Ibn Hazm of Cordoba

A short video on the Andalusian polymath Ibn Hazm.
#cordoba #islam #religion

[@tunperak228]

Some of the Islamic Scholars said "Ibn Hazm's pen is sharper than Hajjaj's sword".

[@Movie2Documentary]

Whats with the statues thou?

[@2009samiy]

youtube mary and jesus in the quran and mohmmad in the bible and the Torah and the scientific miracles of the quran and mohmmad in hindu scripture

[@miiilllooooo]

Idk why I find that hard to believe. I wouldn’t consider this man as a Muslim

[@miiilllooooo]

He doesn’t even follow Islam

[@harharharharharharharharha240]

@@miiilllooooowhta

[@ahmedkhalifa5190]

We need an episode about that ...

[@Prebaaaaaaaaaaaaaa]

Yes please!

[@ishqnoor]

Yes !!

[@nssr4031]

yes

[@intermezzoina]

Yes❤

[@brickS-pq9pw]

Yep even ibn taymeyah and a lot more

[@samadanalmasani1594]

Zahiri school isn't extinct, but it's not as popular as the foir main schools, you can find zahiri in yemen

[@Gexxyfez]

Ibn Hazm also believed in round earth.

[@karimmezghiche9921]

Most humans of the Middle Ages accepted that the earth is not flat

[@Gexxyfez]

@@karimmezghiche9921 not entirely true. Ibn Hazm mentions in his book Al-Fasl Fi’l-Milal that most laymen believed the earth is round.

[@sar_performance_nutrition]

That was commonly accepted by islamic scholars. Quran mentions the earth being spread into an egg-like shape (derived from the roots of the word used to describe the earth, as is the case with most analogies and descriptions in arabic which makes it difficult to always know what something means from just a google translation).

[@swymaj02]

as did the ancient Greeks

[@alinaqirizvi1441]

@@sar_performance_nutrition no the egg shape thing is just zakir naik's nonsense

[@Tariq-oj5zz]

As a quasi-revert Guatemalan-American I'm proud of the traditions and achievements of Spanish Islam!

[@ivand9610]

Vende patria mamao... Just be a good catholic

[@user-lz1tz7um5w]

@@ivand9610nah he don’t wanna worship a man

[@AbdullahMikalRodriguez]

If your Guatemalan why are you proud of something a Spaniard did? You aren't Spanish...

[@HaharuRecords]

@@AbdullahMikalRodriguez after all he is a human being. A human doesn't represent no inheritance in reality..You see, The universe exists in one point and expanded like f

[@ivand9610]

@@AbdullahMikalRodriguez your Spaniard/native. Lol not muslim

[@Ibn_Malika]

Ibn Hazm رحمه الله (or his school) also believed that you could see a girl fully naked before marriage and that if you didn't lie down to rest between the superogatory units of the dawn prayer and the obligatory units of the dawn prayer then your dawn prayer is null and void. So his literalism was a bit crazy.

[@okinoboo4743]

Thank you for that

[@Mj-rl9hz]

Do you have source for that

[@CosmicHase]

That's kinda horny.

[@MuhammadSaleh]

I understand what you're saying, but ibn Hazm wasn't coming to juristic conclusions through any kind of women's lib or progressive framework. He had a juristic methodology, which denied (in theory) the legitimacy of analogical deduction in law, and simply applied it. And it makes sense when you think about why that would lead to juristic conclusions that can appear more "liberal", because when you deny the jurist the ability to extend the law in scenarios they see as analogous to others where the law is applied, then you won't have a juristic ruling on many matters that most other schools of thought will.

[@LetsTalkReligion]

Exactly

[@cheikhsalek7695]

Good informative content!

[@AbdullahMikalRodriguez]

I think 'textualist' is a better label for the Zahiris. Ibn Arabi was also a Zahiri yet no one considers him a "literalist." No true Muslim scholar is a "literalist." This term holds no value in religious interpretation.

[@yassinrian292]

You don’t know what your are talking about…Ibn Hazm is one of the big Muslim scholars ….

[@AbdullahMikalRodriguez]

​@yassinrian292 Your not understanding what I'm saying... I agree Ibn Hazm is a jewel of the ummah. One of the greatest scholars in the history of Islam. His writings are still very relevant even today. I'm just saying literalist is not an accurate description of his and many other scholars methodology. They are textualists, not literalist.

[@laylaali5977]

He was a Quran centric literalist

[@Synocra]

What he explained sounds like a Quranist, can someone explain what Zahirism actually is

[@malek1627]

​@@omaraboal-azm8705 إنهم لا ينفون القياس نهائياً هذا ليس صحيحاً حتى لو زعموا ذلك فكلهم يقيسون فهذا خطأ منهم وابن حزم ليس ظاهرياً على سبيل المثال في العقيدة بل مذهبه بين المعتزلة والأشاعرة في العقيدة وعلم الكلام.

