I Watched EVERY OTHER (Another 24) Analog Horror & RANKED Them

[@moss_yt]

Timestamps! 👻🎃💀 1:40 Chainmail Chasers by EbolaGranola 5:15 Woodlands National Park by Buddy Films 8:32 Chezz Kids Archive by ChezzKidsArchive 11:18 Dreams of an Insomniac by Pastra 14:48 Dog Nightmares by Piggy Soda 17:58 The Children Under the House by Vintage Eight 22:17 The Oldest View by Kane Pixels 26:57 R.O.T by The Mangan Sisters 30:39 Kitty Kart 64 by Scrunklesoft Interactive 34:02 Super Mario 64 Classified by Annielogue 37:32 NOC+10 by Unknown 41:27 Blue Channel (THALASIN) by Gooseworx 44:49 Boisvert by _boisvert 48:10 Sins of the Past by Forky 52:28 Itch by Vintage Eight 57:18 Tryred Witness Archives by J & L 1:01:08 Needlemouse VHS by ShutUpJoJo 1:04:22 Shipwrecked 64 by Squeaks D’Corgeh 1:09:33 The Boiled One Phenomenon by Doctor Nowhere 1:14:02 White Stag Education by After10 Productions 1:17:44 It Lives in the Static by Vintage Eight 1:22:47 Valle Verde by Alluvium 1:27:05 Project Britannica by Jack G Animations 1:28:45 (secret bonus timestamp) 1:30:17 Backrooms by Kane Pixels 1:35:18 Final Rankings Overview 1:35:56 Spaceman Scott’s new Cosmic Horror :D 1:51:38 Spaceman Scott goes into Sleep Mode

[@WhatWasHisFaceAgain]

Thank you so much for taking the time to add these timestamps! You saved us all so much scrolling and searching. Seriously, it’s little things like this that make the internet such a better place-thanks again for going the extra mile!

[@moss_yt]

@@WhatWasHisFaceAgain Glad I could help! And thank YOU for the appreciation!!! 🥰🥰🥰

[@sonicloverlol2]

YOU mean greenio?

[@moss_yt]

@@sonicloverlol2 I just put what was on the screen, but as far as I can tell Annielogue and Greenio are the same person.

[@bananatiergod]

Awww shame there's no Liminal Land, unless I missed it being on the first part

[@cherenkov_blue]

"Ben Drowned so this could swim" is probably one of the funniest sentences I've ever heard in an analog horror review

[@fxckstxrm]

Hearing it in the premiere made me giggle so hard

[@RoachDoggJr-v9b]

it was a funny

[@GreatestNate888]

Nah really tho

[@rohantiamson]

Where is the timestamp of this line

[@OnesieJAM]

1:23:42

[@victowave7066]

Honey, the bisexual man is yelling at the analog tv again.

[@fxckstxrm]

He's my favorite bisexual man

[@Spark_Animationz]

@@fxckstxrmwow not even me?

[@EMurph42]

@@fxckstxrm me too! Me too, I’m a bisexual but not a man…as a bisexual woman, he’s my favorite bisexual man. Yay being polymorphicly perverse.

[@EMurph42]

This is my favorite comment of the year!

[@binary3111]

As the old saying goes, "oh hey! He's bisexual, I didn't know that!"

[@EbolaGranola]

ChainmailChasers S2 coming this fall! :) Glad you enjoyed!

[@NewAndImprovedOnSteam]

Ayyyy nice mate :)

[@nyekomimi]

But will they wear Chainmail?

[@spidey5558]

Is the series just these people reviewing old creepypastas? Or does something happen? /gen

[@EbolaGranola]

@@spidey5558 Something happens in literally the third video lol

[@ThePhantom4516]

Love this series!! One of the freshest & tasty & yummy series I've seen in this genre

[@thebloodyaussie1458]

14:22 "we all wish we could look and sound so professional" says the man who looks like the lovechild of MatPat and Cal Kestis with a buttery smooth voice.

[@ZackTheGiant]

I have a feeling it's also fanastic audio editing at play. I bet he can make the worst mic sound good with Audacity and some spare time.

[@WordoftheElderGods]

Don't forget FPSRussia

[@SqueakDCorgeh]

My heart sank like a ROCK when I saw Bucky in the thumbnail lmao THAT SAID I’m very happy you enjoyed it! Your complaints about the gameplay are definitely valid I originally set out with the idea of making something akin to an ARG embedded into a game, if that makes sense? The ARG and code solving is standard for ARG stuff but to the casual player I can see how it gets repetitive. That said though, thank you!! I’ve been watching your stuff for a while now (and even tried to sub to the Patreon last year, although I ended up having to stop due to kinda crippling financial issues LOL) I should let you know, a followup is in the works, and the lack of variation in regards to Puzzle Solving was my biggest critique I received and I do intend to fix it. THANKS AGAIN THOUGH!!

[@fxckstxrm]

SQUEAK!! You are so damn talented and I hope you know that :]

[@SqueakDCorgeh]

@@fxckstxrm Thank you!!

