How & Why did Vedic Astrology Begin? | Origins & History of Astrology | Ancient India |Hindi w Eng

[@shantanupattnayak1601]

Hora is a Sanskrit word not a Greek word which means "time" also varga . Greek language also originate from Sanskrit.Greece has influence of Sanskrit.

[@RohitPatil-13aug96]

😂

[@chiggywiggy524]

Here comes another andh bhakt 🤦‍♂️

[@hrishavjoshi2669]

Vedic astrology didn't come from greece. They had their parallel system hence still we have sidereal and tropical astrology. The system of Rashi came from the west but nakshatra came from the east if you see now nakshatra and Rashi are overlapped. After west influence, Rashi was preferred instead of the nakshatra. Who says Jyotish is not mentioned in Veda? Chaturmas and darshapurnimas yagna are mentioned in Vedas. To calculate the timing for chaturmas or darshapurnimas Siddhanta was already developed. Parashara was a pre Vedic rishi and he wrote brihat Parashara hora shastra and you say hora word came from Greece? Do some research before making a video. There is a thing called archeoastrology which verifies the history on basis of the planetary alignment mentioned and it goes back before Ramayana.

[@cokguzeladam]

before ramayana? it wasn't a true event that happened man i thought we were way past this debate

[@aryansharma-pw6km]

Exactly, these ignorant fool can never understand the value of our sacred civilization .

[@PremSingh-ev4mo]

Don't worry she has been brainwashed

[@kunal1480]

Nice sir

[@chiggywiggy524]

Hora is literally a Latin word 🤡🫵

[@mssharma1510]

Completely wronge. There is a Vedic mantra nakshatra sukta in rigveda which represents 27 stars. Indra sukta which mainly represent antares (jyesta) star. Aswini mantra which represents betta, gamma stars of arietis. Each and every star, constellation is praised in Vedas. Yama sukta - bharani Bramha sukta - rohini Rudra sukta - ardra Sarpasukta- ashlesha Pitrusukta- makha Vayusukta- Swathi Agnisukta- vishaka Indra sukta - jyesta Dhruva sukta- druva (polarstar) Navagraha sukta- 9 planets Saraswati sukta- lyrae constellation Vishnu sukta- entire northern sky Hiranyagarbha sukta- Galactic center...........etc.

[@astrology_mentor]

Your voice is so sweet & no doubt presentation is awesome/ beautifully narrated... But one thing I must add for viewers Astrology is a Science & in Bharat it is Bhartiya Jyotish /Surya Siddhanta .There are so many classics on Astrology ,written by our great ancestors.. like ..Prashar ,Gemini,Brighu & many more , plz do't forget their contribution ...In ancient times Aryavrat /Bharat was very rich in every field of life Especially in Arts & Sciences , everyone knows ...even these days Bharat is a hub for forign visitors they come here to learn .Bharat is a Guru on Earth. ..👍

[@lasbaraprehs5818]

Super Information. Thank you so much. Kuch PDF ke liye telegram chanal link hay to plz dene ki kirpa kijiye

[@micheles4064]

Enjoy your videos. Wish this was in English. Very interested in the subject

[@HistoriaMaxima]

Thank you so much :) I have added the English subtitles to this video now - take a look. It might happen that visuals may not always match the English subtitles you're reading and that's because the visuals were set to the Hindi script speed. Sentence lengths are not always similar in Eng and Hindi... but I do hope you will still enjoy the video now :) Do let me know :)

[@micheles4064]

Historia Maxima much better. Thank you.

[@amartyaprakash897]

@@micheles4064 Please English me mt dalna Ni to jitne log dkhege usse jyada log dkhna band kr dengee

[@ikartikthakur]

But why Hellenistic astrology works on tropics and Vedic in sidereal?

[@chiggywiggy524]

Cause Babylonians figured out that the constellations are shifting from their original placement.

[@ikartikthakur]

@@chiggywiggy524 zodiacs are made from sun n moon's apparent motion around earth. sun travels 1/12th circle for 1 full circle of moon around earth. This makes 12 zodiac around earth. Babylonians used constellation then symbolized for ease of use. When sun reaches vernal equinox that marks 0° Aries. It 21st march always irrespective of Aries constellation , it can shift. Stars are just marking for simplicity. Sun's path creates zodiac. Babylonian's didn't corrected their zodiac for this reason. Prediction's are based on just stars alone that's nothing to with zodiac either.

