My First Rolex + Love/Hate Relationship with the Explorer (124270 Hands-On Review)

A Review of my 36mm Rolex Explorer ref. 124270. After covering this watch and the many evolutions of the Explorer for what must be 5 years, to finally own one and appreciate the subtleties of the newest reference has made the experience so cathartic. From its extremely wearable size and discretion its to well executed dial, there's nothing about this watch that makes you yearn for more. One lesson I've learnt from this is experience is that the Explorer can be seen as an end in itself, not a means to an end.
#rolex #rolexwatch #rolexexplorer
All Images are Sourced from either Press Release Photos or Public Listings.
Below are a list of the common sources that are used in no particular order:
Bob’s Watches | Revolution Watch | HQ Milton | Hodinkee | Monochrome Watches | Jomashop | Analog Shift | Bulang and Sons | Robb Report | Watchfinder | WatchBox | Phillips Watches | Christies | Timekeepers Club | Fratello Watches | Bexsonn | Worn and Wound | A Collected Man | Oracle Time | Time + Tide Watches
IDGuy Store: teespring.com/...
Support the Channel: / idguy
Follow me on Instagram: www.instagram....
Contact me: [e-mail]

[@ID-Guy]

Let’s hear your Rolex Explorer story! Share any and all experiences you’ve had with these pieces over the years and if you’re looking to get one, ask away. I’m sure there are more than a few of us here who’d really want to share what we’ve learnt. Thank you all for your continued support over here, it's always a privilege sharing videos like these with you 🥃

[@SA17579]

I saw the breitling avi chrono. How do you find it as the thickness? PS Great vid, I'm looking at a 40mm explorer as I have 7.75 inch wrist.

[@Giovan_Nino]

Thanks for your thoughts. What can I say, I had the 39 for 5 years and never thought I’d ever part with it. But eventually succumbed to the 40. It’s so much nicer in so many ways imho..

[@SamHuizenga-ix6yb]

I’m so conflicted. I’m on the AP wishlist for a 124270. I tried it on and immediately was swept up in the romance of all the things you talk about…..But since then I’ve been researching Rolex. The whole Hans Wildorf Foundation cultish secrecy with its Swiss Tammany Hall type policial influence…..I’m wondering if all your waxing poetic about Rolex is a by-product of subversive marketing….because reality is there is no mystique about Rolex…it’s a watch with a movement.

[@thatguy6111]

I lusted for an Explorer for decades and picked up the 214270 to commentate my son’s birth. The 36mm is “The Explorer” but it was not available in 2011. I won’t part with that watch until my son is ready to care for it for the rest of his life.

[@LRSTGS]

You don't own the Everest watch. Sick of hearing professional watch journalists get this wrong. The Explorer didn't exist in 1953, and the Oyster Perpetual was absolutely NOT worn to the summit. Hillary said so, Rolex acknowledged it and apologizes publicly to Smiths in period. Owned an Explorer, prefer the OP reference 116000. Same watch with but minor differences, all of which I prefer.

[@rundns]

Bought mine in 2008 during the financial crisis. Lehman just collapsed, I walked into a Rolex store in the heart of Zurich, no waitlist, no nothing. They even gave me a 5% cash discount. Imagine that today. 5k flat in local currency, at that time around 4k USD. Runs smooth like on day one, never had it revised. Might be time though.

[@ID-Guy]

2008, that was a helluva year for me too, remember it like it was yesterday. Fascinates me that all these years later we can still talk about and appreciate these pieces. Excellent story man, thank you for sharing (don’t we all wish we could walk in and get 5% discounts today… on an already decent price) 😉🥃

[@ed7384]

39mm size is best unless you have a girls wrist

[@256k_]

@BenBouteyour existence is a waste

[@seenkim1128]

@@ed7384shut up

[@PeterKotsa]

So glad you shared the back story to the acquisition and the ups and downs in your life. This is a good box that you have ticked at the right time in your life bro... A huge cheers from the other side of the world 🥃

[@ID-Guy]

And seeing your review of the 124273 last year helped tip me over the edge 😉 Kinda interested in pursuing one… like a nutter. But thank you as always Pete, it’s been an experience to say the least. Have an excellent weekend sir! 🥃

[@nhbmk]

I read this comment in your accent!

[@PeterKotsa]

@@IDKline good to hear from you brother 💪

[@fredstahl2823]

Peter good to see you on another review site! I love your work Brother.

[@BLR653]

I’ve owned my 124270 for 3 years and wear it 95% of the time. You are the first reviewer to rightly nail he pre 14270 true vintage feeling of this watch. Well done. You hit the nail on the head. That is what drew me into the watch. It also disappears on wrist and the comfort is second to none. My Submariner feels like a clunky, clumsy watch n comparison!

[@ID-Guy]

It’s a fascinating thing, really blew my mind seeing how rounded the lugs were (and how old-school it felt) And you’re right… something about that care of the details, neatness to the case, it’s such a refined feel 🥃

[@nads7865]

The 12 series Sub is extremely uncomfortable IMO. I have a GMT right now and it wears so well in comparision. I bet the exp 1 36 would be an even better wrist wearing experience.

[@BLR653]

@@nads7865 I have the 36mm Explorer 1 / the GMT Master 2 on jubilee and the Sub. The Explorer is the KING of comfort. GMT is next w Jubilee and Sub is the worst.