[@SpacemanScott]

Oh dude I LOVED it! Criticisms aside the art direction, scares, and overall aesthetic of the finished product are genuinely so impressive (I mean, I've never volunteered myself to play more of something that made me genuinely freak the fuck out lol) And A SUCCESSOR YOU SAY 👀👀👀👀

[@invertebrado]

@@SpacemanScott dude, now you HAVE TO play the rest of the game

[@SlasherFilmLabMouse]

@@SpacemanScott HI-09 Coming eventually

[@FabbrizioPlays]

Oh boy, I can't wait to see what Scott has to say about my favorite Analog Horror (White Stag). I sure hope he doesn't use harsh but fair criticisms to break my heart EDIT: Oh thank god

[@vintageeight]

Thanks for mentioning Vintage Eight. Always happy to be in the conversation!

[@Redshaw-w3o]

that last silent image of earth at the end was amazing. The concept that we as a species were so stubborn to accept reality that we basically doomed ourselves because we couldn't see the bigger picture is horrifyingly human. Good job holy shit

[@JohnCena-qe1rz]

Horrifyingly human and unfortunately relevant looking at petro companies over the last 50 years

[@spidey5558]

​@@JohnCena-qe1rz The what companies?

[@hotpocketsat2am]

@@spidey5558 petrolium, oil tycoons.

[@CatBxtchNami]

I saw it as kinda stupid, I'm pretty sure that being aware of what happened to aliens would shock up most governments right now. Also the NASA would never be allowed to hide this kinda of stuff from the government.

[@REIMYBELOVED]

He should make it into a series I’m hooked

[@bopplemcnuggets4387]

fun fact about the boiled one phenomenon btw, the boiled one himself is canonically meant to symbolize a ww1 soldier named mutsuhiro watanabe who did some horrible shit to POWs when that war was going on, and part of the reason the series was connected to him was because the story affected doctor nowhere so much that he wanted to permanently taint mutsuhiro's image and turn him into 'that spooky red guy from the youtube horror' and i think that's so goddamn based

[@PinnePon]

Like jerma Sus face

[@PinnePon]

When I said Jerma sus face i was not aware that Mutsuhiro Watanabe was a real war criminal. Sorry for my unseriousness

[@THEFILMED2008]

WW2* (Sorry to be that one guy.)

[@jamblastwizard]

⁠@@THEFILMED2008nah, don’t be. it’s an important distinction! no shame in being a history nerd

[@THEFILMED2008]

@ Thank you!

[@TheEastPatch]

The aesthetics of each series' discussion intro with the tapes and all the board decorations and costuming AND THEN MORE OF YOUR OWN awesome contributions to the genre. I love that you don't just watch analog horror, you bask in it.

[@fxckstxrm]

@TheEastPatch you guys make such good stuff, PLEEEEASE keep going!!!

[@SpacemanScott]

When I have inspirations like your guys' work it's hard not to bask in it 😁

[@FishStyx0]

What if instead of ROT it was called FREAKY and people decided if they were freaky

[@bronzergoth7598]

i played The Oldest View for my parents, they're are both in their 60s and very reluctant to watch anything that isn't on cable TV. it's officially their favorite horror movie ever, they LOVED it and won't stop telling their friends about it

[@budderk1305]

that's wholesome

[@hylianmango8272]

based parents

[@Parzivle]

This is genuinely one of the sweetest things I've ever heard

[@moistywoisty]

my parents fucking hated it lmao

[@Bookgurl656]

@@moistywoisty this isn’t about your parents. This is about the OP parents. We don’t care that your parents hated it. Don’t put it here. (: Edit: fixed my mistake. and all of you telling me to chill out, or that my passive aggressive smile made you groan, I don’t care. Don’t be a bitch in the first place, and I wouldn’t be passive aggressive.

[@TROLLIX-THE-ANT]

the last think i expected from a sequel of this tierlist was an entirely original analog horror good job scooter

[@fxckstxrm]

Merry Easter

[@TROLLIX-THE-ANT]

@@fxckstxrm cherry mister

[@TROLLIX-THE-ANT]

@@fxckstxrm ferry feaster

[@SpookedForky]

thank you so much for covering sins of the past!! im very very glad you enjoyed it and your comparision to the amazing world of gumball means the world to me haha

[@SpacemanScott]

Of course! I'm absolutely obsessed with how you approach the visuals in your series and it would've been a CRIME to not share it with others 😄

[@wormwormer-h3e]

"Close enough, welcome back Paul from Petscop" is unironically so fucking funny

[@greekfire00]

GOD, that analog horror segment at the end kicked so much ass. You seriously have the chops for some great story telling! I'm begging you, please make more like that. I love existential dread in horror, especially before an election LMAO

[@FlookCS]

I agree, the voice acting was fucking amazing, also great story

[@griefingg0lem685]

It's also fits Scott's theming, it's like one of the only times he's done something space related. But also it's such a different kind of horror. No demons, monsters, eldritch horrors, aliens, or anything like that. Just the existential dread of learning that we are doomed, and there is nothing to do about it.

