No video

"Indian women encouraged not to marry men from different backgrounds in Ancient India." Bharat Gupt

  Рет қаралды 21,312

The Festival of Bharat

The Festival of Bharat

Күн бұрын

"Why were Indian women encouraged not to marry men from vastly different backgrounds in Ancient India ?" Bharat Gupt ji explains
Follow us | citti.net |
VISIT OUR WEBSITE
www.citti.net
SUPPORT OUR WORK
www.citti.net/...
MORE CONTENT
Browse The Festival of Bharat's KZbin channel for more exciting content including exceptional talks on India by inspiring subject matter experts, artistes, scholars, change makers and public figures.
All of our content is available at no cost, and with no premium subscriptions required. You can help us spread the word as far and wide as possible by sharing our videos, and subscribing to our channel at / thefestivalofbharat
SOCIAL MEDIA LINKS TO FOLLOW
- Facebook: / cittimedia
+ / festivalbharat
- Koo: www.kooapp.com...
+ www.kooapp.com...
- Twitter: / cittimedia
+ / festivalbharat
- Instagram: / cittimedia
+ / festivalofbharat
FULL VIDEOS
Full versions of our videos are typically published on the @Citti Media channel a few weeks after the shorter cuts are published on this channel.
GLOBAL DIPLOMATS TO UPSC ASPIRANTS
Our videos are watched by millions of loyal viewers, from celebrities and public figures, to #UPSC aspirants seeking high quality, free content.
#IndianWomen #AncientIndia #Caste #Varna #IndianSociety #Kshatriya #Brahmin #Shudra

Пікірлер: 261
@parvathamma1
@parvathamma1 3 жыл бұрын
There is no caste system in ancient times. It was verna system, which is different from caste system which Britishers introduced.. Anyone can get into any varna based on the kind of work they did.
@vivekreddy601
@vivekreddy601 3 жыл бұрын
No they didn't introduce caste system. They dealt it in a fashion that led to hostility between various communities. To say caste was only a British construct is to say there was no India before 1947 or there is nothing known as hinduism before someone gave a name.
@ramabapat
@ramabapat 3 жыл бұрын
Wrong. People married among themselves because the lifestyles were very different. Who would want to marry a poor Brahmin with an extremely strict lifestyle? Anyway, a shopkeeper’s boy or girl grew up learning the trade. Why would he or she pick up a new trade?
@amazingdude9042
@amazingdude9042 3 жыл бұрын
@@talluris.prabhakar2782 yeahh. Why don't you enlighten the world and post all those verses from it on youtube ??
@panjabipandit
@panjabipandit 3 жыл бұрын
@@vivekreddy601 True but the fact remains that they took a system they were familiar with (the Portugese Casta System) in order to explain something they were not familiar with (The Indic Varna System) rather than trying to learn the latter and its unique nuances. Therefore they most definitely did introduce what we know and understand to be the caste system today except this framework does not explain the caveats we see in history as touched on by this video (why are different "castes" intermarrying in history? This is barred in the Portugese system) and why, like many colonized societies, we have such a hard time decolonizing our country, perceptions of history and culture, and most importantly our mind.
@panjabipandit
@panjabipandit 3 жыл бұрын
@@talluris.prabhakar2782 Seems like you didn't understand why our ancestors made a difference between smriti (cultural literature) and shrutu (The Vedas). The Rigveda clearly states that Brahman created humans of the 4 qualities He is made up of. Varna has always originally meant quality. This means I was made up of all 4 varnas, you are and so is everyone else. He did not say he is making professions. Humans made this term mean that by attributing professions to someones personalities. Someone who pursued The Vedas became known as a Brahmin, someone interested in weapons and the army became a Kshatriya, so on so forth. People moved varnas. Shudras became Brahmins etc. Just like someone today can go from working a 9-5 job in a shoe store to pay for college and then go on to med school and become a doctor. Same way a doctor can retire and own land later in life. These titles changed per the will of the person and their desire. You weren't born into it anymore than the son of a doctor is not born with some god given ability to perform surgery without proper education. Manusmriti is a smriti. It is an opinion of the author by virtue of its classification as a smriti not the word of God. This text comes thousands of years after The Vedas and even other smriti texts like The Gita wherein we see people like Karna being raised in Shudra homes and becoming one of the greatest Kshatriya's moreso than even Arjuna. I would recommend you learn the difference between smriti and shurti, which texts are which, etc. Otherwise you'll mix up Hinduism with the culture of the Hindus which are distinct and many times contradictory. The practices you quoted (Sati, untouchability (never found in any text smriti or shruti), and devdaasi) are all culture. Not Hinduism. I would also urge you to learn The Vedas instead of, presumably, reading third-party interpretations to inform you of something you could just read yourself to know whether whatever you were told was right or wrong. People on KZbin aren't being paid to educate you and you have no excuse to not read these texts yourself as you obviously have access to the internet. I don't say this to be rude, but I'm just a straightforward person and I think before incurring the karma of spreading ignorance, why not educate yourself on it? Then perhaps the discussion would be more meaningful because right now its like trying to have a discussion with someone about how the sky is blue and they keep telling you "no it's green", what do you get from that? A waste of time and energy. Unless you prefer to take some inherent hatred out on Hinduism and blame it for things that you assume to be the cause of your hurt rather than educating yourself on the fact that perhaps its just bigoted ignorant people that do things and try to say its their religion when it is not. In which case God bless because knowingly or unknowingly you are becoming the same and projecting the same energy out as was done to you and I'm sorry for that.
