If Authenticity Is Not The Secret To BTS Success, What Is?

[@carlasakiestewa7796]

I am 62 years old. I've lived through 70's Rock, Disco, Heavy Metal, and my family's influence of 60's music. I discovered BTS when I felt American music had lost that creative authenticity. I loved Led Zepplin, Fleetwood Mac, Journey, Yes, Genesis. But the band that resonated with me before BTS was Rush. The Canadian three member Rock group. Their drummer, Neil Peart was a Reader and Writer. He wrote with messages that resonated with him through art and readings...like RM. What makes BTS authentic, like Rush, to me, is their ability to pull from their influences and make it their own, True Artists!! They are talented and love their fans. Rush fans are the same. Before Neil Pert passed away, I never missed an album or a concert. Neil Peart was the most progressive drummer I ever heard. Rush and BTS reveal their music making, their humility and humor and their love and respect for their fans. I think this is what makes them authentic.

[@subobing3551]

I agree with you about respecting snd loving the artistry of past artists (I’m 60 as of this month) and it’s been very disappointing the way American music has gone. And BTS just bring me back to the respect I once felt.

[@delasmercedes2940]

Hello, another Rush 🇨🇦fan here! and also joined ARMY at 60+

[@vanessastein1689]

I wish my dad was as open as you are. He's in his 60s and loves 70s and 80s rock and roll, especially Canadian rock (April Wine, Trooper, Harlequin, Streetheart). I think he'd appreciate some of BTS's music and them as performers in general, but he won't give them a chance because they don't play instruments (as a band all together) and their music isn't 100% like the music he usually listens to.

[@v.r.138]

I agree wholeheartedly with my fellow ARMY’s over the age of 50. I’m a proud person of 68 years and have loved music of ALL types and genres since I was a child. I’ve seen artists come and go and have my favorites in Rock, R&B, Jazz, Heavy Metal, Country, etc. I am so glad to be alive to see and hear BTS and to be part of global ARMY! I will be with OT7 for the rest of my days! Sending PURPLE LOVE to all ARMY’s! 💜 Because of BTS I have come to enjoy other K Pop artists such as Mamamoo, Stray Kids, Ateez, Taemin, So!Yoon, TXT, Epik High, Big Bang as well as learning about Korean culture. Music brings us together and the world needs more of this.

[@eileencritchley4630]

@@subobing3551 I've never really been able to gel with 'American' music industry and artists. In fact I've never taken any interest in American artist or groups.

[@SilverSeaOT7]

I am in my early 60s and had honestly given up on music. I was listening to instrumental music. But I was a trained dancer for 10 years in my younger days. So I was searching for dances to watch to relax before bed. First I came across PTD and loved it, but wondered what else they could do with dance. That is when I found Black Swan. I saw these talented young men with bare feet dancing on stage and another one floating in the air and dancing with the grace of a prima ballerina. I felt at home. I also felt the joy and freedom one knows as a dancer. I always say that Black Swan was when I went down to the ocean floor with them and somehow ended up in the BTS rabbit hole. But I wondered if all K-pop groups were like this.But nothing seemed to match BTS. All the BTS members can dance. They dance as one. They have an incredible musicality and dance from the top of their heads to the bottom of their feet. There are so many examples, but I am thinking of the most recent MV SNTY. And then the beautiful short dance Jimin did to Stuck with You. And how can we forget when AgustD himself surprised us with a Haegeum dance. I can can keep sighting things like this about their talent. But it is hard to pin down. Why are they so loved? Jimin has asked that a few times “why us”? It would take much longer to break that down. Their sincerity for sure is part of it. But for now I am happy to say they are like Haley’s Comet that we see approximately every 76 years or once in a generation entertainers. I could sense in the Disney Monuments documentary, that they had feared going too close to the sun. I think, like some comets, they were dangerously close to the sun, but they survived all the hardships and are thriving professionally as a group and as solo artists even while in the military.

[@maryr1905]

Beautifully written and so true.

[@MSy-u3y]

Their artistry is out of this world! So, comparing them to a comet makes perfect sense. What a beautiful metaphor. I often worry about them because of their openness. I’m hoping this hiatus, of sorts, helps recalibrate themselves.

[@jesss757]

This warmed my heart 😊😢

[@marijatambolas216]

my dear lady, I am 68 yo army, from Croatia /Europe/. First time see BTS when JUNG KOOK was singing in Qatar 2022,and the rest is history. Never in my life I do not have such a huge admiration for any artist.BTS is now my every day inspiration. love them all so so much, Thanks to SUGA discover a great sk group THE ROSE ,/sorry for my english/, big hug to you and to all armys around the world from Croatia.

[@bernadettegross808]

I agree with you. I actually found The Rose before BTS and think both groups are amazing. Love their music and the meanings behind the songs. By the way I’m 73 years old. Happy listening. 🥰

[@maryr1905]

I found BTS through Jungkook's World Cup performance also and agree with you - the rest is history. There is something completely captivating about all 7 of them both individually and as a team.

[@nacmegfeegle2310]

Another 70yo who feels the same way about them. Nothing compares.

[@pamelamt8895]

Another older new fan here…completely mesmerized by these young men and their sincerity and dedication to their craft. Agree with another commenter regarding the direction of American music and I find BTS’ music so interesting! Also have found The Rose through Suga as well as NELL (another K indie rock band) . I don’t see anyone else with the authenticity of BTS….not yet anyway!

