How To Deal With Palestine

00:00 Introduction
04:23 The Principle of Moral Proximity
08:50 Finite Attention
10:50 Palestinian Social Media Inroads
11:31 American Cultural Influence
12:43 Moral Proximity or Elite Solidarity?
14:42 What Does Media Show and What Does It Hide?
15:08 Why Do We Not Care About Other Muslim Lives?
16:55 Do African Black Lives Matter?
17:18 The Case of Central African Republic
18:55 Congo
19:32 Comparing Some Conflict Numbers
20:50 Are Muslims the Most Oppressed Category in the World?
21:37 Focusing on the Local in the Age of Mindless Globalism
30:31 Life Beyond Activism
37:25 Refaat-al-Hariri and Balaach Baloch
39:23 Conclusion
40:26 Meri Nazar Hai Yahaan by Poor Rich Boy • Nazar - Poor Rich Boy

[@bissmahmehmud]

Every single word of this resonated with....you put the point across brilliantly without making it sound like whataboutery

[@feminustani]

Thank you so much, Bissmah. I was quite worried about the whataboutery angle

[@brahm-ahamasmi]

I am also amazed! but she is talking so with so much breadth and so much evidence that people will be lost in getting the "point". The emotional connect isn't developing with the "point". I hope she fixes this.

[@txt4r]

@@feminustani I live in the west your view is fine as you look via Prism of Pakistani culture but your view is very wrong in many ways ( I do not blame you - it is because you live in Pakistan) I pasted a few links but I would like to know if there is a way I can write an article to submit where Pakistanis can read it if you have any recommendation then please let me know ( I am open to submit article and become a co writer if someone wants to partner )

[@PrashantSingh-my1be]

Good to see you back Sabahat..love your nuanced take on a very sensitive subject

[@mmehar996]

Brilliant presentation. Everyone should listen and learn from her. She is most important professor and thinker in Pakistan. Hope all young generation learn from her. This video should be shared in high schools and universities.

[@txt4r]

limited view though

[@digitalSurge0n]

Professor? Thinker? I guess the bar for anything is low in Pakistan

[@doubleslit3066]

Madam ......What about the Moral proximity of Pakistani Christian & Hindu.... Plz raise awareness regarding this issue in pakistan

[@ahmadjamalmughal47]

Congratulations on new mic ustani ji. And also on whole new studio setup, as it appears. It is always a pleasure listening to you, it's good break from regular internet, thank you. It's so comprehensive you could say it makes the most of tawajjo ki maeeshat. I have to watch it again, main kehna wan dil khush kar dita yar. 🙏

[@Patrice-Meursault]

Nice analysis ma'am❤ But I have one request that can you please keep on making these long video essays?

[@bradmayer1639]

No this is not a nice analysis, it is completely biased and wreaks of illiteracy. You are an id-tiot. SHe is an overground worker for Palestine.

[@zainabaurangzaib7106]

I have been talking about this for a long time. Focus on local issues, talk about baloch genocide, ahmadi's genocide,forced marriages of hindu girls in sindh and so many more issues present here.

[@ChefbyMistake]

These issues are because of the Pakistani Establishment a common Pakistani doesn't care about race or religion neither is he Interested in marrying a Hindu or Christian girl. These Issues and the Palestinian Issue is a self-created problems.

[@txt4r]

@zain - so if you have 5 children you suggest only focus on 2 who live near you and ignore the other 3 ? Muslim is one Ummah - if one is in being victimized we all have an obligation to stand with them focus on local issue does not mean you need to ignore what is happening to others in the world

[@fanthony]

@@txt4rwhy are there not protests bigger than the ones that have been organized in favor of Hamas to highlight the more deadly plight of all the other Muslims affected elsewhere in the world? Why is Palestine a more worthy cause in the mind of the Ummah when we know that factually more Muslims continue to suffer and die in far greater numbers even as we speak in other parts of the world?