[@sudeepchopra4315]

Aho mtlb din or ratra mtlb raat Or aho ka ho or ratra ka ra mila kr hua hora or iska mtlb hota hai ghanta To kya aho or ratra ye dono greek sabd hain?

[@predator7418]

The subtitles arent matching with the voice ..kindly fix it

[@HistoriaMaxima]

I tried. It's tough because these are 2 different languages, so I just deleted them...Maybe I'll add them again but they can't match coz sentence length is in Hindi are not the same as in English

[@Mainak_Mallick]

But mam, with due respect, parashar kaun the, wo to vedic period ka rishi the, matlab 1500 bce ki.....to us samay mein greek invation hua tha kaya....nahin to wo books fraud hay....aur varahamihir jaise itna bara scientist......'Brihat jataka' kaise likha??? Wo to predictive astrology hay......phir, either he was fool or the book does not really belongs to him?

[@PrachiSharma-yb2ll]

Nice videos. Plz try to make video on cleopatra, an egyptian queen . Your videos are very informative yet so simple

[@HistoriaMaxima]

Thank you, Prachi :) Thanks for the idea - on it :)

[@rry1994]

I disagree with the theory. Sanskrit, latin and Greek has many similarities and that certainly doesn't mean that similar words mean the knowledge has flown from West. It also discredits and cancels the great rishis and tries to malign the greatness of Indian sages. Poorly researched.

[@gouthamkrishnan6718]

She doesn't said indian astrology entirely came from Greek ones just said it is influenced by greek astrology

[@sapanagholve5006]

All the best!!

[@mayursatav7182]

Hello ma'am could you please mention here some books about the ancient Indian mathematicians, I want to read more about this.

[@Brpwndood]

Probably from the greeks too

[@mahaabhiratnajitjadhav]

This is very important points.

[@hareshbhatkar1636]

Thank You.

[@shantanupattnayak1601]

Sister do full research before making video. It's proven that veda is atleast 8 thousend years ago written book , It may be more . So called western said it is originate in Mesopotamia which is part of ancient Bharat not in the Greece. From my research it is originate in Bharat not elsewhere. Then it spread to west i.e. Greece.

[@himanshuusain]

M jb dekhne lga to socha glt info hogi but ye dekh kr sach me achha feel hua

[@ramkrishankumar]

Very informative videos as well as your sweet voice.

[@rishabjain6549]

Even history says monday is rest day ..

[@vikramadityaparihar563]

Thanks a lot. This information is actually genuine.I always believed that Indian astrology was derived from Greek one as far as I have studied and u proved me true. Now I understood all the game. Astrology is nothing but a fantastic research of human brain of ancient western people. It's the part of that energy of universe that decides our destiny which Greeks discovered after Babylonians .You cleared out my dilemma. Hats off to you.

[@VijaySingh-ht7sy]

I only like for your interesting narration style 🤣👌

[@rakeshwarnathmishra5647]

It was nice presentation and full of knowledge

[@mahaabhiratnajitjadhav]

Thanks for insights.

[@AdhuraEditor]

😂 solid.।। mere kaam ki video nikli.।।

[@virajrandhawa8028]

Nice video... good knowledge...

[@ThiagoOdy]

The legends don't correspond to what is being said... Why did you do this?

[@HistoriaMaxima]

There's a difference between history and legend. That's why I did this

[@lakhanshahi3637]

Great information about new vision astrology. Thanks...from Kathmandu

[@nabyendumandal6729]

But one doubt Shri Krishna born on brisha Rashi. Then how can you tell that the idea of astrology came from Greek?

[@HistoriaMaxima]

Goodness, I have said that only the idea of PREDICTIVE astrology originally came from the Greeks!!

[@ubuntuber1619]

हे भारतीय देवी, भारत एक acid trip है। भारत एक देश नहीं dimention है। यहां ब्रह्माण्ड की शक्तियों का माया जाल और मनुष्य के मनन के बीच की परत बहुत कम है। यही है भारत का रहस्य जिसमें "आर्य से अंग्रेज़" सभी फसे। जिसे समझा वो ज्ञान समझ कर बस गया, जो न समझा वो धन समझ कर लूट गया।

[@HistoriaMaxima]

How beautiful! :)

[@changetheformula686]

Todra information milla 👍

[@dineshgupta4360]

In fact most of the chapters in so called "Brihat Parashra Hora Shashtra" are copied from greek book "Yavanajatka"..

