago in 2019! Will definitely go there again!

[@Brandonhayhew]

@@Jingwushow спасибо

[@Nenet-rj9yr]

Baikal the word is turkic ..do you know all regions mountains Lakes rivers names are all turkic in siberia

[@rlznns]

What a compelling way of storytelling. I am Indonesian, and I wish that we have Indonesian youtuber talking about social, cultural, and ethnic matters the way you deliver it.

[@Jingwushow]

I will cover stories about Indonesia maybe early next year! Thanks for watching my show!

[@rlznns]

@@Jingwushow terrific!! Can't wait to see one.

[@thewanderingrey8830]

Boleh juga... makin mantab aja kalo bahas topik Indonesia hahahah

[@bobbyo3867]

@@Jingwushow how about the mysterious kingdoms of Champa? Nobody ever mentions it and it apparently lasted over a millennia and disappeared.

[@samuelboucher1454]

This was a seriously awesome deep-dive into Eastern history that could only be done by someone in the area. This is what makes KZbin and the Internet in general great.

[@kundankhalkho]

Love the way you tell us these stories. I am not Chinese, Mongol or Tibetan yet hooked on to your videos to listen to, as you narrate them wonderfully.

[@Jingwushow]

Haha, we are all children of the earth though! Thanks for watching my show!

[@TomMorrison-cc6xw]

This was a magnificent presentation! Not just the historical data, but your method of narrative -- you had me on the edge of my seat! I made the mistake of starting dinner before watching the video & had to turn the stove off so I could follow the story! Several times I said, "what happened next?" particularly right around the discussion of Kubli & his successors. Well done & DEFINITELY subscribing! Thanks.

[@sondhak]

Throughout our history, all the nations were fighting against each other for short-term benefits. We all are human beings. Interdependent, we must respect every language, culture, and cast. We have to live as one nation, with no boundaries. Like Europe 🇪🇺 I appreciate your job. Thanks bro

[@Jingwushow]

I can't agree more. Deep down, we are all the same. We laugh, love, and weep the same way across the globe.

[@UurdChuluutNegen]

Lol, the literal irony of your ignorance under the blog about Mongolia the country that created free trade zone with least tax level bigger than EU ever could.

[@robertgalloway3771]

Why is it that some want to take over other peoples countries, many eradicate culture, language and religion. New world order, they never sorted old world order!

[@MullahSteinberg]

I am also Chinese however I spent most of my life in the west Thank you for your effort You should be given a golden globe Extremely informative and entertaining documentaries you make Absolutely amazing Proud to be Chinese I am.humbled to be your audience

[@Jingwushow]

Maybe one day! Thanks for the kind words and support!

[@dreamadventure8220]

Are you proud of Tibet and in Mongolia Colonisation?

[@ZHLi-op4kc]

@@dreamadventure8220 No, it's called merger and assimilation. Mongolia, Tibet and China once jointly submitted to the rule of the Aisin Gioro royal family. China's merger of Tibet and Inner Mongolia cannot be said to be colonization, but a merger similar to the Austrian Habsburg Empire.

[@andaordos]

​@@ZHLi-op4kcWhat you said is very accurate!

[@andaordos]

​@@dreamadventure8220You shut up! You know nothing about the history of China! My ancestors were from Manchuria! They conquered everything!

[@aleksapejic7812]

Just watched the documentary and I LOVED IT, its explained so well, that anyone could understand. The quality, imagery, representation of history is done so well!!! I loved the documentary, much love and support from Serbia

[@Jingwushow]

Welcome, friend! Glad you enjoyed it and thanks for watching my show.

[@LC-bt1kt]

It was great to have met you in the guesthouse in Kharkhorin, Mongolia. Thanks for presenting such history to us.

[@Jingwushow]

Hey, Loretta!! Pleasure is all mine! Glad you enjoyed it!

[@drzlb]

There’s no historical content done so well on the internet, with such depth, such passion, such animation! Really enjoyed it! Incredible, Incredible Content! Keep up the good work!

[@odieagle3145]

thanks Jing Wu … you’re awesome!

[@migspeculates]

a video about the relationship between Srivijaya Empire, the Pala Dynasty and Tibetan Buddhism would be interesting. Maybe another offshoot for how Tantric Buddhism resched the Southern Philippines would also be speculative topic for the next. There was a discovered Golden Tara artifact back in the 1980s suspected to be an earlier Buddhist influence to the country.

[@Jingwushow]

Good idea. I will think about it. Thanks.

[@Albion80s]

Extremely well researched and presented to connect these relatively unknown regions in religions, culture and politics.

[@中国那些事儿-t3f]

其实就和基督教进入西方一个道理。就是在古代的时候，他这个蒙古地区，因为是游牧民族为主，他就比较分散，然后就导致他部落之间就有很多战争，就像欧洲小国林立，就天天打仗，那老百姓水深火热，他就需要一个东西，要把它这个人给整合起来，而且这个东西不能太难啊。 那这个藏传佛教你只要对吧打坐，然后忍受你的身体上的痛苦，相信有来世，那个天主教不也类似吗？你得相信你做好事能上天堂啊，或者你总有一天能上天堂，然后就能忍很多常人所不能忍的事，这就让那个战争某种程度上缓解了，但是缺点就是阶级固化了。

[@中国那些事儿-t3f]

其实蒙古这个主要就是藏传佛教，还有那个伊斯兰教，主要原因都是因为统治阶级方便治理人民搞出来的，当然你也可以说，他为了维持这个稳定的社会搞出来的。因为游牧民族加上在苦寒地区有他的特殊性啊。

[@中国那些事儿-t3f]

