Explained Live - Sheikh Hasina’s Ouster: Causes, Consequences, and Future Prospects

Рет қаралды 14,919

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 253

@koowasha 2 ай бұрын

Indian diplomacy has failed in Bangladesh. Don’t bring former diplomats if you want to build a relationship with Bangladesh that works. Particularly Mr. Chakrabarty is one of the culprits with bad suggestions and ideas. He has no clue on how economy works. Blaming Ukraine and Covid cannot hide the extreme and systematic money laundering from banks by Hasina. Hasina’s relationship with India was based on reciprocal interest of both parties by exploiting regular people of Bangladesh.

@sena3941 2 ай бұрын

He literally mentioned the impact of bad loans and money being siphoned off. He also mentioned institutional capture. Thanks to Mr Chakravarty here, Bangladeshis enjoy easy access to India. He faced a lot of political resistance but he did it. Thanks to him, the enclave issue was settled. Teen bigha corridor would not have been possible without him. But sure let your shallow knowledge and hubris be the judge of this person. He is a well respected diplomat.

@hasanmahmood8078 2 ай бұрын

Adani was plundering Bangladesh by selling electricity at inflated price and coercive agreements.

@koowasha 2 ай бұрын

@@sena3941 ‘Deep’ knowledge in economy does not look at GDP in isolation, a sound economist also talks about wealth distribution. If your favourite diplomat’s intentions were right, he would touch upon Hasina’s killings and torture cells and would give the real picture of Bangladesh.

@sena3941 2 ай бұрын

@@koowasha I have a bad news for you. Crony capitalism was an issue since Zia's rule. He even deemed it as a necessary evil to break out of poverty. At least that is how Anthony Mascarenhas put it in his book on Bangladesh. I do not look at just GDP. But the textile industry was possible because both the BNP and AL mollycoddled with these industrialists and protected them. Your textile industry runs semi slavery system and you think this was only blessed by AL in power. This was the economic momentum that every Bangladeshi before Covid used to pride about. But that is gone. Another issue is the slowdown of labour demands in Gulf. Gulf is moving from labour intensive sectors to service sector increasingly and this means a secular decline in labour requirements. Remittance stagnation of Bangladesh since the Covid period points to that. Not to mention the war leading to increase in fuel and food prices did not help the situation. Wealth distribution in Bangladesh would never get solved if land distribution is not done. Land capture is a huge problem and both parties have done it. Preciously the kind of shit that got solved in West Bengal by the Left. Not only we removed the Zamindars in the 50s (one of the first amendments of the Nehru government) but Operation Borga (yes the Bengali word Borga or share is the source of this name) reduced huge rural inequality that used to exist. Political parties can still capture land but small peasants are more likely to be able to defend their ownership better. We saw in Singur and Nandigram. The very opposite of what one gets to see in Bangladesh. As for excesses of Hasina, for every Aynaghor you have a hawa Bhabhan. Your problem. Instead of blaming your neighbour, your country's inability to build proper institutions get demonstrated. Why should Indian mission intervene? We barely try to do so to dismantle terrorist camps against India within Pakistani territory let alone defend someone's interest. That is a ludicrous expectation. Aage Bharat niye nijer "kowasha" katan tarpor Chakroborty babu r performance niye kotha bolun. Apnara bhojen na Bharat ki bhabhe kaaj kore. Oneker comment theke tai bhojha jay.

@sdutta8 2 ай бұрын

Good, balanced report. One doesn’t hear the voice of the Awami League in the present debates. Let there be free and fair elections and only then will we see how unpopular Hasina really is among the people at large.

@atmshuvo44 2 ай бұрын

mr Chakrabarty was one of the enabler of hasina regime. Now he is spewing bullshit.

@ZedSkill 2 ай бұрын

there is another culprit called vina sikri

@sena3941 2 ай бұрын

A country whose entire concept of sovereignty is assassinating its own leaders on the basis of their perceived pro India bias (Tajuddin and Zia got assassinated for this. And Zia was not even pro India) should have far better priorities than complaining about foreign ambassadors under the guise of their perceived attack against the country's sovereignty. Did you even listen to what he has to say? He has a well rounded analysis and of course as a former Indian ambassador he is supposed to analyse it from the Indian perspective. He has represented Indian interests which is our primary goal not charity. Before you spew more nonsense Mr Shuvo, this is the same man who improved the lives of enclave residents by helping them to belong to a country. Without him, there would not have been an agreement. Without him, the number of people coming for their basic consult would not have been able to do so. Make him the villain at your own cost but ignoring his merits would not make them disappear.

@adilkhasruchowdhury-pk9rp 2 ай бұрын

bro you guys have also killed your leader???

