Husband's Deadly Rage After Finding Her Secret Emails | Keith Reed

In upstate New York, Keith Reed worked as school superintendent. However, when he went missing from his home, a call would come in hundreds of miles away. What happened to Keith Reed would lead back to a string of emails, and a husband's discovery.
Patreon► / thatchapter
Twitter► / that_chapter
Instagram► / that_chapter
Sources►pastebin.com/1zBEY2Cg
For business enquires please email [e-mail]

[@jasonfournier1463]

If you're in a rocky relationship you should never drag someone else into your mess. Handle your issues, end your marriage, get some therapy and wait until you heal before you pull someone else into your life.

[@vagabondslot-machine8832]

Amen

[@billbillinger2117]

That would require personal responsibility in which many people have no interest in.

[@tyreestander6486]

So true …

[@goldfingershat]

Shut up no one cares

[@larryadler6035]

Well said Jason

[@emillychen888]

It's amazing how stress free your life is when you don't kill someone.

[@mariebroyles6874]

and not cheating

[@kingcosworth2643]

I've never killed anyone but life sure isn't stress free, but I get your point

[@susanmary3795]

I’m thinking about getting that tattooed

[@ganjatheninja]

amazing how stress free your life is when you dont have a cheating whore of a wife

[@FlabbyAbi]

​@@mariebroyles6874it's amazing how stress free your life is when you leave your cheating partner instead of killing them. In a fair few cases, people have only cheated because they knew their partner was abusive and would kick off and kill them anyways if they left. Then a loving, kind, friendly sort comes along, maybe even the one but they can't leave because of fear. I'm not saying that cheating is morally right but there are situations where fear and violence is a huge factor and I'd go as far to say that certain violent asshats deserve to get cheated on.

[@afcaton1]

😂😂 "Get a therapist, at least they're paid to listen to your B.S." Best line ever.... 😂😂

[@feraltaco4783]

Had me wheezing. 🤣 🤣 🤣

[@anonymouswind1]

I feel so bad for Keith. He had no idea she was still married until it was too late. He even said for both her and ber husband to not contact him anymore, so he was obviously done with her.

[@fredajordan5704]

Well, if I was him I would have asked her.

[@anonymouswind1]

@@fredajordan5704 Thing is she told him she was divorced and not in a relationship with anyone, so even if he did ask she would have lied.

[@tacobanana6538]

Fr, bro pulled a dumb one and didn't decide to kill his own wife for decided to be the one to cheat. Like the murder is wrong and all and shouldn't have happened in the first place but that's like, basic textbook murder procedure.

[@pnscar3]

It’s amazing this wasn’t national news. I guess national news is reserved for missing wt blonde women and pookies n ray rays

[@QuinnieMae]

​@@pnscar3How strange that all you seem to care about is that some black folks are on the news for the crimes they committed. Like some Caucasian people and Hispanic people and Asian people are. Lol. And yes... some "blonde white women" are on the news when they disappear. How odd that you have a problem with that!!? Odd and gross, tbh. You're not aware that there are more family members of "blonde white women" who report their disappearances than there are black family members that do the same? I mean why don't you start popularizing specific cases of only black women if you think there is a disparity there?? Why don't the families of these women support them more vocally? Does anyone in their immediate and extended family _care_ about them? What have you done other then focus on something as meaningless as skin color without bothering to research what that disparity you claim exists, means??

[@JimmyFoxhound]

So Rob driving to Keith's house with a revolver and then killing him with that revolver gets him 2nd Degree murder?? How in the world could Rob's actions be anything other than pre-meditated murder of the first degree??? Unbelievable.

[@beliedat2457]

The DA was an idiot and couldn’t do his job worth a shit. I live in Clymer.

[@-xirx-]

21:17 I thought Rob would shave his head & click up with the AB, but with that haircut, it looks like he has already become somebodies b**ch inside. Guess he was only a tough guy when he had a gun

[@Scratchingforcash]

It’s a crime of passion.

[@kezfaz6429]

That’s exactly what I was thinking. And crime of passion or not, it’s still first degree premeditated murder.

[@kezfaz6429]

@@Scratchingforcashstill premeditated 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

[@VickyRyan2018]

How beautiful life is without cheating and without murdering

[@rachiG]

Without poor and hungry people/ children, without hate… everyone to be equal and for everyone to be enough

[@TheStar798]

Poor Keith didn't have a clue she was even still married! 😢

[@ralphjune9798]

just wait

[@bakielh229]

it's not that different really, I am equally as happy as before

[@hornetguy9063]

@@TheStar798yeah, his killer is a psychopath and she’s an agent of chaos. They seemed perfect for each other. Well, at least she’s not a criminal, but I hope other men did a Google search on her before getting involved

[@seachel2010ify]

Every time someone claims they were "manipulated" into killing someone I roll my eyes so hard.

[@Burlykim13]

I mean, I think it’s exceedingly rare, but it definitely happens, and while it doesn’t excuse this murder, I do believe she absolutely manipulated her husband, the situation, and everyone around her. She’s vile.

[@JohnnyFarang]

I can't believe he killed him over that mid looking chick. If I'm going down for felony murder it's going to be for Scarlett Johansson or someone of that caliber 😂

[@ScottJB]

I mean, it can happen, but I hope they enjoy the consequences of allowing themselves to be manipulated. They got manipulated into going to prison.

[@joshuajackson472]

Agreed, but the "former" Marine point is highly suspicious

[@Monika-bc3dq]

​@@Burlykim13​​​ I'm 100% with you. She absolutely did it. And it's quite a smart plan too, because it is rare (tho not as rare as people might think, even Mike covered more than few cases with murder by proxy where the actual mastermind manipulated someone to murder someone - Pamela Smart anyone? Or attempt to - that woman called Lovejoy?) and most people will have the same reaction as OC here, just rolling eyes and "sure, bud". She wanted him gone (and without the possibility of coming back) and she made it happen.