吐蕃原来也很强大呀，就是现在的西藏，但是后来不也搞藏传佛教吗？ 原因就是因为这个东西很容易用来愚民，你可以说他是对那个物质需求没那么大，加上他那套理论，可以避免人类争斗，当然吃亏的，就是那个底层人啊。 其实主要原因还是就是哪怕，游牧民族占领了中原地带，但是中原的人实在太多了，他如果做得太过分，甚至如果不被同化，要知道在中国古代当皇帝可不是个多么轻松的事，你如果不被同化，就会遇到很大的反抗，你就像日本侵华当年的武器装备是比中国好太多了，最后还是被中国赶出去了，就是这个原因，还有那个蒙古也是差不多的，搞了不到90年，就被赶出去了，因为你必须要被同化，而不是想办法去同化汉人。 但是你如果被同化，统治阶级就没那么舒服了，中国自古以来是由造反的这个传统的，你统治阶级要对自己有很高的要求，否则的话大概率结果是不会那么好的，那这个蒙古的统治阶级肯定不愿意呀，哪有搞个宗教愚民爽吗？我生生世世可以骑在那个底层人的头上。 但是中国汉人有太强的民族性，满族只是想剃个头，都遇到那么大的反抗，你就比如现在你说剃胡子，我估计放在古代都会遇到很大的反抗，所以你只能被同化，而不是你同化别人。 毛泽东一生最大的黑点不就是文化大革命吗？ 就是他想用这个文化大革命，实现新中国的梦想，但事实证明他失败了，你不能够用一个舶来品，什么马克思主义强制性的同化中国人，这个是绝对会失败的，这个马克思主义他只能被中国化，他不能够同化中国人。 像资本主义也是一样的，中国改革开放之后不是走了很长的市场道路吗？我们最后还是发现有很多问题，最后发现还是要回到老路。

[@Albion80s]

@@中国那些事儿-t3f I am an overseas ethnic Chinese (4th generation) and know little on Chinese history and hence I find this channel informative and intriguing and trying to absorb as much as I can. It always fascinates me how tiny nomadic tribes can rule over a population multiple their size and hold power for such a long time. There must be certain mechanism they possess to threaten the conquered land into submission. Both the Mongols and Manchus had conquered China for a long time. This is unlike the European powers that possess superior firearms and cannons even though their invading force were tiny too, hence they were able to colonise the world for centuries. Today, it is a different story. Even the US could not hold down Iraq and Afghanistan for too long due to strong resistance. Perhaps modern communication technology plays a role in organising rebels which people of the 18th and 19th century did not have, save for the ingenuity of secret messages buried in mooncakes used to depose the Mongols. In response to your comment on capitalism, I would like to recommend you to read up on the work of Professor Michael Hudson. He has been lecturing at a university in Beijing, Wuhan and Hong Kong and has written a great book call "Super Imperialism" which has been translated into Chinese. In it, he differentiates between Industrial Capitalism and Financial Capitalism. The former refers to businesses making profits through producing goods and services while the later refers to speculative activities making what he calls "unearned profits" and creates a "rentier class" that is bad for any economy. I believe his book has caught the attention of policy makers in Beijing which has led to the recent drastic measures in clamping down on property developers and some internet platform activities. On the Great Leap Forward and Cultural Revolution, there are reasons behind and it is beyond the scope of this discussion to get into such complex issues. I agree with you totally that it has left a black mark on Chairman Mao but it was good intention that went horribly wrong.

[@OtKerk]

Your analyses are good! Amjilt husye!

[@akibh3022]

The amount of love and effort you've put in, both in research and in production, shows. I hope you make it big. You deserve it. Love from Bangladesh.

[@Jingwushow]

Thanks! This one took me forever to make. :)

[@amoebayearnsalot]

This was a wonderful, in-depth exploration of this topic. Loved your analysis!

[@Jingwushow]

Glad it was helpful!

[@maryyc-v4m]

Such a fascinating and captivating history lesson. Thanks Jingwu, you are inspiring!

[@Jingwushow]

lol, you are binge watching my shows lately.

[@maryyc-v4m]

@@Jingwushow ahahahaha yep😁

[@ihoulyu8457]

great works, without any political claim, just present the true (or infinitely approaching the true) history. learned a lot

[@Jingwushow]

Glad my work could be of use!! Thanks!

[@littlechineseeverywhere]

I am already looking forward to your new episodes

[@birudo]

Such a good video, thanks.

[@Jingwushow]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@지영현-e5t]

Watching from Korea. Wishing your future production endeavors much success, neighbor.

[@Jingwushow]

Thanks neighbor for the support and kind words!! The next video is about the Korean Chinese in Yanbian.

[@지영현-e5t]

@@Jingwushow Look forward to it! More Korean-Chinese in S. Korea than Dongbei nowadays - come film sometimes!

[@Jingwushow]

Will do, mate!

[@cynomaca]

最近看过最用心制作的视频，一定花费了很多心血，简直是专业纪录片的水平！字幕表里的语言之多也把我吓到，作者一定是个多语言的天才😂 刚把视频推荐给了同在瑞典的越南朋友，因为她说感觉这边的蒙古人无处不在，所以对蒙古的历史也很感兴趣。感谢你的视频！👍

[@Jingwushow]

哈哈，谢谢朋友！我是个语言爱好者，会那么几门，但不多哈~感谢你的分享和喜爱！

[@thunkwaltz5571]

Learned a lot from you regarding East Asian history. Was broadly aware of Chinese and Japanese history but Tibetan, Mongolian and Korean histories are also very fascinating and played a big role in forming present China.

[@hdvoice]

Wow, this got me to subscribe instantaneously! Thanks for the work without geopolitical bias! As a Chinese myself, I admire your effort in informing the world with highest quality documentary backed by systematic research. Keep this coming please….. 🎉

[@Jingwushow]

You bet! Hundreds of them are coming, haha. I'm glad you enjoyed my work! I strive to tell better stories for the world.

[@jackz7690]

I live in a coastal province of China, on the one hand, topic like this are very interesting for me, on the other hand, I can barely gather information about this type of topic other than reading books or anything other than literal materials. So I really admire your work of filming videos that is more realistic.

[@Jingwushow]

Glad you enjoyed it! More is coming.