[@winkpinky1445]

65 yo found BTS after Covid Lockdown. I traveled to visit my mother just before talk of the virus began. I wasn’t feeling well and went to a Dr I had previously had. On 01/02/2020 I was diagnosed with Stage 4 Lymphoma, a type that’s terminal. I spiraled down into darkness. I was stuck 1,500 miles from my daughter and family home. I had start chemo here to buy me some time. At first I refused it. One day scrolling on KZbin the music video popped up of LIFE GOES ON. I turned on the CC and here were these guys from half the world away. The lyrics and the music resonated very deeply and made me realize that all of us were struggling and still we have to go on. The song stayed with me and gave me strength. I started listening to more of their music especially at chemo being stuck in a recliner for hours every week. The song SO WHAT by BTS was another song that gave me strength. Well that started me feeling connected and not so isolated especially watching them and their struggles, the hard work and devotion to ARMY. I became army within a couple of months. I adore them. I think they’re very special young men. 💜😉

[@amandabridget8706]

Authenticity is hard to quantify, but you can feel it when it's real, and BTS is the definition of authenticity. Anyone who takes the time to meet them must acknowledge that. I think you're right when you say it's hard to expect other artists to achieve that same level as BTS. It's really very remarkable what they have done, and I think it is a combination of so many factors, but they all come back to these specific seven men. The leadership of RM, the lyrics they all contribute to, the beats, melodies and production they build, the dance, the unique and skillful vocals and raps, the overall commitment to excellence, the genuine love they have for each other and their fans, their openness and humility, their humor… the list goes on and on. But when you watch them talk about their success you can hear in every instance how they each push each other forward, how they inspire each other to grow and learn and work harder. They each see the tremendous skills and talents of the others and feel the need to do as well themselves. It is really the synergy of all seven of them thinking every other member is the best and they must keep giving their all that has led them higher than anyone else. That mutual love and admiration has pulled them through a lot. Seven minus one is zero. It's them. All of them together. That's the secret of their success. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

[@MSy-u3y]

"BTS spoiled me." How true!! I found them (they found me???) a few years ago. Whenever I need solace, a happy dance, a shoulder to cry on, a feeling of belonging, etc. (you get the gist :), BTS is there for me. Being older (64) is not necessarily easier. They have shown me how to handle challenges with bravery, hard work, humor, and an open heart. To me, they are a success because they are TRULY wonderful human beings. Their artistry flowed from them to the world. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜 When BTS hands you their hearts, how can you not love 'em?

[@v.r.138]

Beautifully said! My sentiments exactly!

[@dahliafortes958]

Mine as well...I am 67 and found BTS when I needed them most. Through time I have listened to all genres from all over the world and still do. Spanish, French, Italian....40's to current. All of BTS music just touches my heart...whether it be rap line, vocal line or all from the group.They are humble beautiful human beings who happen to write and perform lovely music, they are natural comedians, handsome, and very genuine. They are not afraid to show their tears and sincerity. I cannot imagine the rest of my life, without them in it. I love your content dear heart for it is always genuine and truthful. ❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@deannabeserra]

I'm 63 years old and never been a fan of rap music. Since I discovered BTS that changed. Even though I don't understand the language I look up the lyrics. I'm am in awe of these young men. There are no other groups that can compare with BTS. I don't believe there will be another group will be able to surpass BTS. I believe that part of their success is due to the love and respect they have for each other. They all work together not compete against each other which I find amazing.

[@sasras1093]

Bangtan are lightning in a bottle…period. If you’d have told me prior to becoming an army in 2017 that I’d be obsessed with 7 extremely talented/handsome/young Korean men at 50 y/o I’d have thought you were insane, but here I am! Not a day goes by that I don’t check in on them. They’ve made me laugh, cry & put me to sleep every night with their sweet lullabies for 7 yrs. They’ve brought me almost as much joy as my own daughters & that’s saying a lot!! Thank you for another introspective vid! I miss them terribly so it helps to know I’m not alone. Borahae!

[@mccallumha1]

I have a problem with the singer-songwriter model being the only accepted "authenticity" - especially by white Western critics. Elvis and most of Motown didn't write a note but their interpretation is still artistry!!! That model shouldn't be the bar for all groups. I come from theatre so I get and appreciate collective work. What is different about BTS is yes, authenticity in terms of creative direction and subject matter, but mainly their sincerity and uniqueness. And their kindness and depth as people.

[@nacmegfeegle2310]

Yes, well said.

[@cyal146126]

I have been a member of Army in 2017, I am now 64. I have always thought of them as being entertainers above all else. I love their songs and videos but getting to know them as individuals through the Run series, their vacation series, and their individual posts has made me love them and care about their growth as a band. At this point it is like they have become my long-lost grandchildren, lol. This coming from a white woman in the US is saying something, lol. Can't wait till their reunion in 2025.

[@evavictoria4511]

75 and thanks for articulating how I feel.😊

[@nacmegfeegle2310]

70 and the same. I feel like they are my kids.

[@GloriaYoung-qo1ts]

I’m 79 and love them for the wonderful human beings they are as well as their great music.

[@maryr1905]

“There brains should be studied…” so true! This was a great analysis. Every point you make is something that makes BTS different. No other group has captured my interest like BTS. Queen is probably the closest in terms of capturing my interest. I have followed a lot of musical artists and groups over the years but BTS is definitely on another level in terms of engagement.

[@tatianar9429]

Really, people have demanded so much of them already, and they have given more than they ought to. Let them have some peace, and let their brains remain where they are.

[@maryr1905]

@@tatianar9429Obviously. I understood the comment metaphorically and was responding in kind.

[@tatianar9429]

@@maryr1905 sure, but even metaphorically we should really avoid placing more demands on them, even in jest. They have enough pressure

[@henriettaescano7727]

Army, please listen to SB19 as well. They’re Ppop and have amazing vocals. All of them can sing, rap and dance and create their own MVs. BTS is their idol group and they started as a cover group for Kpop.

[@A_RM94]

Yes they articulated and beautifully conveyed their personal responses to situations in their music, but what gets me every time I listen to their music, and when they talk, is the depth of their wisdom. I am years older than them, but I have not thought about things with such depth and clarity, honesty and humility, as each and every member of BTS has done. And this is quite apart from their exceptional musical abilities, dedication to their craft, and the respect they show their fans. To me, quite simply, they are a miraculous creation, and no other will match them, at least in this generation. Thank you for this awesome video, and for highlighting all the aspects of their uniqueness!

[@GloriaYoung-qo1ts]

Well said! I agree wholeheartedly.

[@bdfhvxz]

BRAVO!😊💜

[@christinebaukus8281]

Please publish a book of your essays about BTS. Seriously. Your insights and commentary will make a powerful book for ARMY and a great tool to help the general public understand what and who BTS are.

[@subobing3551]

I agree!

[@amandabridget8706]

That's a great idea. 💜

[@leasaina2838]

❤

[@mavissa349]

Yes! You can do it!

