ian's Goodbye Horses is NOT GOOD

[@theneedledrop]

Correction: ian is from Missouri, not Minnesota. Sorry about that!

[@addisonhouse420]

that’s right the only minnesota rapper ever is lil shine

[@illusma7822]

You are forgiven

[@ysxai]

makes sense

[@matthewbaker7513]

I read this as apologizing to Minnesota

[@CasperLikesMusic-kw3jj]

​@@matthewbaker7513😂

[@endriaskassa9049]

He didn’t even bother to green screen it properly.

[@Turbos-b3z]

It adds to the hilarity.

[@JH-dr4xo]

If Ian is gonna half ass his work, so is Melon!

[@willandspencer101]

Gave it vultures 1 treatment

[@NamelessInternaut]

​@@willandspencer101nah, he gave it the angelic 2 the core treatment

[@mxm765]

😮😮😮😮

[@rylandwhitus6137]

white boy winter cancelled

[@fentanylfrog8403]

We’re skipping right to the Spring Equinox, fuck it

[@jorgeortega6806]

Has been canceled since the MJ Lenderman review

[@ffffv4999]

Thank god

[@voodoo5553]

Tyler dropping soon

[@alfokenny211]

😭😭I’m dead

[@tom6626]

shit disappointed melon so much that the green screen didn’t even bother to work

[@BigOwl51]

Let’s be honest this wasn’t disappointing. We all knew this album was gonna be terrible.

[@kev1619]

corny

[@JohnMae-r1q]

He even did vultures 1 better on the green screen😭

[@traditionalutopian]

@@kev1619 ian fanboy spotted

[@sxwk5554]

2 not goods in a row is crazy

[@respectthag5856]

u would shit what melon has on nav

[@morfeyy-]

he might contest NAV.

[@ThatGuyThomas]

or gunna

[@titan2540]

ian on a generational run rn

[@Donald06-c7k]

Not for ian

[@justthatguytoil]

NAV got a new contender

[@ImDundro]

😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@zman245]

Their battle will be legendary.

[@TheCommentor-]

NAV has a few listenable songs tho

[@phasewaveeee]

do NOT insult my goat nav like that

[@debbiecrankin]

Forgot he existed fr

[@whotfiskelvin]

Ian is yeat for people who think salt and pepper is spicy

[@Turbos-b3z]

Lmao

[@MarkMarkMark556]

😭

[@polarhero57]

Oh my godddddd he sounds nothing like yeat

[@MarkMarkMark556]

@@polarhero57keep coping buddy

[@polarhero57]

@@MarkMarkMark556 how am I coping. I love yeat, him and ian sound absolutely nothing alike.

[@thomaskane9464]

0:05 actually he’s from Missouri. Not that I actually care about getting the facts right for him but as a Minnesota native I don’t want the slander of my state’s people.

[@stealthpoint]

I’m from Missouri. Please delete this comment.

[@littleratfella6857]

That explains so much

[@Rexspecsjosh]

I’m happy I wasn’t born in Missouri

[@unholycrusader69]

​@@stealthpoint only North Korea finna claim this headass at this rate

[@nerdinleather]

​@@littleratfella6857 nah SZA and Nelly and and Chuck Berry are also from Missouri, we got culture

[@επιχείρηση-ι9ρ]

This is a generational run. Up there with Nav. He truly has a bright future on the melon youtube channel

[@sicksadworld765]

Nav >>> Ian

[@ScruFaceJeanOfficial]

Tyler was right

[@605gbird]

Hi Scru

[@gobson435]

Scrus least favorite white boy and thats sayin something

[@ahkader47kader25]

Scrufraudjean the beef pusher, ny favorite instigator

[@bhaskar3200]

Please drop a reaction to the album🙏🏽

[@finallydan]

he was definitely not right

[@thyartismurder6352]

he’s the new nav he’s collecting not goods like championship rings

[@sicksadworld765]

Respectfully Nav >>> Ian

[@DatDaDatty]

ian got back to back not good 😭

[@sleep6837]

Deserved

[@linkthastink]

That’s why he the goat!

