Ilan Pappé, Ph.D. 9.14.18

[@adilismit2822]

Ilan, you are doing a great job as an academic and human being. thank you

[@skanderbessais1188]

Ilan Pappe i watch you from Tunisia, you are such an hero to speak up about the truth eventhough you are israely. wich you come to my country an organise a lecture. keep going you are one of the best historian in the world.

[@vasimajeddy6572]

Ilan Pappe is a man of courage and honesty. Stay Blessed sir. 😊

[@sayedibrahimameermeea3537]

Ilan Pappé is an honest scientific historian whose impartiality is exemplary. He is not on sale !

[@inconvenient-truth99]

Thank you for the coverage!

[@Offa7a]

Thanks for this great lecture. It sheds a light on a lot of issues.

[@PEACEPEOPLENET]

After hearing the opening disclaimer delivered eloquently by City Club President Robyn Minter Smyers, I was expecting the Grand Wizard of the KKK but instead I heard a very intelligent and professionally accomplished Israeli Jewish historian, descendant from Holocaust survivors, whose crime is he criticizes the inhumane brutality and very undemocratic implementation of the Zionist dream. He describes the creation of Israel as a classical colonial venture from the twentieth century, now resulting in a 21st century Apartheid state, which has pursued an overt 70 year plan of ethnic cleansing against native Semitic peoples known as Palestinians. Listen to Professor Pappe's address and judge for yourself, KKK or a rational, intelligent and humane Jewish Israeli social scientist?

[@derekhands9903]

Thats how they try shut down debate. By inundating a host of such a lecture with character assassinations of truth tellers by a variety of underhand means, including misquoting them so good on Cleveland Club for allowing his talk to go ahead

[@ibrahem3444]

Here is Ilan Pappe's official page on facebook facebook.com/pappeIlan/

[@dingdingdingding2871]

#ResistHasbara

[@unbiased786]

They say a self hating Jew. I say a light onto the nations. Stay blessed Ilan

[@alizeedia1595]

I respect this man

[@alifarhan3799]

We should be humans despite of race or religion. All respect to Dr. Pappe.

[@asagk]

Well done! One should not give in when pressured towards censorship!

[@19Pulsar]

Ilan Pappe is a true hero

[@FKCASANY]

A REAL MAN!

[@marrisa17]

Probably the deniers that reacted then, now don't believe Israel is committing genocide. Prof Ilan Pappé, what a phenomenal historian and amazing human being!

[@e.k4393]

One country one vote / all citizens are equal under the law... ❤❤❤

[@Gog3453]

Until the need for white washing accrue

[@muhammaDEsmustafa]

That's just an excuse to take the whole thing (annex the west bank) while maintaining apartheid.

[@ibrahem3444]

Here is Ilan Pappe's official page on facebook facebook.com/pappeIlan/

[@dianazaher2342]

Manipupulation ! 🙏🇵🇸❤️💪

[@visualchannel2385]

sometimes i think there is no truth there's only ideology

[@LuisDiuk]

I don't know too much about the conflict details but base on what I have been learning, the arabs have spent the past 70 years attacking and explicitly saying "destroy Israel, and kill". Didn't they established their state under legal base, they bought the land and then UN gave them approval for it... the british didn't took authority over the region by "imperialism", they fought and die to defeat the Otoman Empire, which they joined Germany who has commited the aggressions that created the war, and then the brithis gave the land for free to arabs, they wouldnt have been able to get rid of the otomans, I think they should be saying thank you actually, for the free country the received, and instead their history has been attacks, bombs, assassinations..it's like outrageous, this is my view base on what I learnt

[@yaramay510]

Luis Riesco You lack understanding of the conflict. Not only the Zionists in deep irony help establish the Palestinians identify for the natives, but also their struggle and resistance. For Palestinians, their existence at the land is a resistance. The Zionists did to the Palestinians exactly what the Nazis did to the jews and other nations in Europe

[@bryn6000]

Luis Riesco: A legal base? The state of Israel was unilaterally declared by a Polish Zionist immigrant to Palestine on May 15, 1948, the day afteer the Britis turned tail leaving the Palestinians to their fate. There was no pre-existing legal basis for its existence. "The UN gave approval". The UN had no land to give to anyone, & never has. The US pressurised several small western hemisphere states to vote for a Partition Plan to be put to Zionists and Palestinians. The Plan required the assent of both. Zionists accepted the Plan because they would get 55% of Palestine even though they were about a third of the population. They were getting something for nothing. Naturally the Palestinians refused because they would be losing more than half their country to recently arrived immigrants from Europe. With the refusal the Plan was dead & thus gave no legitimacy. "They bought the land". By May 1948, the Zionist Jewish National Fund had managed to buy only 7% of the land of Palestine, mainly from absentee Ottoman landlords. It's clear that as you say you don't know much about the issue, so I respectfully suggest you find out more. Cheers

[@laurenceegan6136]

Luis Riesco I think you are to be commended for the disclaimer at the beginning of your comment: that you "don't know too much about the conflict details", before going on to give your opinion "base[d] on what [you] have been learning". Too many make bold statements with the air of objective truth on this subject, and do so by giving the impression that they are an authority on the topic, despite either knowing very little about it, or having been misinformed in their search for the truth.

[@LuisDiuk]

@@yaramay510 You can't call someone an invader or thief after you have purchased the land

[@LuisDiuk]

@@bryn6000 Hi David, the legal base to establish a country-a nation is the will of you and other people, but it's difficult as you need at least more than 100.000 people that's the minimum to make an economy to function, and to make agree 100.000 people on the same rules is very difficult, the Israel people achieved that. The UN does not give you land, it just give you recognition as a sovereign nation, a nation means a group of people united politically with a common set of laws and rules, other nations (the United Nation) can recognize you and accept you, or not. Israel people paid the land and then declared the Independence, the arabs did not hold property rights or sovereign authority over the land

[@nirprizant4228]

i suggest people to look at gil cory shuster u tube channel -ask an israeli ask a Palestinian project to understand the situation and the freetail this gay is selling you

[@arnejensen4425]

A liar and a demagouge. He said nothing about arab attacks from 1920 on. Simply a charlatan. And only jews have NATIONAL selv determination. Something different from selfdetermination. Everything is fitted to his idea of "truth".

[@ea4128]

were there jews in Palestine before 1920?

[@hagaiabeliovich4276]

@@ea4128 yes...

[@littledorrit6819]

@@hagaiabeliovich4276 Jews were a tiny minority of the population of Palestine at the turn of the 20th century, about 5%. That's it.

[@tariqkhonji6556]

Your anecdotal argument doesn’t impress me.