Understanding Pakistan’s Military Business Network Ft. Ayesha Siddiqa | EP244

[@owaisawan5542]

Ayesha Siddiqa's this book is one of the best book i have ever read

[@PUPILOFWORLD]

کہاں سے ملتا ہے

[@legend-ox3hj]

What a personality aisha siddaqua masallah Allah bless you

[@salmankayani9169]

What a great podcast. Every Pakistani needs to listen to this podcast.

[@kashirkhan8560]

Excellent analysis. Dr Ayesha Siddiqa is a great speaker and analyst on military operations

[@khurramamanullah2750]

Wonderful conversation and I learnt a lot - Proud of Aysha Siddiqa - honest and very brave!!

[@ShahidAli-ie5td]

Shayan aap ne bohot acha podcast ki.I will be very pleased if you invite her again. Shukrya

[@ahmedhasssn.01]

Brave lady , may allah protect her . ❤

[@globalislamicreminders]

Hope the whole of Pakistan can get to see this video

[@mohammadinamullah9380]

What is the fundamental problem with Pakistan is lack of common man's participation in political leadership. Politics is totally dominated by feudal elites in Pakistan. As a result military in Pakistan established itself as composite institution.

[@muhammadasadullahsaeed9778]

شفافیت پاکستان کے ہر محکمے اور شعبے میں ہونی چاہیے ۔۔۔

[@keenkhan6205]

ڈئیر عائشہ ہر پاکستانی نوجوان سوچ رہا ہے کہ فوج کو سیاست سے آوٹ ہونا چاہیے۔ سیاستدان یہ بولیں یا نہ بولیں اہم بات یہ ہے کہ عوام سمجھ چکے ہیں

[@jrykmr]

Ayesha sahiba makes a lot of sense.

[@abidacassam4118]

Enjoyed this interesting enlightening talk. Thanks Ayesha Saheba. Stay safe!

[@rafiqhussain-ib6uj]

Absuluty right speech. I salute u.

[@haqatta]

What a Brave lady I m big fan of her and admirer of her. God save her .

[@aanakrukavi]

Thank you Jinnah for taking out the weed from India in 1947 😂

[@DesiJugaarDIY]

Thank you Jinnah for taking us out of weed in-fact , this current situation is awakening not declining .

[@Shekhru121]

still he forgot UP but what can we do

[@arshadraza6506]

If this the case then retuthe Juna Gurah, Punjab, Kashmir, etc. Then the weed will be fully out​@DesiJugaarDIY

[@saqibnawaz8110]

Very educated and outspoken lady.... I really admire her class 🎉

[@afzalmuhammad6776]

Listening the whole conversation Many lessons for #ik

[@tasawarkhan8839]

Waiting for her second episode. Lot of love 💗💗💗

[@aliagha7214]

Superb Awesome Fantastic Mind-blowing 👌🏻👏🏻

[@israr872]

Words of Wisdom from Ms. Ayesha, Such a tremendous person of knowledge, kudos to the host for such informative podcast 👏 👍

[@salmankayani9169]

Great podcast. Kindly bring her back for another podcast. ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@nadiaahs]

Thank you for speaking the truth. You said the golden words " To the Pakistan Military Pakistan is equivalent to Punjab only (sindh, balochistan and nwfp doesn't matter). This mentality has to change to bring stability in Pakistan. I am not sure whether this will happen during my lifetime

[@HIMJIOK]

اس بی بی کا بہت بڑا کردار ہے اینٹی فوج عوام بنانے میں ۔ میں اس کا بڑا فین تھا ۔ آج یہ بڑی خوش ہوگی کہ سارے فوج کے خلاف ہوگے ہیں ۔ مجھے یاد ہے اس پر سابق فوجی بھارتی لکھاری ہونے کا الزام لگاتے تھے ۔ اس کی کتاب ہر سکول اور یہ پاوڈ کاسٹ ہر بچہ کو سنانی چاہیے ۔ بڑا ہوگیا اب بیرک میں واپس جاو

[@MohdYaseen-gq5eq]

ہمارے بزرگ کہتے تھے کہ فوجی کی عقل اسس کی تھوڑی میں ہوتی ہے آج یہ بات سمجھ آی محترمہ کے پوڈکاسٹ میں

[@Kamran-vu6hc]

Very good podcast. Ms. Ayesha Siddiqa is a legend and the podcaster Shayan Mahmud also deserves praise due to his pointed and intelligent questions to the interviewee

[@tarcoal]

Zabardast Aisha sahiba

[@ashrafjehangirqazi1497]

