I CAN ONLY KEEP 20 PRODUCTS?!! My Curated Makeup Collection

[@SofiaSeesBeauty]

Thank you so much for collabing with me Charlotte! This was such a fun video to do 😆 so difficult to narrow down the choices 🤪😂

[@eleniminas7742]

Koukla mou you collaborated with the perfect person on yt .Charlote is precious as you too my two fav girls 👭 LOVE YOU ALL THE WAY FROM GREECE 🇬🇷 ♡♡♡

[@ra.j7210]

I love both of you. My fav girls including morgan, patty and tara. Miss mel though

[@samb6330]

I love you both and although I'm looking at my collection as a non youtuber thinking 'hmmmm, am I happy with a makeup room that I can't ever finish, lmao especially since I went straight to both your links for items I don't have 🤑🤑❤❤❤', I love seeing both your videos and your selection. Charlotte, the pat McGrath highlighter says the colour is vintage rose rather than divine rose, did she bring out a few colours? ❤❤

[@jeanettebennett1527]

Sofia is a joy to watch. I found her about a month ago and have come to really look forward to seeing her videos. Nice video idea!

[@katebruckner3731]

Hey i’m happy that i follow your channel 😊

[@macefresnoza8352]

I think this is exactly the type of video I find the most useful. I found myself really wasting away my coin with bulk buying makeup, decluttering my collection, and doing it all over again. I really just want a core group of amazing products! I'm finally at a point where I don't have many holes in what I want in my collection though I'm still always curious what others consider as their most reliable and go to products

[@reneegrace7965]

Hanging strong on the NO BUY! Day 23!!! I really want some of those lippies but until mine are empty they are a no for me! Loved this idea!

[@marielle7505]

💪 good! You're doing great, keep it up!

[@reneegrace7965]

@@marielle7505

[@Jen-if2it]

Good for you, stay strong!💜

[@SyifaAdriana]

Me too! Good for you and keep it up :)

[@reneegrace7965]

@@SyifaAdriana we can do it! I would love just 1 month with no makeup purchases on my cc. Wd got this!💕💕💕

[@alixlola2167]

I find out what I really love when I travel and have to pack! That's when I see what makeup I can't live without!

[@kirstenolson776]

I pretty much only have one or two items per category...except for lipstick. Having a large, fun lipstick collection is where I find joy.

[@SimoneDE]

I just did a real life version of this when I went on holiday for two weeks. I'm pretty sure I had more than 20 (lipsticks were my downfall) but getting it down to two foundations, two blushes, two bronzers, three Eyes to Mesmerise colours and a concealer was hard! I failed, I had two concealers (one was the Nars Soft Matte for blemishes, to be fair) and I also had a tinted moisturiser in there, but I managed! But I'm not going to mention how many eyeliners I took. That's where I draw the line. They're tiny, they hurt no one.

[@lovefilles]

20 pièces basic for me: Foundation: Lisa Eldridge Concealer: Chanel and Dior backstage Powder: CT Airbrush flawless Bronzer: Wayne Goss Eye Pencil: victoria Beckham Brown Mascara: Lancôme Mr. big or Chantecaille Lip Pencil: Lisa Eldridge or Victoria Beckham Lipstic: Lisa Eldridge Jazz and Dragon Gloss: L. E Dragon Blush: Hourglass face palette Tiger or Suqqu. Highlighter: Path Mc Grath Divine Rose. there you go! Eye shadows: ND Glam and Tom Ford Soleil Neige with the pastel green colour. + Lisa E. : Myth I am a warm yellow skin Tone.

[@VickyRyan2018]

Ohhh that TF soleil neige with the green shade is stunning, i need to use it more

[@lightfragmentsauracle]

This is amazing! I just put up a video yesterday about how I went to the drug store, mind you, and paid nearly $100 for 4 beauty products that I would in the past have paid $40 tops! I was blown away, $20 a piece for drugstore? And so I said that's it! I could have purchased a beautiful higher end product for this! I am going to keep using what I have, mostly higher end foundations and my skin care which is expensive... but unless it's something I HAVE to have, I'm not going to cave to all these new "affordable" drug store releases.