[@mountain_p4th]

He's coming for Nav's throne

[@x_VineM_x]

​@@linkthastink😂

[@K3K3_G0AT]

shii crazy onb

[@gabisyderas1855]

Remember when everyone was fucking fuming that Tyler The Creator said this dude's music was awful and then he showed them by continuing to get worse and worse

[@danielholt6480]

Really? I guess I'm not online enough to see the backlash but I remember seeing Tyler said that and generally agreeing.

[@Bearington8]

You haven’t even listened to the music , listen to the title track goodbye horses

[@okok-tf8rr]

@@Bearington8 its garbage. and the fuck do you mean 'you haven't even listened to the music?' are you him? you can't know that, clown

[@finallydan]

bro didn’t even listen to the album

[@xeno9671]

​@@finallydangood on him tbh

[@madremorelos1573]

For so long I thought this was the guy from Smosh

[@feli6277]

that's- uhh... hmm...

[@ddchampaigne]

Ian Hecox would never

[@zboy1152]

LMAO

[@LatinaCreamQueen]

IT'S NOT???

[@lukegroundwalka]

You’re lying

[@DukeOnkled]

Rich kid gets to play with the rap scene like it's his own toys or some shit. People let this happen.

[@fangal12]

Yachty got that feature check though, that's all he cares about

[@SomeGuy_Somewhere]

That's a lot of rappers & pop artists nowadays, they just pay their way into fame, even KZbinrs are "rappers" now

[@fangal12]

@@SomeGuy_Somewhere are you trying to imply that Trippie Red and Lil Wayne didn't collab with KSI because they admired his lyrical prowess?

[@dakota.7617]

@@fangal12for the clout tbh

[@angelicthecaretaker777]

​@100bandjug she's being sarcastic

[@georgeandfriendsadventures5073]

“ian’s Goodbye Horses is not good” “Every 60 seconds in Africa, a minute passes”

[@westgmd]

"Grass is green"

[@CloudiiHysteria]

The silverware is in the kitchen

[@meaxure]

Water is wet

[@xeno9671]

Water is wet

[@Colt12000]

The sky is blue

[@FishDrinkLightGreen]

As someone named Ian, this entire video feels like Fantano is directly insulting me. Truly a fantastic experience

[@mgz2093]

People dared to compare him to yeat aswell

[@whotfiskelvin]

Ong bro idk where the comparison came from

[@sickloc]

@@whotfiskelvin they have similar sounds ian just pulls it off way worse

[@sleep6837]

Unreal

[@henk4]

@@sickloc Yeat already makes relatively repetitive/similar sounding songs (sometimes a good thing, sometimes not). Having ANOTHER guy taking inspo from the guy who already sounds repetitive was not gonna go well, which is exactly what Ian sounds like to me

[@CiRdy34]

Battle of Mid

[@itsallenwow]

Ian is rap music’s own Hawk Tuah

[@Biokill]

why do you have a blue comment on youtube

[@RexRx-soundcloud]

@@Biokillwait yeah wtf i saw that buts it’s gone now

[@zodiac588]

@@RexRx-soundcloudwtf it’s gone too

[@MedicFromTF2_REAL]

@@Biokill Apparently its a random thing yt does and just makes certain terms and phrases searchable but then it goes away

[@Plaguestray]

Why do people continue to entertain gimmick “rappers” like this? It’s hard to believe they genuinely choose to listen to this over anything else.