[@wongpauline22]

Yes!

[@karenpierce4459]

I'm a 70-year-old American BTS fan. I never listen to music much except Christian music for many years. Once in awhile I would listen to some golden oldies from the 50s 60s and the 70s. I hated rap but I love BTS rap and all their music. Some of the songs that I didn't like at first after hearing it a few times grows on me some of them have become my favorites. I hope that in 2025 they're able to come back as a group and still do solo songs and albums. I think their musical geniuses.

[@eileencritchley4630]

oh they will they made that promise, and they signed that contract. All they talk about is getting back together again. As for solo work well they've always done solo work right from the start it's dotted through their albums, their none Group albums and of course their solo albums. That's just who they are it's how they keep growing.

[@anukatariinasutinen9056]

It has become clear to Me in BTS that Their mutual respect, interaction, understanding, love, caring for each other, mutual knowledge and acceptance radiates from Them. It affects everything from songs, dance, humor and togetherness. It has the kind of magical co-chemistry that melts the soul and heart. And gives a good example of interaction. And gives a good example and model of interaction. That this is how I personally can and will behave.

[@kdonaldson7308]

For me yes BTS are talented singers, songwriters and performers. But their success has come because they combine that with their respect of Army. Just look at other groups, they perform to an audience because they want to, they write songs they want to, they sell what they want. A lot of other artists are happy to take our money, but want nothing else to do with us and often attack if we don’t do /act/support them in the way they want. But BTS genuinely want to create art for us the audience, they want us to enjoy or love it rather than just buy it. And in return we want to listen to the stories they want to tell and are willing to go along with genre changes. For me personally BTS makes Rap and Hip Hop accessible and welcoming as a women I have found a lot of traditional rap and hip hop demeaning and sleazy. (Obviously some exceptions)

[@amithamurali613]

Agree completely. BTS has raised our standards so freaking high. I like many musical artists from all over the world for a few of their songs. Never have I ever come across a no skip artist like our boys.

[@rosainesmarino3151]

72 year old army here. Such thorough analysis. I identify myself and agree with everything you explain. Wonderful job.

[@gretchend6823]

Congratulations on 25000! ❤️ 79 yr old ARMY. BTS is really the only group I follow. It is their sincerity that shines through and the consistent depth and messages of their songs that holds my interest and keeps me engaged. Even their fun and simple songs are not meaningless and superficial. Their music forms a bond between BTS and their fans that simply grows stronger with time. 💜

[@Rmb427]

BTS is part of my daily routines. Listening to their music in spotify, watching various videos related to them is like an anecdote to me when i attacked my anxiety. Knowing them it changes me to become a better person.

[@meemac4709]

Authenticity plus brilliance, discipline, humour, honesty and electrifying aura - this is BTS. Am sorry but what i don't like about KPop Bands is the unnecessary loud noise which BTS has non. And, BTS is daring in evolving for growth. There is no small role in BTS. All roles or parts are huge. Simplicity is not so simple and that is exactly what BTS is. And, BTS listens to each other while singing even during intense performances to sustain their harmony. More importantly, I could easily understand BTS' stuff even if they sing and speak in Korean. For other KPop Idols, I could barely get into them.

[@karenbierle7682]

I've been listening to music since the 1960s and very few groups have even come close to the authenticity I've found with BTS. My fondest wish is to attend a BTS concert after they all come back. I enjoy you very much and I'm thankful for your channel.

[@nacmegfeegle2310]

SAME

[@macl8494]

Me too

[@justice7071]

Me too.

[@RS-oy6bz]

Writing your own songs doesn't mean writing them well. That's hitting the nail on the head. I love Coldplay.

[@subobing3551]

I love Coldplay too and BTS!

[@jelly11011]

I'm gonna be real - I'm around the same age as the BTS hyung line but I've never actually thirsted over them (yes, not even during Chapter 2), which is unlike many of the male kpop groups i supported in the past. I'm definitely not in the "Yoongi marry me" camp lols. When i watch them, i just badly wanna hang out with them and have a conversation. Their music always speaks to me, even the less deep ones, because you somehow understand the intent behind their songs. Eg. Dynamite doesn't really do it for me but whenever i hear it, i inadvertently become lighter in step, which i think was the intent to begin with - to just be a feel-good bop during depressing times. This video is right in explaining why many ARMY are so attached to BTS - they don't view them as mannequins/models to be admired and gawked at, but we feel part of their journey. It's not some toxic parasocial relationship, but a symbiotic one where we draw inspiration from BTS and the members also find courage from their fans and share in the same societal struggles.

[@aldueso3]

Their authenticity is everything about who these men are as individuals and together. They sacrifice lots personally and as a group with hard work in everything they did as a group to grow in producing their own music, being themselves, speaking who they are, philanthropic, showing their humbleness, their hardships…they were ordinary people like all of us. Everything about them made them authentic and humble…this is why they are popular. No other group before has ever done this. ❤️❤❤BTS forever!!!

[@freewolfcub]

I love this topic. It is hard to find and trust so many other artists' authenticity. BTS has shown over and over that they mean what they say. When they ask us to trust them it's easy for me to do it. With other groups I do not feel the same connection. I have never been a "fangirl" until recently when I found BTS 2 years ago. You nailed it with the authenticity making them more relatable. From the moment I watched the first Bangtan Bomb I was hooked. You could feel their love for each other, for their craft and for ARMY. That has never once wavered.

[@beatebender]

Im 62 young too, always loved music and heard it up and down, nearly all genres. My last favourite group was Simply Red but at a certain point I had the feeling that a lot of music gets interchangeable and that was it for years. BTS is now my favourite group after a long time first while their music is great, the freshness helped me in the COVID time and the more I dived deeper to it, I found more and more outrageous facts, the older songs, their messages and how they behave together and with their ARMY, all that is outstanding and my journey isn’t over yet, there is so much to discover… thanks a lot for your expert reactions, I appreciate them very much!

