Identity V Lore Game 3A : A Beautiful Mind

[@sunshines4898]

Game 3A is my favorite, the fact that there was no ‘hunter’ at all. Everyone in that game is so similar yet so different

[@SilminaIDV]

They somehow suffer from a form of mental illness due to their twisted past. Kinda sad if you think about it

[@gloriapascua1044]

I just love seeing lore videos about this game. Idv lore is so complex and beautiful and it gives me sherlock holmes vibes

[@SilminaIDV]

Lol fr, the stories are shattered everywhere. I wouldn't be able to crack it without any help from the experts

[@Jade-kp6cg]

One small correction-Aesop is autistic. He also has a strong cognitive bias. They coexist! The cognitive bias is a result of his isolated childhood and Jerry Carl’s teachings, while the autism is something he was born with. It impacts a lot of things about his character so it’s pretty important. We know he’s autistic because IDV had an official art piece for World Autism Day featuring him and only him. That, along with his deduction mentioning autism, makes him the most confirmed autistic character in the game. There are also theories that Anne is autistic because of her upcoming charity skin. Aesop was also bullied in school, likely for being autistic. His Once skin shows him being called a “freak” by his classmates. His mother is still alive at the time this skin takes place, so he’s always struggled with being accepted by others, even before Jerry Carl’s influence.

[@SilminaIDV]

@@Jade-kp6cg hello, and thanks for the correction. It sure is kinda hard collecting all those lore so, much appreciated for your correction :D Btw do you perhaps know about the details of the Victor story as well? Tried to dig in but what I get is, at best, theories (not to mention that IDV story is kinda hard to crack so yeah)

[@Jade-kp6cg]

@ I think you cracked it pretty well! Victor’s story is scattered across so many things that it’s hard to figure out which parts are connected to what. His S-tier accessory Final Present has this description: “Victor didn't think that this present from his poet friend would be the last testament of their last meeting.” So at some point he had a friend who was a poet, but that person isn’t mentioned anywhere else. It’s theorized that his friend was the policeman who used to own Wick, but it’s not confirmed. He’s also in the 2023 Valentine’s Day event story, but it doesn’t say much lore-wise. It just offers some characterization for him. Anne and Aesop are also in it and they provide a few insights on their childhoods. It’s a great event for seeing these characters outside of the manor game setting.

[@SilminaIDV]

@@Jade-kp6cg ah, that harmonica, the story in the autumn letter mentioned it came from a woman, and it was mentioned as a "gift for a 15 year old", so I was thinking if it came from her mother or another character we don't know yet. Oh well, perhaps we'll see much more when the story unfolds more. Anyway, thanks a lot again for the context regarding Aesop. Since I tried to crack the story of IDV in my video, it sure is nice to meet someone who knows much about it. I still plan to make game 5 and game 0 later on, so yeah, I wish there's more insight like this :D

[@PoeticDream]

Honestly, I believe that Anne was the one who did the most damage in this game since the drug effects on her made her nervous, stressful and panicked most of the time, so I believe she might be the one to get the hunter form from this game, which would be totally awesome since I main her survivor form. And it would kind of apply to the fact that Ganji viewed her behaviour as unusual and threatening and Victor and Aesop also starting to not trust her. So I believe that based on the effects of drugs, they may have viewed her as the bad guy, and it would make sense, since she also has some emotion control problems.

[@SilminaIDV]

@@PoeticDream hmm, Anne's being hunter is indeed an interesting theory. In fact, I planned to cover that story next, so stay tuned :D

[@PoeticDream]

@SilminaIDV Uuuu sounds interesting. Alright!

[@greenbeanpostman]

​@@PoeticDream nah, the ones who did the damage was those who gave them the drugs aka Orpheus and co.

[@FianaMcMenomy]

Game 3A is one of my favorites!! So happy I could watch some sort of video on it. Thanks!!