[@trancentralklf]

Do you lot want lube to have your purchases validated by one another?

[@joeschlicht]

@@nads7865 I recently tried on the 12 series sub and it was comically large. What is Rolex thinking??

[@authorjohnwquinn]

Like you, I own one Rolex - an Explorer reference 114270. I purchased it last year to commemorate my 25th year of sobriety. I love it for all the reasons that you love yours. I wear it most everyday - and nobody knows that it's a Rolex. This is my "one and done" piece. Cheers!

[@beetlefang]

Congrats to your sobriety - you deserve your Rolex and a long healthy life.

[@authorjohnwquinn]

@@beetlefang Thank you so much!

[@freegibran]

Continue to wear it in good health.

[@authorjohnwquinn]

@@freegibran Thank you!

[@BarkandJack]

Congrats on your Explorer, but really sorry for your loss. I agree about the Explorer being an “end watch”. I’ve always struggled to find a watch that’s “better” than my Explorer.

[@dominicrusho]

Glad you are enjoying your Explorer so much! I too recently purchased an Explorer for my milestone birthday - albeit the 40mm 224270. Both are tremendous watches and I think offering two distinct sizes is a smart move on Rolex’s part. Somehow I feel the 224270 doesn’t get enough credit; it’s finally an upsized Explorer done ‘right’ and fixes many of the quirky proportions of the 39mm whilst preserving the overall silhouette. Long live the Explorer…I wish you many years of good health and enjoyment with yours! 🍻

[@ID-Guy]

It's those two lines at the base, oh so clean 🔥 I'm actually tempted to look at the 40mm now just to see if I wasn't crazy to put the 39mm down so quickly haha! Thank you for sharing as always brother. It's been such a good experience going full circle and learning to see this watch for what it is 🥃

[@mkii2363]

224270 does not get credit because whichever “imperfections" 39 may had (still can’t find ‘em since 2020), 40 made them worse. It became thicker, more “negative space”, and “Explorer” moved from 6 to 12, adding to the dissymmetry of the dial. P.S. Read Monochrome article "Hands-on: Some Thoughts About The New Rolex Explorer 40 Reference 224270"

[@cantcatchm3m5]

I also got a 224270 to celebrate my birthday. The imperfections are relative to what you are comparing it to. In my collection, it fits neatly in the GADA spot compared to a Panerai, 2 tone Datejust and 5 digit Kermit.

[@frankv7068]

@@cantcatchm3m5 the 40mm is perfect👌🏽, don’t listen to smaller men lol they have a lot of anger in their tiny hearts 🤣

[@Not_Mark_Twain]

Nice work. My 214270 MK2 is the last watch I would ever sell. For me, 39mm wears better than 36. I travel with this watch, swim with it, and go out with it. It does not scream Rolex, and only watch people spot it. Great watch for all the reasons you describe and then some. Bought mine used at slightly over retail thanks to a cheap Yen.

[@rhystudordavies]

Getting the 39mm or 40mm over the 36mm is a missed opportunity. The 36mm feels just right, so light and comfortable, perfect for every occasion.

[@Milofchg]

I waited for over 15 years to finally get an Explorer. In the 90’s they were difficult to get plus expensive for me as a man in his 20’s. Fast forward into my late 40’s and somewhat settled into a good life. I got the call once this watch was released. First purchase from my AD, not history or much of a relationship. Sure I could have bought the old 36mm but I wanted one of my own, for this Rolex. I wanted to settle for the 39mm but with the pandemic and Rolex shortage I never got the call for the 39mm. Thankfully I was first on my AD’s list when this came out. As soon as it debuted I ran to my AD the next morning. It arrived before my 50’s birthday. Ever since it really kills the need for another Rolex. It’s a true one and done, and I have a hard time between the Sppedy and Explorer. I’m so great full and blessed.

[@rickjason215]

Good for you. One is enough. It is basically the same movement they put in most of their watches. It is plenty water resistant. There is no point in spending $10,000 or more for another model. My brother bought me an OP, which I wore for 10 years. It still keeps great time, though I rarely wear it.

[@juniorjohnson5961]

I lost my Mother 11 months ago I've had a rough time ever since , my condolences with your Dad's passing 🙏 God bless my friend.

[@ID-Guy]

I'm so sorry Junior. It is unbearable... my dad always used to say to me "nobody, maybe not even you, will ever love you more than your mother" - no truer words were ever said ❤ Lots of love to you and your family.

[@charlesthehammer4097]

I’m very sorry for your loss. It’s difficult to get through. I pray that you gain strength with each passing day.

[@jhrodriguez08]

I own one, I wish the bracelet was the same as the OP36 size wise it would make it look less girly 😂

[@ID-Guy]

It's a verrrry severe taper 😆🥃

[@mikeuk4130]

I fell in love with the Explorer 1 when I first saw a fine used example in the window of a Bond Street jeweller. I couldn’t afford it then, and instead bought a new 30th Anniversary Speedmaster Pro, which I still love. Whilst I still hanker after the Explorer, I think they have grown more and more glitzy with every iteration, and that’s just not me. The other Rolex I’ve always loved is the early Pepsi GMT Master, but feel that has suffered the same fate, particularly in recent years, becoming way too chunky, unsubtle and obvious. Today, I’m wearing my Omega Apollo 8 DSotM Speedy in memory of the late Bill Anders.

