Imamate Doctrine of Shia Sect II Imamate & Caliphate II EP-01

Рет қаралды 19,935

Күн бұрын

#imamat #caliphate #shia
اہل تشیع کا عقیدہ امامت
۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔
This video explores the fundamentals of Imamate Doctrine of Various Shia Sects.

Пікірлер: 296

@najmijalali 8 ай бұрын

استاد جی شیخ جواد نقوی حفظہ اللہ کے نزدیک امامت کا نظریہ مکمل سیاسی ہے۔اور نظریہ امامت کا ان کے پاس مکمل سیاسی نظام موجود ہے۔ان سے بھی رابطہ کر کے سیاسی نقطہ نظر بھی جان لیجئے گا تاکہ روایتی مزہبی روحانی doctarine کے سے الگ بھی ہو اور کافی جاندار بھی ہے۔ بعض چیزیں انتہائی مضحقہ خیز ہے۔ ان کے نزدیک امام مہدیؑ کا مزول اس وقت ہوگا جب امت تیار ہوگا ،ان کے نزدیک امام علیؑ سے لے کر امام حسن العسکریؑ تک کے آئمہ کو حقیقی مومن والا امت نہیں ملا۔

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

Naj... Jawad Naqvi sahib highly confused person about Shia Imamat .....

@insidestory924 Ай бұрын

G bilkul agree with you

@HafezAsgar 27 күн бұрын

😂😂😂

@asjadhusnain8822 8 ай бұрын

I am very happy to see your lectures and I am shia athna ashari and really like the way you do your lectures and have listened your lecture on bokhaari sharif. By the way I believe all of us as muslims are waiting for Hazrat Imaam Mehdi A.S. so atleast after nabi paak we all are agreed on this personality atleast .I believe and hopefully we all muslims will be together as one nation inshaallah.

@HarisAwan 8 ай бұрын

Good to hear that

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

@justinsaaf8824 Do U still believe that 28/7 = 13 ??????

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

Asj.. Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever kzbin.info/www/bejne/f3a1h4OOnZ57p9E kzbin.info/www/bejne/hXrMf5iGnMinfJo (Zakat & Ring story) As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran kzbin.infoUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So show a single verse in the present Quran, which says “O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.” Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA. SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public. 2) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,

@najmijalali 8 ай бұрын

میرا تعلق مسلک نوربخشیہ ہے اور آپ کو ہمارے عقائد کی کتاب کتاب اعتقادیہ دیا تھا۔مسلک نوربخشیہ شیعہ کا ذیلی فرقہ نہیں ہے عموماً لوگ مغالطے کا شکار ہوجاتے ہیں۔ امام نوربخش علیہ رحمہ نے فقہ احوط تصنیف فرمائی ہے اور اس وقت کے ہم نوربخشی اسی فقہ پر عمل پیرا ہیں۔اس میں بھی امامت کو مختلف زاویوں سے ڈسکس کی ہوئی ہے۔

@JanoMano-ud1vt 8 ай бұрын

Mari jan khilafat ka bara bi bat karna na jo nahi ki miat ko chor kar saqifa ma chla gia khilafat kalia wo khalifa ha wah

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

Jan.. Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever kzbin.info/www/bejne/f3a1h4OOnZ57p9E kzbin.info/www/bejne/hXrMf5iGnMinfJo (Zakat & Ring story) As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran kzbin.infoUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So show a single verse in the present Quran, which says “O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.” Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA. SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public. 2) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,,,,,…

@shafqatraheel3533 8 ай бұрын

حافظ صاحب آپ نے بہت ہی شاندار کام شروع کیا ہے ۔ اللّٰہ آپ کی ہمیشہ مدد کرے ۔

@muhammadkaif3883 8 ай бұрын

It is an humble request for hafiz zubair sir to make an video on aqeeda of khomeni. Is it true that he had a lot of blasphemous aqeedahs about sahaba and ammi Aisha (r.a). Also he considered himself masoom and better than prophets of Allah. People like engineer mirza promote such individuals. Thank you

@mohammadfarooq5885 7 ай бұрын

Tamam firqa parasti sa jan chorai Allah or Allah ka Rassol ko follow kre

@abumahdimasoomi2350 4 ай бұрын

ایک دوسرے کو سمجھیں؟؟؟ لیکن شیعت کو آپ سمجھنا نہیں بلکہ الجھانا چاہتے ہیں ٹاپ کا فراڈ کر رہے ہیں آپ

@NSnaziakhan 4 ай бұрын

السلام علیکم ڈاکٹر صاحب فرقہ جعفریہ کا کیا نظریہ ہے اور اسکے جوابات بھی آپ دے جزاک اللہ خیرا

@syedpak9549 5 ай бұрын

زبیر صاحب شیعی عقائد و نظریات بیان کرنے کی بجائے اپ درمیان میں اپنے تبصرات و تجزیہ و تحلیل و ارا کیوں پیش کر رہے ہیں؟ اور پھر کچی باتیں اور سطحی گفتگو فرما رہے ہیں اپ! ڈاکٹر موسوی کی کیا حیثیت ہے؟ اپ کے تجزیے میں گہری اور منطقی باتیں کم ہیں اور خام اور سطحی تجزیات زیادہ ہیں۔

@mus2665 8 ай бұрын

MashAllah..may all our shia brothers keep an open mind and listen to the lecture..may Allah guide us all

