How Old Is It - 06 - The Solar System

[@bimblinghill]

There's a lot of good science videos on KZbin, but the combination of solid fundamental science and your clear delivery mean that these are among the best.

[@johnjallen]

also the music is perfect for this stuff

[@circuitsmith]

Thank you Mr Butler for pacing your narration at a natural rate. Some other science videos edit out the gaps between sentences and pauses for breaths. Makes it hard to keep up and digest.

[@christinearmington]

circuitsmith Very true!

[@sablahedning]

david butler has the best voice to listen to, ever!

[@Trouttaranaki]

You are an inspiration David to me and my son. We both love your videos, he is only 6 but is fascinated with space and will watch along with me all day. Thanks

[@wombatop4069]

I love your videos and the way you narrate each video. It's enjoyable and easier to understand, plus it's fascinating.

[@KartingOB_OSNI]

Greetings from Brasil! All your lessons are really well explained... The best science series by far! Thanks a lot

[@shriyasworld9552]

You surpass all those who have tried to explain matter and space ...all your videos are incredible. Easy to understand graphics and beautiful

[@NarenderKumar-ov9od]

I have no words to appreciate your videos. Simply greatest ever I found anywhere in the world. After all it takes length of life Mr. David Buttler has lived with ultimate hardwork, to gain this level of subject experience, knowledge and dedication to produce videos this incredible level. And yes, not appreciating your soft, silken, lovely and attractive voice because it is God's gift to you 😂😂😂. Hats off. Thank you so much.

[@mathymathhandle]

By far one of the best resources for astronomy which includes the math!!

[@andypottkotter9743]

Love the way you build up to new chapters.

[@vinnyvdalidemonet8527]

I think if Carl Sagan were around today. He, himself would be a big fan of your videos and the work you put in David. I certainly am. Thank you for all your work efforts and sharing.

[@soci0path]

Thankyou so much. Decades of watching similar vidoes the puts it all together.

[@KarlosRaver]

Love this stuff, had a bad day today and and somehow this video is helping. Thank you

[@Jobby1975]

Ive had all his videos on for the past year as relaxation tapes.... love them.

[@mouseutopia]

Perfect last video in the playlist before falling asleep.

[@pmrashidrashid7652]

Beautifully explained! Thanks a lot

[@lvangirardi]

You are amazing , Mr Butler .

[@williamberry8895]

I blow my gf away with the stuff I learn on yt about astronomy, history, science. You really can learn a lot. And surprise people with the stuff you learn

[@condensermike]

Wow! These videos are amazing AND they have links to a text version of the chapters in PDF form! Nice!

[@vivekmudgil1454]

Dear Sir, Wonderful explanation with immense true knowledge of every projects taken by u. I truly admire and praise ur contribution to the entire world for knowing the real facts of the events happens in the history of development of Modern Science and cosmology.With my deepest regards, kindly keep continue ur very useful series of imparting real knowledge of science at such an age. I realise that even it is not possible to explain by anyone in the present time.

[@cosmicnomad9324]

Thank you David.. One of my favourite topic planetary formation..monsoon nights and your lectures are perfect!

[@Lonette]

Love the music. Simply perfect for this video.

[@JMDinOKC]

You could fire a lot of astronomy instructors and just have students watch this and it would be an improvement.

[@falten2]

Yes!! More from David. THX.

[@dextrogyren]

Very clear and instructive exposé embelished by a fine background music. Million thanks Sir!

[@merveilmeok2416]

Thanks “Uncle Universe Mr. Butler.” - Cheers.

[@TheExoplanetsChannel]

:))

[@CrewAirDrop]

Yes David you are the man,please keep it comeing.

[@aok3642]

great for falling asleep standing up

[@goodboy1269]

Professor Butler your videos are perfection! Thank you for sharing with us! A cool drink of wisdom from an intellectual mind. 🔥🔥

[@lahockeyboy]

Thanks for another great video, Professor!

[@SineEyed]

Such great videos. Thank you so much..

[@mylesbishop1240]

Caught the ending subtitle. Great touch Mr. Butler. Another amazing video, thank you

[@Just.A.T-Rex]

Time stamp?

[@haiders79]

awesome lecture. Loved it.

[@danniles5256]

Great work David.Thanks a lot.

[@danwelch5913]

Absolutely wonderful to see your videos ! Such a treat to the day / week. Thank you for putting these together :)

[@adag5813]

Thanks David.. .. you're the man

[@-fuk57]

I love how this man refers to everything as "our" or "ours".