[@hammiarts]

I was sitting thinking "damn, this is really on the nose" and it was in a way I LOVED.

[@cupcakejack7375]

Incomprehensible horrors beyond human understanding my beloved

[@SeisTavanel]

My only gripe with it was not being able to fully suspend my disbelief for how voyager 3 was able to know so much about the other planets. Having the story take place in a similar reality to ours while the plot is reliant unexplained impossible technology just kept me from enjoying it fully. It’s a great piece of analog horror, but a bit of research into how such satellites work would have helped immensely.

[@acidicbarkbeast]

CHEZZKIDS WAHOO!!! Your criticisms are completely fair and I myself also had trouble discerning the story. One thing I have to note since I'm not sure from your commentary if you stumbled upon it, but chezzkids isn't limited to its youtube channel. It has its own rabbithole website and an Instagram account with reuploads of some of the youtube stuff in higher (legible) quality! PatRatrick has a really good video exploring the general story so far :]

[@starpupilsx]

also they have a twitter they regularly post on!! most of it is just normal twitter stuff but they have some cryptic messages if you scroll enough

[@thestateofdelaware8057]

“When ranger Craig tells me about false trails I sit my wide ass down” -a windigoon viewer

[@whiskeyhound]

I'm glad you picked that quote and not any of the other things that were said about ranger Craig.

[@MoinCoin]

pretty sure it was "white ass"

[@maiminakami685]

@@whiskeyhound Ranger Craig sure has GYATT To show up next episode :3

[@squiddeon9164]

*white

[@Beckett.]

@@squiddeon9164 beat me to it

[@griefingg0lem685]

I'm sitting here realizing I should have recommended "The Hotdog Archives" to you. Not a horror series, but damn is it a good comedy series that plays off people knowing general tropes of Analog Horror series.

[@-Alluvium-]

I spent almost the whole stream in that Lenny meme pose with the fingers Hahaha, I'm glad you liked Valle Verde, I promise the whole thing will make more sense in the future, if you are curious about the lore behind the THbrain and its functionalities, there is a document written by one of the investigators in my community tab. (Also I might be stealing that swiming quote)

[@fxckstxrm]

Dude I immediately put Valle Verde on my series backlog after seeing the premiere for this video. Such an insane visual experience.

[@judgement7591]

No sabia que valle verde es argentino, ahora me lo tengo que ver (especialmente por el Eva Peron jumpscare de 1:25:46)

[@theman6422]

Ranger Craig is THE GOAT! He walks in the room, everybody is sitting THEIR ASSES DOWN! He doesn’t mean business, he IS the business! Love Ranger Craig! I better not see ANY shit from anyone about him!

[@frmw9357]

when ranger craig warns me about false trails, i sit my white ass down and listen

[@Mimiyan_or_Pikapikafan]

1:14 I told my mom that without context and she found it funny. She found it funny also when I gave her context. I love my mom, thanks for actually engaging with my hyperfixations

[@NotAFossil]

yo kai watch pfp!!! A man of culture

[@Mimiyan_or_Pikapikafan]

@NotAFossil also a man of luck since I got Pandanoko as a kid in 7th grade in Yo-Kai Watch 2 Psychic Spectres

[@fbmb1337]

In the half hearted defense of the 'Backrooms were scarier before monsters' take, I think people are just more talking about the version that...lets be real kinda reads like a lesser SCP: multiple types of monsters, levels, factions and concepts explained to such a minute detail it stops feeling like a look into another world and more like a detailed guide for a videogame that doesn't exist. Monsters might have always been part of the equation, but the STALKER ahh faction system and the simulatenously unknowable yet extensively cathalogued cryptids there sure aren't.

[@GregariousBant]

also "there's something else down there with you" is enough, you don't need to see the monster, there doesn't need to be a bunch of types of monsters, just knowing there is a monster, with no other context, is scary

[@justsomelurkerrr]

​​@@GregariousBant yeah it essentially weaponises your own mind against you in that kinda sense, leaving you to fill in the blanks as to what the hell could possibly be lurking there with you, and nothing against the detailed descriptions of monsters and levels and stuff, but I just love how ambiguous the OG was

[@AgBRUV]

Agreed but I think it genuinely is the most retarded addition to an already spooky subject Sagan hawked video on it is funny to me he did a good job but half the stuff he talks about and tries to make scary just dosent work I get wanting to be apart of a community and adding lore to something unknown sounds fun but it dosent always work but not everything needs to be explained knowing everything about something takes away from it and that community is really hellbent on making it goofy asl

[@demetriam2408]

I just in general disagree with the absolute disrespect to creators who have contributed to the backrooms. Just because Kane created something good doesn't mean that everything else doesn't have it's place or doesn't deserve respect. So many people just absolutely shit on what other people have made in some convoluted way to try and praise Kane. It's gross and unnecessary. You don't like it, that's okay, (not you in particular just to clarify) just don't participate. Let people have their fun. I genuinely appreciate this being brought up in the video because it has drastically decreased my ability to enjoy Kane's series knowing how people are weaponizing it to attack others. So much vitriol.

