In Class with Carr, Ep. 62: Who Was Malcolm X to Us?

[@medicuswashington9870]

Congratulations and thanks for your information and commitment from those of us at the bottom of the well.

[@musclehead8649]

Dr.Carr is the HUMANGOOGLE. I told y'all. Much respect to him and professor Hunter. Y'all are a bright light in this Dark world.

[@toniat8278]

Maaan, you ain’t never lied 😅

[@cheffox100]

I love how Dr. Carr is intuned with the youth of the world and the elderly. We gotta get this shmoney.. I love this class, I've learned a lot since 2020. Everyone should participate in Knarrative..

[@ZafirahAmeenahMuhammad]

I love, love, love this talk. I grew up in Orangeburg, SC in 1956. Keep up the excellent work. These discussions my mom had with us as children. My mom was an educator. Shout out to all the educators!!!!

[@PerryTaylz]

Dr. Carr is so impressive! He is a walking library!

[@crossnations5026]

Dr. Carr, Yes, the children are listening and imitating you! My 9 year old son brings your name up often!

[@KarenHunterShow]

LOL...i love that.

[@vphiameradisogaarwa]

I am warmed over by the increasing appearance of pro-black, pro-unity without uniformity content presented on youtube. This show, along with a few others, have been instrumental in my growth. Thank you so very much Dr. Hunter and Dr. Carr.

[@leightonjscott2]

The info is all over KZbin

[@achuilbol5973]

Keep enlighten us Prof. Hunter and Dr. Carr I feel more connected to my ancestors and their vision through such classes! Much love to y’all from the Republic of South Sudan 🇸🇸 “No more days like those” Malcom X ✊🏿

[@KnicksFanTV]

*This was a MASTERCLASS! Thank you Professor Hunter & Dr. Carr

[@jgraham2802]

Professor Hunter and Dr Carr thank you for allowing the ancestors to speak through you! See y’all over in Knarritive! Much Respect and ❤️ Love! S/n one day I will be in Sankofa buying a book and Dr Carr will be in there and I will scream like a groupie 🤣🤣🤣🤣 #truestory #speakitintoexistance

[@kwameaboagye940]

Mama Karen and Baba Greg many thanks for inspiring me. Baba Malcolm X is one of my favourite African leaders of all time. He was a great man who fought for us, inspired us and never forgotten us at all. I have fortunate enough to read about Baba Malcolm X since 1995. What I love about him that he uplifted himself against the hell that he went through as a youth with the murder of his father, him and his siblings putting into fostering to be racially abused and when he told by his teacher when he wanted to be a lawyer that he can never be a lawyer because he was black and he should be a carpenter. Malcolm being in jailed but he changed his life around with not only Islam but re-educating himself and the rest was history.

[@muznaelhag8507]

I have been waiting for a class on Malcolm X since the start of Saturday classes. Can’t thank you enough. I hope we get more than one.

[@toniat8278]

Yes…. Definitely deserves a part 2 or 3😃

[@cds5633]

Yay so glad the class is about Malcolm X😊

[@karenterrell1077]

The footnotes are not distracting at all to me. I love them! Keep doing what you’re doing, Dr. Carr.

[@omniscient7333]

Amen to that. Dr Carrs unparalleled humility compells him to always credit those who have rolled up their sleeves. i love it. The story is all connected as he says and he wants us to never just focus on him and lose sight of that

[@Yusuf-pm7uc]

A Wonderful Class as usual, Love Dr. Carr's natural style of teaching.

[@deborahhall3860]

Another fabulous class!

[@vphiameradisogaarwa]

Yes, yes it is! I listen to some of these on loops, they really feed to soul!

[@nobullzone8394]

@@vphiameradisogaarwa yesssssss Soul Food 🥰🥰🥰

[@grandmag8499]

Great. Love you both. Just what I needed. Keep teaching. B1

[@thesamanthahavana]

We are so blessed to be here. Thank You!!! Class was AMAZING

[@KarenHunterShow]

Our pleasure!