Brilliant analysis by Dr Ayesha Siddiqa. In Pakistan Manzur Pashteen has the makings of a genuine national leader willing to face down the Army. But because of that he has not been allowed to broaden his political following beyond the Pashtun. The military of Israel is hugely popular with Israeli civilians because of its military record against Arab armies. Sadly the Pakistan Army to put it politely cannot match this record. The only Muslim country's army that enjoyed a similar respect is the Turkish army - and even this respect was compromised by its efforts to constrain civilian supremacy until Erdogan emerged and survived military conspiracies to eliminate him. In addition, the Israeli army has not taken comprehensive control of the Israeli economy. Its influence over Israeli strategy flows from its record of success on the battlefield and not the abuse of its power against its own civilian leadership as has happened in Pakistan. Of course, the whole of Israel including its IDF is a raging cancer implanted in the body politic of the Arab world. Nevertheless, inefficient and greedy militaries may conquer their own civilians but they can never conquer the enemy. The only solution to this challenge lies in organizing and sustaining civilian resistance. Imran Khan today is the only leader attempting to do this.

[@Assasin89FT]

As a nation and to become a real nation and nation state, we must have to engage parliament, academia, military, judiciary and all civil society how to run this in long term under the Constitution of Pakistan. Efficient parliament Professional military (w/out politics, economy) Independent judiciary Clean bureaucracy All the Check& Balance

[@fatman-q9f]

To know if a country is successful or not, one needs to read the objective for which it was created. The objective to create Pakistan was to secure the interests of a few thousands (the elite, the zamindaars, the waderas, etc). The objective had nothing to do with the average citizen (unhe islam ka nasha kara do, wo usi mein khush hain 77 saal se). Has the objective been achieved? Yes. Hence, implying Pakistan is a very successful country.

[@MaryamKhan-vf3zo]

As if waderas were already not living lavishly in the sub-continent 🙄 the sole purpose of Pakistan was the creation of a state where Muslims can follow their religious practices and laws without any hindrance... It's not achieved yet but it's in the process!

[@rehanapotter1042]

“muslims can follow their religious practices” ??? That has not been achieved in 70 plus years. Is that the sole purpose ? What about honesty, decency, truthfulness, tolerance, cleanliness, thoughtfulness and respect for others - none of these traits exist in Pakistan. You see all if these in the Western world where common decency is seen in day to day life everywhere. We still have a 100 years to get there. Munafiqat kab khatam hogi !?

[@SouthindianNarendra]

Mam be safe ❤ from india

[@jitendrtiwari2530]

Bhai pahle jan liya karo ye uk me rahati hai 😂

[@hkpandey1]

​@@jitendrtiwari2530you really think they can't get her in UK if it comes to that?

[@globalislamicreminders]

Excellent video much needed truth

[@muddassarsaadi]

An eye opening Historical facts 😮

[@EpicDubaiUAE]

Right to the point!

[@artpicksportfolio]

many may criticize me.. But I feel strongly for our army compared to everyone else..

[@Longlivepetergriffin]

In what

[@EnigmaticEgo]

​@@Longlivepetergriffin In real estate business

[@Longlivepetergriffin]

@EnigmaticEgo I think our politicians, judges, military elites, civil servants all are corrupt bastards

[@ali_bahar_bhatti]

Such an important information

[@Hamsafar2016]

عائشہ صدیقہ ۔۔۔ایک بیباک مصنف ہیں ۔۔ آپ کی جرات کو سلام

[@ShayanAli-d6t]

MISS AYESHA SIDDIQUA FROM KHANQAH SHRIEF SHE IS OUR NEIGHBOUR AND KHANQAH WALON KA SALAM

[@Umar-s6e]

Heyy, you're from which khanqah? Karachi wali?

[@ShayanAli-d6t]

@@Umar-s6e no bro Bahawalpur 🥰🥰🥰

[@rehanapotter1042]

Brilliant !!

[@kashirkhan8560]

Looking forward to have another podcast with Dr Ayesha

[@MuhammadIqbal-en4vk]

Constitutional path and boundaries need to be respected by all

[@ghazanfarhussain5032]

What is your Complaint ❤? 4:35

[@HarrisMasoodYT]

you're very brave for doing this podcast, much appreciated. The dam of information has finally cracked

[@AhmedKamal-yd1mq]

Thanks

[@ajmaeenmahtab8456]

If the Pakistan army can make money and sustain itself by doing business then what's wrong with it.

[@saleemsayed1108]

If they R more in Making Money, than they loose their Fighting Capabilities...East Pakistan is the Prime Example....Any Army ; if it loose poularity amnog its people. it cannot fight aganist Real Enemy.

[@nooruddinabro6958]

The nice and simple way of description i really learned a lot from madam .

[@Assasin89FT]

“Government” is not a widely taught subject in our education as in many other countries.

[@earth6205]

Big fan from Gilgit Baltistan ❤❤❤❤

[@arshadraza6506]

Pak Army will never leave you alone until pak politicians will be honest, visionary, strong character and not ready to compromise on anything etc.