[@GregariousBant]

@@demetriam2408 people are allowed to criticize the things you like, and if that affects your enjoyment that says more about you and the work than the people making criticisms

[@toastbot9496]

An almost 2 hour ranking WITH a 20 min analog creation of your own? Your feeding us good candy this halloween!

[@EbolaGranola]

Okay, followup comment now that I'm done the ranking section of the video! In regards to your comment about the Mario 64 Personalization thing with Classified, I really really recommend playing B3313. It's a very, *very* extensive rom hack for Super Mario 64 that goes full ham on the idea of the beta versions of the game being utterly fucked. Even references Classified at a lot of points. I wouldn't recommend actually completing the game as it's so *much* and that's not the point. It's best just wandering about the labyrinthine and genuinely impressive castle dreamscape as if you were playing something like LSD Dream Emulator, or a Mario version of Yume Nikki. The vibes are immaculate.

[@EbolaGranola]

Less related to any analog horror shenanigans and just a cool chill horror game with a bit of silliness to it, Voices of the Void is also worth checking out. It's an open world game where you analyze signals from deep space in the most garbage filled shack ever, suffer fucked up horrific random events, and find goofy shit in the Swiss woods.

[@Fighter_Builder]

AGREED! Honestly, I never really found B3313 scary, I always enjoyed it in the sense that it really felt like I was playing Super Mario 64 for the first time again, taking that confusing yet whimsical experience of playing through a game like SM64 when video games were still a relatively new concept to me and bringing it forward in time for me to experience again in a fresh new way. I've never played any other game quite like it. Also, playing it on a real CRT and real N64 controller is an absolute vibe. If you have the stuff to do that, I would highly recommend giving that a shot.

[@rachaelgray1125]

'Should I stream Shipwreck 64 .... and cry?' uh yes pls. We crave human suffering. Also, the plot of your analogue horror reminded me of a storyline of a game I just played (won't say which because spoilers), but the messenger was sent out to see if there was life outside of our own world, but she found the truth and drove herself mad trying not to tell her creator this truth. He finds out eventually, he goes mad, and this madness spiral of both characters spans literal millennia and almost causes the end of life as we knew it :) good times, but a slightly weird tangent for the game.

[@EmileeAria413]

I’m guessing it’s a certain MMO RPG that you can play for free up to level 60? Cause if so, that game made me fucking *sob* multiple times.

[@rachaelgray1125]

@@EmileeAria413 it might be, not naming names though. And yes, I did sob like a baby so many times

[@spidey5558]

​@@rachaelgray1125I'm lost. What game are you talking about?

[@PhiIosophiia]

@@spidey5558 the game is final fantasy 14. EDIT: originally i put a rant here but i dont have the energy, gatekeeping the name of the game you just spoiled is a jerk move.

[@TekharthaMondatta]

Your point about the Boiled One Phenomenon is frustratingly true. I basically wrote the series off because my first exposure to it was niche shitposts from terminally-online subreddits. When I found the actual video I just couldn't take it seriously, and that honestly sucks.

[@Landonshihtzu-o9q]

This is the reason why I love SpaceMan Scott. He is brutally honest and praises good work. Edit: Halloween Kid Cuisine is wild

[@coolcactus8861]

Pastra is an amazing horror writer, istg if you havent listened to his Jeff the Killer rewrite you totally should, he completly transforms the story into something truly amazing.

[@Echodarat]

"3 anger pills and then go to my custody hearing" made me legit fall off my chair laughing

[@JacklynBurn]

Same for me but the line that did it was "this is the kind of art that only the most broken of carbon monoxide detectors can bring you"

[@adrienstarfaer]

What's funny about Dreams of an Insomniac to me is that the first time I heard Pastra's voice was when they did a presentation about Jeff the Killer in the Quinnamon vod where they read and talked about creepypastas.

[@c00LKIDsix9]

I think the main difference between the original Backrooms greentext and a lot of fan interpretations is that the focus is shifted. The original focused a lot more on the dread of being trapped there with the mention that you might not be alone. It's 95% trapped 5% monster. It was vague enough that you could easily see it as you would starve to death before you get out or get killed. Most other things you find is 95% monster 5% trapped. For a lot of interpretations (ESPECIALLY video games) it has just become an easy setting to put scary monsters.

[@rosemary3029]

I think people took the whole "you're not truly alone" in the backrooms as "oh there's interdimensonal monsters hunting you down"

[@agentepsilon5014]

Buckle in boys, Peak: The Sequel has arrived

[@Ihavenonamestopitplease]

Your analogue horror submission just makes me feel an immense amount of dread (in a good way!), it's something I can definitely see happening in real life, so out of touch yet so real, marvelous work!

