17. Carthage - Empire of the Phoenicians

[@tounsi915]

Thank you for this incredible documentary on Carthage! As a Tunisian, I am deeply grateful for how you’ve shed light on the greatness of this empire-its innovations, power, and ultimately, the tragedy of its fall. The depiction of its destruction by the Romans and the burning of the city brought tears to my eyes, even after all these centuries. This is truly a top-quality documentary, combining depth, accuracy, and emotional storytelling to honor Carthage’s legacy.

[@cristihuma6122]

On rare occasions I comment on youtube videos and I never went out of my way to donate. But what can I say, this right here makes my mind hungry for knowledge, and for that, I am forever gratefull. I have watched all videos, I even sleep on them and just dream away the entire history displayed here. This is by far the best way to learn and relax along the way! I bow to such excellence in making all this material and I hope to see so much more from you!

[@FallofCivilizations]

Thank you my friend, very kind of you

[@jasonabshire837]

This is amazing-anthropology grad here. I go to sleep listening to some lecture on history or philosophy most every night with my tablet on KZbin. Invariably, when I wake, this video (numerous times) or something the like is filling my opening ears. It is the best way to start a day. I thank everyone involved and my fellow intellectuals for bringing this to life. I would have given anything to have this, but as a child in the eighties, no such luck. Wow wow wow, thank u!

[@ChineseKiwi]

Here have some more of my money for being the best history channel on KZbin. The research, the professionalism and care for the cultures you talk about, the amazing storytelling, the amazing visuals and even your calm soothing voiceover!

[@jrmckim]

Love your name

[@FallofCivilizations]

Thanks my friend, very kind of you.

[@beyondalpha1072]

If you were getting thw whole truth he wwould not be on Jewtube , just FYI

[@CarloDRTrafficante]

🎉❤

[@Barachodasilvassauro]

@@jrmckimI love your eyes 😊

[@Nhnhnfk]

Paul Cooper and his team deserve to have their work broadcast on the BBC. This is yet another brilliant work, thank you!

[@HoneyBadgerBitMyKnackers]

The BBC would ruin Paul's work. They would insist on sneaking in that the British were responsible for the fall of all civilisations in history. They hate Britain. Cancel your TV licence today.

[@jraelien5798]

The BBC is utter garbage. Do not curse these talented, hard working people with integrity! They are part of a vastly more useful and valuable new era of Media. The old dinosaurs like the BBC are dead and buried. Support people like Paul Cooper instead.

[@jraelien5798]

The BBC is utter garbage. Do not curse these talented, hard working people with integrity! They are part of a vastly more useful and valuable new era of Media. The old dinosaurs like the BBC are dead and buried. Support people like Paul Cooper instead.

[@thornil2231]

Why on BBC? BBC only broadcasts garbage and lies...

[@karlosthejackel69]

But wouldn’t the BBC just say they were all black??……

[@MadworldMedia-ly8ck]

I listen to these while I fall asleep. It's like a movie in my mind that sets the stage for the dreams I have of the past, of the history so many civilizations have had. This is by far my favorite documentary series on youtube, ever. Thank you, Paul. Your hard work and quality history retellings just fascinate me.

[@FallofCivilizations]

Thank you, glad you think so!

[@PRH123]

I do the same. These are amongst the best history documentaries that I've ever seen.

[@michaelfalsia6062]

We are kindred spirits, my friend. I, too, love to fall asleep listening to cintent like this. Sweet dreams! 😊

[@giovannisantostasi9615]

It is amazing.

[@louwaars]

Me too 🤝

[@tovarishleninade9436]

for the last three years I've been really sick, and on top of that, something happened recently that completely destroyed my life even more. I just want to say thank you, with all my heart, because your documentaries are practically the only thing I can enjoy nowadays. I think i've seen each of your episodes more than 30 times and they always calm me and show me how ephemeral everything is, and on the top of that I also love history so much. Thank you for what you do Paul, yours are truly the best documentaries on youtube

[@UnknownUser-fe5zu]

This deserves a ❤️ and a response from Paul

[@mikecummings6593]

Hello my unknown friend I'm sorry to say that you seem to describe my situation to a T and I can only say hang in there my unknown friend and may you find joy in the little things like this documentary series much as I do have you ever heard of the podcast called the history guy it's quite enjoyable and he narrates not quite as well as well but you will likely enjoy once again hang in there my unknown friend

[@tovarishleninade9436]

@@UnknownUser-fe5zu thank you

[@tovarishleninade9436]

@@mikecummings6593 sorry to hear you are going through the same friend, Hope things improve for you as well. Thank you for your comment and your kindness, It is so rare these days. Will check that podcast for sure. And again, thank you, your comment made my day a little brighter

[@mikecummings6593]

@@tovarishleninade9436 awesome

[@effortLus]

Incredibly fascinated by this captivating story. So much knowledge that was never taught to us in school, unless I somehow forgot. Empires like the Romans get so much attention in media, while the civilisations you describe have just as much beauty. Great quality and detail!!

[@FallofCivilizations]

Thank you!

[@dukecity7688]

Carthage is a subject I can never learn enough about. It's only been three years since I got interested in ancient history. Someone gave me my first lap top. I've watched many, many programs about Carthage. None came close to this. It's the most comprehensive study put on video I've ever seen. It's thrilling. Thank you very much.

[@edwardgoodwin9801]

I wonder how it actually went down. I mean his video is bang on. But most information is Roman. So I wonder how much they built up and made hannibal seem more scary so that his defeat would sound more epic.. maybe he was as savage

[@SkyeSage17]

Phoenician history has been doctored by the Romans. Roman's made up His-tory to control sheeple and ewe's. 🤐 🤐 Realize with real eyes the real lies....

