Stalin: What They Don't Teach You in School

In another new video by Ed, a side of Stalin is revealed that is virtually unheard of in the West: A persistent fighter for democratic reform.
People in the West come to learn about Stalin from Western sources that usually do not transcend the level of Cold War propaganda. The image of Stalin and the Soviet Union presented there is so horrific that many do not even bother to seek truth from facts. But the Stalin one finds in actual historical facts is completely different from caricature presented in the West: it is an image of Stalin who spent his life struggling for Soviet democracy and the power of the people.

[@JohnKobaRuddy]

The american constitution had about 50 blokes make it. britain even less for its own constitution. but the USSR's? 40+ million took part in some 400,000+ meetings with over 40,000+ suggestions. Now THAT is Democracy.

[@Paddy955]

Well put

[@reorioOrion]

"All my sons are there" Stalin's response to Nazi Germany's proposal to exchange his son, Yakov (he was captured), for Field Marshal Paulus. After learning about how the Germans want to use it, Yakov committed suicide. Stalin had 3 sons. 2 native sons - Yakov and Vasily, and 1 adoptive - Artem. During the Second World War, all three sons fought at the front. Yakov (senior), went to the front on the first day of the war - June 22, 1941. Commanded an artillery battery. Was surrounded, was taken prisoner. Vasily is a pilot. He was the commander of the air army of the Stalingrad Front (pilot) Artem - commanded a rifle company. Got captured. Ran. Joined the partisans. Member of the defense of Stalingrad and many other battles. I... I just don't know what else to add. Western propaganda manages to trivialize even this by arguing that since Stalin refused to change his son for a field marshal, he is a bad father. Stalin was a dictator. But he acted exclusively in the interests of the common people.

[@aventura8491]

What does it really mean to be called a "dictator"? That you purge the bureaucrats? Well, they should be purged!

[@artemesaulkov2010]

Stalin was a dictator only during war though

[@rylord2004]

Most Americans don’t know any of this. Most Americans don’t even know that FDR actually really like and respected Stalin either. I suspect had he lived longer, had Wallace become president…the Cold War may not have happened..great vid.

[@emanuelneagu14]

There is very hard work to do and strong support for Communists needed in order for them to be able to abolish the bureaucracy. I suspect many more years of education and contending were needed. There is a lot to learn from him and today, with the rise of China and slow descent of the US, we may educate ourselves, stand together, hope and contend at the right time for new neo-stalinist societies in the not-so-far future.

[@PayNoTaxes0GetNoVote]

A Democrat idealizes Stalin? Shocking..../S. FFS they loved Hitler too. Always on the side of authoritarianism....always.

[@Come0ndeath]

A western elitist like Stalin? Who cares

[@kimobrien.]

@@emanuelneagu14 Your neo Stalinist societies are Russia and China each building "capitalism in one country" the way capitalism has always developed in one country despite those countries needing a world market. That is why you have the clash of Capitalism with Chinese Characteristics and American Imperialism. Imperialism remains the highest stage of capitalism and revolutionary Cuba shows that revolution is both possible and necessary.

[@ВадимВадимович-ь6т]

@@kimobrien. go to sleep, hangover will go away once you wake up

[@WorldReserveCurrency]

Wow this was excellent coverage of the man. "Centralization of power to bureaucrats just means decentralization of power from the people". Powerful statement.

[@Conv3ctionDUD]

shame on all public schools all over the world for not providing balanced information about the early development of the USSR.

[@emanuelneagu14]

Shame on the demon Western Empire, NATO and it's core, the US bureaucracy and corporations!!! THAT is why you don't hear of this stuff. Nobody has the power to oppose it. YET. Our hope is China and its partners.

[@reclusedoggo3513]

Not schools but anglo saxonic history xD

[@vchk5330]

Stalin did one thing wrong and that was stopping at Berlin.

[@XnarozX]

He died too early, which allowed for criminals to take power

[@joshualittlewolfe8550]

Lmao I am not a bootlicking fascist that loves autocrats, but I will agree with a mindless Tankie on this point! Capitalism and Imperialism are the enemy.

[@vchk5330]

@@joshualittlewolfe8550 cool story

[@joshualittlewolfe8550]

@@vchk5330 Says the kid that hasn't even been in a fist fight in the name of Communism. Give me a break edgelord.

[@joshualittlewolfe8550]

@@puppet1-170 Random? Racists and fascists deserve what they get. Why are you such a wimp?

[@comradejellobiafra4638]

I am not a Stalinist, but the amount of propaganda made against him- specially after his death- Is insane. Great video!