[@andromeda_neko]

All I can say is it was so good I never want to watch it again or think of it again because of how disgusting it made me feel, the hopelessness of selfishness unraveling into our imminent collapse on society as a whole

[@kingbash6466]

I'm so glad you made another analog horror ranking video because a lot of the series like the Oldest View, The Boiled One Phenomenon, _Boisvert, and Mario 64 Classified are genuinely too great for them not to be talked about, and even stuff that are still flawed and rough around the edges like Tryred Witness Archives and Needlemouse VHS are still enjoyable to watch and discuss.

[@chitheidiot8299]

Seeing Valle Verde here was not only such a surprise, but a very welcome one! This series deserves so much more attention than it actually has gotten, Alluvium put so much work and effort in it and it SHOWS. I definately agree that the story is very difficult to decipher, however with the references to argentinian history and culture i feel like the story building up behind the scenes is going to be really impactful. As a fan and an argentinian, thank you for reviewing it!

[@RoachDoggJr-v9b]

lol the best bit of this was the live stream chat. alluvium and other analog creators were talking to us in it

[@fxckstxrm]

Dude it was so fun being in the live chat. Loved it. Need to do something like this again.

[@RoachDoggJr-v9b]

@@fxckstxrm fr

[@fxckstxrm]

Ok, real comment now Scott, this whole series is wonderful, and I love that it shows a lot of analog horrors maybe people haven't heard of. Really hope you keep this series going.

[@pomato22]

Idk why but him saying “I did not care for needle mouse” gave me the same vibe as Peter griffin saying “ I did not care for the godfather”

[@colinkoops63]

Can’t believe I was late for the premiere; gotta quit my job so I can be here on time next time

[@fxckstxrm]

Quit your job, Spaceman Scott is more important

[@ItsOkAstro]

I was so hooked by your story at the end, that I totally forgot this was an analog horror tier list! I need to see more

[@donutholebandit]

Woodlands National Park is set in the 70s because back then cultural appropriation was standard procedure

[@PARAPPA-BOI-EXE-16]

Hey I got your mention thanks! :) Ps for the ones who don't know I reuploaded the Needlemouse series And pps: i also reuploaded season 2 so it will make sense for Scott to see and if you're planning on making another analog horror video you are gonna love Needlemouse season 2

[@aradiati0n]

if you do another part, "interloper" would be a REALLY interesting thing to cover since this series covers a lot of digital horror stuff too its a series about a strange secret found in half life 2 that expands into one of the most genuinely unique things ive ever seen in this field

[@ShyDoomGuy]

I'm honestly surprised there wasn't any of the Adult Swim infomercials, like This House has People In It or Unedited Footage Of A Bear. Or that one series about the bumper cards from the early 2000s

[@faramirbutnothatone]

"Everyone's playing chess while I'm playing YAHTZEE" is so fucking funny

[@MrShwoo]

Still watching the video (loving it so far) but I wanna put this here before I forget to: If you ever plan on doing another one of these, PLEASE consider including the Lacey Games series by the artist Ghost Tundra, it is without a doubt my personal favorite Analog/Digital Horror series and I would love for it to get some more love and it'd be sick to hear your thoughts on it!

[@moss_yt]

YESSSS I second this HEAVILY!

[@Fighter_Builder]

THIS. I'm pretty desensitized to analog horror at this point but there's some parts of Lacey Games that hit me like a truck anyway.

[@GODofTimewaste2]

Alright, I actually had to pause another video to come back here and just say that I love this video, I love your newer, post-creepypasta-narration videos. I don't know if this information is at all useful, but, still. S-tier.

[@ShibeDogetic]

FINALLY somebody talked about Doctor Nowhere's work outside of The Boiled One! I've only seen it outside of his channel like once and it is CRIMINAL

[@torenchao]

30:07 ...you good dude?

[@twindrill2852]

Great stream! I'm so glad you gave stuff like Boisvert and Valle Verde high ratings, because they definitely deserve it. Regarding your own attempt at AH...eh, it was alright, as someone who likes cosmology horror. I'm not really too into the ending though, since stories revolving around humanity being assholes that'll drive us into extinction have completely exhausted me. Plus the ending is way too abrupt to be impactful...definitely needed another scene or two.

[@budderk1305]

I feel better now that someone else said it first, I liked his previous one way more cause I also can not deal with this kind of plot anymore

[@milliefish]

A5 Wagyu pfp (real)

[@twindrill2852]

@@milliefish Nice! :D

[@elayneciara]

I see everyone talking about how phenomenonal this video is, but also the fact you try your hand at analog horror is the icing on the cake of this whole thing. Amazing work rating and providing insight on these different series, and what an incredible analog horror. Props honestly, I dont know how much more analog series there are out there but I would love to see a part three of this series! (If not, this series has a rewatchable quality to it too)

[@bunnie-wor1d]

spaceman i dont see enough ppl talking about it but i was dialed the FUCK in for your cosmic horror. it feels SO reminiscent of early mandela catalogue I LOVED IT AND WE NEED MORE.