@NasirJaved-f1n 24 күн бұрын

ڈاکٹر صاحب آ پ سے ملاقات کیسے ممکن ھے

@aarontest8174 8 ай бұрын

Shru mi ju apne Allahyari k challenge k jawab mi apny lia pasand kia k aik moderator ka intekhab hojae tu jesay ap apne lia aik moderator chahty waisy apku shia mazhab aur usky aqaid k bary mi guftago karny k lia aik shia ku b shamil-e-kalam karna chaheye tha magar munafqat hy k chupti nahi .... maloom ho rha apne bht koshish ki shia kutab mi gusnay ki magar glass mi utna he paani ata jitni uski capacity ... insan ku usi lense se nazar ata jis se woh daikhna chahta ... shru mi tu apne aqaid e imam shia kutab se dikha k kuch aadilana start lia magar phir bohri, ismaliyo etc ku b shia shumar kar k jahalat aur munafqat ka ajeeb jalwa dikhaya ... pahli baat tu ye jaan lein haqeqi shia faqt wohi hy ju aima ku mansus minallah aur wajib ul ataat manay aur in afraad ki ta'aad hamesha bht he kam rahi degar tamam ju shia kehlae jesay kofi/iraqi etc woh haqeeqi manu mi shia thy he nae but political supportors thy woh ju haqeqi ma'rafat e imam se koso dur thy aur phir apne bht istadlaal bandhny ki koshish ki k zaid bin ali ne imam e mohammad baqir (a.s) ki imamat ka inkaar kia tu bhae ku he nae maloom k bhae mansoos hy kia ap bhool gay hazrat nooh (a.s) aur unky bety ky? kia betay ku nae maloom tha k baap nabi kia bety kay inkaar se baap ka mansabat e nabowat mashkook ho jata? aur kia apne is video ka significant hisa doctor mosa mosauvi ki bakwasiyat pe apna istadlaal qaim karty rhy? kia kisi bashr kay guman ki b koi wuqat howa karti? jin nahaj ul balagha k khatoot se ap moula ali (a.s) ka tasawar biyan karna chah rhy kia ap janty woh khat moula ne ameer-e-shaam ku likha tha aur usy usi logic se istadlaal kia tha jis logic ka woh manany wala tha is se kahe ye sabit nae hota k moula ali(a.s) b is logic ku sahi manty thy .... is tarha apki har baat ka betareen jawab dia ja sakta agar ap koi mazhab e ahlebait ka adna sa hakeeki talib e ilm he apki debate mi shamil kar lein but ap aisa tab he karen gy jab apka haqeeqi maqsad haq ki talash ho ga na shia mazhab ku apni nazar se daikh k us pe tanz karna ....

@rashidmehmood7017 8 ай бұрын

حضرت ابوبکر رضی اللہ تعالی عنہ حضرت عمر رضی اللہ تعالی عنہ حضرت عثمان رضی اللہ تعالی عنہ حضرت علی رضی اللہ تعالی عنہ حضرت حسن رضی اللہ تعالی عنہ یعنی پانچ خلفائے راشدین کے 30 سال اور پھر وقفہ ڈال کے حضرت عمر بن عبدالعزیز ان 12 خلفاء میں سے چھ خلفاء ہیں جن کے بارے میں 12 خلفاء کی حدیث بیان کی جاتی ہے ۔۔ جبکہ اب تمام کی تمام امت بارویں خلیفہ امام مہدی علیہ السلام کی منتظر ہے ۔۔ سوچنے کی بات یہ ہے کہ ساتویں اٹھویں نویں دسویں اور گیارہویں نمبر کے خلفاء بیچ میں کون کون سے ہیں ۔۔ یقینا بنو امیہ میں سے تو کوئی بھی نہیں ہے ۔۔ اور نہ ہی ترکی کی خلافت عثمانیہ میں سے کوئی ہو سکتا ہے کیونکہ وہ قریش میں سے نہیں تھے جبکہ 12 خلفاء صرف اور صرف قریش میں سے ہو سکتے ہیں جیسا کہ حدیث میں فرمایا گیا ہے کہ خلافت صرف قریش کا حق ہے ۔۔ لہذا بنو عباس یعنی عباسی خلفاء ہی میں سے باقی پانچ خلفاء گزرے ہیں اس طرح یہ بات واضح ہو جاتی ہے کہ بنو عباس اور اما میہ شیعہ کے درمیان جو خلافت کا اختلاف ہے اس میں بنو عباس ہی سچے تھے اور یہ بات یہاں سے بھی واضح ہو جاتی ہے کہ حضرت سیدنا عباس بن عبدالمطلب بن ہاشم کی تمام اولاد اس بات پر متفق تھی کہ خلفاء کی حدیث سید المفسرین عبداللہ بن عباس کی ال کے حوالے سے ہے ۔۔ اس لیے تمام ال عباس نے سید المفسرین عبداللہ بن عباس کی اولاد کو ہی اپنا رہنما سمجھا اور انہی کے لیے تگ و دو کی اور حضرت عباس کی باقی اولاد نے کبھی اس معاملے میں اپنا جتانے کی کوشش نہ کی۔۔ جبکہ دوسری طرف امامیہ میں تو امام کا ہی اختلاف ختم نہیں ہوا یہ بنو عباس کے مقابلے میں کیا کامیاب ہوتے یہ تو اپس میں ہی اختلافات پر اختلافات کی برسات کرتے رہے اور ایسا ہونا بھی تھا کیونکہ یہ صرف بادشاہت کے لالچ میں خلافت یا بادشاہت کا حقدار خود کو ٹھہرانے کی نام نہاد کوششیں کر رہے تھے

@fazalamin7351 6 ай бұрын

ولی فقیہ کے نظام کے قیام سے یہ ثابت ہوتا ہے کہ ایران اور شعیہ بھی اس بات کے لیے مجبور ہے کہ ثقیفہ کے علاوہ معاملات چلانے کا کوئی اور ذریعہ نہیں ہے کیونکہ ولی فقیہ کو بھی سو ڈیڈھ سو شعیہ مجتہدین کی ایک شوریٰ ہی منتخب کرتی ہے

