India's World: IMF Scrutiny for Pak

[@vipulbisht620]

Summary Pakistan tax to gdp ratio is lowest in the world approx. 10% ~70% of their tax collection goes to their army. Pakistan's foreign exchange reserve are about $ 8B which is less than nepal, Bhutan, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh etc which are much smaller countries. And above this a huge debt is built on pakistan because of CPEC . PM Imran khan backed by Pakistani army asked Saudi Arabia for loans but they put conditions such as helping them in their shia- sunni war with Yemen and Israel. This was not acceptable to pakistan as this would have bring the Shia sunni war to their home. Lastly they are trying to get loans of upto $10B from imf. Concerns- US fears that the loans will be used to pay back Chinas loan and fund taliban in Afghanistan. India's concerns are that the funds will be diverted to their terrorist activities in Kashmir. Imf conditions greater transparency in china's CPEC agreement and the spending of the loans Background - since 1980 pakistan has asked for imf loans 14 times and each time the conditions in Pakistan worsened and they again look for a bailout Way forward for pakistan 1.) reduce their defence spending in terrorist activities 2.) increased role of government 3.) tax on high nett worth individuals and businesses 4.) open their borders for trade with india 5.) more spending on Social activities and reduce their dependence on China

[@kevinminion5958]

@learning freak please correct your first statement. Actually its Tax to GDP ratio. For eg. if India's tax to GDP ratio is 21%, it means that the government gets 21% of its GDP as tax contribution from the public and entities.

[@vipulbisht620]

@@kevinminion5958 ok thanks

[@chandanchoubey4691]

Grand Salute to you for this effort....

[@NeerajKumar-xt3uk]

Great

[@sandeepsingh-py1ef]

Great description... Looking forward for such description of urs in every debate

[@vidushipandey6290]

What a well executed debate 👏👏

[@agni_7897]

Imagine Arnab hosting this.

[@vidushipandey6290]

Agni _ he’ll not take up such an intellectual topic in the first place itself..secondly he’ll not let anyone speak.

[@agni_7897]

Yeah, that's what I meant. The contrast between this program & his.

[@parminderps8251]

If america and India takes hardline against him what option will be left for them

[@agni_7897]

Durga, I'm not comparing the media, just the manner in which the program is conducted.

[@beninvijay]

CONDITIONS 1. IMF Will directly pay the bills. 2. Defence Will get only salary bills. 3. All defence related plants should be on pay off. Including nukes. 4. Terrorist should be handed over 5. No payment for CPEC

[@jishnupradeep9764]

Dr. Sreeram Chaulia has a perfect notion on his knowledge...great sir..

[@luckysky1876]

The finest discussion takes place at this news channel.... No shouting..... 100% discussion and putting down your point...

[@Travel_anand]

Lucky Sky yes pure discussion no bullshit

[@rohitk7202]

All this is head ache for india for sure, what a great neighbour

[@studywithbhaskar]

This channel is the best

[@HRHKamal]

Brilliant discussion. The panellists hit the core reasons for pak's eternal mess bang on. And very correctly , did not see much hope for its recovery from the deep shit it's been in for decades. Thanks to Frank & the panellists.

[@anakarnayak9246]

A nation formed on basis of Religion which was stripped of it's own glorious past and made to believe that it's the descendants of Arabs,a nation who's still searching for democracy,a nation who unnecessarily got entangled in Superpower rivalry and welcomed disaster itself. It's painful to see them like this,they were us some years before. Be it Bhagat Singh or Sikh Gurus,Lahore was their Karma Bhoomi. The Fun fact is India/Hindu/Hindustan named after Indus majority of which flow in Pakistan..

[@MrPrasunroy]

very well written....

[@jamesmicheal4814]

Nailed it

[@tejwanichander]

excellent narration

[@sumitsharma0452]

Thank god for Indian leaders. Despite all our flaws, we aren't in such bad conditions begging globally again and again! Till Army comes under democratic forces in Pakistan, this country can't have any good future.

[@hvsmanral9320]

Bravo Ambassador Dayal-- Very Judicious Observation Indeed! Ambassador (Rtd) HVSManral.

[@allaud-dinkhiliji2720]

money which is going to be taken from imf will be use for biryani party ....

[@subhankarsingha.]

ahahahahhahaa

[@Travel_anand]

🤣🤣👌 that too of donkey meat 🍖 I

[@karan200590]

fabulous discussion, dutta and chauliya are sharp minds.

[@Skandawin78]

Excellent panel of wise men.

[@subhranshuchaulia]

Thank you rstv .