[@SilminaIDV]

@@FianaMcMenomy glad to know. 3A was kinda dark for me, and yeah, cracking the mystery of it gives me a headache haha XD

[@Someone-zn4dh]

The more I learn about IDV lore, the more I just want to give all of them a hug Even the twisted one like Aesop 😢

[@SilminaIDV]

@@Someone-zn4dh hahaha ikr XD Some of them are pure evil though, like, ahem, Lawyer :')

[@dreamii.krybaby]

@@SilminaIDV true, but lawyer at least trully loved martha (emma’s mom), but someone who is 100% pure evil is definitely richard (knight)

[@MikosTurtle]

Fun fact, My best friend is an Asoep main and i'm obvi a Victor main before their lore even came out. When we found out that they have connections we lost our minds... in a store.... XD

[@SilminaIDV]

@@MikosTurtle lmaoo XD Yeah, both relationships are kinda...unique XD

[@stankycoin3628]

It is also slightly implied that victor and the policeman were friends, as it’s hinted in his harmonica accessories description! (The policeman being the poet friend in this case)

[@SilminaIDV]

Hmm, I'd argue about that though. In the autumn letter event, it's stated that the accessory comes from a woman and is a gift to a 15 year old. My guess is that it's from her mother or from a character we don't know yet, but that's a nice theory though

[@ericstephenneo9904]

so it's lumine voice mode for serious thing, and paimon for sassy, roasting thing LOL

[@SilminaIDV]

Like I said, it'll change again XD

[@Joker3180Z]

22:00 So based on this Every Manor Game has characters that relate to a particular, usually tragic, event that Connects to each Player(Survivor)

[@Joker3180Z]

Also this means the fire Ganji survived is likely the same fire that took out the officer from Victor's Back Story

[@SilminaIDV]

@@Joker3180Z hmm, I wouldn't say particular event. Game 10, game 0, and game 9, for example, have characters that do not connect to a certain theme. As far as I understand, it's almost random. And the fire for both Ganji and Victor, I think both are different, since their stories are different altogether

[@Joker3180Z]

@@SilminaIDV well your the lore expert I'm the noob excited for more of these Videos I like them

[@SilminaIDV]

@@Joker3180Z I'm not that expert haha, but thank you

[@Joker3180Z]

@SilminaIDV in comparison to me you are

[@gardevoirroserade9173]

i just want someone with a tragic backstory to have a happy ending 😭 is there anyone even left alive in lore?

[@SilminaIDV]

Yes. Orpheus is so far the only confirmed alive :)

[@helloimaperson3141]

I relate to my girl anne so much, her backstory breaks my heart honestly

[@SilminaIDV]

@@helloimaperson3141 poor girl forced to become the shadow of her mother

[@hu-ma96]

This lore feels disturbingly beautiful ❤️❤️ And great lore vid as always!

[@SilminaIDV]

Yep, it sure is dark. Also thank you :D

[@Hypnoticxzs]

victor is one of the most unreliable narrators on the game and god hes so interesting, his lore is spread out amongst multiple events and its really relative but it wont stop me from loving him! I love both his "evil interpretation" where he was the one who betrayed the police officer and made the fire and the good one mentioned.. sorry i just love victor

[@SilminaIDV]

@@Hypnoticxzs whoa, I just hear about that evil postman theory. Such an interesting one

[@boothefrogert]

I realized only when watching this video that I play each of them, albeit I play Ganji the least, but postman is my main and my second is Aesop but I play Anne a lot as well

[@SilminaIDV]

Me who rarely plays any of them :')

[@boothefrogert]

@ I had an a badge with my boy Victor so I have to playyy

[@D3N3]

I love hearing about the different types of manor games and groups. Makes me wonder what game Lily (Cheerleader) participated in, (mainly cuz she’s my fave lol) and I hope she survived hers.

[@SilminaIDV]

Hmm, Lily is kinda dark for now since not many clues about her are released. Maybe after we get some more hints that we're able to crack her story

[@D3N3]

@@SilminaIDV here’s to hoping :) ❤️

[@itashiro_furosu]

I have a small feeling that cheerleader and knight are in the same group hahaha

[@SilminaIDV]

@@itashiro_furosu the community that I'm in have different views tho, but 1 thing for certain is that lily, giver her age, cannot possibly be in game 4 or above it

[@Kokokuni611]

When I first saw people saying that It is implied Anne was pregnant and suffered a miscarriage at some point before the Events on the manor, I felt even worse for her backstory and now that the charity skin trailer was released I got so emotional seeing her always surrounded by children and doing her best at understanding the neurodivergent kids and their parents.