[@dukecity7688]

@-ca-- I just read that recently. I loved it. The lavish images invoked were over -the-top. It was wild.

[@tranzco1173]

You a fellow Albuquerque based history lover? I went to school for history, work in a different field, but yes, these are not your typical History Channel docs, about Aliens and Pyramids and Atlantis. Methodologically correct history delivered in an entertaining way.

[@Robespierre-lI]

​@@edwardgoodwin9801 This is one of the most frustrating things about ancient history - the amount that we must rely on the reports of Romans to understand who their enemies were. Carthage, the Celtic peoples, the Germanic peoples ... Archeology has done quite a bit to improve the historical record, but it can only get us so far.

[@khodotany]

I am Lebanese. And this is by far the most informative and educating video I have ever came across all over the internet!!!! Thank you so much for making this masterpiece!!!!!

[@thetruthshallsetyoufree2040]

3njd masterpiece

[@lufasumafalu5069]

i dont know lebanese can comment on internet without israeli permission

[@khodotany]

@@lufasumafalu5069 except there is no “Israel”, and yes we can.

[@holbygrlNMN]

​@@lufasumafalu5069I can't figure out if you actually believe what you commented or if you are actually using satire?? I'm going with satire since I don't want to think you made that comment out of seriousness....

[@hiphop24-s3s]

​@@khodotanythere is Israel, infact 6 Arab nations try to conquered it in 1967 but fail

[@Alex-DML]

I was born and raised in San Fernando, a small city right next to Cadiz, I remember most of my childhood seeing the construction workers tearing up the roads to make space for the new tram system the city wanted to put, and how every few months they'd have to stop completely, because they kept finding archeological remains of Carthaginian burial sites, monuments, workshops etc. for context I think the construction started in the early 2000's and due to all the findings and subsequent excavations they only finished the tram a few years ago, right before the pandemic if I recall. As a kid, it always fascinated me to know that there was so much aincent history buried right beneath the streets of my hometown, but I couldn't really get much info about the people who made their living here millenia ago since the only mentions of Carthage in school were only when they taught us a very basic overview of the Punic Wars. Thank you for putting out such a comprehensive, detailed and immersive documentary on the People that have fascinated me since childhood

[@nikobellic570]

Spain has such fascinating history from across ages, civilisations and empires. Probably most of it is still underground

[@joycepetrina2791]

I’m with you on this. It is my favorite UTUBE presentation.

[@Wasko1312]

Andalucia has a very rich history.

[@esz_01]

Antípolis, San Fernando, era de hecho la necrópolis de los gaditanos desde el siglo VII a.C. si no mal recuerdo... ¡Un saludo desde GDR a los isleños!

[@jugo1944]

Your English is impeccable for a non native speaker

[@VladoMitkov]

Patiently waiting for the next episode while rewatching the full series for the n-th time. Thank you for your amazing work! As a Bulgarian, I'd love a future episode on the Thracians.

[@DerHammerSpricht]

The format of narration in these docs is better than the golden age of history channel, and also more engaging than most movies on these subjects. I'm honored to have the ability to enjoy this.

[@christopherphillips647]

Carthage is one of my absolute favorite ancient civilizations. I was so excited when I listened to the audio version of this, and I'm STOKED for the video version. Thanks so much for all you do! I recommend your channel to all of my friends.

[@hannibalbarca8411]

3 days ago i was standing on the hill of sidi theif facing the bay of tunis and over looking the sea route that leads to the carthaginian port... I was there for like 1 hour just staring at the sea imagining the Carthaginian navy making his way through the waves with the voices of thounsands of worriors yelling and going to war . It was an iconic view especially with the foggy mountains in the distance and the chilling view

[@christopherphillips647]

@@hannibalbarca8411 Aaaah I'm jealous! I've been planning to go see all the archaeological sites at Cartagena for years but haven't made it happen yet.

[@hannibalbarca8411]

@@christopherphillips647 it's fascinating... You can really feel the spirit of greatness in the air

[@ChrisMinorOfficial]

Minus the ritual child sacrifice…

[@tunisianhannibal9585]

It's bullshii.. Imagine how an israeli historian would describe the war against gaza that's what happened and most of carthage's history is unknown except for Tunisians who can be in carthage's side thinking because they don't believe this lies based on nothing of science.. ​@@ChrisMinorOfficial

[@CaesiusX]

I am struck dumb by not only the quality of this production, but a melancholy which I'm overcome by the inevitability of this history.

[@jamesmarshall6619]

feel the same way. Great series and you know how it's going to end and it's going to be heartbreaking but keep coming back for more.

[@riverlady982]

Me too but I also like to think about how there's always a new beginning and sometimes it's better, eventually. It's just like the cycle of life except the civilizations last longer than our lifespans and I just feel bad for the people who are there to see it end.

[@Libbbo]

As Lebanese I can fully appreciate the level of details is astonishing.

[@NoNo-oi7zj]

Probably because you are dumb. 90% of this video is literally fiction.

[@peterhunt135]

This is high art. From the academic research to the writing, to the narrative style, to the voice of the narrator. And this applies to all their work in this series. Thank you! :)

[@colephelps6202]

The combination of narration, hand-drawn maps, satellite photo reference, site photos and ancient texts is FIRE. It makes the history so easy to follow.

[@hostedbysimples5416]

Thank you so much. For everything, for telling those histories of ancient cities that we know almost nothing about. I absolutely love studying history, and your work is the main reason, not because of grand narratives and accounts of war and personalities, but because you care to show how people daily lives were back in those day, about how their identity, what they ate, what they believe, how they reacted to what we would call the end of their civilizations. Its so important to give attention to them, but we always forget to do it, its such a shame we usually dont acknolodge the common folk. Once again, thank you very much for making this.