[@Wimpzilla]

Thanks you sooo much four your time and for sharing awesome science. Please stay safe, much love. ❤️

[@autobotbot]

Hell yeah . Love this shit . Ty for the upload .

[@dundeedolphin]

This is the best channel.

[@sragu5468]

சூரியஒளி மிகக்குறைவாக படுவதால் 'Uranus neptune' கிரகங்கள் நிழல்கிரகங்கள் என்று ஜோதிடத்தில் 'ராகு கேது' வாக பார்க்கப்படக்கூடும்

[@jimc.goodfellas]

Mr Butler here, and David Attenborough, have the best most soothing voices

[@lrcavalli290]

Llp L Lll

[@Jobby1975]

Thank you so much for all of these videos.

[@PurnamadaPurnamidam]

David, thanks a lot your explanations are clear cut.

[@mysterymeat586]

I saw a hypothesis put out, I think was from a Nova series, about Mercury's large iron content. It suggested Mercury might have started out as a gas giant that the Sun evaporated due to it's close proximity to the Sun. Got me thinking of another wild idea that maybe Venus, Earth, and Mars could have had the same evolution. The Sun's solar wind would then be too feeble to have any effect on Jupiter.

[@Just.A.T-Rex]

It’s not quite evaporation but I see where you’re going

[@patrickbowers8359]

I learned humans think of time in a linear way

[@patrickbowers8359]

Anyone ever explain how old is our. Own galaxy which we are only in one of its spiral arms

[@howfarawayisit]

Check out How Old Is It chapters 2 and 3.

[@shabouga]

Great videos

[@benivamos]

That was well explained

[@janfda1807]

Sir I like your all videos can you make video for how large is it I mean how do you measure the size of any star galaxy etc

[@tremoxo]

Wish you were my teacher. Because the one i had still assumes Neutrinos doesn't have a mass.

[@no_more_free_nicks]

Hi

[@TheSphinx04]

" I AM OKAY " and " THANK YOU "...

[@matthewfournier6478]

My favorite line is order from choas. I believe God when he says he re-created the earth. We don’t know from the Bible the length of time that the earth sat before recreation. Oh God made the stars also.

[@DogsaladSalad]

thanks dave

[@knowhoim]

Good dose before sleeping

[@losttribe3001]

6:56. My jokester mind imagines a pilot rolling a window down and sticking a net out to capture dust particles... Also, the “genesis” rock from the moon is another line of evidence as to the age of the earth. While there are older samples, the genesis rock ages to just barely 4 billion years, this one came from 300,000 kilometers away!

[@nadavdanieli]

From what I understand the sun will begin growing in size in less than a billion years, and life on earth would be impossible.

[@howfarawayisit]

I understand that it will end that way, but a lot more than 1 billion years will pass first.

[@nadavdanieli]

@@howfarawayisit I have mistaken the Sun size growth loss of CO2 that is related to the raise in Sun temperature. kzbin.info/www/bejne/raiqlnacjMhkZpI

[@Vazmenko]

Excellent, Sir!

[@JoseFernandez-qt8hm]

where is the remnant black hole/neutron star that was left when those neutron stars collided 6billion years ago????

[@philipstevenson5166]

so given biochemistry's fairly narrow temperature range, maybe not many planets warm enough for sunlight-supported surface life but also with water?

[@TWOCOWS1]

Dr Butler, i have learned that earth and the other rocky planets are the "second generation" planets, the first one having been destroyed by Jupiter and the other gas giants. Can you explain that in one of these wonderful teaching videos, pls?

[@ZeedijkMike]

Hasn't the planet "creation" been revised after discovering several "non standard" planet systems around other stars?

[@howfarawayisit]

It's not so much a revision as it is an expansion. I'm working on a video on exoplanets. I'll have a lot to say on this there.

[@alivohereiam3780]

Thank you a lot for this amazing video David, love it as always but what happened to the resolution? I can choose only 360p so the text is barely readable unlike in your other videos.

[@justin808_]

The video was just uploaded a few minutes ago, youtube is still processing it

[@alivohereiam3780]

@@justin808_ Alrighty, thanks a lot! I never noticed this before

[@sirtedricwalker2979]

Wow....The Bible says From Dust you were formed and Dust you shall return and out of the darkness and chaos God said "Let there be Light and there was Light"......the more mankind discovers the more the TRUTH of the BIBLE is revealed. Revelations says how the Sun and moon will turn Blood Red and the Earth will be destroyed by fire. Very interesting video.

