Ingersoll Rand 2235 - VS - Nitrocat 1250-K

[@rcatank]

why cant all tool reviews on youtube be soo thorough and short.... good work mate

[@RealToolReviews]

+rcatank Thanks!

[@gsxravery]

My last Ingersoll 1/2 lasted over 22 years of Daily use still works just want more power. I think I'll have to stick with Ingersoll.

[@john4kc]

When it's in reverse, there is only one power level on the IR. The power dial only controls the forward power. When it's in reverse the air doesn't even go through the dial, but a different channel. I bet the shorter anvil version of the IR would have more torque than the long anvil version.

[@bindthedevilloosetheangels]

When my Milwaukee 2767-20 High Torque can't break a lug nut loose with a 2" extension and flip socket 9 times out of 10 my I.R. 2235 Standard length anvil can! I love my I.R. 2235 only regret is I did not buy the quiet version. I.R. 2235 QTI.

[@OdinsCloud]

Would love to see the quiet vs standard version of Ingersoll Rand 2235 Impacts

[@garyabc]

Me too! Is it true that you can temporarily remove the filter on the quit IR gun if you need that extra force?

[@ShamelessTR]

Man I love that Nitro Cat. I'm a full time mechanic and I use a 1250k on a daily basis. It's a gnarly beast. Everyone knows me and my Impacts... Ha.

[@thebeetalls]

I appreciate the work you put into this and the fair and balanced presentation. So many "tool reviews" on KZbin are just glorified advertisements.

[@SouthMainAuto]

Greta job Daniel. I just bought one of those Nitro Cats and have been using it at the shop for a while now. It's OK, kinda big and clumsy but OK. I just like my IR's I guess :)

[@vincentneri708]

+South Main Auto Repair My thinking is that as battery technology improves air impacts will become obsolete.

[@satamanschmidt3428]

+South Main Auto Repair I believe that you're the only man on earth that thinks LOUDER is better. I sent you the TOPTUL gun because I couldn't stand how loud it is and you love it. The only reason you prefer the I-R is that they are earsplittingly loud. The Nitrocat/MAC is a little bigger, true, but it's quiet. That to me is an overwhelming advantage.

[@vincentneri708]

I never considered the noise factor because I work mostly outdoors. However, I could see where noise could be a legitimate concern.

[@LazySniper]

+SATAMAN Schmidt If it ain't loud, it ain't working hard.

[@MattsShop]

Loud? That's the best sound in the world!

[@3.0TMKreaZ]

Glad there was a proper review for these. I couldn't see myself getting a truck brand impact gun for more than 250

[@johnlong5899]

I prefer the separate power and direction controls on the IR because I want to set my power ratings only once. I want all the power in reverse for nut busting but the lowest power in forward for snugging bolts down. From there, out comes the Snappy. I don't care to torque nuts or bolts down with an impact. Even with torque sticks. I snug them with an impact only when convenient and there is no risk of cracking something. The direction buttons on the IR are most convenient for me and win hands down plus they make the tool foolproof for how I like to do stuff.

[@donsgotmoney]

I have a Nitrocat 1200, its a freaking beast, I can break class 8 tractor lugnuts all day with it. The two of these are very close in comparison, but the price difference is dramatically different. I shopped around and found a company in Lawrenceville Ga that sell the Nitrocat for 159.00, the IR was at the lowest price i could find 239.00. Excellent review!!!

[@Dcc357]

I got a 1200k too. It stands up to almost everyday use, it's super light, feels comfortable, and it saves my hearing too lol. I got the red protective cover for it that has flames on it.

[@93sundance]

So the Aircat had a whole 14 ft lbs more. I have a IR 2135 for 14 years and it is now what I use at home. For work IR 2235QTI. Amazing power and it is so quiet. Another guy in the shop bought one after his Aircat broke for the 3rd time in about 5 years.

[@Wagonman5900]

I have a Mac Tools AW612Q. I think its a glorified Aircat 1000-TH. I still have not found a bolt or nut that it won't remove with just a socket on the end of it. I can't think of any problem I've had with it that can't be traced back to operator error. Just remember to change the oil in t the hammer chamber every once in a while.

[@feliserlnesdaantos1074]

I've talked to a Mac dealer and he told me that manufacturers of AIRCAT is the one who manufactures MAC Impact Wrenches as well.

[@aleross1000]

Would like to see this comparison again but with the forward and reverse torque tests as well as the dynamic test looking to buy a new impact soon but would like to see an updated comparison

[@stevegoodwin9979]

Lot of Upset IR fans here.... but the truth of the matter is this. It really doesn’t matter which impact has the most torque, at the end of the day whatever busts loose the rusty bolt,nut, etc. is what counts. The difference in performance is so close the real winners here are us consumers.

[@rbhe357]

1 disadvantage not mentioned with the 2235. For the same cost, you can get the Nitrocat plus 120 items from the dollar menu.

[@MattsShop]

Ryan Heyborne Haha cute.