@nawsherahmedsikder2137 2 ай бұрын

@@adilkhasruchowdhury-pk9rp You also killed your leader

@adilkhasruchowdhury-pk9rp 2 ай бұрын

@@nawsherahmedsikder2137 I have just responded here someone commented on our sovereignty claimed that Itis based on killing the nation leader. In response, I have said, they have killed their nations leader as well, whatever notions trying to implied on us similary same implied to you

@ahmedsaqqaf8983 2 ай бұрын

This type of Pinak diplomacy totally failed in BD.

@MonirHossain-sc2tx 2 ай бұрын

He is a total horse sheet

@ChomchomMS 2 ай бұрын

India always have interest on Hasina But not with the people of Bangladesh. India has taken all the advantage From Hasina and still sheltering Hasina who Has done crimes against humanity. After all this happened still indian diplomats think India has no Roll in Bangladesh 😅

@narayankumar6063 2 ай бұрын

India has done everything to help the ungrateful people of Bangladesh who are anti-India and anti-Hindu and radicalized. Bangladesh under BNP has actively aided anti-India terrorist groups and insurgents. India should have converted Bangladesh into a vassal state in 1971 and all these problems could have been avoided.

@sanjeevumd 2 ай бұрын

It is difficult to build a good relationship with people in Bangladesh. Many people in Bangladesh grow up with a bias against non-Muslims from childhood, so they often don't expect to have a good relationship with a Hindu-majority country.

@nasiruddin208 2 ай бұрын

Pinak is no longer a level-headed person to analyze post Hasina Bangladesh.

@MOVIEIpad 2 ай бұрын

I do not think people in Bangladesh wants Hasina anymore

@abuahmed6058 2 ай бұрын

Hasina was elected two times ,in 1996 and 2008 ,through fair élections but after being PM in 2009 she destroyed the voting system ,people lost all the basic human rights ,but unfortunately India very steadfastly stood by the autocracy of Hasina ,what bads happened in Bangladesh under Hasina India was blamed for .yes ,India bears responsibility for what bads Hasina did in Bangladesh .

@narayankumar6063 2 ай бұрын

It is Pak-China axis that has brewed trouble in Bangladesh, not India. India, in the past, has dealt with Khaleda who was anti-India.

@nadeemmahdi6868 Ай бұрын

@@narayankumar6063You people don't see or read news?

@MohiuddinEbnaKawsar 2 ай бұрын

😂😂 talking about Bangladesh where no body from Bangladesh. Indian media at best.

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

They are doing backscratching of each other, rather to dig out the real cause of the fauilure of Indian diplomacy in Bangladesh.

@MahiKhan-sc4qg 2 ай бұрын

Bangladesh is a sovereign country with 17 crore with its own dreams and aspirations, as a progressive secular nation, we shed bloods to earn independence and we will uphold it at any cost. We deserve some respect from our big neighbor and deny to be driven by the Indian security concerns of 7 sisters

@khandkerhossain5886 2 ай бұрын

This is again another Modi prone discussion. Mr. PRC purposely ignored the rampant disappearing of people conducted by the Hasina regime and politicization of the institutions, including the law and order and judiciary ones. That basically created major problems and led Hasina to become the non negotiating autocratic regime backed by the India government.

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

In fact, PRC is here to defend the infamous dictator Sk. Hasina's all the dirty works she meted out in the last 15 years.

@riffata9084 2 ай бұрын

Our banks are empty by the thugs, inflation is killing the people of Bangladesh, they had concentration camp name Aina ghor! Please stay something about it!

@aznabimnahid3934 2 ай бұрын

We understand the pain you are going through due to the breakup of your arranged family in Bangladesh. Now make a new family with the people of Bangladesh, not with any single party as you did with Hasina. We don't want enmity with you, we want friendship but it should be friendship of equality. There will be no dadagiri. You have bad relations with most South Asian countries for dadagiri. Accept reality and stop spreading half-truths information. Sheikh hasina was a dictator & only India support three times (2014, 18, 24) to stay in power of that dictator. That's the main reason of anti India movement in Bangladesh. We hate Indian government decision and foreign policy about Bangladesh not Indian people. We know we can't change our neighbours. We should make a promising and respectful relationship with our neighbours

@mrahmanmd Ай бұрын

India is such a country none of its neighbors like her

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

Indian leadership must see inward to rectify their own fault(s), rather blame all the neighbour. Btw, PRC has been giving wrong information here. He should be vetted out for his misinformation. Keep someone from Bangladesh on your panel to counter PRC's BS.

@muradchoudhury 2 ай бұрын

Since India was so nice to Bangladesh and provided the support for the growth of economy. security, and connectivity, all sides should be ery happy. There should not be any concern.

@rezaasif 2 ай бұрын

@@muradchoudhury ha, ha, ha

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

Please use am emoji after your sarcasm. People won't get the message in right perspective. Btw, Pinak is the real villain against the people of Bangladesh. He should also be blamed for the debacle of Awami League. We will never forget his arrogance while he was in service here in Indian HC, Dhaka.