[@Sailo1881]

Your comment,"maybe BTS spoiled me too much", is just too right for most ARMYs.... as we tend to compare them to every other artists be it western or kpop acts, on terms of musicality, lyricism, their engagement with their fans, humility, dedication, etc, etc. And usually they pale in comparison when compared to BTS, on almost every ground. Yeah.. the conclusion is indeed, 'BTS spoiled us too much', that things that evade us before became an important factor in making someone 'a true artist'🤔 😁😁

[@OrualMuse]

I found BTS after watching Hwarang. I like one song in there, the contrast between a deep and lighter voice made me look for the singers. I must confense though that the voice a enjoyed the most during the song was Jin, the high notes got me. After that it was a slow process but i finally fall for all of them when i watched Run BTS and In The Soop... there i realized they were more than colleagues, they love each other and that was so endering. Later with every live i confirmed they were authentic, down to earth and grateful young men, they care and respect each other. They cannot show us everything about their lives or all their bad moments but they are honest and form a strong bond with Army. I care about them, i want them to be happy and hopefully they will be friends and family during their whole lifes.

[@meemac4709]

💯 % Agree with you. One cannot put down a good man. And, BTS have grown to be good people. More importantly, they cannot fake their truth and, if there is something BTS members are poor at, it is faking their truth. They cannot fake their kindness, their courtesy to people they work with, their sincerity, their humanity and humility, and, more importantly, they cannot fake their love for their ARMY fan. "The secret of good performance is to be "sincere" and "to love what you are doing". Only when you are sincere and love performing can you truly communicate to your audience. People will know when you are not being sincere and when you are faking happiness." - Jhope shared this to then very young Enhypen, I think., in a practice room at Hybe. Not knowing what to do was more difficult [than the long hours of practice at that time].--- Jimin answered in an interview when asked if his tight schedule was not taugh. To let you (referring to the members) down is most difficult to me. - Jin said to V in a video when the two were trying to patch up things out of an issued which later V admitted and cried deeply after realizing that there was no issue at all for it was a petty thing. Both V and Jin were so humble at that time. Guys! We are not amateurs. We are professionals. Set aside your stuff at the moment. In few minutes, we will go up on stage to give a big show." - ARMY said to his members at that same event. For your guys (members), I can do anything - Suga said in one of their Bon Voyage (staycation) where he served Jimin and JHope with crackers over Tuna spread..

[@eileencritchley4630]

You said everything I was thinking about I keep looking at everything they do how well they do it all. They don't play around they take a deep dive into every area of their craft and they know how to bounce off each other support each other encourage each other to make some very special. Bang PD knew he had some talented intelligent young men and boys but did he really realise right at the beginning just how good they really were and how did he know they'd be able to work together so well to create this 'thing' that is BTS?

[@loredelcreus6019]

BTS, is the master of their craft. They are authentic in every essence of authenticity ❤️💜❤️ Thank you Kabayan!

[@ghyslainemichaud9978]

You put in words what I am feeling since I started to listen to their music and Watch their videos and weverses. It has been ages since I ´ve been that addicted to a group or a signer like that. Love every thing about them , love every one of them💜💜

[@footballworld9587]

'To each his/her own ', but for me, I don't think I'll be able to love or appreciate any other artists as much as I love, admire and appreciate our boys 💜.I found them with 'fire' and I was burnt for life! The music, the aesthetics, the dancing, the attitude, the swag, was 'fire' and I was dying to know more. I discovered their story, their personalities and now can't imagine them not being a part of my life 🤗💜

[@yazilahamir]

Thank you for your presentation....very insightful. I think BTS songs are so readily embraced as they tell stories that take you into their lives. Through BTS songs I learnt of the challenges they face and I love that they give it back to the haters with cutting-edge play of words. But of course, to discover all that, I need to look at the translation of the lyrics. So what is it about BTS' songs that got me hooked ? The melody, the beat, the different music genres, the vocalisation, the soulful expression, the diction....the list goes on. All the pieces fall into place, and that is even before watching the mv !!. They are truly artistes that won't settle for less. Have a great day, Army.

[@carmencrespo5704]

I second the motion that you should collect your essays into a book! I prize artists who write and produce their own songs, but I also admire some who are great interpreters and can communicate the feelings of the work. We often underestimate the talent it takes to connect with an audience. I've liked so many groups throughout the years, from Steve Miller Band, the BeeGees, Willie Colon, 4-40, Coldplay, The Eagles, etc. I usually fall out of love with them because the members do something that puts me off or the music stops connecting with me. In my life, the only two groups that I've loved long-term are BTS and Take That, and the latter is because of one member since the others have put me off gradually. BTS is the most intimate connection I've ever made with any type of artists.

[@danielakoff6321]

Totally agree! Very few do the hard work. One group that recently came to my radar is Ateez, their lider is very active in the studio, does a lot of writing, composing and producing. Others in the group do too, Mingi recently did a gorgeous song called Youth about his recently time off/depression problems. They are still growing, but I like the fact that they come from a smaller company, that they’re also Army, (two of them used to be trainees under Hybe and are very close friends with TXT). They also have achieved more success internationally first. I love their personalities, but the music it’s a hit and miss for me sometimes, maybe because I’m not in my 20’s and I love the 80 and 90’s influence that BTS excels at. But it says a lot that Ateez was the only other Kpop group that kept me coming for more since I became Army so many years ago.

[@ac7774.]

Same for me with Ateez. I first saw them do a cover of BWL and liked their voices and stage, so went to look at their catalog. As you put it the songs are hit or miss, I find that I prefer their softer side, Turbulence is a favourite of mine and I also really like Mingi's new track. They're talented and hardworking and it seems to me they want to continue to experiment new things and grow their art, that's something I appreciate.

[@taeggukie_BTS7]

Exactly! My daughter is Atiny so i follow their content with her and they coming so close to BTS. Their story,the love towards their fans. I love Ateez very much..i will always ve an true Army but Ateez is the second group i support with lots of love!

[@danielakoff6321]

@@taeggukie_BTS7 yes. They have a lot of similarities, and for sure are following the “BTS formula”, but it’s not something that diminishes them, they’ve are very hard working, talented and charismatic guys.

[@mavissa349]

Hey Daniela! Try looking into a lesser known group called OnlyOneOf. And not just their singles, but other tracks off their EPs like "Desert", "Tear of God", and "Only One of Me". A lot of OOO's music is very chill, soothing R & B.