[@mrmann44]

The way she takes NO accountability for anything is mind-blowing!

[@annstillwell730]

She's the reason does give a care either. 😢

[@elainewat2607]

Yeah, and I noticed she knew her hubby was headed there, yet did nothing to warn the potential victim, nor went to authorities to let them know....until it was too late.

[@Aware_Bear]

I remember when your channel had about a thousand followers. That's when my girlfriend showed me this page. She found it when you had about a hundred. Now look at you Mikey. We're proud of you. Take care of yourself because we all love you.

[@frankmacias7244]

Luke don't check her emails bro...not worth it

[@vickymaher2755]

Hey same ! I remember when he had 123k when I started to follow him, I always remember the easily remember able numbers , and exactly look at him now 🎉🎉❤😊

[@Aware_Bear]

@@frankmacias7244 😂

[@marcellaricher8296]

@@frankmacias7244 qa a

[@talpark8796]

wasnt quite six digits when i subscribed. not too bagly, for a Mick 😁

[@elizabethmcglothlin5406]

It baffles me. Ya'know there's this thing called divorce to solve this kind of problem. Even desertion is easier than murder!

[@einienj3281]

Do you expect logic from these people who are ready to murder their spouse? Not happening..

[@snicker576]

Know what's even easier than divorce? Not CHEATING ON YOUR SPOUSE lol

[@einienj3281]

​@@snicker576 Even easier to never get married in the first place, just gather your stuff and go..

[@goldfingershat]

You know what else is easier than murder, emptying your bank account to buy some yummmmmmyyy in your tummmmyyyy hot wings for the homeless and using hotbabes to sell them by the dozen!!!!! I love how wings!

[@JJRDRR]

Thanks Liz. Tell ‘em. Dork.

[@kezfaz6429]

Through all this mess there are 3 beautiful girls who are without their beloved father. My heart breaks for them. He seemed like such a great man. RIP Keith Reed ❤

[@wukket]

Your outros are the ONLY ones I don’t skip, out of every KZbinr I watch. Because you’re the only one who sounds like you actually mean it when you say you love us ❤️

[@Bucketus.Lord.of.Buckets]

"Hey you!" Thus, the day was improved

[@ThatChapter]

Haha hope it stays that way!

[@jencstephens5452]

Show of hands, how many of us watch to the very end just to hear Mike say he loves us? ✋️

[@therightshoe8040]

That’s my favorite part ❤

[@shelbybronoske702]

I always find myself saying "Love you too, man! " :-)

[@FlabbyAbi]

If you think about it, there are people out there who only hear it from Mike 😥 he touches so many hearts lol, our lovely Mike..

[@homerg2724]

I remember one of the first videos I saw of him I was going through some rough moments & he said that at the end it was an episode about suicide. We love you as well Mike 👊🏻🫶🏻

[@amybe573]

I remember when he first added that little bit of heaven to the end of his videos. 🤭 It was like the first time you hear it from someone you're really into...I was so excited that I might have even teared up a little! 😍👀👏👏👏😁😂😂 It's definitely gotten me through some rough spots since it's become a fixture. 😁🖤

[@jesmarina]

She KNEW her husband was driving up to confront Keith, and she did NOTHING? Wow, that's really sinister.

[@jari32]

What do you do in that situation? I doubt she thought that he would kill him.

[@peternolan4107]

@@jari32 You start by phoning and emailing Keith ASAP so he can protect himself, even if she really thought her husband would not kill him. Then you call the police in Clymer. You don't just sit there. She complained plenty about how awful her marriage was. Awful enough to get involved with another man. Yet she did not think her enraged husband was capable of murder?

[@V.E.R.O.]

@@peternolan4107 Someone said in another comment that she emailed Keith to warn him and told him to call out sick that day. Don't know if it's true or not.

[@traybern]

@@jari32. At LEAST WARN HIM!!!!!!

[@traybern]

@@V.E.R.O.. EMAILS are NOT always read in FIVE SECONDS. A PHONE CALL is MUCH FASTER!!!

[@thexxit]

The violence in some people is mind boggling. Leave someone instead of killing someone. Very sorry to his family for their loss.

[@narayanstar7787]

No one is worth all that!! Move on !!

[@astrzmbie9968]

He should have done both of them, I would have 💯

[@astrzmbie9968]

You don't understand the violence in some people, you don't have to, just know it's there and stay away from married women.

[@haji818721]

He didn't want to leaver her.

[@mrfarax4944]

You guys obviously don't know some people ruminate

[@zarasbazaar]

It does make you wonder if the wife had a motive, since she didn't email Keith to warn him that her angry, military trained husband was heading up there to confront him.

[@pdizzle5302]

I have a feeling she baited her husband to go confront Keith. She got the outcome she wanted. Why no expression of remorse on her part for partially causing this? Why portray herself as the ultimate victim to the media?

[@damac5136]

Good question.

[@juniorsanchez7441]

@@pdizzle5302 She played both of them. Got rid of her husband and the side piece in one go and now she can hoe around all she wants

[@stefmon68]

She is a POS. I believe she at least wrote some of those emails. Trash. RIP Keith.

[@girlwhomustnotbenamed4139]

You all are fucking unbelievable. A toxic, entitled, violent pos blows a fuse over some emails so much that he goes and murders another person but you're STILL making the woman out to be the guilty one. Maybe, just maybe we should stop coddling violent men who so can't control their emotions when their fragile little egos get bruised that they feel they have the right to take someone's life. Gtfoh

[@xjones2087]

It baffles me too. Why is it that the husband wants to kill some male stranger that he never knew or put his trust in? If the husband should be mad at anybody, it should be the one he exchange vows, love and trust in, his wife.

