Structural Engineering Funda: Secondary Beam and Moment Release | Sandip Deb | ilustraca

[@ilustraca]

𝗪𝗵𝗮𝘁 𝗰𝗮𝗻 𝘆𝗼𝘂 𝗹𝗲𝗮𝗿𝗻 𝗳𝗿𝗼𝗺 𝘂𝘀 ? 📌 RCC Building Design using ETABS and Manual Design (IS456:2000 & IS13920:2016) 📌RCC Building Design using STAAD. Pro and Manual Design (IS456:2000 & IS13920:2016) 📌RCC Design and detailing using RCDC and Manual Check (IS456:2000 & IS13920:2016) 📌Civil Site Engineering & Interview Preparation 𝐃𝐨𝐰𝐧𝐥𝐨𝐚𝐝 𝐨𝐮𝐫 𝐌𝐨𝐛𝐢𝐥𝐞 𝐀𝐩𝐩𝐥𝐢𝐜𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧 𝐭𝐨 𝐞𝐧𝐫𝐨𝐥𝐥 𝐭𝐨 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐜𝐨𝐮𝐫𝐬𝐞- 𝐀𝐧𝐝𝐫𝐨𝐢𝐝 𝐀𝐩𝐩- lnkd.in/d_Rau-sk 𝗜𝗹𝘂𝘀𝘁𝗿𝗮𝗰𝗮 𝗔𝗰𝗮𝗱𝗲𝗺𝘆 is now available for IOS users also !! Follow the 2 simple steps- 1. Download 𝗠𝘆𝗜𝗻𝘀𝘁𝗶𝘁𝘂𝘁𝗲 App from App Store. App link- lnkd.in/dxS74bQk 2. Open the app and log in with Org. Code- "𝗔𝗠𝗜𝗧𝗖𝗢"

[@abrarahmedzardi8783]

Most underrated channel I have come across, u explain way more better than the college professors.🙌

[@brigadeshivu]

What an explanation superb

[@azmat_waseem]

Very Informative... Thanks...

[@sharifulislam2569]

Very nice presentation.

[@ravishankar.p5542]

Your videos are really unique 👌 thanks please continue your videos...

[@ilustraca]

Thank you

[@mangalcin]

well explained....thank u

[@Babucheekkoth]

Thanks sir. Very clear, With simple language 🙏. Please give a full classes about tips seismic analysis in e tabs.

[@sothattheng8624]

Thanks for your Explanation about Primary & Secondary beam concept to release it.❤

[@bnks5693]

Fantastic explaination

[@moemmednihal6978]

What a superb class..love u sir❤

[@surjagain]

Nicely explained.

[@SunilPatel-nk3pg]

Explained well sir

[@sksingh509]

Wow..u explained 👌

[@shivanandjonnikere8642]

Very well explained sur

[@ebilpikkel]

Would appreciate it if you can make a tutorial on explaining stiffness modifiers (cracked vs uncracked) and how to check and apply them!

[@yesheysingye1778]

very informative , thank you

[@yogeshbang]

The best one..thank you

[@ramaraosiram16]

👏👌 Sandip

[@ilustraca]

Thanks brother

[@chandragupt8860]

THANKYOU SIR

[@ghufranullahkhan7479]

Even if you release the moment at ends, physically when you construct the beam connection, it will cause some torsion in the main beam. And so the question still remains why we even then provide the negative reinforcement at ends where we have already released the moment.

[@ilustraca]

You're releasing the moments, not shear, if the reinf is not provided how the shear transfer is going to happen? those bars used to participate in shear transfer .. hope it is clear to u

[@w.k8624]

@@ilustraca Shear is resisted by bottom bars, not top bars. ✌️

[@ilustraca]

minimum 2bars need to provided

[@vaihamisamumbuu7426]

Very outstanding lesson indeed. MAY KINDLY DO VIDOES ON HOW TO DESIGN A CORNER WINDOW BEAM IN STAAD PRO CONNECT EDITION PLEASE SIR

[@Rocketfuelz]

Would love to see some videos for connections and steel baseplate design. Thanks!

[@soumyadipchakraborty1632]

GREAT GREAT GREAT ........

[@nadirummer]

So, basically, can the reason for releasing the end moments be summed up as The difficulty in providing development length at the ends of secondary beams - leading to lesser torsion in the primary beam and greater sagging at the midspan of the secondary beam?

