‘I didn’t have any human rights’: Hostage captured on October 7 speaks with Andrea Mitchell

Andrea Mitchell sat down with Aviva Seigel, a hostage who was captured by Hamas from a Kibbutz on October 7th and released after 51 days.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/information/dow...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#Hostage #Israel #hamas

[@yasminyitzhak-vanderhal2565]

Just horrible! The hostages must be released from those monsters.

[@aabanlafeez6166]

What about the Palestinians that were taken from their homes and wrongfully put in prison? How about Israel stops treating Palestinians like dogs ?

[@aabanlafeez6166]

Nah not until they release innocent Palestinians. I don’t think they should be released

[@gruweldaad]

@@aabanlafeez6166Which innocent Palestinians? Name one.

[@aabanlafeez6166]

@@gruweldaad wow… just straight up ignorance I see

[@marleneg9729]

God bless you 🙏 I hope your husband and everybody else can come back and be safe and happy 🙏

[@NorthAmericanDemocracy]

Hope and love dear lady!😢

[@odedrokachify]

Praying for all the hostages

[@imhere8380]

Which ones? The hundred or so Hamas have or the thousands held with NO CHARGE by the Israelis.?

[@LucyO-jl1cw]

Abdoulll...abdoulll Take your medication on time. It's really important.

[@imhere8380]

@@LucyO-jl1cw Here we go again with a cold blooded Zionist reply.

[@user-sp1md5xu8j]

If all Americans or Europeans saw what Hamas did on October 7th, they would be incapable of supporting a state for the Gazans in any form and might even volunteer to join the IDF soldiers.

[@jonnyblunt4755]

​@@imhere8380 you listen to too much propaganda

[@Carla39894]

Those terrorists are monsters

[@willgee7777]

Sounds like how the slaves were treated to me

[@user-sp1md5xu8j]

If all Americans or Europeans saw what Hamas did on October 7th, they would be incapable of supporting a state for the Gazans in any form and might even volunteer to join the IDF soldiers.

[@aabanlafeez6166]

Yes those Israeli people that support this nasty mess are real monsters

[@avivacohen8785]

Keith is American, why doesn't Biden insist Keith be released now?? What kind of a person are you???

[@tzipi22]

the world needs to hear that. if they won't listen now they will regrat it

[@user-mu1vo2ys3x]

Or what? You’ll attack the world too? 😂😂😂

[@SHH0000000]

The people commenting here that are pro Hamas could care less about the hostages and the rapes. It’s disturbing.

[@Yanel5795]

And you could care less about palestinians or any brown and black victims of your white supremacy for the last 500 years. Not just Palestinians in gaza and the west bank October 6 and before

[@Yanel5795]

You make it team like palestinians attacked israel first. Or Palestinians supporters, as if Israel did not do anything to Palestinians 1948 to present , really 1917. They are acting in self defense. Invaders are in their land, you Christians are getting judgment from GOD very soon

[@Work4Good757]

They are all criminals. Everyone who supports Hamas are complicit

[@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci]

Of course they don't care; they're the same ones who were celebrating on Oct. 7th.

[@nancyiaj]

Free Palestine 🙌🏾

[@workingtoseethelight8244]

Thank you so much for courage and words.

[@Janet31690]

We are praying for you and all the hostages that they all come back home soon 🙏🏻🙏🏻❤🇮🇱🇮🇳❤

[@margerybritton793]

My heart is breaking with you❤️

[@tammyhightower2242]

My sincere prayers for you and your husband and the rest of the hostages

[@abynor8687]

Finally, we are allowed to see the other side of this tragic story... ..... HAMAS has to release the hostages now.

[@Joshua-fg8mz]

Finally this is been going on and reported on the whole time, why do you think people want a ceasefire and a trade of prisoners or hostages whatever you want to call it.

