India's INTELLIGENT Finance Minister Taxes like Sweden & serves like Afghanistan | India's Tax Fraud

[@namanshrivastava]

Over the past few days, our KZbin, and Instagram Channel Blew Up. And ever since, we’ve been approached by numerous organizations to do 'paid' sponsorship posts for them. Some of these partnership requests are very lucrative - ranging between a few lakhs per video integration. While these opportunities can be flattering, we have cautiously chosen not to walk down that path. I never aimed for this channel to be a profit-driven venture. I'm not a 'KZbinr', and neither do I intend to become one. You will NOT see a single sponsored reel/short/video on this channel. This post is also a reminder and a promise to myself - that I stay true to that ethos. I’m dedicating my 30s to one thing and one thing alone: getting good people to occupy important positions in this country. Many will laugh at my dream, but until and unless we have good people occupying important positions, NOTHING will change. This dream has a very personal meaning to me, and I'm truly happy to be working towards it via our work at MisFits, and Global Governance Initiative. Standards of a society are dictated by whom the members of the society admire. People holding important positions should stand for values, and not the Monetary Pleasures of life alone. Personally, I do not have high luxurious ambitions. I don’t dream of buying a 'villa' or swanky cars or retiring early in life. The dream that many members of MisFits, and the Global Governance Initiative are working towards is beyond the simple monetary equations. For me, your faith in us is what matters most. We pledge to continue earning that trust with every post, every video, and every interaction. While we appreciate organizations that approach us, we feel that declining sponsorship offers is in the best interest of maintaining the authenticity of our channel. 'Sponsored' content, by its very nature, introduces potential biases. I'm here on KZbin to build relationships with my subscribers - and that is always personal. Not a Financial Calculation. Best Regards, Naman

[@gauravSingh-ij7iy]

Sir aap kitna sahi bolte ho. Being an employee in IT industry i pay 30% taxes , but still I am worried about my child's future because of this inflation and poor government facilities that I can't send my child to government school or no support / relaxation from government, no medical facilities. I am a single earner in my family . Nirmala sitharaman and current government has made the tax policy worst .

[@amaldfury4793]

Sir i hope this comment reaches you that video you have shown in a video clip is of Tripura not Arunachal pradesh

[@grey5421]

@Naman Just a request... You speak in English.. but common people will not be able to connect with you coz of this... And this is kind of content is what India needs... Please make video in widely spoken languages like Hindi.... Thank you.

[@1stRizzMaster]

sir why do you have such long coming up section on a 15 minute video .

[@rajaparikshitsingh9688]

Sir, Hindi Me bhi kariye taki aur bhi log aap tak pahunch sake, Please 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@shankpi]

We live in the india where vada pav girl maintains a luxury car without paying a single rupee of tax where as avg software employee is working 3 months in a year for the government.

[@average312]

Then go complain to govt about her lol. I mean if it's legal we can't do anything.

[@Aerrow62]

​@@average312You can always fight to make it illegal.

[@dattaganesh1]

@shankipi you have no idea if she pays taxes or not. Keep your stupid, half baked analysis to yourself.

[@thechesswiki5480]

Who is this vadapav girl?​@@Aerrow62

[@DEEPANJANBISWAS]

​@@average312 why will that be legal for any roadside food vendors to earn in lakhs and pay no or minimum tax? It is IT department's incompetence that these business owners can earn without paying any/minimal tax! It is not our job to collect or inform IT dept to collect tax.

[@VaidehiKale-k6z]

That woman is really shameless. She do not have any valid answers for the tax related questions and just laughed her ass off.

[@munirathnam96]

yessss - she is working for congress and BJP will loose badly in elections because of her and only because of her Taxes

[@JobsHorn]

Tax is simple topic, make digital transactions only. See who can escape from tax 😂

[@kunal8423]

No empathy for the person who had a genuine concern. She's a pure psychopath

[@HemanthKumar-hu9sc]

Tax is simple topic 😂😂😂 Lol Man, Pity for your knowledge ​@@JobsHorn

[@JobsHorn]

@HemanthKumar-hu9sc use tools, don't pity on my knowledge. Educate yourself first.

[@lakkarajushankar]

The worst spineless FM ever we had, now she is back. No hope or scope.

[@dhavald4359]

feku's blessing is with her

[@DaUrbanGoose]

She is a scapegoat. Everyone is blaming Nirmala, Not modi xi.

[@imnoone8532]

If you think the next govt will scrape them all? Nope. They need money

[@UPSCAspirant-s1c]

The majority of political leaders are shameless. They have lost their dignity

[@naytonfernandes2991]

All elected members of the parliament and Assembly are people's representatives. Please refrain from making such comments. These are insulting to the Indian citizens who have elected them. Indians need respect and trust you will do that.....

[@arkochattopadhyay8875]

​@@naytonfernandes2991 Indian people are unconscious - BR Ambedkar

[@upendrameena5129]

No my brother, they are leaders because they don’t have dignity, there was no dignity to begin with.

[@1stRizzMaster]

@@naytonfernandes2991 but this is reality dude 99.9% politicans are like that

[@AJ-cx6br]

​​@@naytonfernandes2991people's representatives who steal from the same people who they represent 😂😂

[@Varun-ij2pp]

She didn't even acknowledge. Shame....

[@gamedo4269]

It's because she doesn't make the rules it is made by group a senior govt officials. She just presents it publicly in Parliament.

[@adityasinghmeena4405]

@@gamedo4269 if she presents it publicly and is basically the spokesperson of that department then she is also obliged to answer the questions revolving around that department

[@PKorp-PriyankaKalyan]

​@@gamedo4269 lol, what's up with you, man?

[@Varun-ij2pp]

@@gamedo4269 If the same person does something good, people like you will give all the credits to her not the people behind her. No offence. Peace.

[@SUMITKUMAR-hl4vl]

​@@gamedo4269 oh! my chutiya countryman...aaa thoo....

[@adityapwc4246]

When that guy asked a valid question. And when FM dodged to answer, Why those clowns in the crowd are laughing. Shame on them

[@paddys-k2m]

She dodged it coz she knew he is right. But the Govt's hands are tied and will remain so until our direct tax receipts increase, whether this or a non-bjp. There is no quick fix, agricultural productivity needs to go up and that will mean less people engaged in farming. All the rest will have to move to organised forms of employment only after which there will be improvement in tax base. this will be a multi generational effort

[@anujasmartphone1627]

​@@paddys-k2mshe needed to say this out loud as an answer then. But i doubt she understands this

[@paddys-k2m]

@@anujasmartphone1627 yes only keyboard warriors understand it. Not ministers who are supported by a while bunch of economic advisors n technocrats.