[@Heyitskrystal]

The Nars Orgasm on the Beach blush palette is discounted on Nordstrom Rack I bought it when it released but if you didn’t pick it up you deserve it ❤️

[@amykingston3133]

This is a collab match made in heaven. Two of my favorites! Glad you’ve found each other. Great choices:)

[@lesliehatch-herman9325]

This is an awesome idea for a video!! Thanks to both of you for sharing your pared down “essentials” ❤ Trying to limit the lipsticks would be an awful chore, and would make me weep like a small child. Love you guys!!

[@sunshinemayday]

My top two favorite youtubers❤ I watched every video of you two! I also love Tania B Wells😊

[@kymberly8908]

"One primer to rule them all." 😆 🤣 Lord of the makeup should be the next video!

[@CareyXO]

I just found Sophia not too long ago and I really enjoy her. She’s got a great personality and that’s important to me. I am not a KZbinr (unless you count the reviews I do in my head while putting on my makeup) but have a KZbin size collection. 😆 I guess it’s my passion that fuels my hobby/collecting. I’m going to be more cognizant of my purchases this year which is why I love your you don’t need that series.

[@SofiaSeesBeauty]

🤗🤗

[@katam3310]

Oh so it's not only me doing reviews in my head 😂❤️

[@CareyXO]

@@katam3310 You’re not alone. I find myself doing it all the time. 😉 Maybe I watch too much KZbin. 😂

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thanks for sharing!!

[@katam3310]

@@CareyXO 😂😂😂 same ❤️

[@Makeupbyrach18]

Can you do a GRWM using nothing new and do this makeup?? So pretty!! Unless you've already done it! I have trouble using my PM palette on a regular basis because I feel like it's too much. Don't get me wrong I'm not afraid of sparkle but your makeup looks so pretty and wearable.

[@karenphipps7532]

Not a KZbinr and am 75 years old and I couldn’t cut down to 20 products 😂 Good for you for trying to show us a bare minimum necessities ❤

[@DeborahCarlston]

Great concept. I love you both. My skin color is closer to Sofia's and I'm brunette, but both your channels are relevant. I use high end products, and with these high prices, reviews are essential. You have never steered me wrong. I wouldn't have bought Vega without your review. Great work, and thanks for the video!💚

[@chrystar1]

You and Sofia complement each other so well! You both bring that bestie vibe to your videos.

[@crab3696]

I definitely agree on the Hourglass palette especially for someone with warmer skintone, any one of Lisa Eldridge velvet lipsticks really look good and feel great, Charlotte Tilburys Easy Eye or Super Eye palettes are great. You should do one of these videos for travel and limit it to 12 or 15 products.

[@chinchillin6280]

I’m creeped out 😂 I’m literally in the middle of putting together my personal small capsule wardrobe of makeup. Did you read my mind?! Had to get a new little collection after throwing away all pre and pandemic era makeup :/ Thanks for the lovely content! Xoxo from Los Angeles!

[@CharlisDailyDiary]

Hi Charlotte! Love this kind of video! Great choices! Sofia is very good! Love her personality! Have a good week everyone!

[@noaamouyal1395]

I love my motherships (I have 5) and I'm actually a bit disappointed by Mothership X. It's not a BAD palette, but I seem to only get one or two looks out of it so if I could only have one (or two) palettes I def wouldn't pick that one. I'd probably go for Divine Rose II for party and ND's Glam for every day.

[@tjeannine99]

Haahaaa "25% more powerful!" So true. Lisa makes you feel so slammin', in charge, gorgeous! Honestly, her liquid highlighter is on another level, and her lips oh wait and her jewelry, oh wait and her foundation, oh wait and her LIPS and now her eye shadows - Geez!

[@marileem3162]

I love the products mentioned in these videos and I’m definitely going to give a few a try. Subscribed to both now. Well done ladies!! 💄❤️

[@violetgrace6856]

This is a fantastic and practical video-thank you. I have dozens of items in all categories but these items are all going in my cart! Beautiful advice! ❤

[@juliajulesiscool684]

Oh I have followed Sophia for a while too 😅like you she has a great fun side to her would have you both as great friends in real life 🤣💞

[@deejaywest7951]

If anyone is looking for the NARS cheek palette, it is on sale for $34.97 at Nordstrom Rack🥳

[@richapraja]