[@SadmimHossain]

Ayurvedic video's link, please!

[@lazyrokrbhu1]

Astrology is science..

[@theintrovertpanda]

what does it means astrology is real?? Mangal dosh kind of things really exists?? is'nt so scary?

[@theone9077]

Are you astrologist?

[@smritichakravarti7946]

Bahut sundar 👍

[@ketulpanchal12]

Apko pata hoga ham gulam the britisaro ke or vohi greek vale hai To unhone hi sab kiya dhara hai ,abhj bhi vohi sikhaya jata hai Hm to sab budhu hai na Abhi bhi mentally gulam hi hai aap me nahi

[@somanathbidika6149]

Thanks for this information

[@alipasaha7446]

New information. Thank u.

[@Akshar_vedic_Astro]

Hora is Vedic word.... "ahoratra " first and last word minus

[@aditibhardwaj5859]

Bohat hi badhiya information! Aur videos banao please Hindi me..

[@HistoriaMaxima]

Thank you, thank you... ! zaroor banayenge hindi mein aur :)

[@Sukuman-ot4fv]

Nice thanks

[@priyankarrakshit2721]

Such a funny person.. it cracked me when she said hai ram!

[@AnilKumar-wf4bj]

Hora is ASanskrit word based on it hour word is orginated

[@Razer_Gaming12]

amazing😊

[@shivangipatel4032]

Lovely!

[@theone9077]

Are astrologist witcher?

[@suyashmule21]

Then why the astrology is not having in the Greek historical books, why it is in vedic scriptures? Don't fool the people. It's written by the Rishi's only and not from so called Greeks.

[@HistoriaMaxima]

Have you read all the Greek historical works? Obviously not. Try this for a beginner's read at least - iep.utm.edu/astr-hel/

[@proudhindu57]

@@HistoriaMaxima astrology lutne ke liye greeks ne banayi thi india first that jisne astronomy bani aur greek first tha jisne astrology banai Kuch bhi Europe se aye na pahale use verify karo fir mano aur kuch byi india se aye na use man lo fir verify karna hai toh karo warna mat karo.

[@narvachanbhattoo6251]

at least you cleared that its older than vedic time & its true .Asfar as viswaguru there are so many on earth & end those who are try to proove that its only zindia is inborn intellectual on earth because they havent exposef to world .Kua ke mandak

[@astrotalks1863]

You are wrong❌ Because Bhagwan Biswakarma was the first Astrologer & Scientist

[@gyagafon]

And also the ancient alien

[@AnujSharmaFitness]

Madam jo rahu ketu hai jisne samudra manthan ke dauran amrit pee liya tha jiss wjah se vishnu ji ne uska sar thadd se alag kar diya tha aur jo rahu ketu astrology mein itna ehem role play krte hai wo greece se aaye hai ?????? Wahan ye story hai????? Apne facts clear kar liya karo pehle adhura gyaan hanikarak hai

[@gyanaranjanmahapatra533]

What a voice myadam maza ata he sun ne me

[@kannyx8350]

Again I’m really not offending you or anything I’m so sorry you are amazing but these are the facts you can do better just try this out not for this subject but choose whatever subject but completely explain that from origin to sustainability and current situation Great simple visuals and honestly amazing which is why I’m typing so much because it’s so good I just wish it was true so much hard work you have put but facts are bit kacha

[@shubhamgaikwad457]

Video was nice humorous, informative But try to have some objective before writing script, only then it will be worth watching by millions

[@HistoriaMaxima]

Thanks for the feedback... how do you mean "objective"? My purpose was to give unbiased info on the history of astrology...

