NO 1 PRODUCT IN EVERY CATEGORY! What Survived From 2021?

[@sambricker2234]

Girl Mel made me buy almost everything lol. She could really sell a product. I miss her

[@Ajlatango]

Can’t believe it’s been a year since she’s gone

[@theoracleofmakeup8061]

Mel Thompson truly WAS the POWDER QUEEEEEEN ❤️ 💔 she will be forever missed 💔😢

[@Heyitskrystal]

This format is great if that different format takes ALL day please never feel pressured to do it ❤️

[@kirstenolson776]

I wish Pat McGrath would come out with a palette of just her duochromes and special shades. I don't want to drop a bunch of money on a Mothership palette when all I really want are 2 maybe 3 shades. If she did a Mothership of just the special shades, I would throw my money at her.

[@KaliKali-hv9bt]

Yes I only love the VR shade in mothership X

[@dazereigh]

Mel made m buy the Sisley too 😉 it’s so pretty, that iridescence is just so nice.

[@oceanbird.]

My favorite setting powder is the one from Saie. I also hate powder because my dry skin looks sooooo dry with powder. But the Saie one gives me blurring and sets everything without looking dry. I can't even see it when it's on, and it almost melts into a satin finish. Beautiful stuff! And I thought I'd never have a favorite powder.

[@lavayuki]

I love a lot of your recommendations, I trust your reviews and love discovering new great makeup from your channel :) It's fun to look at how our makeup tastes change in just a year. I was thinking maybe your Tom Ford foundation would be kicked off the pedestal with all the great releases, I was wrong! Although i'm equally surprised to see the pat mcgrath concealer replaced by Huda, I'm a big fan of the Pat MG after you recommended it so now I want to try the Huda one if it's truly better, as Pat's one is amazing

[@CobraDove1111]

Wow! It looks like you are the beauty youtuber I've been looking for! One who is super honest, talks about stopping mindless consumerism and shows the best of the best products always for those of us who buy minimal makeup and want to buy the best. I literally just made a comment on another of your videos decrying the lack of youtube videos that do this, keep a number one and see what kicks it out! THANK YOU!

[@nadiadncr]

I’m shook Tatcha is not your n1 primer but I loved the option you gave I want to try it. Love this type of video and to add 80% of my make up is from what Mel made me buy I miss her very much 💕 midnight sun is one of many items you made me buy 😂 😝

[@chlomo2618]

I like the Lisa Eldridge glosses but I'm not a fan of the component. It's awkwardly shaped so that once you've used a third of the product the doe foot can no longer reach the gloss. You have to take out the stopper and move the gloss around so you can reach it, then when you get to the last third of the product you have to remove the stopper entirely and use a lip brush. I'd definitely prefer a softer applicator too, as this is fairly scratchy. The packaging lets it down and after going through two I'm not going to buy any more.

[@mariam.a.]

I may have to think long and hard about most of these categories before choosing a favourite, but blush is one that is a no brainer in my house. We worship Pat's Desert Orchid and that's that. Really enjoyed this video Charlotte!

[@lightfragmentsauracle]

The Pat McGrath Midnight Sun is still on sale. I researched makeup sites the other night and decided to settle on the Nars site wide sale. I purchased 2 minis, blush and bronzer as well as the Illumination foundation, all for $65. I thought that was a great price for 3 items. If I don't like the minis, not a great loss, I can pass them on without breaking my heart lol. I looked at every single palette on the PM site and really studied the colors. The Midnight Sun, for me, would get more use because of the color theory, not just because it was on sale. But thank you for your in depth reviews.

[@twoleftfeet9626]

I ditched silk canvas in favour of the Nikkia Joy primer. Ditched Pat Mcgrath concealer in favour of the Huda beauty one, Cle De Peau is still my favourite foundation

[@veronicamcminn7775]

You like the Nikkia Joy? I thought of trying it. I love her loose powder. I love the silk canvas so I’m reluctant to try. But if you think is fabulous maybe I will try it! I was worried it may be too Matte.

[@twoleftfeet9626]

@@veronicamcminn7775 no it isn't too matte at all. I find it excellent

[@veronicamcminn7775]

@@twoleftfeet9626 great thanks I’ll give it a go.

[@janicedevereux2839]

@@veronicamcminn7775 I purchased the Nikkia primer also… I have to say it is nowhere near as good as silk canvas. It does not blur my pores like silk canvas or the Tarte. Possibly because the key is is a liquid as opposed to the Tatcha and the Tarte being putty’s 🤷‍♀️. Good luck.

[@veronicamcminn7775]

@@janicedevereux2839 yea that is true. Consistency is key!