@SanjeeveRao
@SanjeeveRao 3 жыл бұрын
Purpose of Brahmin (man or woman) is to achieve spiritual goals in life. A woman of lower varna, can benefit from the spiritual growth of the Brahmin. A Brahmin woman, knowing the benefits of spiritual growth, among her family, would not want to marry into a varna lower than her own, because each of these varnas as they go lower, are more materialistic than the previous one. She was not interested in such desires. Modern day people are all similar in thinking when it came to accumulation of wealth. So, the varnas are for name only. No benefit. So, people are going for luxury
@jaswantsingh9287
@jaswantsingh9287 2 жыл бұрын
Casteism was introduced by Colonial British 250years ago.India got Independence from colonial British 75 years ago but has not abolished caste system yet. IT seems politicians and temple pundits love caste system for manipulating the illiterate masses... Colonialism hangover still in the head.
@hdthor
@hdthor Жыл бұрын
There are many people who wrongly think that they get their varna at birth, and not realizing that it requires a careful upbringing and value system. There is no varna in genetics, it is entirely in mindset and upbringing.
@Satyam-0610
@Satyam-0610 3 жыл бұрын
Intercast marriage chal jati hai lekin interreligious marriage ka kya hota sabko pata hai.
@shivam9749
@shivam9749 3 жыл бұрын
Ussa dur rho yaar
@sukumarmansingh8936
@sukumarmansingh8936 3 жыл бұрын
Suitcase
@shivam9749
@shivam9749 3 жыл бұрын
@A K vivekananda ji neh kaha tha leaving on one person in sanatan dharma is not one people less but an enermy more and you could see today in india
@rajababu42010
@rajababu42010 3 жыл бұрын
First of all even after convent education every sanatani now must take interest in scriptures ,granths and indic education throughout 25 years or more .... Everyone by reading must promote gurukul education and spread It's ideas as mandatory in every schools in future ...More than these things we must rejuvenate and bring the awareness of knowledge in society then only inferiority complex would go away ....
@amazingdude9042
@amazingdude9042 3 жыл бұрын
Why don't you do it rather then barking here ??
@panjabipandit
@panjabipandit 3 жыл бұрын
@@talluris.prabhakar2782 Yet they always seem to do ghar whapsi. I wonder why that is and what they discovered in Christianity that made them convert back? Also, I assume you are not Hindu. In which case, you perhaps don't know that a Brahmin's kid is not a Brahmin. That's like saying a doctors kid is a doctor. Many Hindus practice it this way but religiously there is no sanction for this and varna was never meant to be profession. They were inherent qualities to explain someone's personality (why are some humans great at music and others great at writing and philosophical study?). However, its obvious you are here to troll, not learn anything. Good day.
@rajababu42010
@rajababu42010 3 жыл бұрын
@@talluris.prabhakar2782 yes that's the reality and very sad, that's why are raising awareness so that the next generation don't repeat the mistakes which we have done ...Any way we think definitely change will come
@rajababu42010
@rajababu42010 3 жыл бұрын
@@amazingdude9042 obviously we will bark everywhere and make people aware ,do what u want ✌️👍
@amazingdude9042
@amazingdude9042 3 жыл бұрын
@@rajababu42010 he he. dogs barking don't make people aware. dogs just want stupid attention.
@Satyanarayana-k7v
@Satyanarayana-k7v 3 жыл бұрын
जय श्री राम🔥🔱🕉🚩♾️🌏🇮🇳🙏
@anantmvyas8271
@anantmvyas8271 3 жыл бұрын
But @Bharat Gupt ji there was inter Varņa mobility. Whilst your explaining your subconscious assumption may be that varņa was by birth and not by worth. Dhanyavadah 🕉🙏
@MithileshKumar-ul2on
@MithileshKumar-ul2on 2 жыл бұрын
In ancient India, princesses used select the groom in a "Swayambar" from many suitors.
@nimithanimeh
@nimithanimeh 3 жыл бұрын
Caste system weakened hinduism.. Thats why people converted to other religion.