[@gabrielkobari2267]

Appreciate the content. This is nice info 👍

[@2009samiy]

youtube mary and jesus in the quran and mohmmad in the bible and the Torah and the scientific miracles of the quran and mohmmad in hindu scripture

[@Saadbsth]

Man i just wish i could tag along you on these trips. Can you hire me as your secretary or something?

[@2009samiy]

youtube mary and jesus in the quran and mohmmad in the bible and the Torah and the scientific miracles of the quran and mohmmad in hindu scripture

[@exponentialpotential9442]

Philosophers inhabit a Fabulous concept 😊😊😊 Blessings Thank You The Dignity of The Moors...Profound

[@2009samiy]

youtube mary and jesus in the quran and mohmmad in the bible and the Torah and the scientific miracles of the quran and mohmmad in hindu scripture

[@exponentialpotential9442]

@@2009samiy Thank You 😊🕊️

[@b4r_085]

it sounded weird saying that their school of thought prohibited (forcing) women to wear the veil , as far as my knowledge goes i don't think there is a school of thought where they allow that !!!

[@Edan_Marf_TV]

Will there be an episode about him?

[@2009samiy]

youtube mary and jesus in the quran and mohmmad in the bible and the Torah and the scientific miracles of the quran and mohmmad in hindu scripture

[@user-zt5no2jg7j]

Please do episode about Ibn Hazm 🙏🏻 Like if you agree 👍

[@ahmedbenissa5982]

Saying that Ibn Hazam allowed music, is not completely true. In fact, Ibn hazam could not verify the authenticity of a Hadith, to which the scholars refer to forbid music. Nevertheless, he literally stated that if later we can verify the authenticity of this Hadith, then I withdraw my statement. The Hadith was later verified to be authentic.

[@novailkhan4973]

Barakallahu feek akhi

[@DrWoofOfficial]

The hadeeth is authentic to some, and still unauthentic to others, and there is detailed discussion on that

[@novailkhan4973]

@@DrWoofOfficialIf you don’t mind me asking, which scholar of Hadith declared the Hadith to be weak? There is a consensus of the sahaba that musical instruments should be considered haram as a rule. RasoolAllah ﷺ said that the jummah would never unite upon misguidance therefore we should assume music to be prohibited in Islam.

[@DrWoofOfficial]

The Dhahiri/Zahiri school is definitely not extinct. It just doesn't have many followers. I would consider myself closely aligned with that school

[@godsblackpanther]

Thank You. So Appreciated 😊😊😊 Blessings ❤️‍🔥

[@2009samiy]

youtube mary and jesus in the quran and mohmmad in the bible and the Torah and the scientific miracles of the quran and mohmmad in hindu scripture

[@introspectivex8346]

The Zahiri’s have been given the translation “literalist” but this is not a correct interpretation and leads to a misunderstanding. Zahir means “apparent.” So his school was essentially saying that if the literal meaning of the Qur’an is more apparent then to go with that, and if the metaphorical meaning is more apparent then to go with that rather than doing analogies (Qiyās). The translation to “literalist” gives the Zahiris a bad and incorrect impression of being literalists by only taking literal meanings and not accepting metaphorical meanings.

[@polinaberberez4816]

Beautiful ❤

[@2009samiy]

youtube mary and jesus in the quran and mohmmad in the bible and the Torah and the scientific miracles of the quran and mohmmad in hindu scripture

[@ishqnoor]

How interesting! Thank you 💚

[@2009samiy]

youtube mary and jesus in the quran and mohmmad in the bible and the Torah and the scientific miracles of the quran and mohmmad in hindu scripture

[@lilyhk701]

I passed his statue randomly in one of the streets in Cordoba and looked him up. Really fascinating to learn about him

[@2009samiy]

youtube mary and jesus in the quran and mohmmad in the bible and the Torah and the scientific miracles of the quran and mohmmad in hindu scripture

[@Jose-ur7jz]

Gracias

[@2009samiy]

youtube mary and jesus in the quran and mohmmad in the bible and the Torah and the scientific miracles of the quran and mohmmad in hindu scripture

[@ciano9535]

Damn the world misses the golden age

[@ogreycloud]

The opinions u mention as liberal were not unique to Ibn Hazm but where a matter of disagreement between scholars.

[@LetsTalkReligion]

Right, but they are the liberal options among them.

[@ogreycloud]

@@LetsTalkReligion it was not a matter of being liberal or not. It was matter of what evidance u based ur opinion on.

[@LetsTalkReligion]

@@ogreycloud And yet they are the more liberal ones compared to others. Don't be afraid of a word.