[@CoExist64]

Same for women if not worse. I’ll never understand going after a stranger when they’re not the one cheating on you! I’m anti-violence, so I say leave if you’re not happy!

[@Mephisto-ie2xg]

EXACTLY.

[@sharonpowell3656]

Amen. Everybody always wants to blame the "other" man or woman. Even though I have absolutely no respect for someone sleeping with a married person, they are not the ones who made promises. Put the blame where it belongs.

[@rosemadder5547]

@@CoExist64 if not worse? Incel.

[@ciarapress4878]

Because they still want what they think is theirs and that other person is in the way. Or they know it will hurt the one they want ...

[@tamiwanzie3923]

I appreciate how you can narrate a sad but true story and throw in your humor.... l LOVE your accent! ❤

[@edwardchance2543]

I like his accent too I wonder what part of Australia he is from "throw another shrimp on the barbie" lollol 😂 I feel sorry for the victims tree daughters

[@Velvetnovel6]

So sorry for Ketih, he seemed like a wonderful person who got in a wrong place at the wrong time 😢 I’m so sorry for his daughters too that no longer have him around and the students and friends left behind, this was so unfair

[@aazappa]

How was this second degree? There was premeditation and should have federal charges for crossing state lines in the commission of a crime.

[@woahblackbettybamalam]

Because female. Bring down the matriarchy

[@TheRationalist.]

The wife deserved a charge too. She was married and living with her husband. She was the root cause.

[@napoleonbonerfart278]

​@@TheRationalist. charged for what though? Instigating? This isnt hockey.

[@mr.mcpurrz3143]

​@@TheRationalist. Why would charges be brought against someone for living with, and be married to a criminal?

[@feeltheillinois]

@@napoleonbonerfart278 lmao

[@Catherinzsl]

I am so sick and in so much pain at the moment, thoughts of euthanasia have passed through my mind. And yet, _"THIS PHONE SMELLS LIKE VAG!NA!"_ had me burst out laughing. Thanks, Mike.

[@michellerock3543]

Hoping you feel better soon. ❤

[@zoftigbeatnik]

Sorry for what you are going through. I hope things get better for you. Will keep you in my thoughts.❤

[@kerricaldwell2380]

Don't give up 🙏

[@missme1794]

Oh my heart. I hope you recover and find something to help you cope with the pain soon. Great painkiller though, Mike's humour. Killed me too that part 😂

[@saraseveryn8650]

Comedy and Laughter can be very therapeutic!

[@stefaniekay8699]

LOVE YOU MIKE!! Not in a weird way but I have been watching you for the last 4 years during cancer treatment, I’m good now, but still LOVE YOU!

[@narayanstar7787]

So glad you are healthy now !! Mike is such a friendly guy. He got me through Covid.

[@stefaniekay8699]

@@narayanstar7787 thank you!! Yes COVID and quarantine were brutal.

[@TAGMZs63]

I'm glad you're recovered. I think humor is the best medicine and Mike is so awesome and funny

[@stefaniekay8699]

@@TAGMZs63thanks!! I completely agree!!

[@ElizabethHernandez-zj9oi]

I’m so happy you beat cancer hon I too am in remission 🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽 God bless you 🙂

[@blueyedkitten7415]

I find it VERY curious that Mary KNEW her husband was crazy jealous, KNEW he'd taken off to "where do you think?!?" yet never thought to reach out to warn Keith, or a police agency, that her husband had disappeared in a rage. Doesn't she hold some responsibility here? First, she's an absolute piece of garbage for getting involved with ANYONE while still married, and also not informing Keith that she was still married. But, to sit idly by and not do anything when he tells her he's gone, makes her complicit in my mind.

[@Geno5]

I had a similar situation with a woman, but she never told me she was still married. Turns out the husband was a low level drug dealer and got a hold of my cell number. I got a call while on vacation from him. I hung up, blocked him number. He would go out and buy burner phones to call and text. Mind you I had not seen his wife in months, no contact. I ended up going to court to get a restraining order. It only worked because he was on probation…. Life can be crazy!!!

[@Geno5]

@@bksvdb thank you. Crazy thing, she was a business owner, she had a CBD store and I had some pain from an accident and people told me to try it out. I went in, she helped me and was very helpful and very beautiful. I was a customer for a couple of months and she asked me to dinner. I never hit on someone at their work, seems tacky. Went out had a great time and she got busy, we saw less and less. At the time I ran a company with 60 employees and was also busy. Then out of the blue I was sitting at a resort having dinner with friends and got this weird call. “Geno, how are you?” “You doing good?” “Well you wont be if you keep seeing Allison (Name changed) she is my wife!” Lol that was just nuts

[@ditzygypsy]

I am glad you are ok. It could easily have turned out differently. Just scan some of the comment streams on this video, and you will find many, many comments from kooks who honestly say that they think murder is a better option than divorce. Because they mistakenly believe that women get everything in a settlement. I paid my ex husband monthly AND paid full child support for 50/50 custody. I am a woman. They feel that they’d do better choosing murder because they’d have free rent and three meals a day. I am not kidding! It seems they forget about Bubba wanting them for a girlfriend. Just nuts!

[@goobyplz2646]

That’s why I blame the woman in this situation not the guy

[@SirZipper]

I was seeing this girl once and one night while I was at her place her ex showed up screaming and crying, saying he was gonna kill himself if she didn't take him back, tried fighting me then said he was going to watch us sleep through her window. Be safe out there, fellas.

[@cuppycakey5013]

Yep, one thing people don’t understand is that often times the other person is lied to, and they don’t know the person is married. If your spouse cheats on you, take your betrayal and anger and hurt to the actual person who made vows to you and who broke those vows. If it wasn’t that person, they’d cheat with someone else.

[@kamilee3833]

OMG! I love Mike: “Get a therapist, at least they are paid to listen to your bullshit!”