[@blazer-p4c]

Because you don’t actually get rap or have tried to in your life like fantano. Ian is talented

[@DCT97]

@@blazer-p4c lmaooo get a load of this ret*rd

[@jisforjae]

@@blazer-p4c talented to stupid people, maybe

[@voidddth]

@@blazer-p4c ok ian's fake account

[@alixyxv]

Explain how it's a gimmick

[@maxpagan635]

calling it now we're gonna get some real inescapable radio hits in 2-3 years when he pivots away from hip hop entirely after using the genre as a stepping stone to fame

[@warnejoseph]

So you're saying he's going to become the next Post Malone

[@maxpagan635]

​@@warnejoseph maybe, but if so definitely worse than post, I actually like some of the post malone songs lol

[@diamondsare4ever]

@@warnejosephno post Malone is actually a great musician and songwriter. Man’s got like 6 diamonds songs lol I don’t think Ian is quite capable of doing that even posts earlier work like white Iverson was unique. That’s the thing post is himself and Ian is a clone. Clones don’t have longevity you gotta have ur own sound

[@PaballoKobe-xh9ve]

Gonna gear that Hawk tuah on radio😂 cant wait

[@eliscott0833]

@@diamondsare4everfr ian don’t got shit on post

[@spikegn4970]

Title alone, this is H.BomberGuys favourite album ever

[@ibnibz2636]

Goated comment

[@paiten-nr2do]

goodbye horses, you arent real anymoreeeee

[@JacobMosegris]

Hbomberguy's 2 hour slaughter of James Somerton is also the greatest diss track ever released.

[@Jumsut_]

@@JacobMosegris”Jesus Christ, it wasn’t y’all it was someone else. IT WAS THEM’LL” Absolute bars.

[@JacobMosegris]

@@Jumsut_ "How does, and I mean this as a compliment, the most fuckable twink I've ever seen in my life tell me how to manage my T-levels? Is he speaking from experience?" was also absolutely brutal. Different guy, but same video. A sick bar every minute.

[@michaelz1212]

And people are legit saying he's better than Tyler... Humanity is rotting

[@natetingen1404]

thats bait

[@turnthonkee]

@@natetingen1404tiktok generation reads bait, believes it, and internalizes it as their legitimate opinion. so its hard to tell

[@natetingen1404]

@@turnthonkee so do old people on facebook

[@SomeGuy_Somewhere]

​@@natetingen1404who do you think grows up into those old Facebook people?

[@rehreh92]

@@natetingen1404i thought plaqueboymax was being fr 😭 he sounded like it

[@pointpaa]

10 years old kids are going to be mad at this, watch out Fantano...

[@BigOwl51]

Ian makes music for kids who religiously watch every single episode of Skibidi Toilet when they come out.

[@MichaelMunch-x3o]

Not surprised. The industry plant is crashing down very fast 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@xonytfr]

thankfully enough

[@MichaelMunch-x3o]

@@xonytfr facts

[@nolay530]

ian been here for years btw

[@gottaluvdd]

@@nolay530never heard of em till tiktok

[@beans4052]

I think the worst thing to come out of all of this is when I look up Goodbye Horse on Spotify this album shows up first before Q Lazzarus’ song 😔

[@credenzamostro]

let's hope his career turns out the same way hers did

[@cutecrazycoolstreams]

saying goodbye to a horse is always not good 😓

[@spheress]

I LAUGHED SO HARD AT THIS

[@timothyohara7659]

I don't think that most people in the younger gen are looking for music like this, and if they are there are plenty of drake albums to listen to. I think this is only really an artist for a layman audience that isn't really looking for anything specific in their music. I'd be extremely surprised to see him go much further than this.

[@interjosh]

Its the wanna be "thug" white kids who think this corny music is good

[@jay_344]

I think the appeal is a bit deeper than that. many people like simple rap and Ian is effectively easy listening for rap fans. I don’t know anyone who is expecting a true hit from Ian, which puts him in a strange lane. he showed us that he gets the music objective and now he can tread water. it’s like a youtuber who doesn’t do anything new or unique, but you kinda like watching them bumble through a content portfolio. there’s.. charm? to that. on the flip side, everything i just said could just be an excuse to pat myself on the back for sitting through some mid

[@timothyohara7659]

@@jay_344 thats a fair shake, but in terms of just looking for simpler stuff I think there's so many better options, I don't really understand why anyone would opt to put their time into this versus a gallery of artists who are perfectly fine staying in a lane while doing it better. it's an odd thing that I've seen with some artists that have been getting somewhat big with internet popular sub genres aswell.