[@comradejellobiafra4638]

@Jesus él McNuggetCunt Oh yes, the imperialist Vietnan VS the freedom fighters of Belgium, France, UK and USA.

[@sovietbot6708]

Stalinism doesn't exist. If you look at the characteristics of Stalinism, most of them wouldn't apply to Stalin. In fact, if you went back in time and told him the characteristics, he would reject and likely speak out against them. The word Stalinism was created by his enemies.

[@kimobrien.]

@@sovietbot6708 Yep eventually even Stalin became a victim of historical falsification that he pioneered. Stalinism never existed. LMAO.

[@deadrat7989]

stalinism doesnt exist because stalin didnt create a new version of marxism

[@kimobrien.]

@@deadrat7989 Stalin never understood Marx or Lenin either He lead a privileged and murderous bureaucracy that took control of the Soviet Union, the Communist Party and the Communist International. Instead of defending the Soviet Union by moving forward with the world revolution he adopted the reactionary theory of Socialism in one country and used the Communist Parties as diplomatic arms of his bureaucracy. Stalin revised the revolutionary teachings of Marx and Lenin replacing them with those of the reformist second international. Return to th two stage theory of revolution where the national bourgeois plays a progressive role. .

[@onanysundrymule3144]

The subtle irony and cleverness of this video is that it uses the very words of Stalin's detractors themselves to illustrate the actual opposite of their nefarious propagandistic intent. ie, many of the books listed here (Stephen Kotkin's for example) are written specifically to smear Stalin and the USSR, but they nevertheless concede certain points, as 'group' highlighted in this video. When thus grouped, they demonstrate the literal opposite of what we have for so long been told and lied to about.

[@iavv334]

Based and red pilled

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Read the 1956 Khruschev speech.

[@gla9322]

@@jaisbrennan7696 no

[@Kobe_Jay_Kenobii]

As Fidel said: "History will absolve me" History will absolve comrade Stalin! This is an incredible video with all of it's sources, we need more information like this, it is the truth. Stalin saved the world from fascism, and was the most selfless Marxist of Europe. God bless this man and may he rest in peace.

[@kimobrien.]

That quote was taken from Fidel's trial after the attack on the Moncada barracks. It goes "..Condemn me it does not matter History will absolve me." Stalin's followers today are working overtime to erase him with claims such as their was no such thing as Stalinism. Everyone carrying pictures of the Stalin God was just another CIA plot. .Face it Stalin studied to be a priest and that part of him never left.

[@cheesemccheese5780]

Do you have Dementia or something? He was responsible for the start of world war 2.

[@cstick2664]

Pretty solid video, however if I where to make one criticism I would recommend adding page or chapter numbers when citing a source or quoting a book, it’s a quick way to check further context without having to look through the entire book. A list of sources in the description would also make things just a bit more convenient for further research as well.

[@seth1782]

I see what you did there.

[@daseapickleofjustice7231]

The amount of propaganda that had to be made against him prove how smart he was

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Stalin was a Nazi. A mass-murderer. He murdered a whole generation of Jewish Poets. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Night_of_the_Murdered_Poets

[@vladimirlenin3562]

@@jaisbrennan7696 “”” A group called the Jewish Anti Fascist Committee asked that Crimea be converted to be a Jewish Autonomous Oblast (State like US States) and the USSR said no, arguing that there was already Birobidzhan (a Jewish Autonomous Oblast), that Jews were free to emigrate to Israel, and that there were ready ~12 Jewish Autonomous Councils in Crimea. The JAFC didn't like that their request had been denied, and decided they would try to start an armed uprising in Crimea to form a Jewish State. The USSR did not like this, and punished the instigators through a series of trials, many of which resulted in executions. It was not a single night of killing people like the name implies.

[@vladimirlenin3562]

@@jaisbrennan7696 and no it wasn’t a whole generation of entire poets lmao

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@vladimirlenin3562 Yes it was.

[@pohatuthereactor1693]

@@jaisbrennan7696 did you even read your own article it said only 13 people where killed

[@oscarleon1170]

Comment for the algorithm 🦍☀️

[@TKanal3]

o7

[@yeeyee5117]

Gorillas and suns! Man, people should be watching this kind of stuff instead of all that stupid Fortnite, GTA V, Minecraft, Trump, MAGA, Biden, VoteBlueNoMatterWho, coronavirus, covid news, new Battlefield 6, new album drop, CALL ME IF YOU GET LOST, Tyler, the Creator, cod Warzone tiktok compilations nah let's get political up in here with Comrade Stalin o7 y'all

[@730g9]

Reply for comment engagement in KZbin algorithm

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Read the 1956 Khruschev speech. Stalin was a serial killer.