[@FallofCivilizations]

Thank you my friend, very kind of you

[@luxluciferin]

Two years subscribed to your Patreon, and I still feel blown away by every episode, like the universe cannot possibly be so kind as to deliver us this content for free. Only I know it's not the universe, and you're out there on a laptop somewhere, drowning in books and articles, down weird rabbit holes at odd hours, wrangling the little nuances of original soundtracks, voice actors, and copyright legalities, putting in a breathtaking amount of work that most of us cannot even comprehend to create something this long, to this standard of quality. Paul, you are a gem among gems. I think it's a mark of this podcast's legacy that you have such an avid fanbase willing to load up the catapults to fling money at free content just to see it keep going. Whenever someone near me complains about the attention span of my generation or those before and after me, I just laugh a little and point them here 😊 All that to say... I'll be here for as long as you keep going. Thank you!

[@FallofCivilizations]

Thank you my friend, that's very kind - and thank you for supporting the show for so long.

[@johnburke429]

I’m 😮😮😅

[@johnburke429]

1:08:38 w😅😮😮w 1:07:59 1:08:01

[@LordVader1094]

The visual versions of the podcast are what truly make these, the quality is astounding every time

[@markb8468]

I know. I usually listen as a podcast at work but I know I'm missing out on the great video production.

[@davidt3563]

These should be required viewing for everyone.

[@stevekozlowski649]

It takes a while but it is so worth it to see!

[@DivineByDesignWithDani]

Totally agree and I'm too the point that I can't listen to the podcast because it's just not the same without the video. Been eagerly awaiting this video since the podcast dropped a few months ago. Now the story feels complete.

[@MacKennaTheGoddessofRadiation]

For real

[@deusvult7559]

WOW...These comments are NOT exaggerating. This is hands down the most definitive documentary on Carthage that I've seen in thirty or so years of absorbing everything Carthaginian I could find. THANK YOU, for sharing it with us and for all your incredible work. It's just amazing...I hope I don't have to wait another 30 years for something like this again. Stunning....

[@yzh7728]

This far exceeds BBC's golden era documentaries! Well done 👏

[@genghispecan]

Thanks! I was particularly looking forward to this one. As always, well done, sir. Thank you for your continuing "AAA" content.

[@Akkolon]

I love this podcast. I cannot recommend this enough to anyone who likes history. Paul and the people behind him are true hero´s of knowledge mediation and history.

[@FallofCivilizations]

Thanks for spreading the word!

[@JohnMisdreavous]

Literally the only youtube channel i allow notifications from

[@lgorenc]

@@JohnMisdreavous Me too.

[@markb8468]

It reminds me of Dan Carlin. Adding rich colors and context to history. And he has a soothing voice. Top shelf stuff!

[@joshuataylor3550]

@@FallofCivilizations You've come far from barrel-making.

[@barbecueman6352]

Paul you may not read this comment but I want to say that the production quality and effort put into your documentaries makes me feel blessed to be privy to such history. Thank you.

[@mikeyforrester6887]

It's great, but Why does he talk so slowly though???? I have to listen at 1.25 speed

[@ninjagamerz6085]

😅😅😅😅😅😅

[@ninjagamerz6085]

😊😊K lop

[@DS-re4co]

​@@ninjagamerz6085źzźźźzźźźźźzźźźzźzźźźźźźźźźż0

[@jameshennighan8193]

@@mikeyforrester6887 It is his speed of delivery that makes these documentaries what they are. Our understanding of the subject is greatly enhanced because we are given the time to absorb and learn from what is being said far more easily. We are given the time to gather our thoughts. All of which adds to greater accuracy. Think of the speed of his delivery as the ideal speed at which we read. This is actually far more normal than many would have us believe, and is certainly more restful. Rather than assume that he is speaking too slowly, we should perhaps ask ourselves what is is about others that causes them ti speak more quickly............and why..? James Hennighan Yorkshire, England

[@jordanfeldman8962]

The description of the loss of the Carthaginian records is moving. The entire thing is extremely well done. Bravo!

[@AlfJCNunes]

Thanks. The best documentary channel in you tube. In any one I see I’m amazed by the knowledge and study needed, the time needed and the quality of the images/video. Thank you very much for sharing and spreed the passion for history

[@rickshawwheelchair]

Your work has actually enriched my life. Thank you

[@grunchlk]

Proud to be a patron of this outstanding podcast series. It's, if I may say so, one of the best on KZbin. It's emotional, factual, high in production value - just a joy to watch and listen to.

[@howardroark6594]

This movie production made it possible to personally connect with the pride, then pain, and finally the pain of the total destruction of a people more than a millennia removed from today. I took Latin classes for years during my education and the Punic Wars were only a collection of meaningless dates, names, and locations. This movie brought the lives of the Carthaginians into my heart so that it was possible to share their triumphs and their defeats. WOW

[@okramronan]

Who ever are this team they deserve an oscar or some nobel prize.... amazing service to humanity this guys are doing... i wud love to be part of them...

[@Robespierre-lI]

Nobel Prize? Lol. It's a high quality summary of established scholarship. Not the discovery of the Higgs Boson particle.

[@markforrest4900]

The fall of empires a series of documentaries by a 20 something historian some episodes he will speak at the conclusion asking you to subscribe 👍

[@unholyallen9572]

Finally! As a Tunisian I'm very happy to see you cover the Empire that once ruled over our lands.

[@DerHammerSpricht]

What does the average person in your area think of Carthage or Rome today?