[@lukegroundwalka]

Watch him retire in 2 years and be forgotten in 3.

[@abysmalist4761]

horses aren't even real

[@jay_344]

horses were invented by the government to cover up the existence of unicorns and as a part 2 to this comment, as per my my unspoken contract with fantano, I must say some shit that stirs up a bunch people for no reason: I think Ian’s music isn’t bad and I enjoy it. it isn’t deep, but 99% of the music I listen to isn’t deep. influence isn’t enough of a disqualifier for me

[@ewan7283]

2:42 is an insane bar

[@SpareMango]

Ian's horse album gets a NOT GOOD right before Yeat's horse album gets a 10

[@MTrevor1016]

Pretty good but I think it’ll get a 5 from him

[@yourboibigbrain7353]

​@MTrevor1016 I think he's not gonna like it as much as 2093 fs but for me yeat is still on a crazy run by far the best rage rapper

[@winkipodlife2866]

Nah he got bullied back to his old sound he's not gonna like it

[@normanfernee3500]

@@winkipodlife2866it’s not really like his old sound bar the fact it’s more “ragey”. this album still has lots of 2093 elements

[@dess234]

@@winkipodlife2866it’s definitely not his old sound, it still has them metallic sounds. Nothing like 2 Alive

[@THElerolus]

i don't think mid is the same as not good. mid would be like 5/10

[@deejaycxre]

People fuck up the meanings of everything nowadays. mid is literally meant to be short for middle.

[@ImpendingRiot83]

This immediately following the ELUCID review is one of the clearest examples of How To (ELUCID) vs. How Not To (ian) I’ve ever seen.

[@Raichiro]

Some 15 year old is crying watching this review

[@mthzb]

We made it from "farty synths" all the way to "sputtering diarrhea bass". Icethony Spicetano

[@MichaelJimenez416]

Idk, if you’re a hip hop nerd, you can at least tell that Ian knows a lot about the history of trap music. The bars might not be that great, and there’s almost no personality, but it’s nowhere near as exploitative as the stuff Lil Mabu does.

[@dylan_epic4]

Exactly like i think the album is listenable and has pretty good enjoyable moments and at its worst it isn’t bad just mediocre. It’s not listening to something absolutely absurd or mind bending but it’s enjoyable to listen to.

[@Teh_Akod]

“The track Loco is not Loco enough” is probably the worst insult I have ever heard.

[@jiliel7887]

Yo anthony about 3 years ago i donated 5 dollars on a stream and asked if you had listened to ruben slikk. You said no and that you would check him out. I have heard nothing from you since then. I think the only just recourse here is for you to review his album "king astroslikk the magnificent" In all seriousness it's an amazing album from a dude that could definitely use some help/exposure rn

[@mechabubba]

none of you learned a damn thing from fantanos second channel video

[@kylefoley6745]

The comments perfectly reflect the music. No need for a deep musical discussion

[@nadpher]

@@kylefoley6745 yeah id argue this album is one of the few that actually deserves the incessant irony

[@KathyClysm]

To be fair, in order to engage in a thoughtful discussion about this album, I'd have to subject myself to listening to it and yeah, I'd really rather not.

[@xylin3683]

I typically would agree with you, but there's no need to have a thoughtful discussion about an album that took zero thought to create.

[@silverreaps6803]

You expect a thoughtful discussion to be had about f*cking ian??????

[@kristofermccormack6]

He must have a dirt rich parent in the industry cause how someone so limited can make this big a splash is beyond me.