[@deicide666100]

As soon as Israel releases the thousands of hostages they have, at least the thousands of children they have kept without any type of charges or trials and put through military tribunals, but go ahead and keep asking for the “hostages “ ( soldiers and retired soldiers) to be released

[@deicide666100]

Still with the propaganda.. ugh

[@contact594]

@@deicide666100 just lies, there are not thousands of kids, you believe anything without evidence...

[@ceciliac3261]

@@contact594 and so do you

[@katelaloba8243]

This is how monsters behave

[@aabanlafeez6166]

Yes those monster Israelis had it coming to them when they treated the Palestinians like dogs

[@notthis888]

Unfortunately, I fear most of hostages are dead.

[@McGather]

the one of the worst parts these people were peace activists that was helping Palestinians for a better lives but Hamas come along killed and kidnapped them.

[@shshshshsh]

💔💔💔

[@huguettemasliah7365]

It hurts just to hear her

[@user-sp1md5xu8j]

If all Americans or Europeans saw what Hamas did on October 7th, they would be incapable of supporting a state for the Gazans in any form and might even volunteer to join the IDF soldiers.

[@saphire2214]

Nonsense

[@isabellrc]

People, especially those who are aware of worldviews have seen it all. It’s extremely complicated, so far as who is claiming what from when, which is serving no purpose right now. It’s getting innocent people out, and back to their homes. And, stop the vast warmongering that again, is not helping

[@fazoumanasanogo2660]

We did see it and we saw every day afterwards

[@snarf0596]

Well if Israel let the media in Gaza we could see this " Moral army" that I hear so much about.

[@user-sp1md5xu8j]

@@fazoumanasanogo2660 Who is this "we" that you are referring to?

[@JaneHallstrom1]

I’m so so so very sorry this happened to you and is still happening to you and your husband. And all the hostages. Horrible horrible horrible. I’m so sorry. 💜💙💜💙

[@18thCenturyMulatto]

All the pro Hamas supporters have no sympathy

[@matthew-jy5jp]

Grow up reject.

[@al-bot1094]

No sympathy for who? Everyone in Hamas was born into a concentration camp that was built by and is maintained by Israel.

[@ceciliac3261]

So if a person cares about children, humanity they are Hamas supporters? Only sick twisted fools would think that way!

[@SuperKripke]

I'm one of them. Is it a war aim to eradicate me as well?

[@al-bot1094]

...and you have no sympathy for people who had their land stolen and were put into a concentration camp.

[@nancycornett9949]

😢❤️

[@leandrocosta2311]

She knows her government let them down.

[@Bertrum123]

Seems the un are complisit in this by there actions what surprises me is that there are women that actualy support these monsters .

[@shshshshsh]

💛💛💛💛💛

[@user-ib3kb1fd1c]

😢

[@SilverSprings1997]

At least we can all agree that it's inhumane to block people's access to food, water, movement and basic human rights.

[@rooster1012]

Ummmm if only that was true, Israel obviously doesn't care that is why they are committing genocide,

[@tuckernaughton]

​@rooster1012 no they aren't

[@duncanpurves7955]

What we can agree upon is that it's inhuman for those people's government , Hamas, to be totally unconcerned about the provision of those essentials both during peacetime and war.

[@anatzalmanovich8793]

Israel is ttying to give food movment and freedom. How do you sugest dealing with terror govement like HAMS that imbeded them selfes inside bellow and above there own civillians?? By the way when we withdrawl from gaza on 2005 and gave it to the PLO we gave the m an airport there. They could develop there country but instead elected terrorists to lead them . The slugterd every member of the PLO in Gaza. The declair that they dont care about palestinkan country and suffering on earth but want some king if Islamic state in the middle east and to destroy any liberal values. We kept quiet and hve them money whlle the were firing rickets at us hoping that miney and prosperity will lead to moderate regim and peace in the future but they took all of it to bult terror tunles and rocket and to the leaders pockets... so waht do you suggest?? Is seema you all have no isea what realy is going on.

[@nagarmiri]

Shame on you

[@rebeccareid1494]

This is so sad 😞

[@carolineebert5602]

❤

[@TLH22]

Why isn’t the USA doing more to get our citizens held over there ?!?