[@ogreycloud]

@@LetsTalkReligion what I'm trying to tell u is that u can't call such opinions liberal because they didn't come as a result of a liberal orionted thought but rather evidence. Ibn Hazm himslef has rulings more strict than other scholls especially being a Thahiri. I just don'want the reader to get a false idea due to ur choice of words

[@Movie2Documentary]

@@ogreycloud valid point; though the intention was to show his views were more liberal (to Western Standards), but by leaving out some nuance it may shows that he's liberal. According to other cultures, liberal may be defined differently and less appaling.

[@tt7762]

I remember studying about him in school

[@abunafizalmahi2065]

Make a video on him plz

[@2009samiy]

youtube mary and jesus in the quran and mohmmad in the bible and the Torah and the scientific miracles of the quran and mohmmad in hindu scripture

[@Nimsan]

Bros pronounciation is crazy good

[@brandonrobinson281]

god i hate shorts because I need more of this discussed

[@EliteBengalSultanate]

Don't shave. Beard looks good on you.

[@ramzan6949]

I also from Bangladesh.

[@2009samiy]

youtube mary and jesus in the quran and mohmmad in the bible and the Torah and the scientific miracles of the quran and mohmmad in hindu scripture

[@azadjm3742]

Love the hiatory

[@2009samiy]

youtube mary and jesus in the quran and mohmmad in the bible and the Torah and the scientific miracles of the quran and mohmmad in hindu scripture

[@TyphoonS.S.]

Whatever goes against the quran and sunnah must be rejected. When Allah Almighty made something halal or haram, nobody can change it

[@johnflannery6763]

Just sends a goat to eat the page

[@TyphoonS.S.]

@johnflannery6763 says a man who believes God was born from a woman and killed by his own creation.

[@MafroomMan]

Forbidding women from going to the mosque or saying its not mandatory to cover the face are both main stream views and if memory serves me the majority opinion

[@YusufAhmed-vd4ry]

Zahiri madhab is not extinct. Rather it is found in rare regions

[@joakker8820]

Louder for the people in the back!

[@qasis42]

I find the Zahiri school very interesting.

[@Faz.76]

Nice beard

[@471444a]

❤

[@2009samiy]

youtube mary and jesus in the quran and mohmmad in the bible and the Torah and the scientific miracles of the quran and mohmmad in hindu scripture

[@abdoobaset6100]

Women are welcome to all mosque usually they have separate area built for them nowadays and in the old days they pray in the back separated by children the orders goes men children's women .

[@issakabeer1535]

U go Ibn Hazm

[@2009samiy]

youtube mary and jesus in the quran and mohmmad in the bible and the Torah and the scientific miracles of the quran and mohmmad in hindu scripture

[@abdulmobin230]

This dude is doing so much good work but people just dont get it

[@abdot604]

well music is debatable among scholars even though the majority forbids it, also the majority dont believe the face vale is obligatory and the majority don't forbid woman from going to mosque. all those scholars arent from ibn hazm school.

[@cartesian_doubt6230]

why does your hair always look wet or greasy?

[@owncraticpath]

What is liberal about not making haram what God made halal?

[@jhonshephard921]

Its the Western political interpretation but due to colonization it gets adopted by everyone

[@nullvoid6095]

This is an academic/educational channel, not a theological one.

[@owncraticpath]

@@nullvoid6095 Of course. I know what he meant. I just pointed out, as someone who was a classical liberal, that liberalism has principles which have nothing to do with Islam. And forbidding what God made permissible is forbidden in Islam, not the sectarian versions tho. So why would what God ordained be liberal now? When liberalism goes against God's law in many instances. Just wanted to point it out, that theologian didn't make up his views, he was based on scripture unlike the sectarians. Peace

[@rockyhilton2816]

@@owncraticpath What he means by “liberal” is more related to the original meaning as “liberty” in constrast to restrictions, rather than Liberal as opposed to Conservative in the political sense. Having the liberty to play instruments or to dress more freely, indicates a more liberal understanding of Islamic practice than the restrictive interpretations of some.

[@Goyim-phobic]

​@@rockyhilton2816actually there is no never consensus amongst Muslim scholars that Muslim prohibited

[@qlippoth13]

Do one on Aposthia and those said to be born aposthic like Moses and Muhammad.

[@muwahid5022]

I mean the whole thing about women going to the majid was already stated by prophet Muhammad ﷺ The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Do not prevent women from their share of the mosques if they seek your permission.” Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 900

[@mohammedjafferali693]

It has never been the case that women arent alowed in mosque, people blow gender seperation in mosque comically out of proportion

[@ishubetterthanyou1582]

​@@mohammedjafferali693"if they seek your permission" is a very good example of basically not allowing them. Oh, and MOST mosques don't even have a section for women, so no, it's not exaggerated.