[@shayanmahmud6832]

Let us know if you enjoyed this content!

[@samiyamlk5]

What wd ur next edition include? Will it be military ink to judiciary ink?

[@MasaudAtif]

excellent miss aysha❤❤❤

[@uk4490]

Thanks for this podcast. Please don't delete it on napakbhoj's pressure.

[@tahirhabib4056]

Good

[@TableegDeen-i8z]

Very very very good 😊❤ video Salutes.

[@shivampatil23]

Kala dala reaching destination soon 💀💀

[@ashutosh5663]

😂😂😂

[@farhanjabbar1116]

She is in usa

[@Gurdevsingh-s7r6z]

You are great Lady 👍

[@adnangul1202]

Every Pakistani, civilian or military person should read her book Military INC.

[@AK-gi1ke]

Pakistan civil economy cannot support expenses of army , so army indulges in businesses to support itself Also to support themselves or enemies will buy some You didn’t mention the ineptness of civilians politicians, dishonesty, corruption and mismanagement of bureaucrats So you need to blame both parties

[@bashirahmad9166]

"Good or Bad" is an emotional expression. It's suicidal if applied anywhere, private life, institution or a stat.

[@Khan-dg9gv]

She is another thick head journalist. Probably today if Pakistan is existing is because of Army . If we leave this country only on politicians they you you can think of worse situation.

[@ghazanfarhussain5032]

A Muslim soldier Has every Right 👍 To participate in Business ❤❤❤❤ 3:40

[@AsifMehmoodWaince]

Need is that our politicians and Militarly leadership should consider and learn from thoughts of Aysha Jilal to make Pakistan better and it's Military a more professional war Machine to come up to the expectations of Pakistanis.

[@mohammedlateef9919]

Ayesha excellent view points on milbuss best interest of milelites to take corrective measures b4 it is too late

[@AK-gi1ke]

In USA , biggest spender and purchaser is USA army or department of Defence People who were in army or DOP when leave posts became supplier to DOF During President Bush his Def secretary Dick Cheney’s firm Halle Burton made billions by supplying DOF everything for Iraq war Fifty percent of members of congress own all firms producing/ supplying to department of defence Point is Pakistan is not only country where army is controlling most Most of third world falls in same category Whether is wrong or right

[@FurqanKhanoffi]

47:00 to 47:24 bilkul Sach aur talkh haqeeqat and that y nation of Pakistan now hates from army.. very logical from Ayesha siddiqa

[@ijazanwar7257]

One of the problem is one man has so much power There’s no check and balance Now public is more aware of what they have been doing to civilians? No military can succeed without public support

[@MohinKMoh_Kamran]

She is ABSOLUTELY right. Bold woman, a thousand salute to you madam. A million salute to the channel for hosting her. The only issue or rather the only pre-requisite for Pakistan’s stable future is to make the Army say ABSOLUTELY NO, to do any non-military job in the Pakistan. This hollow and imaginary concept of Security State, is now Obsolete.

[@ravi2004ravi]

It is very good that Pakistani Defence forces are running many businesses. This helps them to understand the national better. This is also as per Islam. Just see Islamic History, the military has always played important role in the development of the nation. The Mughals also traders and professional business managers

[@Vladimirprotein09]

Pakistan army Zindabad

[@MudassarMumtaz-hl7pz]

We have no problem how much military is making money but they should not interfere in politics,let the politicians perform independently and let the people select their leaders independently.Our military needs more money to compete with our enemies.

[@SuryanarayanaJagarlapudi]

Mrs. Ayesha siddiqua is obviously very familiar with the problem she is dealing with and knows that it is taboo to talk about the Army and its role in Pakistan because the Army is EVERY THING in Pakistan.

[@jainilvaidya4355]

To see who's ruling you check you cannot criticize

[@Tk-cf2ip]

Pakistan military zindabad, down with the people on Indian payroll like her…

[@younis9819]

When anchors asks a question in Urdu, it is appropriate to answer in Urdu, it sounds prideful to start speaking English when the question was asked in Urdu.

[@jamshedfbc]

😢 Sad state of affairs 😢

[@mohammadmukhtarelahi4264]

Good description.BUT WHAT NEXT.is there any way out for this in Pakistan if so than how.

[@HumayunMirza-s8f]

Quite realistic talk. There is a time when things will start reshaping n that turning point has reached for pak army it's obvious that massacre n force failed to subdued people reaction against establishment rather the tyranny has worked as a catalyst to expose the self centered interests n limitations of the estb. It may take time n happens not suddenly. PTI evolution is also building in this direction n IK resolve to stand solid n not compromise is something which is enough for certain powers to feel he mean business.