[@unholyallen9572]

@@DerHammerSpricht We study Carthage and the Punic Wars in elementary school but these topics don't get much attention later on. The average person considers it as a piece of distant history as we rarely shed light on the Carthaginian heritage we might have.

[@DerHammerSpricht]

@@unholyallen9572I imagine Islamic history is treated by your schools as the more important history? Christianity does the same to our history.

[@asmrnaturecat984]

@DerHammerSpricht Can't blame them, if anyone to be blamed, its the roman who destroy everything Imagine tunisian learning about their past written by roman, its like modern day arabs learn about themselves from hollywood, painted as evil and bad guys Meanwhile, the history of islamic tunis is pretty much preserved and no "tunis delenda esta" ever happened Umayyads, abbasids, aghlabids and many islamic dynasty leaves tons of scholarly legacy continuesly to this date

[@unholyallen9572]

@@DerHammerSpricht We study the Arab conquest of North Africa and the Islamic dynasties that ruled over the region in elementary and secondary schools. We also have a subject named Islamic Education that we study pretty much in every educational level. Islamic history gets more time to shine as it is more recent than Carthage and the Pheonicians and had also a bigger impact on our society and continues to do so nowadays.

[@shanechaisson9383]

I’ve told countless people about this podcast. It’s truly one of the best I’ve ever listened to. I hope you never stop!

[@farmtutor2379]

If there’s one thing Ive learned from this podcast… Everything comes to an end. No matter how great.

[@cocoaorange1]

Truer words never spoken!

[@LouisaWatt]

It’s amazing that something this high quality is freely available on KZbin. 👏

[@xianghouzinjianghu5001]

Yeah as it should be. Education should be free and accessible for everyone. To assert otherwise is grotesque

[@zanzah_]

We are so lucky

[@arostwocents]

​@@xianghouzinjianghu5001unfortunately censorship and desire for more money is pushing a lot of creators to an alternative paid service :(

[@sherebiahdesigns]

@xianghouzinjianghu5001 WHAT? Educating you should be free?... to assert otherwise is grotesque!?!?!? ARE YOU KIDDING ME? Such a privileged, bratty little thing to say!! Do you happen to think this three hour+ massive scale of a beautifully crafted documentary was free to make?!?! Just for starters, sir or madam: Look it...think of the major amount of money to make this three hour+ documentary. First, there were at least hundreds of hours of pre-production, getting permissions to trample around on these ancient Islands with a huge crew of actors, directors, extras and so forth with so many locations, hundreds and hundreds of ancient costumes that had to be made, all of the animals and their trainers brought in, all of the sets, added extras brought in to make up the crowds, all of their costumes, ancient looking ships that had to be rented, the massively beautiful professional cinematography of land and arial scenes, decorators to stage the scenes, travel expenses to move all of these people from one location of filming to another, pay for lodging for the extras and the actors, pay the excellent narrator for tons of hours preparing and familiarizing himself with three entire hours of script so that it flows seamlessly, the director working with his team to flesh out every move made on set. Feeding ALL of these people every day😢 and on and on and on....whew!!!!! And you get to sit and watch it for FREE... and you think that it would be an outrage if they wanted you to pay something to see it! The sense of privilege is horrifying!

[@gianapedri-zj4fk]

I yrt😢dd come Dre e

[@kkupsky6321]

These are the greatest thing ever to watch given so freely on KZbin. I watch these episodes over and over. This man needs an award. So awesome how much goes into this. Such a production and we’re blessed to have it.

[@bigboi4307]

Thanks for shining light on the most underrated civilization in history. The obvious next choice would be Babylon to compete your Mesopotamian trilogy which are your most popular videos by far but some more underrated shouts would be Nubia or Aksum for more African content or goguryoe/joseon for Asia

[@Robespierre-lI]

The African civilizations would be great to see. Babylon would be essential. The acient Mississippian and Anasazi are not known widely enough either. Also the Khmer Empire and Persia I kinda like that he hasn't done Greece or Rome yet. Unless I missed those episodes

[@Fruitcupper]

It's 3.29am and your voice is the only thing that helps me sleep softly.

[@uydagcusdgfughfgsfggsifg753]

Crazy to think there hasn’t been a mid episode yet in this series, every single one is exceptional! Would LOVE to see you cover the Fall of Merv - near Mary in modern Turkmenistan. Its ruins are still out there in the desert, and I’ve never heard its story told properly

[@chrisbusenkell]

Merv? I'll have to look it up. Sounds interesting.

[@uydagcusdgfughfgsfggsifg753]

@@chrisbusenkell it really is, once the largest city on earth before the Mongols arrived. The Khwarazmian Empire was the civilization behind it, which, just prior to their fall, became the defacto superpower of the Muslim world. The old Shah - speaking to his son, who went on to become the Shah who ruled when the Mongols came knocking - the warning he gave is haunting

[@mdq.music.]

One of the most breathtaking documentaries I’ve seen in my life.

[@nerdybrothers]

Thanks! Amazing work as always. Easily my favorite series. Keep doing it!

[@FallofCivilizations]

Glad you enjoy it!

[@audiodoctor100]

Why does KZbin keep taking me here after every video??? It’s not even in my queue or suggested?? (I like it but it’s getting a little annoying)

[@artrereed8242]

Thought I was the only one😂

[@MichaelM-hw6nk]

SAMEEEEE!!!!!!! Al

[@Vicus_of_Utrecht]

Yup, same.