[@grammigram3225]

You have come s9 far in the las5 four years! Congratulations on your success!

[@GMW.artist]

For me, Benefit 24hr Brow Setter is the ONLY thing that keeps my hairs up and in place!!. I brush it in backwards and let it dry a little, then brush it in the right direction and then press them down with my finger... 😎✌🏼💜

[@Monica68817]

You are so entertaining! 🤣 Glad I found this channel!

[@isabelsolana157]

Regarding the charlotte mascara controversy, I bought both sizes and I must say I love far more the bigger size, the small one dried so quickly and my lashes were less impactful. I recommend 100% the big one, It’s my holy grail 😍

[@av-lz5db]

Calm...YOU are here in your format (no try on), definitely not a shambles. You are living your best life, family, channel. Many items were probably tried on in previous videos. 🎀

[@pattylynch8609]

The nozzle on the Charlotte Tilbury large bottle is so much better. It’s a much finer mist. My continued repeat fave is also the push up lashes. Sooo good.

[@olgacherkasova7111]

I would like to report that yes, I used the full size of Push up lashes, and this mascara was absolute goals, then it finished I bought travel size of that same mascara, and the effect from it is nowhere near the full size version!

[@ShonaMM75]

Yassssss! Love this video concept. Your choices are excellent imho. ❤️

[@marniash9559]

So, I have some broken capillaries on my cheeks that I struggle to conceal and the huda concealer is THE BEST at covering!

[@parksbpknit]

Caliray mascara, OMG and Maybelline Sky High, cannot live without both, give it a go!

[@CobraDove1111]

same, I like Loreal Beauty Tubes tubing mascara and maybelline Sky High for when I want bigger lashes. I want to try Caliray, but I refuse to spend that much on mascara....unless for some reason it totally is really worth it

[@parksbpknit]

@@CobraDove1111 it is, I had a travel size originally and recently bought the full size.

[@oliviagilpin8057]

I just came across your channel and I can't stop watching your videos! My favorite foundation is the La Mer "The Soft Fluid Longwear" I really recommend it!

[@surimoskowitz3249]

I wish Lisa eldridge would make her lipsticks more accessible. In USA had to order.

[@kirstenolson776]

I tried the full size Charlotte Tilbury mascara and don't care for it. However, I know my preferences in mascara performance are different than yours. It clumps too much, makes my eyes dry and itchy, and leaves a lot of fallout (probably because I touch my eyes because it makes my eyes itchy). In comparison, I love the Lancome Hypnose 8, which you despise, lol.

[@ayesha5113]

Yes, the sample size CT mascara has definitely been the worsy mascara I've ever tried. It even smudged when I just had a zoom call around the house. Now I'm curious to see if the full size will work for me.

[@hildawhincup6700]

Def Mel made me buy Sisley powder a few years back. 💔love your choices even though I have not tried a lot of them. Love your wit, your style your comedy whatever you call it. Chef’s kiss 😘 at how you do this channel.

[@laurieann2714]

I love any reviews you do and always love your sense of humor!

[@mariarosemarie]

How did you get that look with Midnight Sun? I decluttered that palette because it was too dark for me and difficult to work with. I see people make beautiful looks with it, but I hated it every time I used it. So, I'm very curious how you got such a light and bright look with it?

[@janicedevereux2839]

I’ve always struggled with mascara on my bottom lashes. It just looks like charcoal gray shading and it is not attractive… The beautiful Mel Thompson had mentioned that she used a tubing mascara for her bottom lashes🤯. I pulled out my Thrive mascara that I did not like at first, but like most mascaras it got better over time👏👏👏. I now love it❤️. My lashes just grow and grow and grow with that mascara… Just need to be careful of clumps. One good coat and your lashes look fabulous you don’t even need a second coat but of course I pile it on🤷‍♀️. When I put the Thrive on my bottom lashes they look fantastic. I like that Betty Boop lower lash look, somewhat spidery. The tubing mascara was definitely the answer. I now love doing my bottom lashes👏👏👏👏👏. Just one more thing I am thankful for Mel🥺… she was so talented and taught me so much❤️.

[@Eileen3007]

Great video Charlotte xx

[@HannaTK]

I call my RMS blushes "Charlotte blushes" ;-) You started my obsession with these and I'm so grateful!