@syedimrannaqvi6510 8 ай бұрын

نبی کی سیاسی زندگی الگ ہے سنی منھج میں ؟؟؟؟ قرآن سے ثابت کریں !!! نبی پاک کی سنت کو سیاسی اور مذہبی میں تقسیم کرنا خود ایک متنازہ بات ہے 😂😂

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

Sye.. Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever kzbin.info/www/bejne/f3a1h4OOnZ57p9E kzbin.info/www/bejne/hXrMf5iGnMinfJo (Zakat & Ring story) As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran kzbin.infoUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So show a single verse in the present Quran, which says “O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.” Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA. SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public. 2) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,,,,,………

@muhammadnaseem504 8 ай бұрын

Allah pak aap ke Hafazat farmaey. Allah pak aap ko seht.e.kamala k Sath Amal wali lambi Zindagi aataa farmaey. Ameen

@RizwanAli-go6mb 4 ай бұрын

Agakhani is the only sect who has living Imam through out history; please correct, Bohra Muslim has Dai not Imam; their Imam is Ghayab like Ithna-ashari

@HRDwithmehboob 2 ай бұрын

Zaidiya is the followers of Imam Zeenul Abideen.

@تفسیرقرآنکریم 8 ай бұрын

آپ کی گفتگو امامت والی انتہائی جہالت پر مبنی ہے. آپکو امامت اور پیغمبر ص کی جانشینی کو دنیاوی جانشینی اور سیاست جاھلانہ کی طرف اشارہ کر رہے ہیں. امامت اور کلافت اللہ کی طرف سے ہوتا ہے اسکی آیات بھی ہیں روایات بھی ہیں تمہاری کتابوں میں بھی موجود ہیں.

@jamilahmedshaikh7676 3 ай бұрын

Imamiya ka bhi ye hi aqeeda ke Imam Nabi se Afzal he.Rasoolullah SAW ko nabwat ya risalat Sayedna Ali ki waja se Mili.Ek zakir sahih Hadith ka ye Matlab samgha Raha tha Nabi neeche Imam ooper.

@MustafaKareemMoni 5 күн бұрын

Ye interview lene wala Banda bahut disturb kar raha hai 😠

@hassanhsni8623 6 ай бұрын

Shion ki mash hoor o mustanad aur motbar kitab JiLA UL Oyoon men Hazrat ALi R z ki shadi ki pehLi Raat ki Manzar kashi tehreer ki gai hey Jo ke sara sar Toheen hey Toheen hey ShiA Aaj Tak Challenge ke bavujud bhi is gustakhi ka jawab na de sakey khud Ra in khurafat ko parhen Aap ke paun taley se Zameen nikaL Jaey gi AAP kano ko hath Lagaen gey sabut ke Liye molana haq Nawaz ki peshawar wali taqreer youtub pe mojud hey Jo ke sara sar Toheen hey Toheen hey ShiA Aaj Tak Challenge ke bavujud bhi is gustakhi ka jawab na de sakey khud Ra in khurafat ko parhen Aap ke paun taley se Zameen nikaL Jaey gi AAP kano ko hath Lagaen gey sabut ke Liye molana haq Nawaz ki peshawar wali taqreer youtub pe mojud hey

@no1_cheema543 8 ай бұрын

ماشاءاللہ حافظ صاحب ! اللہ پاک اسکی تکمیل میں آپ کا حامی و ناصر ہو آمین❤ ہمیں حق سمجھنے کی توفیق دے آمین

@musmanarshadsair 2 ай бұрын

26:26 yeh tum logo ka aqeeda hy khalifa k baary main?ab pakky rehna es baat per k tum logo mai khalifa hujjat nahi hy zalim fasiq o faajir bhe ho sakta hy🤣🤣 now don't ever take a u turn from this...

@bukharinashriyat 8 ай бұрын

میرا تعلق 1992 سےسپاہ سے ہے، میں نے بہت سارے لیکچرس شیعہ عقائد خصوصا عقیدہ امامت پر سنے، لیکن جس طرح آپ نے احسن طریقے سے اور منصفانہ انداز میں لیکچر دیے ہیں اس کی مثال مجھے اس سے پہلے نہیں ملتی۔۔ مجھے آپ کا اندازبہت اچھا لگا۔۔ اگر کوئی شیعہ بھی آپ کے لیکچرس کو سننا چاہے تو وہ بھی بخوشی سن سکتا ہے۔ بلکہ ہم یہ لکچرس اپنے شیعہ احباب کو بھی شیئر کرسکتے ہیں۔

@تفسیرقرآنکریم 8 ай бұрын

ہم بہترین انداز میں ان شاءاللہ اس کا جواب دیں گے.. پھر خلفاء ثلاثہ کو چھیڑیں گے اسکو بھی غور سےسننا .. تاکہ پتہ چل سکے حقیقت کیا ہے.