[@shashankshekhar2895]

I don't know, but nowadays criticising ways of the government, asking tough questions is considered anti national and attracts negative attention.

[@cuckooo7502]

You just did and did not get labelled, chill bruh,

[@vidyanagarajan9135]

Because the same people will never ask questions to the state government ruled by non BJP . Secondly the person who is asking questions to BJP will he dare to ask the same question to Chidambaram? Pls introspect

[@aadarshchoudhary4321]

​@@vidyanagarajan9135 adhbhakt. Why question opposition? And why question state? If I ask questions to Modi and centre, regardless of any government in state. Why it ia considered as anti national. What kind of a fool you are. People like you are the real anti-national

[@MMC619]

lol then why no question to Kejriwal Mamta benjeri or dmk . People don’t hate questioning bjp what they hate is hypocrisy which is very evident.

[@nayan.j]

​@@vidyanagarajan9135average bhaktendra behavior

[@gohilarjunsinh1743]

Taxes like Europe 💀 Facilities like Africa🤡

[@danieldayal2570]

Good one 😂😂

[@Ruksana_sheikh]

Kuchh jyada ho gaya 😢😂

[@goa184]

very well said ..... very well said ... correctly

[@Vivek10010]

The difference is 90% of Europe's population pays income tax. While barely 6% of the population here does. Whats more is that a lot of parties here think distributing freebies (out of the tax money of course) is a good idea.

[@erg0pr0xy]

African countries like Botswana and Rawanda are better and cleaner than India btw

[@Mr_-Heisenberg]

Nowadays if you critically analyse the government, they will call you anti national 😂

[@hrudaypatil564]

careful.....bhakts on their way to spam your reply section with hate

[@MultiGirlawesome]

People have fundamentally lost the sense of what a government is supposed to do. It is supposed to serve the people. It is supposed to work for their welfare. But more more I'm seeing increasing levels of god like devotion to politicians which becomes very dangerous

[@HeMr.Crucial]

​Bhai 4 mahine hogaye....koi "bhakt" dikha to nhi .... Naman ji yhi kehena chahte h ki bharat log sirf dhrm ke naam pe partys mein batt gye hai aur ye politicians usko exploit krrhe hai lekin tum jaise bswalon ke dimaag ye kataye jaana @@hrudaypatil564

[@MonkeyLord-h6x]

Bought a land with "my money". Built a house over it with "my money". Now have to pay yearly land tax for "my land". Have to pay yearly house tax for "my house". Feel like a powerless joker🤡.

[@adityasundar324]

And I still don't get facilities for the taxes paid for me :)

[@TheCycloneTrooper]

Don’t forget, the land ultimately belongs to the government and if need be, certain articles can be pressed into use to justify the forceful acquisition of the land or the property from you as an ordinary citizen. So technically, it’s not even your land to begin with 😂

[@dhanajayamj880]

who is giving security to home, city, state and country where you leave? Nonsesn don't compare our country with others . Can you compare indian population with same expenses they doing in there country?

[@MonkeyLord-h6x]

@@dhanajayamj880 sorry I didn't understand half of what you said. Maybe my vocab is not good enough. But for the part of security, police force in my area doesn't provide me with any proactive security in form of patrols etc. I had theft at home. So I am not exactly sure about the "security" you are talking about. Also in my whole comment there is no comparison. I am not sure how you got that idea.

[@dhanajayamj880]

@@MonkeyLord-h6x I didn't see your user ID. 😂😂😂 user-xxx every one know that Id is from the sleeper cell ..

[@Proud_Pagan]

She is one haughty Finance Minister who is proud of her incompetence and callousness .

[@paddys-k2m]

She dodged it coz he was right. But Govt's hands are tied. How are they supposed to fund the budget ? Borrow like Pakistan?

[@percy8682]

​​@@paddys-k2m build a couple more statues and make a few more trips abroad. That's how we'll make money, ehh?

[@Joegolberg1]

Small taxes can affect investment decisions such as whether to choose tax-free municipal bonds over taxable bonds or do a Roth IRA conversion. I’ve been sitting on over $745K equity from a home sale and I want to invest on the stock market, how do I achieve this without being taxed twice?

[@Justinfred11]

There’s more benefit to holding fixed-income assets in tax-deferred retirement accounts as opposed to taxable accounts. If you're not who understands strategies to invest in the market, seek a Financial advisor to guide you.

[@Benjaminarmstrong684]

Indeed, I did make use of a financial counselor. As I get closer to retirement, their advice has been really helpful. I thought compound interest on index funds wouldn't be sufficient because I started late. It's amusing how I've done better than colleagues who have more years of investment experience. I've profited more than $886k tax free.

[@Joegolberg1]

this is definitely considerable! think you could suggest any professional/advisors i can get on the phone with? i'm in dire need of proper portfolio allocation

[@Benjaminarmstrong684]

GREGORY LEO CATTEL is the licensed FA I work with, I can't speak much about him you should make a search with his name, you'd find the necessary details to schedule an appointment.

[@Joegolberg1]

he appears to be well-educated and well-read. I ran a Google search for his name and came across his website; thank you for sharing.

[@anupamkumari2855]

The Air Force has time and resources available to serve for Ambani's' wedding but they don't have time to put out the Uttarakhand forest fire which is still spreading rapidly. Only did the Air Force take action when the fire reached towards their own cantonment. Adequate measures are still left to be taken. How can the government be so insensitive!!!

[@Rohit24Kumar]

Ambani must have paid for it and once the forest catches fire, it is almost impossible to stop it because of the large area and rate of expansion

[@thenikhilway]

Jin logo ko ye impossible lgta hai unhe europe us Australia and brazil bhejna chahiye taki vo wha se sikh kr aye vo log ye impossible kaam krte kese hai. Hume anpadho ki zarurat nhi 🙄​@@Rohit24Kumar

[@Rohit24Kumar]

@@thenikhilway dikhao kaha Uttrakhand jaise pahadi aag ko bujhaya gaya hain

[@thenikhilway]

@@Rohit24Kumar 2018 California Camp Fire.