[@danielakoff6321]

@@mavissa349 I will, thanks for the tip! 😉

[@1hotshon]

I discovered BTS through Dynamite but fell in love from watching practice videos and all of the behind the scenes content that expressed their inner thoughts, be it from unboxing content, production documentaries or Vlive/Welive. They share more than just music and you feel like you're a part of their creative process. You want to invest your time (and money) because they invest their time and money!

[@Mori-Chan613]

It's the substance for me... in their songs, their group discussions (especially SUGA's wisdom! That man is far ahead his age), in their artistic direction.. I listen to other groups as well but I really don't like the noisy upbeat sound that most kpop songs have. And checking on other idols, I'm always looking forward to that authenticity I found with BTS. I know it's wrong because they're completely different talented people but I can't help it. BTS has become my standard.

[@dolinca5730]

I really hope and wish that the members of BTS watch your videos. You do an amazing job of breaking down and analyzing their work and performance in such a professional, not overly emotional, thought provoking way that I wish they could know and understand what we, their fans, truly see in them. My concern has always been that as their popularity grows…. the “suits” in the music industry around them will just start using them to pump out songs that are not “authentic” to BTS. Jk is the one that concerns me the most as he is immensely talented but I despise 🛴Braun’s managing of his artists…..no real concern other than💰……and I don’t want the corrupt music industry to eat him alive. I think what appeals to me, as a fan most, is BTS’s innocence. They are like dinosaurs in a “only for profit” industry because they appear to put their artistry and heir fans’ needs and wants before the money. It’s like they are the David fighting Goliath…..and along with ARMY…..they are winning😍. For me….I am a BTS only fan….I don’t like kpop in general……I did like GODS by New Jeans….but only after somebody put out an AI version of BTS singing it. Oh…..Mamamoo…those girls have some pipes🔥

[@nacmegfeegle2310]

Agreed about Braun. JK could get sucked into a world that would not be good for him.

[@delasmercedes2940]

I wouldn’t worry about JK with his close to 13 yrs of experience in one of the toughest music industries: K-pop and their fandoms He knows where he stands and, in a bad case scenario, he has six brothers and BHM behind him. So, fans’ infantilism isn’t him; remember that his main underlining message in his “7” single debut for ARMY was : “I’m an adult now; and I’ll do what I want. Don’t like it? Too bad” At the end, SB role on G has been exaggerated to hurt JK’s extraordinary success on his global debut. SB only did some a&r; check credits more closely. all decisions were made by JK and his BHM overall production team. It boggles the mind how solos/multis/mantis disregard a A MAJOR FACT in JK’s success: he’s the main vocalist of the biggest musical band in the world!!! supported by the biggest and most committed fandom. AND he chose to go MAINSTREAM POP and nailed it to perfection!! CH 2 is about RESPECT for each member doing their own thing. We were gifted seven indisputable musical creators and Kings. ENJOY!

[@kshafer6220]

Yeah, don't worry about the guys' innocence. After twelve years in the cut-throat competition that is Korea's music industry, and after all the dirty tricks and underhanded tactics they've seen both in Korea and the US, they're not lambs for the fleecing. They're very experienced, savvy guys who know the music business very well indeed, good and bad both. They've made it clear that they do it their way, and they have both ARMY and Big Hit at their backs. And don't worry about SB. He'll do what he does with HYBE America, if co-CEO Lenzo Yoon can't rein him in, but CEO Park is the head of HYBE Korea, and he's the right sort.

[@angelacurtis4456]

American Army fan who now follows BTS, pretty much left the American music scene behind as everything is stale, flat and we all know the music industry pays to put artists at the top. There will never be another group I think that will reach the level of BTS's authentic creative selves. They are living legends in their own time, and they haven't even reached their peak. As Suga said, their will be no next BTS. 🇺🇸🫰💜

[@enimaryani1781]

I listened the other groups KPop but i don't understand why I don't like their song like I like BTS's song. Just something missing with their song. I am sorry for other groups fans. Their music is good but just don't like to listen more than once

[@ArdrianaLeigh]

You hit on the point that the audience wants to understand the genesis of a song. But you didn’t make the point that they are geniuses at writing trilogies that don’t stop there but create themes that weave, reweave, loop back and morph from yet other themes to create a universe of quality thought and penetrating feelings. They play the long game. They’ve created a discography where any song can stand alone but together is an history of these seven voices expressing both the internal and external issues in the life of an idol. Then they make sure those themes have universal appeal. Something anyone can relate to. They are masters at achieving multiple critical and commercial goals with every comeback. If audiences are more demanding to know an artist’s process, it’s because BTS taught us to be.

[@Crispina-qx2rq]

Only BTS❤💜❤️

[@angelacurtis4456]

Their brains should be studied, I swear to God, hade smiling. BTS is BTS and there will never be another group like this group.💜🇺🇸

[@btsarmyintnl]

You are right when you said BTS spoiled us. I tried to see the concert of the other bands. Try to like them. But no one gave the save excitement or goosebumps if I am watching BTS. Even the joy I have felt with other bands that I saw before BTS. That was overshadowed. BTS sets my expectations too high now.

[@wanwan4bangtan625]

The way BTS gives us a glimpse behind the curtain of their songwriting is amazing! The only other artist I respect besides BTS is The Rose because, like BTS, I think they're genuine & also seem to care about their fans. BTS will continue to be my one & only artists 💜

[@corinnewatterson5556]

at times I feel like it really was serendipity that produced BTS, the authenticity you spoke of, also great tunes, wonderful performance, the commitment, the fan interaction, but also letting us in to see their personalities, their kindness to us as fans, their wonderful voices, it also doesn't hurt that they are also gorgeous, but that is not the primary reason for liking them, I have been a fan of all kinds of music my whole life, following my dad and brother, liking many genres, and I love the content and sound and heart of bts songs, each one of them brings something great but the sum is greater than the parts and they all seem to feel that too,, much as I have also enjoyed much of their solo work

[@alipotter0613]