[@seth6691]

Tbh I know it’s weird but handsome+jock/basic bitch frat bro vibe+ weed+ money, connections+ chronically online spongebrain(Ian)+ ironic album covers. As much as it’s uninspired, the kid knew how to get the hype. Not giving him credit per say, but I can’t act clueless as to how he got here

[@hhere2stay]

he does have rich parents.

[@zaharpolovinkin1048]

The valedictorian mixtape is okay but this album is hard asf

[@juddgottschall1954]

3:53 melon has such a way with words

[@CameronCunningham-h4f]

Fun fact: ian is the first artist to get 2 not goods within a year

[@largegrainofsand]

Second. NAV was the first, in 2020.

[@CameronCunningham-h4f]

@@largegrainofsand three if you count brown boy 2 as a separate album

[@hhere2stay]

NAV respect button ----->

[@AngelCTR430]

The indirect sxprano slander is crazy

[@jamahll6152]

sxpranos beats are perfect

[@hhere2stay]

@@jamahll6152 not perfect he has some mid beats but hes getting better fs

[@hhere2stay]

@@jamahll6152 his beats were the reason i even listened to valecdictorian lmfao

[@mondaybear21]

bro tried to be Lazarus Q

[@nononono-ls1hp]

goated track

[@takeiteasyaaron]

and surpassed them 😮‍💨😮‍💨

[@ALi-ROBi]

My absolute favorite fantano videos are not goods. I know I don’t get a recommendation out of it, but they are so entertaining

[@xanderkai6353]

same, it’s something i genuinely look forward to 😂 when there’s a dry spell i like to go back and rewatch some of the iconic ones (best example being angelic 2 the core)

[@paulmaloney4387]

i cant believe this album sucks... my expectations were incredibly high.

[@sleep6837]

"it's an embarrassin comparison"

[@jefcoble8827]

Flytroop right here

[@sleep6837]

@@jefcoble8827 🪖🪖🪖

[@debbiecrankin]

5:02 can somebody tell me the most up to date hip hop, trap, electronic music with most interesting snares, drums, Etc? Like what should I be listening to?

[@seth6691]

Eh this project is underwhelming but fantano doesn’t have authority/the ear for trap music. You can have a legendary and very “experimental” beat with conventional snare sounds, 808, cymbals.. like that’s what being inspired is. Tons of newer “hyperpop” or rage beats use the same hi hats and 808s yet it’s more about the synths, the composition.. what the chords/melody evoke. There’s no right thing you “should” be listening to. I like lil shine, Xaviersobased, Laker Brady, Bladee, zelooperz, Joeyy, Sickboyrari. They all use convention trap drums yet the beats go hard in my opinion

[@debbiecrankin]

@@seth6691 damn those dudes SUCK 🗣️ I just listened to two of them

[@seth6691]

@@debbiecrankin Well you think they suck, a lot of people don’t, fantano has given positive reviews to some of their projects, go listen to Eminem or whatever you like. What the fuck does “up to date” even mean? There’s folk music released a week ago that still uses the same guitars bob Dylan used, yet it can sound fresh. It’s not some linear technological progression. That’s not how music works. If you listen to Coat I would Buy -Joeyy and can’t even fathom how that’s be fun to turn up to, that is sad.

[@superdrummerboy1028]

​@@seth6691 Lmao "the authority" on trap music is NOT something I expected to hear this week or possibly ever

[@superdrummerboy1028]

​@@seth6691 Lmao "the authority" on trap music is NOT something I expected to hear this week or possibly ever

[@AyeJRRRRR]

if it was called goodbye melon he would’ve gave it a 10

[@QuestKim2374]

If it was called To goodbye a Horse 😭😭

[@lordofthewasps8583]

Ian is gunning for Nav’s record

[@nb7560]

You are only saying this album is not good because it is not good. Very biased and unoriginal of you mr melon. Unsubscribed.