[@p.w.7493]

Some wise person once said "knowledge is power". I'd like to say THANK you Prof. Hunter and Dr. Carr for empowering us with the knowledge you share on In Class With Dr. Carr!! I love that you're featuring Bro. Malcolm X today. This brother was a wonderful human being who triumphed despite all that was done to vilify him!! It's unfortunate that so many of our people did not realize the 'jewel' we had in our midst until he was gone. Nevertheless, better late than never!! It's always nice to be reminded of the contributions of our ancestors!! And, Dr. Carr, you've done a masterful job, as usual, of giving us all the 'nuggets' on this brother!!!💯

[@vphiameradisogaarwa]

I will be joining Knarrative by the end of the week, I am cancelling other subscriptions to join, this work is too important.

[@KarenHunterShow]

see you next week!

[@stuart1837]

@@KarenHunterShow How do I join? Is there a link? I am more then ready to learn from you and Dr. Carr.

[@KarenHunterShow]

@@stuart1837 www.knarrative.com

[@leightonjscott2]

Wat is it??

[@CJGsMom]

When Dr-Bro-Professor makes mention of various events and people, I go to the internet and search them out. I love this program and these 2 brilliant people.

[@tyrelllindsley7030]

I absolutely love the demonstration of Mutual Respect continuously displayed in these Matter Class Sessions! Love you two, and also Love how Prof. Hunter waves her sword without much effort or need to flex! Much respect! PeaceNLove

[@jimmyrayford2944]

Wow! Simply speechless. This is the one - I’m for real this time - until next week! 3 more books on order. Dr. Carr and Professor Hunter are a treasure to us and are providing us with treasures!

[@omniscient7333]

to be protected at all costs!

[@kelvincook4246]

Thanks so much for all the science that you all drop every Saturday. I was very happy to see you all mention Yuri Kochiyama. My mother-in-law was an Atomic Bomb survivor and she made trips to NYC for survivor meetings, not sure if she was there for the Malcolm X speech. But even though I knew of Yuri Kochiyama, I had never made the connection before. Thanks again and please keep up the good work.

[@miab4594]

Watching Dr. Carr look for a book is like a lullaby or someone singing the yellow pages ☺️ I will never tire of it ❤️

[@KarenHunterShow]

LOL...love it. Me too and I'm like, "is he going to find it...?"

[@miab4594]

@@KarenHunterShow totally!!!☺️ and maybe eventually.

[@p.w.7493]

This is so TRUE!!💯

[@cynthiaharris2561]

Another fabulous class !! Thanks so much Professor Karen and Dr Carr.....love y’all to death!!❤️✌🏾❤️

[@KarenHunterShow]

to life...and thank you.

[@victoriaalvin2446]

Watching the replay on Sunday! Thank GOD for the "replay". Thank you to the "Knarrative". I have a nephew born (1997) on the same date as Brother Malcolm X.

[@lyfestile7]

Right on time. Thank you both

[@lamontvernon757]

I appreciate the lessons!

[@mscici001]

Awesome class as ALWAYS!! 💋🤎❤️

[@micheleholley1070]

Professor Karen, this was a very liberating and soul cleansing segment. It is soul cleansing because growing up under the religious social structure I was taught in the Black Church that Minister Malcolm X was in hell burning, as well would the followers of Minister Louis Farrakhan, I was taught our R&B music was "devil" music. It took me many years to shake off this indoctrination or to get out of the "trick bag" as Dr. Carr would say or get out of the "Matrix" as another Elder would describe. Thank you so very much Professor Karen and Dr. Carr for helping our people get out of the "Trick bag/Matrix".

[@DrMichaelWalker]

All I can say is, "I understand what you're saying." But, as they might say in poker, "I also raise you one!" I've found that many times over the course of my life I've thought that I'd shaken that social and religious structure propaganda and indoctrination about Malcom and more. Only later to realize that ish is real and it's a constant awareness and openness that will allow me to discover and remember who I really am and what my people were before this settler colony ripped us from our geographical and spiritual roots.

[@ernestrhodes2621]

Hello. Thanks Dr. Carr for setting the record straight about Malcolm pilgrimage.