[@mitchgaby5842]

This is tragic and she deserves respect. My concern is that this is now 6 months and we have over 30,000 people killed including children, not to mention 100 hostages who's lives are a stake because of the ongoing war. It's time to end this!

[@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci]

Hamas now admits it's far less than 30,000. And how do you propose this be "ended", without military force?

[@mitchgaby5842]

@@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci yes!

[@theresiarufenacht2210]

😭😭😭

[@FaizCaliph]

Anyone named Keith never gets sympathy

[@DaveDaShrubber]

Jimmy Carter's boy Anwar Sadat got whipped by Golda Meir when he attacked Israel on Yom Kippur.

[@FaizCaliph]

I see why they released her. Annoying voice.

[@contact594]

Peace for Israel means security. The world and all people of good will must respect the territorial integrity of Israel. We must see Israel’s right to exist and always go out of the way to protect that right to exist. Martin Luther King

[@tiaenadavis4304]

He also stood with Palestinians as blk American I hate when people try to use martin Luther King quotes to prove a point lol please read more about him and if he was alive today he would stand the oppressed people the PALESTINIANS

[@contact594]

@@tiaenadavis4304 oppressed...FFS ...they dug their own hole. Imagine your government dug 500 km of tunnels and they wouldn't let kids shelter in them.

[@zehavitmimran7414]

​@@tiaenadavis4304Martin Luther King stood with the Jewish people just because it doesn't seat with your agendas doesn't mean she is wrong so go on tell yourself whatever

[@willgee7777]

I love to know what was her life like before oct 7

[@RS-kq9rr]

Maybe living in a house they steal from a poor Palestinian or something. I don't believe a word she said. I can't since there is Genocide going on and previous hostages all said they were treated well

[@successfulperson3304]

What a courageous woman bless Israel!!! 🇮🇱 🇮🇱🇮🇱

[@ClaudinneV]

"Something needs to change..." let's start with Bibi... btw ...her accent..where is she from?

[@zehavitmimran7414]

Israel

[@TLH22]

People better stand with Israel and not fall for terrorist propaganda.

[@IaintreadingallthatFREEPALI]

So she is Australian and her husband is from North Carolina…

[@SuperKripke]

Yes they are indigenous to the land and their presence in Israel totally justifies the displacement of a people who have been there all their lives.😝

[@leilasmiller6070]

And 95% of arab muslims in America are fn American !!

[@asa1973100]

The Palestinians are all from Egypt and Jordan so what your point?

[@IaintreadingallthatFREEPALI]

@@asa1973100 lol they are? I didn't know that. didn't realize the 750,000 people expelled from Palestine in 1948 were actually invited in from surrounding countries. Im assuming all the land confiscation and displacement over the last 60 years is also actually Egyptians and Jordanian people coming in.

[@axaeyexus]

​@@asa1973100No. They're all colonizers from Arabia.

[@orangeapples3]

Let us pray the Holy Spirit descend upon all of Israel and bring peace and healing ☮️☸️💜

[@mohammadhoque239]

They don't have have any rights. How can you expect when you are with them!!!

[@hpysexyy]

Hamas are terrorists.

[@lohikarhu734]

"hard" comments get deleted...

[@RS-kq9rr]

Yep Because they want the propaganda to win

[@casanova0102]

She thanked Biden but not Bibi. Why?

[@krislee5343]

BIBI and the U S. Government have failed the hostages

[@MileHile]

Netanyahu is the Israeli PM. He is the leader in charge of negotiating the release of the hostages.

[@user-yb5bg8im5g]

hamas has failed the hostages

[@gruweldaad]

how

[@user-yb5bg8im5g]

@@gruweldaad because they are still hostages...

[@kathyelliott4051]

Her experience was for sure was awful. Sadly, her story isn't is as bad as some I have read about in the people in the West Bank. their experiences when kidnapped by the IDF is beyond brutal--if you live. I wonder if she knows what happens to women and children in the prisons? It is time for peace and an end to Israeli occupation.