[@Rohit24Kumar]

@@thenikhilway I didn't any article saying it was successfully controlled. Every article is talking about loss and destruction

[@shashank8189]

Toll tax and road tax, soon we will see oxygen tax and right to live tax....also look at how FSSAI functions...

[@SimplySurf12]

Canada (Ontario) introduced a “rain tax” , in addition to the carbon tax , soon they will tax the sunshine, pets, etc. In this life 2 things are guaranteed - death and taxes (even when you are dead they will find away to continuously tax you aka graveyard tax)

[@chinnu1964]

Don't worry those can't be in INDIA, government doesn't have data how many are dying ​@@SimplySurf12

[@praveenpayiran]

oxygen tax has already been brought indirectly a few years ago they allotted 4000 crores to improve air quality and directly by making us pay green tax for old vehicles

[@helltoheaven-xd4pv]

@@praveenpayiran if old vehicles pollute the air then whom wiill pay the price

[@vidyanagarajan9135]

Do you know in California there is a water tax and during summer they charge double the rate. In UK once you are finished your education you have to pay municipality tax irrespective of whether you are employed or unemployed So stop giving lecture

[@surajitsaha5930]

For the first time in my life I have found someone who lights up the bitter truths. Always raise your voice up sir and unfold the reality.

[@borntoride3857]

That why left India, paying only %25 Tax in Canada and getting world class services in return and peace of mind.

[@radhikakumar2331]

Shame on you!!

[@jonathanandrew5249]

​@@radhikakumar2331gfy. He made the right decision. Taxes should give the people their money's worth

[@gaminguld9550]

Good for you

[@deep.kr.bharati9576]

Good Decision

[@shubhamsingh-wq5th]

​@@radhikakumar2331shame on you

[@samueldavid.1994]

What a slap it was ! on the sleeping citizens ! Every word was like a hammer hit !

[@iamthelegendripper8900]

It's the same thing with every party do you think if you elect Congress or India alliance European will be will be erased India lions has said that they will distribute your wealth to poor people

[@Business.Network]

​@@iamthelegendripper8900 Haa bhai mere ghar se "bathroom ki tuti" le jainge, "mere 3 room mai se ek room" le jainge, meri "4 mai se 1 bhais" le jainge😢

[@proudsanatani5079]

So was tax less before Modi govt?

[@Mrinsanemoment]

​@@proudsanatani5079bro live in past, what government is now you are in with and why they cannot minimise indirect tax

[@ravi0555]

⁠@@Mrinsanemomentfirst widen the direct tax then we can reduce indirect taxes at least 30percent pays income tax we can improve the country’s conditions. Our people has no awareness about taxes,tax structure, and even some don’t know tax rebates that govt will give due to this people will rely on accountant by paying extra fees. What can we say even business men also using BEPS(base erosion and profit sharing)for avoiding tax in country? Only fate and time will lead the country further?

[@KrishnaDeepak.V]

The WORST Financial Minister till date.

[@bhavtosh5328]

There should be a campaign against pensions to these corrupt leaders and bureaucrats.This is the nexus which we have to deal with.

[@Amar-in4gc]

Fact is that original constitution have never had a provision of pension to MP's

[@userbncftdg]

will u start the campaign

[@Amar-in4gc]

@@userbncftdg 👀😁🤌 sab bolte hai karta koi nahi

[@userbncftdg]

@@Amar-in4gc isliye uncle se puch liya maine

[@Amar-in4gc]

@@userbncftdg 😁😁

[@TUFAILGUL0]

'if individuals believe we are not taxed, they will feel less invested how the government funds are used' Golden lines brother.

[@liyakathalikhan7138]

with 40 percent tax in germany there is free health,free universal education and many moreee with everything world class and here in india minimum basics are not provided with that 40 percent tax

[@kayalvizhi1107]

Govt is sleeping partner so there is no answer from nirmala ji

[@uvnok]

Khud toh wo R hai .

[@SharedAccount-yz9zb]

​@@uvnokkisi aurat ke chritra per sawal uthana aise he tumhe charitraheen banata hai

[@souravkar9]

😂😂😂😂​@@SharedAccount-yz9zb

[@syams84]

Not sleeping partner but sleeping looter

[@ArunKumarmauryaji]

@@SharedAccount-yz9zb acchi baate karna tumhe accha nahi banata.

[@MM-xp8vs]

Unfortunately there is no solution to this in a country like india that was plagued by casteism, poverty, large scale corruption, and over population. A country where uneducated people decide the fate of educated.

[@wisteria8791]

Yes there is and its not only indias problem. Lets join these voices together. Its time to see that you're not alone . Its time bring this down . Its time think beyond race , nationality, gender, caste , religion, party and all the fake distinctions they created to break us . KZbin strategically kept my keyboard frozen as soon as i tried to write this comment about this issue but i waited to write it to you that as a Human im with you . Its time . Don't let them devide uz .

[@jonathanandrew5249]

Yes . They still think India will surpass China and USA by 2047.

[@taplubambhos2869]

@@wisteria8791you have no idea how deep rooted hatred for others is in our County and how widespread. Its a battle that can not be won for atleast 200 years.

[@MMC619]

Abe lower cast where does casteism come here it’s a systematic problem thoda iq raise kar apna har jagah same copy paste nahi chalta . India copies European taxation Indian policy makers itni mehnat nahi karte ki vo apne desh ke hisab se policy design Kare. Just like their god father b.r. Ambedkar.

[@MM-xp8vs]

@@MMC619 the language in your reply shows what your standards are so no more response is needed

[@hariteja1702]

I exactly want to ask the same question, “how they are spending my tax paid money” but worried about the consequences after that

[@ManishChauhan-lk2ki]

I was shocked to the answer of Indias Finance Minister the biggest porfolio of Govt Of India and utter nonsense was seeing the people sitting their Laughing with her . Is this what we have voted for , Raise you voice ask for Answersss No matter who the Party is .

[@cambo-indiafriendship]

chnge fm of this nation

[@abhishekmukherji8620]

The middle class always has a brain to smile for their issues they never have regret if they really see how much tax have they pay and in return what they have got 😮

[@intellectfactory]

People : "What is your thoughts on the increasing onion prices in the country?" Nirmala ji : "I don't eat onions." People : "What is your thoughts on the heavy taxes and govt acting as the sleeping partner?" Nirmala ji : "A sleeping partner won't answer the question here."