[@nonprecision]

But I keep watching it…

[@Gubbins_McBumbersnoot]

Same here, I just gave up lol

[@nomfundomdluli1544]

The last 30 minutes are absolutely heart-wrenching, its so tragic my eyes welled up with tears as if it was me or I was there helplessly watching it all unfold. I was trasported to that time by your brilliant writing and captivating presentation. I felt their desperation and utter helplessness and despair at their impending anhilation. I was so very sad for them, thank you Paul for making me connect, care and cry for people from thousands of years ago, very well done.

[@riteshyeddu]

So true!! Especially the feeling helpless part :(

[@andrewascencio3461]

Who else woke up here?

[@conor9345]

Just did

[@classiclife7204]

Block the channel

[@lucasassefa5654]

7:35 am just woke up bro 😂

[@justblaze1656]

same lol

[@markforrest4900]

Lol me too

[@amonferrari]

What an amazing episode. This is one of the best YT channels. Made me feel so deep about Hannibal and his people. Thank you for an amazing storytelling.

[@Pan472]

I'll say this once again: This podcast is by far the greatest, and the one which will do Greek civilization the best honour if he makes an episode or episodes on it

[@Jacob-df5hr]

Did Greek civilization ever really fall? It seems more like it ebbs and flows.

[@hiphop24-s3s]

​​@@Jacob-df5hryeah it falls but they didn't destroy the culture. Infact the conquerors of the Hellens adopted theirs native culture... That's why eastern Romans( both native Greeks and greeknized peoples) became a Neo-Greek empire... The only legitimate fall of Hellenic civilization is when ottoman defeated the East Romans

[@tunisianhannibal9585]

​@@Jacob-df5hrthe same for carthage despite the defeat and destruction, it was the second important city of the world after rome during the roman empire then it was the city that destroyed rome with the vandals then it became the second important city after constantipole and even now it's the presidential home and the capital of Tunisia (tunis and carthage are the same capital for the same region) but greece have never been an important power after the fall of the byzantin empire and that if we even consider it as greek.. The western movies weren't honest about history, ancient greece didn't have any important city compared to Tunisia which had more than 10 capitals which ruled thousands of miles in africa and Europe and asia

[@kingmaker2603]

You can't really make one on Greeks because they never got wiped out they got assimilated into other empires similarly you can't do a video on fall of persia because it never truly fell it got assimilated into arab empire and flourished.

[@workouts_2024]

That piano solo gets me every time. It puts me into a deep, contemplative frame of mind and sets me up for the journey I'm about to take into the past...

[@Rayrard]

If only these illustrated retellings were placed on history channels where they belong, but then "history channels" are long since defunct. These have amazing production quality and the set pieces and actors set the scene well.

[@rustam-e-hind3973]

Was really looking forward to this episode after listening to the audio version 2 months ago. Thank you so much Paul and team for the quality and heart you put into your work. Much love and gratitude. ❤

[@MOV1983]

Paul Cooper. Narrator extraordinaire. I could listen to this guy all day.

[@brianlara6451]

The research put into these is astounding. That you make one every few months is impressive. I cite your work all the time as definitive in my conversations. Thank you for the Carthage episode I was waiting for this since I saw y'all the first time a few years back.

[@FallofCivilizations]

Thanks for spreading the word!

[@ozboxing2232]

✌️

[@pointerish]

I’ve watched/listened to this 6 times so far. Outstanding production and honorable work. Here’s some help for you to keep it going!

[@AisforAtheist]

I've watched multiple times as well. This channel is such a gem!

[@Internetjim1235]

As a student of Phoenician history, I have to say this is your best documentary yet and the fall of Carthage really encapsulates your channel’s theme.

[@The_ZeroLine]

The best because you’re most familiar with the history? 😉 They’re all awesome. The Assyrian episode, IMO, is the most amazing.

[@Oscuros]

As a student of Phoenician history, how could you let him get away with missing out on the fact that they invented money with those flat, stamped pieces of iron that they used to trade with, because it makes me doubt that you are a student of the Phoenicians to not know that, like he doesn't.

[@idiotequedwaal]

​@@Oscurosexcept they didn't and your aggressive arrogance is utterly pointless.

[@Internetjim1235]

@@Oscuros why don’t you make a documentary as long and as detailed as this one? Then you can criticise…

[@jhymeliv]

I cannot stress enough how much you deserve every ounce of success that comes your way Paul. Each piece of content you produce is simply breathtaking. I even had to chase down Salammbo to read while waiting for the documentary version of this episode. After watching the very first episode "Roman Britain - The Work of Giants Crumbled" I was hooked. All of this is without even acknowledging how great of an author you also are. Honestly this series should be on television or in stores as box sets. Thank you so much for your continued work and effort Paul, especially that we, your audience, get to enjoy this entirely for free on KZbin. I continue to hope that you receive all the recognition you deserve.

[@FallofCivilizations]

Thank you Joey, that's very kind of you

[@lufasumafalu5069]

Salambo is fictional nonsense

[@FallofCivilizations]

@@lufasumafalu5069 yes of course, it is a novel

[@lufasumafalu5069]

@@FallofCivilizations the novel took too many liberties with available historical data from historian of the era.. it is entertaining tbh

[@FallofCivilizations]

@@lufasumafalu5069 Yes, though it was published in 1862 so archaeology was limited and he was working mostly from classical sources. Some things like his inclusion of an aqueduct in Punic Carthage attracted criticism at the time, to which he pled artistic license.

[@andrewcharles459]

The quality of production in these is just astounding.

[@kevinvilmont6061]

IKEA

[@joelmodestus2210]

Can't believe this is free! Keep up the great job!

[@jelopezmusic]

I for one am quite pleased that this always comes up on autoplay. Super high quality work - thank you to the creator!