[@talib123ful]

That was well known in some circles of influence but was always given to the public as a magic moment in his life when he knew since 1957 there were Muslims of all colors in the world especially in Mecca Saudi Arabia. That come to “,Jesus “ moment (for lack of a better phase) was just propaganda.

[@stevestuart6701]

Reading the autobiography of Malcolm X changed my life for the better. His thoughts created a new paradigm shift in my thinking.

[@abdulraheem415]

A childhood friend gave me the autobiography fast forward to today...I've become a Muslim traveled to Hajj and learned Arabic. I'm also the father of 5 boys and I'm an elementary school teacher....let it be known that his life had a HUGE influence on me!!

[@justmyopinion9883]

Minister Malcolm's autobiography was very inspiring for me too. I thought of politics and race differently after reading that book.

[@jeffpeters41]

It goes without saying that all these In Class with Carr episodes are informative and amazing, but this episode, 62 is one of those special ones...

[@franklee318]

Both of you are totally awesome 👌

[@KarenHunterShow]

Thank you so much 😀

[@Polygroove1]

I would love to hear Dr Carr's thoughts on Milton Friedman and Thomas Sowell. That would be a great discussion.

[@dipthongthathongthongthong9691]

Yes. Particularly on the latter. I would love to hear Dr. Carr debate John McWhorter. On critical race theory for example. Would pay to see that. I suspect however that such a debate would be propagandized. It raises the social vs governance structure dynamic. Who is Carr to McWhorter personally? How would the white power structure exploit a public “disagreement” between them for political purposes?

[@dipthongthathongthongthong9691]

Dr. Carr and Prof. Hunter can speak for themselves but my guess is he/they would avoid commenting thoroughly on the likes of Sowell... and debating MCWhorter, Glen Lourey and other black centrist conservatives as it serves the governance structure as public black-on -black intellectual antagonism. White people love black people’s public ideological take downs of each other.

[@Polygroove1]

@@dipthongthathongthongthong9691 I understand exactly where you're coming from. I was thinking more in the vain of the old Tony Brown forums from the early 70's that had Black People from different industries and backgrounds discuss these things without thought of what the "white power structure" considered. They didn't agree on everything but it was intellectual debate. If outside forces try to politicize it, it's because, as with most things they try to subvert, it's hitting a nerve. My opinion is that if the shoe was on the other foot they wouldn't lose sleep over how we felt about them discussing how to improve their lot in society. Anything dealing with race and power structure is a raw subject because you get into equality, humanity and human rights...etc. In today's climate I would just be interested in what Dr Carr agrees or disagrees with with those gentlemen so that I can see both sides of the coin from an intellectual perspective.

[@thelocc144]

Omg this was so deep and needed 🙌🏽💯

[@staciestacie1327]

"We are in it right now. We are no longer accepting 'black face(s)' in these spaces." "Every movement comes from within." Dr. Carr and KH, keep it coming.

[@PamArmistead]

Omg...so many golden nuggets in this episode. Can't wait to see the next season in Knarative.

[@donaldacree2271]

Great and informative as usual. Dr. Carr, I need that sweatshirt!

[@paulasmalling5488]

I love Dr. Carr’s hoodie! Queen Nanny 🇯🇲🇯🇲🇯🇲

[@3rdworldfamous]

Thank you! The hoodie/tee is available at 3rdworldfamous.com

[@paulasmalling5488]

@@3rdworldfamous Thanks!

[@ornealm]

Great show...I named my son Malcolm to honor the great man. While growing up in NYC in the 70s, I would visited the Audubon and when I saw the Podium, the tears began. In 1981 I relocated to DC and a few years later, I developed great tennis skill to be Cathy Hughes tennis teacher. I did not know her father was in the Nation but was aware of her association with WWOR and Manager of WHUR. My younger brother was an intern at the station. She is beautiful in so many ways and loved. Please do not forget Earl Caldwell in your work. Thank You!

[@NIJEECAPRICORN23]

I've been looking for books on Noble Dew Ali! This is the insight that I needed cause in high school I did not know anything about Malcolm X. They did not teach us about him but I remember I went to a borders and purchase his autobiography. Thank you Ms Karen Hunter and Dr Greg Carr.