[@cgattchnz7530]

Thank you Sir .

[@knowhoim]

Love the music acustra

[@pyroktanor]

Wait so theres just space dust falling into the planet all the time? Thats so cool!

[@Catperson84]

9:41 it's BB-8

[@patrickbowers8359]

Its younger then u think

[@istvansipos9940]

pardon me? its younger what? And then what? Wait a sec... Did you mean "it's younger than you think"? well, ok. how young is it, and how can mankind test that claim?

[@bobyale6159]

Brilliant!

[@smallbee1234]

...Life...

[@patrickbowers8359]

IF I UNDERSTAND THIS CORRECTLY OUR CORE IS BASICALLY NUCLEAR

[@spacedoutcowboy8621]

Thank you ....very interesting. Just one thing though...you did not include Pluto as a planet. Pluto is not a rock...is has an atmosphere, formed into a orb. Has moons, but because it is so far from the sun has not cleared out it's orbit totally. I doubt that earth under similar circumstances would be able to clear out it's orbit either....as long as we have that cleared up . continue....

[@Emdee5632]

Please look up the three criteria for a planet and why Pluto fails for the third. Yes I know these three criteria are controversial, and might change in the future. But the fact remains: Pluto is a Kuiper Belt object. Rather a large one and pretty close to the inner solar system, but it still is one. It's NOT Pluto's distance to the sun that makes it a dwarf planet. It's its huge neighbour Neptune that placed it in its present orbit and which in complete control of Pluto, like Neptune is with so many other Kuiper Belt objects. Having or not having an atmosphere isn't relevant. Having or not having moons isn't relevant. Saturn's moon Titan has a dense atmosphere. Mercury, a planet, has no atmosphere. There are asteroids and other Kuiper Belt objects besides Pluto that also have moons. Pluto was discovered in 1930. They did not know about the existence of the Kuiper Belt back then. Had they known, Pluto would have been classified as a KBO immediately. Dont forget Ceres was classified as a planet too when it was discovered. After so many other asteroids were discovered they realized these objects deserved to be in a class of their own. Hence, Ceres was reclassified as an asteroid. In 2006 it got reclassified as a dwarf planet, just like Pluto. i don't hear you complaining about Ceres!

[@jasonwb6884]

How does looking at other stars that aren't field stars give us an idea of how old our solar system star is. The Milky Way is still a very active galaxy, new stars are born from gas clouds all the time right? I guess we know at least 5 billion years given how old earth is. But earth could of been in a magma state a very long time, or even multiple magma states.

[@howfarawayisit]

It doesn't. Did you watch the video. It tells you how we did it.

[@patrickbowers8359]

SO IN OUR OWN GALAXY GIVING IT MAYBE TRILLION YEARS OLD IM SURE THERE ARE MORE INTELLIGENT PEOPLE MAY NOT LOOK LIKE US BUT THEY AINT ALEINS THEY ARE IN THE SAME BOAT

[@theskyatnightrawunderthedome]

One day you people will realize in your minute existence, that you know absolutely nothing...you don't even know yourselves~

[@Sco692]

bow to your sensei,science and knowledge

[@raedahmad3637]

if you are alone in an earth like planet you can construct a home with living tools fishing and cooking for yourself and making books and computer an television and communicate with earth .

[@vincentneale2620]

We`ll have to start with a theory - in other words well have to start with a wild guess hahahaha

[@raedahmad3637]

if you are typing on a computer do you think big bang is fake? or some physical theories immagination because computers are based on physical theories that are right in this way so big bang is real.

[@dt5072]

It must be decided what one means by the big bang, i think we can be sure that the universe was once in a hotter denser state. But it is only a theroy, albeit the best one we have at the moment

[@raedahmad3637]

@@dt5072 anyway i am not a physics professor i dont know the calculations of big bang but when i see an airplane flying in the sky i know physics is right not fault science big bang is right not fault its a theory and fact and let science buzters science buzters.

[@sirgoatofcheese]

Ah..no. This is our old understanding. Science is not static nor dogmatic and it should never ignore evidence in favor of preserving the model. The Electric Universe theory has way better explanations.

[@dt5072]

electric universe is poop

[@sirgoatofcheese]

@@dt5072 Good intellectual comeback. I'm convinced!

[@raedahmad3637]

the universe was infinite small dense in infinite time its big bang

[@istvansipos9940]

wanna try that in an existing version of English? No kidding here, I legit have 0 idea what you tried to say in your comment.