[@ID-Guy]

Agree that so many of these modern pieces have become more and more flashy. It saddens me how glossy the Rolex ceramic bezels are (considering how brilliant the Pelagos manages to address it) Blows me away that Bill was born in 1933... imagine seeing the world over the last 90 years? Incredible 🥃

[@jonebm]

I'm 31, I've been in the watch game for some five years, and I got my 124270 around a year ago. I'm a sucker for details and quite adventurous when it comes to trying new styles. I'd say I've flipped around 50 watches, give or take a dozen. The 124270 is the only watch - ever - that I've described as perfect. To me, it's pure perfection. It's Rolex going 100 % for making a perfectly proportioned, robustly built, and yet quite subtle watch. It does it all, besides screaming "look at me, I'm a Rolex". It's quality and craftmanship in a classy and mature way. I hope, and honestly believe, that I will keep this one with me for as long as I breathe.

[@ianforber]

I bought a 124270 Explorer about 6 months ago from my AD after a 6 month wait. It’s my only Rolex and I don’t feel the need to own another. I wanted the watch because of how it looked and I wasn’t even aware of the Everest connection until I went into my AD to try on the 36mm and 40mm versions to see which suited me best. I have 3 other watches, all Omega and all in the 38-39.5mm size. The Explorer does feel small when I initially put it on but after a while it makes the other watches look large on my 6.2” wrist. I could quite happily sell my other watches and only have the Explorer for the rest of my life. I’m not going to, but I could!

[@bill8406]

I waited 1.5 years from rolex AD - DAFC in Vietnam... 1.5 years.. this is how they controlled the distribution. I doubt is high demand in Vietnam.

[@shadowsocks7472]

You're 100% on this, it is the closest Rolex will ever come to a reissue. Slightly less than 36mm, a more tapered bracelet, all making it hollow link light. This is as much a call back as we will ever get.

[@andrpers14]

I’m actually pro 114270 for its 20mm bracelet. Daily wearer, but i bring out uncle 1016 from time to time 😉

[@ID-Guy]

Uncle 1016, brilliant 😉 And good point about the 114270, makes for the great strap changes that these newer references aim to squash haha!

[@conorbuckley2214]

I have been very tempted by the Explorer, but my experience with a few AD's put me off. I have the 41mmm green dial OP which meet the Rolex itch. To meet the design need I've just ordered a Sinn 556 A.

[@markikn3183]

Really enjoyed this episode, IDG. The same type of deep satisfaction you had when presenting your amazing Zenith piece to the world. My life circumstances mean a Rolex isnt in my near-term future (3 month old and a 2 year old to cater for), but you got me staring at my own watchbox and thinking about the good times i get from that piece, and that piece, and that piece. None of mine are North of $2k, but that doesnt matter and i don't feel the need for a Rolex or a 10k watch (yet 😅), but loved seeing the love you shared for yours. And your comment about your dad and how his memory fits into the equation. A pleasure and an honour to view this one, sir.

[@ID-Guy]

Thank you Mark. Truth be told, I'm getting all of the enjoyment out of the way now before the toddlers start arriving 😆 I know that day is coming! One of these days you'll reward yourself with something excellent (to mark a milestone) and it'll be all the more worthwhile. Really appreciate this comment man, thank you 🥃

[@Michl2532]

I feel you, I still have mixed feelings about Rolex. I am sneeking around a 36mm 116000 with the blue Explorer dial for years, but could not pull the trigger yet. Do I really want a Rolex? Do I want to be a Rolex guy? Not really, or do I? Maybe next year when I’m turning 50…

[@wonderwatch2239]

Oooo yes! The explorer line is the true Rolex, at least for me 🤗

[@martinkaplan1805]

Love how you combine the art of romance and the science of engineering in your reviews.

[@jasons46]

The 124270 can feel a bit small after wearing a bigger watch, mainly because of the bracelet taper but after a couple of hours it feels perfect. The easy link is very useful. If forced to go down to one watch this would be it. Great in the outdoors, very easy to read, goes well with a suit, rugged, waterproof, good-looking.

[@DanielMealo]

My wife got me a 124270 a little over two years ago for our 20th, and it is probably on my wrist 4/7 days since. I’m not a Rolex fan, but this watch is just about the perfect watch, and more “me” than any other watch. Your comment about the watch you’d wear when you’re 80 resonated with me. I also recently lost my dad, who was into watches but very much not into Rolex. I also appreciated how you touched on the geometry of how the hands intersect with points on the watch as they go around. They do that with the novella of text on the dial, too, and it even makes that charming. I have had mine in 1x to correct the amplitude accuracy issue that affects some of these movements. It has been rock solid since. I purchased and had it serviced through the local AD, part of WoS group. That has not been a great experience, but also I’m fine with this being my only Rolex, so I don’t care to have a deep and meaningful personal relationship with a reseller of goods. Excellent channel, and excellent video.

[@rickfowler3710]

The magic of the explorer dial is when you angle it to a bright reflection like a computer screen or a window and all the white gold elements catch the light. How something can be so elegant and not feel overly feminine is the magic

[@ID-Guy]

Fascinates me. I had a section of the video I cut about the “characterful numerals” that seem to change on the face depending on the angle they’re viewed at. It is a piece of magic, no doubt 😉🥃

[@AlexG-ey7md]

Totally agree, light bouncing off the white gold numerals is very satisfying. It's the little things about this watch like the quality of the polishing on the side of the links and the sides of the case. It seems boring but every time you put it back in after rotating, the love comes right back.