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

@@تفسیرقرآنکریم Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever kzbin.info/www/bejne/f3a1h4OOnZ57p9E kzbin.info/www/bejne/hXrMf5iGnMinfJo (Zakat & Ring story) As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran kzbin.infoUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So show a single verse in the present Quran, which says “O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.” Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA. SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public. 2) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,,,,,

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

@justinsaaf8824 Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever kzbin.info/www/bejne/f3a1h4OOnZ57p9E kzbin.info/www/bejne/hXrMf5iGnMinfJo (Zakat & Ring story) As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran kzbin.infoUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So show a single verse in the present Quran, which says “O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.” Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA. SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public. 2) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,,,,,

@ZawarjunaidAli365 8 ай бұрын

Chandio 😂😂

@yahyafaisal7469 3 ай бұрын

Khushi se cheiro aur apne naam se aya kro 😂😂😂😂@@تفسیرقرآنکریم

@HRDwithmehboob 2 ай бұрын

you both are Dr and your program is highly intellectual discourse.. I as Nizari ismaili like your wisdom. You explore wisdom in sects that is great we Ismaili have a lot of love, respect and generosity for other sects of Islam. All these are the different followers of the same Garden which is called Deen-e-islam. we Ismaili have living and present Imam from Mula Ali to till present Imam Shah Karim Al Hussaini....

@raiaon8754 29 күн бұрын

Hassan Allahyari se debate mein sb pata chl gaya tha to ab jhoot or fareb se dhoka nhi de skte ap

@mohammadashfaq4853 7 ай бұрын

Tum virti hoie diwaron ki naakam koshidh kar Rahe ho social media ka door he woh what gaya jab Talib ilmon ko madarson me aur awam ko masjidon me Islam ka naam Le ker bano omiya ki taleem de kar bewaqoof banate they.

@syedimrannaqvi6510 8 ай бұрын

اچھا کام ہے آج تک سنی صرف اس موضوع کو چھپا رہے تھے جو جدید دور میں ممکن نہی ۔ اب عقائد و نظریات کو اپنی فہم کے مطابق پیش کر رہے ہیں اور کچھ عرصہ بعد اس موضوع کو واقع سمجھنے کی کوشیش کی جاےگی ۔ اور یہی اس مباحثہ کا مثبت پہلو ہے ❤❤❤

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

Syed.. Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever kzbin.info/www/bejne/f3a1h4OOnZ57p9E kzbin.info/www/bejne/hXrMf5iGnMinfJo (Zakat & Ring story) As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran kzbin.infoUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So show a single verse in the present Quran, which says “O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.” Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA. SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public. 2) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,

@Kuch.bhi.official 6 ай бұрын

imamat kis qadar important hai ap k mazhab me ?

@hassanjaved4068 6 ай бұрын

@@Kuch.bhi.official \ No Imamat in Islam...... simple as that.......

@hassanjaved4068 6 ай бұрын

@@Kuch.bhi.official No Imamat in Islam......

@engineersupervisor927 4 ай бұрын

Sara jhote Bolta hai molvi SB shia muslman han ya nahi app ki tahqiq say TU lagta hai shia muslman he nahi

@Ridavlogs-i6d 6 ай бұрын

Sirf haq imam ko Mano _ imamat nazryte nahe hay- Quran ma hazrat Ibrahim ,as Dua hay imamat Quran may tak qayamt chlay ge- alla zalim may imamat nahe daga

@trevlog91 8 ай бұрын

ڈاکٹر صاحب: بہت شکریہ اہل سنت آپ کا احسان کھبی نہیں بھولے گی آپ مبارکباد کے مستحک ہیں لوگوں کو ابھی نہیں پتہ چل رہا یہ کتنا بڑا کام آپ سے اللہ رب العزت لے رہا ہے میری دعا ہے اللہ کریم آپ کو نبی مکرم صلی علیۃ کی زیارت عطاء فارمایئں آمین

@trevlog91 8 ай бұрын

@justinsaaf8824 Mere Bhai kehna Kya chahte ho

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

@justinsaaf8824 Do U still believe that 28/7 = 13 ??????

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

@@trevlog91 Bro He (Just Insab sahib) believes that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 !!!!!

@HafezAsgar 27 күн бұрын

لفظ درست لکھیں مستحق ہے

@jahirgadhia4780 19 күн бұрын

Excellent analysis

@iraza2487 Ай бұрын

Aap yaha pe sirf matter ko uljha kar shubha create karwana chah rahe hai...warna ghadeer se aur baqi aima aur hazrat ibrahim a.s. ki imamt jo ki unhone apne zurriyat me baqi rahne ki dua ki thi woh baqi rahi baqi nabuwat aur risalat nabi s.a.w.w. pe ayat aane ke baad khatm ho gayi..lekin imamt ke khatme ki koi ayat nahi utri aur unki zurriyat me aaj tak baqi rahi.

@yasiryaseen3418 15 күн бұрын

Anchor ka dimagh kaam nahi kr raha

@arceus51214 8 ай бұрын

25:11 سب؟؟ ہمارا عقیدہ ہے کہ فقط نبی ہی نئی شریعت لے کر آ سکتا ہے۔۔۔ امام فقط کسی نبی کی لائی شریعت کی تشریح کرتا ہے۔۔۔ یہ اتنا بڑا فرق آپ کیسے نظر انداز کر سکتے ہیں؟؟

@furqanulhaq7250 6 ай бұрын

Mere bhai baaz nabi ese bhi the jo ke nai sharyat leke nahi aye. For example hazrat Isa (who followed the sharyat of hazrat musa) and many othera. So sharyat is not necessary for nabuwat.

@arceus51214 6 ай бұрын

@@furqanulhaq7250 Sir ap baat ko smjhay nhi... Mein ne ye nhi kaha keh Nabi hoga to shariyyat lazmi layega... Magr agr shariyyat aani hai to Nabi ka hona zuroori hoga kiunke ghair e Nabi shariyyat nhi laa skta... It's like: All Sahibaan e Shariyyat are Nabis but not all Nabis are Sahibaan e Shariyyat

@AbbasMoon-of9pj 6 ай бұрын

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

@AbidHussain-ri6pi 8 ай бұрын

زبیر صاحب آپ بات کو مختلف شیعہ مکاتیب کو discuss کرکے عوام کو confuse کر رھے ھین. آپ شیعہ کے سب سے بڑے فرقے امامیہ اثنا عشر کو focus کر کے بات کرتے. یہ کمزوری ھے آپ کے اس سارے پروگرام کی.