@snair8448
@snair8448 3 жыл бұрын
And did the converted find salvation or help in the Abrahamic religions? No! They fell from the frying pan into the fire. Hinduism self corrects and that process is underway in India. Abrahamics r stuck in a 2000 year or 1400 year old, men crafted illogical stories masked as faiths! Not scientific or applicable to humans of all gender or types of inclinations! That’s why Abrahamic faiths are imploding!
@sidharthapatra4296
@sidharthapatra4296 2 жыл бұрын
@@snair8448 they didn't convert to find salvation, but to get rid of oppression, and they definitely did.
@snair8448
@snair8448 2 жыл бұрын
@@sidharthapatra4296 You mean Christianity is not oppressive? Tell that to the Native Americans, Aboriginals and the Maoris, Incas and Mayans!
@nagamani9297
@nagamani9297 2 жыл бұрын
Why , are there no differences in other religions? A rich Christian would never go to a church built for or attended by these converted SC and ST Here in Hinduism we all go to the same temple and pray to the same God., There are many types in Christianity like Catholics, Protestants and so on .They don't go to each other's church . In Islam it's even worse . Sunni, shia , deoband and so on , and they even kill each other . They convert not due to the differences in Hinduism but due to the lies, false promises , materialistic traps and brain washing propaganda by the other religions as part of their plan to expand their religion It's due to the false propaganda they are getting converted
@varundeshpandevd
@varundeshpandevd 3 жыл бұрын
I am no expert in the history of ancient Hindu society, but I feel it's very convenient today to say that the shudras were not discriminated by the Kshatriyas, Brahmins and the Vaishyas. We have numerous documented evidences of this very fact. Very disheartening to see someone advocating the "Varna" system that became the foundation of the regressive "Caste" system of the Hindu society. Even today the Dalits in several places of India are given a second class treatment. We need to create equality of opportunity in education and jobs, and make healthcare and technology easily accessible to truly get over the Caste barrier. Having said that, I love the awareness that this channel creates on several other issues 💐.
@GirishVenkatachalam
@GirishVenkatachalam 2 жыл бұрын
True but it is never as bad as what happens among converts where xtians who leave Hinduism fearing ill treatment get worse after they adopt another faith. Meeting the lion on the way to escape that is
@jamesanthony8234
@jamesanthony8234 2 жыл бұрын
yeah well this is very very different now. im an indian guy from australia. My white mate shows me his tinder account and i swear you not. he had 4 different indian girls lined up for the day and this is not an isolated incident, not trying to paint all indian girls with a brush but the new age way is indian girl with the white man before an indian guy marriage. i’ve seen this wayyyy too many times that i hate even bringing this up.
@liladevi3169
@liladevi3169 3 жыл бұрын
Varna system gave us gem and all time great like brahmagupta , acharya chanakya etc. Golden period of India under gupta empire caste was followed strictly to avoid varn sankra
@bharata5496
@bharata5496 3 жыл бұрын
Varna system
@sritharunreddyasokkumar2228
@sritharunreddyasokkumar2228 3 жыл бұрын
I also support jathi system but also varna system but against inter caste and inter religion marriages Many must come forward to spread the knowledge of not to support the inter marriages or promote it which is a very bad thing to our society and will affect our culture more badly Finally, I am against these kind of inter marriages
@bharata5496
@bharata5496 3 жыл бұрын
ok so it was hierarchical i understood.Definitely a Scientist will have a higher respect as compared to an ordinary engineer. It is still in functioning today. It was correct for that time cause it was isolated and operated correctly. But today, we have these atrocity litrarture today. It should be operated rigidly and changing Varna should be easy based on Karm. A boy who was although born as a son of Doctor -Shudra by birth but by karm he became IAS - a Kshatriya so he should be allowed to marry a Kshatriya girl by birth or by karm - This was allowed in ancient times. But Now even a Brahmin girl by birth or Karm should be allowed or tolerated to marry that boy. - This also happened in ancient times but rarely. So looking at this I agree with what was practiced in Ancient times. Inter-caste or Inter-VARNA. Inter sub caste marraiges should be promoted and everything should be respected or atleast tolerated. Promoted only when it is ensured that resources and capabilities are not getting wasted. sorry ananth but with my understanding. There's nothing in it I felt was any kind of Nazi or Brahminical supremacist. Cause In previous videos he has clearly explained that Varna system used to recognize you by birth but gives more importance to karm. And see it is obvious that a Father would prefer to marry his daughter to a person who has same profession like hers to ensure that her capabilities are not being wasted. So anywhere it is being ensured then it is fine and this heirarchy is also fine when it is being recognised by Karma not Janm.