[@littykitty040]

If you do end up making a Part 3, I wonder if you'd be willing to look back at older internet horror series like Marble Hornets and Ben Drowned. I'd be interested to see how they stack up against today's stuff. Also Lacey's Games, please that one needs more eyes on it.

[@lemonshark5292]

A pretty good fnaf one is "Freddy Toddler Fun" : D And "Lacey Games" is one about one of those 2000s games for girls websites

[@squiddeon9164]

Lacey Games may break his heart irreparabley

[@lemonshark5292]

@ fair lol :,)

[@archerscars7380]

Scott: HEY! Just so you know! There’s trypophobia in this part of the video! Me, who up until a few minutes ago was convinced that I only had slight trypophobia: surely me watching this while eating my food will end well Narrator: It did not, in fact, end well.

[@d4chance]

I'm so happy you covered Dog Nightmares. It's been my favorite analog horror for some time and really hit me at the right time. I found it only a week after my dog of about ten years passed away and the entire thing felt like a unique, almost unsettling love letter to a lost pet and it, despite being really unsettling and spooky (just as you described!), it was a comforting watch to see or feel the character go through a similar feeling as to what I felt. It stuck with me hard. I'm so excited to see more of it and I love that you're also a fan of it-- it's SUCH a good and spooky series with so much talent in it.

[@FroxoVR]

22:36 when i first watched the oldest view i genuinely thought that kane walked around an abandoned mall and just edited the guy in really well. im floored as to how real it looked now that i now everything was made in blender

[@charcoalangel7536]

Oh my God! THANK YOU FOR POINTING OUT THE MARIO DEVS TALKING IN ENGLISH. That took me out of so many analog horror series.

[@AmondoDazz]

Thanks man! Listening to horror stuff is how I usually fall asleep. And after just finishing your previous ranking video yesterday. This one came in clutch.

[@maddy2265]

i told all my friends about u thanks for being my new comfort silly man

[@Dantalliumsolarium]

Oh I loved that’d ending piece you made!! Such a scary idea of something that kills planets. But almost worse is how the investigator is like, making the scientist feel bad for not telling this information earlier. Then flipping to keep it classified ! What a good feae!

[@clementineshetheyfae8312]

Anything using “genAI” is an instant F tier. Make your own stuff stop forcing computers to try and imitate art

[@DominatorElite4]

Not everyone is born artistic talented

[@clementineshetheyfae8312]

@ No one is, you have to learn

[@pegglelover82]

@@DominatorElite4then learn art or pay someone else to do it or try and make an artist friend who wants to help you if you don’t have money. If you can’t do something then you don’t get a robot to do it for you

[@extraaccountnh8883]

​@@DominatorElite4 exactly. you make it. it takes work

[@GHOSTLYGUNK]

@@DominatorElite4 then learn dumbass. y'think i came out of the womb drawing da vinci?

[@cthulhubecausewhynot1182]

I wonder if anyone will have a line that beats his “You’re going in the spider contraption” one from his last analog horror video. That phrase has permanently entered my vocabulary.

[@cthulhubecausewhynot1182]

Yup- “Welcome to space, motherfucker- Bad news: There’s lots of it.”

[@SirBhoger]

This video is how I’m spending my Halloween evening

[@fricc3824]

comparing pastras vocal inflections to early mattpat was such a whiplashing moment to me that i dont think ill be able to ever hear him the same again

[@GUNUFofficial]

The titanic reveal is even better because in the series lore it was said to have been scrapped and also it has the upgrades the Olympic recived later in its service after the real life titanic sank, including new name letters and more lifeboats, also its promenade deck seems to be open instead of closed. My inner ship nerd that has not been released since i was 7 has been released.

[@EmileeAria413]

Oh wow, your new analog horror at the end is basically just what Final Fantasy XIV: Endwalker’s ending might have looked like. Very well done, well written and well performed!

[@juliamiller711]

You just made me think of the concept of a ffxiv analog horror and I fell to my knees

[@Prophecyx01]

Yeah, I instantly thought of Endwalker when listening to it

[@TheTlay101]

Backrooms discourse always baffles me. It's not about "wheh me no want monster" it's typically people not liking people turning it to a shitty survival horror with shit like Almond water

[@surelylune]

the almond water thing is so funny. its such a perfect example of people who have no understanding of implication or subtlety trying to expand of something into a universe that didnt need to be, because the original worked best as a stand alone product

[@NailTransGayming]

I played Shipwrecked 64 at your recommendation, and I gotta say, I agree with a lot of your take - my only addendum is you underestimate how tedious it is LMAO You think it's bad as far as you got, hoo boy, the plaza level is some of the worst tedium I've ever endured in a horror game. That said, it was still worth playing and has a lot of cool stuff going on - great video, thanks for all the good content Scott!

[@beegooselaw]

I have been WAITING for this one!!!

[@Bl4ck_m0ld]

i would LOVE to see what you think of the magnus archives, its a 5 season podcast over 200 episodes. Every season is 40 episodes long. All about fear, i LOVE it.