[@oscarleon1170]

@@jaisbrennan7696 He lied, we have now access to soviet archives debunking him

[@s33lu]

Shout out to Ed & Raul for making this video! Thanks for your work guys, another banging vid🦍☀️

[@jaisbrennan7696]

In 1956, Nikita Khruschev exposed Stalin's atrocities.

[@JohnKobaRuddy]

@@jaisbrennan7696 in 2021 you revealed you hated facts over feelings

[@fruitbat2714]

If only Stalin and FDR had lived another 10 years..

[@JohnKobaRuddy]

yep. FDR has his bourgeois faults but if he had lived beyond April 45 the world would have been a much better place.

[@mauzekoni5196]

​@☆𝔍𝔬𝔥𝔫 ℜ𝔲𝔡𝔡𝔶☭ Yes. There's a reason the survivors of concentration camp Buchenwald (who were in huge part communist) commemorated FDR in their oath against fascism.

[@Banana_Split_Cream_Buns]

Or better yet, if FDR had died in 1943 or early 1944 so that he was replaced by his Vice President Henry A. Wallace.

[@BusinessGamesAI]

I come to the same conclusion …

[@CartersRemasters]

Or just don’t replace Henry Wallace with Truman

[@blancofishbac8770]

While I don't know if I agree with everything said in this video, it definitely get me thinking about how I view Stalin and how he is portrayed in the West. After watching this, I went ahead and decided to look into some of the claims made about Stalin and I soon found that it wasn't as black and white as I originally thought. I actually read an article in which researchers looked into private letters and conversations with Stalin that found that a lot of our ideas about how evil he was were completely fabricated. They specifically looked into the Great Purges and found that Stalin did them not because he didn't like people but because he was afraid that they were threats to the communist project. Especially given the rising powers of Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan, Stalin thought it necessary to take care of those he saw as enemies from within first. These fears paired with overzealous officials is what led to the Great Purges as the researchers found. It was only after Stalin had died that the bureaucrats who carried out the purges pegged it all on Stalin to absolve them of all responsibility. I had never really known any of this and had always assumed Stalin to be a bloodthirsty tyrant with no regards for others, but after looking into it a bit more, my previous idea of the man have completely come apart. This doesn't mean he was necessarily a good guy, but he's not the monster people portray him to be. Because of that, this video is worth watching if for nothing else to get people thinking about how they view Joseph Stalin and the propaganda they have been raised with in the west.

[@dickyboi4956]

If joe biden led the government and a purge of all socialist or communists or people accused of affiliation with them and then it turned out that he actually just was worried they would destroy the country and the officials were the ones carrying out most of it and he only oversaw the government and allowed it to happen would this absolve him?

[@mikemurray2027]

The real truth that has been so carefully and diligently buried is that there really were large-scale plots by senior figures in the army and state apparatus who wanted to overthrow the government and were in contact with western intelligence agencies who were helping them. The question for historians is: what was the extent of this network and how did it operate. But of course, it's all just denied and explained as 'Stalin killing his enemies', though the same people claim that there were no enemies. It is unimaginable that there was not western intelligence networks operating in the USSR, particularly German, Polish and probably British. They were active in all other countries, after all.

[@jaisbrennan7696]

He murdered innocent people.

[@mikemurray2027]

@@jaisbrennan7696 No one denies that innocent people were judicially murdered, but it's all a bit more complicated than you seem to think.

[@jaisbrennan7696]

​@@mikemurray2027 It really isn't complicated at all. The people who say it was complicated are the same as neo-Nazis like David Irving who deny that Hitler knew about the Holocaust.

[@vectorbasis4725]

This is actually a very important video. If the philosophy of Stalin can be proven to be separate from the turgid Nomeklatura that the USSR degenerated to, then it completely changes the perception of Stalinism.

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Nikitia Khruschev exposed Stalin's atrocities in 1956.

[@kimobrien.]

@@jaisbrennan7696 They had been exposed by Trotsky in the 1930's.

[@Conserpov]

@@jaisbrennan7696 "Exposed", sure. 🐒

[@bourbon2242]

@@jaisbrennan7696 read Grover Furr

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@Conserpov Read the Posepelov Commission.

[@DonScrews]

Should have 100 million views

[@Diamiratrapbeats]

I see what you did there

[@forthelulz5411]

Algorithm

[@Andrearuch97]

Comment for the algorithm

[@stonedsour2097]

Ed is awesome

[@agentsmith4409]

Workers of the world, unite!

[@DialecticalMaterialismRocks]

I prefer the first title: Stalins legacy of democracy

[@checkitoutguys1]

music in background is literally aphex twin's stone in focus lol. great video btw, eye opening to say the least.