[@shubhamgaikwad457]

@@HistoriaMaxima I found information was scattered. That need to be line up in proper sequence to convey your message. Just like storytelling. Otherwise u r doing good job

[@Jeevaji14]

Vedic astrology comes from tamil, they had sidderiyal calendar ancient times

[@theone9077]

Mean astology is from Greek.. Actually in islamic history our God gave this knowledge to one of the prophet named hazrat idrees a.s..and it is also there in Jewish scripture like Hazrat issa a.s

[@nareshzala2478]

Kyu logo ko galat jankari de rahe ho. Greek influence matlab aryan invasion theory ko justify kar rahe ho . How old is haddapa culture you have a any idea . Kya apko pata he rugved me sarasvati river ka mention kiya gaya he . Sarasvati river ko vilupt hue 3000 saal se jyada hogye. Rugved sabse puraana granth he almost 6000 se jyada puraana or wo time Mahabharata se bhi purana he

[@priyankarrakshit2721]

Okay.. i feel greek and sanskrit have a common ancestral origin..

[@ShubhamSharma-ko9ni]

he writes a book before neton and enstine ever exist

[@kannyx8350]

Hey you have a great voice great animation and amazing presentation.... out of all the videos I saw your video was the only one that was simple relatable and not irritating You have great potential But your not fully utilising it.... please don’t get offended I’m not trying to insult you and I’m not a heckler or anything. I honestly loved everything but girl fact check.... but see beauty even though I knew you were wrong I still continued watching because the graphics and voice were very impressive Why not use it with right information? Ask your team to fact check everything over a hundred times and get dates right! I explain why dates are important later.... and other thing you cought my attention but you also lost it just as easily.... Now just me as an example I’ve been obsessing over chronological timelines and mythology religion evolution of man kind etc etc for days now trying to find a connection... so when I saw your video in my search I clicked on it but the next video was nothing got to do with this So checked out your playlist and even there you are jumping from one topic to an other topic and it’s bits and pieces.... all vedios are good but please understand that you have to stick to one topic and finish it bits and pieces starting with something generic and then deeper bits and then the complicated parts and put that as one set! Like this a person like me will stay hooked for atleast 4-5 videos and then change the topic it’s ok Like here you started with astrology ka origin (which is wrong) but challo you started with the origin of astrology so now next explain in short about our 5 planets, 2 stars and the shadows Next move on to constellation Then each planet has his own story explain that and what it signifies Then move on the complicated part of how planets are related to the constellation The conclude with the most complex part of relating everything to Morden science and how days of the weeks are 7 and how the time is 24 hours a day The end Now let me explain why your wrong in this video first of all we did not adapt from Greeks they took versions of Hinduism.... I know you’re going to argue but challo since you mentioned Alexander the Great who invaded India. Do you know who was the first king he fought? That king was Porus. So Porus had no religion before Alexander the Great? Google nearchus He was a soldier in Alexander the Great’s army who has written that India had Vedic medicines and were far better and effective than there’s he also mentions Hinduism as it’s hospitality anyways that’s a big story not important Look Alexander the Great came to India in 326BC Indus Valley civilisation is a civilisation matlab first time man was forming something now that something evolves slowly wait I’ll explain in next sentence so Indus Valley civilisation is from 23,000-15,000 BC

[@ankurpandit3706]

सूर्य सिद्धांत आर्यभट्ट ने लिखी थी ?

[@siddhantchavan6862]

Aisa kyo laga ki apko tamiz nahi bat karne ki. Aur dusra ye ki apko Hinduism pat koi proud nahi

[@krithacks509]

❤

[@mohitesanjivani2901]

Information provided really helpful about astrology

[@simplensample2724]

Horooo-shaastra from horoscope

[@shaileshmotar2099]

Wow

[@gyagafon]

Ancient aliens, and trying to separate from the creator

[@Mr.chandravanshi_0II0]

ग्रीक he india से leke hora kiya or bad mai इससे hour krdiya 😂afsos

[@proappstore]

Really funny🔥🤝

[@preethirakala6904]

Being women.. u r telling kitni lutayega..shame🙄

[@theone9077]

Bhoout khuss 🤣

[@sahilmahi1083]

😀👍😀

[@smritichakravarti7946]

Good information 👍👍👍❤️

[@theone9077]

😂😂u r funny

[@slokaroy7020]

😂 good oratory

[@omprakashshukla1458]

कुछ भी बोल दिया वीडियो बनाने के लिए।कैसे कह दिया मैडम जी की वेदों में astrology ka प्रमाण नहीं है।एक बार पुनः अध्ययन करे

[@rocco2181]

Astrology ekdam bakwass 😂