[@seanrowshandel1680]

Northern India's iron grip on this entire half of the world (through Buddhism, a sect of the controversial Hindu "religion" AND STATE) is the most humiliating thing to ever occur at a PREVIOUS point in time to any people ever. It is very strange to say this to you people on KZbin, but to be honest, I'm grateful for anything that Europe/Europeans/Russians have done in order to intimidate/weaken these "Tibetans" and their Northern Indian commanders. It has been SO DIFFICULT to clean the Middle East (the cleanup was a failure), and Muslims certainly aren't going to do a DAMNED thing to rebel against their Northern Indian "counterparts" (they barely differ at all). They perpetuated UNIMAGINABLE atrocities against the expansion of the respectable "East Asian" families which traversed Asia as pioneers of not only the environment, but also of Man[kind]: they undoubtedly progressed the development of both "Nature" and "Nurture" THROUGH having a government based on accountability (the "center of gravity" of which was a court which Actually relied on Evidence in order to convict criminals -- embarrassingly, this was a new concept to peoples like mine at that time), literacy (of officials), and appropriate dialogues. Civilizedness and manners were "imported" from them, to say the least (we are still indebted because of their valiant/noble/fruitful efforts to bring everyone to the same page as Koreans -- whether or not that means we will still remain far "behind" the "Chinese". The area of the world known as "The 'Stans" was a place where many hundreds of thousands of them, as migrants, were massacred during their retreat (which occurred over centuries). The cities in that region are still mostly located on passes through mountain ranges (this was not for the purpose of collecting taxes/tariffs/etc on internationally shipped commodities: this was for killing migrants and then collecting bounties. I would imagine Native Americans to have collected similar bounties in exchange for the scalps of African-Americans, Europeans, and Whoever Else There Were Bounties On)

[@seanrowshandel1680]

Ok thanks don't talk to me like this in public (are you serious? they can definitely dig it up and read it: the "Muggles"). Are you filing the adoption papers yet? Don't give up on such an opportunity. OR ELSE, SEE! [after having forgotten the exact sequence of words I intended to write, I resorted to an abrupt attempt at comedy. Never Let It Happen Again, SEE? I'm turning into a pecularly-sized bird, SEE? Do we need the next political cartoonist to add color to his work and call himself a Zeus/Seuss for you to get the point? I will be done joking with you by then, see?]@@zhouzhou-k2k

[@prasanth2601]

​@@seanrowshandel1680wth dude

[@michaelz9]

@@seanrowshandel1680 I don't agree with you but you are one of the nicer Indians I've seen. "India's iron grip on this entire half of the world" It probably applies to subcontinent but I think all east asian counties consider the buddhism a beautiful gift. The religion is hard to escape for the lives of the mass grass roots in ancient times since it captures the human nature (or weakness). The buddhism is happen to be very compatible with the ancient Chinese society especially as a complement of the Taoism which lacks the serious religious characteristics compare to others. Of course the buddhism of China is different from the OG buddhism and Tibetan buddhism, it was modified and also assimilated into Taoism.

[@terranablett6208]

thanks for covering so much ground you've answered so many queries i have had about the two cultural spheres, cheers. from West Australia.

[@Jingwushow]

My pleasure! Thanks for watching!

[@Yogoat837]

Hi from Kalmykia. Thanks for your effort. Every time I watch about crushing Dzungars and Outer Mongolia by Qing dynasty, I wonder how Mongols were divided at that time. Only if they were united, dzunagars would’ve survived and inner and Outer Mongolia had not been occupied, as well as Tibet.

[@thewanderingrey8830]

Oversimplification. The nature of nomadic empire made it so that personal power is intertwined with political powers - when you have a weak successor, all pretenders have the right to contest the throne - and it was thus that Mongols will spend most of their time fighting each other rather than united. The state being the ultimate authority and thus one must sacrifice his personal powers for the benefit of the state is an alien concept to nomadic powers like Mongols (not so to the Chinese however with its confucian and legalist concepts)

[@boanzhou-tj8tm]

你们的祖先回中国没有能力把你们带回中国😢😢😢，

[@boanzhou-tj8tm]

你们祖先是卫拉特蒙古之一的土尔扈特，你们部落被准格尔部落欺负你们就迁移到伏尔加河流域生活，后来沙俄强大上你们的男子出人打仗死的很多，所以你们祖先就想带你们回新疆，因为他了解到准格尔部落被清朝屠杀了😮😮😮😮

[@vythai479]

always looking forward to watching your documentaries!

[@Leon-in5qh]

This is a great video! Thank you for your effort and input. Much appreciated.

[@teamjupeter9451]

As a Korean, glad to understand various historical events arisen among our relatives; Manchus, Mongolians and Tibetans.

[@Jingwushow]

Glad you enjoyed it, neighbor! My next project is on the Korean Chinese.

[@chinlancelot3709]

how come Tibetans are ur relatives?

[@BieZhang]

Just asking, do south koreans consider americans as their relatives as well?

[@yazi-ir2dg]

Linguistically Tibetan, Myanmar and Chinese are in the same language family.

[@cocaineminor4420]

​@@BieZhangthis girl is probably not south Korean Koreans usually don't speak English

[@AamalaStore-rv5xk]

As a Tibetan family I found your blog made us really interesting to know all the history which is my favorite subject too. Thank you for all the knowledge.May peace reveal around the world. Once again thank you all the team 💐🙏🫡

[@Jingwushow]

You are welcome, friend! The pleasure is all mine.

[@GL7000-b5u]

@@AamalaStore-rv5xk if you are really Tibetan you should know what really he is trying to do here. He is trying to claim Tibet as part of China since ancient time as CCP claims.

[@WaMo721]

@@GL7000-b5u kukpa labu-jinpa ,kha tsum

[@GL7000-b5u]

@@WaMo721 really talks like Wamo.

[@GL7000-b5u]

@@WaMo721 མི་རིགས་ཤ་ཞན་མེད་པའི་ཝ་མོ་།། ལུ་རྒྱུད་ལ་ཁྱོག་ཤེད་བྱེད་པའི་ཝ་མོ་།།

[@seitch1]

Thank you for such a thorough summary of the relationship between Tibetan Buddhism and Mongolia. It's a complicated subject but your video explained it very well. I've subscribed.