[@BobBob-yr4qo]

I usually watch videos at 2x speed, but this I watched at normal speed. Damn was it worth it

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Read the 1956 Khruschev speech.

[@comradedude5824]

@@jaisbrennan7696 Read Khrushchev Lied

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@comradedude5824 Read about the Shvernik Commission, the Posepelov Commission and the book "Let History Judge" by Roy Medvedev.

[@comradedude5824]

@@jaisbrennan7696 Read Stalin

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@comradedude5824 Why? His Short Course is a lie. It calls Zinoviev and Kamenev spies when the opened Soviet archives prove that they weren't.

[@pixeldoor4792]

I was browsing reddit and this video popped up on five separate subreddits in order, the universe gave me a sign and I regret nothing, great video!

[@DEMONTOR6]

wtf reddit based????

[@pixeldoor4792]

@@DEMONTOR6 if you know where to look, all the good stuff is on quarantined subreddits like fullcommunism

[@DEMONTOR6]

@@pixeldoor4792 I'm familiar with those subreddits. It was mostly a joke but the culture of reddit is the problem. Of course there's going to be some good info on there. But it's buried in a pile of masturbatory BS.

[@pixeldoor4792]

@@DEMONTOR6 I could tell, and yeah you’re right Edit: autocorrect

[@JohnKobaRuddy]

Glorious work

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Nikitia Khruschev exposed Stalin's atrocities in 1956.

[@JohnKobaRuddy]

@Jesus él McNuggetCunt rewriting capitalist history which is a lie

[@JohnKobaRuddy]

@@jaisbrennan7696 an entire book has been used to debunk his secret speech! It’s available online for free called Khrushchev lied

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@JohnKobaRuddy Furr is a 21st Century adherent of the Stalin School of Falsification.

[@JohnKobaRuddy]

@@jaisbrennan7696 and multiple historians have proven Khruschev to be a liar.

[@iliveinyourfloors]

Rewatching this masterpiece,would be cool if Infrared posted more vids like this.

[@davidalvarez1388]

Could you share the bibliography that the video used? (for convenience of the viewer and for future read)

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Read the 1956 Khruschev speech.

[@stranger1805]

☀️🦍

[@Milan23_]

Thanks for video, I was thought that Stalin was monster almost as Hitler

[@JohnKobaRuddy]

it gets much better once you actually read some actual real data combined with nuance and dialectical historical materialism. Slava Stalin.

[@UmQasaann]

"Stalin is a monster" ^According to capitalists and fascists!

[@morningstararun6278]

Stalin was indeed a monster for Treacherous Fascists and Poisonous Capitalists.

[@realone5128]

o7

[@RunOverHomeless]

incredible video

[@robsl18]

Lit video, what's the music in the background I recognise it?

[@cam-gv2gf]

stone in focus by aphex twin and #13 (blue calx) by aphex twin

[@robsl18]

@@cam-gv2gf thanks I couldn't tell if it was boards of Canada or aphex twin

[@greatwhitenorth5280]

Based

[@crawcrey2698]

🦍☀️

[@Anthony-jx6vo]

Great vid

[@garybulger4686]

Can you please list the source material in the comments for easier copying? I need to update my library.

[@edwardallan197]

Thank you. ❤

[@amilcardapraia]

Great vid!!! Can anyone tell me which soundtracks were used for this?

[@ethel9459]

Stalin pilled 😎

[@sbqhd7174]

🦍☀️

[@Cicada-oo7ti]

BASED

[@erinboom]

Thank you for sourcing the books. makes a great reading list

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Proof that Trotsky was a Gestapo agent?

[@jaisbrennan7696]

In 1956, Nikita Khruschev exposed Stalin's atrocities.

[@comradedude5824]

@@jaisbrennan7696 Khrushchev Lied by Grover Furr you obsessed maniac

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@comradedude5824 Read about the Shvernik Commission, the Posepelov Commission and the book "Let History Judge" by Roy Medvdev.

[@jonsnow5513]

Stalin helped feed Indians suffering from the Bengali famine before anyone else 💪🏽… “Documents can wait, hunger cannot.”

[@TKanal3]

o7

[@adt_10terrarian5]

Churchill: Caused the Bengali famine Stalin: Helped to solve it And the normies today remember Churchill as a hero, and Stalin as a tyrant, while it should be the other way around

[@blackpathos5791]

@@adt_10terrarian5 "Churchill" didn't cause the Bengal famine and no historian accepts this argument, he was a bigot but he certainly wasn't mentally capable enough of singlehandedly orchestrating such an heart-wrenching atrocity

[@justamoteofdust]

@@blackpathos5791 it was his policies that caused it. Wtf are you talking about?! Should I cite the study from India here?! Don't you dare try to white-wash that bastard's crimes!