[@THE.STARI1]

I love watching Anthony dislike something i dislike it's really a day maker

[@jvsebastian2884]

Ian following the path of real rappers like NAV and Gunna by receiving NOT GOOD's for the melon

[@blazer-p4c]

Proof that fantano doesn’t know trap

[@royalwarlord2342]

Saint Chroma is the only one who can save us at this point 🙏🙏🙏

[@javiartem]

chromakopia is the album, saint chroma was the teaser video he dropped

[@royalwarlord2342]

@@javiartem saint chroma is the name of the character. “ST. CHROMA” is the intro as “IGOR’S THEME” is to “IGOR” and “Sir Baudelaire” is to “Call Me If You Get Lost”

[@Bl00prs]

At this rate of NOT GOODS, ian will be the new NAV 👏 🎉

[@JonathanLeon]

Goodbye horses I'm flying over you

[@Shaizimusic]

I loved it personally

[@walker4607]

this dude professionally hates ian 😂

[@CoolChris16]

Because he doesn’t like his albums like you do??? Grow tf up dude 😭

[@walker4607]

@@CoolChris16i made a statement 😂 never said my opinion

[@deejaycxre]

you weirdasses wonder why he's hating yet choose to glaze over a random ass white kid imitating an already kind of bad artist. and this is the same dude that gave a sexxy red album a 7 so you know y'all are weird.

[@bigballer1019]

What you said at like 2:10 ish is valid. I actually like Ian for the vibe and everything surrounding him. Don’t think he’s super talented overall tho

[@TurtleMansion]

I personally liked his last album but didnt listen to this new one yet, i think hes just someone whos able to catch on to the current sound and is using social media to show he can blow up from it, not really trying to create his own sound hes just trying to benefit from it & the culture/social media

[@jacobdonnelly27]

2 NOT GOODS in a row? NAV's got real competition.

[@vitasomething]

till i die?? like until i die?? machine girl mg ultra?? wow i want to listen to mg ultra now so i dont have to think of this ian kid

[@cheetahkin]

First two beats literally sound like something on the Eric Andre show where they'd have rap tracks as gags. It's literally Rapper Warrior Ninja.

[@benjamin_cheatler]

real bro

[@Bassotronics]

What a coincidence!... Just last week I was listening to a song called "GoodBye Horses" by Psyche and I love that song! I got scared that Fantano was referring to Psyche but he's referring to "Ian" with the same Goodbye Horses title!

[@nuclearbaconLIVE]

some of the songs are pretty good, like shit sad and end up gone. ur hatin

[@Spaceman23457]

Frr Ian hate is so dumb when they glaze yeat

[@scottyp8323]

agreed, the ending of goodbye horses is gorgeous

[@ChrysTheMusicianReacts]

I love how fans will always find a way to justify trash. “Oh he’s just having fun, don’t take it too seriously” than any actually good rapper takes even a slight back pedal lyrically and they get crucified.

[@jp_cam]

ian's goodbye horses gets a review but not glaive's may it never falter 😪😪smh my head

[@Lycanvenom]

I saw this coming when that shit dropped a week ago. No one talked about it, the album didn't have a Wiki page, there were zero review scores, and the album had been out for a full day and a half by that point.

[@beanu1237]

this guy played at my college and everyone was more hype for the girl who opened for him than ian himself

[@4tado]

6:44 Mid is average/middle of the road is it not? We need mids in this world to make the greats greater and the bads badder.