[@taylorj9589]

What is your wrist size? Like you, I moved my 214270 along as the proportions never really sat right with me. I remember trying a 36mm on years ago and thought it was too small but I am starting to get the Explorer itch again and know I won’t like the 40.

[@charlesthehammer4097]

Sorry about the passing of your father.

[@brad10000]

I own almost 100 watches (including over 10 Rolexes). And I’ve owned the 36mm 124270 (great but a bit too small for my wrist) but the new 40mm😊 224270 is horological perfection. It is my most versatile watch - wear it to the gym, the office - everywhere. The taper in the Oyster bracelet is just right, but I normally wear it on a NATO or a black sailcloth band. (Yes, the. 17mm width makes getting good straps a bit trickier but any wider or narrower would ruin the proportions.) After decades of evolution, the 224270 is design perfection.

[@MonkeyChocolate]

This is the perfect one watch for me. Would love to get it one day, although I already have Sub No Date 41 for the last 3 years as daily.

[@epbrown01]

I used to own a black on black BMW E46 3-series 5-speed with sport package. It wasn’t anything amazing - just an excellent execution of a 4-door sedan in terms of comfort, performance, features, and quality. I liked it more than the E90 I replaced it with, or the X3 I’ve got now. My Explorer reminds me of that car - a well-made item that does things better than a run-of-the-mill counterpart.

[@jeanlouisdubillon4212]

Best ever Rolex …. I got it since 6 month….. m’y graal watch ….

[@Robert-vw3od]

This is a Rolex watch which is worth having. You don’t need gold you don’t need diamonds , it doesn’t have to appear on the wrist of some moron who plays football or works in the financial district of London. This is a proper Rolex watch, like the watches I saw on the wrists of men when I was a child. I own a Tudor ranger and the only other field watch I would have above that is the Rolex Explorer.

[@jsytac]

As ever, a beautiful video but 🙄 the Explorer is NOT the Everest watch. That was the Smiths A454. There is a wonderful thread on this that I would love to send you but I cannot post links in comments. Get in touch and I’ll send you a copy.

[@ID-Guy]

Agreed, Smiths reached the peak (and was on their wrists) There's a theory that Hilary was wearing one watch on each wrist when he summited buuut it seems like a stretch 😉

[@lesguersten7252]

214270 owner - gifted it. It's class. Understated & yet total presence. Nothing pretentious, great backstory what more could you want. Aiming for that 1016 one day, got the nice Everest tribute as a starter for 10 before summiting that mountain...

[@flutterstone1281]

Sorry to hear about your dad. I lost mine in 2017. Someone said to me, “he will seem closer to you now than he ever did before.” I knew immediately what the person meant, though the closeness made his absence harder, because it was an intimacy that I couldn’t share with him in a way that was completely satisfying. I love the Explorer, but I could never own one, because I’ve come to the realization that I absolutely require a date window. I don’t even like the look of date windows, but when I wear a watch without the date, I drive myself crazy looking to see what the date is.

[@JoeyJiggles]

Sorry to hear about your father. I do agree 100% on the date window thing. My favorite watch of all time is my BLNR but what I wear the most after work is my Tudor Maroon Bezel Smiley Dial. It has no date, but I can tell you there is something calming about no date sometimes, when you just need to worry about the time. Enjoy your day!

[@waltman36]

How very philosophical, yet personal and authentic! I don't own a Rolex and concerning finances I never will. But I loved listening to you and I think I understand you and your notion of mysticism. Thanks!

[@JoeyJiggles]

Every time you talk about your Dad, I feel it in my heart.

[@greghassen4726]

I’ve owned my 36 inch Rolex explorer for over 30 years. I beat the heck out of it at one point I chipped the crystal and it got pretty scratched up. I never serviced it for 30 years and it started losing time finally so I took it to a watchmaker and they replaced the crystal and cleaned it up. It’s the greatest watch ever, although I did get a Submariner in the meantime and I love that too. The 36 inch is the way to go. The 39 to me looks bizarro and there’s even a 40 out there which is even more insane! If you want to get a 40 inch time only Rolex get the OP. Thanks for all the great videos. Keep them coming. Cheers!

[@palmeadia]

big watches

[@SoCalWatchReviews]

Great video brother 👏

[@MikaelTorseth]

Great video! I've had my 124270 for a little over a year, and I love it for many of the same reasons as you mentioned. It's so understated. Rarely does someone recognize it, and when it happens it's always an enthusiast.

[@daisuke4890]

Nice video. But did you try the previous generation Ex1, the 114270? I prefer it, the dial is less in your face with slightly smaller 3, 6 and 9 numerals, and 20mm lug width is more balanced and convenient for strap changes. Do you want to borrow mine to do a comparison review?

[@drkesrf]

Cant be a GADA without a date IMO.