[@xCorvus7x]

And this guy allegedly starved the Ukraine?

[@franalovana6417]

Up Up ✊

[@EmperorZeldar]

🦍☀️

[@crater35]

Stalin embodied the wideness of the people 07

[@papichulo4171]

Real kzbin.info/www/bejne/jXzOl31qf8xlmKs

[@RobWickline]

Here's a list of all the cited sources: 1. Against Vulgarising the Slogan of Self-Criticism (Works, Vol. 2) - Josef Stalin 2. Waiting for Hitler - Stephen Kotkin 3. Soviet Communism: A New Civilization, Vol. 1 - Beatrice Webb 4. The Red Executive - David Granick 5. 'Excesses are Not Permitted', Mass Terror and Stalinist Governance in the Late 1930s (Russian Review, Vol. 61) - J Arch Getty 6. Soviet Legal Innovations and the Law of the Western World - John Quigley 7. State and Society Under Stalin - J Arch Getty 8. Stalin's Constitution - Samantha Lomb 9. Terror and Democracy in the Age of Stalin - Wendy Goldman 10. Practicing Stalinism - J Arch Getty 11. Mastering Bolshevism - Josef Stalin 12. Magnetic Mountain - Stephen Kotkin 13. Stalin and the Struggle for Democratic Reform - Grover Furr 14. Economic Problems of the Socialism in the USSR - Josef Stalin

[@somethingelse9228]

Thanks

[@willdavis7254]

#13 should be read by everyone!

[@fantomchaser1]

One thing they didnt go into is the story about him taking all the grain starting the famine part. else i missed something, id very much like to know about that part

[@RobWickline]

@@fantomchaser1 sounds like you should make your own video essay if you think this is lacking. also, i simply listed the citations so im not really sure how well-placed a criticism is in response to a list of citations.

[@fantomchaser1]

@@RobWickline for me its like you are asking me to change years of history lessons ofc for me to change my mind i need to have some diggin done. I am so focused on all the ongoing geopolitical stuff along with economics to start diggin down in a whole history rewriting it would just be tooo much of a task on top of what i am diggin into. Which is why i am asking and as i said i might have had missed it if it was in the video so not critism but curiosity and was hoping you or any one who saw this comment might know where to look for the answer in regards the story we are told that he removed all the farmers took all their grain and moved the farmers to the gulag and replaced them with inexperienced new farmers which resulted in the massive famine for years to come.. Id just very much like to know about this and where to look again not critism but curiosity

[@shmee6296]

backing music great as always

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Stalin murdered the majority of the members of the Bolshevik Party from 1936 to 1939.

[@shmee6296]

@@jaisbrennan7696 really I had no idea thank you for informing me of this little known fact

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@shmee6296 You're welcome.

[@TKanal3]

10k LETSS GOOOOOO

[@The80sWolf_]

🦍☀️

[@kino_enjoyer]

There was a joke like this in the later USSR: - Why are there no beaver hats in the stores? - Because beavers are being shot constantly, but the nomenculature was last being shot in 1937.

[@jaisbrennan7696]

So you admit Stalin was a mass-murderer.

[@kino_enjoyer]

@@jaisbrennan7696 yes and I approve it

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@kino_enjoyer So then don't cry about Hitler massacring Leningrad

[@kino_enjoyer]

@@jaisbrennan7696 I'm crying that Stalin didn't finish them off

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@kino_enjoyer Finish who off?

[@geodude205]

The 1936 Constitution is the most democratic constitution in world history. And it worked.

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Stalin murdered the majority of the members of the Bolshevik Party from 1936 to 1939.

[@WM-gf8zm]

@@jaisbrennan7696 churchill murdered majority of africa & asia from 1936 to 1945

[@therepublicofamerica716]

@@WM-gf8zm please shut up

[@isaacstamper7798]

@@jaisbrennan7696 source?

[@markusjohannesmischawolf4193]

That's true: kzbin.info/www/bejne/jKXKXqKel7OMn6s

[@boostcanaddict9208]

🦍🍽🦈

[@NathanNathanNathan]

algorithm gang

[@iron_sky7]

Просьба сделать перевод на русский

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Stalin was a serial killer. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Night_of_the_Murdered_Poets

[@JohnKobaRuddy]

@@jaisbrennan7696 Stalin IS a Hero! Now, then and forever.

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@JohnKobaRuddy Read the 1956 Khruschev speech.