[@SilminaIDV]

Her charity skin makes the gap a bit clearer ngl

[@Khez_IDV]

ITS FINALLY HERE!! THANK YOU!! :D

[@SilminaIDV]

Heya, you're welcome :D

[@Go_go_dancerr]

Great video as always!! But it would be nice if you could do your next video of canon manor games on the control group?(Ada, Emil, Ophy, Helena, and Gala)

[@SilminaIDV]

Hmm, I'll see about it. I don't know much about their lore yet, so I'll need time to study them first lol

[@DraculauraTheHeartStealer]

Unfortunately, I think a lot of things connected to game 3 will stay nothing more than speculation and ideas of possibilities for a long time to come, on the upside, sooner or later, game 3 will get focused on in the plot, so sooner or later will probably find out what really went down until then, we just have to patiently wait for it to be it's time to shine, since game 8 is the current focus and we know after that it's game 0 maybe we'll get lucky in the next game to get focused on after game 0, will be game 3 I hope so at least, after all, it's by far my favorite game and I can't wait to see what they do with it

[@SilminaIDV]

Wait, wouldn't it be AoM after game 8? Was it mentioned somewhere that it'd be the control group after the hullabaloo?

[@DraculauraTheHeartStealer]

@SilminaIDV ok, that's what I thought too, so please take this next part with a grain of salt. I don't remember who all I heard say this, but I've heard multiple people say the next game that would be focused on after game 8 would be game 0 I could also be wrong about this, but I'm pretty sure it's been basically confirmed, yet again, though this could all be wrong, it could all be connected to baseless speculation but I have heard a lot of discussions connected too game 0 being the next one, of course I am open to being corrected on any of this or discussions on other possibilities for what could be the next game focused on. ( also, I definitely should have worded my first comment a little bit differently to avoid confusion sorry about that 😅 )

[@SilminaIDV]

@@DraculauraTheHeartStealer well, I don't really mind game 0, but the Q&A somewhere mentioned that the main story will continue in 2025. Main story is AoM since we play the game from Alice PoV. That's why, I kinda curious about the news source mentioning game 0 as the next :D

[@bambiikisses]

You do well in summarizing these games, it's easy for me to follow, we love you silmina (≧∇≦)

[@SilminaIDV]

@@bambiikisses heya, thank you so much ^^ Glad if I can help somehow

[@justhere-uu6mw]

Wow this is dark and pretty sad too love these lore vids tho they are very interesting

[@SilminaIDV]

Well, IDV lore is dark indeed, and some of them are frustrating bc you need to crack everything lol

[@justhere-uu6mw]

@SilminaIDV I really love the historical touches too it gives it more depth and it feels a bit realistic that way

[@Ghostroam]

These story is so sad...just when things were starting to work out the manor just breaks them :(

[@SilminaIDV]

Well, that's the manor for you. The most evil thing in the game

[@purinsann21403]

Sometimes,i felt like. The characters i love could also meant to myself. And Anne represents my severe anxiety, overthinking and desire for freedom. ( I don't have family issues )

[@SilminaIDV]

Hmm, for me, it's Alice :)

[@iheartyeji]

i love how the voice changed accents randomly sometimes😂😂

[@SilminaIDV]

Sometimes indian, sometimes UK, sometimes American :D

[@iheartyeji]

@ yessssss i noticed😂😂😂😂

[@mitchsayshi1993]

Anne is such a cinnamon roll, her trauma is so devastating and heartbreaking..

[@SilminaIDV]

Yep, you can say that :')

[@Joker3180Z]

It's Showtime!

