India's World : India-Russia Bilateral Relationship

[@kavyalakshmi2186]

The professor should be called more often on all rstv shows . He's like a treasure trove of knowledge and vision.

[@manvendrasinghgaharwar2041]

A fabulous pannelist and his explanation is tremendous . I really thank to rstv

[@VikasNathvikasN900]

Russia is our most trusted friend and parnter.

[@indranilmandal4496]

So much to learn from these panelists and the host is just awesome ..keep it up

[@TheHarharmahadev]

The best channel for international relationship. Kudos to frank sir and his team

[@sabarishbhasi5221]

immense respect for the uploader, such wonderfulll discussion. thank u .

[@dasham8963]

Be brave, Indians. Soon dollar and America will be ruined. And you'll become very rich! You're not alone. Russia is with you. Russians ALWAYS win . Russians never were slaves and never lost great wars

[@prasadlonari4297]

Very True Daira M. We are Looking Forward.The Days are Nearer that Russia & India will Rule the World & Powerfull Strongest economy in the world.🇮🇳🇮🇳🇷🇺🇷🇺 💪💪

[@jamesmicheal4814]

Daria We trust Russia more than USA With love and respect to russia from India

[@sauravpaul1075]

Not always but many, yes won. Japan defeated you guys in 1905, Crimean war, WWI, Afghanistan, Polish war to name a few. However, Russia is way better than USA, that part is true.

[@dasham8963]

No, you are mistaken. Finally Russians joined Poland to Russian Empire. Catherine the Great did it. Although before it the Polish had burned Mosсоw. Crimean War was a part of BIG war with Ottoman Empire, which had lasted for 400 years. Britain was an ally of the Ottomans. Finally Russians ruined Ottoman Empire and later USSR ruined British Empire. Russians didn't lose the War with Japan. It was a draw. Draw is parity, peaceful agreement. Generally, Russians were about to win, but Americans financed first Russian revolution 1905-1907, that's why Russians decided to make a draw with Japan. But draw is not a defeat. And later during WWII Russia occupied several Japanese islands, joined them to Russia. In the 1st World War Russia occupied Iran, Iraq, was about to occupy Bosphorus Strait. Americans again financed revolution in Russia in 1917 to prevent our victory. Because of that revolution Russia collapsed in 1917. WWI ended in 1918. But anyway, our enemy Germany lost WWI and paid reparations. Pro-America Afgans lost 20 times more people than Russians did. It isn't defeat. Japan lost 2 times more people than Russians, Germans in WWI also lost twice as much as Russians. By the way in 1904 Russia protected China. Japanese attacked China, that's why Russia announced war to Janan. Russia never lost wars. Some battles - yes. Wars - never. Now our aim is to ruin USA

[@SS-yg6jw]

India needs USA. Only US can help us in keeping away China.

[@akhileshsemwal235]

best telivision discussion. great work big picture

[@adityamotsara9067]

🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 friendship cherish long...

[@satyanandtripathi1119]

Awesome discussion

[@trivedhkaruturi7481]

What a clean discussion!

[@GenAsthanaAnalyses]

Dear Mr Gupta, I appreciate your interest in 1962 war. Reference your comments and all replies given in response, I would still suggest to you that Henderson Brooke- Bhagat Report is only one version of the war. There are six more versions of the records with us and our historians have visited all US archives you are referring. Our experience with US archives is that they give westernised version. As you have been in US for so many years, the western bias is understandable. I would humbly suggest that you can get in touch with me through my website and we can have a meaningful discussion , instead of wasting time of others who may not be interested in the subject. The fact that I gave you the name of the officer who flew first Mig 21 from Tashkent to Chandigarh, I don't think the fact can be refuted unless you give evidence to the contrary, instead of prolonging conversation by diverting it. You can find me as Shashi Asthana in all social media platforms or just google my name. Gen Asthana

[@jamesmicheal4814]

I think if Russians has no issues It must invite Indians to immigrate To Russia It will be a win win game for both nations

[@sauravpaul1075]

I live in Darjeeling, it's 10 degree C, decembers sometime go below 0 (rarely). I have heard Russians think of that temperature as summer.