[@papichulo4171]

Fantastic video

[@danko152]

I love the quote of "I know that after my death a pile of rubbish will be heaped on my grave, but the wind of History will sooner or later sweep it away without mercy." Already Predicted it

[@emilarm]

Only one problem, that We don't have any sourse, that Stalin said it

[@WhyTho525]

@@emilarm He said this to Molotov in 1941. Even if he didn't say it, it is still true.

[@emilarm]

​@@WhyTho525 It's modern myth about Stalin. When Soviet Union clashed many fake informations were created.

[@TKanal3]

It’s probably not a real quote but its still true and can be posthumously canonised.

[@JohnKobaRuddy]

it was as far as my memory serves me said to a foreign emissary. whether Stalin said it is very much open to debate but it stands true though that just cant be denied.

[@ImXs1p3r]

lets go 10k

[@Andrearuch97]

SLAVA STALINA

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Stalin was a serial killer. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Night_of_the_Murdered_Poets

[@zinozee8929]

@@jaisbrennan7696 wikipedia 😂😂😂 did you write that yourself? I found the edit button

[@yeeyee5117]

This channel doesn't miss!

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Read the 1956 Khruschev speech.

[@yeeyee5117]

@@jaisbrennan7696 Khrushchev should have been purged like Gorby too

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@yeeyee5117 Read the Shvernik and the Posepelov Commission.

[@BlackLenin]

ZA RODINU, ZA STALINA! Great Video on Stalin.

[@vladimirlenin3562]

Black Lenin 😳

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Stalin was a serial killer. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Night_of_the_Murdered_Poets

[@hmmmm9174]

Based USSR

[@sauvagesauvage1869]

10k in 1 week let's goooo

[@ElViejo1]

Another banger. Outstanding work, Infrared is Rising..

[@TKanal3]

INFRARED RISING

[@vladislavbg9307]

CPUSA 2036

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Stalin was a Nazi. A mass-murderer. He murdered a whole generation of Jewish Poets. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Night_of_the_Murdered_Poets

[@rationaloutlook5772]

@@jaisbrennan7696 LOL the fact that you said Stalin was a Nazi alone proves that you don't know what Nazism and Marxism-Leninism is.

[@vaibhavsajith4267]

@@jaisbrennan7696 lmao Wikipedia hahahahahahah

[@RealIsaiahSwift]

Infrared cannot be stopped. Like if you agree. Stalin lives in our hearts!

[@TKanal3]

INFRARED RISING

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Stalin was a Nazi. A mass-murderer. He murdered a whole generation of Jewish Poets. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Night_of_the_Murdered_Poets

[@vladimirlenin3562]

@@jaisbrennan7696 A group called the Jewish Anti Fascist Committee asked that Crimea be converted to be a Jewish Autonomous Oblast (State like US States) and the USSR said no, arguing that there was already Birobidzhan (a Jewish Autonomous Oblast), that Jews were free to emigrate to Israel, and that there were ready ~12 Jewish Autonomous Councils in Crimea. The JAFC didn't like that their request had been denied, and decided they would try to start an armed uprising in Crimea to form a Jewish State. The USSR did not like this, and punished the instigators through a series of trials, many of which resulted in executions. It was not a single night of killing people like the name implies.

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@vladimirlenin3562 The trials were fabricated. There was no armed uprising. That's why after Stalin died, Beria released the unjustly imprisoned Jewish Doctors.

[@vladimirlenin3562]

@@jaisbrennan7696 The Jewish doctors case is very complex

[@mimema7973]

MAN OF IRON

[@thomaswynn4082]

Glory to comrade Stalin

[@jaisbrennan7696]

A goddamned murderer.

[@thomaswynn4082]

@@jaisbrennan7696 a hero

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@thomaswynn4082 what's heroic about murder?

[@thomaswynn4082]

@@jaisbrennan7696 without him you'd be speaking German right now

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@thomaswynn4082 He murdered the majority of the members of the Bolshevik Party from 1936 to 1939.

[@boostcanaddict9208]

Beautiful

Comrade Stalin was one of the best communists in socialist history 💪🏽

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Read the Khruschev speech.

[@RedNeckRed647]

@@jaisbrennan7696 Read Khrushchev Lied by Grover Furr

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@RedNeckRed647 Read The Stalin School of Falsification by Leon Trotsky

[@comradedude5824]

@@jaisbrennan7696 Read Stalin

[@markusjohannesmischawolf4193]

@@jaisbrennan7696, did your family suffered under Stalin?.

[@juanbermudez6489]

I've been waiting for this for long time!!! Fierro!!!

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Read the 1956 Khruschev speech.