@robiulawal9876 2 ай бұрын

your country should concentrate on neighboring countries as a friendly way but not as a big bro. We are really happy that we are not under the surveillance of India. Please don't be treat as a Godi media PRC is one of the hatred diplomats in our country, just flatterer.

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

You have spoken my mind. Only the elaboration of PRC = Pinak Ranjan Chakravarty needed, just so that we don't mix it up with People's Republic of China (PRC).

@tuf41l 2 ай бұрын

Pinak must be trialled under international law.

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

Yes, you are right. He meddled in the internal affairs of Bangladesh and had the allergy of BNP Jamaat and ISI boogies. This guy must stand trial in India for the deterioriation of relationship between India and Bangladesh. History will prove how wrong India played against Bangladesh.

@narayankumar6063 Ай бұрын

@@mhu1954Laughable 😂 idiotic statements by Islamists

@bondychy3035 2 ай бұрын

Pinaky is culprit.

@hillsrivers 2 ай бұрын

Bangladesh is no more Bangladesh, it is now East Pakistan !!!!!!!!!!!!

@tuf41l 2 ай бұрын

What is your problem?

@bdbusiness7896 2 ай бұрын

Keep your dirty paws off of our country. Mind your own business.

@hillsrivers 2 ай бұрын

@@tuf41l Same as you, dear.

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

Wishful thinking!! Wake up man.

@aliridwan7244 2 ай бұрын

Pinak Ranjan controversial role 2007-2009 we will not forget that his mastery attitude t damazed india Bangladesh relationship.

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

I remember clearly when he was posted out of bangladesh to Thailand IHC, this man PRC audaciously said on air that he is going to Thailand, but will keep a watch about Bangladesh's matter. Hope he will get a due dressing from Indian foreign ministry for his misdeeds while he was in Bangladesh.

@aspiringscientist5455 2 ай бұрын

Indian foreign diplomacy has failed in Bangladesh and in all their neighbor country. change your policy first

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

Can't agree more. PRC and Veena Sikri, Former High Commissioner of India to Bangladesh were two of the few audacious diplomats from india, who served in Bangladesh, and nakedly supported Awami League, against the will of the people.

@monerakhahobe 2 ай бұрын

After her, it is peace, prosperity, the pursuit of happiness and screwing India.

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

Agreed

@HossainSiddiqui 2 ай бұрын

Instead of saying “we provide electricity “, you should say “we sell electricity “ and in high places in the world. This discussion again proves why Bangladesh people are angry on India too.

@sarkarshahab6688 2 ай бұрын

Atleast don't spread rumours, we never have communal riots in Bangladesh, you Indian media work on so many rumors and propaganda, do you know how many Muslims are being persecuted in India?

@ZedSkill 2 ай бұрын

india is land of destitute, hunger and scammers

@shravanamuhuri9514 2 ай бұрын

There can't be riots if one part is 80% and the other is 20% .... It can be one sided killings only..... Hindus suffer bcoz they don't have sharp arms in their homes and are not accustomed to see the live animals killed for meat in front of their eyes , which Muslims are casual with.....

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

India needs to look into mirror to find out why they are so much hated among their neighbours.

@zakeasultana5847 2 ай бұрын

No it's not true that minor communities were attacked. It was a propaganda from Awami Politicians.

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

The much of attack Hindus undergo in Bangladesh are done by the BAL and its supporters. At times we found that a few Bangladeshi Hindus were used to atack a few of Hindu temples so that they can arouse Indian hatred against Bangladesh. But fortunately, all these maligning campaign failed and right thinking Hindus realised BAL motives and refraining to join the orchastera of "Hindus are being attacked in Bangladesh".

@nadeemmahdi6868 Ай бұрын

And mostly the Godi Medias of India.

@NazmulBhuiyan-ei2hk 2 ай бұрын

I dare you or any Indian media to invite a Bangladeshi named Pinaki Bhattacharya

@sena3941 2 ай бұрын

I have nothing but utmost condolences for your grey matter. If you listen to him, then the joke is on you. He would put Peskov to shame when it comes to gaslighting another country. Indian Express is an institution in India. They fought back during Emergency and continues to stamp their journalism with their incredible work. Nobody can stop them. Unlike your crony medias who has fooled their own people and is now continuing to fool them with nonsense on the floods. Why would IE tarnish their reputation by inviting a rabble rouser like Pinaki?

@tuf41l 2 ай бұрын

@@sena3941yes, very honest media. Remains completely silent when minorities are being prosecuted in India.