[@TenzinSanta]

​@@txt4r when religion stock in urs Asshole than u talked liked that, so u doesn't care about minority of Pakistan, ty r also urs brother and sisters dude, wat mean by Muslim aumah , if all Muslim r urs brother than why 8 lakh afghani r kicking out frm Pakistan, in the condition Hamas and Isreal both r wrong, when Hamas attack innocent civilian, u don't feel pity on them, Calling Allah hu akbar and killing, raping a Isreal girls, can u justified this shit,

[@sunia.9426]

I am only halfway through the video and it's refreshing to see how you are taking things step by step and actually putting in effort to explain things without being condescending

[@mmehar996]

Thanks, brilliant.

[@feminustani]

Glad you liked it!

[@SachinDolittle]

Wow Mere kafi sare confusion aaj dur ho gye Thanks itni impactful video bnane k liye ❤

[@SubodhKumar-tz9bo]

Wow Best analyst of Pakistan on Palestine till now on. I know in India/Modi people simps of Israel for Technology & Weapon . But Deep down they all support 2 state. Its social media which intensity the rage . In real world nobody care in india about Israel Palestine war except muslim community. We are fighting for malnutrition, Poverty, how do $2.6K per capita developing country eradicate it . We didn't realate with Israel Palestinian , Russian Ukraine war until our finace affect it. We can support moraly. Although thanks for the amazing content.

[@genuinebombayite1966]

Beautiful analysis, Sahabatji! Aapke videos aur analysis ka humein besabri se intezaar reheta hai! Aur aap se main kaafi Urdu bhi seekh leta hoon! Bahot bahot shukriya aapka 🙏! Best wishes to you all the way from Baltimore, MD, USA!

[@anarkali_217]

thanks for making it. struggling to make terms with what is happening n what can one do about it. U put all together in a very beautiful way.

[@relax_your_mind_Nature_8944]

Your insights are truly inspiring! In just a few moments, you've managed to shift my perspective and see things in a whole new light. Your wisdom and influence are deeply appreciated and incredibly impactful. May Allah help you to bring more content like this because, sadly, such truths are not allowed to be spoken in our country.

[@muhammadhussain7976]

I love how you always keep it real with your facts and sensible takes. Your content is not only engaging but also super informative. Keep the good work up!

[@Comon-l9b]

The analysis is insightful. I've been trying to explain to some of my friends who frequently share such posts that while we sympathize, it's not within our control and thus we can't offer a solution, especially being in Pakistan.

[@zobiahareem6493]

I have always waited for your video ❤. Such a great analysis you presented❤❤.

[@TrulyYoursInDreams]

Nuanced, relevant, broad and brave. Learnt a lot . Stay happy , stay healthy and stay safe.❤

[@censorednoman1]

Soo well said Sabahat! Every word endorsed.

[@soumyapaloor6115]

Thank you for this video. This is equally relevant for us Indians

[@sarahkhan3711]

A very wise analysis! Wish there were more people who thought like you.

[@sharjeeljawaid]

Excellent analysis. Jazakallah!

[@adilyousaf5388]

So well articulated.

[@unknown9288]

Great analysis 👌🏼👍🏼👏🏼❤️.

[@txt4r]

This is very typical misguided view of typical Pakistani Journalists because they do not have clear understanding of how Western Democracies work ( no one living outside West can have that understanding) In this Global world Muslims can make a lot of difference in many ways from Boycott brands to learning about lobbies in Western world

[@user-ml6op5jp6z]

AOA maam waiting for your videos please koshish karen tawatur k saat aye i know k your videos take so much time but be regular or try to come live cz i learn so much things from you .

[@Shakeel.Irshad]

Ufff, wow, very balanced and logical analysis... It's difficult to speak with nuance on such sensitive topics but you done it... We can merely hope best for all oppressed people of World

[@tasrbcpa]

What should the miserably failed state of Pakistan should do about Pakistan?