[@hullagtpp]

Why do you think America lets immigration happens ? That is also for its own interest, sorry to say - taking our talent pool only for selfish purposes ofcourse - stats say so .. i don't. ( oh and sorry for 1 year late reply)

[@ramgovindyadav7532]

Superb ...

[@nitinsatao7646]

awesome discussion in all perspective......

[@amitnara2610]

May be we will sign agreement like lemoa with Russia as well

[@prateekakkanawru5273]

Thank you for great insights.

[@user-hm3bb9de1u]

Russia Indians best friend

[@avi-up9kl]

Nice sir .👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌

[@raghavendraa1857]

tck x yes u are right ....the contemporary problems that India faces is rise in crude oil price ....and due this dollar dominated system we are harmed than getting benefits....understand from November we will not be able buy crude oil from Iran ....we are facing the heat of petroleum price rise....why is America not helping India in this issue....?india is facing energy crisis and Russia built 2 nuclear reactors and 4 on the way and understand that it is better to trust aged mother than sexy girlfriend....we saw this ethernal friendship in 1971 war where Russia took side and supported India....in 1998 Kargil war America did not not give radars for India and also they supplied the same to Pakistan...and we faced lots of causalityes ....and even today Russia vetos Pakistan resolution of kashmir issue....I really want to say India may be formidable today but this formidable power was nurtured by Russia ...and we should not forget that....lots of respect for Russia 🇷🇺 🙏🏿

[@ankushanand5931]

awsm

[@nikhiljha00]

100% indigenous defence product and large scale production can only solve India defence industry problem.

[@vijaychauhan-zp4rm]

A long way to go for this achievement.

[@thesevenacoustics]

For that we need to invest hugely in R&D and i don't see that happening in a few decades. It is a gradual process, till then we are dependant on technology transfer.

[@Ajay-fl7bl]

It's not Turkey it's Mongolia

[@parastrivedi2778]

Jammu & Kashmir Turkey too was invited by Russian military and they are observer in this exercise.

[@bipinmishra8427]

'2+2 is less than the sum of its parts.' Often we fallen in the sentiments while India is strengthening herself & is alert at strategic forum . Anyways every country prefers its National Interest n India is maintaining same with minimum deterrence capacity necessarily.

[@raghavendraa1857]

the contemporary problems that India faces is rise in crude oil price ....and due this dollar dominated system we are harmed than getting benefits....understand from November we will not be able buy crude oil from Iran ....we are facing the heat of petroleum price rise....why is America not helping India in this issue....?india is facing energy crisis and Russia built 2 nuclear reactors and 4 on the way and understand that it is better to trust aged mother than sexy girlfriend....we saw this ethernal friendship in 1971 war where Russia took side and supported India....in 1998 Kargil war America did not not give radars for India and also they supplied the same to Pakistan...and we faced lots of causalityes ....and even today Russia vetos Pakistan resolution of kashmir issue....I really want to say India may be formidable today but this formidable power was nurtured by Russia ...and we should not forget that....lots of respect for Russia 🇷🇺 🙏🏿(BULLING NO MORE TOLERATED.....TRUMP MUST UNDERSTAND THAT GREAT POWER COMES WITH RESPONSIBILITY....AMERICA FIRST POLICY WILL BE IN DITCH VERY SOON)

[@jamesmicheal4814]

Russia needs access to warm water port. Gwadar of Pakistan suits it . But i think we have to sign a LEMOA would treaty with Russia

[@glimpseoflifewithaadi]

Superb discussion frank Sir. ..please do discussion on Banks merger...

[@prasadlonari4297]

🤑😁😂

[@nidhi520]

I have noticed that RSTV bigpicture is also somewhat gender biased. For a discussion they never bring female panelist except in some cases where topic is especially on women. I hope bigpicture will look into this and atleast bring 1female panelist in every discussion. I know they don't see gender they only focus on experts. Who ever is expert they invite them but my request is to also bring female expert as there are many.

[@ananyakirti2798]

you, like Cynthia enloe are asking "where are the women?"

[@chitranshutomarjatt8788]

Girls need just a topic to brag about gender discrimination.

[@raghavendraa1857]

Nidhi Anjali bro we didt have women in our army in 1990....and our distinguished panelist’s are defence experts

[@nidhi520]

@@raghavendraa1857 I m not talking specifically of this episode.