[@PoojanMistry]

pls make video on water tank design.

[@sultansavardekar7495]

Yes please

[@rupeshkhandekar6340]

very nicely explained . can you please share same concepts for steel structure frames??

[@克拉不啊]

Good

[@lovepreetsingh4566]

Hogging moment will be cancel with each other in secondary continues beam? So that's why they don't create torsion in main beams

[@ilustraca]

Not always true... only incase of equal span..

[@15vatsaljoshi42]

@ilustraca sir, so is it good to release Mx of each secondary beam rather than release My and Mz at ends of secondary beams 🤔?

[@sudhirpayal171]

Discreet explanation. Thanks.. Please do explain how much will be the development length in case of beam releases at end support in comparison to fixed support. Also whatever be the decrement in fixidity achieved by providing beam release at joints, there will be torsion on the primary beam (till failure) , so what do we achieve by releasing moments.

[@civilideas1925]

👍🏻

[@seanbooth42]

Kindly show me how you do it step by step. To put it clearly, what command have you used to show that you have released the secondary beams at the ends where the get attached to the Primary beams? Thank you.

[@MyPrasad2]

Nice info

[@mayurgawade9644]

Sir plz make video on footings and punching shear behavior.

[@user-ud5bz8ky6c]

What if the secondary beam supported on column at one end

[@samveglohiya]

Sir, but why do we need to keep the beam continuous?

[@hindikavita8390]

Why we release moments in my,mz direction

[@aimalkhan7907]

Great

[@alleasy8160]

Hogging moment gets cancelled out in the mid span, so do we need a top reinforcement for that?

[@ilustraca]

@@alleasy8160 Where is it cancelling out ?? Watch lecture again

[@yogeshbang]

How to release beams partially in required % as we do very easily in Staad

[@kiranmoysamanta4262]

Although the designers tend to release moments at the end to avoid heavy design (considering torsional) in reality there still going some reinforcement right so there will be hogging moments at the ends and we are neglecting that will that not arise any problem?

[@ilustraca]

the extent of that will be minor... if you think that the junction will be as rigid as at the support, then you can avoid releasing the ends.. discretization varies from designer to designer and the condition you are going to make.

[@kiranmoysamanta4262]

​​@@ilustraca Too much confusion on the topic. As designers tend not to provide enough development length for steel in Secondary beam as they have designed the primary beam excluding torsion (meaning just for Mu and not for Me=Mu+Mt) But still they shall ductile design as per Code cause although they have ignored the torsion in reality there shall be still torsion coming right? Also, sir how to know that the primary beam shall be or shall not be designed for torsion?

[@ilustraca]

That's completely depends on how you interpret.. there is no hard and fast rule to release.. based on ur engineering judgement you can decide

[@er.lalitbhatt7343]

Hello sir, for the case of providing the secondary beams to divide the large span slabs, shall we release the moments at the end spans of secondary beams too ?

[@ilustraca]

yes .

[@sudarshannikam5243]

Thanks Sir. How staad identify secondary beam in case of when two beams intersect to each other like Plus sign ( + ). Having supported by columns at extreme end of two beams.And intersection of beam unsupported. Can we customize primary or secondary beam at intersected junction of beam by releasing suport reaction Fy in specification /release support reaction Fy in STAAD.

[@ilustraca]

Staad won't be able to indentify...u have to release ends accordingly

[@sudarshannikam5243]

@@ilustraca Thanks Sir 🙏

[@ahmedferdous2433]

U r a boss

[@CIVILENGINEERHUB]

and in steel connection ? same concept ?

[@ilustraca]

No no...

[@bnks5693]

Sir, kindly show one example how to design building located in hill slope [step building)

[@jaypar123]

Why My and Mz released not Mx

[@ilustraca]

you can release Mx also.. but in one end to avoid instability error.. unless the difference in span in two sides are not high, the torsion used to be very low or negligible.

[@acharnandakumar]

Don't stop making videos for KZbin 😮

[@azarbhai2236]

M.tech civil best branch list future use aboard and india

[@azarbhai2236]

Reply me

[@simhachalampisini238]

Hello sir, can you please design multi storey building with beams spanning 30 ft?

[@ilustraca]

9m span.. it is possible.. depth will be higher, or u need to go with PT beam

[@brigadeshivu]

Sir pls explain partial fixity

[@rushikeshdubey7654]

Great explanation