[@ytc257]

You are a nice women. Do you know Jesus is a messenger of God

[@trexusification]

Women and children get kidnapped by the idf?

[@jdsthird]

@@ytc257Do you know that’s all fairytales?

[@JRR31984]

(ETC)

[@cx34r]

The hypocrisy and lack of self-awareness is astounding.

[@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci]

How would you like to go through what she went through?

[@RS-kq9rr]

​@@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci It's a lie They always lie They are discovering their lies, that's why they keep killing journalists

[@louisesullivan7426]

This is a terrible experience but it pales in comparison to the experience of 1000s of innocent Palestinians especially children.

[@zehavitmimran7414]

No it's not, its just your opinion we are bothered with the bibas kids a baby and a toddler helding in the tunnels just because they are jewish so go on tell yourself whatever

[@gruweldaad]

That isn’t true at all. Do you want to know why? This woman and everyone she knows would give anything to have Keith back with them. The Palestinians pray that someone photographs their child’s corpse and it ends up on the front page of the New York Times so idiots like you think that there is an equivalence between what happened to Aviva and Keith and what the Gazans have brought upon themselves by supporting unprovoked attacks on Jews for over a century.

[@hananamro]

I share the human side of this and feel how she must have been mortified. Can she/you readers also see the side of suffering of people in Gaza Going through genocide

[@asch21289]

She said she wants peace for people in Gaza, and literally while her husband is being tortured and held captive by those very people. So to answer your question, yes! I would love to hear a Gazan say the same about the hostages though...

[@omarbowie4525]

Something just doesn't add up is it me alone ?.

[@hpysexyy]

@@RS-kq9rrThat didn’t happen.

[@RS-kq9rr]

@@hpysexyy What didn't happen?? The whole world watched the hostages talking about been treated well . How about the ppl that have been bombed non stop ?? Did 33000 dead ppl ring the bell??.

[@yhochste4511]

The earth seems flat, is it just me?

[@Stephanie-zd5im]

No it doesn't add up. Several of the hostages who were released early on have said they were treated well and not abused in any way. Then the narrative started to change after Netanyahu forbid them to speak to the media.

[@hpysexyy]

@@RS-kq9rr That’s why 1300 people were invaded and murdered without provocation? Because Hamas is peaceful?

[@MD-bu3xc]

And the point of this was?

[@orlandodasilva2529]

They're grasping at straws, pulling at heart strings while they carpet bomb the areas where the hostages are. This woman is repeating known lies from Oct 7 but we're supposed to believe the rest. It's disgusting

[@user-mu1vo2ys3x]

She’s been coached by Mossad and Hasbara officials

[@FaizCaliph]

Want American sympathy by saying her husband Keith is American 😅

[@jdsthird]

Will Andrea Mitchell talk to the women, children, and men who have been released from Israeli prisons? Held without charges or trials. They have similar stories and there is 8.000 currently being held.

[@annchristine47]

Now the world knows how Palestinians feel

[@hpysexyy]

They elected terrorists.

[@ius1141]

there is no palestine no two states no greek state that divides Israel

[@saphire2214]

Palestinians have been terrorized by the Israeli government for decades. This woman's words are applicable to the Palestinian people. She doesn't understand that her government are the "bad people" she cries about in this interview. My heart goes out to her and it also goes out to the millions of Palestinians who have been enduring the same pain over decades.

[@olivka7560]

Israeli soldier was pointing to Palestians what to do and keeping them locked? There were no Israeli soldiers in Gaza for the past 17 years or so.

[@saphire2214]

@@olivka7560 Look up the free documentary here on YT called “The Occupation of The American Mind”.

[@user-mu1vo2ys3x]

@@olivka7560 you’re brainwashed or denying FACTS. Israel withdrew from Gaza in 2005, but promptly imposed a total land/air/sea siege on it since 2006. Plus the IDF Gaza Brigade would regularly go into Gaza on ‘mowing the lawn’ operations: killing, brutalising and capturing Gazans.