@rajeevborah143
@rajeevborah143 3 жыл бұрын
Well all these explaination seems apt until u realise that lower caste women had to pay tax to cover their breasts other wise they lived bare chest, lower caste were denied land ownership rights, they couldn't use public water resources etc...they were untouchables....such great Varna system
@sritharunreddyasokkumar2228
@sritharunreddyasokkumar2228 3 жыл бұрын
@@rajeevborah143 these kind of things happened during British period not during any our maharajas period Britishers rewritten our history and made our people believe that lower caste must not cover their breaststroke without paying tax and made them untouchables Before British and Islamic rule they were also given rights and were respected and were not untouchables This happened during British period and lower caste slavery started in North India during Islamic rule and many rajas abolished slavery especially chattrapathi sivaji maharaj have done it. So it all happened in a sort of time and it is not based on our varna system and jathi system ,those people were treated like that First know our history and systems and then say
@mandarp9472
@mandarp9472 3 жыл бұрын
There is a compatibility issues with marrying from other castes like financial backround, traditions, eating habits, nature, temper, behaviour. But in large metros where both genders know each other, that is not the case today.
@angelsbackgroundsounds
@angelsbackgroundsounds Жыл бұрын
ya its called evolution
@sindhu_21
@sindhu_21 3 жыл бұрын
Where can i get full videos of these talks? The snippets are useful but it’s hard to find the full talks, so appreciate if you can provide links to full talks if they exist 🙏
@Napoleon4778
@Napoleon4778 2 жыл бұрын
Valid points, but not argued very well, unfortunately.
@anandaramkhalawan5383
@anandaramkhalawan5383 2 жыл бұрын
Varna according to the Gita is based on Guna or The three Mental Characteristics which make him suitable one of four functions of which there are only Four Castes The Mahabharata (Yudhisthira) states that knowledge and Character determines one’s caste and not birth in a family line. Jati or sub-caste is based on birth in a family line, regardless of character or learning. There are hundreds of jati while there are Only Four Varna’s. Therefore in a discussion which is intended to enlighten the Public the Speaker must Always state whether he is speaking of Varna or Jati. This will also eliminate The Ignorant Comments made by Ignoramuses. Om.
@Yash-rg9sv
@Yash-rg9sv 2 жыл бұрын
Well , Renuka devi (Mother of Lord Parshurama) who is also known as Yellamma in Maharashtra and Karnataka , was a Rajkanya (princess) . Her father married away her to Jamadagni Rushi ( who was a brahmin) . And further gave birth to 6 sons , including Lord Parshuram being the youngest .
@ankitanandy6076
@ankitanandy6076 Жыл бұрын
Yellamma is a woman who sacrificed herself for Renuka, they are two separate people.
@user2-lx1xl
@user2-lx1xl 3 жыл бұрын
Inter-Racial marriages would lead to biggest fall of hinduism due to oversexualisation of Indian women and demeaning and stereotyping of Indian men.
@user2-lx1xl
@user2-lx1xl 3 жыл бұрын
@Padmavathy Oruganti who are you talking to if me can you explain ?
@user2-lx1xl
@user2-lx1xl 3 жыл бұрын
@Padmavathy Oruganti I'm talking about INTER RACIAL not interfaith and intercaste
@user2-lx1xl
@user2-lx1xl 3 жыл бұрын
@@rk-is3cw Foreign men are travelling to India to find some sort of submissive women over here (Asian/Culture Fetish) by meeting local Indian Women online.
@abhisheksingh4587
@abhisheksingh4587 3 жыл бұрын
that is the most ridiculous thing i have heared
@user2-lx1xl
@user2-lx1xl 3 жыл бұрын
@@abhisheksingh4587 what ?
@deepakgurung6565
@deepakgurung6565 2 жыл бұрын
It does not matter, what they did in the past. Do you guys think , it is relevant now?
@vijaybhat5379
@vijaybhat5379 2 жыл бұрын
In Kerala a very famous female writer converted herself in to Muslim cast to marry a person whom she was in love and that person who happens to be a politician was rewarded in billions. If you want you can fact check this story. That is WHAT IS HAPPENING HERE.
@thebharatglobalpower6411
@thebharatglobalpower6411 2 жыл бұрын
Do not explain wrong explain or own imagination .lower can go to higher but higher can not come lower . Varna system according to last life work so higher Varna should not marry lower Varna because of downfall
@vijaybhat5379
@vijaybhat5379 2 жыл бұрын
Baapre baap, Namaskaara. Excellent detailing .Very mature talk. Thankyou sir.
@millannegarcia7450
@millannegarcia7450 3 жыл бұрын
Isn't there a difference between varna and jati (aka caste)? I think that should have been mentioned as well
@sidharthapatra4296
@sidharthapatra4296 3 жыл бұрын
Large number of jatis (castes) grouped into 4 varnas.
@superrex723
@superrex723 2 жыл бұрын
@@sidharthapatra4296 That is not correct but vice versa of your statement can be considered. Jati emerged from varna. Not jati group into varna.