[@NIJEECAPRICORN23]

@Dutty Rock I've been looking for books on him and Prince Hall

[@NIJEECAPRICORN23]

@Dutty Rock lies? what are you talking about?

[@OceanisInfinite]

I need to start taking notes so that I can reference them by searching for more information & create a book list. This is amazing.

[@deelayton9923]

2nd) Peace & Blessings to y'all, Professors Hunter & Dr. Carr.❣️ A wonderful & informative #InClassWithCarr today.🖤 Malcolm X is One of MY FAVORITE PEOPLE Ever to have lived. And still, I didn't know All of the things of the things, that Dr. Carr dropped in today's lesson.🤦🏽‍♀️☺️ I've never heard of the Japanese woman that was talked about , in the beginning of class. So Thanks for that lesson. I'm still working on tryna join (fully) #Knarrative. To be able to join class next week. 😊❣️

[@irisahmad1573]

Good evening Dr Carr and Professor Hunter bringing us knowledge once again!✊🏿

[@kitani717]

It is fascinating to gain that 'inner' knowledge from Dr.Carr. Having been young and searching and a New York resident in that historic period, I am grateful. .

[@tyrelllindsley7030]

Just learned that I made the Dean's List this semester. I want to take a minute and Thank You Prof. Hunter for being You! If not for you saying we can be "Masters of All", I may still be telling myself I'm not a "school person". I'll graduate in December and I plan on finishing on the Dean's List!! PeaceNLove y'all✊🏿✊🏽✊🏼✊🏾

[@CoreyHarrisinterviews]

Who had the nerve to give this beautiful exchange a thumbs down?

[@KarenHunterShow]

trolls are gonna troll...they have to.

[@uriellevelupriley684]

I love this show . I've been using you guys work to further my work . #Urhealing Thank you so much for week after week bringing facts to the forefront.

[@ReMeTeka]

Thank you for the insight on Ms. Hughes

[@jmit7451]

Love this platform so much, please continue to enlighten us, yall are amazing !!

[@KarenHunterShow]

thank you. are you subscribed to the channel?

[@jmit7451]

@@KarenHunterShow i am now.

[@willamettennisbarnett3373]

Thank you

[@Yusuf-pm7uc]

I just joined Knarrative! Started My Journey its Phenomenal! I wish I had this when I was in school, but that's ok because I am in Class Now with Dr. Carr! It is not often that one becomes Enriched and Enlightened at the same time. Thank You!

[@cajokolo]

I made a small search about "The Original Maroon 5" (on his shirt). Not disappointed at all!

[@kwameaboagye940]

My favourite books on MX 1. John Henrik Clarke, Africans at the Crossroads: Notes for an African World Revolution 2. Oba T’ Shaka, The Political Legacy of Malcolm X 3. Ben Karim, Remembering Malcolm 4. Theresa Perry. Teaching Malcolm X and 5. Malcolm X speaks to Young People

[@theresaedwards6542]

When I was a student at the University of Pittsburgh (Main), I can't remember the sister's name, Malcolm X's personal secretary spoke on campus. The Black Alumni Association brought her. I was a non-traditional student; so, this was in the mid-90's. She died shortly thereafter. Anyway, I was riveted by her first hand accounts of Brother Malcolm. I truly appreciate this conversation. I love learning.

[@Niayolonda777]

Thank you Dr. Hunter and Dr. Carr for your classes! Speaking Truth generates ACTION And DETERMINATION to save our people against the evil doers.

[@otwgamingpromotions]

Y’all the 🐐‘s appreciate the ancestors still empathetic w they time & insight. I know I do

[@eunicepowell4700]

Just finished watching this episode and throughly enjoyed it! Lot of information to digest! Looking forward to next week in Knarrative!

[@TryOne1Ty]

Thanks!

[@katielindsey5674]

Love you Dr Hunter and Dr Carr.