[@ghostbuilder3187]

Fatass

[@sharksshark6212]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@automedic9781]

I had a 1250k from about May to October 2017 and it was the best impact gun I've ever bought. I have a Matco gun now as I dropped the NitroCat off of a four post lift from about 8 feet in the air and cracked the casing. I really wish I'd waited to buy another 1250k instead of my Matco gun, not only because of price but performance as well. I could definitely see myself getting another NitroCat a few years from now as I just don't want to spend the money right now.

[@Soccerthelegend]

I have had my aircat 1200k since they came out with it very good gun and still works till this day I got curious and called aircat just to see what a repair kit would cost and they told me the kit was $21.00 I was shocked to hear that. so if anyone is looking to get a aircat don't hesitate. there very strong and reliable impacts. I've also had the 3/8 nitro cat 1355 and that little guns a beast too plent of power to do most jobs. reliable as well. good video man keep up the good work!

[@RealToolReviews]

Thanks! And great price on a rebuild kit....cheaper than I would have guessed!

[@snapshot12002]

I had a bad Aircat 1200k right from the box. I got it off eBay new, so who knows, the seller may have unloaded a suspect one?? Aircat sent me a new one right away. It is quiet. Sometimes I don't think its working right because its so quiet, but it breaks the bolt free. Its nice to have. Just did front end work with it today.

[@Smokin07ram]

FYI the Nitrocat 1250K IS the Mac tools Quiet Drive.....Yeah its that good. Mac brags about this tool...for good reason. We have both IR and Nitroccat in my shop...HANDS DOWN the Nitrocat wins in breaking stuff loose. Having taken both apart, and serviced them....Both look like good long term pieces.

[@tomith0162]

Just subscribed to your vids, love the reviews! I was a mechanic for 13 years until recently just giving it up to become an independent tool truck. One concern I think that come with the review of each tool is longevity and ease of repair (availability of parts) because we all know nothing last forever. Surprised the air cat comes out on top! I was always an IR guy, if I had seen this earlier may have swayed me the other way! Keep up the good work.

[@RealToolReviews]

+Josh Swanson Thanks Josh! I agree....longevity and ease of repair is a huge plus (or minus) when it comes to tools, but I havent heard any consistent complaints with either of these so far. The other thing to keep in mind would be the ease of warranty.....both of these have 2yr warranties, but as you know --- some companies make that a LOT easier than others. It is definitely best to research as much as you can prior to investing in any tool......good luck with the new career! :)

[@Rickm2003]

l have aircar 1150, no regrets. Have not had a nut or bolt it couldn't knock loose!! l used this review to help me decide as far as power and price point. This was a few years ago, but better late than never.

[@doughayes6084]

The extended anvil with the ir is going to loose tq compared to air cat

[@FusionBoost2.0]

My local mechanic that does the work I can't do my self at home like tire install, alignments etc runs a nitro cat and he's run everything from snap on to CP and will never go back... Best gun he's ever had

[@RealToolReviews]

+2011sportsman Nice!

[@krislizana2017]

the ingersoll rand is max power reverse, and adjustable in forward, from what I've read on ir's website.

[@cbmech2563]

I've had my nitrocat for over 5 years and I have absolutely no complaints and it's much quieter than ir or snap on. You do have to have a half inch hose to get maximum torque out of it.

[@opichocal]

I just got my 2235qtimax in today. I rotated my truck tires with no effort. It blows away my old cheapie and judging by all the reviews I've read should last for many years. Ebay had the best price around. $181 shipped!

[@RealToolReviews]

Nice!

[@kongvue5160]

I've had my Aircat 1150k for 6 years so far. Use it off and on and it's still solid. Sometimes sits in my garage over winter as well. I've broke loose Acura TL crank bolts with it. That's a guarantee win there. Just picked up a Aircat 1156-XL and it's a beauty... small and can get into so many areas where the 1150k can't... and still pack a 550ft lbs. They are designed very well and are very durable. I do have one question. Are you running high flow couplers and fittings? I do run swivel fittings for ease of use and to prolong the life on my lines. Do you think this will have a big impact on air flow and power loss?

[@tstep522]

RTR, Thank you for a very precise and analytical video. I love AvE as much as the next guy but sometimes my inner engineer wants test data, procedure, etc... So good work. My question is, have you tested the lower powers on the guns, meaning level 1 and 2, or levels 1,2, and 3 on the IR to see if the values you are getting match up to that of the manufactures published numbers? Also, have you tested the torque rated extension bars that are on the market to see how accurately they tighten a connection. Thanks again.

[@eghty8fox780]

You should compare if there is a difference in torque between short and long anvils

[@Lanninglongarmmowing]

I think in the future everyone will be switching over to battery powered impacts because there's no air hose to drag around. There won't be hardly any air impacts. Great vid!

[@Vrdavila67]

Please do a review on the Aircat 1150.