[@Stephanie-zd5im]

​​​@@olivka7560 Innocent Palestinians have been arrested by the IDF and held captive for years with no charge against them. Some even children as young as 7 yrs old. They are mostly taken from the West Bank. Human Rights Organisations have been reporting on this for many years.

[@shannond.4129]

Now she knows what Palestinians go through.

[@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci]

What's that? Palestinian Arabs have better lives, better education, a higher standard of living, better health care, and a higher life expectancy than people in any other part of the Middle East.

[@Yanel5795]

@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci thats complete nonsense. Palestinians have horrible oppressed lives. Many who refuses to move out their homes are taken to Israeli prisons where they are r@ped or S.A, not that you care.

[@marloulman104]

Your disgusting! trump supporter?!

[@user-mu1vo2ys3x]

@@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci you know very well that it’s about the Palestinians in Gaza and West Bank. Plus Israel is in reality only a democracy for Jews. Israeli Arabs generally have lower opportunities and standards of living than Jews- well documented fact if you bother to research

[@Stephanie-zd5im]

I don't think she computes that!

[@frankdunne-gp6oy]

Complete lies.

[@RS-kq9rr]

Of course So, we can forget about the genocide that is going on

[@RS-kq9rr]

Btw, comments gets deleted in KZbin,for some reasons.

[@hpysexyy]

@@RS-kq9rrAnti-Semitic lies.

[@RS-kq9rr]

@@hpysexyy 33000 ppl dead 15000 children I guess that is also a lie. Anyone speaking the truth is Antisemitic. Do you know if you are a Semite ,you can't be Anti Semite??? Let that brain work a little bit

[@ius1141]

we do not have any right here with US

[@leilasmiller6070]

🙏💔😪✡✡🙏 Please God Help Hostages For Gods Sake !!!!

[@Liberty5075]

If what she is saying is true, then of course that’s bad in all standers, but just imagine what Palestinian people, women, children and elderly have been going through for DECADES by the Israeli bloody occupation.!

[@brooklyn2349]

do you really think you know anything about the "occupation"? do you know that israel left gaza in 2005? do you knowthat Hamas murdered the opposition when they wre elected? there was no bloody ocupation of gaza by israel

[@lilvat262]

@@brooklyn2349 do you know Israel never left gaza it was controlled by Israel how much items and products can enter gaza with limited items no freedom of space for economy to be built

[@user-mu1vo2ys3x]

@@brooklyn2349 you’re either ignorant or knowingly lying

[@brooklyn2349]

I am neither ignorant nor lying. Everything I said is truth.

[@lemonyblue2437]

The narrative is developing...

[@hpysexyy]

The truth.

[@jdsthird]

@@hpysexyyWhich truth? There are 8.000 men, women, and children being held in Israeli prisons held without charges or trials. They have similar stories of suffering and abuses while in captivity. Will mainstream media tell their stories? Or the 14.000 children who have lost their lives in Gaza? What about them? Do they have a right to live? To dignity and justice? Or is it only for some?

[@hpysexyy]

@@jdsthird They are terrorists and have committed crimes.

[@thesystemera]

Very different from some of the other hostage reports. This is weird.

[@nancyiaj]

Completely different.

[@imhere8380]

ALL PART OF THE ISRAELI PROPAGANDA MACHINE...........HERE WE GO.

[@ostarafarm8403]

How so? This account is no different from the other accounts I have heard.

[@nancyiaj]

@@ostarafarm8403 it’s absolutely different. Other hostages have not reported bad treatment.

[@NRml6ln]

@@nancyiaj No. One elderly hostage reported so. The other reports were horrific.

[@ceciliac3261]

Israeli government could bring them home right now if they really wanted to. Release prisoners now who have went through the same treatment and worse. She doesn’t even realize her own government and military is just as bad and worse.