[@akshat_khare]

Ma'am if the female experts are present on the subject, they will surely bring them . Knowledge doesn't depend on gender . either you have or you don't regardless of gender.

[@GenAsthanaAnalyses]

Mr Pawan, Everyone is entitled to have views and I respect everyone's views. Putting the record straight, In 1962 lack of air power was one of the causes of Indian debacle. Russia helped us with induction of MIG 21. Through due process of induction, which takes some time, the first MIG 21 was inducted in April 1963, when the 1962 war has not been called off formally although unilateral ceasefire had started. Ref URL www.dailyexcelsior.com/fifty-years-of-mig-21-in-indian-air-force/ Your Para1 of Comments is your perception of history, which was not subject of discussion. I agree with Para 2 and I said the same during discussion. You may like to go through the debate again. Your Para 3 is your perception, which again was not subject of discussion. You must appreciate that all details cannot be put across in such short programs. You can google my name to get my coordinates and we can have more discussion on it, instead of making remarks. Maj Gen Asthana Maj Gen Asthana I am sorry if I offended you. We lost a lot of friends and neighbors in 1962 war. We also had direct access to a lot of very senior officers from the NEFA who gave us blow by blow account of the Oct/Nov engagement with the Chinese. I have gone through the Henderson Brooks-Bhagat Report very carefully and it matches with the facts recounted by our friends after the conflict. FYI the first Sqn Ldr of MIG 21 was my neighbor. Please correct me if I am wrong. Dear Mr Pawan, Thanks for your information. We normally go by official records and not individual perceptions. In April 1963 the first MiG-21 was flown by Wing Commander Dilbagh Singh from Tashkent to Chandigarh Air Base. I am the Chief Instructor of USI of India, which has largest repository of these records in our library. Ours is a 165 years old organisation and has a unique Historical Section which is globally acknowledged. It has compared all records, individual perceptions of participants in various wars including 1962 War. I also conduct a course on Military History for officers of Services. My contact Numbers are on Website of USI of India, or you can google my name. I would invite you for a cup of tea in USI and continue with further discussion. Hereafter I will not have time to spare more time typing out more replies. Thanks. Maj Gen S B Asthana

[@sandeepraj-ov1gr]

Why not Russia make Chinese compelled to make India nsg membership my question?

[@Skd833]

Russia is on a defensive front with China... It can never assert on it... Russia needs China to balance the hegemony of US in the same way need India to balance the power of China like in BRICS

[@akhileshgupta7409]

As far as I'm concerned China is very sensitive towards its Sovereignty and nowadays China is major player then Russia so there is a no way that Russia can insert his has a money on China.

[@gauravindia100]

Hello Sandeep you asked a valid point. Actually there are many issues involved- 1. Russia is a junior partner in its relationship with China. 2. US sanctions post Crimea annexation have crippled Russian economy and has made its economy very dependent on China particularly its energy and defence sectors. 3. Finally, Russia is not what it used to be few decades back. We don't share any special and privileged relationship with Russia despite the tall claims made frequently from both sides. Russia knows that India has drifted to US side in the last decade. However, Russia is important not only as a defence partner but also for continuation of multipolar world order.

[@shashwatsingh3907]

Russia has strong armed China into accepting India into SCO . it can not make way for us everywhere, but never the less i am sure they have their full support for us.

[@PrasannaKumar-mm5wz]

Indo Russia relationship_ special and privileged strategic partnerships, not a greater player in Indo Pacific, Russia want to balance out Chinese hegemony.dimond , pharmaceutical export to Russia, mig during 62 war, 67 percent of hardware russian origin, nuclear submarine, despite caatsa s"400 defence system, healthy competition among defence supplier, repair of military hardware need Russia expertise , after cold war era i New avenues only 10 million trade engagement, Indian product not finding .market in Russia, Russia is also looking toward Europe, language issue, bringing business community , Russia shrinking population not provide market, oligarchy in domestic market enjoying state protection and privileged .moving beyond arms and defence. S,-400 air defence system, next generation aircraft to china, naval treaty with Pakistan can be a problem.carrying forward relationship.foreign policy should issue based.india Russia cooperation in Afghan peace process.big ticket defence agreement.sco - brics platform for reaching out to Pakistan .

[@Pauli650]

Aryan indians + russians unite!