[@EdwinTyler]

People: do you have a brain, madam? Nirmalaji: if I don't have one can I answer that question?

[@R.K.3010]

@@EdwinTyler that's a good one

[@riturajanjana09]

People : Daughters are getting raped. Nimmo tai : I don't have daughters, So I don't care.🌚

[@swapnilsarode-s4q]

She doesn't deserve that "ji"

[@chotatopips4177]

@@swapnilsarode-s4q Nobody deserves a 'ji'. Especially politicians. Politicians exist to represent us. They are not some higher power. They represent the will of the people.

[@aloysiussaldanha3200]

Well done, these questions need to be answered. Compare with any other country- the taxes paid vs the facilities provided.

[@gnyanashree3344]

I purchased a Yoga Mat which was priced at Rs.889 that with profit margin not of the goods price ! And again had to pay Rs.160 CGST + SGST !.. I mean approx 200 extra for 900 not even worth product!... And he says he is promoting YOGA worldwide !... Tax slab is so worse for middle class All above 15 lacs pay 30% to govt !.. Even 1crore package or 2 crore ! ... With 15 lac today a person can't even afford a plot in an urban area but he is forced to pay 30% out of his pocket as direct tax ! .....

[@elena537743]

Thats one thing , we work our back off to get 8 % hike and in that too the govt snatches . Its like loan sharks waiting for your salary. I rhought bjp would change this but lately i came to conclusion that congress was atleast mindful of middle class people.

[@amlanjyoti2]

Hey, and don't forget about all the indirect taxes.

[@wisteria8791]

Dont pay . Thats simple . Lazy corrupts will not even send you any notice unless you earn 50 lakhs

[@elena537743]

@@wisteria8791 how do you not pay when you are a corporate govt knows your salary and directly connects.

[@wisteria8791]

@@elena537743 hm i didn't know. If you form a non profit organizatnaion then you can save a lot tax 😬

[@UPSCAspirant-s1c]

One side Beti bachao beti padhao another side 18% gst on education. Everyone would have to pay either you are a billionaire or daily wages labour

[@jaimourya9613]

Bro I support ki 18 percent is too high for education....but I would I also like to inform BETI BACHAO BETI PADHAO SCHEME is for GIRLS FROM POOR BACKGROUND .....FOR THEM GOVT. SCHOOLS ARE CONSTRUCTED AND TEACHERS IN GOVT TEACHERS ARE REALLY QUALIFIED....I MYSELF HAVE STUDIED FROM GOVT. SCHOOL TILL 12TH CLASS....AND I AM ALREADY A GRP B SERVICE OFFICER ...

[@ShubhamKumar-nl2ii]

It's on coaching

[@harshvardhan4771]

​@@jaimourya9613another important factor here is, which Government school? Some states have government schools performing better than ever, while in other states they are deteriorating even faster.

[@jaimourya9613]

​@harshvardhan4771 yeah that's very true.....I m from MP .....infrastructure in my school was not that good..but teachers were supportive ...

[@regal_lane]

​Bro, a majority of government schools in India don't even ensure a robust, holistic, and vibrant educational model No world-class pedagogical system , coupled with the lack of soft skill development. Many private schools fall in this category, leave these govt. schools.​@@jaimourya9613

[@vishnu1619]

Breakfast seller in hyderabad and banglore earning avg 1lakh to 6 lakh on monthly and paying 0 tax, what about them? Ask them to pay first

[@Jijitsuk]

80 cr people are getting free rations who have the calibre to ask questions to their masters.

[@astudent63]

That's really sad We have to provide almost 60% of our population free ration We have to work hard to provide them jobs either in organized sectors or unorganized sector just so they could afford basic amenities We have to provide the poor section's children quality education just so they can compete with the private school kids in entrance exams

[@priestf1964]

N.Sitaraman is Shameless. How shameless to smile when a citizen is asking genuine question and a public servant smiles and responds like that. Yukk.

[@FactsCountdown]

They are not servent as servent don't make laws of the land they are rulers as they make laws of the land and collect taxes from their slaves.

[@thehonestreviewindia]

Even Afghanistan has better services available! We server like South African Countries!

[@siddharthbhawsar2557]

Coming from middle class and having 100% legal income (business), I've to pay 18% GST and Income Tax, I'm already working for 4 months in a year for govt. Still no tax cuts, highest interest rates (Poor gets interest rates cut by govt, rich by banks), no govt facilities not even basic amneties. Now I get why businesses like Flipkart setup their HQs abroad.

[@R.K.3010]

Business put the burden of Tax on People they don't bear anything just increase the price of product whenever tax is increased.

[@Greek-b8y]

​​@@R.K.3010ask the govt to control taxes in the first place😂

[@themanwithnoname9578]

Not just flip kart. I have also left the shithole more than a decade ago. Now I'm a multimillionaire. Having business all over Western hemisphere and West Asia

[@paulsattarus114]

I actually feel ashamed as i daily sit with people who are divided among BJP vs Congress, i asked them what is this government doing, what are our MPs doing but nothing. Lets take a case the NGT ruling of the 10/15 year ban while people are taxed for the entire 15 years and the Sunfilm Ban rather than updating rules equipping the police with valid equipment, setting up proper Vehicle fitness centres, the critical thinking has gone down the drain. The mentality is if i can afford it doesn't matter to me. The Same Rajma, Dal, Chhole that was available for Rs. 60 per kg is touching Rs. 150 per kg nobody raises their voice. It is truly a shit country, shit judicial administration.

[@randomdude001]

Well said. Feels Pathetic tbh

[@Rudra-iq1ve]

True, everything can change but the sheer amount of population and their herd mentality can't

[@paulsattarus114]

@@Rudra-iq1ve Yeah another point i forgot, "population" we've surpassed china, some sort of 1 child rule needs to be passed. If you can't have a child, adopt one there are a lot of children who have lost their parents, adopt them. It is truly a shit show, seeing the grin on people when BJP, COngress, AAP wins make my blood boil because they are not voting for a candidate or a person who can be held accountable but a party whose representative for all they care is Rahul Gandhi, Modi or Kejriwal.

[@rakshitkumar2014]

Sadly we don't have any better alternative than BJP (at least not yet). Things were much worse during Congress rule. Inflation were 10-12% then. While right now its around 6%. No doubt BJP is bad but congress is worse. Having an unstable government could be a disaster in these uncertain times when there's multiple wars ongoing (Russia - Ukraine, Tension in middle east, China looking to invade Tiawan, risk of a world etc).