[@robertstewart8364]

These documentaries are just beautiful to listen to and to watch again and again. I’ve watched many of them multiple times. I’ve been waiting for the video version of the Carthage to drop and it’s finally here! Thank you Paul!

[@rustyreturns9754]

Your talent as a writer is most evident in this episode. The descriptions of the town, food & drink, and explorations are particularly good.

[@rupnishadas9814]

I've been waiting for this video for ages. The Phoenicians are such an anomaly and I know no one could map their empire out like you can ❤ Lots of love

[@FallofCivilizations]

Thank you, I hope so!

[@monkeeseemonkeedoo3745]

ME TOO MANG

[@MrIlleism]

Please give whoever did this documentary a pint and a raise. Absolutely incredible!

[@gailblissitt4504]

This story is so massive in scope and cruelty as to be almost unbelievable !!! Thank you for this beautifully told history…..your efforts in doing so are equal to those who lived it. Thank you !!!!

[@SuperBsk2010]

My god these episodes are brilliant! Completely entranced for hours. I found this podcast and listen via Spotify! I can't say I have found a single history book or podcast on this level and I am sure many would agree!

[@andrewlukonis7516]

Another incredible episode! The tenacity of the Carthaginians was remarkable, as well as the military success of General Hanibal. Even though we already knew the ending, the fall of Carthage still brought tears to my eyes. Paul, you and your team breathe new life back into the histories of our great civilizations and you enrich the lives of all who listen to and watch your magnificent podcast.

[@annier6835]

I have immense admiration for the creators of Fall of Civilisations. Such beautiful work. I found this one particularly heartbreaking. History came too wretchedly alive. I look forward to watching the next episode - but I need some time to recover from the ruination of Carthage!

[@flowstate6769]

Idk what they call an Oscar for KZbin videos, but this guy deserves one.

[@bondjamesiv]

Hmmm, a WEBster, perhaps?

[@scott5671]

He is light years better than the 'professional' documentaries which rely on sensational sound effects to make sure the viewer doesn't lose interest. No such need here. Paul Cooper wins Gold 🥇

[@compassioncampaigner728]

The YTube Oscar? You don't get censored.

[@charlesbianco7932]

@@scott5671xugx

[@charlesbianco7932]

@@compassioncampaigner728cu😅😅😅😅😅😅😅gas x😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅g

[@jasonball1010]

I literally gasped with joy seeing this dropped today. Thanks so much Paul and the team for making the greatest history podcast and videos of all time. The amount of detail and immersive experience of the people’s lives is outstanding. Also the videos are sooooooo impressive and make the experience even better.

[@Tipu1799]

No amount of appreciation is enough for the incredible work that you and your team are doing Paul...Your narration skills are so high that it feels like I'm passing through these ancient civilizations...I hope that soon you'll give us yet another masterpiece but this time featuring some middle eastern or south asian civilization

[@markb8468]

100% agreed!

[@davidt3563]

We get to live in one of the greatest cities for 3 hours and 40 minutes. A trillion possibilities for our imaginations.

[@Tipu1799]

​@@davidt3563you are right about the imaginations and that's the most fascinating aspect of Paul's documentaries....You can feel yourself in these civilizations as Paul narrates their stories

[@jelmer1984]

Exactly what I was thinking! Love these series, it's like somekind of time machine. Can't wait for the next one, the wait is definitely worth it. And yes, as someone else quoted, Paul has changed the game of documentaries of ancient civilizations, big time.

[@makeorbreak4life]

​@@markb8468pp😊😊😊

[@Aramigo123]

Outstanding, as usual. The first time i've watched instead of just listening as a podcast, and I am blown away. A+

[@FallofCivilizations]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@chrisw.5138]

Amazing, how truly emotionally impacting your work is while never failing to deliver on the main point: factual history. I feel very blessed by this experience - thanks Paul & team, very much appreciated.

[@ProgPiglet]

In constant awe at the tasteful production value and pacing of these documentaries. It's so easy to cut corners on youtube, so a documentary like this takes not only an extraordinary amount of work, but discipline and passion. this documentary in particular breathes life into the few first hand accounts left of Carthage, and the crumbling remains of it's cities. yall deserve all the success you get and more. cheers

[@PaddyHerrlinger]

Top quality content, thanks for making it free!

[@FallofCivilizations]

Thanks my friend, very kind!

[@IndigenousHistoryNow]

I did not expect this video to impact me as much as it did. I knew Carthage was destroyed, and I knew the grisly details of the sacking, but I always thought it was a direct result of the battle of Zama. A (unfortunately) not unusual case of the campaign finale war crimes. I didn’t realize it was 50 years later and after the city had recovered and been minding its own business. Something about the capriciousness of that siege makes it all the more horrific. It was just a completely preventable human tragedy where tens of thousands of people had their lives destroyed forever all because of the jealousy and spite of a bunch of people hundreds of miles away that they weren’t bothering at all. That is evil.

[@Nachos237]

It was a genocide

[@aleale6277]

​@@Nachos237The romans destroyed Carthage, not the punic people. There were thousands of punic cities and villages aside from Carthage. And to be fair the carthaginians were given an ultimatum and they refused.

[@davidfentonhancock6646]

There was nothing much fair in ancient history, just there's not that much today. It's dog eat dog...these days the rules are "fairer" in a funny kind of way.....@@aleale6277

[@smurfyday]

@@aleale6277 It's like you didn't watch the episode. The ultimatum was designed to be rejected. And it was a genocide. We don't even have words from the Catheginean people.