[@janicedevereux2839]

I too am loving the RMS blush🥰. You have done a tutorial with the blush a couple of months ago and I fell in love with it👏👏👏. It is so beautiful with it a luminosity without being a highlighter. I am 50 years old and highlighters do not come near the face anymore… I will run and hide from anything glitter..😳. With these new blushes and it’s beautiful shades has just the right amount of glow without any sparkle… They are just beautiful... $30 for the compact and 25 for a refill… I have two shades but I’m going back with the black cherry shade I don’t recall the name🤪. So so pretty.. You Charlotte made me buy it... my first shade was also Mia Tia. He then had me pick up one of his friends to move in.. Pat McGrath are Beautiful also. Pats embossed flowers on her blushes are just so so pretty🥰 I love those too❤️

[@garnwalkerstables]

Me too that RMS blush is amazing!! I would never have purchased it but for influencers but it's gorgeous

[@gailainsley6939]

I only came to watch because you had the Charlotte tilbury mascara up. I wanted to see if you had the same opinion as me on it but you don’t..😅but I’m glad you mentioned that someone else did because I don’t like it either (I got the full size) but It really does go to show how everyone has different experiences with things. I thought I was going crazy 😂

[@beckaj2775]

Wow I have brought so many of these because of you! Charlotte never lets me down!

[@KittyKat9999]

On your comments, I got the huda concealer and you are right! Better than mcgrath. Huda doesn’t crease much at all and smooth ❤️

[@deejohnson827]

Yay! Another Charlotte video! I appreciate how you made clear that you still enjoy the former winners. After hearing last year that the PM blush was your favorite, I put it in my wish list. I have yet to buy it, so now the RMS will be added to it. 😁 Thanks for sharing!

[@Midwest_Sunshine]

I’m obsessed with the RMS blushes! Bought 1, then bought the other 5. (Oops!) My complexion is pretty fair, but I find that each shade still works for me. (Hanky Panky was an unexpected love.) They are GORGEOUS! Also fell in love with the Chantecaille Anti-Aging Face Tint this year…perfect for a 5 minute makeup routine. Loved hearing about your favorites, thanks for sharing! xo

[@elainebines6803]

I'm definitely picking up the blush soon

[@Midwest_Sunshine]

@@elainebines6803 you will not be disappointed! They are absolutely beautiful and so easy to use. I got a free blush brush with mine, so you may look around and see if that code is still out there.

[@angelabenigno]

Hi Charlotte, you made me discover and try both the mascara and the setting spray of CT and now I loooove them! (BTW, I had never used a setting spray before…) thank you!

[@loism7703]

I love that you don't wear eyeliner on the top or bottom today. I use dark eye shadow for both but most of the time I don't do any eye liner look of the top, I do do a dark crease (blended). Hard lines are something I don't like.

[@oceanbird.]

I got the Lisa Eldridge dragon gloss too! The color is so pretty!!! And YES to the Charlotte tilbury setting spray! It's so good! It holds like nothing else and doesn't change the finish of your makeup. And it also is alcohol free which is great for my sensitive skin. Love that stuff!

[@andrageorgescu1147]

I will definitely buy the Huda concealer because of you after I finish the Nars one (also have the Rose inc but I need at least one to go before a new one 😅) I was also rooting so much for the VB bronzer!! I sadly broke mine badly during a fall and will be buying a refill but I tried the last bit of it today after using the Rose Inc/Vieve (Dawn palette) one for a month and... The VB is supreme in how natural it looks ❤️ shame for the price 🙈 And always do the video formats that work for you, we'll be happy either way x

[@heatherkrome8280]

Got the CT mini mascara as my bday gift from Sephora & was so excited because you rave about it, but it smudged so bad on my bottom lashes.. now, your theory has me wanting to try the full size!!

[@adawinford6511]

Ok, you talked me into my first Pat MG pallet. At least it was on sale. I love both my sample size and full size CT mascara. Actually prefer the sample size because it’s easier to apply. Your videos always cheer me up.

[@fenixcharlotte]

Oh wow I haven’t tried the full size pillow talk mascara. I did try the sample size and hated it !

[@amykingston3133]

I really enjoyed seeing how your preferences have changed! Mimirose is my ultimate fav! I’m dying to try the RMS blush. You have me interested in midnight sun now. Mascara is a tie between the Caliray and Rare beauty.

[@michellegerrell2375]

Fabulous review Mrs H!❤️ At the risk of sounding a bragger I have most of makeup mentioned( mainly off the back of your reviews). Love, love, love the the Tom ford primer and Victoria Beckham bronzer the best 😍 expensive they are but feel so chic when I apply them!The Dior Addict lipsticks are next on my wish list to buy! Love your channel 👏💞

[@gladysgarrity5721]

Thank you for sharing love 💕 all the products so beautiful see you soon 🌺

[@twoleftfeet9626]

Try the Urban Decay all nighter setting spray. I found it to be better than the Charlotte Tilbury one

[@MsBNoodle]

I used to use the Urban Decay one but much prefer the CT!

