Aliexpress Fake Milwaukee vs Genuine Milwaukee Impact Wrench

[@brynnond.6952]

The Milwaukee terminals are floating by design

[@dormstories]

battery connector is loose on the original Milwaukee by design, otherwise it and the battery connection would be damaged from the vibrations produced by the tool.

[@icku]

I'm pretty sure that's not the case. I have a few Milwaukee's and that "design" is something new

[@anthonylancer]

Sir, I promise that man is correct. It's for strain relief.

[@AlexY2-b6y]

Many M18 impact wrench after several years of hard usage, the pin connector worn out causing battery disconnection.... hardly a good design....

[@jason620362]

@@ickumy 3 genuine tools acted like that also

[@victorhoyt4352]

Yeah, he's right. It was a big problem with Milwaukee for many years.

[@jackrenders8937]

2:51 This is by design a spring in there should keep it aligned when there is no battery in and it is suppose to absorb some shock so the tool vibrates less in your hand and the battery isn't rattled around as much. the Parkside performance impact do not have this for example and they vibrate a lot more. So is a comfort feature (on the real Chinese Milwaukee)

[@icku]

You are talking about Bosch. Bosch has such springs, on Milwaukee i haven't seen

[@jfnotk255]

​@@icku - Yes, but he's right, the movability shall prevent the contacts from mechanical load. As you mentioned the battery goes in easily. So the battery has a bit play and the contract block should move with the battery and not try too keep it in position with the contacts.

[@plunder1956]

On the genuine product the pins of the battery terminal are floating to allow for vibration and make insertion work easy. Some makes like Makita make the whole battery mount a floating element to reduce vibration stress on the battery.

[@icku]

You cannot reduce vibration by making the terminals floating. The vibrations are transmitted to the battery thru the battery socket. The contact between those two is really firm. The idea of floating terminals is different, but here is a pure manufacturing defect.

[@AlexY2-b6y]

Many tyremen experience disconnected battery due to a worn out pin connector. Only the new High torque 2967 have the battery isolation piece.... dunno why they they say its a by design choice on the older models🤷

[@jkd7799Yann]

C4 parkside bro.. was waiting this from you

[@tristanlang3470]

Könntest du mal noch den Milwaukee Akkuschrauber testen?

[@nelchan2421]

You forgot the trigger sensitivity test.

[@icku]

Damn it, you are right 😂 Well, I can't remember all..

[@nelchan2421]

@@icku I swap mine to the drill control board and trigger switch assembly for better trigger sensitivity the one without a speed button selector.

[@АстаЛависта-р7е]

​@@ickuА теперь бы цену обоих инструментов? А то может за цену настоящего Милуоки можно штук 5 подделок взять. Они и про служат дольше.

[@soulxtr]

@@АстаЛависта-р7е он сказал про 4х кратную разницу в цене

[@DarioBattiston]

hi colleague, nice video! I also did the original and fake comparison test a few months ago, also using the fake battery! Mine had a 3/8 anvil and I mounted the 1/2 one 😎😆 The video of the 12 volt 80 Nm comes out tomorrow, I hope you'll enjoy seeing it, I've been thinking of you😂

[@icku]

Haha i hope you are thinking of me just for some technical matter 🤣🤣. Bring up the video 🍻

[@DarioBattiston]

@icku ah no big deal😂 I just continued the tests to get a rough idea of ​​what the new batteries are like😎

[@1pcfred]

Milwaukee is going to kill you with the battery prices. So they get you either way.

[@je1966]

I think you are wrong to doubt the quality of the connectors. This movement is so that the connectors make good electrical contact, if they were fixed it would not happen.

[@jason620362]

I bought two of those at the time Not gonna lie they served me well but their throttle control were shit 💩

[@aliveandkicking1977]

Thanks.Happy new year.

[@icku]

Happy new year

[@Tonyplat98]

The wobble is intentional on the original milwaukee. That is because when the tool is used it vibrates and it allows for the battery connector to stay connected and not vibrate and break off. It's a design feature not quality issue.

[@icku]

Nope. A floating terminal connector is something totally different and it's used for better electrical contact. Google it and read the patent - it's publicly available. This here is bad engineering design or manufacturing quality.

[@Tonyplat98]

@@icku Where did you get your electrical engeneering degree from? Look I could be wrong here but my dewalt impacts connectors wobble exactly the same way. If it's not intentional then all these tools are defective then.

[@icku]

@Tonyplat98 I'm not the one stating otherwise the terminal will vibrate and break off 🤣 Earth to Tony - the battery socket is holding the battery, not the terminal. If there is any vibration it will transfer through the socket. The terminal won't be damaged even if you hammer the tool in the ground. The terminal is an electrical connection, not structural like the socket.

[@Tonyplat98]

@@icku ok so we're saying the exact same thing then.... and I was right that it was by design. What seems to be the argument here?

[@icku]

@Tonyplat98 By design is the terminal of Bosch Professional. I'll see if I have a model in hand to shoot it for you. The Milwaukee is a bad engineering...

[@ArcherROG]

Cacca tutti e due 😮 nei punti diversi sul legno può andare più veloce anche lo stesso avvitatore, dipende dalla natura del legno e non dal avvitatore. Milwaukee avvita in 9sec 500€ Parkside avvita in 10sec 50€ 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Per 1 o 2 secondi più veloce devo sprecare 450 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Ridicolo

[@АлтынбекДюсембаев-л5ь]

Text name milwaukee is it paper printed? Or molded plastic? I mean on the side of the fake tool.

[@icku]

Plastic molded

[@henrykurish]

The original Milwaukees terminal jiggles because if it was solid the vibrations would bend the terminals on the tool.

[@icku]

Its because of bad engineering 🤣 Nothing to do with vibrations. The terminals are not holding the battery, the socket is. The vibration is freely traveling through the socket. If you wanna see proper floating terminals (there is even a patent on that) take a look at Bosch Professional terminals. The idea of floating terminals is to make better electrical contact, not eliminate vibration. But here at Milwaukee, the idea is manufacturing cost savings and the result is terrible...

[@henrykurish]

@ sir you are quite mistaken, because if it was solid it would beat up both your battery and the tool since the battery slot allows some play after a lot of use on a high vibration tool like that. It’s not to eliminate vibration it’s to keep you from breaking stuff.

[@icku]

@henrykurish Henry, I have tons of battery operating powertools, none of them broke due to stationary terminals. If something is to break its not the terminals, but the socket. Period.

[@henrykurish]

@ it’s just Milwaukee trying to prevent it because I know your a wood worker and don’t actually get into situations where you have to use high vibration tools such as a 1/2” impact on a seized bolt where you really get vibration through the hand and tool. But Milwaukee has a reputation of breaking batteries and they were attempting to combat

[@MuhammedsWorlds]

interesing,crazy

[@NonyaBuzinezz]

The real one has a battery, thats not a fair comparison

[@icku]

You don't say 🤣🤣🤣

[@domenicocampanelli593]

I m non udestrand i have bought a fake Milwaukee and I saw the real torque is more than the real. For me is 550 nm