@sidharthapatra4296
@sidharthapatra4296 2 жыл бұрын
@@superrex723 jatis like barber,fishermen were already there. Later they were named Shudra. This is what I know. But as per your statement they emerged from Varna. How?
@superrex723
@superrex723 2 жыл бұрын
@@sidharthapatra4296 These are professions and not Jatis . There were varna system first based on your work . Very fluid system. Later it solidified. As new professions emerged varna system began to break. These new professions solidified to particular professional and became jatis. Example:- Kumhar is pottery profession but it became Surname and jati.
@sidharthapatra4296
@sidharthapatra4296 2 жыл бұрын
@@superrex723 if it is so,then alone Varna can't explain professions !,for example shudra covers many professional like an umbrella but kumbhar gives a clear idea about a particular group. And practically if you wished to hire a kumbhar you have to use the profession name,not Shudra.so shudra, the varna name remains just a hidden identity and jati name comes in use. And many such jatis come under one Varna. As you said jatis emerged from Varna based on profession and solidified later,I think they had to,for practical use,to specify a particular person. Like you call "hey shudra",a 100 would turn to you but you call "hey kumbhar" that'll be different,only kumbhar.
@drsanjayashikhii8847
@drsanjayashikhii8847 4 ай бұрын
Again if a woman of lower Varna was officially allowed to marry a man of upper Varna, then so called "puritan" theory proved to be false.
@75snambi
@75snambi 2 жыл бұрын
Please do not use the term "caste". Use "jati" or "varna" instead. There is a ton of difference between "caste" and "jati". There is nothing discriminatory about "jati" or "varna". OTOH "caste" is highly discriminatory.
@saijunk8697
@saijunk8697 3 жыл бұрын
Let the men have the right to choose the women equal in worth and Guna to their own worth and Guna as life partner. And Let Women have the right to choose men equal in worth and Guna to their own worth and Guna as life partner. And if they prefer to choose a life partner who is not equal to them in worth and Guna then that’s their choice . They have the right to choose and they have the right to be chosen . One thing which is common between sex ( be it a one night stand or premarital ) and a marriage for life time is “ Mutual Consent between two individuals “ Hope that people understand and respect this . By the way Varna is not Jaati . Varna is one’s own congenital inner quality and Guna . And by congenital quality I don’t mean the father’s or mother’s quality or the traditional profession of the family but rather the individual’s own quality , capacity and Guna . . But jaati on the other hand is defined and determined by the family and community in which an individual is born . And forcing an individual to follow the so called profession of their jaati even if they have the capacity to do something else , something of a much greater or different value is just so criminal and perverse . And the same thing applies for marriage . So let’s not force people into either same caste or inter caste marriage . Let them choose . Dharma gives the right to the individual to choose the form of God for worship ( Ishta ) and the life partner .
@dayanandanongmaithem4234
@dayanandanongmaithem4234 Жыл бұрын
Great explanation. That should be the aspiration.
@AX-fx7ng
@AX-fx7ng 9 ай бұрын
Stop using lower and upper higher labels.
@piyushbharadwaj3209
@piyushbharadwaj3209 3 жыл бұрын
Sir excellent explanation.
@ekdanta
@ekdanta 2 жыл бұрын
The audio is of poor quality.
@rjclue2630
@rjclue2630 3 жыл бұрын
its better not to marry an indian women due to her culture that she will bring and the desiresto your home . she will not be happy cuz she likes to be in that culture. its better to marry someone who has no culture but educated and respect. unless the indian woman is willing to drop the3 culture for good relationship and frienship it will work. men are happy with her as long as he has good sex , food and love with her but she will not be happy with her life marrying other culture. may be she pretends to be happy outside but within her she will miss the indian man touch and behavior as it will mostly relate to her family. its better for someone with strong culture marry the same, unless they as willing to dissolve the culture all together and adapt to new culture.
@adityajaykumar-mysevenchak3986
@adityajaykumar-mysevenchak3986 3 жыл бұрын
Why are you reducing the sacred bond of marriage to "resource allocation". Lol. I don't agree with this theory.
@mountainlion.9163
@mountainlion.9163 3 жыл бұрын
Go and jump in a well if you don’t agree learn something ,u don’t have to be judgmental.
@adityajaykumar-mysevenchak3986
@adityajaykumar-mysevenchak3986 3 жыл бұрын
@@mountainlion.9163 Do you ask everyone who doesn't agree with you to jump in a well? Lol
@shivaa3ps177
@shivaa3ps177 2 жыл бұрын
Not convinced at all... "Waste of Resources" and that too when women from upper Verna marry a lower Verna guy while the reverse is fine?