[@TrashArtist89]

I wouldn't say idv lore is complex.. just the details are kept muddy either intentionally or because the writers are lazy to fill the holes 🙄

[@SilminaIDV]

Hahaha that's one way to say it indeed XD

[@basiloids]

ILY SILIMINA I WAS JS TALKING ABT HOW BADBI NEED THIS TO BE COVERED LAST NIGHT

[@SilminaIDV]

Aww thank you, hope you enjoy it ^^

[@AmritIThink_IDV]

Unrelated the word ganji is usually used to refer to a bald woman in hindi😀

[@SilminaIDV]

Wahaha thanks for the info :D

[@saladwithasideof]

this is how i found out anne died?! NOOO

[@SilminaIDV]

As an Anne fan myself, noooo

[@BoyyInterrupted]

PLEASE DO GAME 5 PLEASE I NEED MORE LORE EXPLANATION ON THAT ONE FR

[@SilminaIDV]

I'll need to study it first :D

[@xxshadowstripexx]

Poor Ganji he didn't even do anything😞

[@SilminaIDV]

Yeah, poor guy. In fact, 3A (or 3C by some theorists) consist of survivors with tragic past

[@mitchsayshi1993]

Y'all is the boy in Ganji's lore Fire Investigator.. FIRE IS LITERALLY IN EVERY STORY WAIT

[@SilminaIDV]

Nope, different guy

[@sheteloco4560]

All this time I thought Victor is Mute.

[@SilminaIDV]

It's mentioned he's muted but that's more of a figurative speech

[@shinigamik3027]

Game 3 is the most interesting game in my opinion lol- the excitement I felt when I saw this 😗 Can you do the game painter was in at some point btw? Or maybe just do all the games XD? I’d watch them all…

[@SilminaIDV]

I haven't studied game 5. Maybe after I studied it :D

[@thedustwalker5380]

Waiting for the game manor where andrew is in

[@SilminaIDV]

3B? Hmm, well have to wait for survivor 315 first haha, bc it hasn't been confirmed

[@ur_mom100]

@@SilminaIDV I always had a theory that 3-1-5 was fire investigator 🧏‍♀️ I even made a whole video on it just to convince my friend

[@morningstxrvenus]

The fact people ships Aesop and Victor but lore players knows the truth-😭💀

[@SilminaIDV]

@@morningstxrvenus hahaha, well Aesop really think Victor as his friend though

[@yjjbii-hm3kc]

most people ship them specifically bc of the lore idk what youre on about

[@sleepysmoke7581]

I now ship them

[@Lilo_rexi]

Ty for cover the history of my boyfriend victor 🤗

[@SilminaIDV]

Heya, you're welcome :D

[@Oskar-love7yishar]

My lover gets killed by naib.. 💔BTW I love your vids

[@SilminaIDV]

@@Oskar-love7yishar aww sad :'(

[@Oskar-love7yishar]

@SilminaIDV I still love magician🎩 :)

[@Pluhblush]

@@Oskar-love7yishar naib killed 3 people so who exactly is your lover?

[@Oskar-love7yishar]

@@Pluhblush magician 🎩 :(

[@Joker3180Z]

Wait there's more than numbered games, well shit

[@SilminaIDV]

@@Joker3180Z yeah there's more :D

[@Haruawa00]

Victor 🥹

[@SilminaIDV]

He's so desperate, kinda sad with his backstory and all

[@katiebun4574]

Will the next year's story lore be on game 3? Like how this year it was game 2 hullabaloo and last year game 1?

[@SilminaIDV]

@@katiebun4574 as far as I know, next year would be the continuation of AoM first, and then game 0

[@dawidoksinciuk8766]

NEW VOICE OMG 0:19

[@SilminaIDV]

Wahaha XD

[@itsthosehours]

I was wondering if you can cover game 5?!

[@SilminaIDV]

Vera nair, hmm, I'll need to study it first, especially about the theory of vera ID switch that has been around for some time

[@joeyishere9498]

Actually this is game 3B, 3A should be Andrew Sangria Antonio

[@SilminaIDV]

@@joeyishere9498 as far as I know, it's still debated up to now. I followed the wiki for the numbering

[@joeyishere9498]

@ In the Antonio third letter its said Orpheus need to find new participants for Game 3 , so this is the first game, Wiki wrote wrongly

[@mihaimitel7576]

I think there’s still smt weird abt this game why r there only 4 people instead of the usual 5 players

[@SilminaIDV]

@@mihaimitel7576 3A was never happened. All the participants died before the game ever started. I guess we'll never know what kind of game or who the hunter is in that one game. Also, up until now, some of the IDV lore is pretty hard to crack. There is game 2 with only hunters participating, and game 7 which has never been revealed.