[@oh_hi_mark2820]

During the analog horror section, I totally forgot I was still on the same video Please expand on this, it was incredible

[@MsMoonDragoon]

Is the backrooms ruined by monsters? no. Is the backrooms ruined by the whole ass groups of survivors and civilizations people shove in there? yes.

[@demetriam2408]

It is actually not ruined at all and people just have different taste? Yes. Don't be an ass.

[@lorenzomeulli750]

​@@demetriam2408 "Yeah let me explain why an horror concept about being isolated to the point of being outside of normal reality isn't affected by having HUMAN FACTIONS WITH THEIR OWN AGENDA THRIVING INSIDE OF IT". Jesus Christ, you couldn't tell the moon from a large rock even if one hit you in the face.

[@Ryzard]

Underrated analogue horror idea would be a therapist (like the "why tf is your imaginary friend split in half") desling with one or multiple people all desling with their own analogue horror issues that slowly but surely start to overlap (or like a police investigator, school councilor, etc.)

[@Blaze-nm1uh]

I mean, the idea of a therapist as the main pov character is kinda explored in children under the house, but considering I’m currently intending to get into that field, and I’m aware of how actually traumatic being a therapist can be, honestly it’s kinda tempting to work on myself.

[@lilomartino9068]

dude genuinely thank you so much for the phobia warning a lot of people appreciate that and the timestamp. i am in your debt

[@peachypurrfect2955]

i wish there were more comments discussing your original video and idea, i found it SO SO fascinating! the voice acting was done incredibly well and theme of space exploration really hooked me, i would be so interested in seeing more you could do with this concept!! great work and thank you for the amazing videos!

[@Holl1day]

That final ARG you made was amazing, Scott! It really reminded me of the toning of Godzilla, with a hearty helping of interstellar mixed on top. seriously underrated channel

[@Smoke6683nb0]

49:32 was eating breakfast and when this started playing I had to put down my spoon and sit back so my tears didn't get into my oatmeal

[@Drydoctor-qo5wt]

“Welcome back Paul from Petscop” Yeah so you know that feeling where you feel like somethin’ is pandering to you specifically?

[@smae98]

finally, a part two i’ve been feining for that won’t come out when im dead and buried! (i love this duology, i can’t sleep so this is perfect)

[@0clectmovie781]

I cheered when you put SM64: CLASSIFIED in S-Tier, as it’s my favorite Analog Horror series. Especially as someone who’s a big fan of Mario, I can definitely say that it was certainly effective, right through to the very satisfying finale! That was the best moment of this video for me. (I will admit it’s not perfect, but hey, it’s Mario 64 except it has a scene of Luigi drowning and reference to Stanley the Bugman!)

[@Apollo9898LP]

One thing I do like about Valle Verde is that if you pay attention you can tell what's going on, especially since the TH Brain Debrief document was released as a supplement to the videos. Basically it seems to be that a rudimentary AI peripheral for the PlayStation called the TH Brain was created with the intention of it being able to generate new video game content in real time. The TH Brain was going to learn by studying real human neuron communication, via some very unethical experimental brain surgery. Then the kids whose brains were hooked up to the TH Brain somehow got trapped in the machine, which was running an instance of Valle Verde to test the TH Brain. Now the TH Brain AI is essentially playing god with the world inside the game, literally styling itself in biblical trappings, trying to use the kids' brains to expand its own capabilities. And the footage we're seeing is from QA testers who are running tests on the TH Brain trying to figure out how to get the kids out of the system before the AI can kill them and assimilate their brains into it. Or at least that's what I THINK is happening because to your point, you can get like 80% of the way there if you're paying attention but there is still some logical leaps you have to make. I'm definitely excited to see where it goes.

[@reidj2226]

I like how in your horror there wasn't much of bigger twist of some cosmic like dread i expected, it wasn't a "oooh big monster will destroy us" but more of a dread of how we as a humanity are literally told what's our problem is but will arrogantly say "bullshit" and lock away those who might help against the expected results. The final shot on humanity played exactly same way dead planets from Voyager 3 observations really sets the reality of the ending. I might liked it if there was some underlying bigger truth like government already knowing it or something like that but the whole interaction was cool regardless, voice actors did good. Something like "yeah we spied on your observations and knew exactly what's gonna happen if you'll gonna resign so this entire interview was a test to see if you're gonna be smart about it and keep your mouth shut or if we'll have to come to more cruel conclusion, unfortunately you picked the second." Although it brings me to question if analog horror implies someone watching it on analog tv with a tape or something, then what exactly would happen to us? I think it's really missed opportunity to add in that this whole thing is watched by the mentioned mental health psychiatrist and leaving an option for them to do something or just vainly stay silent in horror of it.