[@MatthewRiley-ep1qi]

Damn, Kieth was my dads uncle, they were super close. I was pretty young when I learned he died, and wasn’t given any details besides that he was killed in his driveway. Me being young just thought this guy was a super baller, rich, and had assassins after him, over 10 years later I’m just now learning the full story.

[@feliciawebb6081]

Fun fact: even though I’ve been watching your videos for over two years, it took watching a spelling bee episode of TRY channel to learn that you lovely Irish people pronounce the letter R like or! And then the very next video of yours I watched was this one, where you confirmed it for me! Oh how I love listening to you all tell stories! Sincerely, a poor sheltered American 😅♥️

[@ericaosborne5241]

It occurred to me today, that Mike's videos are the only ones I don't turn off as soon as the story is over because I like to hear him say "I love ya"🥺😂❤

[@bravepoodle]

Me too! I live by myself away from my family and Mike's '…cuz I love ya!'s are a very important source of love for me. ☺️❤️

[@MrRisingapple]

@@bravepoodle thats sad man

[@bravepoodle]

@@MrRisingapple I know, right?! But I kinda like my current job so I'll hang in there a bit more while. Thank you for your caring words!

[@justkiddin84]

❤❤

[@TheMummymc76]

I look forward to it

[@williamglaser6577]

I think not commiting adultry and not killing someone might be better lessons to learn from this story.

[@TheJarlath9]

The only thing I don't understand is why not kill your wife Keith wasn't the one cheating

[@InshasChoice]

No no, don't kill anyone

[@mlee81]

​@InshasChoice but clearly s9me are crazy enough to do just that, so don't answer the email. Playing with someone's relationship is playing with fire.

[@ravenshane2753]

I think the lesson is don't go back to your psycho husband

[@cuppycakey5013]

The lessons are: if you’re in a miserable marriage with a controlling man, leave him, then date. If your wife cheats, leave her, don’t threaten or harm the other guy. SHE betrayed you, SHE doesn’t love you, and no one else owes you anything. Don’t ruin your life or take the life of someone else over a cheater.

[@christopherheaton4774]

Former Marine was used quite commonly until fairly recently (10-20 years ago). A recent commandant ordered that the term "former" is no longer needed...

[@anaderol5408]

Best advice at the end. If the relationship is over - stop communicating / stop contacting / stop talking about the ex.

[@CallmeJAYNE]

Almost choked on my own saliva "This phone smells like vagina"😂😂😂. Was not expecting that.

[@lilyt18]

I’m still recovering from that line 😂😂😭

[@PauliG]

Until about the 12 minute mark, I kept saying how familiar Keith looked. Like I KNOW him. Then you said he was originally from Saratoga Springs. I grew up there. I’m 50. Although I don’t recall the name, it was a pretty big high school, I am SURE that’s where I recognize him from. Creepy and sad. RIP.

[@Dimino519]

Mary definitely has some blood on her hands but I'm glad the man who pulled the trigger is behind bars. I'm from Buffalo and remember this story - thanks for covering it. If you're ever in the area I'll buy you some wings buddy! Love the channel - keep up the great work. Go Bills!

[@kevinspacey5325]

Yeah that woman should be in jail too......

[@MrShucklers1]

I knew this gentleman. Extremely nice guy absolutely did NOT deserve to die.

[@darkespeon64]

Didn't deserve to die but he was a piece of trash. He messed around with a married women then when found out proceeded to taunt the man. In the very least he was a garbage person

[@utubecop11]

​@@darkespeon64This might just be the stupidest comment Ive read all week lol leave your basement you little dweeb

[@just-dl]

@@darkespeon64 you’re making some leaps there. Nothing in this video indicated he knew she as still with Rob. She led him to believe she was “available.”

[@MrShucklers1]

@@darkespeon64 so how did he taunt the man?

[@gaaraxnaru]

​@darkespeon64 He didn't know she was married. Mike said so himself. Did you miss the part where as soon as he was contacted by the husband, he told them both to never contact him again? He never taunted Rob and was quickly done with Mary when the truth was out.

[@binarydark4811]

"This phone smells like vagina, what's going on!?" Absolutely love it, and hope that this phrase can be used again.

[@jimmydeewilliams6489]

So sad the school superintendent had to lose his life in this tragic way.He seemed like a great beloved dad to his three daughters and the entire community. I'm happy they caught his killer and his now reaping the seeds he has sown now he's in jail for a long time

[@KxNGFeel]

Holy shit!! Woodbridge Virginia!! We finally are on your show!!! 🥴🥴🥴🥴🥴🥴

[@LeeBv9983]

And not in a good way. Isn't the alternate spelling "Hoodbridge" for all the crime there?

[@tiffanysantiago516]

“Get a therapist, they’re paid to listen to your bs” 📝 noted 😆 words to live by

[@SykoNerd]

The smelly phone line had me dying!!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 love ya ✌️🖤

[@AnthonyTyger]

Holy shite Mike... never in a million billion years did I think you'd cover something so close to home. I didn't knew Keith personally, but I knew of him from his family. (Notably after/around the time of his death.) I lived and grew up in Salamanca, for most of my formative youth, and while I never met Keith, I knew his father (who was a local politician) and his brother. (Who grew up in Killbuck NY, just a hair shy of Salamanca, and was pretty close to my family... the Mohr's and the Hoag's.) His whole family is buried where several of my own are, in the Crawford Cemetery. Also, damn good pronunciations on everything.

[@inheritmyshoes9559]

Fellow Western NYer! Currently in Olean!

[@inheritmyshoes9559]

Lmao I said the same thing about his pronounciations!

[@AnthonyTyger]

@@inheritmyshoes9559 I got loads of family in or around Olean. Hello! :)

[@inheritmyshoes9559]

@@AnthonyTyger hey there! This was a sad case, Mike did it justice as always!