@hamza51012 6 ай бұрын

Agr apka khalifa bura b hoskta Allah ki trf sy b ni hai to jo log apke khalifa k kartot Apki kutb say sabit krty hai to ap log un par kufar ka fatwa q lagaty hai?

@AbbasMoon-of9pj 6 ай бұрын

Mohammed ne 72 fenke bataen

@Ridavlogs-i6d 6 ай бұрын

Ap ko qyamat ka pta hay _ nabe ki umaton ko ektalf raha hay+ akre nabe as aay esaiun nay nahe mana ap nay imamat ko nahe mana ya umate kartay rhay haan!

@dilawerhussain8432 8 ай бұрын

ڈاکڑصاحب میرے خٖیال میں پروگرام کا آغاز یہاں سے ہوتا کہ امام ابو حنیفہ اور امام مالک جو کہ شیعہ ائمہ کے امام باقر اور امام جعفر کےہم عصر ہیں انھوں نے ان آیمہ کا تعارف کیسے کروایہ ہے؟ وہ اپنا اور آیمہ اہلیبیت کا موازنہ کیسے کرتے تھے ؟

@syedimrannaqvi6510 8 ай бұрын

صحیحین کا کانسیپٹ شیعہ میں نہی ہے یہاں کوئی کتاب مکمل صحیح کا درجہ نہی رکھتی ۔ کافی میں بھی بہت زیادہ ضعیف احادیث ہیں ۔🎉🎉🎉🎉

@faisalsiddiqui1718 7 ай бұрын

السلام علیکم محترم ڈاکٹر صاحب اللہ تعالیٰ آپ کو جزائے خیر عطا فرمائے۔ اپنی اس گفتگو میں برائے مہربانی ولائت فقہی کی تفصیلات سے بھی آگاہ کر دیں۔ یا اگر کسی گفتگو میں یہ تفصیلات بیان ہو چکی ہیں تو وہ لنک شئیر کر دیں۔ شکریہ والسلام

@shaheengk5352 6 ай бұрын

Excellent Expose’

@sadiqhussain157 7 ай бұрын

اسمیں کوٸ شک نہیں قرآنی آیات وقت اور سپیس سے تعلق رکھتی ھیں انہیں عام کرنا دقیق علم کا تقاضا کرتا ھے جیسے سورہ النسا ٕ میں ھے اے لوگوں جو ایمان لاٸۓھو مقابلے کےلیے ھر وقت تیار رھو پھر جیسا موقع ھو الگ الگ دستوں کی شکل میں نکلو یا اکٹھے ھوکر ۔آج اس حدیث پر کیسے عمل ھوگا یا یہ خاص وقت کےلیے ھی ھے

@تفسیرقرآنکریم 8 ай бұрын

اس شیخ نے اصلی کتابوں کا مطالعہ نہیں کیا ہوا اور نہ ہمارے علماء کی کتابوں کا فقط سکول کے ٹیچر کی کتاب کو اٹھا کر عقیدہ امامت پر اٹیک کرنے کی ناکام کوشش کررہے ہیں.

@muhammadabubakarrazaattari7090 Ай бұрын

أصول کافی تمہارے سب سے بڑے کلینی کی کتاب ہے😂

@iraza2487 Ай бұрын

U r under prepared

@skaswani 8 ай бұрын

Its an interesting video and good efforts explaining to Shia from their own authentic sources. Thanks for highlighting many facts. Some reflection from my side: 1) Shias believed in the Imamate on verbal narrations, however the Shia Imamate doctrine was written by Imam Baqir and Imam Jafar a.s (it is not that dogma of Imamate was introduced after the occultation) as Imamate is a essential concept in Ismaili Imami Shia (Nizari and Tayiabi Ismailis)

@tufailhussain. 8 ай бұрын

Non Shia se shia aqaid k bare me sawalaat .. bewakoofi ki alamaat hy... Kisi shia alim ko bhi layen... Agr itni hi dilchaspi hy shiyaat ko samjhne me to Allama Hassan Allahyari se mukalma krle

@islamforeveryone3146 8 ай бұрын

Allah yari se kaha toh he aajao kisi neutral channel per, baat kerlo imamat per.

@AbidHussain-ri6pi 8 ай бұрын

امام مہدی علیہ السلام جن کے آخری زمانے میں امت مسلمہ کی قیادت کرنے پر اتفاق ھے تقریبا. ان کو کون منتخب کرے گا گا آیا اھل سنت کی عقیدے کے مطابق عاوم چنیں گے یا الللہ انھیں منتجب کرکے بھیجے گا. احادیث کیا بتاتی ھین

@islamforeveryone3146 8 ай бұрын

Awam chunegi unhe log pahchan lange or unki bait karange wo koi dawa nhi karange.