[@bhardwajparitosh]

very nice discussion..Good points Sreeram :)

[@MrutyunjayJoshi]

Dr. Shreeram gave a very strong reply. 0% apologetic

[@Gagarin8294]

Loved the enriching debate thoroughly...

[@spookyandsmokey]

Frank utilizes every second of the 30 minutes to the last (sometimes more but never too less) which is commendable imo. Frank you're the best!

[@chaubeysworld3757]

Guests really know what they are talking...nice one :)

[@LalitYadav-hp4kg]

Thank you very much rstv

[@AdityaKadamMechanical]

Nice to see a college dean being called for discussion :)

[@kunalverma2790]

Frank bro really like the way you calmly conduct such discussion, better then most especially on private channels.

[@raushankumar2529]

I think Pakistani mango people should watch this debate instead of watch debate of their fool expert . Very expressive,clear and factual about the Pakistan's condition.

[@Nobody-tk6fz]

Decades of inbreeding, madrassa education, and state-sponsored radicalization and creeping islamization in every aspect of life including school textbooks has ensured that this type of discussion will not have any effect on them, half of them wont understand it and the other half would not be rational enough to understand and absorb the facts.

[@radheshyamsingh1866]

Thanks Frank Sir 🙌 you're a nice host!

[@snr5950]

Thanq Mr Frank for hosting a wonderful n educative discussion Pakistan n the prospects of IMF bail-out....

[@bhadrabalraj5536]

Ambassador had very good points,Frank excellent as usual Well executed debate

[@rashmir7305]

Perfect discussion

[@rish2197]

7:32 official use of 'CHUTSPAA' 😂😂

[@HRHKamal]

Hahahaha! Actually, the word he used is " chutzpah"

[@HRHKamal]

Lol!

[@goal6640]

very good discussion

[@amreshkumar7860]

what a fantastic show!!!

[@samcall930]

0.5m taxpayers in a country of 200m!!!...

[@marcusdanizel9816]

Hahahahaha people over there don't trust on government or politics Main reason Pakistan is second North Korea coumminst shit type

[@akhildev7939]

Frank did a wonderful job as usual, good debate

[@mundeniks1]

From panelist discussion I found out that best carrier in Pakistan 1. Join army 2. Join terrorists group 3. Cricket 4. Politicians

[@shyamdubey6212]

Marvelous Stan off

[@DrLavleshYadav]

Very Nice debate..Wish Pakistanis could see it..& i think Pakistani people deserves this all bcz they are the one who making all these organization (govt,ISI, army, etc) & as people not opposing all these organization means they r indirectly supporting them..So they are the main culprit & they hv to suffer for it

[@ninjarao79]

This What Happens when in country "Military Ltd Companies" Do better then Country itself . CPEC Contracts Benefits going to Military on Public Money, Wow ! .

[@mundeniks1]

Educated mind best productive discussion ever, why regular new channel have such standards

[@sikandarzaidi4561]

Prabu dayal is the best

[@munnancs]

good discussion.

[@abhisheksingh3819]

To the point...

[@abxexceptional]

excellent debate

[@mu9063]

I AM LIKE THIS TYPE OF CHANNEL.

[@subhamdwivedi4975]

I think india should help pakistan by defeating their army and destroying their resources badly

[@snowman2647]

Good thinking

[@TheALPHAGAMABETA]

From 2002 to 2015 all indians including their senior analyst were saying on the main media and social media that Pakistan will not exist on the map by 2015. Now they are saying Pakistan is done by the economy is in crisis they have lol Listen you indians we are here and we are going to stay you like it or not. Pakistan Zindabad.

[@umairkhalid2071]

Only pakistan is discussing here.PROUD TO BE PAKISTANI

[@amarnathtripathi5950]

Excelent analysis and solution. Strategically it is imperative for us to see that state of Pakistan is always bogged down on domestic day to day issues. Their Army, even if it goes silent for a few years will never ever give up its links with terrorism and they will rise again and create problems for us once their economy stabilizes. It is in the interest of India to either see Pakistan disintegrate into several nation states or else ensure, Pakistan is forced to think all the time, from where the next morsel is going to come from.

[@gautamsachdev7216]

👌👌

[@chandrashekharchauhan4120]

Hope the awaam of Naya Pakistan watch this and understand where they are headed.. The army is the biggest obstacle between development and Pakistan.. But they are unfortunately seen as heroes in pak

[@Travel_anand]

IMF Bailing out Pakistan sounds like west paying for their own mutilation 😀

[@Gagarin8294]

Imf addict...good keyword

[@fazalmalik2884]

Jeet hamisha pak ki hogi...

[@ZenithSSX]

of-course !

[@rajunaik26]

Honeymoon period over for Imran kan.