[@JayBeeThree]

He was my computer teacher way back in the day. Crazy to find out he was murdered.

[@heezypeasy8611]

Omg "this phone smells like vagina!" killed me 😂 Mike, you're doing amazing things with your channel!!!! Keep up the great work!!!

[@heatherlamoureux0]

My husbamd passed away about 7 weeks ago, and i can relate to the marine comment. He was very much a Marine even though he hadnt been active since like 2004. They instill that in them. he would never had said former marine, if anything, he would have said he was a marine veteran. But yes, i 100% agree they would never have said former. I love ur videos and humor. ❤

[@cierralostrick1390]

Hey Mike there’s a missing person case in pa about a women named phylicia thomas. She went missing in 2004 at 22 years old and has never been found. Her mother still has hope that she will be.

[@yepthatsme8184]

You would think Rob would be more pissed off at his wife for contacting Keith in the first place😳 Sadly a family lost their father🥺

[@seame3795]

The way she stands there door open blabbing to a stranger about how bad their marriage was & says she’s glad he’s in jail. Disgusting. She should be devastated. Did she even bother to call Keith or the police to warn them that he was coming?

[@joanodom2104]

She actually CAUSED the murder! She couldn't even be bothered to pick up her cell phone and warn Keith. Mary is an absolute POS and she needs to be in prison for her involvement in this appalling crime, as she was the architect of the entire thing. I had a huge laugh over Mike's Southern accent when he said something about West Virginia.

[@missbee3618]

​@@rabbit_bum at the very least tho, she should be feeling fkin rotten about it, not casually chatting away, when if she'd have sorted her own life out before trying to have it all at the same time & dragging poor Keith into it, he would probably still be alive. But she's so casual about it! I couldn't speak about it like that, knowing I was the catalyst for the murder 🤯 smfh...

[@BlisaBLisa]

@@joanodom2104 this phenomenon isnt specific to true crime but its truly wild how whenever a guy does something fucked up people will look for a way to pin the blame on a woman instead 💀

[@juniorsanchez7441]

@@BlisaBLisalol more like the other way around. But in this case it’s definitely her manipulation. Neither of these men would have ever crossed paths if it hadnt been for her

[@BlisaBLisa]

@@juniorsanchez7441 she was married to a violent abusive man, who then went on to kill the man she cheated on him with. it isnt unusual for a woman in such an abusive relationship to have a secret affair with someone else. idk how someone comes to the conclusion that the woman in a relationship with the violent abusive man was actually the real manipulator behind all of this. its mental gymnastics and its based on nothing but vibes. there is clear proof that this guy is abusive and violent and unhinged, there is no proof that the wife wanted any of this to happen or did any kind of manipulation or sent any of those emails. its just a theory the defense came up with because they had nothing else.

[@missmaggie2620]

Wow, my Grandpa had a dairy farm & once was the Mayor of Clymer and at the time, if you blinked your eye going through town...you would have missed it.

[@lovesara2209]

You make me crack up ease up my depression and keep me focused Mike thanks dude ❤ the phone comment made me spit my wine out 😂

[@ANONM60D]

How is this not 1st degree murder? He clearly planned this

[@NotSureIfSrs_x]

Was it really though? the man went to the guys school that has a ton of cameras, and even told people where he was coming from... he was planning to kill him infront of everyone, it doesn't seem like much of a plan. Looks like a crime of passion and rage to me.

[@Hcaz1113]

Vagina was involved. There was no clear thinking from the start.

[@ScanManDaMurka]

​@@NotSureIfSrs_x a crime of passion that requires driving for like 7 hours. I would think a prosecuting attorney could destroy that sentiment with such a long drive.

[@ReelTimeStrategies]

@@NotSureIfSrs_x Cause by who?

[@broeheemed32]

It wouldn't surprise me at all if she told her husband that the guy raped her, knowing he'd "avenge" for her.

[@elisaseverns2543]

How terrible. He told the guy to tell his wife not to contact him. What more could he want? So sad.

[@nfb6454]

Yep I was coming on here to say this. He pretty much agreed; so this guy went ahead and shot him? I’m baffled.

[@latoyagardley8000]

Very strange he chose to take it out on Keith , not saying he should have k*lled anyone but that was very selective and immature

[@Pollllz]

Mike, as a new subscriber I just wanted to say how much I love your channel. Hands down my absolute fave of the true crime bunch. What I especially love is the way you dig out the often piss poor police investigations that lead to killers being free to kill again or to appalling injustices against innocent people. Most importantly though you have total respect for the victims and their families, so hats off to you for that.

[@fredajordan5704]

Wow, Mary surely is a messed up individual. Cheating can lead to worse.... Poor Keith, he did not deserve this.

[@lisahinton9682]

Even before the end of the video when Mike talks about the defense stating Mary is a manipulator, I knew that was the case. Who sends someone an email thanking them for phone sex, after all? And then leaves it open for their spouse to find? It's clear (from his email response back to the husband, i. e. MARY) that he didn't know he was speaking to a still-married woman. It's such a sham, and I hope his much-loved daughters are doing okay.

[@goldfingershat]

I’m not afraid of women I got mad respect for women

[@Wistful77]

I agree she is a bit sus, I also think she is lucky to be alive.

[@annereidy7981]

Time line please, also, you leave your private data around in hopes that someone will intrude into it? Lisa, you need to protect yourself because it seems you know very violent people. And oddly enough, yes people do make stupid mistakes, like thanking someone for p sexs, esp if they are under the illusion of private conversation function?

[@junemarshall-kingsley566]

@@Wistful77 Wouldn't phone sex be enough? Does she really need to thank him for it?

[@richardc2410]

Man mike i'm pretty sure you gave epic presentations in school on your reports and probably had awesome stories to write

[@RM-mm4jr]

Never thought of that but yeah, you're so right! Mike sure wld have been spectacular!!