Charlotte, you are absolutely delightful and I love watching you. I have a request though - can you please do a swatch of Victoria Beckham's bronzer in shade 3 and 4? I'm definitely darker than you (around medium tan neutral) but would love to see their individual swatches to see what might be a good shade for my skin. TIA and much love xoxo

[@cwalsh4992]

Stunning collection! ❤️ Love Sofia too. She's amazing ❤️

[@shellteresa778]

I love this collab video!! This video is helpful for ppl that don’t want so much makeup. My makeup collection is smaller then a KZbinr but more then average person. Eyeshadow palettes, blushes, and highlighters is products I have a lot of. With foundations I always have a matte and a more satin one. I have oily skin but in winter mths it’s more normal. Powders I have just a few. I have two favorites. Bronzers I can get it down to one. I have my most favorite that I repurchase a lot.

[@chrissymoss514]

I reckon a lipstick and a lip liner ought to count as one - just my thoughts, but there you go. I would obviously cheat 😅😅 This was great fun, interesting and pretty thought provoking. Thank you 😊 Love ya, ❤🌸❤🌸❤

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

😅😅

[@valerievalois6263]

Wow, beautiful choices, versatile and covering all bases and every mood! Bravo Charlotte. 🥳👏

[@claudilovesbeauty9573]

I took notes of all the categories and will try to fill them with my important products. For example it is Chanel les beiges as foundation and loose powder. I love your video ideas!

[@EvelienHV85]

Fun collab! I happened to stumble across Sofia only last week and immediately subscribed!

[@SofiaSeesBeauty]

🤗👋

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🤩💞💞

[@pennypenpen5371]

Thank you! 🤩 I'm going to use this as my wish list when I want to try different products 💜🧚‍♂️

[@jackieturner4144]

I thought this video was really good for people just starting out with make up rather than just going out and blind buying also it gives over buyers inside xx

[@kristamarie02]

You know Charlotte is your favorite makeup KZbinr when you have all 20 products. I absolutely trust your opinions you never fail me 🫶🏼

[@KBellaBeauty1]

Oh this would be quite the challenge!

[@leazettegreen4625]

Great Collab. This was so much fun to watch. I would have to have my Nars and CT cream bronzers as well as my Gucci bronzer. I agree with your choice for the hourglass and the Chanel Water Fresh Tint. They are both great. I forgot about those two. I would never be able to do this video because there are just so many things I love.😂😂😂😂 You both did a fantastic job on narrowing your choices. Great video

[@alisonmarie252]

I love videos like this that highlight the holy grail products.

[@emmanewman9863]

I like this. I’m loving that charlotte tilbury setting spray. I’m going to buy the mascara, and pats powders. Thanks.

[@leeamoroso7845]

Spot on as always Charlotte! I would have to add Lash Clash by YSL which I just got this week and does magic to my lashes. Thanks for another informative video from which we can create a great "capsule" of makeup!

[@Desertmermaid52]

I will have to try the pillow talk mascara- I have tried her Legendary Lashes and I loved it! Soft fluttery lashes is what I love and it delivers. I never got the Hourglass palate- was dying to try it but it was too deep for my fair skin and the others had repeat powders I already had so had to pass on it. I love this type of video because aren’t we all trying to spend a little less and make use of what we already have and love? Great video Charlotte❤

[@tarski7420]

Great video & collab! Love watching you both, and loved all your picks. Your videos always brighten my day ☺️

[@meganryan9945]

So much fun! Lips would put me over the edge🤯

[@lisapierce525]

Great choice for a well rounded collection. I’m saving this video. There are several products in here that I want to purchase in the Spring after I’ve paid for a new central heating & air unit😩 Thanks Charlotte!

[@susanshowersinger6793]

This was a fantastic video idea and it really was helpful to hear you reason out each of your choices! This is real life for most of us, and I definitely will be checking out the items that made it through your selection process😁

[@lovefilles]

Your eye makeup is really amazing today! Very unic combo of colour!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you so much 🙂

[@marianmoore6901]

Charlotte have you tried the Suqqu blushes? They are so soft and buttery and blend like a dream, with lovely colour choices. I have numbers 3 & 4 and they are beautiful 😍

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Yes! x

[@Bekind94]

You ease my anxiety. Thank you.