@sena3941 2 ай бұрын

@@tuf41lIndian Express reports everything. I don't know where you are coming from. We may have our problems and there have been unfortunate incidents. But our courts are doing a stellar job of giving appropriate punishment. Recently a district court set a precedent by giving life sentences (more than 25 years) for the Harpur lynching case. You know why? Because our institutions work. Unlike yours. That is why despite the communal elements, our minorities have stayed in India and keeps their faith on our courts. Because they get justice no matter how delayed it is. Something that is a rare commodity in your own country. Indian Express is a reputed paper and continues to be the bastion of good journalism. Real good journalism. Something you probably don't understand. They report what they see including the lynchings. Our courts give appropriate justice and ensure our democracy survives. Not something you can say about your country. All you can do is complain about your neighbour. Even if you are worried about our minorities, you would not see them trying to cross into your own country. Something you cannot say for your own minorities.

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

Mr. Pinaki Bhattacharya, Bangladeshi KZbinr and blogger, now living in Paris, if brought in this loop of the discussion here in future, then he will beat the shit out of the PRC.

@nadeemmahdi6868 Ай бұрын

@@sena3941Your Media are being called Godi Media by the most popular Indian journalist "Ravish Kumar". The most honest and popular Influencer like "Dhruv Rathee" "Akash Bannerjy" feels the same. How can you expect trusted news from them. Do you think your media is free and fair?

@muradchoudhury 2 ай бұрын

Hasina banned Jamat literally within the last weeks of her fall. One wonder why 🙂

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

Hasina thought that by banning Jamaat and its students wing Shibir on 1st August she can deflate the momentum of the students protests that culminited into One Point Demand to the resignation of Sk. Hasina. Jamaat played smart and didn't come out on the street to protest, after the Jumma Prayer on the following day (2nd August), and that failed the tactic of Hasina to incite Jamaat and show the world that Jamaat is an unruly party fit fo banning. Now PRC is defending Hasina. What a shame.

@RabiulHossain-s5m 2 ай бұрын

There is no useful purpose in performing so frequent post-mortem . India & her int org RAW knew everything that happened and what’s going to happen in August. Possibly there were some miscalculation. With gems of diplomats at all levels there has been miserable fiasco in genuine appreciation. I will place two facts for consideration: border killings & depriving fair share of water from common rivers .

@jeleto 2 ай бұрын

Pinak the culprit who facilitate hasina authoritarian rule and blind supporters her killing aperture. India behave like British monarch and puppet hasina appointed like lord clive . Infact every crime hasina did not only backed by india but also they advised what to do .

@narayankumar6063 2 ай бұрын

Bull shit

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

Correct

@bdbusiness7896 2 ай бұрын

Bending the reality as we know it! Bravo the great spin master!

@ShafiqUllah-j1n 2 ай бұрын

So nice , bnp and jamat is evil and awamelig is angel. 20:55

@tazuddinkhokan8320 Ай бұрын

India is culprit.

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

hahaha

@mosharrafhossain7978 2 ай бұрын

I think Mr PRC has forgotten the role of Pronob Mukherjee clearly narrated in Pranab's book.India has plundered BD since 71 in terms of MAking BD a market for indian goods ,interfering in political governance of the country.PRC is talking like Hasina who would have done in the given context.She could destroy the institutions because India was by her side.

@sha58gvcfbj 2 ай бұрын

See we are concerned about the Bangladeshi migrants Mostly. Whatever discussions are happening for that only. Dont come to india for medical purpose are other things and also protect your minorities. Dont create a situation so that they have to migrate to india suddenly. We indian Bengali hindus or muslims face problems for Bangladeshi people in other parts of india apart from kolkata

@abul_kalameajdani9487 2 ай бұрын

India should support current government and try to gain Bangladeshi people’s friendship. If India support Bangladeshi people It will create strong relationship between two countries.

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

Can't agree more.

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

Pinak Ranjan Chakravarty, former Indian High Commissioner to Bangladesh was the mastermind to support Hasin aby going against the will of the majority of the people of Bangladesh. Not only once did PRC played dirty before the general election of 2008, his cohorts (Veena Sikri is one) in the subsequent general election of 2014, 2018 and in this year 2024 supported Hasina nakedly and aliniated the whole nation (sans the BAL) against India. Keep one panelist from Bangladesh in such discussions and get the real feel of what, why, and when the situation went from bad to worst in terms of Indo-Bangla relationship.

@AslamM 2 ай бұрын

Bangladesh looking this criminal

@khbasher 2 ай бұрын

Mr Pinaki failed to adhere to the protocols expected of a diplomat. On several occasions during his time in Bangladesh, he made comments on the political situation of the host country, which is inappropriate for someone in his position. Even today, he continues to speak as though he is a spokesperson for Awami League. His remarks during a press conference, in the presence of then-Minister Ms. Dipu Moni and journalists, regarding other political parties and what should be done about them, were completely unacceptable. He embodies the attitude of a colonial overseer rather than a diplomat. By providing a platform to someone like Pinaki, the Indian Express has not only undermined its own credibility but has also exposed itself as a tool of colonial influence.