[@raushaunrigsby1181]

Now do Iraq, Libya, Afghanistan etc., all in this century by evil Amerikkka

[@deshawnrivera2032]

Already watched this on Patreon, but I must watch this at every chance I get. Perfect work. As a filmmaker, you inspire me and some projects I am working on.

[@FallofCivilizations]

Thank you Deshawn, that's very kind of you. Best of luck in your own work.

[@gavinboss22]

I've never had a history story move me as much as this one, the story is so well told, the ups and downs and final ending is so dramatic it brought me to tears...

[@anonanon5147]

There is nothing quite like this to be found elsewhere. Every episode is a masterpiece. Your work stands out from all the clickbait, shallow and short attention span content out there.

[@cinema6r845]

Thank you, Paul, for everything you've done. Both you and your team have done an amazing job. The way you guys catch the imagination even without an illustrated version is astounding. A whole new perspective of the past with colorful image.

[@kcairns1]

Heading to Tunis for the 4th time on Sunday, listening to this again to inspire me on places to visit this time around. Thank you for everything you do 💙

[@FallofCivilizations]

Wonderful!

[@Robespierre-lI]

I'm afraid there's not much left of Carthage. Rome saw to that. And then the Islamic Conquest did further damage. It's sad.

[@CD-lx6sc]

Your work literally brought me to tears. I actually shed a tear at the lament poem by the end. Wonderful work Paul, simply wonderful.

[@Fallenangel_85]

me2, what a very sad end for such a great human achievement I guess really didn't like all the child sacrificing etc.

[@veila0924]

If you haven't, listen to the Easter Island and Aztec episodes. They had me bawling

[@CD-lx6sc]

@hardlo7146 I have and I agree, so very very sad. I couldn't believe how cruel people could be. It's really upsetting.

[@veila0924]

​@@CD-lx6scIt's especially tragic because even today thousands, maybe even millions of people, justify and relish on the actions done against them, often talking about "human sacrifices" they performed, as if that wasn't infinitely dwarfed by the evil inflicted upon them.

[@CD-lx6sc]

@@veila0924 right!? Couldn't have said it better! It's astounding.

[@GiuseppeSan]

I recently came back from southern Italy, specifically the town of Scilla which is just across the straight of Messina from Sicily. There's a castle there which goes into detail about the wars that followed in the 16th century and onward, but only glossed on the deeper history. This magnificently told story has helped me realize the deeper historical significance behind the places I visited. Seeing the narrow straight with my own eyes, it was obvious that control of that straight would give a massive advantage to whomever could secure it. Fascinating that this control oscillated between Ancient Greece, Rome, and Carthage. Top-class documentary!!

[@perchta2164]

Whatever is most overlooked by mainstream science, history and literature, is where the gold is

[@Mystery-q8e]

Yes, so true about Scilla and the strait.

[@brightbleu]

Please never stop creating these amazing podcasts and videos! I've been so spoiled by watching them that whenever I watch other history documentaries I wish they were all produced by your wonderful team.

[@g-mansemployer7282]

shut up please

[@momissimo4087]

The best history channel in the world. Paul, you deserve all the best for the passion and the quality of your contents. Greetings from Italy!!

[@abe2562]

Thank you for this! My grandfather is Lebanese and always says we are “Phoenician”. Now I finally understand where I’m descended from and it’s AWESOME. Thank you again

[@og8263]

Conquered by Muhammad but you worship him😂

[@Robespierre-lI]

You could find that if you took an ancestry DNA test, any links to the Phonecians 'ay or may not be there. The Levant was the meeting point of ancient Empires ... Until the Arab conquest caused a massive shift in the population and destroyed most of the ancient diversity. And of course, the crusader states also changed the ethnic composition of Lebanon as well.

[@Badgerbeard]

@@og8263 Why must you dismiss and disparage somebody who is proud of their heritage - It looks very petty and sad.

[@-Mitra-]

​@@Robespierre-lIwrong. Neither Lebanese not Syrians etc the look like Arabs from Saudia, Qatar, UAE and other Khalidj countries.

[@-Mitra-]

That's great you grandfather didn't call himself an Arab! Proud Phoenikians with magnificent, astonishing historical and cultural heritage you are!

[@RobRoss]

The siege and fall of Carthage would make an epic movie!

[@DivineByDesignWithDani]

This was the first documentary/ podcast series i ever took tge time to watch on KZbin. Ive not found another channel to even come close to the magnificence of this one . The narration is captivating ! And the other channels can never be you and cannot hold my attention at all . Thank you for another spellbinding masterpiece ❤️ 💜 ❤.

[@DaveDraperGuitar]

This work is some of the best content on the entire internet. Been looking forward to the Carthage episode!

[@Jurek009]

I don't often think about the Roman empire and I didn't wake up today thinking I'd end up crying for Carthage, but here we are. Great documentary!

[@smilestreetart]

I was always fascinated by Carthage, and always wanted to know more about this mysterious challenger to Rome, thank you for such a brilliant presentation!

[@tunisianhannibal9585]

Rome was the challengers and carthage was the master before it falls

[@robwonder630]

Hello Paul, I just wanted to express my gratitude for your great work of bringing fallen civilizations back to life.

[@Frank-it9kl]

Thanks for the absolute excellent documentaries. The video on Rapa Nui is worth a donation alone. Bravo 👏 👏 netflix should pick you up.