I don't follow any female artists apart from listening to a couple of tracks by New Jeans and XG so can't comment on them. I remember watching Stray Kids on their elimination show and they really reminded me of early BTS, they had pretty good rappers and a fire in their belly. However, as BTS grew older their music also evolved from the school trilogy era to I Need You / HYYH era (2013-2015/6), and I don't feel Stray Kids has had that same growth. Don't come at me Stays! Even now you still have a hyper track with Felix growling in a lead single that sounds similar to previous A sides. But that may be to do with management who want to stick to a format that works and not taking any major risks. A couple of things stood out in BTS solo era, first Tae on Suchwita. He said that he was feeling bad and a lot of pressure around his own songs so he decided to receive songs. However, we all know how much influence he had over the direction, the production, all the videos and the choreo. He did not write but he was the LEADER of this Layover project. Secondly JK. He has said in early interviews that he always wanted to 'sing like Bieber' and 'could he carry a solo show himself?' and he proved something to himself with Golden. So I completely understood when he did an all English album, to test those waters and fulfill part of his ambition. We all know JK can write beautifully and produce but asking someone who is not fluent in English to write or even co-write English tracks? That is a bit much to ask. And not forgetting time constraints due to military service! Sorry for the long comment, but you did ask!!! Love you!!!💜

[@evavictoria4511]

I don't have time to listen/watch/be interested in any other group! 75 and ARMY! Borahae! Apobangpo!

[@mirabel_moonchild]

I thought I was the only one that felt that way about stray kidz. I haven’t really seen any significant artistic growth from them. Maybe in the future

[@patchtrivino]

I respect artist that respect BTS 😅 It's really not on purpose but I end doing that.. So.. Coldplay, Epik High, Halsey, Max, The rose, Eric Nam, Mamamoo, TXT, and others that have openly speak about BTS in a good way and share their passion for music. I like their music too but don't resonate like BTS music.

[@NanciBK]

Add Enhyphen to that list. They gush over BTS. They all got into the industry because they were ARMY. All of them. Asked to recommend KPop deep cuts or BSides and they all name BTS songs. kzbin.info/www/bejne/aJnIoX6hodCba5Ysi=kL2J285LAdscfF0z

[@mavissa349]

Charlie Puth, too. Enhyphen.

[@elsaapostol8486]

Thank you for your detailed insights about BTS. They are once in a lifetime group that i will admire, love and support because of their overwhelming charisma, humility, discipline, work ethics and genuine love for each other and us ARMY. Aside from their authenticity in their music they are real and so relatable people that every ARMY will love them unconditionally.

[@nacmegfeegle2310]

I have not seen any other group (so far ) that interests me even half as much as BTS. I am always looking for meaningful art (which is why their english songs are not my favorites) They have convinced me that the personalities that we see are the real deal, they feel like my friends to me, people I would like in real life. The only girl group I have come across that I can tolerate is Mamamoo, because they act more mature, and have lovely voices. Most girl groups mystify me with the overly sweet cute little girl styles, even though they are not that young. Even their voices are too cute. And the ones who act "tough" just look like they are play acting. Thanks for doing these videos, you are saying things that I have thought for a long time.

[@justice7071]

Songs that captivate or excite your audience. BTS are talented lyricists, practice consistently, and are persistent. They all have never give up mentality. That makes them formidable.

[@Cat-Tiger-Taegi-Cult]

The magic of BTS is in their love for each other, no jealousy, no competition, every one of them is genuinely happy when one of them succeeds outside the group. They perfect every aspect of their performances, all contribute to songs be it lyrics, choices of how to present a song to the armys, adlibs, everyone is vital to the success of BTS.

[@Strangering-i6x]

WRITING your own song is not to be praised as an artists, it is literally the BARE MINIMUM. To be able to connect & mean what you write makes people resonate. Anyone could write love yourself but don't mean it, nor have the right to say it.

[@sugakookie7985]

BTS has the largest fan base (Army) on earth, at the core Army is responsible for BTS success and the guys know it

[@crystalsnow1138]

But what drew all those fans to liking BTS in the first place and how does BTS retain their loyalty for so long?

[@kshafer6220]

@@crystalsnow1138I think it's probably a little bit different for each fan. We can all say generally that we love the guys and love/appreciate the music, but that's where it splits off into millions of different reasons, specific to each person. And when we compare stories, we find ourselves saying, 'For me it was like this, and for you it was like that- there's a similarity there, because we both ended as fans, but to you, what drew you in was *this* song, under *these* circumstances, and for me it was *that* one, under *those* circumstances.' And that's the really magical part, that they can touch so many different hearts in so many individual ways.

[@sharonmcneil3545]

I'm a 56 year old Army. I used to listen to mostly country, but once I found BTS I was hooked. They truly helped me with the death of my husband and are just so inspirational. I do listen to a few other Kpop groups, but I don't feel any of them reach the level of BTS

[@sybelj8116]

Thanks for this essay. I'm always trying to figure out why they are authentic and this really helps. Also, back when you were reviewing their book, you said you were going to do a video on your days as an original ARMY. I'd love to hear more of your anecdotes. Next month is my second ARMYversary, so I live vicariously though people's early experiences as ARMY. Please think about doing this.

[@rjs722]

Loved this. Keep up the great analyses and I will keep following.

[@beth5870]

I don’t really expect much from other artists, but BTS has won my loyalty. Not only do they contribute greatly to their music, but you can feel the sincerity and emotion in their songs. I have listened to songs without reading the lyrics first, and I could feel the emotion. I would read the lyrics later and that just emphasized my initial emotional reaction. Finding 7 people that are willing to open themselves to those feelings for all to see, are loyal to the members and to their fans, and are genuinely themselves ( while striving to keep down to earth) is so very rare. I think that is why they are so successful.

[@alexinfired7109]

I'm 54 years old. I was listening to old-school rock, metal, rockabilly, blues, folk and classical music. I found BTS in 2015 and I became a devoted fan for the first time in my life. Because of them I discovered the modern music scene and some songs I like from other acts and genres too. I rarely find kpop songs that I like tho. The only kpop group that has more than one songs I like is Mamamoo.

[@jenniferlastella210]

I’m in my early 60’s too. I love many different genres of music, but bts just hits differently. I see talent in these kids that I haven’t seen since Michael Jackson. I just love them.

[@Inspiredsoul999]

“The Rose” has the ability to go the distance

[@jcw9136]

True...

[@mavissa349]

The Rose is playing Coachella along with Ateez this year.