[@Loushe7788]

As a Han Chinese, i am really into Mongolian culture since a very young age. And I reckon i was a Mongolian last lifetime. Everytime I went to Inner Mongolia I felt the sense of familiarity and warmth. Your music, language and even your faces give me great peace. Sincerely hope you can retrieve your original culture...

[@Tibetan-experience]

Free Tibet

[@Garren-kx2jg]

dont mind the hate comments here bro, im happy you can feel well about unique cultures outside!

[@躺匪]

说的跟真的一样，那也是在你们民族灭亡之后~@@premchopra6521

[@tariksmall9790]

I am from Jamaica and a lover of History first and geopolitics second then kung fu movies and i have been a huge fan of the Chinese costume dramas that depict the different dynasties. Always wondered what became of the mongols and this cleared it up big time. Well done ✔️ .

[@Jingwushow]

Haha, welcome! I'm not a big fan of costume dramas though, lol. Thanks for watching!

[@TammyMullins-tp5uf]

Thanks for the education on Tibetan people I've been so interesting in the Tibetan people

[@RickGrimes_ton]

This video helped shed some light for me on the great curiosity I had about the fate of the Mongols, why did they fade from the modern era after having conquered the largest area in the world ever? Thank you for your amazing effort compiling this. There's very little known about the historical connections between the Central, Southern, and Eastern Asian regions(specifically the interactions between Tibetans, Mongolians, Nepalese, Chinese, etc., and the connections between the peoples of Tibeto-Burman language family). I haven't had the chance to learn about all the history of Buddhism and Hinduism but wanted to ask if you would ever consider making videos on one of the oldest forms of Buddhism(Newar Buddhism), which also has many connections with Tibetan Buddhists who actually first learned of Buddhism in the 7th century through their exchanges with the earlier Buddhist disciples from India and the Newars. (There's also a clan inside the Newar Buddhist community called the Shakya. I could totally be wrong about this but I've always wondered if they are related to or are the real life descendants of the kingdom from which the actual Shakyamuni Buddha was from! There is a Shakya kingdom shown in ancient Indian maps located in the general region where Buddha was found to be from and I've heard a story speculating that the Shakyas migrated into Kathmandu from this region but there's not much studies done on this topic). I myself am agnostic and don't observe any religion but have always found this history to be so fascinating, as something that everyone who admires Buddhism struggles with is how to incorporate this wonderful belief system into their lives in a way that is flexible to our modern lives. After all, we cannot all be monks or nuns and renounce worldly matters. So in the way of this topic it surprises me how *little* is known about the Newar Buddhism of Nepal. It would be fascinating for all history geeks if you made videos exploring the Newars and their take on the wisdoms of Buddha that I think fits more into the modern lives for the vast majority of us. By the way a fun fact: Remember you visited that giant white stupa in Miaoying temple of Beijing that you said a Nepalese artist Araniko built for the Yuan dynasty? Well that Araniko was initially sent by the Newar King Jayabhimdeva Malla to Tibet with the 5th leader of Sakya sect of Tibetan Buddhism Chogyal Phagpa to construct a golden stupa, initiated into monkhood there, was then sent on to work and teach in the court of emperor Kublai Khan(while Phagpa became the 1st imperial preceptor of Yuan dynasty) and led teams of artists and craftsmen to build several Pagoda structures in both China and Tibet. Pagoda structures were already taken to China from Kathmandu as early as the 7th century, which I suspect was the first cultural exchange in Asian history that transferred the pagoda architecture to East Asia from Nepal. It gets more interesting, the artist Araniko was Newar himself. Newars have been known as the greatest artisans and architects in all of the Himalayan societies, with Kathmandu compared to the creations of Italy and Persia and Newar cities termed as "Florence of the East". The artistic excellence of Newars was so greatly coveted that they were requested to bring their talents into their dynasties by Chinese emperors, Mongolian emperors, as well as Bhutanese Zhabdrungs, and the leaders of Tibetan Buddhism, thereby teaching their craft to the Bhutanese population unfamiliar with gold smith work and bronze work, and Chinese artisans. They left a lasting influence in the culture of Tibet, Mongolia, Bhutan, and China (and subsequently the far east in Japan and Korea where pagoda structures became prominent after China. Amongst the Newars there has been historically two major religions, Hinduism and Buddhism. It is also popularly known that in Nepal these two religions coexist alongside each other and even has incorporated elements from both that has long been practiced by Newars. I really see this mindset of syncretism as the way of the future. Learning from various beliefs and adding on to what we already know, which is also done by many dharmic faiths such as the biggest one of course Hinduism. The Buddhists of Newar ethnicity do not become monks or nuns but incorporate the various knowledge of the Buddha while simultaneously living a life more in equilibrium with modern times. The syncretic history of Newars includes traditions such as reincarnation culture similar to Tibetans and as you've taught us, of Mongolians for a while. But the reincarnation tradition in Newar culture was started as both a Buddhist and Hindu practice and is understood to symbolize the coexistence of both religions, (the Newar reincarnation tradition had received negative attention from western journalists in the early 2000s as the most popular of the avatars (there are multiple) is female and the specific myth of the goddess associated with the Royal Kumari Avatar requires their caretakers to ensure they do not bleed before natural menstruation, which explains why the Royal Kumari is not supposed to be walking outside the royal palace due to many dangers that may inflict wounds. However she does walk outside on carpets laid by her caretakers during festivals and has been playing inside the royal house with friends and family regularly). The Sino phobic elements in the west eagerly propped up the Tibetan issue for political gain and did not make any noise about the reincarnation and monkhood traditions of Tibetan Buddhism that traps the monk child/selected Dalai lama for life, but they were very noisy about the Kumari tradition where the Avatars only reign up until a certain age(with ritual duties as required during important days and festivals but also have access to education and enrichment) and resume a regular life with careers if they choose after their reign. It is another fascinating exchange of political ambitions between not only Tibet, Nepal, China, and Mongolia but now the West in its attempts to put itself in the forefront of the new world order. Religion and by its medium, culture and art, and the exoticism or denial of it is all determined by the political order that is current in any given time period and it's just so fascinating to see how different cultures and peoples interact with each other. Thanks for this video again!