@sha58gvcfbj 2 ай бұрын

@rezaasif 2 ай бұрын

@@sha58gvcfbj With this attitude your country will have no hope of repairing of relationship with my nation. Without your diplomatic and other soddy supports Hasina could never make Bangladesh bleed so much.

@sha58gvcfbj 2 ай бұрын

@@rezaasif First stop hating india. You protect your minorities. And Delhi didnt supported Hasina its a sovereign state.yes Hasina was a secular face so minorities was protected. May I know why Rahul Ananda's house was attacked? India didnt interfere in internal issues of other country. You guys come to india for work and then hate India, then again you come. Dont purchase anything from india.

@narayankumar6063 2 ай бұрын

@@rezaasif What is the geographical location of Bangladesh? It is surrounded on almost all sides by India with a sliver of land border with Myanmar. Don't spew hate or else Bangladesh may be just end up as a vassal state of New Delhi.

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

@@narayankumar6063 your such "Zamindar" type of attitude may be good in your own country while you divide them among casts, but this is Bangladesh an independent country. Stop trying to play as a master.

@salahuddinahmed788 Ай бұрын

Mr. Pinak what about West Bengal ! If you play bad game against your neighbour, West Bengal may want Independence in the long run ! Pl stop play bad game against your neighbours.

@thesaifullahjoy 11 күн бұрын

Hasina again come!!! Joy Bangla Joy Bangabandu ❤

@QamarAhmed-qy4fm 2 ай бұрын

Jamat was alliance with Awami league &Jamat chief wasminister

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

This will not be noticed by the PRC.

@Gxy9640 2 ай бұрын

Please save bangladeshi Hindus 🙏,We Hindus are under a lot of pressure, after the journalists left, they tortured us again, they told us that there was no attack, we can't say anything more.😢, please request your govt not to issue any type of Visa towards Bangladeshi Muslim, it will be a life saving help 😢🙏

@sha58gvcfbj 2 ай бұрын

A discussion by the Bengalis, on bengalis and mostly for the bengalis for both side of the border

@ShafiqUllah-j1n 2 ай бұрын

7:02 Which indian investment came to Bangladesh? Can you be more specific pls

@ArciBD 2 ай бұрын

Unfortunately if West Bengal is lost you will not be able to protect your Seven Sisters. This is the reality. I understand as a Bangladeshi observer that you will lose West Bengal in the hands of Mamata Banerjee and that may be by creating a civil war like situation and Bangladesh will play an important role in this civil war.

@pirateking45 2 ай бұрын

স্বাধীন করব আমরা। পুরো বাংলা এক হবে। বাংলার রাজাকারদের শাস্তি হবে।

@sena3941 2 ай бұрын

What kind of clownish observation is this? There are several thousand problems with Mamata but civil war? That is such a weird observation. Unlike your country, we have elections at every level. West Bengal has a historic level of political violence and cronyism entrenched within its system. Particularly since the Land Reforms carried out by the Left. Mamata Banerjee and TMC rode on people's frustration with that but it later turned out that they are far worse than the Left with respect to the above aspect. I do not like Mamata but even I have that much faith in the system that she would bow down if she is defeated electorally. West Bengal has a history of bandhs and protests. What one sees is not an exception rather it used to be the norm. West Bengal has survived a Naxal insurgency, Maoist insurgency and millions of refugees from your country. If it can do that, it can also witness political changes peacefully unlike your country. People from West Bengal would rather eat shit than collaborate with Bangladeshis. Never seen unreal level of hatred even among Murshidabadis and Malda people. They face a lot of nonsense thanks to the water diversion from Bhagirathi and Ganga and illegal migration. Bangladesh would play no role. We ejected out your political elite in 1947 itself after one of them tried to burn down Kolkata with his goons. Bengalis fought for Indian independence and Bengalis would die on that hill. Our hero is Kakababu (Muzzafar Ahmed), Subhas Bose, Alimuddin Ahmed and many others who fought against the imperialists. Unlike your Nizamuddin and Suhrawardy who collaborated with the British and spread communal nonsense. Bidrohi kobi's writing was the basis of Indian nationalistic revolutionary movement which inspired many young Bengalis. And even if a state goes to disorder, governor takes over and central rule is imposed. This ends up stabilizing the state. Good luck trying to challenge the Eastern Command and CRPF. These are not your UN shrills but battle hardened toughened soldiers who would not tolerate any nonsensical violation of territorial sovereignty. Your juvenile comments reveal nothing but your self defeating ignorance of the country. Aar ghorer kheye bonner mosh na tariye onno kichu korun.

