I Asked ChatGPT About the Four Dimensions of the External Affairs Powers of s51 (xxix)

I Asked ChatGPT About the Four Dimensions of the External Affairs Powers of s51 (xxix) | AUSSIE LAW

Рет қаралды 3,077

Күн бұрын

I tried Open AI's Chat GPT, and it did not correctly identify the four dimensions of the external affairs power of section 51 (xxix) of the Commonwealth Constitution. I explain each aspect of this constitutional head of power in this video.
0:00 - ChatGPT and s51(xxix)
3:00 - The correct answer
// This video does not provide legal counselling or opinion about cases. This channel was created for educational purposes only. //
SUBSCRIBE: kzbin.info?s...
BECOME A MEMBER: / @aussielaw
*****
PLAYLISTS:
- Australian Case Law - • Australian Case Law
- Constitutional Law - • Constitutional Law
- Constitutional Interpretation - • Constitutional Interpr...
- Constitutional Provisions Explained - • Constitutional Provisi...
- Federalism in Australia - • Federalism in Australia
- Australian Government (Executive) - • Australian Government ...
- Australian Parliament - • Australian Parliament ...
- Australian Law and History - • Australian Law & History
*****
RELATED VIDEOS:
- The Characterisation of Laws: Identifying ‘Heads of Powers’ in the Australian Constitution - • CHARACTERISATION of LA...
- Incidental Characterisation: The Incidental Power of Section 51 (xxxix) of the Australian Constitution - • INCIDENTAL CHARACTERIS...
- The “Subject-Matter” and “Purposive” Heads of Power in the Australian Constitution - • Purposive and Subject-...
- Characterisation and Proportionality: Tests to Balance the “means” and “ends” of Commonwealth Legislation - • Characterisation and P...
- The Australian Communist Party Case (1951) and the Purposive Defence Power of Section 51 (vi) - • The Australian COMMUNI...
- Tasmanian Dam Case (1983): The Corporations and External Affairs Powers of the Commonwealth - • TASMANIAN DAM CASE (19...
- The Commonwealth’s External Affairs Power Explained: Section 51 (xxix) of the Australian Constitution - • The Commonwealth’s EXT...
*****
RECOMMENDED READINGS:
- The Constitution of the Commonwealth of Australia (Aroney, Gernagelos, Murray and Stellios)
*****
LINKS:
- The Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act : www.legislation.gov.au/Detail...
- Tasmanian Dam Case : jade.io/article/67055
- R v Sharkey : jade.io/j/?a=outline&id=64626
- Koowarta v Bjelke-Petersen : www.jade.io/article/66984
- Seas and Submerged Lands : jade.io/article/66566
*****
TWITTER: / renatosmcosta
ACADEMIC PROFILES:
law.uq.edu.au/profile/11028/r...
www.uq.academia.edu/RenatoSaeg...
#auslaw #australianconstitution #externalaffairs

Пікірлер: 7

@AussieLaw Жыл бұрын

SUBSCRIBE: kzbin.info BECOME A MEMBER: kzbin.info/door/loahlV-M4A0LIc14rmfNnwjoin 0:00 - ChatGPT and s51(xxix) 3:00 - The correct answer

@josh1622 Жыл бұрын

Hey Renato amazing work. All your videos are very useful. Just subscribed. Quick question that I am confused about with regards to external affairs power if you have the time: can a treaty that is only signed but not ratified by aus executive gov enliven the external affairs power? (assuming the limitations for treaties pose no other restriction - bona fide… specificity… etc…). In other words can federal legislation be enacted with regards to a signed, but un-ratified treaty? (Sorry if I’ve missed/misunderstood this somewhere) :) Edit - just subbed as a member, sorry didn’t realise that was needed for comment reply :) !

@AussieLaw Жыл бұрын

Hi Josh, thanks for your question. The question is very interesting, and although not specifically in my area (but more towards Public International Law), I went around to find an answer. The treaty's signature (a prerogative of the Executive) allows the Cth Parliament to use its external affairs power to implement the treaty. The ratification occurs at both the domestic and international levels by the enactment of the Federal Law giving effect to the treaty. The best explanation is here: www.ruleoflaw.org.au/treaty-explainer/ .

@josh1622 Жыл бұрын

@@AussieLaw awesome! Thanks Renato, I see where I was going wrong now. That source is very helpful. Thank you for going out of your way to help, I appreciate it!