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

Abi.. Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever kzbin.info/www/bejne/f3a1h4OOnZ57p9E kzbin.info/www/bejne/hXrMf5iGnMinfJo (Zakat & Ring story) As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran kzbin.infoUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So show a single verse in the present Quran, which says “O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.” Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA. SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public. 2) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,,,,,………

@shahzaib8327 8 ай бұрын

So beneficent JazakaAllah shaikh❤

@imtiazahmadmehdi6351 8 ай бұрын

اگر آپ درست عقیدہ امامت سننا چاہتے ہیں تو آپ لازمی استاد محترم سید جواد نقوی کو سنیں ۔

@saleemabbas8771 8 ай бұрын

Bilkul.....apki bat sia so feesad mutafiq hn

@Growing_Pakistan313 8 ай бұрын

بالکل بجا فرمایا سید جواد نقوی حفظ اللہ خصوصا اردو جاننے والے افراد کیلیے نعمت ہیں ان سے استفادہ کیا جانا ضروری ہے

@aldeenulqayyimofficial2467 8 ай бұрын

Bhi doctor sahib kon sa apny sy bol rhy hain wo to ap hi ki kutub main likha hai

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

@@Growing_Pakistan313 He is Highly confused about Shia Imamat concept.......

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

@justinsaaf8824 Do U still believe that 28/7 = 13 ???????????

@shahidmasood6453 8 ай бұрын

sir please ap hussan Allah yari ko answer kro jo sab ko challenge kr raha ha.wo b sahi muslim sahi bokhari or hamari dosri books sa🙏🙏🙏

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

Sha.. Ask from the following Q; Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever kzbin.info/www/bejne/f3a1h4OOnZ57p9E kzbin.info/www/bejne/hXrMf5iGnMinfJo (Zakat & Ring story) As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran kzbin.infoUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So show a single verse in the present Quran, which says “O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.” Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA. SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public. 2) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,

@MuhammadFareed-w7b 8 ай бұрын

ماشاءاللہ اللہ تعالیٰ سلامت رکھے

@m.k.rahman2012 2 ай бұрын

Good points discussed...It's very good points we should understand ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

@rajasulehria..3770 8 ай бұрын

علیہ ا لسلام۔۔ کا غیر انبیا علیھم السلام کے لیے استعمال أئمہ اہل سنت کے نزدیک درست نہیں ہے۔

@Engineer262 8 ай бұрын

نہیں ایسی کوئی بات نہیں صحیح بُخاری میں امام بخاری نے آنحضرت کے اہل بیت کے لیے علیہ السلام کا استعمال کیا ہے

@rajasulehria..3770 8 ай бұрын

امام بخاری نے نہیں۔بعد کے کاتبوں نے ایسا کیا ہے۔

@hamzaaliwaris9093 8 ай бұрын

@@rajasulehria..3770 Arbic matan phro ja kr ALHEBAIT A.S likha ha or Rahi bat bad Mai likhny walo ki toh hath uthao bhukari se or pata nhe kia kia change kia Hoga bhukari se..

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever kzbin.info/www/bejne/f3a1h4OOnZ57p9E kzbin.info/www/bejne/hXrMf5iGnMinfJo (Zakat & Ring story) As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran kzbin.infoUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So show a single verse in the present Quran, which says “O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.” Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA. SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public. 2) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,,,,,

@hafizabidurrehman2190 8 ай бұрын

سباءیت کا ڈھکوسلا کہ زین العابدین ہی باقی تھے۔انکے بیٹے باقر رح دو سال کے تھے۔نیز حسن مسنی بھی بچ گءے تھے۔مگر شدید زخمی تھے۔

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

Haf.. Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever kzbin.info/www/bejne/f3a1h4OOnZ57p9E kzbin.info/www/bejne/hXrMf5iGnMinfJo (Zakat & Ring story) As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran kzbin.infoUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So show a single verse in the present Quran, which says “O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.” Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA. SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public. 2) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,,,,,

@stellarsubjects3733 6 ай бұрын

مہربانی کرک کوئی بھائی اس کے ٹوپکس بنا دے

@szanaqvi1 8 ай бұрын

او بھائی صاحب، شیعہ کے بارے میں شیعہ سے پوچھو، یہ کیا بکواس ہے ڈاکٹر صاحب۔ شیعہ کے بارے میں سنی کیسے بتا سکتا ہے۔

@arqamghaffar1996 8 ай бұрын

MashAllah podcast is so informative but unfortunately host seems so uneducated. he sounds so annoying. ugh. bro don't even knows what Fatmid is, bro don't even know names of imams, Zubair bhai pls ask him to stop interrupting you.

@eobimangamandi5356 8 ай бұрын

aik zabardast tahqeeqi kaam hai.

@AbidHussain-ri6pi 8 ай бұрын

حافظ زبیر کی یہ دلی باکل بودھی ھے کہ امام حن کو بھی اقدام کرنا چاھییے تھا امام حسین کیطرح.. آپ یہ سوال کریں کسی شیعہ دانشور سے. تو اس کا جواب آسانی سے مل جائے گا. آپ اسکو مانیں یا نہ مانیں

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

@amirqazi1008 6 ай бұрын

Sir most respectfully ek baat mey add krna chahonga agar Allah tala chahty tou sab shia ya phir sab sunni musalman hoskty thy ya Nahi bas itni baat pochni thi... Aur agar ap khilafat ke behes pe ajao tou phir hazrat ali (AS) ney khilafat ke khilaf isi liye bahes nahi ki kyunky wo nahi chahty thy key musalmano k 2 barey firqay apas mey laren.

@alexa360 8 ай бұрын

DR HAFIZ. SAHAB EK. SAWAL ? KIYA SHHIYAON. KA. IMAM KO FOLLOW. KARNEY. SE. SUNNI. AKIDEY. KO. KOYEE. NUKSAN. PAHONCHTA. HAYE ? KIYA. ALLAH ROZE. HASHAR ME. YEH. DONO. FIRKON KE. LOGON SE EK DUSAREY. KE. MAMLEY. ME. PICHHEY A. JAYEGA .