[@Jingwushow]

One of the greatest joys of making historical videos is finding this kind of golden information from my viewers. Thank you, thank you, and thank you for sharing such in-depth information with me and all of us. I am in awe. I didn't know Araniko was a Newar. I promise to dedicate my time to researching this topic in the future. However, at the moment, I'm focused on producing content about the story of Korean Chinese, which I'm confident will also be captivating. So please stay tuned for that. I wanted to express my appreciation for your informative comment and for supporting my show. Thank you very much.

[@RickGrimes_ton]

@@Jingwushow It's the little details connecting wider historical events that really put things in perspective isn't it. Looking forward to your videos!

[@princezuko6804]

Interesting! As an Indian all this information is very fascinating.

[@angrymaniac53]

​@@Jingwushow arniko is indeed a newar and from what I have heard he is locally called "bala bau" which I think means "good boy" in Newari(not sure since I'm not that good in Newari but he is indeed used to be called something like bala bau). So yeah Arniko is not the original name but rather a name which he got in Tibet/China.

[@zogway]

I am from Ladakh(extension of the Tibetan plateau) which is now in India well to simply put it throughout the course of the video it seemed as if I was watching videos of ladakh through different lenses same people same clothes same culture seperated by vast distances and nationalities I think we still share the same spirit and yes after Buddhism was virtually eradicated from Mongolia it was fortold that arhat bakula Rinpoche would revived Buddhism in Mongolia , he was born in Ladakh this prophecy became a legend when the communist were destroying the monasteries and killing the monks well the prophecy did manifest itself when 20th bakula Rinpoche was India's ambassador to Mongolia and helped revive the religion

[@Jingwushow]

Thanks for the comment and sharing your thoughts with us. I’ve been to the Ladakh borderlands two years ago. And yeah, I have read about him. :D

[@中国那些事儿-t3f]

佛教在这个世界，最后只能够成为一种精神安慰，因为佛教本身是一种避世的理论，他并不追求改造现实世界，这就导致一个问题，中国有个老话，叫落后就要挨打，国际政治的现实也证明了这一点。 那佛教是不利于发展生产力的，顶多是把它当成一种文化或者艺术去看待，否则只要你生活在这个物质世界，那你搞佛教，或者以佛教治国，你最好希望你那个国家没有什么能源资源风景，否则的话，结果大概率是会很悲剧的。 这个世界从来不和平。

[@zogway]

@@中国那些事儿-t3f Einstein believed that Buddhism was the only religion capable enough to serve the morden scientific World so he'd certainly disagree with you Buddhism is in all senses is a atheistic religion no one's greater ,lower than us or equal but rather different and in that difference there must be acceptance likewise there is no creator or the created but rather self creation in many of it's texts one can find scientific relevance wether it be quantum physics explaining dual nature of matter or the religion also expands on the existence of extraterrestrial beings but getting back to your point yea Buddhism embraces the idea of a eutopia of peace without suffering of the human beings you choose to believe that the basic nature of human beings is violence that is by all means your choice even so there have been many instances where Buddhist kings and generals made their mark on history Buddhist nations on contrary performed better than others in many instances

[@i_love_tibet7001]

@@中国那些事儿-t3f I think you got the wrong view about Buddhism ...... look for Bhutan and Thailand as a great example.

[@中国那些事儿-t3f]

@@i_love_tibet7001 谁跟你说不丹和泰国很幸福？泰国男的当人妖，女的当妓女，很幸福吗？你在逗我吗？ 我就不说泰国能有今天这个独立的地位，是因为中国在旁边，否则的话，我说实在的，就是越南都能够把泰国给收拾了。 但是越南老怕中国呀，虽然我们中国对越南从来不感兴趣。 你就说中国当年得罪谁了，什么是闭关锁国，就是自己发展自己，孤立主义，但是为什么有那么多国家侵略中国？ 中国主动去侵略那些国家了吗？ 还有叙利亚得罪美国了吗？ 不就是因为叙利亚有石油吗？所以美国在那边驻军。 这个才是现实。很多小国家根本都没这个意识，其他国家之所以不去打你，要么是因为，你在某个大国的附近，然后某个大国利用你来牵制另一个大国，或者你旁边有某个大国，很多小国，他只能够团结起来，来让自己有一定的自保能力。 但我说实在的东南亚国家，对中国防范心太重了，因为你东南亚国家那么多人，我们中国对你东南亚，真的没那么感兴趣，我们也不是像美国那么残暴的国家，动不动就搞种族灭绝，我们也干不出这种反人类的事，甚至是反动物的事，动物都做不出来这种事。 中国对东南亚不感兴趣，就是因为东南亚人太多了。 但是南海是我国的国土，是二战之后中国的战利品，这个是事实啊，有些东南亚国家无视这个二战后的事实，一味地侵犯我国领土，我觉得如果因为这个产生战争，还是有可能的，但是中国不会对统治东南亚有任何兴趣，因为成本太高。

[@-robertri6093]

Masterpiece, very hardworking for the audience. Thanks a lot. ❤

[@Jingwushow]

Haha, that's true! I toiled endlessly for my viewers!

[@-robertri6093]

@@Jingwushow long enough for enough emotional being. 😄 感謝你的做

[@LP18888]

My direct ancestor Galdan Khan also studied many years in Tibet. Thanks for another great video.

[@少康战情妇]

噶尔丹这个狗汉奸居然学习今天的台湾拒绝与中国统一。清圣祖仁皇帝，小指一挥，噶尔丹瞬间灰飞烟灭。

[@Khamtruk-7]

Thank you for sharing such great documentaries and fascinating events in Mongolia and Tibetan history. I found very interesting things in your vlog. Can make a video for Tibetan empire in 7 an 8 century?