[@travisfletcher6342]

For Halloween, I dressed up as Scott if he were me

[@Artisticzorya]

The way I smiled when I saw the notification that this was posted. I was having a bad day and this made me feel a lot better :)

[@cellolord4304]

As someone who was there when Needlemouse was being released in real time, yeah the story fell apart as things went on, but I do think there were some interesting ideas that came about it, like changing the format from VHS to early 2000s Windows Moviemaker style videos and playing around with the supernatural element of the series, there were also some genuinely great art in those later episodes For anyone curious, the second season has one the son of one of Sarah's friends trapped in the game finding it while there's expositioning more about what truly happened when Sarah died and to her girlfriend at the time of her death, as it is eventually revealed that there are actually two supernatural beings in the CD, one being basically the .exe representing her hatred that has been manipulating Sarah into doing all of her evil shit (btw she kills the two teens that find the CD because fuck them kids) and a good one that is basically trying to free the spirits and move on to the afterlife, which is the ending of the series as all the spirits trapped escape, including Sarah, from the .exe's influence Oh and from memory Sarah was killed accidentally by Luther during a bar fight where everyone was too drunk, so yeah The main problem with season two is that it's both too dense and too little descriptive at points on what is actually happening, and sometimes there were also problems with the fact that audio was not subtitled, which made understanding some of the scenes with crunched voice acting a nightmare And yeah fuck whoever wrote the article for Sarah god I hate it, as far as I know Sarah's a full-blooded American girl, so I have no idea why she is described as Asian in the (likely vandalized) Wikia Thankfully ShutUpJojo has rebooted the entire Needlemouse universe with Speedduo64, which does deal with some of the issues from Needlemouse overall and I'd recommend keeping an eye on it

[@fishstickfailur3]

jojo did canonize that sarah was asian somewhere iirc NO FUCKIN IDEA WHAT THEY DESCRIBVED HER LIKE THAT THO 😭😭😭oddities wiki is incredibly. *fucky* , i'd say, when covering content since its so much less moderated than say hb wiki

[@tr1f1ght3r]

Thank you so much for how you end these vids. I am genuinely in love with the example in this video, PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE BUILD OFF IT I LOVE HORROR INTHE COSMOS

[@ElseWhere19]

I feel like the prospect of there actually being other life out there that destroyed themselves like we have the potential to is much more scary then any weird ass creature out in space. Also the fact that the government would just sweep it under the rug is realistic as fuck awesome story Scott and I guess the tierlist was pretty cool too

[@farawayxgalaxy]

Yayyyyy I’m so excited to see this!!!! I absolutely loved your takes on the last one, and I always enjoy a video by you :)

[@Mixxium]

God, this was so good. The bit at the end was absolutely captivating.

[@felisazure1820]

The analog horror you made at the end is so well done. Whoever you picked as the initial voice actor fit perfectly. Really reminded me of those documentary narrators from the ones we used to watch in school, or like those educational programs and shows. But really, all the voice actors did an amazing job. I was pulled into the story right away. That picture at the end really got to me. Great call back to the pictures throughout to show Earth isn't special.

[@supersmilyface1]

I was NOT expecting to see _boisvert's work in here! Love that wild series. Feels more like an art piece than anything tbh and I LOVE IT. "You're still in the basement" is a line that will stick in my brain forever.

[@ImJustBag]

Skipping over Blue Channel and its related video Deep Blue slightly miffed me. Gooseworx is a musician-animator, and Blue Channel was initially for the mostpart just music. Interestingly, Goose describes the videos as VHS tapes which kinda contradicts the idea of it being a channel. But Deep Blue explained through very quick messages and figures in the dark what the Blue Channel is. It's a gateway. Watching the Blue Channel tapes gives an opening for things from somewhere else to come through to out world. Thalasin may be one, but most things that pass through are living things. The blue channel may not be a tv channel but a different definition of channel. Either a connection of seas, or a way to channel these entities to us. Watching opens the path.

[@dekuloveshair5667]

DOAI MENTIONED!! Iirc pastra has in streams mentioned he wanted to re do the early episodes of doai, I absolutely can see what your saying, pastra is a favorite creator of mine, they are a big horror fan so who better to make a horror series!!

[@vincentjonesvr]

Fantastic video in every way. Great list, great breakdown, *GREAT* cosmic horror at the end.

[@averagetoasterenjoyer6931]

One anthology series that I quite enjoy, although it is very small and not well known, is maple 9 from the same guy who’s making the new portal underground series.

[@nobellprizz2831]

I am so happy you put Dog Nightmares in A tier. I also accidentally stumbled upon it while on a train ride home from the airport and I loved the slow-burn dread. It's been a while since I've watched it but I cannot forget how awful it was seeing the dog-man for the first time. Something about the inhuman jerks just really got to me.

[@Madmankey13]

If you make a part 3, would you consider Ted's Caving Journal? It is based off of a creepypasta and is more found-footage than analog, but it would still be cool to see in a video

[@octavius3800]

The analog horror at the end this time is REALLY GOOD. as a blackpilled USA resident, government corruption truly is the scariest thing around.

[@kingsnakke6888]

Government corruption clashing and mixing with people who truly think they're in the right is next-level realism horror.