[@sarahhollowayshore7141]

I didn’t get on with the push up lashes in black but then I bought it in maroon and really like it … tempted to try the black again! Love this video Charlotte ❤️

[@evamobius6689]

I have the full size CT mascara and it gives me raccoon eyes and stick straight lashes 😂

[@reneegrace7965]

How do you wash your face with your brows laminated? Do you have to be careful when removing the rest of your makeup?

[@DM-eg6ow]

I had the full size Charlotte mascara first and loved it. I got the smaller size for travel and I couldn’t wait to be done with it and get the full size tube again.

[@KBellaBeauty1]

I love hearing your updated faves!

[@chrishawkins6362]

I tried the CT Pillow Talk mascara and was sooo disappointed. I didn’t like the formula or the wand and yes, it was the travel size. Now you’ve got me wondering…..

[@juliep971]

Video idea: when you think the travel size is different than normal/full size. I can think of several product examples.

[@megdvs21]

Such a fun video 🙂 I didn’t have a favorite blush or highlighter so far this year or year ….. but a may in blush by the end of they year because I am thinking of picking up the chose your own Pat Mcgrath blush trio deal soon, but in other categories I do have so new or additional favorites from last year, so in the categories that I have new favorites in, I have : Brows - new favorite this year - CT brow cheat & refill Mascara - last year - rare beauty perfect strokes mascara - This year - both the rare beauty perfect strokes mascara ( for a drama mascara ), and the milk makeup rise mascara ( for everyday makeup ) Eyeliner - last year - toofaced killer liner in the shade killer storm - this year - lh cosmetics crayon in the shades grey and greige Powder - this year - kosas cloud set powder Setting spray - last year - CT airbrush flawless setting spray - this year - CT airbrush flawless setting ( winter spring and autumn , tarte stay spray ( specifically in summer ) Lipstick - last year - Lisa Eldridge velvet lipsticks - this year - Lisa Eldridge velvet lipsticks ( autumn/winter ), lux lucent lipsticks ( spring/summer )

[@olechka2023]

I have the opposite experience with CT mascara, love the small one and not the full size.

[@amyhuber4787]

Definitely a few surprises!!! Love this video!!!!!

[@QueerBones]

Midnight sun is my favorite mothership

[@PM-xj5fp]

Travel size or full size, (Charlotte Tilbury mascara), it should preform the same. Unacceptable that it doesn’t. I’ve tried the full size and it was awful. It was so dry, it was like I had it for years. Returned it the next day

[@caitlinallen8400]

Don't feel bad. Your family comes first!

[@kkbay88]

Fabulous selection 🥰. Midnight Sun is £70 at the moment on the PML website. (Or it was yesterday). I'll be using mine all through Autumn, along with Bronze Seduction.🍁🍂 Not sure I like the CT mascara though...I think it's messy 🤷🏻‍♀️...but I have the burgundy shade...so now I'm wondering.🤔 Xoxo

[@theresabmcintyre]

I absolutely hated that Charlotte tilbury mascara….but it was the travel size. Will def try the full size as so many people absolutely rave about it. I also need all of the Lisa Eldridge liners and glosses 😂 x

[@tyishastephen]

Midnight Sun is my fav too. It’s brilliant!

[@mariaflower6369]

Hi Charlotte 👋. Was just wondering if you buy the Victoria beckham beauty? I've just recently bought their eyeshadow brick in signature and would love some inspiration in using it. Also have you tried the lipsticks? They're amazing! Hope you're well hunny xx

[@katietetzloff9248]

Have you tried the newish Laura mercier glowy blushes?!! They’re so beautiful and definitely a new favorite for me!

[@MelissaSmith1]

❤❤ Thank you for this video! I love it!

[@tanyts]

Hi Charlotte, can you say what shade you got the huda beauty concealer in? Thanks 💕🙏

[@derilyjoy]

Oooh I just picked up midnight sun on sale. My 1st Pat palette. Yay!! Excited to get.

[@sureiseeyou]

It was my 1st too. It's OK for me. Not my favorite as its too much like the Jungle Lights palette I own by Flower Beauty. I'm gonna try the 10 maybe.

[@derilyjoy]

@@sureiseeyou hoping to get no. 10 when on sale as well. Those colours look so wearable.

[@sureiseeyou]

@@derilyjoy yes. I agree. Very wearable.

[@adawinford6511]

Me too! I hope I like it.