@anshu_1601 2 ай бұрын

@@ArciBD You people are on drugs from Burma next door. Just because Mamata is anti-Modi does not mean she is anti-India. In fact she is as much Indian as Modi. And no West Bengali, me being one, even dreams of considering himself or herself anything but an Indian. Unlike you people and the Pakistanis we celebrate the diversity of our great country. It is our pride and joy and it is what makes India what it is: India.

@nadeemmahdi6868 Ай бұрын

Very wise thinking.

@narayankumar6063 Ай бұрын

@@nadeemmahdi6868Butthead

@akonakon2818 2 ай бұрын

TO WAIT AND SEE.... .

@mffakhru5567 2 ай бұрын

I am told that next week they will discuss radicalization in India that led to the election of the BJP.

@hasanmahmood8078 2 ай бұрын

The ambassadors views are one sided and very very 24:21 biased. No normal person will agree with his views. Hasina was using quota system to recruit her party cadres in government jobs.

@hasanmahmood8078 2 ай бұрын

Ambassador is misleading the viewers with wrong information. After the success of Bangladesh movement India has forgotten about Pakistan and China and concentrating 200% on Bangladesh. But why, can the ambassador answer this?

@anshu_1601 2 ай бұрын

@@hasanmahmood8078Have you heard our EAM Jaishankar's speech today today regarding India and its neighbours at the launch of Rajiv Sikri's book. It will put things in the right perspective to you as far as India's relationship with Bangladesh is concerned.

@jabediqbal6739 2 ай бұрын

@@anshu_1601what did he say?

@pmm7268 2 ай бұрын

Unusual of this channel to present a good interview.

@masudulhasan6509 2 ай бұрын

While working as Indian Highcommissioner Mr. Pinakranjan referred to the Bangladeshi visa applicants as THUGS. Keeping in mind may I ask you gentlemen why you are wasting so much time discussing about these thugs?? Specially with Pinakranjan??

@buildtechnologies6156 2 ай бұрын

The Government always try to avoid punishing the culprit ( the Police officer). They design the case in their own way. This also ignites the fire.

@ShafiqUllah-j1n Ай бұрын

The quota system was here to give advantage of government supporter. 29:49

@riadmahmud3929 2 ай бұрын

Make Hasina Indian PM please.

@Rk-gk4tk 2 ай бұрын

Ok😂

@riadmahmud3929 2 ай бұрын

@@Rk-gk4tk 😅😅

@salahuddinahmed788 Ай бұрын

Mr. Pinak play a dirty role against the total interest of Bangladesh ! He is a person against Bangladesg ! He is an one eyed diplomat !

@gholammustafa4307 Ай бұрын

Mr Pinaki , will you please explain the contradiction of Indian psyche - when Zamat becomes an integral part of AL to suit latter’s political interest, its okay, no question is asked about it’s religious fundamentalism. When Zamat goes it alone it becomes a fundamentalist posing all kinds bogey threats to all and sundry particularly to neighbouring India. Does this narrative reflect India’s skewed and partial view in relation to Bangladesh ? Thanks.

@hasanmahmood8078 2 ай бұрын

😂Hindus are not being targeted in Bangladesh, the entire world has supported this view except India.

@proudtobeaninfidelkafirand7471 2 ай бұрын

Not the world, only CIA and Paki ISI

@MultiHaboo 2 ай бұрын

After Hasina?. Business as usual and long over prosperity !!

@mishuvaiya 2 ай бұрын

Who ever he or she may be is none of concern of india its about us. Who ever we think is worthy we will elect him or her.

@MahmudulHasan-1989 2 ай бұрын

I am a Bangladeshi citizen I voted for Bangladesh Awami League for the first time in my life i.e. boat brand 2008 Sheikh Hasina had no choice at that moment but to run away because she was in power for the past 16 years when she was in power she abused her power, administration partisanship. did, killed the people of their own country, looted banks, smuggled 18 lakh crores of rupees, massacred Islam in the custody of Islam, committed corruption in the name of big projects, there is rise in commodity prices, looted banks, killed 57 army officers of BDR rebellion, last 700 people disappeared and murdered in 16 years, thousands of crores of rupees were looted from the stock market, they made mirror houses and detained dissidents for years without trial. There was no more opportunity to meet. In these 16 years, the people of this country have been deprived of their right to vote. In these 16 years, the vote was held three times. Also there was no freedom of expression of people, for example if you post on Facebook against the government, in that case the government has made digital security laws so that no one can write against the government even on Facebook, any television journalist has made arrangements so that no one can write against the government in the media, its corruption and The level of crime is like a mountain. In a word, the lives of the people of Bangladesh have become unbearable. In the last student movement, there was a massacre. More than a thousand students were massacred. Currently, more than a hundred murder cases have been registered and the leaders and activists are running away. The lives of the leaders and activists are under threat. There is doubt whether the power will come. Sheikh Hasina is responsible for everything Thank you

@mhu1954 Ай бұрын

I have seen many of my educated friends voting for BAL (Bangladesh Awami League) in the General elections held in Bangladesh on 29 December 2008 and now repenting. Let PRC spew out his poisions against BNP, Jamaat or Prof. Md. Yunus, and against the right thinking people of Bangladesh.