[@imrank340]

Prabhu Dayal should keep his sentimental views, and restrain dishing out opinion 'do's and don't' simply not in the favour of India's well being, if the country sucked into its own oblivion IS their own prerogative. While our soldiers dying on Border on LOC, Saikat has spoken out the very factual scenario of nuclear-armed weapons and its reprecautions.

[@mohitKumar-br3nr]

Please provide hindi medium also....

[@kundandhayade5301]

Gazba e Musalman, Ya Allah Pakistan ko dojat me lejao, jahnnum ki aag me jalao . insha Allah pakistan ke 1000 tukade honge. Insha Allah pakistan ki serjamin Hindu🚩🕉️🏆🇮🇳 vo ka parcham jabtak Allah is kayanat me he tab tak lahrata rahega.

[@mukeshsingh-gl4os]

nice

[@TheSrinathgold]

1.Reduce army to 50% 2. Take control of ATOM BOMB Locations 3. Train civil servants to work neutral. 4. Remove religion from the text books. 5. Flush out all terrorists in to the sea or deserts. 6. Monitor all above activities for the next 20 years. As far as Kashmir is concerned, it will fade away automatically without any war with Pak. Above may change society at least in the next 30 years.

[@Raushankumar-of4qd]

this is how debate should be not like arnab goswami shouting like mad man

[@prof_amit]

Sir,Will america's stand against Pak will not change after India's S-400 deal with Russia?? Will america be more soft with Pak now and will let them take loans from IMF to counter India???

[@radheshyamsingh1866]

Pak should poise relations with India, which is the only way for a better tomorrow! This is only achievable when Pak is governed by it's common people and not by Army.

[@Skandawin78]

Wow , never knew RajyA Sabha TV comes with such excellent panel discussions. Time to ditch ndtv,republic and subscribe for their TV channel.

[@beninvijay]

INDIA, US,JAPAN, FRANCE, & UK SHOULD DRAFT THE CONDITIONS TO SIGN THE Bailout or they should vote against

[@1inipi]

IMF credits are always used to pay off outrageous interest rates of previous imf loans. And the conditions imposed by the IMF on the receiving country aims to support impoverish the poor and make the Wall Street companies very wealthy. It is also not in the IMF interest that the receiving county ever will be able to pay back the loans and become independent again. This is not democratic at all. I disagree with the former Ambassador on the statement that the IMF has no transparency of the Pakistan financial situation. They have their loyalists are controlling the national bank, ministery of finance and economic.

[@michaelscott3190]

KARMA AT WORK.

[@abhibittu16]

Now it's up to IMF to direct the Pakistan in the right direction of progress

[@aquaknight21]

i guess the lion has more roar than bite.

[@aquaknight21]

the problem is not mismanagement, the problem is inherent to the banking system/ not only is credit created from a small amount of currency reserves, literally from thin air. it also creates interest, a by product that never grows old nor shrinks, while all other things you buy with debt does. so if the debt is created from a small amount of currency and it causes interest, where is the currency that pays for the interest of the debt will come from when you have a system that inherently has more credit than currency. we are living a big lie thru this banking system and the longer we stay in it, the bigger the collapse will be.

[@ravisingh-mk5uw]

saudi has given 20billion dollar package to Pakistan.

[@keepquiet6750]

One naval blockade is enough to wipe out Pakistan economically

[@hitenvakharia1640]

Perhaps three condition IMF should apply should be stop cpec and terrorism military spending

[@deepakv21]

While i agree with views of panalists I'm little sceptical as Pakistanis are facing this issue since 1980 & every time they find something to work around.

[@69bobr]

It's the WILL of Allah!! 🙏🙌🙏 JAI HO!!! 🙌😁🙌

[@Education-id5cx]

Sir जी ये episode हिंदी में नही आयेगा

[@Mudda_aajka]

Adarsh Pandey nhi ayga Bhai

[@azogdefiler86]

watch desh desantar

[@flanker53]

pakistani people watch how debate should be done....

[@ay6401]

I am damn sure our coming generations will read in their history courses the topic "modern colonialism " and the case study would certainly be Pakistan ( being colony of its master China).

[@veewakeworld8910]

Is there any concern for India if Imf rejected Pakistan loan??

[@meatwad74]

all painfully true facts. But unfortunately all countries have very deep and disturbing facts. If Pakistan didn’t have nukes, they would have followed suit of Iraq, Syria. Many countries would have invaded by now. Russia, India, u.s. Most military come from Punjab, so even the common people there are intertwined with the military. Those who have resisted, are subdued very quickly. Afghanistan has been a very troublesome neighbor for Pakistan also, and a big cause of problems. I live in u.s and can tell u that u.s and especially under trump, is such a cauldron of state run hypocrisy, corruption and criminality that it baffles the mind. And to see them use them use military and economic tactics to ruin other countries, and even their own people is beyond imagination. I guess the British passed on the mantle to them after ww2.