[@geraldinewarren9279]

🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾to Palestine🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾😔

[@Cneph1964]

Everything Malcolm - Love it :)

[@antoinettecraig8980]

Love your show

[@KingSimonPresents]

Great show as usual

[@cynthiajames2019]

I love the show like always and Karen you and Dr.Carr were spot on this is about humanity.

[@kmttaseti]

Yet one more A+ outing.

[@ccarr625]

My name is Carla Carr and I thank you Dr.Carr for your information on history.

[@ellahayes1]

My thoughts on the Israeli Palestinian issue was confirmed today. Thanks to this class. I don’t analyze what’s put out by our media the same way. I finally got my husband to watch “Exterminate the Brutes” and his eyes have been opened about Colonialism and White Supremacy. HBO took part 2& 4 down. Hmmmmmm!!!!

[@dawngregory6181]

Another excellent talk. See you in Knarrative next week 🙌🏽❤️

[@blackfunctionalman7562]

How does Dr. Carr remember all this stuff ? Loves this guy.

[@KarenHunterShow]

that muscle called a brain gets a lot of work...

[@blackfunctionalman7562]

@@KarenHunterShow thank you so much, I truly appreciate you and Dr. Carr.

[@shuranalee7503]

I love when Dr Carr go wait...ssshhh sssshhhhh.... hush ya mouth because yall don’t know what y’all talking about .... I die every time 😂😂😂 because that’s so real .... majority of us don’t know enough to speak on situations.... I love this class and both of y’all 🖤🖤

[@kwameaboagye121]

My favourite Baba Malcolm X’ books 1. John Henrik Clarke, Africans at the Crossroads: Notes for an African World Revolution 2. Oba T’Shaka, The Political Legacy of Malcolm X 3. Ben Karim, Remembering Malcolm 4. Theresa Perry, Teaching Malcolm X 5. Malcolm X Speaks to Young People

[@classicharlem3952]

Once again Thank You!!!!! ✊🏿 DEEP!

[@dougweeden9600]

Dr Carr your shirt game is fire!

[@SLUGTHUG]

Malcolm X is the greatest Man to walk the Earth!!!

[@jamierowling8337]

I don’t know for others but I’m not an African American, I’m a daughter of Moroccan migrants who fled poverty in the 70s for France. I was 14 the first time I heard about Malcolm X and since then I’ve been reading his speeches, autobiography, watching movies, documentaries on brother Malcolm and for me he is a man I respect, admire, a visionary, a truth teller, a brave and courageous advocate for his people. Actually not only for his people but for all of us the black and brown looked down and undermined in every possible way for so long . Malcolm X showed us that we are not victims we are human being, women and men who should stand for ourselves like he did so bravely. May his soul rest in peace/ Allah y rahmo ❤️

[@danieldhardman5388]

"WEB DuBois's hundred-year plan...start to look at what that should look like now." "Can we make a common stand?" Now you're talking! I will join Knarrative and do my best to be there. Can't wait.

[@bryanjones3588]

You should do something on the palestinian and Israeli conflict and how it relates to our struggle here in america. I think this would build a stronger resistance to this oppression that's going on to all ingenious people around the world

[@shinebabyshine.]

Looking forward to this weeks class 🤎

[@lacinabakayoko4634]

We African ppl we luck to have so much great master teachers.baba JAMES SMALL,baba CARR,baba JEFFRIES,baba NOBLES,mama ROSALIND JEFFRIES,baba KABA, mama BAYYINAH BELO so many more

[@maxinestewart1922]

Thank you for teaching. I have learnt so much....Thank you

[@TheEmillz1]

43:00 "when do you know you are at the point of the evolved." - Hunter

[@mawyadeen7607]

Protect beast Mode at all cost..✊🏿✊🏿

[@deelayton9923]

1st) It's the "The Original Maroon 5" sweatshirt Dr. Carr is wearing for Me.💓💗❣️ I wonder the "story" or "meaning" behind it .🤷🏾‍♀️

[@tyrelllindsley7030]

They won't leave you wondering about the sweater for long lol...