[@derilyjoy]

@@adawinford6511 I'm 55 Ada so not sure if too pigmented & will accentuate my crepey eyelids but I'm dying to try. Even just a 1 & done with the green or taupe will be pretty I think 😀

[@idreamofparis7233]

The CT mascara is the opposite for me. I tried the travel size and liked it enough to buy the full size. The full size betrayed me. 😂😂

[@jennyhicks1930]

Same!!!

[@jillpotts7472]

im so excited for this video ❤️❤️❤️

[@preetibhatia9795]

Hey Charollet..u won’t believe before u say I knw the ans m so surprised I knw most of ur favs❤️❤️👌👌love the video…

[@geebrewer8186]

I love your eyebrows. I really don't like heavy, dark eyebrows, and yours are very nice. I like the color altho it is a little red for me. But they do flatter your face without standing out like Groucho Marx brows. Being a senior, I have none of your recommendations from last year or this year lol. My fav lipstick/gloss is Chanel Rouge Coco Flash in the color Jour. Matches my lips well adding just a tiny bit of color, and my fairer (but with rosacea) skin tone. Having Rosacea all my life, blush was always my least favorite product, never used it due to the redness of my skin.

[@taylamae3421]

I would LOVE to know what you think about the Westman Atiler setting powder!??

[@debbieotoole1072]

I absolutely love PML midnight sun it's gorgeous. CT setting spray is still my favourite setting spray. I used to love the CT flawless foundation but now thats charged it's now the Nars light reflecting foundation absolutely love it and my skin has changed alot in the last 12 months, i have my acne under control now so i want more medium coverage now less full coverage. My brows are still the same it's the Benifit 24hr brow setter, goofproof and Huda Beauty bombbrows. Great video

[@elainebines6803]

I was surprised with the blush. My number one and has been for a number of years is guerlain meteorites

[@BlingyBea]

I’m one who bought that CT mascara in the mini and brand new it was all dried out, maybe I need to try a full size, good to know.🥰

[@gailschaefer-guajardo6731]

Great review on your fav's👍💯❗

[@eo4zoa]

Absolutely hate VB bronzer. It hard panned after a few uses. For the price I paid, I’m pissed!

[@Ari_Kle]

Loved this video! ❤️

[@jillpotts7472]

i was suprised about the blush!!

[@miriamhanvey5826]

I love hearing your favourite hope yourcare enjoying your summer holiday with the kids not long now until they are vack to school xx

[@jillpotts7472]

u have to try them all on sometime!! but i still appreciate u❤️

[@Lovesmakeup4772]

What happened to the Lisa Eldridge foundation? I was eyeing that for my next foundation but it seems to have dropped off peoples radar.

[@leeamoroso7845]

Can you do a contour vs bronzer video with placement? Thanks!

[@silvipaskov9147]

Totally good choices but I am wondering about the mascara - CT? I tried Lancome Grandiose and it was phenomenal- the difference is that longevity of Lancome is like ×10 more, doesn't go under your eyes and you get the same effect. The price is the same...

[@jackieturner4144]

I love all the colour tops/ vests xx

[@Erin.Kendall]

Armani is my favorite concealer

[@elainebines6803]

OK, I've got the large size hourglass primer. It's going to take ages to get through as I have a few more primer brands lurking in second and third drawer but no Tom Ford primer 😭

[@peninalipkin2974]

I have purchased so many things because you even though we have different skin tones and i have been happy with everything. i love rms blush i wore it today to work in Sangria just stunning. I plan to get maidens blush for the fall time

[@kuklakid]

Maiden’s Blush is amazing

[@louisewarren6472]

I just love the story time !!!!

[@juliajulesiscool684]

Really interesting regarding the push up lashes. Mine smudges every time but it’s the travel size 😬 do I risk the full size 🤷🏼‍♀️ I love it otherwise 🤣 hope we get some feedback in the comments 😘👌🏼 to all your other favourites I’ve purchased many❤️

[@lavielyle168]

Oh Charlotte I have missed you..

[@daniellespence7022]

I have love pillow talk mascara so I brought the travel size one to take on holiday and it was rubbish 😩

[@X3N14]

I loved the Charlotte Tilbury contourwand but somehow the dark shade is perpetually out of stock. The lighter one seems to always be in stock. Very annoying because it’s my favourite for contour.

[@marielle7505]

Hmm. I tried the Charlotte Tilbury mascara in the mini size too. Didn't like it. Curious now about the fullsize. But I do think that a mini should be a proper presentation of how the product performs. There shoudn't be a difference. Still a bit curious now.

[@kimberlyfouche8119]

Do you have access to One Size? They have a great setting spray.

[@Charlottec968]

I tried the travel size Charlotte Tilbury Mascara, looks great but flakes off throughout the day tempted to get the full size now