[@Jingwushow]

Hey, thanks for watching!! Maybe haha. I have too many projects ongoing at the moment. 🤝

[@chriswang955]

You rock!, young man👏👍First time to see a documentary that goes so deep in finding the religious and political relationship between Tibetan and Mongol and Rulers. 蒙古人從軍事上征服了藏地，藏族人從精神上征服了蒙疆。本人在青海長大，如今已從事了四十年旅遊，其中最早的十多年是在青藏高原工作。把蒙古與西藏的政治、宗教、地理、歷史人物等諸多關係梳理出線條，一一道來，你是第一人。謝謝🤛👏🤝

[@chriswang955]

This documentary could be a academic thesis of Mongolian and Tibetan Study. Love to watch it.

[@Jingwushow]

哈哈，谢谢前辈的鼓励和喜爱！我继续努力！谢谢！

[@ybdeng7736]

塔尔寺？

[@中国那些事儿-t3f]

站在统治阶级的角度，你就理解为何选择藏传佛教了。 我问你，在中国当皇帝爽，还是在西藏的那个喇嘛爽？ 你可以看看古代那些不昏庸的皇帝，他们的那个工作，那是真的苦到姥姥家，我只能这么说。 所以明朝有个大昏君，万历皇帝。 我是真的发现，就我们这些地区的人吧，就是黄河流域啊，黄河流域的，包括什么陕西，安徽，河南，还有江苏徐州等地，就是对这个政治敏感度非常高。 有时候也确实因为太敏感了，就是导致不擅长发展商业，或者说大多数人吧，因为知道你这个商业发展到一定的高度，可能就会倒大霉。 小富即安。

[@chriswang955]

塔尔寺藏语叫贡本贤八林，英文Kumbum，因先有塔而后有寺，汉人称其塔尔寺。属藏区黄教五大寺院@@ybdeng7736

[@tamasbalogh7535]

I am a Hungarian and I am very grateful to the author for this excellent video about the very close relation among Tibetan, Mongolian, Manchu and Han Chinese peoples. All these historical events and Buddhism are not so clearly taught in our European schools so a lot of facts were surpising and unknown for me. Contrary to the fact that the Mongolians attacked our country - Hungary - in 1240-1241 now I can understand better why it happened and which reasons led to this attack. One of my fellow citizen, Körösi Csoma Sandor made the first Tibetan-English dictionary and he was much interested in Tibetan language and culture in the 19th century..

[@cocaineminor4420]

Clearly they weren't close I mean Mongols killed alot of Chinese Manchu too

[@DwightMeline]

没有什么特别的原因，蒙古帝国就是以战养战的典型。当时蒙古攻击西藏时也是惨无人道的。他们到了一个城池开始屠杀，立威。然后其他人希望通过谈判达到不死人，然后向蒙古人提供金银财宝，然后颁布一系列政策用来稳固统治。中国的历史书有详细的记载，在中国的网络平台都可以查到。

[@17leprichaun]

Impressive documentation!!! Thank you and greetings from switzerland

[@Jingwushow]

Thanks for watching! And welcome!

[@Alonoda]

That was a fascinating story of spirituality, religion, wars and politics that was completely new to me as a westener seeking to learn what I can about China, Tibet, Buddhism and everything in between. I live in Jerusalem which was and still is a center for neverending religious turmoil and conquests. I grew up to believe this is a core part of monotheism, but with time I've learnt how far this story about human nature goes. Hoping to learn more on these topics on your channel, that was an excellent film and production! Blessings :)

[@choenyi67]

As a Tibetan from nomadic family I strongly believe we Tibetans and Mongolians are brothers and sisters

[@coreypenjor4910]

I am from Bhutan and I feel like Tibetans and Mongolian are all our brothers 🎉🤝🤝🤝

[@tantrichill192]

I am a Mongoloid race from Nepal also. There are many tribes in Nepal who contains Mongoloid and Tibeto burmese genes. The Buddhist scriptures we have here in Nepal are the same scriptures used by Tibetans. From A to Z they are all same ..No fabrication but the truth

[@choenyi67]

@@coreypenjor4910 yessir 🙏🏼

[@sonamlonden7574]

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@conanmoody2032]

True, you both have a lot of blood on your hands and a violent past

[@tenzin8260]

Very well researched content on the history of Tibet and Mongolia,

[@Jingwushow]

Glad you liked it!!

[@asullivan4047]

Interesting/informative/entertaining. Excellent photography job/pictures/maps. Enabling viewers to better understand what/whom the orator was describing. Making the documentary more authentic and possible.🙏

[@Yam_ze]

When I listen to you I don't hear race, nationality or propaganda but just a pure History of My land ( Tibet) and Mongolian brothers. Thank You.

[@Jingwushow]

Thank you for your understanding. I’m very glad to see comments like this. Thanks, friend.

[@MsKittensoldier]

❤

[@MsKittensoldier]

@@JingwushowHe/She just gave you the biggest compliment. Hello from Norway

[@thewanderingrey8830]

9.30pm after watching -Lhakar Sang- "Uniform Day" Tibetan dances LIVE from Chengdu, I realized my favorite Mongol youtuber have uploaded and the topic is How intertwined the Mongols and Tibetans are. Great job! Now watching this with a beer on hand so the documentary becomes more profound while watching it on Wednesday (if you're a Tibetan Buddhist, you know you know ) By the way - 15:40 do you think the Tanguts were a subset of the Tibetans?

[@Jingwushow]

Thanks for stopping by, buddy! Always good to see a familiar face.

[@thewanderingrey8830]

@@Jingwushow thank you for another great documentary! I really enjoyed it... PS: You have yet to initiate the "Super Thanks" feature in your channel? Then fans maybe can contribute a little...

[@Jingwushow]

Thanks man! I will get it sorted.

[@Jingwushow]

I’m not sure. Mongols pretty much killed them all (for causing the death of Chinggis). The Tanguts were Tibetanized too though.