[@bettypayne5694]

I was wondering too🤷🏾

[@deelayton9923]

@@bettypayne5694 He did explain it at the end of the class/video who they all were.❣️ I know that he said the "Maroons" were the "Enslaved Africans that escaped Captivity", but I don't remember all of their names he said.👌🏾💓

[@lacinabakayoko4634]

Black ppl we should have international day may 19 For one a great African men who walked this planet celebration world for him.

[@gregs8061]

All signed up, no way I'm going to miss next week.. 🤎

[@KaikalaMoon]

This one qualifies for "the best of..." Here's hoping pic of lil sistah is posted on Knarrative.

[@pharoahblaque]

This is one of the ones I had to play more than once !!!! So many books drop

[@cavhaynes]

@25:50 “It’s a false equivalency to talk about rockets versus missiles” Great point!!

[@darniusterix5774]

Kenya! Uganda🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯!

[@franciscophile]

Wow! the 1989 World Series came up. I was here in San Francisco during the earthquake. I remember the documentary on Grace Lee Boggs.

[@iketorres]

If you’ve read Alex Haley’s “The Autobiography of Malcolm X”, check out Les Paynes “The Dead Are Arising”. The amount of research and detail is amazing. Both books are excellent companions.

[@jetunb]

and prof karen is deep on a spiritual tip...ie when do you know ur in the evolve

[@meetupspeakup4161]

I would love to have a deep political conversation with Dr.Carr

[@supermike2164]

I had that "jambo means hello book

[@bloved7615]

Time to reread, Betty Shabazz, A SisterFriends’ Tribute in Words And Pictures.

[@danieldhardman5388]

I want to reflect back to Profs Hunter and Carr the question she asks often, and that is how does this free us? Harold Cruse wrote about an accumulation of social issues in 1967. Those accumulated issues persist to this day. I can't express how much I appreciate these classes, but how do we translate the information gained here into solving those social issues thus freeing ourselves? How do we convert this knowledge into solutions that the Black/African American community can use?

[@DrMichaelWalker]

Daniel, that's a good question. However, I sense in the question the seeds of perhaps some frustration and just maybe a mistake that I've made myself in the past. That error that I've made often in my life is to look for a roadmap to a specific destination along with a grand send-off. Now, I am taking little steps to start on my sphere of influence. For example, taking this time to respond to your comment, hopefully in a positive and encouraging manner, will reverberate far and wide. Malcolm, or as I prefer, el-Hajj Malik el-Shabazz, set that example in how he responded to Yuri Kochiyama and her inquiry. But, if you go back and listen with ears listening for ideas, I'm sure you'll hear something that will spark a fire in your consciousness. When you do, I'm sure I'll see the results. Best wishes.

[@danieldhardman5388]

@@DrMichaelWalker Let me be clear. What you sense are not "seeds of frustration" but full grown, mature plants of pisstivity. Furthermore, they are not mistakes but the natural outgrowth of a lifetime of disappointment. But here we are. So how do I continue to inspire my children to vote and believe things will get better when as we speak a new voting rights bill--the 3rd in this nation's history if my count is correct--languishes in Congress in 2021? Don't get me wrong, I know Profs Hunter and Carr are doing their part. But are they the only ones? If Cruse laid things out so precisely back in 1967, why is there such a shortage in 2021 of Black/AA Intellectual thinkers doing what Hunter and Carr are doing? Ok, maybe I'm missing something and if so, I stand corrected. And I'll say again I am super appreciative of and excited about what this team is doing. But the urgency I sense among us definitely has me concerned. I'll be honest with you. I don't think we have time for little steps. We need to cover some significant ground soon.

[@malikkhalid2941]

The greatest. And we didn’t listen to him

[@roxannjackson8809]

Prof. Hunter , please ask the AMAZINGLY GIFTED Dr. Carr what is his diet and what kind of NATURAL mind warped memory knowledge herbs is he taking . Or is he a historical robotic genius from another PLANET. I AM IN AWE of his clarity and prophetic wisdom and remembrance of History especially BLACK HISTORY❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️‼️

[@KarenHunterShow]

LMAO...I think you heard that his diet before the pandemic depended on the generosity of the women in his circle. I think he's learning how to cook. That mind is from the Holy Spirit. It's supernatural.