@hamza51012 6 ай бұрын

Allah ka bht shukr hai jo mei Ahlesunnah umri mazhab chor k deen e Ahlulbait as apna lia 🥰

@ansari280 4 ай бұрын

😂😂😂

@angelmikael1555 8 ай бұрын

Bht KhooB Ustad G

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

I can NOT write my comments as my All IDs for U tubes are blocked, otherwise I have very Interesting Q to Shia for this so-called Shia Imamat. Shia could not prove this in last 7 years of debate with them.

@AbdulSattarSoomro-y5c 6 ай бұрын

Mashallah Hafiz Zubair SB Allah apko apki femly ko hmesha Khush rkhe ap ne jis thqeeqi treke SE Shia Ka akeda imamt smjhaya h aj tk ni suna kafi swalat k jwab mil gai Shia Ka akeda imamt FR to khtme nubwt Ka inkar howa ❤❤❤❤❤

@HaiderAli-xi6li 8 ай бұрын

Hazrat Hussain A.S Lare Nahi Hijrat Ki

@MrFourtwenty-f5s 6 ай бұрын

Good sir I think you should promote this cannal by any legal and illegal means

@HadiAzad-p5t 8 ай бұрын

Salam, a piece of advice, please think about it - Masala e Imamat requires extensive study - meaning going through a hell lots of Shia authentic books, Quran and Ahadith - before you conclude this matter from your perspective which might mislead your listeners, be sure you have done a good amount of study. Please also ready Al Tijani Samawi and Saleh Alwardani - not sure if you have studied as much as them... but sure, you have the right to do you analysis - May Allah guide you towards reality, Ameen!

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

Use,... Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever kzbin.info/www/bejne/f3a1h4OOnZ57p9E kzbin.info/www/bejne/hXrMf5iGnMinfJo (Zakat & Ring story) As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran kzbin.infoUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So show a single verse in the present Quran, which says “O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.” Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA. SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public. 2) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,

@alexa360 7 ай бұрын

DR, HAFIZ. AAPKE SAMNEY. JO. SHAKHS. BAYETHEY HAYE WO. AAPKI. BATON PER. PURI TARHA. BA TAWAZOO NAHI . MEREY. KHAYAL SE WO. AAPKI BAT KO SAMJNEYSY KASIR. HAYE.

@sherazkarim4110 4 ай бұрын

24:30 main difference between imam and nabi is that imam pa na wahi hoti hai, na imam pa koi kitab nazal hogi, na imam koi naye shariyat laye ga balki imam ka kaam quran ki tashari karna har dor mai

@Jaffiry14 8 ай бұрын

حافظ صاحب کی نظر میں سیاسی خلافت دینی قیادت سے جدا ہے !! یہ تو سیکولرازم ہے

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

Jaf.. Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever kzbin.info/www/bejne/f3a1h4OOnZ57p9E kzbin.info/www/bejne/hXrMf5iGnMinfJo (Zakat & Ring story) As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran kzbin.infoUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So show a single verse in the present Quran, which says “O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.” Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA. SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public. 2) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,,,,,…

@Jaffiry14 8 ай бұрын

@@hassanjaved4068 قرآن کریم میں کسی کے نام آنے یا نہ آنے سے امامت ثابت نہیں ہوتی اور شیعہ و سنی دونوں متفق ہیں کہ قرآن کریم کے علاوہ حدیث ایک اہم منبع ہے۔ لفظ تشیع کے چوتھی پانچویں صدی ہجری میں متکلمین کے ہاتھوں ایجاد ہونے والے معنی مراد لے کر ابتدائی صدیوں کا تجزیہ کرنا غلط روش ہے کیونکہ اہل تسنن میں شیعہ کا تاریخی ، رجالی اور کلامی معنی جدا ہے ۔ چنانچہ اسماعیلیوں اور زیدیوں کو روائی لحاظ سے شیعہ نہیں کہا جا سکتا ۔ مکتب تشیع میں امام اور امامت کے بلند تفکر کی وجہ صحیح السند احادیث اور عقلی دلائل ہیں جس کے شواہد اہل سنت کتب میں مل جاتے ہیں، مثلا حدیث منزلت میں لا نبی بعدی، یا تصوف میں انسان کامل کا نظریہ جو سب حنفی شافعی و مالکی و حنبلی نے ذکر کیا ہے ۔ باطنی طور پر نبی کے برابر ہونے سے کفر لازم نہیں آتا اگرچے اہل سنت خلیفہ اول و دوم کچھ ہی اسٹیٹس دیتے ہیں

@truthwithreference3262 8 ай бұрын

ازراہ کرم امام غائب علیہ السلام کیلئے لفظ روپوش استعمال نہ کریں

@mazharabbas1459 2 ай бұрын

بھگوڑا صحیح رہے گا

@hafizabidurrehman2190 8 ай бұрын

الفاظ کا چناءو مناسب کریں ۔ لفظ دو بڑے کیسے بولا۔جب اپ انکو بڑا بنا رھے ہین۔جو یہان پر دو پرسنٹ ہین تو پھر کسی کا کیا قصور۔نیز اردو میں بات کریں ۔انگریزی کم بولین۔تاکہ عوام کا فاءدہ ہو۔اردو بھی عوام فھم ہو۔تاکہ گفتگو کے مقاصد حاصل ہو سکیں ۔

@IlyasKhan-yl5dt 8 ай бұрын

Zanab imam gaiyb ki aad mein to sab badmasi sadhe 11 saal se karte chalei aa rahein hai jina dokha sab jayaz kiya hai

@FarooqAhmad-rs3mc 8 ай бұрын

Ma Sha Allah!! Great art of speech !! Great atitude !! May Allah increase u in knowledge !!