[@tibchox]

It’s great that u did very good research and at the same time visiting the historical places. I m glad that I somehow shows Tibet as a nation separate from china, while CCP claims Tibet was part of China since early Qing or Ming dynasty. I m really tired of how CCP gives false narrative about Tibet. At your last remark i felt as if we were into thinking that Dalia lama’s last year headline regarding showing tongue to Indian boy somehow made you think he is doing with the bad intention. I want to clear this out, Dalai Lama likes to poke or tease people of every political, social or religious status. That time it was during an event at his temple. They were so many audience were present there and he lovingly tease that boy after the Dalai Lama’s answering the boys question. Dalai Lama in a playful way ask the boy “suck my tongue”. It was shared few months after the incidents and it’s shared by a Chinese KZbin account holder with no picture or any other video Defaming or demonizing the Dalai Lama is CCP’s no 1 policy . It’s publicize to mislead and it’s easy to mislead since the video is showing just that incident but not the starting and ending of the video where the boy’s parents were the guest and how they felt blessed and fun. This is what happened. Now I will tell you why Dalai Lama has no intention to abuse or benefit. 1 tongue in Tibetan culture is not sexualize as western or modern world. In Lhasa and around we greet with tongue out while smiling and moving hand gesture. Still this gesture exist in older people. 2 as a Tibetan we have custom of chewing dried yak cheese and feeding children with mouth to mouth like many other Himalayan communities , when child as for more food or beg the dried chewy chess from your mouth and then either food is all eaten or no dried cheese in your mouth we show the child ones tongue and say “wanna eat the tongue.?.” meaning I got nothing to give except the tongue in my mouth. In short the Dalai Lama felt very fascinated by this Indian boy asking question with pride made him felt very close like him being his grandparents. In short I want to emphasize that they were few cases to lamas who sexually abuse people , but the headline regarding the Dalai Lama and the Indian boy is completely orchestrated backed by CCP to defame Dalai Lama and destabilize the faith of the people towards him and to disturb the Tibetan struggle to regain the freedom with the genuine autonomy.

[@Rickristian]

Thank you greatly for educating me on these wonderful historical documentaries about mongolia. You should be top nominee for youtube oscar in academic history category and a $1M award.

[@WaMo721]

And a lifetime free access to chipotle

[@brianperkins4155]

A well made documentary on Tibet and Mongolia from a Chinese perspective

[@Jingwushow]

Thanks, hope it was helpful!

[@ronnytang]

非常用心的一部纪录片，历史串联了起来，感谢！

[@Jingwushow]

朋友有收获就好，我就没白忙活！

[@AvidanTheExpositor]

top notch enlightening video on the history of tibet and mongolia. thanks!

[@johannbaratin7770]

I'm french and I went to China a long time ago. But near Beijin, I went to Cheng De, or something like that. There was un little Potala and a Summer Palace. Very beautiful. Now I'm understand the meaning. Thanks a lot.

[@Jingwushow]

Glad you made it to the little Potala! Not many people know about it these days. 🤝

[@Sj-md4xq]

终于更新啦🎉

[@Jingwushow]

哈哈，是的！终于把字幕整理好了～

[@sanhtay1350]

This is a very impressive piece of work. I watched the entire video without pausing once. Thank you for sharing such an invaluable video.

[@lohguowei7559]

nice explanation!!! keep it up!!!!

[@IRM-cm2ic]

It is only scratching the surface of the history iceberg. The untold story is many times greater than revealed in this video.

[@Jingwushow]

True! I cut at least 2/3 of the script to make it more accessible for viewers. I also had many “long story short” in the video. There are several Tibetan Regents and Mongol Khans I wish I had more time to discuss. Maybe in a different video. :)

[@bertbarnhoorn]

Great:I did never know anything of it. So you did very wel to make and publish this video! Thanks.

[@moogiibat5845]

This is such a great premise for Assassin creed game. A Yellow Monks are the Templars, and the assassins are trying to get rid of them but failing.

[@isokiller2346]

😂😂

[@kingmadboyka]

Good job brother I’m a Tibetan frm India my parent are from shigatse, didn’t know about these detail. Thanks for giving me wonderful knowledge. Much love n respect #freetibet ❤

[@TibetofChina-ut5wo]

我是中国青海，正宗的青藏高原的藏人，你跑印度干什么？

[@kingmadboyka]

@@TibetofChina-ut5wo ?? No Chinese only Tibetan or English

[@TibetofChina-ut5wo]

@@kingmadboyka We Tibetans have lived on the Tibetan Plateau in China for generations, and you go to India and say that you are Tibetan? Look at how many Tibetans there are in China. Look at how many fake Tibetans you have and Indians who are living with a completely different race from us.

[@TibetofChina-ut5wo]

@@kingmadboyka We Tibetans have specialized schools for learning the Tibetan language and script. We live in the regions of China's Qinghai and Tibet, which have been inhabited by our ancestors for generations. How about you? Do you live in the area once colonized by the British, India?

[@i_love_tibet7001]

@@TibetofChina-ut5wo Don't talk nonsense if you are Tibetan.

[@saltsugar1641]

非常非常非常感謝你廣博精深的研究、親行萬里路的拍攝、剪輯、寫稿、配圖、配樂，製作出這麼長、這麼超高水準的紀錄片，讓人在家中輕鬆觀賞，猶如跟著你行走萬里路，遊走於充滿戰鬥、分合、妥協、奇蹟的八百年。只能說，我真的真的很很很很感激有你這樣才高八斗、能將複雜多變的歷史說成精彩戲劇故事的蒙古人！！！！

[@Jingwushow]

哈哈哈，不敢当！谢谢朋友的观看和喜爱！再接再厉！

[@BhomoMila]

This was so educational! I am Tibetan with Mongolian ancestors and there are many areas in northeast Tibet where elders say that they are descendants of both Mongols and Tibetans. China destroyed so much of our real history since it’s occupation so having you showcase and share the actual historical connection is very much needed. Thank you!