[@godissecondtome]

i get the sentiment but lows vs highs is objectively a bigger distinction when mids aren't involved. its like how black seems darker on a checkerboard than in a gradient

[@backinblackskin23]

Nah wack shit needs to stop being co-signed. Participation generation shit is trash

[@FishSticker]

Mid means bad

[@ronanmcintyre]

It's something that tends to happen linguistically to words, they start to get more extreme over time. Mid might have meant 'average' or 'underwhelming' to begin with but now it more often means 'crappy' or 'worthless'

[@tegar8926]

​@@FishStickernah bro mid means mediocre aka 5/10, but that words has pretty much lost all meaning nowadays

[@jorgemcguitarhero]

Ian's music is reminiscent of early Chief Keef, early rage music, early yeat music. Just because Ian is white doesn't mean he can't take a genuine interest in rap music. He is speaking about what matters to him and in a perspective that's relatable to many people. You're welcome to disagree but if you liked alot of these things he's influenced by, he's doing his most authentic version of that. In regards to the type of beats/producers many people like that early 2010's "cheap" sound.

[@mishailaa]

“an authentic version of influences” ? bro is literally just biting 😭😭

[@deejaycxre]

I agree race doesn't matter. but saying he's putting out thee most authentic version of his influences is delusional. it's imitation. he may technically be a part of the genres he's contributing to, but he never added to it like chief keef did. at most i can say he has a good ear for beats, but drake had a good ear for beats and he's also mediocre for the most part.

[@jorgemcguitarhero]

@@deejaycxre art at is core is a cycle of imitation slightly modified. We're all copying the first guy

[@deejaycxre]

@@jorgemcguitarhero technically, but i'd consider imitation and inspiration two different terms.

[@fuosdi64]

You sound like you're 15

[@克雷-b4d]

Bro he’s totally a Ian hater😭

[@TTYLIG]

Is he the first person to have 2 not goods in a row? That’s impressive

[@glxy2605]

nav has a current streak of 5 not goods (dpba is in the playlist although it’s not explicitly called “not good”)

[@loganleatherman7647]

Nah, both Gunna and NAV have back to back NOT GOODs

[@XXWildWolf]

How much yall wanna bet Ian’s next album is gonna be country

[@479films]

I liked some of the songs on it. showboat, end up gone, big wigs, hate me, and goodbye horses were solid tracks. so 5/13 for me in todays world that's not a terrible album. does he have so many similarities to yeat of course he does. he's different though. i hate him being torn apart because he does things others do. he makes good music here and there. the album has a defined vibe and theme that's more than lots of albums have. the continuity is nice the emotion is real those 5 songs are good regardless of whether the technique, flow, lyrics, bars, etc have been used i couldnt care less. im here for good music not newness for newness sake i just want good content fr. the album cover was nice too he is unique in some ways, ways i like, i like him being in the mix

[@longlivethesheet4561]

I for one can’t wait for ian’s villain arc

[@ninjadad725]

Here goes the fantano d riders who haven’t even listened to one Ian song and if you have then you haven’t listened to Yeat because have completely different styles and vernacular. The only song I’d say sounds like Yeat is hardest goodbye.

[@f-22raptor420]

Imagine being an Ian d rider 😂

[@nikolai4380]

I swear these ppl are corny as fuck they just go w the hate train

[@fuosdi64]

Its absolutely hilarious how fantano didnt even care about cropping the album covers correctly into the green screen 😂

[@ThermodynamikIsAThermo]

How the hell are there Ian glazers

[@choirsofdeath]

4:56 Not defending Ian here but these kinds of songs were not really characteristic of 2016 anymore. That song is clearly very inspired by Futuristic glo or Chief Keef’s sound around 2013. I agree that Ian’s music is generic and cheap but Fantano clearly has a negative bias (and lack of understanding) when it comes to trap music, and it’s clearly evident in most of his criticisms (for example at 5:07 where he talks about the snare rolls being done before; repetition of previous things is characteristic of a lot of trap music. Not everything has to be forward thinking). I know many people view trap as a surface level and drab genre but there’s a lot more nuance to the genre and how it has developed than most people think.

[@OtherM112594]

I’m the opposite. I think Ian is NOT BAD.

[@failadin1]

I thought lil bro had his 5 seconds of fame a couple of months ago.