[@Rudra-iq1ve]

@@paulsattarus114 @paulsattarus114 True, we've surpassed china, and the main thing is that in just few cities the crowd is so dense that it feels suffocating, like really it puts pressure on mind . Sidewalks taken over by illegal shopkeepers, everything is so fked up that really even God would not be hoping that majority of Indians could improve. Nonetheless, these narrow minded people will never come out of the Bjp or congress mindset. Naman sir also knows this😂nothing can be done, because 145cr+ population is no joke and it is bound to collapse due to unavailability natural resources primarily and idiocracry secondarily

[@suji1103]

As a middle class working person my tax is deducted from source. I don’t mind even if the govt taxes me 50 percent. The problem is we are not getting anything in return.. I live in a BJP state before it was ruled by congress.. still the conditions of city roads are in same condition as its use to be. Drinking water same like it use to be ..municipal officials are corrupted same as it used to be.. I hardly see any difference. We middle class Indians are taxed right, left and centre

[@patrock11111]

We urban and salaried class are taxraped in india, on the other hand farmer income is untaxable in india, and all political parties support it bcoz these politicians declare themselves as farmers and do money laundering with it.

[@HarishChouhan]

Can't blame govt. or politicians. People deserve this. People spend so much time researching their next damn phone but have less idea about their local representative. Even with access to Internet, no one bothers to fact check so why you expect?

[@travellerrana9978]

The Man was voice to all the working class of India 😭

[@Hariiyaa]

Even on sanitary pads (basic need) it'z a worst nightmare fr underprivileged girls

[@shashanks631]

rich want that all girls & women become their commodity... these rich influential people & their allies r always in hunt for good looking girls & women.... india is a gone case... just name left of raam raajya, dharma and culture....

[@wonji5385]

What should be the tax structure ? Your thoughts.

[@judo2111]

​@@wonji5385 Find the loopholes, which are being used by people to escape tax. Then reduce the tax amount and make laws against people who are not paying taxes to reduce the indirect tax.

[@102679nc]

There are places where you can get them for very less price sometimes even free, please search.

[@p_HoE_niX]

Those people will move out to Dubai-Singapore. ​@@judo2111

[@ashugowda5284]

This is very true.. The middle class is being screwed in the name of tax.. So the incidences of stress amd psychomatic illness is raising.... This is a serious human rights issue that govt of India should bother about 😡😡

[@Dev_G07]

Yeah it's very shameless to not answer that important question which any finance minister should have answered it. We are paying 30% of tax from our salaries and then there is tax on interest income, dividend income, trading income besides GST and service tax. A salaried person is worst sufferer of the agony of financial mismanagement in this country.

[@MrBhavan006]

Only 30%? So lucky

[@sknbbx]

As Sam bahadur said, India. Soilders and army are not for construction work, its very sad that peeps from IAF are working for those money makers, its time to raise the mind of consumers. India needs great surge of awakening to happen

[@anilv3724]

Yes... He was the man, the legend and I wish I could go back and meet him 😢

[@CM-lw3qf]

Apparently, Mr. Manekshaw missed the memo from Julius Caesar lol

[@pradiptakudas4403]

Budhiya is not paying tax,she doesn't purchase anything .,askher the cost of edible oil

[@priyanshibhatt9146]

Correctly said. The main reason for all of this happening is "ignorance of people in politics". Every other person should learn and indulge themselves in some kinds of political matter for gaining experience as well as holding the "so-called leaders" accountable.

[@MonkeyLord-h6x]

Umm I don't think knowledge of these things will solve anything. Largest portion of Indian voters are are poor who pay least taxes but get max freebies and benefits from gov. What makes you think they will care about any of this? Also their consolidated votes have the power of making/breaking governments. That power is not held by middle class who cares about taxes.

[@shashankzode233]

It's not about BJP or Congress-the reality of taxation is undeniable. However, my issue is with the disparity: why is only 5% of the population paying taxes while the other 95% goes unquestioned? I'm willing to pay my share, but what do I get in return? Government hospitals are often inadequate, government life insurance options are lacking, and the quality of education in government schools is subpar. Until government services match the quality of private ones, it feels unjust to demand taxes without providing equivalent benefits. This is why I'm considering relocating to a country with zero or low taxes, where the system feels fairer.

[@amlanjyoti2]

Same here. This country is becoming unbearable to live in. I hope to move out too someday elsewhere. I hope you find what you desire soon 👍🏼

[@AnimeCritical]

When you find a better country to live in, let me know. In west, you will never be able to afford maid services like you do in India. Cleaning the house, cooking etc, all will need to be done by you. UPI ? Forget it. Digi Locker, DigiYatra? Good luck. Fast Tag? Maybe. Being able to call any service at home, via Urban Company etc. Groceries delivered at home? Sure buddy. Expensive food: Check. If you live in USA, gotta deal with homeowner's associans, gun violence, etc. You have no idea how good you have it here. Priviledge is invisible.

[@dr11_99]

​@@AnimeCritical and last but not least traffic rules😅

[@EdwinTyler]

​@@AnimeCritical most of my friends and relatives who moved to USA from India are happy. There are obviously some drawbacks but it's a developed country in the end and that's why so many people try to move there.

[@AnimeCritical]

@@EdwinTyler You really think that if they are unhappy there they will tell you? They know USA NRIs when they come to India have a lot of clout (which everyone loves). If they start saying they are miserable there, then they will lose all that. I will give you an example. There was a school near my place which was extremely renowned. For the children who did not study there, it felt like heaven, which they could not even dream of. Everyone said good things about that place. I was able to pass their entrance test and get in. I realized that this school was not even at the level of my previous school. Not only did my heaven get destroyed but my home (original school level facilities) was also taken. I was miserable. But then a few days later one of my neighbours asked about my new school. Without a second thought, I blurted, its a great school. I hope you are able to realize, things are not always what they seem. Grass is always greener on the other side.