[@williamvandenbroeck3849]

hamas has rejected the latest ceasefire proposals and can't seem to provide proof of living hostages

[@ceciliac3261]

@@williamvandenbroeck3849 because Israel bombed them to death and starved them to death! They never cared about the hostages ever. They worked with Hamas to get the most important ones out then bombed the rest!

[@Carla39894]

Hamass doesn't even know where the hostages are, that's why they refuse the deal

[@odedrokachify]

Hamas terrorists (I’m guessing you call them freedom fighters?) from October 7 are still treated in Israeli hospitals. No moral person can claim “equal treatment”

[@ceciliac3261]

@@williamvandenbroeck3849 they have all been bombed by Israel on purpose so now they can say Hamas killed them all

[@higgs923]

Neither do the Palestinians.

[@18thCenturyMulatto]

You sound like a pro Russia supporter

[@adii.3665]

You sound very ignorant.

[@leilasmiller6070]

✡✡❤❤🙏

[@saphire2214]

Where is Hamas going to get food, water and medicine to give to the hostages if Israel is blocking it from entering Gaza?

[@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci]

Israel is not doing that. Hundreds of trucks with hundreds of tons of aid enter Gaza from Israel every day.

[@saphire2214]

@@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci There is definitely attempts for those aid trucks to enter but the majority of them are stalled and stopped by Israeli protest encouraged by the IDF. Go look it up.

[@brooklyn2349]

did you even listen to her? they had food. they ate it in front of the hostages and didn't give them any just for the joy of making the hostages miserable .

[@saphire2214]

@@brooklyn2349 You mean like how the Israeli “protestors” cheer and share pastries and coffee in celebration for preventing the food and medical aid trucks from entering Gaza?

[@scabiestransistor2068]

@@brooklyn2349that is literally what Israel does, eats food while Gazans starve.

[@nikkster01]

how about an interview with a 15 y o Palestinian who just finished a 6 month stint in one of this lady's jails there are only 5000 people to choose from) you still have your arms and hands lady unlike many innocent doctors in Gaza shackled for days at a time arrested for????????????????????????????????? sorry but I have lost all capacity to feel sorry for Isreelers now

[@tiaenadavis4304]

Thank you...

[@snarf0596]

I posted this too, funny how the country is shifting towards Palestinian freedom and now the media is scared and is trying to change the country narrative.

[@marloulman104]

EVIL!!

[@audreydaleski1067]

As if gazans have human rights, in their own country, palestine.

[@hpysexyy]

They would if they didn’t elect terrorists.

[@tredjesongen]

Never been never will be a "palestine". They missed on every single chance they got. Its a fantacy. An excuse to persecute jews. Nothing more nothing less than that. Its over its done it has been paid enough for.

[@delta5297]

Why do we expect Palestinians to care about our rights if we don't care about theirs?

[@segs3394]

Really? you think they think like you do and have your values. Ask yourself, if given the opportunity what will they do to you.

[@turc9808]

They dont have to care, they just can't take hostages

[@SuperKripke]

@@segs3394 You come off as the kind of person that watches Star Wars and roots for the Empire over the resistance.

[@segs3394]

Keep deceiving yourself

[@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci]

What "rights" of theirs are you referring to? Specifically, not cliches. What do you think drove people in Gaza to deliberately and methodically do these things to Israeli civilians on Oct. 7th, and after? I mean, what do you think was going on in the minds of their captors, when they left them underground with almost no air, and no food or water, for two days? Would you ever treat people like that? Would you kidnap a couple in their 60s from their home, at gunpoint? Or a mother with two babies in her arms?

[@tiaenadavis4304]

Frist u said u hugged her but they wouldn't allow u to talk now u saying she told u she was attacked okay..She using Israeli talking points just be honest i hope she get reunited with her husband.

[@brooklyn2349]

she was talking about her own experinces. they are not anyone's talking points' they got talked about a lot because it's true and no one listens

[@snarf0596]

@@brooklyn2349 Why not interview the other hostages that have been very critical of the government?