[@JohnKobaRuddy]

@@jaisbrennan7696 read Khrushchev Lied by Grover Furr

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@JohnKobaRuddy Khruschev is a 21st century adherent of the Stalin School of Falsification.

[@Buorgenhaeren]

The USSR under Stalin was the greatest civilization that humankind has ever built

[@s1050]

Yes and now the People’s Republic of China has taken its place

[@WM-gf8zm]

@@s1050 no

[@kobemop]

@@WM-gf8zm yes

[@DEMONTOR6]

@@s1050 BASED!

[@WM-gf8zm]

@Resilient Z socialism in 2500

[@gheo.2641]

Awesome video, it really made me question my knowledge. I’ll certainly look deeper into this, thanks a lot!

[@oliversmith4044]

nice

[@dielawn87]

The Soviet Union is a message in a bottle

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Read the 1956 Khruschev speech.

[@alejandro3702]

@@jaisbrennan7696 Read Grover Furr

[@judoexpert2057]

Man when I talk to Western "leftists" and recommend them a reading list which includes Stalin's writings like foundations of Leninism, they say "I'm not gonna take the opinions of a mass murderer seriously" that breaks my heart, there's so much propaganda against stalin, you can't even begin to change people's minds. ps-my pfp is a joke I'm not a titoist

[@protonmaximum6193]

it’s funny because these “leftists” are agreeing with western propaganda by doing that

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Nikitia Khruschev exposed Stalin's atrocities in 1956.

[@Dima-px6pr]

@@jaisbrennan7696 because he hate him and try to destroy his lagcy

[@lellaughnik2728]

Massmurders aside Stalin simply didn't really understand dialectics and leninism. Even with good intentions we was doomed to fail like this.

[@Maverick.D.]

Hell yeah.

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Read the 1956 Khruschev speech.

[@dorothydepth000]

As a Russian person born in the USSR, let me thank you for this video, comrades! From the bottom of my heart. Thank you! Workers of the world, unite!

[@TKanal3]

Thank YOU and your country for all you have done!

[@dorothydepth000]

@@TKanal3 without the support of our comrades all across the world, none of it would have been possible! The international workers' movement defended the young Soviet Russia against military intervention of the bourgeois forces. And our comrades' continuing support helped the USSR to survive and develop. So thank YOU! The time will come again, comrade, to support and help each other.

[@kobemop]

hopefully someday USSR can make its return

[@dorothydepth000]

@@kobemop it can ;)

[@kobemop]

@@dorothydepth000 sorry made a typo, i mean can*

[@TKanal3]

Rewatched it the next day and this is still a DECISIVE Video

[@jaisbrennan7696]

In 1956, Nikita Khruschev exposed Stalin's atrocities.

[@bojout]

@@jaisbrennan7696 you just posted it under all the comments lmao

[@JohnKobaRuddy]

@@bojout he has two accounts on here doing that

[@perfecto_monstro]

Привет из России! держитесь товарищи по ту сторону океана! У нас такие же проблемы как и у вас. А по сему; пролетарии объединяйтесь!

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Proof that Trotsky was a Gestapo agent?

[@JohnKobaRuddy]

@@jaisbrennan7696 ask Lenin’s wife nadezhda

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@JohnKobaRuddy She helped Lenin write his Last Testament suggesting Stalin not be his successor.

[@aarondevaldez9134]

УРА!!!

[@iSgtxPepper]

I’m so hyped for this video!

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Stalin was a serial killer. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Night_of_the_Murdered_Poets

[@yuven437]

Absolutely stunning work! My only critique is the dark sombre music that one often hears in propaganda pieces on stalin and communism

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Stalin was a Nazi. A mass-murderer. He murdered a whole generation of Jewish Poets. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Night_of_the_Murdered_Poets

[@utryping]

@@jaisbrennan7696 Too bad

[@Andrearuch97]

@@jaisbrennan7696 COPE LIBTARD

[@JohnKobaRuddy]

@@jaisbrennan7696 awwwww poor poets who were also Israel first and vet anything else. Boohoo! Stalin is a hero! PERIOD!

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@JohnKobaRuddy Murder is wrong, whether the perpetrator is Hitler or Stalin or Baruch Goldstein. Anyone who says otherwise is a fucking creep.

[@YellowstoneCommie]

I was unsubscribed from this channel after subscribing . I heard one show a couple weeks ago that was really great. I then heard about some new content and realized KZbin unsubscribed me. Thanks for all the hard work. Z

[@pablovonclausewitz]

You just don't get such a thought provoking, articulate and informative video anywhere else. NO BASELESS CLAIMS. NO TRACES OF SIMPLE MINDEDNESS. UNBIASED. ACTUAL DEEP CRITICAL THINKING REQUIRED.