[@twoleftfeet9626]

Dior glow primer is now my HG. Goes beautifully with Haus Labs foundation. Dior forever concealer has kicked Huda Beauty off the top spot for my HG concealer

[@kittenfantastic7730]

I am a non KZbinr and work from home…I have more than 20…eyeshadow palettes alone oops 😳 I like shiny pretty things 😂

[@ClaireJaneGray]

Re the Hourglass face palette, they were recalled and I was led to believe it was so they could be taken out of their limited edition cases and placed in another one. I love my Elephant one - it is gorgeous: thanks for the recommendation ❤

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🤞🤞🤞

[@DanielaTemelkovska]

Such a joy watching you both❤🙏🍀

[@DM-eg6ow]

Oh. Great picks! I would have thought you might have gone with the MAC Stack, but that can get messy on the lower lashes.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Charlotte Tilbury has been my holy grail for a LONG time x

[@megdvs21]

Such a glorious curation 😃🤩, the hourglass foundation and the Lisa Eldridge enchantment lipstick would also be in my curation if i were to do this type of curation 😀☺

[@melissastarbuck7553]

I thought for sure you were going to choose Cinnabar, but enchantment is so lovely❤

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Enchantment is much more wearable more often for me x

[@rosaazevedo6667]

Wonderful! Congratulations!!

[@chelseatodd2194]

Seriously……. Two of my favorite KZbinrs collaborate……..click…..I’m in!

[@sharigreenman1020]

Catching up on your videos Charlotte. Thank you for this one. Can you compare the CT Nude Talk to JK Magic please?

[@VickyRyan2018]

My holly grails : MUFE HD concealer shade 3.3 / Chanel Les Beiges Eau De Teint in shade Medium / MUFE Ultra HD Setting loose powder / Sisley Phyto-Touche Sun Glow Bronzing / DIOR Blush in Charnelle / CT setting spray / DIOR single shadow in Beige Mitzah / NARS lipstick in 112 / Lawless one and done Mascara / CoverGirl Brow pencil in soft brown along with ABH Brow Freeze Hope you like my holly grails guys

[@preetibhatia9795]

Hey Charollet..love the video..❤️👌u r right 1 blush nd 4 lippies it was really tough 😂For me in top 20 onlu blushes nd lippies..lol

[@tamizilla]

Hallo Charlottes, I have been on the hunt for a lower waterline pencil. Noting stays in my allergy eyes! I am thinking to try this. I Like your choices most of those I have and yes do touch, MINE lol. Love this video. Thank you

[@doledesigns5938]

Loved this- got me thinking!! A couple of questions- did I miss a brow product? Just curious, but I was wondering what you would pick. Also it would be awesome to see a get read with me now using just these 20 products. I never miss your videos- love them all♥️

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

No! As I only had 20 spaces I skipped brows as I have mine laminated I rarely need to do much to them! That would be tricky as there are several products in each category and only the one face 😅

[@eleniminas7742]

OMG MY TWO FAV GIRLS COLLABORATING ♡♡♡ @SOFIA SEES BEAUTY IS GREEK ♡♡♡♡♡♡ SHE WAS IN GREECE 🇬🇷 THIS SUMMER. LOVE 😍 YOU BOTH SO MUCH ♡♡♡♡♡♡♡

[@WendyWiseBeauty]

Great video Charlotte Thanks. ❤

[@nadiadncr]

Great picks Charlotte 💕

[@darlosmurf148]

Charlotte. Really enjoyed this video 🤌 also - has that Dior box found its home on your fragrance shelf? 🤣

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Of course!

[@JustMe-px9qy]

Dalia, Oasis and Tide are my favorite. Oasis and Tide remind me a little of Chanel Adrien and Chantcalli Honeypot. What are your thoughts?

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I'm not sure what we're talking about? 😅

[@gemmas8052]

Charlotte, I was with you all the way. I could manage with one bronzer, blush ( be still my beating heart) I could pick a couple and a palette, but for the love of all that is holy my anxiety hit the roof when you got to lipsticks, and I didn't want to play this game anymore! 4 lipsticks? I had to check my lipstick drawer to make sure they were all snug in their beds, 4! Not on your nelly!

[@ke-chiachen6726]

Love this video! Does Tom Ford's or Hourglass's foundation turn oxidized? I have been using GA for a long time and have started to think about finding a new one.