@Jaffiry14 8 ай бұрын

نوبختی نے شیعہ اصطلاح جس معنی میں استعمال کی ہے وہ متکلمین کی ایجاد کردہ ہے۔ اہل سنت محدثین و متکلمین نے خود سے شیعہ اصطلاح ایجاد کی جبکہ اثنا عشری شیعہ کتب میں روایات اہل بیت ع کے شیعہ اسماعیلیوں و زیدیوں کو نہیں کہا جاتا

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

@jahangeermedicalstore 8 ай бұрын

Wrong

@Jaffiry14 8 ай бұрын

قرآن کریم سے امامت کو ڈسکس کر سکتے ہیں لیکن پہلے یہ تو تسلیم کریں کہ حافظ زبیر صاحب اپنے مسلک کے قواعد کے مطابق شیعہ روایات پڑھتے ہوئے ادھر ادھر کی بیکار جمع آوریاں کرتے ہوئے تجزیہ کر رہے ہیں جو کسی شیعہ کو قبول نہیں کیونکہ واضح اشتباہات کا شکار ہو رہے ہیں

@hassanjaved4068 8 ай бұрын

@justinsaaf8824 Do U still believe that 28/7= 13 ????????????

@softwareengineer5764 8 ай бұрын

or jo ro pesh huey imam hain woh saath asli quran saath le gaey hain or abhi jo quran baki umat k pas hai ye nakli hai Shia mazhab k mutabiq.

@funpathsala7043 8 ай бұрын

Every Muslim first understand differences in sect of Islam ,and don't says kafir or munafiq to each other

@AbbasMoon-of9pj 6 ай бұрын

Jo Suni Siya ho rahe hain unko roko

@abdulghani6592 8 ай бұрын

Mashalla dr.sb.excellent presentation.i will suggest to listen molana ishaq lectures on imamat as well so that u can present your case More strongly

@khanesthetic 5 ай бұрын

most underrted chnnl

@fazalamin7351 6 ай бұрын

کیا یہ بات انسانی عقل اور فطرت میں آسکتی ہے کہ توحید نماز روزہ زکوۃ اور حج تو قیامت تک جاری رہے گا لیکن امامت جو ان سب سے افضل ہے وہ ڈیڈھ سو سال بعد غائب ہو کر معطل ہو جائے

@dgreen9653 6 ай бұрын

Imamat is self made rank .....there is no concept In Quran dear

@M.S10000 8 ай бұрын

Sir you are very respectful

@gouravsaini7197 6 ай бұрын

minhat ul sinna book paro shaikh abn e tamia ki.. shiat per good book hai..

@basitmirza1978 7 ай бұрын

JazakAllah

@shutup__aesthetics4363 7 ай бұрын

Hassan Allahyari 🥱 ke agy phass gya tha haha ye drama bazz munazra dehky

@AbbasMoon-of9pj 6 ай бұрын

Jab yah har jaate Hain to yahi drama karte Hain

@احمدبلال-ه1ز 8 ай бұрын

next episode kb ay gi

@funpathsala7043 8 ай бұрын

Mashallah, best approach is to not considered one sect Afzal or haq and making statement before understanding it

@JanoMano-ud1vt 8 ай бұрын

Mari jan na quran jama na khalifa banya rasoool.sws apni ummat ko asa chor kitni hadees ha ka mara 12 imam ha

@hajiarslan7988 8 ай бұрын

❤❤❤

@zulfikartejani224 8 ай бұрын

allah aap dono bhaio ko ilm e huqe apane noor se inayat kare aur aap ko huqe bayan karneki hidayat inayat kare aamin

@JanoMano-ud1vt 8 ай бұрын

Shia kitab kamal ul deen wa tam ul naima parha sheikh sadooq ki imam kia kar raha nabi as 40 sal kia kar raha tha jab batio ko zinda dafan kar dia jata jab allah ka hukam aya to un ho na tablig ki jab allah chaha ga wo zahoor kara sara sa hisab kara intazaar karo ap bi or ham bi quran ayat

@syedmehdi8793 8 ай бұрын

Strangely interesting.....I am a Shia and have been researching on Shia Aqeedah Imamat as practiced and believed today. I have come to the same conclusion, and in the process made hundreds of enemies among my friends and families, but this is a fruitful journey. There is no Anti Christ or Imam Mehdi coming before Qiyamah, Quran does not support this notion. Also I would request my Sunni brother to share the names of the books he has used as a reference, so more and more people can see the light of the truth.

@Kuch.bhi.official 6 ай бұрын

bhai qayamat se kareeb aik insan jis ka name Mohamad bin abdullah aik Hakim hon gy jo sunni books me bhi hai lakin inka ALLAH ki jnib se hona or wahi ana etc asa kuch ni just a good political leader hoga jis k door me Ummat aik page per jama ho jaye gi... ye aik peshgeo samjh lain. unlike shia imamat....

@syedmehdi8793 6 ай бұрын

@@Kuch.bhi.official sir, the more I read Hadees book from Sunni/Shia sources, the more doubts are created, this life is a test for all human beings, and there maybe a bright future for the Muslims, nothing in the near term. Poora DNA badalne ki zaroorat Hai, warna Allah says in Quran, I can decimate, and bring on a new Ummah

@Kuch.bhi.official 6 ай бұрын

masla yeh hai k logo ne intezar shuru kar dia hai or apne tamam masail ka unko hal samjh lia hai jab k asa kuch b ni hai. Quran kafi hai Rasool Allah saww ki taleen kafi hai. baki us political leader ka ana kab ana kesy ana is se hamaray deen me koi farak ni parta. hum per quran per amal wajib hai @@syedmehdi8793