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Read the 1956 Khruschev speech.

[@realaurorien]

@@jaisbrennan7696 bs.

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@realaurorien Read the Shvernik and the Posepelov Commission.

[@jeebusthegreat8819]

@@jaisbrennan7696 Yeah, Khrushchev lied.

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@jeebusthegreat8819 Read the Shvernik and the Posepelov Commission.

[@binkycat]

Good video. Going to watch this while taking a cold shower.

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Stalin was a serial killer. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Night_of_the_Murdered_Poets

[@Andrearuch97]

@@jaisbrennan7696 COPE LIBTARD

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@Andrearuch97 What's "liberal" about not wanting to murder innocent people? There is nothing powerful or "tough" about murdering innocents, it's weak and cowardly.

[@zinozee8929]

True Russians love Koba.. as do us Bangladeshis. They always help our country BD/Russia brothers for life

[@mikemurray2027]

Excellent work!

[@cam-gv2gf]

Reminder that Stalin tried resigning FOUR times. Could anybody imagine a REAL dictator like Hitler doing the same?

[@therollerlollerman]

Tbh there's no need to mention those resignation attempts as other dictators more stable and savvy than Hitler have done the same to show how they were "supported" by the people (and they knew no one would dare remove them from their seats anyway). Better to look at the real democratic nature of the Soviet state and system that still functioned until the end when it was finally subverted by the nomenklatura.

[@generaltso9402]

​@@therollerlollerman Stalin tried to resign FOUR times!!! See he was the GOOD GUY!!! He was really a GOOD BOY!!! What BULLSHIT. If he really wanted to quit he could of.

[@chanegun]

im a fan of this channel, but this is not a great argument. Trotsky and Lenin also threw tantrums and pretended to resign when they didn't get their way. It was kind of a thing

[@1homelander179]

This is a very liberal point. We don't want to prove that stalin wasn't a dictator by liberal standards. Because he was. What we need to prove is that which class did the ussr served and it was defenatly the proletariat. I don't care about liberal standards, i only care about marxist standards.

[@yeeyee5117]

@@generaltso9402 just watch the damn video

[@futureangles]

Thanks for this! I overdubbed in english a great russian vid on Stalin too if anyones interested!

[@JohnKobaRuddy]

i am

[@JohnKobaRuddy]

subbed. cheers comrade

[@TKanal3]

Absolutely incredible video in every regard

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Read the 1956 Khruschev speech. Stalin was a serial killer.

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Read the 1956 Khruschev speech.

[@ImXs1p3r]

SPREAD THIS FAR AND WIDE

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Read the 1956 Khruschev speech.

[@tornadonick6480]

based video, everyone needs to see this

[@EurekaRepublic89]

I will not allow anyone to say Joseph Stalin without the title 'Sheikh'.

[@ImXs1p3r]

INFRARED IS RISING

[@JulienTeyteau]

Magnificent work.

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Read the 1956 Khruschev speech.

[@JulienTeyteau]

@@jaisbrennan7696 Read the book "Kruchtchev lied" by Grover Furr. The speech you're referring to is an absolute pile of bull dung. Lies upon lies upon lies.

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@@JulienTeyteau Read about the Shvernik Commission, the Pospelov Commission. Read the book "Let History Judge" by Roy Medvedev. Read Anastas Mikoyan's testimony.

[@JohnKobaRuddy]

@@jaisbrennan7696 hahahahahaahahahahahahahahahah

[@hey01e5]

the fact that kuckchev went around and started dissing stalin after his death makes me so mad

[@DEMONTOR6]

He went on a world tour of cope

[@UshankaShow]

Why? Stalin was the guy who chose him. In Stalin's democracy no one could be promoted without Coba's direct involvment.

[@jaisbrennan7696]

Stalin was a Nazi. A mass-murderer. He murdered a whole generation of Jewish Poets. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Night_of_the_Murdered_Poets

[@e11-f2l]

@@jaisbrennan7696 based

[@jaisbrennan7696]

@Hussein the supporter of KARA BOĞA Stalin was the one who created Israel in 1947, I guess he was a Zionist too? No, I will condemn it to the Nazis, because a murderer is a murderer.

[@readdworkin8786]

Really REALLY well done... this is going to make people mad

[@zx1048216]

Hopefully. Angry debate is emotionally honest debate with little opportunity for rehearsed dogma and propaganda. People in the west have never been honestly educated on all the good Stalin did.

[@josephstalin7767]

Amazing information source, thank you 💯💯💯💯💯💯

[@ngomasound]