[@Kombrig_2]

Do you believe that the entire hydrosphere of the Earth (roughly 7 quintillion tones) has been brought by comets and asteroids, David? I've found this idea completely wrong and preposterous! This is a great lecture, I enjoyed it!

[@dannydazzler1549]

It's pretty old Bro's

[@KasidAli-su1xx]

❤

[@rayomaro549]

Everyday. I have to take shower. I have to change my socks. I make sure i wares clean clothes if not i be stinky i guarantee. Tell me if my New toys work's better.

[@bellekiller]

please make more~~~~~ i will donate if you set up a donation account! just hire some people to collect information for you and you can do the narration!

[@raedahmad3637]

the existence is from an infinite time from everlasting but our universe is a new born universe in the infinite space and time where there is out new born universes and new destroyed universes why we dont return back in the existence like trillions trillions trillions trillions years ago to see what they was in this old universes maybe we are not alone maybe there is life in other places or planets like earth in this infinite space of universes stars moons and planet God is great the creator of all things.

[@jaimecoburn1339]

what about fairy dust

[@Dudes21]

It is made by God..

[@omeritachiquita]

🌝

[@Accu53Mation]

Great. So the sun could have been born a few years after the Big Bang theory, and we only have a few billion years left. Not enough time with current procrastination, to get off this rock.

[@Mokinono45]

Violation of the laws of Thermodynamics, are running amuck in this video. Also 2:52 the Sapphire project can do this in a lab using a difference science. Lots of stories here, but I don't see any science. You can explain much of with alternative theories so much is just speculation. Rather a poor video, at least it looks good. 17:30, heat reorganizes matter? Wait a second, that contradicts the earlier part of the video with the suns couldn't make certain elements saying that they weren't hot enough. The Sun is over a million degrees (at parts) but the meteor doesn't get to a percentile of that--yet you claim it requires a supernova to create the heavier elements. It's almost as if heat really doesn't matter.

[@istvansipos9940]

damn, you are all over the place. with some coherence, please, what is your point / your question? and what do you mean by "heavy" elements? how heavy?

[@saqqarabird6698]

This is all just theory, no one really knows.

[@chiyamamoto5092]

素粒子進化論早くしろ！💢スピード進化論早くしろ！💢問題クリアする話🤩進化論早くしろ！💢

[@mrloop1530]

I don't care what anyone *thinks.* According to the Bible, God's creation is slightly more than 6,000 years old.

[@istvansipos9940]

yes. and god creates carbon based life with 0 carbon in the universe, species survive with 1 male and 1 female, a fella survives in a "fish", and junior walks on water. yeah... there are tinly little signs that the bible is a bit wrong, to say the very least

[@PadreMortalis]

That was a troll comment if I ever saw one. You don't believe that. You just typed it to get a response. Here. You got two responses. The bible is rubbish.

[@opiestanborough4774]

wow, i made it 14 minutes in before i couldnt take it anymore.... knowing this is a absolute horse shit ! next youll try and say there was a big "bang" lol, sorry, the only big bang was when my mother in law had a heart attack and face planted on the floor .....

[@lunamaria1048]

I love your videos, but hate to say that every one of the thousands of exo planetary systems we have discovered have debunked the current collapsing molecular cloud as the origin of our solar system.. Also, our solar system is full on anomalous orbits and rotations of some of our planets that can't be explained by the current model.. Also, the planetary plain is tilted a few degrees off from the sun's rotational plain, which is impossible, if this model were true.... Most exo planetary systems we know of have the gas giants orbiting closer to their star and terrestrial rocky worlds are the farthest away.. We see it again and again... Why is this erroneously model still being taught, as what your type calls "settled science"?... Instead of just admit the collapsing nebula model is WRONG, scientists try to so the planets radically migrate in other systems LOL

[@howfarawayisit]

Lunamaria, You are right about one thing. There is a lot more to it than the collapsing nebula model. But end-game planetary placement does not 'debunk' it. Hot Jupiters are as common as binary systems. Also, rest assured that there is no such thing as 'settled science' - certainly not in astronomy (or global warming). All I am doing is helping people understand the evidence for the current theory. I'm waiting for JWST data to do a video on exoplanets.

[@kingsojo]

LOL

[@raedahmad3637]

prove me the earth is a round planet not an infinite flat plane and all what we see from space not a spiralfibonacy.

[@JefferyCarr-fk9wb]

LOL THIS HAS GOT TO BE THE MOST ABSURD VIDEO ON KZbin.

[@noonesflower]

I totally agree

[@PadreMortalis]

Holy bible. Rubbish.