[@Imme_begin]

As a 68 yr old JK bias, this topic is very sensitive to me. Why is it considered a character flaw if song writing isn’t your passion, but singing, dancing and performing are? We all know he CAN write, but I don’t think he enjoys it that much nor does he seem confident in his abilities. I enjoy his music and I enjoy BTS and all the members music and that is enough for me.

[@zc5519]

I am surprise that I like The Rose. I knew about them thru Yoongi…

[@stonefireswordgaming5070]

I don”t follow any music artist but BTS. They possess all, talent, hardworking, genuineness, respect for others, good looks and more. It will be very hard be like them. They have all different ages of fans and they are special. No one can replace them

[@olgacastro8359]

Love your videos, your analysis to the diferent topics is so great and of course well articulated that help us -at least me- to understand and appreciate the work of Bangtan. Congratulations for your 25k and my best wishes for you to keep growing. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

[@gailobrien982]

I am happy I found this page! I am 65 and BTS made it so I love music (and life) again. These discussions are my jam😎

[@cynthiavillanuevawalker]

I don't follow any other group, bts is my favorite waste of time. I learn what I need to know from you. Thank you.

[@bluesidecollection]

I think that being able to see BTS grow is so amazing. I was a casual listener since debut. Dark & Wild was my first comeback as an army. I just found their music relatable and good, and I was born the same year as RM and Jhope. So, hearing the song 2nd grade while I was entering my second year of college, and they were also entering their second year as a group, which made me feel a sense of understanding from BTS. Also, the group was allowed to grow together and as individuals. We can see this in their discography. They used to be very rap heavy in the beginning, and then you can see the transition of their sound as the vocal line got more confident. Some groups don't grow as time goes on or refuses to try new things, which is fine. However, I'm more inclined to groups that incorporate different styles into their songs. That is why i can't really get into stray kids. Yes, they write their own music, but the style of their main tracks is not something I like listening to a lot. I can't get into g-idle music at all, especially their new releases. As for who has the potential. Lyrically, i think Ateez and Stray Kids has great potential. They have some beautiful lyrics in their b-sides. If they show this in their title tracks consistently then I think more people would connect to their lyrics. Another group is TXT. I know they are not usually seen as self produced as other groups in their gen, but they are already really expressive performers and they also contribute to the lyrics too. I think TXT stands out more because they are not heavily focused on rap like other self produced boy groups and have a more pop/rock sound. I dont think we will get "another BTS" from these groups in terms of sucess, but these groups have great potential for longevity in the kpop industry.

[@aiyu419]

bts only💜💜💜.

[@dutenead790]

I'm a late adopter in everything, so the other artists I have an interest in are nothing new. The Rose and IU top the (short) list. I'd love to get other recommendations, but BTS is a tough act to follow and has made it difficult for others to catch my interest (my loss, no doubt). I guess when someone does it will be a completely different type of artist!

[@jhondavid5244]

BTS!!!!💜 💜 💜 💜 💜

[@snagglejag1977]

They aren't kpop, but I think City of Sound is cut from this cloth. They have a brilliant message, wonderful music and really good interaction with their fans.

[@C.J.Yshler]

Though SB19 is not as popular globally as BTS at this point, I believed in the talent, craft and musical genius of our boys from the Philippines. Though they may have a long way to go, but they've reached a certain milestone for themselves in terms of their music career. I believed SB19's songs resonate to certain group of audience too, their songs are no short in talent, emotional appeal and authentic sense, not to mention their vision towards introducing the Filipino music in a newer sense [domestically and globally]...our boys need to have the chance to be discovered or recognized as they continue their journey in the music industry. Thanks BTS and other K-Pop artists for the inspiration and the great songs. Truly, music thrives beyond language and nationality.

[@charstar386]

It’s a FAIR advantage that they spit substance lol. It’s their natural brilliance. :-)

[@NanciBK]

Yeah, an unfair advantage would be cheating. BTS is not cheating. Its just who they, and Big Hit, are that made their success. The fact that others can't get on their level is like saying it's unfair that not all athletes can compete on the Olympic level. That's not anyone's fault. It just is. Not everyone has the same combination of talent, hard work, mindset, charisma, charm, articulation, honesty, integrity, kindness, devotion and group synergy, not to mention timing and correct choices on marketing and management, to be what BTS is. That's why they are special.

[@aprilforgue]

I can't get into other K-pop groups. I have listened to many, and they dont do it for me they sound the same. I like a song here and there, but that's it. BTS no two songs are the same. They are lyrical geniuses to boot. I can't wait to see what they do next.

[@jcw9136]

Very well said..i don't think there is any other group that can be like BTS...there is only one BTS..There is not going to be another BTS. I found them may be 4 years ago, after that i never looked back. When some songs goes viral through ticktok or shorts from other groups, i do look them up, once or twice i do listen to that, after its kind of forgotten, never gets into my playlist, but BTS songs is my solas. Another one is The Rose, they are also my favourites.they also got some genuine songs.

[@mamaneelie]

I too believe in their authenticity and genius as artists, but wonder if perhaps the most important thing they did (this may be unpopular) was to use English in their songs - even if just a lineor two, or a chorus - like many other 'foreign' artists over the years who found international support by increasing audience. The fact they did it so well is of course because they are the incredibly hard working BTS we came to know and love. Thank you for your videos, like many others here, I would love for you to collect and publish your BTS essays. Fighting! 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

[@alccec8593]

SB19 of the Philippines! They can sing, rap, dance, compose and produce their own song! Their song “MAPA” translated into different languages.

[@alvin12able]

You are very good in analyzing BTS career. Love it. The group is Enhypen, TXt.

[@avabickham]

TXT New Jeans and Stray Kids are still evolving but the groups to watch. BTS another level and they aren't done yet !