@ambedkaritehindutva7403
@ambedkaritehindutva7403 2 жыл бұрын
Justyfing the caste system Waah The caste system destroyed hinduism Thats the reason why your great casteist civilization could not defend itself against the rag tag turk and mughal invaders. I am a proud hindu and I do not support the caste system and a hinduism for everyone.
@rohithsharma1476
@rohithsharma1476 3 жыл бұрын
Caste system must die. This is in national interest. And inter-caste marriage is the way forward.
@amodityadav4266
@amodityadav4266 3 жыл бұрын
Nope, it should not be promoted
@amodityadav4266
@amodityadav4266 3 жыл бұрын
Should be tolerated but not promoted
@saurav5490
@saurav5490 3 жыл бұрын
absolutely
@shriraamayyar7744
@shriraamayyar7744 3 жыл бұрын
To eradicate caste system, firstly there should be - No reservation- No matter what.. But then this is a very difficult thing, so we need to find a solution out.. reservation was based on population statistics available, or say deprived people, and then hence you have open category and various other reserved categories. I'm fortunate enough that I could complete my professional education in an open category with decent amount of marks merit. , But I know of my few other colleagues a few in open category just because of 0.25 marks short.. They could not make it up to higher super professional educations. Also I have very close dear friends from reserved category who are true to their work and have shined in their respective works And I respect them 🙏🌹., And a few others who have wasted the so called or so thought privilege.. If at all there is reservation, There should be a time bound frame which is very difficult to keep. Hence if you are having reservation then there should be a set clause like- Give to economically under privileged people in open category also. There are Brahmins and Parsis who are minorities now, And there are many poor in them too but yet deserving and highly qualified and intelligent, If it is based on reservation then are these people doing anything to these open category people. With regard to reserved category, once a student who has taken admission in reserved category shall Not be eligible for repeat admission again in resort category., Similarly if he has taken admission for his job in reserved category once, And then leaves the job, he will Not be allowed to apply in reserved category again.. he And his family are all "uplifted". Not more than two children in one family should be allowed to take privilege. If more than two children, Then the family should not be allowed to take the reservation as they are preventing their own other colleagues to enter in. Every reserved family needs a seat. But they should not fill up, without giving to other needy in their community. If you are economically well to do, set a margin for it, Then they should not be allowed to take reserved seats. They just eat away seats who really deserve seat in a reserved category.. Once you take reserved seat say in graduation, Then in post graduation, society has "transformed " you, rather "uplifted" you. Once uplifted, the person should not be eligible in job again then in the category.. If you have fill the form in category and you wish to opt admission or job in category, Then you cannot take a seat in open, You have to take seat in your own category as you have filled. If the seats in reserved category go empty, all that they are left later on after admission, the seats should be filled by deserving open categories student only. Not more than 50% reservation should be there for reserved category and 50% mark should be there for open category. This should never be diluted. All this crap has already led to a lot of brain drain from India outside .. If you have taken seat in reserved category then you are bound to do service to the nation again and repay what the society has given you. There should be more opportunity for open categories student that should be created by these people. It is sad that sometimes the true work of leaders who fought for reservation and their true words that reservation should not continue for more than 10 years has been violated by the very people who are supposed to take care of us. If you want to see quality then reservation should eventually disappear.. And if people wish to fight for reservation then these same should Also accept or suggest by which it reaches real needy and ways to decrease the same.. Hare Krishna..
@shivam9749
@shivam9749 3 жыл бұрын
Yes it should be accepted but not inter faith especially in india
@bharata5496
@bharata5496 3 жыл бұрын
i have a problem here. was Varna really hierarchical? I am confused.
@bharata5496
@bharata5496 3 жыл бұрын
ok so it was hierarchical i understood.Definitely a Scientist will have a higher respect as compared to an ordinary engineer. It is still in functioning today. It was correct for that time cause it was isolated and operated correctly. But today, we have these atrocity litrarture today. It should be operated rigidly and changing Varna should be easy based on Karm. A boy who was although born as a son of Doctor -Shudra by birth but by karm he became IAS - a Kshatriya so he should be allowed to marry a Kshatriya girl by birth or by karm - This was allowed in ancient times. But Now even a Brahmin girl by birth or Karm should be allowed or tolerated to marry that boy. - This also happened in ancient times but rarely. So looking at this I agree with what was practiced in Ancient times. Inter-caste or Inter-VARNA. Inter sub caste marraiges should be promoted and everything should be respected or atleast tolerated. Promoted only when it is ensured that resources and capabilities are not getting wasted. sorry ananth but with my understanding. There's nothing in it I felt was any kind of Nazi or Brahminical supremacist. Cause In previous videos he has clearly explained that Varna system used to recognize you by birth but gives more importance to karm. And see it is obvious that a Father would prefer to marry his daughter to a person who has same profession like hers to ensure that her capabilities are not being wasted. So anywhere it is being ensured then it is fine and this heirarchy is also fine when it is being recognised by Karma not Janm.