[@SMGR201A]

Per Capita Tax Contributions for 2024-2025: 1. India: Total taxes: $382 billion Population: 1.41 billion Per capita tax contribution: $271/year 2. USA: Total taxes: $5.27 trillion Population: 334 million Per capita tax contribution: $15,775/year 3. EU (European Union): Total taxes (including social contributions): $5.55 trillion (approx.)​​​​ Population: 448 million Per capita tax contribution: $12,388/year 4. UK (United Kingdom): Total taxes: £978 billion ($1.22 trillion USD approx.) Population: 67.2 million Per capita tax contribution: $18,155/year​​.

[@multiple_applies]

My argument is about 18% gst in education is shameless, and high tax in educational commodities, both are an issue and should be discussed😊

[@varunadas]

We need a real think on why basic necessities like food, medicine, children clothing, education were bought under GST. Most developed countries charge Sales Tax as Value Added Tax and hence by definition only on items were a value is created like oranges are exempt but orange juice isn't as there is value created. I think most of bureaucrats sitting in that GST panel simply decided to put everything under GST and remove/reduce on some where there is fierce opposition - a very unscientific way of deciding allocation of GST. Remember the 28% GST slab on cement - how stupid it was ?

[@SURESH-rb6mi]

We purchased a projector for students gst is 28%,huge amount unbearable, i think rulers trying to push people to their extreme of limit...

[@sohailshaikh1334]

Her Husband was in Congress & She's in BJP. Hypocrisy ki bhi seema hoti hai🤣🤣

[@TamashaAurTareef]

Hello sir Shahid

[@Kush_Nitesh]

But Seema toh Sachin ka hai 😂

[@sageofsixpaths98]

Palki Sharma is pro BJP, and His husband Sanket is a Leftist reporter.

[@vivekanandapanda9166]

​@@Kush_Niteshit cell memeber spotted

[@multiple_applies]

Politician without principles is unworthy for Democracy regardless of of ideology and party

[@kakazkuim]

When she said I don't have any answer, the fools sitting there were laughing shamelessly, said reality, because taxes aren't effecting them.

[@Upanishadicsaint]

The worst thing is overpopulation and unconscious citizens Indians are not conscious about pollution, unpleasant noises, Rivers, cleanliness,quality of food . Poor still producing too many children, 1980s onward after Indira ji no govt. tried to control population for appeasement of some sections. We still need a strong government for a lot of good reforms a govt which works for the nation not for voters appeasement..

[@Rudra-iq1ve]

Overpopulation is really leading to make this hell a lot more hell.Only in fee years when the people will cripple unders its own population then they will understand

[@AriesGodOfWars]

Bhai the ones having children like rats are the peacefulls ola ki den wale toh kitna bhi social awareness blah blah le aao the status quo wont change ever.

[@WhatsUpBiyach]

Why are you always blaming on overpopulation.... Look at China, it is their human resource which made them what they are now.. After their strict "one child policy" led to declining population, now China wants more kids to be born but people are not interested to have large family. Dont listen to these old thoughts , a western school of thought which is a complete bogus just like climate changes a naturally occuring event blamed on mankind. Developing countries are being targeted so that the collective west can prolong their luxurious life for few more years. The World is too big for more men just the human hearts are too small and filled with greed. Overcome caste, religion, supremacist, sect, party based voting instead of independent candidate, we India can develop even if each family have 3 or 5 kids....

[@savezshaikh9820]

true .. bihari hindu fertility rate is highe thn kerala muslim rate accord to 2011 census ….

[@Amangupta-ut3sg]

​@@savezshaikh9820BIhari mushlim ka fertility rate pata hsi? Gawar... Yaha bhi hindu- mushlim shuru kr diya.

[@NRIAjay]

There is a moment when every boy realizes that there is no help coming in, no one is coming to save you, eventually, your parents will die, and you will become relatives of your own brother and sisters, that day the boy turns to be a man. few boys never see this and live the rest of their lives as children. Similarly people who don't understand what's happening in India now, How our own ignorance is leading all of us to a darker future, Not understanding finance and politics has impacted more INDIA than not understanding anything at all. Much appreciated your insights Naman. I hope to see the same fire in young adults especially 90s Kids. we are getting impacted the most.

[@mustafaalikhanmohammed1274]

I rarely comment on KZbin videos, but your intelligence, efforts to raise awareness using KZbin, and most importantly, your passion for truth have truly inspired me. Hats off to you, sir! Unfortunately, I am part of the 5% you mentioned.

[@Jainਸਹਿਬ]

Middle Class = Sandwich

[@IAS23-xt5tq]

We want a new political party!.... people are not that fool... people saw hope in new political party (Aam Aadmi Party) they voted for this party and now AAP is on the same track.... every ministers sons and daughters are enjoying the life of elite class....and lets not forget about our STEEL FRAME OF INDIA(CORRUPTION POOL OF INDIA) , at the time of UPSC CSE result interviews they only talk about "innovation and changes"....and then become puppet of government.... If these so called powerful people couldn't do anything how could we the people of India do with diverse personal interests😶

[@tube4vivek]

Country needs a movement to save middle class A political party formed by middle class people is the need of the hour

[@santhoshb.r5547]

when i joined a company as fresher my sal was 22000/ 7years before now i am paying 22000rs as tax every month but still no benefits i am receiving 😢

[@venusbansal]

My CA friend told me to pay taxes honestly and i send him the picture of a beautiful road made by the government.😅

[@ganeshshedole1245]

He said that because if you don't pay honestly than income tax officer will come to your home regularly degraded you as a money lender typically does in movies and in end you will have to pay penalty for not paying tax and in some cases you will end up in jail also after that no one will care only your family will suffer so technically these are the cost of living in society

[@gotohell78]

free revdis given to villages , 20 kgs of ration, and other things which are given free. all the youngsters in villages dont work , play cards, and say why to work when we are getting free food. i work late night to feed these juaris.

[@average312]

Ration items are procured from farmers at cheap rate. Not from you. Rather ask govt for good facilities.

[@jeniljebajosin5967]

why not question the tax breaks given to corporates which is in lakhs of crores ? Because tats the reason they employ mediocre workers in their MNC companies ?

[@akashdwipbiswas7445]

where do the govt get the money to buy the goods even if it is at cheaper rate?​@@average312

[@varunk6633]

Are you not worried about Nita Ambani purchasing 22 carat gold kitchenware? She flew to Sri Lanka in private jet to purchase it.

[@Vilecosmos]

Bro there was a saying: Every country deserves the leader it chooses. So glad I found you.

[@y1.5]

Unqualified finance minister..