[@annukumarsingh4905]

Imran khan also none as dubicate pathan ...

[@samabala6348]

Let Pakistan intellectuals listen to this talk than talking for themselves... their endless stupid talk will take the countrie's economy in to quagmire.

[@Nobody-tk6fz]

You can only wake up people who are sleeping, not people who are pretending to sleep.

[@bashirbarak9495]

Now india must praper for Pakistans refugees

[@arungupta9265]

*ek Baar KO tou lug raha tha kee BHAINSSAYN BEYCHNAY sey hee kaam chalaa leyngey ye dhaqqann >> purr sub nautanqee thee .*

[@jdjcickrhxjf5597]

U have stomachache?.checkout it may be labour pain.

[@subhashchanderbhalla1687]

Pakistan main tread is that of contact killer which is not perpetual business ostensibly having no regular income nor collateral to offer as net worth is negative -liabilities and loans are more than the tenable Assets besides if bailout is given it will again be invested in non profitable venture i e Army , the Generals will wine and dine and ask for more loan result in multiply loan faster than bacteria as income will be so meager to repay even fraction of Interest not to think of Principal and multiplier factor fast Pakistan will remain in viscous circle like death well in Circus under such apprehensions and untenable contentions offered by Pakistan how come its bailout package can be considered by IMF with sympathetically consideration and sanction written with far smother pen

[@shivkumartalks]

Pak 10 see bhi below ho Jaye in tax collection

[@Amitvlogs4u]

Anchor sahahb aj shave krke aye he

[@ravishankar1972]

IMF is funding a country which is bankrupt and has nuclear weapons. Pakistan has lot of crazy people who put their ego over the economy and their people. It is clear and obvious that IMF want Pakistan to have nuclear weapons at any cost, otherwise why they will fund Pakistan for a long time. It is history now. Too many bail outs with Pakistan. I am sure Pakistan will sell nuclear weapons to Saudi Arabia or Iran or both or some other country to come out of this crisis. Nuclear weapon or Nuclear waste sale is inevitable for the time being, it is difficult to guess who is that buyer who is willing to pay the chunk of money that Pakistan is looking for? Money will be raised through hawala route via Dubai. What they are saying out side is Saudi wants Pakistani Soldiers for Yemen conflict is a lie. Actually Saudi and Iran has asked nuclear weapons from Pakistan. This is the truth of the discussion. India has lot more to worry about Pakistan because we don't want a bankrupt neighbor who has nuclear weapon running around crazy for money. Americans can ask Pakistan to surrender their nuclear weapon in exchange of bail out. This is a possible option for Pakistan and America. I don't think Americans will never get this kind of option or opportunity to take over the nuclear weapons from Pakistan.

[@jishnupradeep9764]

Pakistani politicians must understand instead of blabbering brotherhood and becoming slaves of china , you should open trade with India, opt for the opportunity instead of your dirty stinky ego and envy . It's foolishness thinking friendship bw india and pakistan is imposible just because we have fought 4 major war and many battles.i hope you remember WW 2, where whole europe fought, after the battle they understand they have to stay together for betterment and development, so they became european union and still working as a single nation. They together made fighter jets and military equipments. Here in Asia india is going ahead with great visions and plan ans becoming a global power, pakistan is trying cross indian boarder ,. China is playing like a intel prostitute who try get land of neighbors inch by inch, srilanka behaving like keep of china playing family politics by updating nations constitution like mobile phone software update,bhutan no vdo development but happiness index development.... No interested in cooperation and collaboration but to become like backbitching aunties....

[@garamiglm2026]

Stop being Angrez..speak normally God damnit I am a proud Indian, but it is sad to see our language taken to trash.. so lets please do something about it.

[@71espn]

Which Indian language should they speak in? Kannada, Malayalam, Bengali, Tamil, Telegu

[@garamiglm2026]

Have you heard of Hindi??.. Is it too much to learn? I guess their personal Punjabi, Telugu, Kannada, Tamil, and dozens more are too precious to forget.. So how about we only speak a language of 10000 miles away, right? There is a saying - You can take a man out of bondage (slavery) , but not bondage out of man... Does this apply to a country of 1 + billion ? i thinkso.. Interestingly we have to use English to stop talking English..lol

[@Globalscanningeyes]

Pakistan military Pakistan military Pakistan military Pakistan military essentially the debate about pakistan military