[@mohammedjafferali693]

@@ishubetterthanyou1582 what are you even talking about 😂😂 who even said that... I pity you for that delusional username when you can't even read

[@gabrielkobari2267]

​@ishubetterthanyou1582 the text literally says if the women seek permission then do "not prevent" them from going to mosques The fact that you couldn't even understand that shows your lack of IQ.

[@swymaj02]

​@ishubetterthanyou1582 that does seem exaggerated though. no mosque I've been where there's no woman involved.

[@ibrahimmohammedibrahim9273]

Zihiri is more close to Maliki school of law

[@2009samiy]

basically he was a simp .

[@l__Dark__l]

Women are allowed to go to the mosque though? The heck? They have been allowed that for 1400 years. 😂 Forcing women to vail their face is literally forbidden in the Quran 2:256 Bruv. To cover your face is not even a fard(compulsory) but a sunnah. Also if he rejected the teachings of the Prophet and tried to make haram, halal, then he isn't even a muslim anymore. Musical instrumens except the duff is forbidden in Islam(Music itself isn't cuz there is a form of music known as Nasheed)

[@codingblues3181]

Zahiri school is not extinct. Just a small correction.

[@user-hj4ym7ug3h]

Name 3 modern Zahiri scholars

[@serine4044]

لا تمنعوا ايماء الله مساجد الله ....

[@MAYONNAISEMOOSE]

liberalism = good now

[@suksuk5191]

people think the salafi islam they see today is truer to old and traditional islam than more "liberal" schools of thought, when it's the exact opposite and salafi is actually extremely modern while these "liberal" schools are actually traditional. Sheikh Khaled abu el fadl from Usuali institute speaks about this topic quiet a bit

[@faruqatumceddal92]

I thought that the zahiris that aloud music, in all cases as a muslim I cannot accept the fact that Islam forbids music.

[@greaseTalk]

So he was against the prophet Muhammad. Awe may Allah keep me far away from him on the day of Judgement

[@novailkhan4973]

Do not say this brother. You have no idea where he’ll be on the day of judgement.

[@gkhfbnhfvng]

He looks european

[@novailkhan4973]

Yeah cause he like many Islamic scholars were from Muslim Spain.

[@gkhfbnhfvng]

@@novailkhan4973 Thanks!

[@ultrasignificantfootnote3378]

Where can I find Islamic scripture that say women are forbidden to go to the Mosque ?

[@NoMan-pp1jq]

There is no scripture forbidden women going to the mosque. The opposite is true and all mosques today either have a man and woman section or they are separated by a curtain

[@laylaali5977]

There is none it’s based on opinion of socially conservative mid evil Hadith centric scholars like Wahhabis

[@AvocadosAtGaming]

Ok allowing women in the mosque is not liberal, the prophet instructed not to forbid them to go to the mosque. Veiling in public, im not sure and music is interesting. Because the Prophet PBUH instructed people to close their ears every ti e they heard music. Which would imply it wasn't out right banned. I speak out of knowledge on the second part here so take everything with a grain of salt.

[@BlondeManNoName]

A progressive thinker? Nice.

[@novailkhan4973]

This implies he was trying to be a progressive thinker. He simply wasn’t. His method for interpreting evidence brought him to those conclusions. He wasn’t intending on coming to those conclusions.

[@nazmorgan8696]

I can tel you that this principals are non existing in Islam. Not now and not in the last 100-200 years…

[@QuadrantRoyale]

Zahiri... Modern day wahabi

[@farajalharbey5293]

Wahhabi Hanbali jurisprudence is against Dhahiriyya, and Ibn Hazm does not have much popularity, neither from a jurisprudential nor doctrinal standpoint. There is a famous saying by Ibn Abd al-Hadi, a student of Ibn Taymiyyah, in which he described Ibn Hazm as a flogging Jahmi.

[@joshuacrommie6249]

Actually the he Wahhabis are Hanbali

[@bilehassan1115]

Liar

[@jalaluddinahmadshaharudin1106]

With your vast knowledge, you should help the Ahmadi religion to unite and liberate humanity from the monetary slave matrix!

[@fizzadawooddogar7375]

u have plenty of religion based knowledge wish could marry you😢

[@ExposingHindutva101]

Are you a Muslim ?

[@ExposingHindutva101]

What ? 🤔

[@ExposingHindutva101]

Are you a Muslimah ?

[@neowiza360]

So, a "bad" Muslim.

[@pepepepito623]

Ah! Infidel :Let us bring that statue to a muslleen territory...why not?

[@alexginger1948]

?

[@abdulHaqqqq]

Behave yourself and be mindful what you say. The prophet Muhammad pbuh said “speak good or remain silent”