[@AnotherDaveInParadise]

My Explorer story starts with a Submariner in 2015. I really loved the 39mm Explorer, but having the small handset I bought the Sub and moved on. Then they released the 39mm Mk2 which I didn’t have the funds to buy. Fast forward to 2021 and the 36mm. Yes, I’m in, but after trying one thought it was too small (despite owning a 36mm DateJust). When the 40 was released I was convinced this would be perfect. However, on trying it on there was just something about the size I couldn’t get on with. I then started thinking about the 36 again, and watching a few videos on here confirmed it. Instead of saying it could wear bigger, etc., it was about embracing a small watch. Classic size, deal with it. Tried it on again and was 100% sure. In October I was in Harrods (where I purchased my Sub 8 years before), asked about it and left my details. 6 days later I got the call. It’s 100% a keeper and I love the size and wearability, even on my 7.25” wrist. It could easily be my only watch, but where would the fun be in that. 🙂

[@threethrushes]

The Rolex does nothing for me, but I could watch you all day talking with enthusiasm about the watch from a gifted story-teller and one of the few likeable 'personalities' in the YT watch space.

[@ID-Guy]

Can't tell you how much this comment means to me man... thank you. I'm also working on another channel (behind the scenes) where I one day plan on covering everything *but watches, so history, design and all the rest ;) Comments like these give me that boost to commit 🥃

[@rickjason215]

I don't get it either. He feels it is the most beautiful watch in the world and I see a plain very basic watch. I like having a date, because I never know it. Rolex has done an amazing job of making people believe they are getting something special and amazing. It is just a good machine made watch, nothing more.

[@9er..]

HERE HERE!!!💪💪💪. Can’t stand the Explorer but I’m here because this is my absolute favorite watch channel. Timeless has nothing on ID Guy👊 Think about that Patron you have. I was there for a minute but there wasn’t an incentive. I’d happily help support your content.

[@micheleparadiso6664]

I got the 224270 40mm last week. I was waiting for a Submariner but an Explorer came before and I choose it. It's simply perfect with is minimalism! I'm very happy of this change. The 40mm size is modern and perfect for me (190 cm tall, 90 kg and 17 cm wrist, sorry for the purist but the 36mm on me looks like a lady size...).

[@Joe-xo3xy]

The predecessor of the Modern Explorers (39 and later 36) is the one to get in my opinion; The modern 39mm, while it seems modest in size, it just has this brashness and flashiness, especially with the state of the art technology used in the hardware, it misses that romantic look that the 1016 has. It is modern enough especially with the font, it just works.

[@Weedandwatches]

A distraction from the real world!!!! That’s is exactly what I experience… Love your Chanel!!! Alittle Zepplin coffee Distraction complete

[@ID-Guy]

What a story! Funny, in 2015 I walked into the Harrods boutique (on a Tuesday) and had the full selection to choose from... but of course, I was a Student and had zip to my name... still fondly remember having everything from Subs, GMT's, Exp2's handed to me and available for purchase... and the scratch front! Mine came pre-scratched on the clasp which actually took the sting out of it 😉 I'd reccomend getting one mark on it and just carrying on from there, it's always the first mark that hurts most hahaha!

[@rhgrabowski3855]

If I may, I will share my 124270 story. BLUF, I don't own one even though I consider it waht represents to me as the PERFECT field watch. In November 2022, I put my name on the list for a 124270 at a local AD that I frequent. In May 2023, Charlie calls me saying he has an Explorer for me. However, it it the 224270 40mm. I turn him down and affirm my interest in the 124270. In June 2023 Charlie calls me again and says he has the 36mm Explorer for me. Damned on all things, I really wanted the watch but it just wasn't the right time for me. I passed on what I figured would be my one and done penultimate field watch. As you know though, my watch journey continued. I continued seeking the one watch that would speak to my tool watch desire, as in many respects I had given up on Rolex. December 2023, after a one-month old request through the same AD, the Tudor Pelagos 39 arrived for me. All green lights were a go, and the P39 has adorned my wrist daily ever since. Do I still pine for a 124270? Yes!

[@ID-Guy]

That Pelagos 39 has really stepped in and done it all 😉 Thank you for sharing this sir! Ironic how timing factors into this hobby of ours, right? I've had more than one situation where the timing was off (and missed great opportunities too) Never say never though! An Explorer may be on the cards when you least expect it ;) 🥃

[@rhgrabowski3855]

@@ID-Guy Thank you for uplifting reply.

[@Robert-vw3od]

The talk about Mount Everest is something I find to be spin and advertising, 🎉 not the only watch to go up the first time and if the truth be told we don’t even know if it was the first watch to reach the top of Everest. countless Casio G-Shock’s have been to the top of Everest. when it comes to mountaineering and watches Vulcain must take the gold medal.

[@LRSTGS]

It wasn't. Categorically not. Hillary stated so in a British newspaper and Rolex published a letter acknowledging so. Lazy journalism because the information readily available.

[@srenjrgensen4512]

Rolex never went to the top. Hillary was wearing a Smith watch. It’s all a pr scam

[@karlschwenk8583]

I thoroughly enjoy your videos and 99% of the replies. You are adept at articulating thoughts/ideas regarding these watches, that make sense after hearing them, if that makes sense….

[@tennistron588]

Love this watch but I've found the perfect 36mm for me. The midsize Swordhands Seamaster from mid 2000's. Specifically the 2236.50.... it has got rid of my explorer 36mm scratch!