[@brooklyn2349]

@@snarf0596 this has nothing to do with criticizing the government or not. The hostages are telling their own experiences. they are not politicians.

[@Stephanie-zd5im]

I was confused as well because first she said she wasn't allowed to hug the girl then later she said she hugged her.

[@brooklyn2349]

@@Stephanie-zd5imit sounded to me like she wasn’t supposed to hug her and spontaneously did before she was told ( ordered? ) to let go. But in general, when people describe traumatic situations anxiety gets in the way of clarity

[@user-ly9cj7vb3o]

Palestinians have not had human rights for years now

[@adii.3665]

Well that's a lie, but it's not about facts, is it? You lie in the name of your "cause".

[@snarf0596]

@@adii.3665 Yea getting bombed by Israel "mowing the grass" policy every year is full of human rights. Or the Israeli snipers shooting kids and elderly from across the fences, that's ok as long as its brown folk right?

[@user-mu1vo2ys3x]

@@adii.3665 you’re the one lying with impunity and without shame 😡

[@andyvonbourske6405]

an Israeli complaining about not having human rights ? that's rich.

[@user-us3xl6id6t]

You dehumanize her. What gives you the right?

[@andyvonbourske6405]

​@@user-us3xl6id6t stop with your faux outrage

[@RS-kq9rr]

​@@user-us3xl6id6t Her story is all lies since most hostages said they were treated well. It looks like a propaganda to get a lost sympathy from the world, that's all.

[@mohmedhassan6875]

1. Haifa Massacre 1937 2. Jerusalem Massacre 1937 3. Haifa Massacre 1938. 4. Balad al-Sheikh Massacre 1939 5. Haifa Massacre 1939 6. Haifa Massacre 1947 7. Abbasiya Massacre 1947 8. Al-Khisas Massacre 1947 9. Bab al-Amud Massacre 1947 10. Jerusalem Massacre 1947 11. Sheikh Bureik Massacre 1947 12. Tantura Massacre 1948 13. Jaffa Massacre 1948 14. Khan Yunis Massacre 1956 15. Jerusalem Massacre 1967 16. Sabra and Shatila Massacre 1982 17. Al-Aqsa Massacre 1990 18. Ibrahimi Mosque Massacre 1994 19. Jenin Refugee Camp April 2002 20. Gaza Massacre 2008-09 21. Gaza Massacre 2012 22. Gaza Massacre 2014 23. Gaza Massacre 2018-19 24. Gaza Massacre 2021 25. Gaza Genocide 2023 is still ongoing DONT LET ANYONE CONVINCE YOU THAT IT STARTED ON OCTOBER 7th PLEASE REPOST

[@BillBarr4President]

All started with Palestine's refusal to accept Israel as a sovereign state.

[@contact594]

very partial list of massacres committed by Arabs against Jews: Safed Massacre 1834 (before zionism existed) Battle of Tel Hai 1920. Palestine riots of 1929. Tiberias pogrom 1938. Haifa Oil Refinery massacre 1947. Convoy of 35 massacre 1948. Ben Yehuda Street bombing 1948. Jewish Agency bombing 1948. Hadassah medical convoy massacre 1948. Kfar Etzion massacre 1948. Ma'ale Akrabim massacre 1954. Avivim school bus massacre 1970. Lod Airport massacre 1972. Kiryat Shmona massacre 1974. Ma'alot massacre 1974. Zion Square massacre 1975. Coastal Road massacre 1978. Dizengoff Street bus bombing 1994. Beit Lid massacre 1995. Sbarro restaurant massacre 2001. Dolphinarium discotheque massacre 2001. Hebrew University bombing 2002. Bat Mitzvah massacre 2002. Yeshivat Beit Yisrael massacre 2002. Café Moment bombing 2002. Passover massacre 2002. Kiryat Menachem massacre 2002. Shmuel HaNavi bus bombing 2003 Maxim restaurant bombing 2003. Mercaz HaRav massacre 2008. Jerusalem bulldozer attack 2008. Jerusalem synagogue massacre 2014. Tel Aviv shooting 2016. Beersheba attack 2022. Bnei Brak shootings 2022. october 7 massacre 2023.