[@SamJones01011]

I love Bangtan, what they stand for, and, I love their relationship with ARMY 💜 I'm a fan of many talented artists, but BTS is the first that I felt encouraged to engage with, eg, I really appreciate your vids 😊

[@suzannebarry6337]

“Blackbird” in The Beatles song is also referencing Billie Holiday’s song “Strange Fruit” which is also about the hanging of black men in southern America during the 20’s and 30’s

[@Annys07-1]

Para mi ningún grupo se acerca a BTS, creo que los grupos de i dols todos miran lo que hace BTS y se inspiran en ellos , unos más que otros. No creo que esté mal pero se pierden en ese sentimiento de mirar a BTS. Podrías explicarnos porque los mismos grupos estudian y analizan todo el contenido de BTS en lugar de hacer su propio camino? Es que de verdad llegarán al nivel de BTS, yo pienso que no, por la falta de originalidad, porque aunque tratan de hacer sus propios sonidos, los están observando y copiando sus discursos, su forma de expresarse de comportarse de llegar a los fans y es una lástima. La mayoría tienen mucho talento, buenas voces, carisma pero les falta entender que deben ser ellos mismos. Vemos como los miembros de BTS son todos diferentes pero son como un puzzle que se une perfectamente. Es maravilloso ver la diferencia en sus trabajos individuales porqué logramos ver esas diferencias, sin embargo esto aporta a los idols, seguirlos estudiando individualmente más en profundidad.Un excelente grupo que sigue su camino creo que es the Rose. Pero la realidad es que ni me gusta el kpop. Lo pude comprobar al ver las premiaciones, me aburren , los grupos de chicos todos me suenan igual, las voces de las chicas es casi el mismo tono ..las mismas voces con algunas excepciones. Me quedé con BTS por el talento, el carisma, la simpatía y la cercanía, y porque no me suenan como un grupo de k pop.

[@mariajuliatizon8330]

For me it's only BTS... NO MATTER WHAT, COME WHAT MAY.

[@glossaria2]

I disagree with you calling their creative contributions to their music "authenticity." A talented singer who isn't a composer or lyricist isn't any less "authentic"-- it's just a different skill set. If I can sing but I can't dance, I'm not any less "authentic" of a singer, I'm just probably not going to become a K-pop idol. If I can't carry a note in a bucket and rely on AutoTune to make me sound good, or if I lipsync all my "live" music to a prerecorded track (note, I'm not talking about backing tracks here, I'm talking about Milli Vanilli), I lack authenticity as a singer. BTS has the good fortune to not only have *extremely* deep skill sets among the members, but also be incredibly good at them, AND have a broad range of flexibility within those skill sets (for example, as a producer Suga has a talent for both artistic AND commercial production), AND work their butts off They're triple threats, and that's why no one else in the industry can touch their level of success.

[@tracydowd4013]

XG is a group that has potential to be the next mega girl group. They are a fairly new group, and I don't know a lot about them, but I do think they are pretty special. BTS is and always be my number one group. I've never loved a group so much in my life, or dedicated my time and money to following their journey. I haven't ever supported an artist or group as much as I have BTS.

[@genovevalara3989]

LOVE YOUR CHANNEL. 💜💜💜 LOVE BTS

[@oliviamp6859]

Seventeen. thanks for the video from Army France

[@nanamishita9048]

The groups that i like and respect are Maneskin, The Rose and TXT. I don't love them as much as I love BTS, but their music and the way they talk in their interviews makes me appreciate them as artists

[@taeggukie_BTS7]

Bts will always be my 7 kings in every way, but i think Ateez is a 4th gen group (best in 4th gen) that is in some aspects kinda relatable to BTS, they work hard and bringing a message to the world,their stage performance is amazing and they love their fandom very much...they also coming from a small company, writing their own lyrics, having a story behind the group, the music is obviously not the same sound but each song has a story related to the members/group. Ateez is an underrated group for my opinion. My daughter is an Atiny so i automatically follow Ateez content and i do love them so much after my kings of course. For girl groups it's definitely (G)-Idle but again very much underrated. But nothing can top BTS for me..once an Army always an Army! Thank you for this video i love like you explane everything. Lots of love from Belgium💜💜

[@marifepareja8029]

SB19 of the philippines is also an amizing artist.

[@tellyshadden3840]

BTS, number one, will always be, but I also like The Rose, Mamamoo, Stray Kids, Seventeen.

[@MatadorEvents]

The authenticity for me comes from Bang PD’s vision and decision to see the potential in the songwriting genius of RM and Suga. They were not hired because of their visuals, vocal or dancing prowess but their ability to communicate through lyrics and melody and performances. He chose artists and creators because that’s what he wanted BTS to be. They were not a manufactured group like most KPop artists are known to be. That’s why they connect with their audience.

[@andrevanseenus4095]

Appreciate you so much. I grew up in Amsterdam, and was "educated" by the Beatles and the Stones. Then Bowie, then Trip Hop and Portishead, Tricky and such. Philip Glass stands on his own. Then techno. Finally, low and behold BTS. (When was 70)(gasp!!!) As to what I think of as the next....... For me the Rose and Shinee. Global; Stray kids? (Side note: I have not developed a liking for kgirl bands. I find the hyper cuteness off-putting, both in voice and in their movements...) I hope BTS will be able to be able to regain their level of success, 2yrs is a long time in music land.

[@JeanneJereza]

Thank you for informing us. God bless you.

[@parveedeekempadoo9577]

Thank you for a wonderful video. The question you ask about other groups, i have to say i listen to other groups befor but sine i started to listen to BTS and watch them that was it for me. Don't get me wrong i like the other group but not for me. I use to listen to shinee and CNBLUUE but BTS got my heart ❤️ 💙 💜 💖

[@archelynwolf]

The only other kpop group I follow that gives me almost the same feeling is (G)I-DLE, and coming from someone who listens to literally anything, BTS is #1 even then

[@rafaelsmith5737]

6:31. 12:24 yep

[@normaoloughlin3180]

I 💜BTS and COLDPLAY. OneRepublic and Milky Chance are great too.

[@rafaelsmith5737]

They're not groups but Lyricist and artist I like, Bo Burnham, Lin Manuel Miranda, & Taylor Swift They're artistry & Lyricism is top tier, but of course I still prefer BTS best

[@NanciBK]

I've been getting into DPR Ian lately as well and think he belongs on that list. Not only does he spit substance, write, produce and compose his music, dance and sing, but he is also a videographer, editor and does effects so he makes his own MVs - which are often an Alice in Wonderland on Acid trip to "The Other Side" as he explores his complex and serious mental health issues.