@mrahmanmd Ай бұрын

Boarder killing by India, Not giving Bangladesh's water share . Disproportionate trade balance . is this called Improved bi lateral relation !!!!!!!

@r2zee 2 ай бұрын

Pinak drank too much cow-cola today

@QamarAhmed-qy4fm 2 ай бұрын

She ruled the country with iron hand policewas not independent they were party police & one thing she use to sayRazakarthose r notherparty .member except Awami league ever bodyisRazakar that's why she ordered police togun down the army chief is her relative even he couldn't stop the movement lastly she compel toffee from her own country to herModi'sBharat

@hillsrivers 2 ай бұрын

I believe that only India can play crucial role to develop peace in Bangladesh. (from Bangladesh)

@aisonnet 2 ай бұрын

@@hillsrivers Really? We are playing India Out. It will take some time but India will go out completely.

@hillsrivers 2 ай бұрын

@@aisonnet It's fine India/Pakistan out but no one wish to be prostitute, dear ?? --------NGOGRAM

@rezaasif 2 ай бұрын

Are u nuts?

@hillsrivers 2 ай бұрын

@@rezaasif I am your diehard follower, but for how long you are nut. Thank you.

@hillsrivers 2 ай бұрын

@@rezaasif Same to you. Both are Nut and Boltu !!

@farchoudhury 2 ай бұрын

Truth mixed with lies, that’s the former HC Pinaki has done In this podcast. Distasteful.

@AbdusSattar-nr2dv Ай бұрын

What's wrong if Bangladeshi people practice Islam and Establish Islamic State if Much people or Bangladesh wants it!! It's so funny you guys are so worried about the islamic practice!!!

@anshu_1601 2 ай бұрын

Don't worry...Bangladeshis seem to prefer a manic-depressive political culture moving between independence and subjugation every 50 years.. 5th August 2024, the day Hasina fled, is their 3rd Independence Day in 75 years, I believe. No doubt they will feel the need for many more Independence Days in future and the relationship with India would change in the interim period...Nothing to get worried about. India should just ensure that Bangladesh does not do something stupid while its population is peak manic or bottom line depressive which might do real harm to India's interest, that is all.

@jabediqbal6739 2 ай бұрын

@@anshu_1601 the Indians appear to act as the uneducated treating physician who are trying to erroneously diagnose a problem in Bangladesh having no clue how to deal with these problems.

@sanjeevumd 2 ай бұрын

Mr. Chakrabarty is 100% correct. However, the Muslims of Bangladesh will protest Dr. Chakrabarty's speech, as they tend to be very anti-Indian and anti-Hindu

@Birchattala76 2 ай бұрын

my favourite country.. 👇...CR7..🏆🐐 🇵🇹🇵🇹🇵🇹🇵🇹🇵🇹🇵🇹🇵🇹🇵🇹🇵🇹🇵🇹🇵🇹 🇵🇹🇵🇹🇵🇹🇵🇹🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇵🇹🇵🇹🇵🇹 ❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹🏆🏆🏆❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹

@zulkerhyder9510 2 ай бұрын

I have question to guestbwho was embessdor to bangladesh Sir what and why you thinking itbis rhetoric when bnp and other political party demands india must chnage Being an educated your self sir, india being a democratic country , your country had been supporting aa facist government for 16 years Is it rhetoric to demand india must change its policy India shoukd have aupportrd democracy and people of bangladesh not one individual hasina

@drrmdebnath8356 2 ай бұрын

It is large india and hindu india..

@nizamselim7825 2 ай бұрын

I beg to differ with your introductory analysis deliberately making conspicuous the "minority Hindus" as distinct from the Muslims and Buddhists, Christians and Tribals who together constitute the BANGLADESHI NATION. Your "Divide and Rule" policy of India has adversely affected the body politics of Bangladesh and created exogenous artificial fault lines to install Sheikh Hasina and the Awami League to serve Indian interests alone by playing the ethnic card in steamrolling the majority of Bangladeshis and shore up the so-called "War on Terror" of the US Republican Party and George W Bush for Sheikh Hasina and the Awami League singing in tune "Muslim Fundamentalism" and removing Muslim leaders of Bangladesh by extra-judicial killings under the disguise and garb of a cooked up "War Crimes Tribunal". This stage-managed drama engineered and orchestrated by India and RAW has come full circle in falling apart by a popular revolution of Students and the masses. Mr. Pinaki Ranjan Chakravorty sings the Indian tune that is a far cry from what our Mr. Pinaki Bhattacharya has been unraveling in his podcast. Pinaki Bhattacharya is a true blue BANGLADESHI and upholds our independence, freedom and Sovereignty that Sheikh Hasina and the AWAMI-BAKSAL-INDIAN LEAGUE has sold out under the boots of the Indian hegemony in subservient servitude like puppets on a chain. Bangladesh Zindabad.