[@changlong6549]

你拉倒吧你，西藏从元朝就加入中国了，元朝的皇帝是蒙古族，你能说元朝不是中国？明朝和清朝继承对西藏的法理统治。 我们中华民族是多民族大家庭，不喜欢这里你可以离开，退籍费250元

[@台湾井盖质量世界第一]

自己不记录自己历史，说别人毁掉了，可笑不。

[@Skygoers]

As an ethnic Tibetan, I must applaud Jingwu for this very interesting and fairly objective take on the history of Tibet, Mongolia and Manchus, as mediated through the phenomenon of Tibetan Buddhism. A project of this scale spanning over few hundred years will obviously miss some details. For example, just as Tibetan culture influenced Mongolia, Mongolian culture also influenced Tibet. We celebrate two New Years, for example. The sonam Losar (or the farmers' loser) usually coincide with the Chinese New years as well. But the Gyalo loser (Royal New year), which is the official losar up to the present time, was actually based on the Mongolian calendar.

[@Jingwushow]

Thanks for pointing this out and sharing with us, friend! Glad you enjoyed it.

[@kunga._-123]

Where r u form?

[@tsudagenam6292]

@@kunga._-123 lots of fake Tibetan. Popular Chinese method is to say as a ethnic Tibetan bla bla bla. The whole title of the video was how Tibet ruled Mongolia when it should be that how Mongol leaders used tibetan Buddhism over shamanism due to fears of the political power of shamans to elect new khan if the current khan underperformed. Tibet had no military or cultural might that change the ways of mongols but the danger of shamans being able to kick ruling khan's was the key trigger. The power imbalance balance between the ruling class VS religion was the key reason. Tibetan Buddhism just got lucky cuz mongols could have adopted other religion as well. The Tibetan needed constant help from the mongols it seems according to the video. No point in the video did Tibet send any army to influence Mongolian way of life.

[@sunmatr]

@@tsudagenam6292 Bullshit. Not just religion, Hphags-pa created Mongolian script, introduced Tibetan culture, and profoundly changed the relationship between Mongolian tribes. You just believe in the anti China propaganda, but the true historical is in Chinese.

[@tsudagenam6292]

@@sunmatr 😂 anti chine propaganda my ass, can't trust any Chinese sources due to the control of Chinese gov over the narrative. It seems you didn't address any points I made, u need to use a better translator it seems. Key point, Between Tibet and Mongolia, Tibet was the weaker state in terms of military, culture and economics. Mongolian leaders were not subjecated , defeated or incentivized to convert. Mongolian were more incentivized to adopt Chinese culture than Tibetan due to large populations of Chinese being under them. Tibet just got luck, and Mongol leaders choose Tibetan Buddhism over Chinese, Christians etc

[@Dantto92]

Very high quality video, thanks!

[@Jingwushow]

Much appreciated!

[@kenshintop]

Awesome video! Thank you for taking time to do this. I learned a lot!

[@Jingwushow]

Thanks for watching! Glad you enjoyed it!

[@cartercharles8755]

卧槽过年了！终于更新了！！

[@Jingwushow]

欢迎欢迎！

[@kindface]

Your channel should be receiving multiple times more subscribers. Liked, subscribed. Thanks for taking us on your journey.

[@user55241]

As Mongolian you are absolutely right ! We don't understand any Tibetan. My family members and relatives friends are have a Tibetan names.

[@Jingwushow]

True! Many of my Mongol friends from Inner Mongolia also have Tibetan names!

[@krish5608]

I m Tibetan, and I enjoyed ur video. Thank you for ur history lesson. It is very difficult to find Tibetan history. I don’t know why. Out history topics r very limited.

[@IRM-cm2ic]

Not only Tibetan history is hidden, the worlds history buried and hidden. Many reasons for it. One of the reasons is political. The authority wants to decide what one should know, because if you know something, which discredits authority, you won't obey it. History is politics, authority names the enemies you should fight and tells what you should do in life. And since the religion is the quintessence of politics many new wars can start. Second reason is big conspiracy on earth. Word conspiracy means someone acts hiddenly in conjunction with other entities to make evil to others. Or he wants to do evil to others and face no resistance, so that they don't understand what is done to them. Or involve others in doing evil, they would never do if they had other information or understanding.

[@Jingwushow]

Glad you enjoyed it! and I couldn't agree more. The Tibetan history is rich but rarely discussed. I will make another video on this subject in the future when I get to visit there again. Thanks again for watching my show!

[@malorybertie8046]

if you are real Tibetan then you are lying here .there are tons of Tibetan history videos on KZbin .why do I know ? because I know Tibetan language ,and I have seen so many videos about Tibetan history on KZbin .

[@premchopra6521]

​@@malorybertie8046no one sharing history of tibet honestly because of evil China

[@vankilaya]

A great video which filled in many gaps for me, as my interests in the subject is vast. Thank you for this and can't wait to watch another.. be well...^_^

[@Jingwushow]

Glad this video found you! Thanks for the support!

[@tendar6666]

Nice research, I wish u could learn Tibetan Buddhism before making documentary. You have nice outlook on effect of Tibetan Buddhism on geopolitics.

[@phoolonsanorboo3347]

Bunty❤

[@rosangbantawarai2630]

Not only Mongolia Sikkim's and Bhutan's former kings (gyalpo) was Tibetan too I'm from Sikkim I'm kirati ...we believe that Mongolia is our origin... We worship nature and ancestors and the few culture are quite similar to Mongolian and Burmese too...

[@LeMoN-vb4pe]

there are no tribe in nepal that originate from mongolia kirats originated in tibet not mongolia becaue language of kirats and mongolians donot match even a single word mongols are turkic and mongols ancestors were xiongnu but kirat language doesnt match with tibetan also some believe they originated in burma

[@JonathanKumar-zp9fv]

Shamanic or bon in Tibetan predates Buddhism. So every Tibetan was shamanic once till Buddhism came to Tibet. I believe only Tibetan from Amdo region are genetically related to mongols or mongol tibetan mixed. Sikkim, Bhutan, Ladakh have mostly Utsang influenced. It don’t add up.