[@P3N1SLUVR]

Another great video, thanks Mike. Hope you're taking care of yourself as well 'cause you know we love ya too.

[@surfside75]

Bro!! The floating head is back😂 - my favorite background ❤

[@theimpossiblemary]

Thank you, Mike, for being so consistent and yet still producing excellent videos. That is why you are now one of the top dogs.

[@ls_812]

It's the Life insurance Dance that took him to the top 😅

[@ctenterprises134creech7]

? Life Insurance Dance ?

[@ssQ2U]

I hear you barking, Big Dog 💖

[@GodsThirdEye]

Bro this lady knew her husband would kill Keith and would be in prison for life. She did it on purpose to take everything and get rid of his toxic ass forever. Keith was just a means to an end for her.

[@giffgaming9246]

He's not one of he is

[@lisalynnmarie2448]

This was so sad. The poor guy had no idea that they reconciled. After Rob sent that email and Keith responded to not bother him again, he probably thought it was over. Little than he knew, he never stood a chance. I'm glad his wife turned him in and he's where he belongs, hopefully never getting paroled. I even want to give a shout out that I watched this while having coffee with Mike's "Let's give it a goo" mug 🤭 Maybe I'll make that a ritual for Tuesday and Friday video time lol....Have a good weekend all❤

[@FlabbyAbi]

Yes let's hope he never gets paroled. Hate the "crime of passion" aspects in a lot of these cases. If someone can get murderously dangerous when they're emotionally hurting, they should be treated as dangerous to everyone. The ritual sounds like a great idea btw 😁 don't forget the podcasts too! Will have to get myself one, don't need anything but it's nice to support a creator who makes a difference to your life.

[@shadysif6220]

His wife showed zero remorse for the innocent man that was murdered because of her dishonesty. I actually believe some of what the defense is claiming. And that she was manipulating both sides. If he was as outraged, demanding her email password, and she knew he was going to confront him. There's zero chance she didn't know it was a potentially deadly situation, where the authorities should have been involved, to prevent such an outcome. But ultimately her husband decided to murder a person, who wasn't a threat, in fact he did exactly as asked. He left both parties alone. So there was zero reason to go out his way to even lay a finger on him. That's borderline first degree murder as far as I'm concerned. He should never see the light of day. Taking someone else's life like that is forfeiting your own.

[@PatHaskell]

@@shadysif6220 No kidding, why didn’t she call him and tell him that she was afraid her husband might possibly heading up there.

[@realfingertrouble]

@@FlabbyAbi "crime of passion" - people who do crimes of passion don't use their military training and take all the lights out first. This was premeditated.

[@crystanick2697]

​​@@shadysif6220 right... She knew where he was going. She could've sent like a heads up email or text. Or if he just flat out refused to speak to her give the cops a heads up. I doubt they could've done much but at least she would've tried. Something. She wanted the drama and attention... She certainly got it.

[@nicolestewart]

You did a great job Mike. We love you. Thanks for all you do for us 😊❤

[@kathydavenport4422]

Rest In Peace Keith Blessings Be. Gone but not forgotten May your family and friends find healing and peace I ask this for your daughters Healing and Peace Blessings Be.

[@devinsmyname]

The year I became a freshman Keith Reed became the principal of my highschool, he was a cool dude. My step-dad told me about his murder and I remember being quite surprised at the time.

[@guyrabinowitz]

You didn't do too well in your writing class, it appears.

[@lococomrade3488]

​@@guyrabinowitz His principal died, my dude. Give him some slack. 🤣😂🤣

[@guyrabinowitz]

@@lococomrade3488What? His principal was not his best friend or a relative, and how is that relevant to his writing poorly anyway?

[@lococomrade3488]

@Guy Rabinowitz O boy, you don't understand Sociology, huh? I promise you: the kid and their principal share a common network of friends and family in the same town. Good luck being a short-sighted dimwit asshole, I'm sure it'll get you far. 🙄

[@lococomrade3488]

@Guy Rabinowitz Fun Fact: language evolves and the idea of "good grammar" is not only classist and racist, it's archaic af. Take your time to figure that one out. 🤣😂👍🏼

[@seandelap8587]

She didn't seem that bothered about what Rob was going to do to Keith otherwise she would have followed him and tried to talk him out of it when he went over to Keith's house

[@pegs1659]

She should have called the cop so they could stop him. If she followed him, he might have shot her as well.

[@micahgirard7772]

You seem like the sweetest man. Thank you for all the stuff you keep us entertained with :)

[@robweatherford5957]

Absolute respect to any police agency willing to use the word “suspect” instead of person of interest.

[@bobbyhillthuglife]

Those are two different things

[@robweatherford5957]

@@bobbyhillthuglife you would think so, but absolutely not, today’s department chiefs, don’t ever say the word suspect anymore. It hurts peoples feelings. What a joke.

[@ThrasherGnar]

Those are two different things bud.

[@breezemansker3366]

I'll never understand why someone would rather their "loved one" dying vs a divorce/separation.

[@sythiadawn]

It's about ownership. You're mine! No one else can have you. My ex used to show up drunk and want to "check" my bedroom to make sure there was no one there. This went on for years.

[@FlabbyAbi]

​@@sythiadawnI hope you don't have any bother these days. You're spot on with that.

[@lolitahaze02]

You don't have to understand it

[@africanfartingfrog]

That's because you're not a psychopath

[@shadysif6220]

He didn't kill a loved one, he killed an innocent man being manipulated by his wife. The husband should have been a man about it, and left her, or took his own life, as opposed to someone else's. But the wife also showed zero remorse for the role she played in the victims death. She knew exactly what she was doing, and I personally believed she got what she wanted. Away from her husband.