[@tiaenadavis4304]

Exactly

[@user-us3xl6id6t]

Safed pogrom-33 days of massacre of jews by Arab muslims- no Palestine, no Palestinians in those days.

[@Stephanie-zd5im]

​@@BillBarr4President It was not a fair offer.

[@lilianehuddleston9363]

Let us also pray for Palestinians hostages in Israeli jails held without due process for years

[@mattseaman5662]

Starved of food and OXYGEN ... is this the actual wonderwoman ?

[@EricAllen8494]

🙏🏼☮️🗽⚖️🕊🕉🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

[@ius1141]

no greeks exist there in Israel if you do not like that its not my problem

[@peepobaba9220]

Free Palestine.

[@axaeyexus]

No

[@nancyiaj]

Shame on MSNBC

[@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci]

Can't stand a bit of truth?

[@nancyiaj]

@@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci All these white lies are a bit irritating…

[@Yanel5795]

Exactly its propaganda that justifies more genocide

[@Yanel5795]

@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci you want truth. Jesus is Black, and The Biblical Israelites are black people, they are The people you call African Descendants of Slavery, African "americans" are the Real Tribe of Judah, that means the real Jews, you been blessing the wrong people and cursing Gods people, now there will be judgment on your nations. America first. The 2nd Exodus is about to begin.

[@user-mu1vo2ys3x]

@@KathyPrendergast-cu5ciyou’re a Zionist propaganda puppet 😂

[@buscandolaverdad4117]

She is another tragic victim of this horrible conflict. This genocide of palestinians and the war crimes against Israelis on October 7 must not be forgiven. Lets stop the genocide!

[@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci]

There's been no "genocide of Palestinians"; just stop this BS. Their population has increased by over 500% since 1948. The population of Gaza has grown since the start of this war.

[@imhere8380]

QUOTES BY ISRAELIS...If I were a Palestinian living under Israeli occupation, I would fight Israel to achieve freedom » ~ Amy Ayalon, former head of the Israeli General Security Service (Shin Bet) Israel will not emerge with a picture of victory from this war, even if it manages to assassinate Yahya Sinwar, Whoever believes that the Palestinians will surrender does not know the Palestinians, nor Hamas, or the Islamic movements of this century. » ~ Amy Ayalon, former head of the Israeli General Security Service (Shin Bet)

[@478AB92]

You would "fight" by rping children, setting families on fire?

[@jasielm5258]

0:49 😂 that’s all I needed to see to make a comment and tune off. Thank you Biden? GFYS

[@imhere8380]

HOLD ON...................HER STORY IS VERY DIFFERENT FROM THE OTHER HOSTAGE STORIES. INCREDIABLE THE TIMING TOO. 1. If there was no oxygen, how come she survived? 2.If she was derived of food for 51 days, she would have lost at least 45 -50 pounds, not 20. 3. Palestinian hostages and prisoners are treated a hundred times worse, including being starved with guards eating Infront of them, not allowed to talk, no one to help. I swear, what she described was a pale version of an Israeli cell. 4. SHE WAS SENT BY THE ISRAELI PROPA GANDIST MACHINE............WE ARE DONE WITH THIS ISRAEL. 5. SEND HER BACK TO ISRAEL WHERE HER COUNTRY CAN ASSIST HER WITH CARE AND KINDNESS. 6. ISRAEL................ STOP USING AMERICAN RESOURCES, TAXPAYERS MONEY, THE GOVERNMENT/MEDIA'S TIME................................. GO BACK TO ISRAEL AND HEAL THERE. MAY GOD GIVE YOU GRACE AND MERCY.

[@0703651000]

😢This evil she speaks of. I understand her and really appreciate the exact words about what is happening in the world It has to be stopped. (I know the evil from a slightly different direction, but the source is more or less the same source.😢