[@loganleatherman7647]

This is the modern era, where 5 secs of fame gets stretched out over like 5 years until ian is down to hosting his own podcast as his main source of income

[@failadin1]

@@loganleatherman7647 god I can’t wait for the valedictorian podcast, im so excited for such insightful conversations to happen.

[@harleyfields1664]

would probably be a better venture for him that tbh

[@ThePoisonJelly]

He did, this album flopped

[@hhere2stay]

@@loganleatherman7647 He will be featured on the Talk Tuah podcast

[@cynicismIncarnate]

I feel like "Goodbye Horses" would be a really good album title for something rather jovial. Under Ian's god awful everything, the "Goodbye Horses" title comes off as word salad, crafted by someone artistically and intellectually uninterested. I can only hope Ian's career fizzles out sooner rather than later.

[@slackstarfish8133]

1:00 actual clown💀💀

[@andrewwbj]

Tyler is right 😭

[@danielclingersmith4656]

Tyler right 😂

[@fluorescentfuneralalt]

I think he meant the dude's manager ​@@andrewwbj

[@MrBubby659]

Nah bru shit feels like we’re listening to a 2014 trap beat with so much bass you cant even hear ian

[@juliefoster3354]

beats from the early 2010s were better

[@djywrites]

"Ian is unignorable in the same way that Lil Mabu is" Me, having never even heard *of* either artist: yes absolutely

[@gabe2k07]

Ice spice’s latest project is NOT better than this.

[@pointlessfeature]

grass is green

[@gio52903]

Two not goods. IAN is truly an artist of our lifetime.

[@nut311aman]

Idk, I think NAV still has him beat. We can only hope the brown boy's next album will define the next generation...

[@bluejay7090]

babe wake up new not good droppped

[@honestone4306]

I love you for giving Mac Miller the respect he deserves I wish more people had known what a multitalented artist he was before it was too late.

[@Hal9000ize]

Anyone see Fantanos video on sincerity?

[@mechabubba]

reading these comments, clearly not

[@lilyluhtwizzy]

Gonna need a link!

[@featherpure]

what is it even called

[@duhduhduhdiesel1436]

​@@mechabubbalol exactly. Many of his 'fans' are straight up cretins

[@In.New.York.I.Milly.Rock.]

Not sure this album is the best place to ask about that. It's not like it deserves any sort of insightful commentary

[@mxrliin]

Where did Ian even come from? He just spawned one day 😭

[@YoungChill31five]

You’ve aged out of underground rap music and that’s fine but why do you HAVE to be all squidwardy about it?

[@joedatius]

underground rap? bitch Ian is a privileged little white boy who has been given everything to him. kindly stfu

[@tonyjones5500]

Ian feels like the opposite of all the "lyrical miracle" white guys from the late 2010s

[@swansonjoe7121]

I didn’t even know he came out with an album lmaoooo Tyler’s gonna mop the floor with him 😂

[@emeraldbaby2259]

😂😂😂

[@bigballerdefault1054]

What? Ian’s album has nothing to do with tyler

[@TheTryhardBeast12]

I’d sure hope the established mainstream artist who’s been around for over a decade would mop the floor with a 19 year old who just started getting attention this year lmao

[@Plaguestray]

@@bigballerdefault1054they’re pretty much saying that Tyler’s album will overshadow this gimmick rapper’s album by a landslide and it’ll actually display talent and creativity in hip hop as apposed to this tasteless attempt at rap

[@bigballerdefault1054]

@@Plaguestray again… why? Comparing them is useless, obviously tyler will sell more he’s just the larger artist, also I don’t really care if tyler’s project will be good or bad, or if Fantano doesn’t like ian, Ian’s got quite a few tuff songs on that tape

[@justintylermendez]

fantano couldn’t fathom the aura ian is producing

[@fuhlash]

i wonder if nav is starting to get jealous

[@alternate2002]

Can you review the 2hollis album from earlier this year?