@panjabipandit
@panjabipandit 3 жыл бұрын
Originally no. It started as Brahman (God) stating he made humans of 4 varnas in this context meaning qualities. All of which he also has and we have all 4 in varying capacities. They were meant to explain personality differences (why one person is great at singing and another at studying/philosophy). However Hindu culture took it and attributed it to professions then over time made it hierarchical. Genetic evidence shows Hindus were mixing before Manusmriti (please look up the difference between smriti and shruti; one is cultural literature the other is religious scripture). Hence all castes in India today are more alive in genetics than they want to think because our ancestors were not as narrowminded as we are today.
@shubhamraj9986
@shubhamraj9986 2 жыл бұрын
Jai Hind Jai Bharat ❤️🇮🇳
@RC-br1ps
@RC-br1ps 2 жыл бұрын
'Higher and lower' varna, and yet no discrimination existed? ...what honesty and what a brilliantly crafted argument (hint:sarcasm). 🤣
@arkodas3298
@arkodas3298 2 жыл бұрын
Varnasram system is most sophisticated social system
@Satyam-0610
@Satyam-0610 3 жыл бұрын
Lakh bimari hai hindu me lekin phir bhi ek dushare ka gala nahi katate hai . Dheere dheere sab problem solve ho jayega . Agar aisa na hota aaj india ke 25 tukade ho gaye the. Aur Afghanistan ki tarah civil war hoti yaha.
@alphamale7489
@alphamale7489 2 жыл бұрын
Jatt Sikh I love my caste
@vijaybhat5379
@vijaybhat5379 2 жыл бұрын
But today world the odds are so much that a Brahmin or Punjabi are highly prized item in India. I"ts shameful.
@saurabhkumar-ee3my
@saurabhkumar-ee3my 3 жыл бұрын
But now a days modern India women prefer interfaith marriage . Tremendous changes in Moder hindu women, they are direct jumping from same verna marriage to interfaith marriage 😀😀😀.
@polestar5319
@polestar5319 3 жыл бұрын
Intra caste marriage is a successful family system, because , different castes have different behaviour and ideas that can cause clashes among couples, Moreover the caste practice, family community network forces couples to behave themselves in the community. I see many inter caste love marriage fail within months.
@enlighteneddespot945
@enlighteneddespot945 2 жыл бұрын
Through Endogamy you are reducing the mating chances which can extinct your species. Such practice almost wiped out Twice borne varna caste in ancient times. That's why to sustain they allowed the marriage of the men of upper varna with the lower varna. If you think I am wrong then see the Demographics of the UC population. If you combine Muslim, Christian and Sikh populations then they are a minority in this country. There are certain States where Brahmins are less than 1 percent, for example, Kerala and still, they have a shortage of brides so to maintain caste purity they are Importing Brahmin brides from UP and Bihar, but many UP and Bihari Brahmin who are financially well-off are not ready to give their daughter because of Racial differences.
@persaud1
@persaud1 3 жыл бұрын
👌🙏✊
@andreamessiasgomes7118
@andreamessiasgomes7118 2 жыл бұрын
Am shocked at this, this is not true Sanatana Dharma, you should be able to marry whoever the hell you want weather poor rich fat ugly caste no caste black white yellow Red tall small be it anything, so that means sanatana Dharma too has its faults! And from a country where all races developed either what this lady said is manipulated Hinduism because Sanatana Dharma should be not only concentrated only of one place but whole world to grow not fucking stagnate!
@kbcbcjs
@kbcbcjs 2 жыл бұрын
How a Shudra girl or girls from other varnas could marry a Brahmin? Don't you think their resources and skill would be wasted if the got married to a Brahmin? Sir, ain't you contradicting yourself? Our caste system is responsible for the decline of Hinduism.
@pks2552
@pks2552 2 жыл бұрын
@Mr. Ayush then there is no india left in the next 100 years..tata bybye good bye gaya....clear political division
@bichitrachakraborty5461
@bichitrachakraborty5461 3 жыл бұрын
Brahmin women could go to Shudra because their economic condition was same and the ladies could bring the wisdom to the Shudras.
@aryanchakraborty5175
@aryanchakraborty5175 3 жыл бұрын
Ki bolchis 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️
@user-uq6ic8pw8x
@user-uq6ic8pw8x 3 жыл бұрын
I don't think it works that way lol. All shudras must understand things will improve over atleast 2 generation if u work hard and have good morals. It takes generation to bring things to speed. Marrying brahmin woman wnt serve any purpose. Just dilute the intellects in the country.
@jonik2121
@jonik2121 3 жыл бұрын
@@user-uq6ic8pw8x u are lucky to have such an amazing grandpa..pranam to him🙏🙏🙏
@sidharthapatra4296
@sidharthapatra4296 3 жыл бұрын
You are a great thinker!!