[@MasterSam85]

Thanks for sharing your experience, I feel the same in many ways : a "reset" watch, the perfect "one Rolex" watch to own. That was my reasoning at least..."If I could ever only buy/wear ONE Rolex model, which one would it be ?" After waiting over a year for not getting this 124270 (guess the AD never really took my request), I bought a used 114270, and actually now prefers it: slightly lighter, no engraved rehaut, the good ol' classic stamped clasp...The lacquered ink dial is a masterpiece. The only drawback, for a one-and-only watch, is the weak/lack of lume. This is where the new 124270 shines (pun intended).

[@johndudeman365]

After 1.5 years on near daily wear, I’ve come to appreciate the Exp1 124270’s bracelet as the best feature of the watch. Yes, It’s smaller than previous generations. But, 1mm of difference is completely invisible to anyone but the most discernible wearer. That slight decrease in size somehow translates to a monumental increase in comfort. I dont know how or why it feels better, but it just does. For me, comfort is more important to me than appearing 1mm larger.

[@ID-Guy]

I’m in the same camp, don’t get me wrong, I enjoy a wider bracelet on a dive watch (for substance) but on my watches with leather straps, the more extreme the taper, the better 🔥 same with the Explorer. Dresses it down, makes it less noticeable and all the rest 🥃

[@mattisoncrowe79]

I remember watching your video of the 39mm not long before I got the 124270. It was not my first Rolex, that would be the 126710. But your description of the Explorer’s lessons in restraint hit home for me. I took a cross country trip last year to relocate, and this little watch was the one I brought for the month. Subtle, understated. Deceptively rugged, yet can span a wide range of events and places. I thought the19mm lug width would keep me from removing the bracelet, but it is as much of a strap monster as my speedy. I’m glad your brought you much joy after a tumultuous year.

[@Conversus]

I was looking at the Explorer for a long time and eventually decided for a Datejust 36 (mint green). It suits my lifestyle much better than a field watch or a dive watch. Just be honest with yourself and who you really are and you’ll find your watch.

[@ID-Guy]

I've been looking (casually) at a white dial Datejust w/jubilee as that polar opposite to the Explorer and its fascinating... Agree 100% that the right model will find you eventually if you stay true with who you are. Excellent point AND I hope you're getting tonnes of enjoyment from your Mint Green DJ 🥃

[@theammar]

imho, the main 'test' you can apply to yourself whether you should get an explorer or not is that if the explorer isn't made by rolex but some unknown independent, or if rolex doesn't command the 'brand equity' that it does, would you still want it. my guess is a lot of people will just say "it's just a boring little watch. why would i pay that much for it"

[@xcellenceJavea]

The Explorer was the watch that got me into watches Im luck enough to have owned a quite a few Rolex, but as I got more into watches I sold all my Rolex to help send me down the rabbit hole which is VC but I kept my Explorer 114270 it’s difficult to explain why I will never let it go. As you say there is something mythical, mysterious about her, she’s the first love, the one that never dies. Again a great video 👏 Keep up the great work

[@gafakyusef6201]

My good sir, the Rolex is the steak, not the condiment.

[@ID-Guy]

Oh so brilliant 😆 When going off script doesn't work out haha!

[@maynardjoseph]

congratulations, now go forth and scale Mountains.

[@danielkatz7516]

Very authentic , real in delivery , I lost my dad 1.5 years ago

[@fieldwalker]

Dad was a 1016 guy, so I too have always wanted a modern Explorer. (Even if it was never 'the Everest watch' - That's some Rolex mythmaking at it's best) . Been turned off the brand by rude Rolex ADs that won't deign let me wait for one... so now perpetually if I actually want one, or shouldn't bother. I don't want gray - so can't bring myself to grovel anymore to get one. So great watch - horrid company - difficult to separate!

[@nicholaschavez6245]

I’d love for the 124270 to be my one and done. The only thing holding me back is the 32xx. However, videos like this are making it less and less of an issue. Great job 🥃

[@UltraDoug]

Excellent summation as per usual. I have yet to purchase my first Rolex, but the 224270 Explorer 40 is on deck as a celebration of 30 years of marriage come next April. Of course, that may end it, but what a way to go. 😂 The 40 is the size I’ve been waiting for and then they did it, so that’ll be my first and only Rolex. - The set looks great, white shirt?….meh. 😊 Cheers~

[@997steve]

I have a 214270 and a 1816 speedmaster. I agree with you that having the explorer has quenched my thirst for wanting another rolex. I think the explorer is the definitive rolex and am looking at iwc big pilot 43 for my next watch, i love Arabic numerals and any watch without a date.

[@ID-Guy]

"May end the 30 years" 😆 Brilliant! Talk about ending the milestone with a bang! I reckon you'll enjoy the 40 so much Doug. These new generation Exp's... ah, they've worked their magic. Thank you for sharing this as always sir! 🥃

[@GoTerpsGoBlue]

Explorer 36 is the only Rolex I would own. All Steak and no unnecessary Sizzle

[@Julian_O91]

One of the best watches ever! What do you think about the bicolor variant?

[@ID-Guy]

After experiencing this variant, the 124273 seems like such a great option. Thinking how that gold will age (and go matte over time) is so cool. Also considering it's the first "gilt dial" since the early 1016's of the 60's. Crazy, right? 🥃

[@lv293]

I’m planning on buying a 1016 birth year watch. Option A: full set, pumpkin dial & hands, unpolished OR Option B: full set, Tiffany stamped, unpolished Which one would you lean more towards?