[@ammaryasir3841]

Never a time wasted on this channel ❤

[@minhajraza6740]

Behtreen Analysis 👍🏼

[@AsmaAsrarQureshi]

Thanks

[@ammaryasir3841]

So brilliant, insightful and thought provoking

[@TheSinner749]

October 7 dekh kar nind aa gaya tha??

[@amina2571]

This is all so well thought out. I really hope Pakistani people start to think more deeply about their activism and it's intersections + interactions with all the various factors involved.

[@ziarehman4421]

War and religions are business.

[@nazirbaloch613]

aap bout kam videos shot karthee hain ,,,,,, i am your big fan

[@CanadianStargazer]

Elightenment can be experienced by all human beings. Obviously, it is not limited to Lord Budha only (no offense to followers). I may be wrong, but I tend to think that two major reasons/factors are food (we eat) and genetics, are at work. Love your works but I think you should consider writing more books(?)

[@SaifullahJatoi-oh4ri]

You said what i had been thinking about the selective activism etc.

[@Abdullahahmed-yw3gn]

Love your videos! I've some ideas to share with you, What's the best possible way to contact you directly? Let me know I'd love to have a conversation with you.

[@tasrbcpa]

How many Palestinians were murdered by Pakistan in September 1970? How many Syrians have been murdered by Assad? How mamy Yeminis have been murdered by Saudi Arabia?

[@ChefbyMistake]

This is not a good argument. 1) How many Syrians openly support Israel ? 2) How many Yemenis protested against Saudi Arabia ?

[@Aroma-wn3pr]

Excellent video

[@bajrangmma4929]

👏

[@kailasjawale1503]

One of the best Pakistani podcast

[@Vkswami_Chari_GVP]

Hope i get answers, if not get answers with correct way. A_) First you deal and set it right your country Pakistan then later on think on Palestine. B_) Did u seen any Jhulm and Jhakti u did to minorities like Hindus, Christians, Sikhs Jains jews in your country and B.1) Did any time u raised voice against force conversation of Hindu or Christian girls to Islam aged below 15 years via kidnap or rape or married to old age man 40+ years. C_) Why did u Muslim want sharia law in UK or USA or Europe, Russia, India to be forced on Non-Muslims. D_) Why u Muslims want Equality/ citizenship rights/ secularism in Europe, India, USA and Non-Muslim countries and but not give equality and citizenship rights/secularism in your Islamic countries.

[@shahidraza7207]

Is qaum ko jis marzi side pe laga do lag jaye gae, lekin apne neighbourhood mein kisi Mazloom ki madad nhn karein gae. Aur manafiqat tou is Kader hai in mein ke apne mulk ki minorities pe Zulm jaiz thehraty han aur Israel ke khilaf nawry lagaty han

[@nofilkhan6743]

Establishments project of tying the relation of educated punjabis with the citizens of other muslim countries ( palestine) so they can ignore all problems at home. Once you syep out of Lahore and go to a place in South Punjab, then you can see the reality of Pakistan. Plus it was saraiki labourers, not punhabi..

[@user-kx4qw6ku6q]

I am curious which institution you studied in, I mean, you are so well-educated

[@ha3908]

I remember sharing the Idea of we are not in America so can we should stop say and do whatever happens there and everyone looked at me like am crazy

[@Realt0rReels]

Bhajan was good. whatever feels good to you is good for you and whatever is not good for you is evil. There will always be 2 sides, one is doing bad, and it is good for them, and the other side is getting crushed and it's bad for them or evil.

[@GolamZakaria-rj7ki]

before we call east pakistan .now bangladesh phalestin issue also same

[@wasifmumtaz9661]

There is an old theory in communication studies called Two Step Communication which says that communication reaches to the masses in two steps: source and some opinion leaders or influencers. In this case the American universities became the influencer and opinion makers which catapulted the weak voices from Palestine to the world at large. You are spot on that we live in an “American World” and follow their culture and counter culture as high culture. We conveniently forget everything else which has not American stamp on it.