@jemuel6222
@jemuel6222 2 жыл бұрын
christian are the best
@kumarj8556
@kumarj8556 3 жыл бұрын
Excellent thumbnail 👍
@amitahegde6127
@amitahegde6127 2 жыл бұрын
👌👍👍
@omshiva4645
@omshiva4645 3 жыл бұрын
This is all balls.
@sk-pg8zd
@sk-pg8zd 2 жыл бұрын
Sudhra will be always sudhra what ever they does.. but brahmins kshatriyas vyshas can change their wah wah
@sheetalverma8940
@sheetalverma8940 2 жыл бұрын
No no. Maharishi valmiki was said to be a thief or a mleccha. Lower than a shudra but he wrote the ramayana so u can change. Veda have no such restrictions.
@sk-pg8zd
@sk-pg8zd 2 жыл бұрын
@@sheetalverma8940 Those morons never understand leave it..
@ricktrutherreport7852
@ricktrutherreport7852 2 жыл бұрын
Today, dalits under SC category are able to get education, govt jobs, and everything under reservation quota. India is trying to make it better.
@venkateshnatarajan2941
@venkateshnatarajan2941 2 жыл бұрын
You should not use the word lower varna.. at that time and today the word lower actually conveys what many outsiders think of caste system from it's origin. It morphed to a very different thing in the modern age which is again the thing that should be taught in schools..
@1973dineshkumar
@1973dineshkumar 3 жыл бұрын
People should not use their caste names or surnames. This will ensure the caste system is not practised in work place. Early Promotions for lower caste in government jobs should not be encouraged. South Indians normally use initials with there names or it is fathers name or village name as surnames. This enables people look at the capability and intelligence and work attitude rather than caste.
@sritharunreddyasokkumar2228
@sritharunreddyasokkumar2228 3 жыл бұрын
South Indians also use our surnames within our names along with initials and locality name We use our jathi name with much proud within our name and it is our pride So without knowing don't spread misleading informations
@1973dineshkumar
@1973dineshkumar 3 жыл бұрын
@@sritharunreddyasokkumar2228 I am from Kerala only. Here we use either caste name or fathers name with person name. Only when full name is required in filling some forms we give full name.
@sritharunreddyasokkumar2228
@sritharunreddyasokkumar2228 3 жыл бұрын
@@1973dineshkumar hello I am also from kerala trivandrum I know how many of my friends have surnames within their name Most of my nair friends either have their tharavattu name(traditional house name)or their jathi name (eg:nair,thampi,pullai,kartha,menon,panikkar,namboithiri,etc..)or both tharavattu name and caste name in their name and brahmins also use like nambeesan,bhattathirippad,etc.. many Christians also use surnames like Roy,Perera,etc..in their name and my jathi people and other telugu jathi also use surnames and house names in our names anywhere we settle and in karnataka also the same is happening. So we south Indians use our jathi names proudly in our name especially savarna jathis(upper). So in south india also we people use our surnames Most of the us call either by full name or our jathi names and we r proud of it. And this is happening in the same place where u live ,kerala. Not only my friends I have seen my people like this, ok. So don't say like this or mislead anyone by spreading wrong informations
@AK-sm7hw
@AK-sm7hw 3 жыл бұрын
Completely agree. If we don't remove caste and Varna Hindus will never unite. Scholarships can be given based on income levels not caste
@1973dineshkumar
@1973dineshkumar 3 жыл бұрын
@@sritharunreddyasokkumar2228 You have only mentioned some of the prominent castes of Kerala. You are actually not getting my message. If you read my message properly I was advocating for no discrimination on basis of castes. When u mention a caste as surname a person will tend to differentiate in providing quality service or goods. He may prefer his own caste by giving better discounts.
@everythingisupsidedown9593
@everythingisupsidedown9593 3 жыл бұрын
Identity is your idol.
@soniathomas3512
@soniathomas3512 2 жыл бұрын
Even untouchables are still there. Dalits are considered as untouchable in this time 2021 🙄
@bharata5496
@bharata5496 3 жыл бұрын
Inter-caste or Inter-VARNA. Inter sub caste marraiges should be promoted and everything should be respected or atleast tolerated. Promoted only when it is ensured that resources and capabilities are not getting wasted.
拉了好大一坨#斗罗大陆#唐三小舞#小丑
00:11
超凡蜘蛛
Рет қаралды 16 МЛН
❌Разве такое возможно? #story
01:00
Кэри Найс
Рет қаралды 6 МЛН
hot mtf shapeshift, mtf body swap
1:14
disguiser
Рет қаралды 33 М.
"Hindu temples are not at all what you think they are" | Shefali Vaidya ji
5:13