[@ID-Guy]

Oh, this is a tough one… I’m probably the worst to ask (because the Tiffany branding has never been for me) Also, likely more dicey that it could be a counterfeit - folks will do anything to milk buyers with vintage. I’d say go pumpkin patina 😉 But that’s just my preference, as always, condition comes first! 🥃

[@mrt2760]

Love my 40mm Explorer, a true GADA watch

[@ID-Guy]

So glad to read that the 224270 gets a lot of love too. They really nailed the text placement on the dial (something about 2-lines at the bottom, just exquisite) 🥃

[@mrt2760]

@@ID-Guy The Explorer really grew on me the last couple of years so picked one up when the 40mm was released, it’s super comfortable too, I’ve started to come away from chunky watches so this is perfection.

[@dingodave3966]

Dear Mr IDGuy, Many trials and tribulations we endure. Life… If you can enjoy what you have and be happy, then you’re a winner.

[@nhbmk]

124270 is king, one of my favourite watches that I own, up there with my mark 20

[@mkii2363]

A black t-shirt looks cooler on you. My 214270 helped me "find a path" to 226570 and complete the Explorers Club, of which you are now a member. Explorers are unlike anything out there - the smartest choice one can make.

[@ColinLack]

If I were getting a Rolex Explorer I’d go for the 36mm 2 tone. That’s one of the few Rolexes i like

[@ID-Guy]

That 124273 is very compelling. I just realised the other day, the last "gilt dial" Explorer since the early 1016's 🔥

[@SimonKinsella]

I'm struck by your observation which exactly matched the question I asked myself, approaching 50: "Which watch could I see myself still wearing age 80?". Only one comes to mind - the Explorer. In the end, despite having put the funds aside, I didn't get one (or anything) for my 50th, deciding that I'd prefer to wait until the stars feel more aligned. But the day will come.

[@dannysimenauer5745]

At 12:22 when ID Guy says I don’t need another Rolex, I overheard Rolex CEO Dufour calling his head of marketing into an emergency meeting this weekend to work on the ID Guy to buy his next Rolex!

[@umist123]

Less is more...after having owned a number of dfiferent watches, I wanted to settle down with just a simple watch... a mindset that is similar to folks wanting to move from the city to countryside....Happy to retire with my one and only 36m Explorer.....in the countryside...

[@ID-Guy]

In a world that seems hellbent to push more and more features and complexities, going down that simpler road is something great to aim for 😉 Well said brother!

[@dmt191105]

Great video. The Explorer is my exit watch the 124270 36mm. I thought about the 114270 because you can find it cheaper, but i believe I would not be happy with anything but the new 36mm. I have my grail Rolex which is the 114300 Rhodium dial, I remember seeing it on the WatchTime cover in 2015. I have a 2019 model and had thought about trading it towards an Explorer but I want both. I believe that duo would be the quintessential Rolex collection. I’ve always wanted a 114060M 2009 or 2010 but I refuse to pay what is asked for it. Thank you for how you expressed what the Explorer means, I couldn’t agree more with it. Yes it is the one watch I want to wear when I’m 60, 70, 80.

[@frankv7068]

That watch wears perfect on you, unfortunately not me, also nice narration.

[@ID-Guy]

Thank you Frank, really appreciate it man 🥃

[@latinballa88]

Watching this whilst wearing my BB36 smiley dial. Nearly identical dimensions. Love my explorer 36. Love my smiley BB36

[@AFK-47x]

When I sold my Explorer, I got physically ill over it. When the new buyer said it wasn't right for him, I instantly bought it back.

[@wristopia4101]

Great video as always. I recently picked up an Explorer 40. Weirdly I got an email, not a call! It was still pretty good though haha. I was a little bit reluctant for the piece, and nearly passed on it, but it very quickly became my best friend and a genuine daily (not something I have done with a Rolex for decades). It measures 38.5mm though. Is the 36 actually 36mm?

[@MA89.]

Great stuff. Love my 39mm, as you say can sometimes be seen as dull/boring but that’s why it’s so special

[@jamesgreig8796]

A great watch, perfect size 36mm. Simplicity, perfectly executed. Certainly my choice when it comes to size. I believe the Smiths was the first to top Mt. Everest. I always look forward to your videos. Thanks

[@JLUnit416]

My 124270 will be celebrating its first anniversary in August. It's become my "dumb reach"; when in doubt, Explorer. I tried to get one in 2022, but wasn't that serious and had my heart set on a 3861 Speedmaster anyways, which ended up being my significant purchase that year. I tried again last year, same AD, different sales associate. The experience was part job interview, part watch nerds, nerding out about watches. They had the two tone on display, which I handled and tried on, but the sale associate also let me handle his own personal 124270 that day, something I really appreciated. I "got the call" (an email) three weeks later. If there's anything I "dislike" about it, it's that I basically have to force myself to wear other timepieces.

[@cjsolarmusic]

I wanted to love this watch but ultimately felt too small on my 7.25 wrist… maybe I’ll try the 90’s one with larger lugs and see if that changes the wear for me 😢

[@harveytan7506]

Adrian Barker says you're eloquent. He's absolutely right.