[@shamako4ever718]

Having a bad quality air issue is not fun but now that Mike is here, it smell like a good freshy episode in the air and i hope everyone are safe, now let's give it a goooooo.

[@ThatChapter]

Ah hope you’re doing ok! It’s all over the news

[@mandalynn410]

Same. It stinks.

[@sourgummiez]

I’m from Northern California, I know all about that! It gets worse here than anywhere else

[@zhill2001]

@@ThatChapterSame here in Central North carolina😮

[@laratheplanespotter]

I’m thinking of you guys. It can’t be easy. I have my fingers crossed that it passes quickly 🤞🏻

[@taylorflores1645]

Hi Mike! I’m from Jamestown NY, not too far from Clymer. I learned a lot of new details about this case in your video that i didn’t know before! Thanks for covering it! Go Bills!

[@chrissy3120]

I love when Mike tells me he loves me AND gives me a wink! Makes me melt 🫠

[@arianaajbeaverhausen8175]

Last year my best friend visited me and I put on a TC episode, she seemed to enjoy it and since then I'd completely forgotten all about it tbh. Well, I saw her tonight and the first thing she said was "let's have a gooooo!" 😂😂😂 I wasn't expecting it and burst out laughing, she told me that she subscribed to your channel that day and is now also listening to your podcasts. She watches you every morning while getting ready for work 😄 Just in case you ever read this I just want to thank you for all of your hard work, much love from your Edinburgh true crime family! 🥰🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿❤🇮🇪🔎

[@greengoblin876]

Piershill here , mikey is quite popular in Auld reekie

[@arianaajbeaverhausen8175]

@@greengoblin876 small world, aw the best fae yer neighbour in Lochend! 😁❤😄

[@JessicaOrtiz-im2gg]

😊😊

[@Mama-tea]

Just in from sunbathing, now relaxing and covered in moisturiser . Burnt . Scotland isn’t used to the sun ☀️ 😂😂🥵

[@cesarincamendozaloyola4407]

Enjoy the sun.

[@laurajeansimons5212]

Hello Mike, I live in Chautauqua County and remember when this happened. It was really unfortunate and troubling. I can't stress how unusual this type of thing is in Clymer.

[@girardmatwijkow9304]

As a resident of a small town just south of Buffalo I have been to Clymer a few times for their farm auctions. A quaint picturesque town. A place you would never think to relate murder to. Great video

[@alexf3007]

Dude, I checked out your stats on social blade because I just notice your sub count. Been a subscriber for a year or so now and congrats on such great content and consistent growth! So happy for you! 🎉

[@Trustkillx]

Dude, I checked out your stats on social blade because I just notice your sub count. Been a subscriber for a year or so now and congrats on such great content and consistent growth! So happy for you! 🎉 25

[@karascene13]

​@@watchmejumpstart69I see your point- but Mike has to work & attract viewers with the KZbin algorithm. If he puts up a spicy title & videos that are short, (because no one has an attention span anymore,) he might pop up on your feed. KZbin lesson 101

[@karls432]

@watchmejumpstart 48k views in 1 hour!! I think his doing alright 😂

[@loveforeignaccents]

@@Trustkillx Is that all you do is copy and paste other people's comments? Please develop some thoughts of your own. For a grown man, this is really pathetic, and this is obviously not the only channel you continually do this on.

[@akisok2024]

​@watchmejumpstart I've been watching Mike for years and he's the only content creator I've not gotten bored with. I really look forward to new videos and podcasts. We each have our opinions though ✌️

[@melancholygirl840]

Absolutely right Mike! STEP AWAY FROM THE COMPUTER!!! People go online to figure what their better halves are doing all the time and they are the ones hurt and looking like a fool! 😂

[@goldfingershat]

Touch my ramrod

[@justinbarnett9476]

Checking each other’s phones is a big one too. If you don’t trust your partner enough to not invade their privacy you shouldn’t be with them

[@JohnnyFarang]

As soon as I saw how freely this woman was snitching on her husband I knew she had something to do with it. She left thise emails out on purpose and probably goaded Rob into killing him. Thats why shes throwing him under the bus in interrogations and interviews.

[@guardrailbiter]

Brilliant defense. "I propose to you, the jury, that my client in not guilty by reason of _manipulative wife._ I mean, how could he have been expected to exercise the discipline of a Marine by _not_ committing murder? It's not his fault."

[@robaxl3088]

*Your upstate NY stories scare me even more…I live near those stories.* *Just 2 hours away from this one*

[@richardwhiteaker55]

Bro, you have been popping off. Look at all these comments and views you have already. Congratulations man. You’ve came along way since the first video I’ve seen of yours.

[@wanya_telborn]

He has over a million subscribers so I think he knows

[@goldfingershat]

He knows idiota

[@crosswired9]

I just was thinking this

[@goldfingershat]

@@crosswired9 think yourself into under the dirt

[@goldfingershat]

@@crosswired9 skull gang bloody

[@stacyward4309]

I haven't watched Mike in a while, how many videos is he putting out in a week? You go Mike

[@sandysizemore501]

Mike I’ve been gone. But I have you on my 55 inch TV now! Can’t go without you and my music. Just letting you know I still love ya!🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@mariahunter1784]

I was going to comment about this senseless murder but Jason has said it all really. So well said Jason. Mike, your a pure legend. Im an Irish woman still living in our beautiful emerald Isle and im so proud of you. Looking forward to the next one. 💚🍀💚

[@damienkarney2251]

Do not reply to the message above

[@cocraic_crypto]

So strange to see you cover this one as I went to school with Keith in Salamanca. He was a family friend and his death really shook everyone. Really messed up, pointless and a dumb act of cowardice!

[@CoExist64]

I’m truly sorry for your loss. God bless

[@MandenTV]

Act of cowardice?? He was a cheater!

[@cocraic_crypto]

@@MandenTV We agree and I remember when this happened. My Godmother was Keith’s aunt and it really tore her up.