[@MumtazHussain-vn3sd]

Amazing listened to you for the first time and you make a lot more sense than most of our brainless KZbinrs ❤

[@SeventyFive-gn9kh]

Order more stuff from Lockheed?

[@zk6239]

Why Capitalism is not discussed. If we deeply think on all these issues, we find a capitalist mindset everywhere. Maybe we also need capital to survive, that's why we can't be unbiased completely. This is how the system is established.

[@HappyForestTrees-si8lx]

Aap nay kon Sa awaz utha li mazloom logo kay haq may siwae 8 march walay din kay? Mazloom kahin ka bhi mazloom hota hay, mujhay nahi pata tha kay aap ko itni takleef hogi Gaza ki himayat ki waja say

[@ImranNafees-xo5ru]

Amazing video. I hope viewers are able to look at this analytically - and apply the message in the video on the video itself :)

[@ImranNafees-xo5ru]

Retroactively

[@arshad8455]

Nothing you said has any basis in the Quran. Its all about your views, your thoughts, and your opinions. me, me, me.

[@onlyPROFIT_BITCOIN]

she will try to bring islam to gather more followers

[@CanadianStargazer]

10:35 "Being a victim is powerful"

[@jhonelia5316]

Mera pyara femunistani baby

[@Qasim7W2]

So, How to Deal with Palestine? By Ignoring Palestine :)

[@user-ce2gy5oe2p]

There's just only one solution for the Palestine problem with Israel. Each and every Palestinian needs to live with PEACE with Israel, and to avoid terrorism !

[@rameshrajs8140]

The problem is you only feel bad for muslims ... Why ? What about humanity in general ?

[@feminustani]

Please watch the video before making absurd claims

[@relax_your_mind_Nature_8944]

hahahahah..Are you kidding

[@relax_your_mind_Nature_8944]

you don't even watched video

[@shawnbutt]

Ramesh… you have the absolute right to make any statement u wish. I will only request you to watch the whole video and then re-publish the same message if you feel the same. We all, in our haste, judge books by their covers or News articles by their headlines. 🙏🏻

[@Vkswami_Chari_GVP]

@@feminustani Give me the links u raised voice for Hindus, Christians in Pakistan or in any Islamic country. I given questions to u in once of above comment, hope i get replies from you with valid reason, not just saying for the saying.

[@arifmaghribi]

Mark my words, due to these protests in favor of Gaza, Trump will win. 01-07-2024.

[@atanumandal3586]

You can see the brutality going on in Palestine... But Can't you see the *brutality going on Kashmir?* . . . . . . The brutality being done by Pak Army on people of POK & GB??

[@noumanabbasi9547]

Hanhhh propaganda same as before do you think they(Pakistani army) will hunt down us easily???!!! I am from ghariduppata Azad Kashmir there are problems that need to be solved but we don't live in curfew just like on the other side of border there is no violence in GB as well there are sectarianism in GB on the basis of that violent incidents happened in different parts of GB so don't try to relate sectarian type incidents with other things.

[@rrao7963]

​@@noumanabbasi9547 Israel zindabad

[@ImranNafees-xo5ru]

Chorein sb.. you’re beautiful. And your appeal is of a timeless variety .

[@vijendergsp5690]

Ma'am, kya aapko 7 oct 2023 ko nind aa gyi thi ? were you sleep well 7 october 2023

[@akmunchkin]

Boycott! Boycotts work! Stop drinking coke for starters. Also donate to UNRWA and legitimate charity orgs working in Gaza. That's all we Pakistanis can do for now.

[@txt4r]

Journalist is a product of low grade education in Pakistan has no clue what works internationally or in the west BLIND LEADING THE BLIND

[@Dr.HanumantBahirat]

जय जगत

[@The.Scum.Z]

Please refer to Zulm and jyaati ka matalam in Slamic context ,and then pl comment