[@BAF605]

Any Explorer in any size is a great watch. I'd go as far as to say any Rolex is a good addition to any collection. I'm just into double figures and have never regretted buying any of them. My Explorer is the 39mm and it was my second Rolex buy. After the madness Rolex watches are available again which is a good thing, but even if you find your AD won't play all but a select few are available grey at retail +/- 10%.

[@kahuhipajae4088]

Great review as always, I too have been debating on this exact model. Also to have the pleasure of passing it down to my son. I think its a perfect honest watch.

[@gassanmaiki]

the perfect watch is the one you can afford ⌚️

[@ID-Guy]

Absolutely, and that's one great thing that the years have taught me, not to get caught up in the illusion of owning a certain watch but seeing that it's just one of many, many terrific pieces out there 🥃

[@andym5073]

Lovely video and back story to finally buying this. I remember your dissatisfaction with the 39 mm version. Congrats on what is a lovely watch. I had the option of this and an OP36; went with the latter for a number of subjective design reasons. Let's hope neither of us falls victim to the dreaded 32## loss of amplitude after a few years 🤞 Enjoy the piece chief 🙌

[@ID-Guy]

We can only hope that they’ve sorted out the quirks with the movement a few years on 😉 And thank you Andy, it’s been a wild time finally deciding. Have a great weekend! 🥃

[@Ryan-pu9yw]

As a watch nerd and a gun nut, I like to compare guns to watches. I think the Explorer is the equivalent of the Smith and Wesson Model 19. It's not fancy but a perfect balance of firepower, aesthetics, size, and utility.

[@ID-Guy]

Great comparison! I never thought it to be compared to a S&W 19 (also never knew it was a .357) Helluva punch 😉 Really interesting thought comparing watches to guns 🥃

[@harleynarwhal]

It all too often goes unsaid in the size debate, 36 vs. 39 (or 40mm in this case). What it really comes down to is how big your wrists are. The 36 looks proportional to the vast majority of the population but for those with wrists measuring >7", it just looks wrong.

[@masanobuyamamoto6395]

Congrats man! The explorer is the ultimate everyday watch imo. And the true Bond watch (according to the novels anw). Two months ago I bought my first luxury watch the Blancpain FF 45mm stainless steel preowned. I bought it after buying Blancpain and Swatch collab Ocean of Storms. This year is my last 20s and what’s better than buying a real FF for my 29th birthday. I will continue to buy few luxury watches for my collection on special occasions, the Rolex explorer definitely is on my list

[@ID-Guy]

A BP FF as a first watch is incredible. I think if I was to start again (and not have a channel that requires me to cover such a wide selection of pieces) to pick up a FF would be something else. Wow 🔥And great point about adding pieces around special occasions, when they have that added meaning behind them, so much better 🥃

[@esbee1177]

Like the watch. What I don‘t get, is why a Pilot‘s Watch (Air King) needs crownguards and the Field-Mountaineer-Watch doesn‘t. I find this a flaw in consistency. But maybe, that‘s just me.

[@y3n0]

I have a 14270 and I do like it. However, for some reason, I realize that the applied indices are not for me. The 1016 would be what I want--but i cannot justify the current market pricing. For kicks, I tried out a Smiths PRS-25 and I prefer it over the Explorer! That said, i've been thinking of unloading the Explorer for a polar white 16570 :p

[@m.arriott]

Brilliant video as always. I got the 124270 36mm allocated just before my wedding last year. It is the perfect watch in my opinion

[@ID-Guy]

What an incredible wedding watch… sheesh… Rolex really smashed it out of the park with the 124270, striking that ideal balance that a lot of other pieces maybe don’t hit as squarely 😉🥃

[@pixelmonkey912]

How big is your wrist? I tried the 40mm explorer and it's too big, the 36mm feels too small. I own a black bay 58 and that's perfect. Great video by the way

[@deskdiver]

One thing is certain, Rolex and humble rarely fit in the same sentence. However, should I ever own a Rolex, it would undoubtedly be the same model as yours. Thank you for sharing your experience with the watch; for a watch enthusiast, there's nothing more valuable than the honest perspective of an owner.

[@sdm107]

Did you consider the 14270? I am waiting to receive mine, from 1996. I like both but the older dial with the smaller numerals was preferred

[@liottastudiosllcFineArt]

I find it interesting that you don’t mention wrist size in regard to the 36mm Explorer. I purchased my first Rolex well over 40 years ago. And even back then, when people were used to much smaller watches, I felt that 36mm was just too small for my generous 8” wrist. I always loved the 1016 but it just didn’t feel right. And while there is no rule as to what size watch one should wear, I can’t help but feel that the size of one’s wrist plays a big part in choosing what watch to wear. So you can only imagine how thrilled I was when Rolex released the 39mm version. I’ve had mine four years now and it’s become my everyday piece, causing me to leave my 14060m and 16600 (which I love) collecting dust.

[@scollyutube]

Exp 1 not for me, but that Omega is fantastic!

[@ID-Guy]

I’ll always be that Omega diehard until the end 😉

[@paulbonaventura4969]

So I got the call for the 40mm Explorer I… and I declined. I thought it was ok when I tried it on and later it was meh… still on the no date sub list thought

[@ID-Guy]

I'm sorry it didn't live up to the hype Paul, but I get what you mean. Something I dig about the smaller size is the "compactness" gives it a far more focused feel on the wrist. But the Sub is a Sub, can't fight THE icon 😉