[@kapilmhow]

She talks very sensible. Hats off to you madam.

[@ghazanfarhussain5032]

Those who fight in the way of Allah ❤️ Are superior to those who Sit at home 🏡 parliaments ❤😂❤

[@sarfarazahmedlarik]

اس میں کچھ غلط نہیں۔ وہ اپنے اخراجات میں ٹھوڑی بہت سہولت ہوجاتی ہے۔ دنیاں کی اور افواج فوج کے فلاح کیلئے بزنس بھی کرتے ہیں۔ لیکن چھوٹے پیمانے پر۔ بھارت نہ کر پایا ورنہ وہ اس لیول کا بزنس کرنا جاری رکھتے شوق سے۔ سوال یہ ہے کہ پی ٹی آئی کے حمایتیوں کو اس سے تکلیف کیا ہے۔۔۔؟

[@mairajavaid6796]

Unfortunately, these people were right.

[@Adil-g9y]

Even if someone has written a Big Book, if it's showing personal grudge (that's clear from lady's talk) then, it reduces its value. Complainant can't produce independent material.

[@MuhammadFazalUrRehmanSiddiqui]

''The Militrocracy has, unfortunately, entered an era of Pigliotics by feeding Piglioticians.''

[@ghazanfarhussain5032]

Why should Pakistan Change its ethos 11:48 ❤

[@snowman6408]

What is the solution

[@muhammadsohail9272]

Masood hassan ki kitab ka nam batayen koi please jis ka zikr madam ne kia hai podcast me.

[@MuhammadIqbal-en4vk]

Unfortunately, our parliament is much oversized of incompetent, corrupt and criminals elite . For better future we need to have small parliamentary system of competent and honest people who can deliver some thing good for Pakistan

[@RaziAkber-i9z]

Not sure why do people feel so apprehensive about supporting the only national party which has shown enough courage to stand against the system? What proof do these people really need?🤔

[@amjadfiaz4830]

Good anayalsis ❤but land reform also very essential in pakistan

[@ghazanfarhussain5032]

Why should Pakistan Change its ethos 11:48 ❤64% Pakistan is the Feudal society land ❤

[@sarfarazahmedlarik]

Kya Ghalat hai is men...? PTI k puppets ko takleef kya hai...? Duniya men bohat si Afwaj is waqt bhi businesses krti hen. Lekin hum se km level p. Kon nahin chahta apne expenses ko support krne k liye. Hum gareeb mulk hen. Humari economy ki haalat dekhen. Defence budget is lowest hai. Or nahin barh rahi kai saal se. Mehngai k bawajood.

[@usmankhaki]

9:42 dramas

[@UsmaanMukhtarBajwa]

Scary stuff, How can we survive like this ?

[@isloooo]

Amazing podcast... Thanks to the firewall, the video stopped at least 100 times😂.

[@Trading-h3e]

جب عمران نیازی کو فوج نے لایا تھا تو تب یہ پاکستان عوام کی فوج تھی جب نکالا تو اب یہ عوام کی فوج نہیں رہی 😂😂 اس انٹی کا کرش بھی عمران خان ہی تھا اب اس میں ہمارا کیا قصور ہے

[@bluemoonmedia6093]

This is the time to make 25 provinces this is the only way of success for Country

[@ghazanfarhussain5032]

What is the Muslim model 👍? 7:09

[@pawankumarkhera5917]

Dr Ayesha Siddiqua ji aap great hai mera aap ko or pakistan ki Janta ko namaskar hai mai bat bade dhyan sey suna bada dukh hata aap logo mag kar chin kar Pakistan lia lakin aap milttery or politician durat or lalchi unhen apny country sey koi sarokar nahi unhen apny corner ka plot lena hai ya apny children ko amrica mai settle karna ya contrect leny hai jis country itna bura haal hai to bachari public ka hall hoga ismein public ka koi dosh nahin wo inko jhal rahi hai aap logo yai aap man ley ki Pakistan failed state hai ab kya ho sakta hai is par aap logo ko vichar Karna chahiye mere vichar mai aap or mai jitani jaldi is baat man lenge ki aap Hindustani hai yai ek hi mulk hai na hum logo alg alg hai Pakistan ko duniya barbad hone sai Bharat hi bacha sakta hai aap hum milkar banglades ko milkar ek country bany or progres kary humy divied karny ka plan agrejoo ka tha taki ladty rahi bat Kari ab issue hona chahiye ki kab sey unity karni ub aapas mai ladne ka time nahi hai 77years barbad ho warna chukay aap discuss karty rahoge baki country kaha sey kaha pohoch jayge

[@infinitedigitalfuture2152]

Pakistan Army Zindabad ❤

[@sureshpal670]

Hindu suffered a lot in the history Now suffering because of cast system - never ending issues in India