[@garianne]

LOVE you both!!! ❤❤❤

[@SofiaSeesBeauty]

🤗🤗

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

💞💞💞

[@MrEjw412]

Pretty

[@AC-qo8oq]

Great video

[@lindalew8087]

Love this topic!! 🙏

[@melindagenitempo2359]

Loved this concept. Didn't Sofia do this with All feisty too? Love all these great collaborations Picking 4 lipsticks gives me the hive yikes 😬

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

They did a holiday releases collab! x

[@melindagenitempo2359]

@@CharlotteHoldcroft yes I saw it. Yall did so well it was great

[@sallyhumphrys7955]

No eyeshadow primer? I find the Pat Mcgrath shadows fall everywhere without one.

[@pamelawolf313]

QUESTION: Would you say that the les beiges from Chanel would be light enough for the palest skin? I’m so interested but done want it to be too dark for me. Please & thank you.

[@yeshikanaidoo7702]

Love most of these, although I can’t seem to use the Huda concealer without it creasing or coming off! I’m not sure what I am doing wrong as this does not happen with the Nars, Pat McGrath or Shiseido :(

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

It may just not work for you/your skin type! x

[@itsthespiceoflife]

You didn't say what mascara that was? But if I had to guess is it charlotte tilbury?! Lol

[@katebainbridge]

It’s the pillow talk push up lashes!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I mean, if you don't know by now....😉 but everything is listed in the description box x

[@lavayuki]

I never bought anything from Tom Ford as they are far too expensive for me, but SPF50 is pretty high for a foundation as most are 15-20 or 30 if anything. Have you tested if it has flashback btw, like is it really bad? I used spf 20-30 ones without issue so just wondering how the tom ford one fairs

[@mariet647]

I'm surprised you didn't include Lisa Eldridge Velvet Affair! You always talk about how much you love that color but the CT and Dior must've stolen the crown 😆

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

One of my absolute favourites, but this wasn't a favourites video and therefore the thought process was different! I made choices that were very versatile, I could wear very often and were very different to the others x

[@ashligannon]

Hi! Sofia sent me :)

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Hi!! 💞💞

[@Linallarii]

Tom ford foundation photograph well without flashback?

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Absolutely x

[@tammystewart7059]

Good morning from Washington State 💕💕💕

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Morning!

[@phoenixgirl11]

Hi. I have a question. It doesn’t pertain to this video but awhile back I was watching one of your videos and you mentioned a product for your eye lashes that didn’t have the prostaglandins ( I think does how you write it. It doesn’t have that thing that changes your eye color) can you please tell me what was the product and do you like it? Thank you so much 🙏

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Glow for it! You can find out more in my December roundup x

[@phoenixgirl11]

@@CharlotteHoldcroft Thank you 🙏

[@Beyondsixty]

Are your final lipsticks have staying power, I have so much trouble finding a lipstick that lasts through a meal?

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Have you tried the Rouge Dior Forever? x

[@jilldocwra9391]

You never said what the mascara was,looked like Charlotte Tilbury packaging.?

[@rurifamelia8549]

Did she give a long explanation about mascara but didn’t say the name of the mascara? 😮

[@lindapassos]

Just 20???😬 Let's see from this 20 how many I need to ADD to my collection 🙈😉🤣🤣🤣

[@DrTaid]

🩺

[@reneefrenette2106]

Hello! I'm a cream-cheek-product fan and I'm reaching out for help with... powders! After my glowy base and cream bronzer is applied, I find it so awkward to then blend a powder blush on top! I assume brush type makes a difference? Can you do an in-depth powder blush on top of a cream base tutorial with brush options? Would love that. Keep up the great videos! 💗

[@carolegunfield9460]

You have to set foundation with powder first.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Which cream bronzer you use is important! It needs to set down otherwise it will definitely be trickier to apply powders on top! My favourite is the Charlotte Tilbury x

[@pappyone6062]

So this is 20 products excluding lip products, right? Otherwise no way I could do it 😂

[@donnamcdermott443]

Should have done a high-end and drugstore version of this video I can't afford to spend that much money on make up and with you saying that the other girls channel is all about luxury there's no point in going over to that channel she probably won't review anything the average Joe like me can afford to buy 😔

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

We are both luxury beauty channels 💞