[@PP-gp3wv]

Finance Minister need not be an educated one, Any dumbest elected/nominated politician can hold any portfolio, isn’t it in our country.

[@sankar-rl3zv]

Her qualification B.A in economics, MA and M.phil from JNU what other qualifications u need ?

[@Dvlogzilla]

​@@sankar-rl3zv I also studied economics in BA but does that make me qualified to sypmathize with the common man? You need to have a soul and we all know that the first thing politicians do is to sell their souls

[@dtvind]

@@sankar-rl3zv Sanghi found supporting Iyers

[@cryptoboyyt]

She only cares about her designation 😂

[@nishantbansal540]

Who can question the govt. And who will answer. We also live in a autocracy not a democracy if anyone looks in closely.

[@Noobfarmer_0]

Our country is going to become next Africa. These politicians and their sons daughters will loot and then they will move to another country.

[@HimanshuMahajan-zn3nq]

We live in autocracy 🤡

[@sarthakgothalyan8952]

​@HimanshuMahajan-zn3nq we dont live in autocracy 🤡

[@HimanshuMahajan-zn3nq]

@@sarthakgothalyan8952 bada hoja bhai pehle..duniya dekhni hai tuze bhot abhi

[@amlanjyoti2]

True

[@prabhattripathi7827]

Thank you for raising your voice on this topic. Now im gonna forward this video to my dumb friends

[@allley11]

Thanks

[@SumitKumar-xk9ix]

What you just paid, is it taxable?😂😂😂😂

[@ThDaniel]

Biggest Jhumla Party does not answer anything to public. They speak only to corporates through electoral bonds 😂

[@gaurav_34]

The problem is no other better party is there

[@ajaynaithani1]

Tere papa logon ne bhi liya tha electoral bonds se paisa😅😅😅

[@akshaybengaluru1212]

Congress receive 1600 crores with power in only 3-4 states. 56% of electoral bonds were received by opposition parties with power in 12-14 states. BJP is in power in 18 states, union government and received 44% of electoral bonds. Jhumla is done by opposition parties.

[@tagore161]

The problem with people like you is your religious and ideological bias blinds you to everything good bjp has done but makes your mind amplify all its negatives, thus noone can take you seriously

[@brucewayne357]

​@@gaurav_34opposition is better

[@ayushrajbhatt110]

Leaving the country is the solution bcoz it will take more than 20+ years of time india getting into good place.

[@himanshuagrawal4698]

Also talk about the misinformation in our country, how data is being manipulated and people are having an illusion of success.

[@ajaynaithani1]

Tu hi bata de sahi information...gyaani baba😅😅

[@himanshuagrawal4698]

Good work, You are equivalent to the modem day Bhagat Singh, Spreading awareness no matter how dumb people come and comment without prior knowledge. If you ever start a movement or do something else, then I'll be glad to sign up as a volunteer and help.

[@rb5720]

Electricity charges raised by 4 times....now I am paying 10,12 thousand per month ....earlier used to pay 3000 per month.

[@rocks7688]

Tax is Punishment in British Raj Since 1851 Act. I am highly educated unemployed but still paying taxes why ??😢😢

[@ChandanKumar-xw8gl]

Why the heck you are paying tax??

[@xtreme6409]

​@@ChandanKumar-xw8glGST

[@focusonselfbetterment]

I am paying tax on my invested money that I saved in years ,though at present I'm not working ​@@ChandanKumar-xw8gl

[@umabisht3588]

Yes, even everyone is paying tax irrespective of what they do, through GST, income tax etc

[@Stickman-rz9nu]

@@ChandanKumar-xw8gl even after watching the video you had to ask that ? how much IQ do you have ? 10 ? 20 ?

[@sukhibanur6502]

She is a woke FM . Shame on her

[@naytonfernandes2991]

You cannot make negative comment on minister......

[@BandelaSimon]

Yep we can​@@naytonfernandes2991

[@devbhise]

@@naytonfernandes2991 They are also ordinary public servants, the only difference that they are sitting at the highest level and as per consitution of india and the binding of accountability they are entitled to be criticised and answerable to it

[@rohitaryan7245]

​@@naytonfernandes2991 says who?

[@divyamsingh579]

​@@naytonfernandes2991why not??

[@GODSenpaiXD]

I’ve been asking the same question from 10 years that the tax system doesn’t make sense

[@Rock_y2021]

This is why PM hasn't done a Single Press Conference in his tenure.

[@neerajnagi4231]

Anpadh hai , teleprompter padh leta hai itna hi kafi hai

[@Bigdave123]

Nirmala thinks it's a kitty party...

[@santhoshbosco7158]

Look at her arrogance and meking fool of a citizen asking a valid question....is this why we voted BJP? The oerson who dont have an IOTA of idea about the taxing and its impacts is sitting as finance minister....

[@imnavo1]

What is the next step? Everything stops after only discussions and complains.

[@sharathmanya8964]

Hundred Percent True. Voice of Middle Class doesn't matter. No wonder, people don't want to continue working here. The chances of middle class becoming financial independent is becoming difficult day by day.

[@utubevideos3317]

This video must become viral get billions of views! People should become one against this taxation 😡

[@priyank5939]

Sleeping partner is sleeping even dont have answers for their own policies.Irony

[@Aiyaz17]

It hurts even more when i see our money getting used to build statue's which aren't even of any utility or can't even generated enough income to sustain itself, My tax money is being paid to Indian Air force which play a role of contructor and labour worker when needed for this private parties and wedding. wow i am amazed...

[@harishetty4]

Today we have what ever that you look around due to tax payers. Until corruption exists at the lowest to highest level, tax money will always never be sufficient for th government. Create a movement to curb corruption.

[@gautamsharma4959]

The citizens along with the government should be blamed for all the crisis. I have seen many videos of people claiming that they will blindly cast their vote for the same political party even if prices of commodities get roof high and even if they have no money left to feed their families.

[@arpittalmale6468]

She is shamless. Just doing ha ha ha he he he. she totally outoff mind.

[@noturtype3803]

wow...S Jaishankar's son is not indian...jst wow

[@sathishkumar-dt4zc]

I pay so much tax but dont have roads, electricity, drainage and healthcare areas in my City

[@brevitygreaves2321]

Where is that city which doesn't have roads?? Or electricity??