[@cocraic_crypto]

@@CoExist64 Sadly, Keith’s mom and dad also lost their daughter due to a long and drawn out illness. They were very good people as was their entire family.

[@onethingleft2try_109]

I'm from about 20 mins away from Salamanca and never heard of this case! Very upsetting

[@Yohanan552]

"Isn't that corrupt? Isn't that cheating the public" - Neal Breen

[@ColeYounger16]

Hey Mike, love your channel! I find myself saying during the day, "let's give it a go"!

[@flej01]

R.I.P Kieth, my thoughts are with your family. Even if she manipulated him, she didnt drivd down and pull the trigger, jealously is such a horrid emotion.

[@kdot8340]

Nice.. more excuses for a woman.. had it been a man who had a woman killed, your comment would be attacking the man.. clown

[@flej01]

@Repo Man he was fooled by her but, he did it

[@Allworldsk1]

Yes and the cheating wife is directly responsible for this

[@christopherdunn3094]

Yeah, and you just never know how treachery will be received. Some men will walk away with a little dignity... others will off the whole family. It has happened so many times, to act incredulous is very disingenuous. She knew there were risks, she just thought she could control it. She caused this, otherwise these men never cross paths like they did.

[@utubecop11]

​@Repo-ManI beg you, 3 Brain Cell Boy, to explain the CCTV footage of him, then. Did she astral project his imagine to the school?

[@karaamundson3964]

I'll listen to your reruns a grillion times, but there's nothing like a brand-new That Chapter. Thanks, Mike...it's edge of my seat time again

[@ryanmilliken6106]

They are all reruns now.

[@daniellezadora7637]

This is by far one of the BEST channels! Love ur content and love the way u tell the stories too xo 😘 keep up the great work sir!

[@Preston-UNC]

"This phone smells like Vagina!! What's going on?" LOL bro you're hilarious.

[@paulaschmidt-ginn7162]

I have trouble sleeping and spend a lot of early mornings watching That Chapter videos. When he said "this phone smells like vagina" I laughed so loud I think I woke up some neighbors.

[@NecrOphelia747]

"Mr. Keith, din din" Thanks, Mike. I was about to start drinking in my car then saw this upload 👍

[@shitneyb5562]

What is happening here

[@nancybee250]

The thing that bugs me is that the wife knew her angry husband was going up to Keith's house, so why didn't she call and warn him? Maybe the same reason she accidentally left her steamy email up?

[@alikarol3]

She was probably pissed he broke things off with her.

[@narayanstar7787]

I agree, No one would leave an email like that up by mistake .No way. People know when they are being incredibly sneaky and they cover their tracks.

[@frenchy1987]

I instantly thought she left them emails opened on purpose!

[@pjlewisful]

wise advice from Mike about leaving some messages unread or deleted if in any uncertainty

[@ChrisSprenger.]

You’re just a likeable person ! Keep doing what you are doing, love this channel.

[@thejurydoctor6097]

Mike… I just want to say how much I appreciate your content and although I can’t afford to support you on Patreon, I’m subscribed, like all your vids and have watched all your vids at least 5x’s! The first channel I subbed to and only channel I religiously do the aforementioned for ❤

[@ThatChapter]

Thank you so much!! Your support means the world!

[@jamierupert7563]

Do you watch all the ads all the way through too? If not, you should. He doesn't get paid for them if you don't so if you're really supporting him, don't skip through the ads.

[@thejurydoctor6097]

@@jamierupert7563 I am on premium so I don’t have ads, I believe though because I’m premium the more I watch his shorts and vids he gets extra, right?

[@187mrsmith]

@@jamierupert7563 that's not how ad revenue share works at all you get paid more 💰 per how long they watch the ad but as long as the ad is played for 5 seconds he gets money which you can't even skip a ad until after 5 seconds so no matter what he gets money lol y'all sware u know people's bank accounts and finaces

[@frenchy1987]

​@@187mrsmith they are just trying to help,no need to be so cocky!

[@Sorchia56]

Quarter past 9p here in Ireland. Brilliant time to watch a video and get a dose of Mike before bed. Hubby just slid over to watch with me 😂. He’s American so it’s hilarious to hear him say ‘time to give it a goo?’! Mary should have left her husband long before contacting Keith. If your marriage is rubbish, take of it. Leave others out of your business. Poor lass’s lost a phenomenal Da. Rest in peace, Keith.

[@jenniferw5095]

Love you too 💕 Mike. Thank you for the story. It's sad she got that loving father killed.

[@callme_buddieganja4514]

Bro I just want to point out that 1.1k people have liked you in about 16 minutes of this. And also 16 minutes of you posting your newest video.... I have witnessed some big-time names like Mr. Ballen, does NOT get those kind of numbers, so fast. Bro I'm telling you. I'd be so proud of that! We do love you man! Edit: Thank you everyone for liking my comment so much! No looking for validation, but I just wanted Mike from "That Chapter" to know. To never quit. We love your coverage, and we don't want you to stop. Keep progressing like you are. You own that $h!T because you deserve it.

[@ruthie8785]

wholesome

[@Lady.Olga.]

I keep wanting to see Mike's channel bloom and blow up the way Mr. Ballen's has. They have 2 very different styles, but they're the 2 best at what they do. I like Beyond Evil as well, but yeah, Mike and Ballen. I keep watching to see Mike's numbers go up because he deserves it soooo much!

[@elisaseverns2543]

😊I discovered Mike while reading comments on a MrBallen video. I’m so glad I did. I enjoy watching both but really like Mike’s humor he interjects.

[@Johnieboi]

MrBallin sucks

[@rc6888]

Mr Ballen doesn’t tell stories like Mike, that’s for sure.

[@donnafeketemcmullian8786]

Thanks Mike for the advice at the end.