[@FallofCivilizations]

Thanks my friend, very kind of you

[@jrmckim]

Only 18k until 1 million!!🎉 I can't think of another channel that works harder to provide such high-quality content for free. I love that you let the history determine the length of the video, instead of squeezing all they can into an hour video while leaving out such vital information. I want to thank the entire crew for all the work and dedication. You guys have really given so much. Because of my health, I cant go out or have anyone come by. Its super lonely having cancer sometimes 😅 All of these videos have saved me from falling too deep into darkness. It gives me hope that even at the end of everything, life still manages to continue. At the heart of all of us is a will to move forward and start again. ❤ This wasnt supposed to turn into all that 😅 Jist know that youve really made an impact on me. Thank you ❤

[@jujubean54ify]

I’m so sorry that you are ill, and I send my prayers to you. These podcasts are the best thing on the internet-they make a person feel that they are THERE in history!

[@heydanfran17]

Glad you have something to cheer you up... keep strong. Blessings and love to you

[@justinkim4393]

0

[@paulcheney3636]

My Sammy is just over a year free of leukemia. Hang in there and best wishes 🙏 🎉

[@30secondsflat]

Thanks so much Paul. I have to say the complexities of the Punic war always confuses me but your delivery made a dynamic conflict very straightforward and easily accessible without “talking down” to your audience, and that by itself is why so many people gravitate to your work

[@FallofCivilizations]

Glad you thought so!

[@ozboxing2232]

✌️

[@mattiemathis9549]

I am astounded that this series is done by an individual. The quality of the videos and the quality of information is top notch. This is better than anything the history channel has put out in decades. Thank you sir. In addition to learning really cool stuff during the day, at night I find your voice very peaceful and relaxing. 🙏

[@superlean5991]

Paul - I often relisten to your episodes throughout the week. Seeing this made my day. So excited to dig in. Thank you for continuing this project. It’s so important to learn about our history and your content is top tier.

[@alyxleaf]

This has quickly become one of my favourite KZbin series. I don't usually sit through 30 minute videos, but your storytelling makes me able to listen to this for nearly 4 hours and still want more. Could you do an episode about Ayutthaya in Thailand?

[@MoonLitChild]

He already has!

[@alyxleaf]

​@@MoonLitChildLink?

[@PatrickLongblkwhtrbbt]

@alyxleaf there isn't one. The only east Asian cultures have been Burma/Myanmar, Han China, and Cambodia

[@tyrian_baal]

I've been studying and reading about Carthage for years now and I tell you, the description in that ending brought me to tears along with the Poem and I'm glad you have made the history of this City State more well known

[@digdugbingo]

This is a wonderfully sad and empathetic documentary that actually sheds light on the downfall of the Carthage empire and what led to its demise. I absolutely recommend this documentary in full. I know it's lengthy however, it is by far one of the best and informative docs on Rome that I've ever seen. Props and respect to the team...

[@theofficialsoldierthatreviews]

I have personally watched the Sumerian episode 11 times. I truly enjoy the immersion into the fall of the first cities.

[@YogiMcCaw]

In many, many ways, the Sumerians set patterns all of western civilization would follow right up to present day. It's humbling. We think we're so great with our Industrial Revolution lasting 250 years. The Sumerians bested us by 10 times that long, and a majority of it was peaceful - a feat we cannot replicate. We cannot go a single generation without some horrible war slaughtering 10s of thousands. We need to check our ego at the door when we are encountering some of the ancient civilizations. In spite of our technology, we still haven't learned some very fundamental things about being human on this planet.

[@reaganwasswa2554]

It's the Assyrians for me. Almost 2000 year culture fell into Oblivion

[@theofficialsoldierthatreviews]

@@reaganwasswa2554 another great episode

[@tomlxyz]

​@@YogiMcCawI'm getting more and more the feeling it's not in spite but because of technology that we have regular wars. With modern transportation and fast communication it's much easier to fight

[@Vicus_of_Utrecht]

​@@tomlxyzfeeding armies is a trivial thing now

[@prowlerjames1552]

Seriously the best guy on you tube to chill and learn with...naturally a story teller...articulate and educated without being opinionated....I can't even say that about myself...so rare

[@VIC-jk2qd]

I’ve recommended this podcast/KZbin channel to all of my friends. Fantastic work. I think I’ve listened to the Byzantine episode 5 times at this point. I would love to see a video on the fall of old kingdom Egypt. Also, on top of being a fantastic history channel, you are a fantastic storyteller.

[@lgorenc]

I've listened to Sumerians more than 50 times. Some of the other episodes more than 10. This is my #2 now. Incredible work!

[@Blisterdude123]

That, as much as the pure history, is what I love about these podcasts. It's the way that art, stories, and poetry are so smoothly woven into the overall narrative, without ever feeling as if the historical integrity has been compromised.

[@starcapture3040]

an episode about al Andules would be fabulous

[@malaikamillions]

Of the abject weirdness the KZbin algorithm used to auto play if I drifted off, thank goddess it now ONLY kicks these videos into rotation for me. I have the most amazing dreams, & yet best sleep, when these play. They are absolutely dreamy when awake, and even more phenomenal when dreaming.

[@lucasjames7524]

Why does each episode make me tear up at some point? This is my favorite KZbin channel of all time.

[@athiefinthenight6894]

The loss of every book in their language is just tragic, imagine all the myths and poems and histories we lost because of it.

[@SalahaldeinAhmed]

This happened many times. By Moguls in Bagdad, and Spanish in Andalusia.

[@og8263]

Muslims did it all over Africa and the middle east​@@SalahaldeinAhmed

[@kingmaker2603]

​@@og8263 Nope muslims didn't do it in even a single city much less all over the place.

[@longandshort6639]

@@kingmaker2603yes the Muslims did as Islam was spread by violent military conquest.

[@Badgerbeard]

@@kingmaker2603 Why do these jealous xenophobes try to sow division wherever they go?

[@Velvet_Intrigue]

One of th best podcasts ever! Thank you so much for all that you do to share the history of the world.