@AbdusSattar-nr2dv Ай бұрын

Mr. Chakrabarty What Sujata done in 2014 Election! Do you have any explanation for it!! If u cant then stop to present the rubbish stuffs.

@wearetheworld3406 2 ай бұрын

Rendia boycott

@Rk-gk4tk 2 ай бұрын

Kanglu get lost😂

@ShafiqUllah-j1n Ай бұрын

Police did by who's order ? 31:13

@sanjeevumd 2 ай бұрын

@hasanmahmood8078 2 ай бұрын

Hindus earn in Bangladesh but invest in Kolkata. They don't think Bangladesh is their home.

@abirshikder2003 2 ай бұрын

Absurdity you are right the think there own Country is India and thay are playing roll east India company lot our country.

@mdhasanabdulquiyum419 2 ай бұрын

Hi. Change your diplomatic relations.

@dominicrozario5163 2 ай бұрын

Bangladesh is finished without Hasina, how the students are going to be educated in Bangladesh ? students want their fight against the Government without asking for a sitting down meetings and discussions. But student wants violent action against Govt.; Bangladesh is done economically for next 20 years, starvation will kill about 15-20 million people, how the student will feed them ? since they are the boss now for the country ? Students are the boss of the country. Can you imagine ? No investors will come to Bangladesh any more. Bangladesh is doomed with America and India, big mistake done by students to negotiate properly.

@sharierprotik7620 2 ай бұрын

By d way কোথায় সে???

@sarodrau4602 2 ай бұрын

Hon. Ex High Commissioner has the correct picture and historical chronology of Bangladesh...fair and factual! A person like him can rebuild a good relationship between the two states instead of two PMs level!

@tazuddinkhokan8320 Ай бұрын

Ex High commissioner is a great liar like Hasina. All his discussion are false.

@Edonas-ru9zz 2 ай бұрын

I am a student from Bangladesh. 🇧🇩❤️ Sheikh Hasina was a blessing for Bangladesh. Some misguided students did wrong against the Bangladesh Government. Thanks India for helping our beloved Leader.🇧🇩❤️

@NazmulBhuiyan-ei2hk 2 ай бұрын

@@Edonas-ru9zz from which district?

@Edonas-ru9zz 2 ай бұрын

@@NazmulBhuiyan-ei2hk Dhaka

@pirateking45 2 ай бұрын

ছাত্রলীগ, কোন গুহায় আসোস?

@Edonas-ru9zz 2 ай бұрын

@pirateking45 why are you looking for me? Are you terrori*t? or Talib*n?

@uncensoredwiz162 2 ай бұрын

@@Edonas-ru9zz BCL? Which category BCL are you? Answer it or you will be considered as randian

@muradchoudhury 2 ай бұрын

Hinduttabad is very secular.

@tazuddinkhokan8320 Ай бұрын

Last 15 years Indian policy on Bangladesh was totally wrong. They only support one party one woman Awameleg and Sk. Hasina. They don’t make relation with general people of Bangladesh and other political parties. Shame! Shame!

@quazimostufa2380 Ай бұрын

Bangladesh achieved true independence on 4th August 2024 by deposing the worst fascist nonelected undemocratic awamileage regime led by Hasina and sponsored by Delhi. Hasina was in power without any election for the last 15 years. Bangladesh will be prosperous as it will have an inclusive democratic country. The people of Bangladesh are determined to protect the cultural/religious/territorial sovereignty of Bangladesh. India was solely responsible for the destruction of all democratic institutions in Bangladesh by supporting/protecting Hasina. Pinaki Ranjan was one of the people who played a serious role in destroying the democracy of Bangladesh. India must not preach secularism and religious minority protection when RSS led Modi is power.

@azimulhaque901 2 ай бұрын

Hi Mr Pinaki You people never be demarcated every party has good or bad people’s ?? Secondly unable to develop good relationship with people’s republic of Bangladesh instead of choice of person & party ?? No three Only Indian Govt positive attitude can make better relationship as well as ensure safety & security of both this country & win win situation Personally my personal development happened in collaboration with USA indian cultural & educational support

@azimulhaque901 2 ай бұрын

Your opinion now I see it is totally o sided helps to grow as a dictator & vein their party

@hijamacuppingtherapy9119 2 ай бұрын

pinak seems frustrated

@jamaluddinsyed7372 2 ай бұрын

Do not be talkative do not waste time from right now try to build up toilets, pure drinking water, edible foods better livings otherwise india is in dooms day.