[@sathishkumar-dt4zc]

@@brevitygreaves2321 come to Chennai South

[@sathishkumar-dt4zc]

@@brevitygreaves2321 Medavakkam Chennai, ruled by DMK thug Ravi. All streets are named after his family members. Despite so many residents, it is still controlled by panchayat but surrounding suburb is under Chennai corporation

[@brevitygreaves2321]

@sathishkumar-dt4zc And yet I can see plots for sale in the village of Medavakkam listed on the internet, meaning that it's being developed as a suburb of Chennai. Roads are being dug up to lay sewage pipes. Power cuts are common outside urban areas of cities. Doesn't mean it has no roads or electricity, does it?

[@sathishkumar-dt4zc]

@@brevitygreaves2321 roads have been in the same state for the last five years because continuous construction of bridges, sewages, pipelines, under ground electric lines due to poor planning, but this is only main roads we are talking. If you look at the street roads, they are horrible, even a poor village anywhere in India will have better roads, when it rains, my street is easily flooded with drainage water and you can feel the strong stinking smell inside the house. hence sanitation is the biggest issue in my area. We have complained so many times to the village office but they just don't care. Regarding electricity, my main board got burned recently because of high voltage fluctuation, when we checked, the output was close to 500 volts, this is insane, our street has around 50 houses yet we don't have a transformer

[@ayushramwani2]

Tbh sir, I was sitting on the fence whether to attempt upsc or not, I had settled for ssc, but the sheer dystopian state of my nation made clearer than before by YOU, is the driving energy for me to put my efforts to enter the system and correct it, even if this didn't happened I solemnly swear that I'll enter politics and become the kind of candidate that INDIA needs. And ofcourse HAIL SRIVASTAVA 💥🔥

[@officiallegenderyboy8138]

Businesses should also pay taxes on their profits only if the government is willing to compensate them for their losses.

[@nibhasingh8335]

Why everything is free for politicians...be it house, servants, food, fuel...

[@Kaivalya-yv5ld]

Yeah Naman Bhaiya I also higlighted these facts in front of my own family and they got against me saying ki tu COngress ka dis and that. I realized at that very moment it is not that our older generation can be changed but the change have to start from the seed that will be turning into giant protecting all the small sapling and plant. You are doing incredible work keep doing #SpokepersonofIndia.

[@ajaynaithani1]

During congress rule 100% people were paying taxes??????

[@Kaivalya-yv5ld]

@@ajaynaithani1 Does it matter?? Congress is also so damn corrupt but so is BJP who gives a fuck fuck I am paying 25% of my profit as tax and it is not me lakhs if not crores and I have right to know. IF goverment is using my money to make captailist or industrialist rick. I am going to raise question if you want only congress to answer and not BJP good keep doing that.

[@Raaj913]

Changing government will do nothing even if you change it it will go in freebies

[@Kaivalya-yv5ld]

@@Raaj913 Yes totally agree we will change the indivduality

[@asmitaupadhayay]

I agree! When we criticize govt. People take it so personally. Also, the only statement other person gives is 'WHAT ABOUT SO AND SO PARTY?' It's not about party, it's about nation. The motives parties is not equal to demands if nation... idk when will we understand that. 🇮🇳

[@chaitanyak4150]

I bumped into your videos randomly, and your videos share feelings that a common person face everyday. Thank you for touching these topics and sharing them with larger audiences.

[@Abhisheksingh-cl3bn]

People get the leader they deserve..

[@Dr.NancyMBBS]

India need more youth like you .We should not remain aloof from politics.Most of the youth loves being apolitical .Thats where the problem arises .They don't have idea about indirect taxes .How they will question the government

[@manfromdownunder8407]

well if you support any party, others will attack you, hence do whatever you want while voting....just dont tell others for peace.

[@nachi1588]

When people start voting for candidates and not their religion, if the person has not worked everyone should vote NOTA so the candidates cannot fight. Congress is not good for India they will keep playing Hindu Muslim. Bjp is busy in marketing and blaming Congress.

[@shahbajalam6776]

Even if we come across indirect tax , the price mentioned on the bills, receipt and products does not give us information about how much tax we are paying on it or not even what bracket of taxation it come under. Because its very easy to fool fellow Indians just by writing (inclusive of all taxes) at the back.

[@Karmanya101]

I do not know Finances much nor Taxation, but after relocation from US (after 15+yrs) to India, I was told by a Big Tax consulting company .. "your tax will not be so complicated as you will Pay more tax in India than US, so you can claim that in your US tax filing". In US, I can (and have done so) emailing and via voice mail communicated with my US Rep about some issues, Not sure if it can be done in India, and interestingly I received a nice letter from my Rep about thanking me for contacting his office :) feels good that they at least listen. Some Rep are true to their words ..and take up the issue, others just ignore if its not profitable for them. Long time back, or ages back.. I wanted to try my hand at UPSC and try to join IPS. That dream died on the vine. Hope you guys become a Good bureaucrats and serve India well.

[@simplymirage]

You are amazing Naman. I like your videos, but how can we all work to make it a reality? Just curious?

[@surajbandal1422]

she is shameless dont care about anything ...should be changed for better economy

[@pritishpatil7659]

Unpopular opinion: the day Indian youth stops chasing UPSC and government jobs and open businesses or work in private jobs instead, if the day India will truly March towards developed country.

[@abhishekmukherji8620]

Youth chasing govt jobs on reservation basis can never be a developed country.

[@sundars6771]

They don't develop proper infrastructure and road. But we pay tax.

[@Narendra_Bikaner]

This will be an eye opening video for those arrogant, ignorant people. 👍💯

[@vaibhavrajput6084]

Exactly that is what i asked nitin gadkari ji in his comment sections😂. Once he said in an interview, we are collecting tax only from those who have cars, one who have car cannot be said as poor. How can a fortuner owner and a alto, desire or any under 10 lakh car owner who bought that car on loan be the same? It means nitin gadkari ji who drives a toyota mirai and i who owns a under 10 lakh car, we both are same no matter even if i use CNG i will pay same toll or road tax😢😢😢

[@sanskaryadav8876]

The problem of our country is when you saying against the government supporter of government will say go to Pakistan and you are anti-national and if you support any good work of government then you are declared Anad bhakt people aren’t thinking of development of nation and no debate is going on regarding education, health, unemployment, underemployment, women security and so on But for our country’s media debate on Hindu, Muslim, Mandir, Masjid, Caste and so called jati debate are more important then the real issues of nation