[@mihaimitel7576]

@ sinse hunters r the halucinations of another survivor in most cases it’s safe to assume some if not all the characters in game 2 should getting a survivor side

[@Pluhblush]

So ganji is the only one who survived?

[@SilminaIDV]

@@Pluhblush actually no, he died as well. I use the word subdue but he is actually eliminated by both Aesop and Anne. My bad

[@Pluhblush]

@SilminaIDV Damn my boy ganji can't catch a break 😭

[@flaviogutierrezllanos3330]

So happy the voice changed. Can't stand the other one

[@SilminaIDV]

@@flaviogutierrezllanos3330 I use 2 to 3 types. The kid voice one is used for a sassy video :)

[@jotchuaandfriend1067]

​@@SilminaIDVlol that voice is what I think of "silmina"

[@SilminaIDV]

@@jotchuaandfriend1067 bahahaha XD

[@Restless-being]

What’s the next game you’re planning to cover

[@SilminaIDV]

Maybe 9 since their diaries are complete, idk, I'm not sure yet

[@Aesoup11]

WHAT DO YOU MEAN AESOP DIES 😭😭

[@SilminaIDV]

@@Aesoup11 he died in the end. Well, so many IDV surv dies in the end

[@Aesoup11]

@SilminaIDV HE IS MY FAVORITE ONE 😭

[@MelonGuy001]

Hello remember me i just your old fan when 2020 i Miss that :/

[@SilminaIDV]

@@MelonGuy001 oh hello :)

[@MelonGuy001]

Finally (0_0) ()/\() ()()

[@ОскарИудин]

The voice changed🙁

[@SilminaIDV]

@@ОскарИудин I use this voice when it's a serious theme :D When it's a funny theme, I'll use the child voice XD

[@nsgamesbs2275]

Why is Perfumer in the thumbnail

[@SilminaIDV]

@@nsgamesbs2275 it's Anne :)

[@nsgamesbs2275]

@SilminaIDV oh sorry 😭😭 idk why i though that was Perfumer

[@SilminaIDV]

@@nsgamesbs2275 don't be sorry, we all start somewhere ^^

[@gardenofforgottenminds]

I was wondering how could I not see this video earlier, when I was researching about the games, and then I looked at the time of publishment, lol xd Thank you for collecting information about the games! I'm pretty new in idv and searching for pieces of lore is pretty confusing sometimes

[@SilminaIDV]

Heya, glad I could help. And yes, IDV lore is quite confusing. The stories are like scattered everywhere and sometimes explained implicitly, so it's kinda confusing

[@gardenofforgottenminds]

@@SilminaIDV it also doesn't help that players can receive only one letter (the main source of information) per year, which makes new ones be years away from new info and details if they don't communicate with the fandom! So, yeah, your videos are really handy, I'm definitely looking forward to seeing your next creations

[@SilminaIDV]

@@gardenofforgottenminds thank you! I'll try to make more of it :D

[@jbjb1069]

😢😢😢😊

[@malfeaseance]

not second cause imagine being second 😎💯

[@SilminaIDV]

Nyahaha XD

[@jbjb1069]

Ok

[@nick6503]

First time im this earlyyyy love your videos

[@SilminaIDV]

Heya, thank you ^^

[@gl2outfit_designer]

Aesop did NOT need to do allat for victor man im shipping them i dont care what anyone says

[@SilminaIDV]

@@gl2outfit_designer joscarl shippers would be sad :')

[@gl2outfit_designer]

@SilminaIDV nuh uhs them

[@gelomalikhademo]

Second ig

[@SilminaIDV]

Le hooray :D

[@hello-hc1bl]

Firsttt

[@gelomalikhademo]

@@hello-hc1bl NOOOOOOOO

[@hello-hc1bl]

​@@gelomalikhademo🤣🤣🤣

[@SilminaIDV]

Wohoo :D