[@bryvr6]

something not mentioned at the end of the video the variable speed on the ingersoll is a hell lot better than the nitrocat, ive owned both ingersolls and nitro, and it makes a huge difference using them daily

[@patringler]

Nice reviews! How do either of these compare to the Air Cat 1150 ? So far I'm leaning towards replacing my worn out CP 734 with the 2235QTiMAX.

[@AamirShaikh812]

Please review Cleco Impact Wrenches, they are the rugged work horses

[@RealToolReviews]

They are pretty much the same as the Gearwrench versions. Both owned by the same parent company. I have seen them in person, but have not used them. If I can get some in-stock, I will add them to the lineup. Thanks!

[@AamirShaikh812]

Thanks for your prompt revert! appreciated!! Looking forward to more videos.

[@joeybrewer9595]

What size hose are you using because that does factor in. I have never heard you say anything about it in any of your videos.

[@dchawk81]

Did you happen to test the other forward settings? I have the Nitrocat and wouldn't mind knowing what it hits on low and medium.

[@bigblockfox83]

could u please do a test on the new dewalt 1/2 inch impact gun? its rated at 650lbs and id like to see where it stands because I have the 3/8 in and its impressive.

[@magmomwise]

From my experience the Aircat/Nitrocat impacts have show to be the powerhouses of air impacts getting the really tight rusted fasteners loose when all the other brands can't do it.

[@rjames822]

Good review, one question though, why did you use an extended anvil for the IR? The longer anvil actually reduces torque slightly.

[@RealToolReviews]

+P Jones It is the one that I have here.....and IR claims that there is ZERO torque loss with the extended version, check out there site......if I get a regular version also, I will run them against each other to see for sure.

[@OdinsCloud]

an average of 1193 to 1207. Well that is a very small of a gap (14ftlb or about .5% ), could well change considering the small variability of each individual unit. I assume both were oiled prior. My understanding is that the extended anvil is not supposed to reduce applied torque to the fastener like an extension would. Could it of had any impact on applied torque? Perhaps a 1/2 of 1% reduction in applied torque? I certainly do not know. Great reviews however!

[@VanNguyen-ng9so]

Hi.what size impact torch wrench can undo crank bolt vehicle.with air compressor 2.5Hp.please thank you very much.

[@VAHOSS]

why compare a long anvil to a short anvil

[@ghostbuilder3187]

Exactly torque difference all day

[@DannyGruesome]

I thought straight extensions didnt affect torque

[@jasonhull2163]

dat boi Uhhh yes... Extensions effect torque greatly. Especially if you are trying to pull a transmission out of a dump truck and tie two seperate extensions together. You can easly lose 35% torque that way. I have a 3 ft solid extension I use for dropping transmissions on big trucks. You still lose about 20% power on a single non tie extensions. You will not lose much power from a 3 inch extension, but you will lose some. I have had alot of air impacts. I still favor Ingersoll Rand over any brand. If I am not mistaken (correct me if I'm wrong) I have a Matco 3/8 air impact. I believe Ingersoll Rand makes it. It looks identical to Ingersoll Rand and works the same, but cost more.

[@DannyGruesome]

Jason Hull now im talkin torque wrench not impact.

[@DannyGruesome]

Jason Hull and i also am a fan of ingersoll rand i have their 2235timax and it is just as good as my coworkers snap on or better

[@andyc3909]

I liked your review, and I watched your video several different times trying do decide on which impact to buy between the Husky 800, Earthquake 1000 and the Ingersoll Rand 2235 TiMax. Another review showed the Harbor Freight Earthquake is stronger than the Home Depot Husky. Although you did not compare them directly, according to your videos, the Ingersoll is stronger than the Earthquake. According to your 2 different review on the 2235, you said it has 4 different torque setting in both forward and reverse. However, I just bought the 2235, and regardless of the reverse torque setting dial, it runs full blast in reverse. I did not know if I had a defective gun or what, so I went back to the questions and answers on Amazon. They said there are 4 torque settings in forward, but you cannot change the reverse torque. Is your 2" anvil different than the standard gun? If not, how could you review the 2235 twice and not know that you cannot change the reverse setting? I would be very interested to know the answer. I have been a subscriber to your channel for a few months now. However, if you can not trust your reviews, I do not know if I would watch another one. I am not trying to be mean. I am just trying to understand how you could of reviewed this item (more than once) and not try the torque settings on the impact wrench, which feature did comment on.

[@edwarcusi9096]

HI COMPARE AIRCAT 1150 VS NITROCAT 1250-K

[@caseyanderson9169]

Can I run the 2235TiMAX off the IR wheelbarrow compressor?

[@weldingjunkie]

Here's the hard truth. The long anvil doesn't loose torque it's rated the same. Two the speed switch is much better on the Nitrocat and lastly you can rebuild the Nitro cat cheap and easy yourself and cost half. It's not rebranded either it's a family owned company. I have 3 Nitro cats and they out perform my IRs on a daily basis. 1200k / 1375 / 1175 all great guns. Light powerful and easier to get into tight places.

[@eonwagoneer]

Jason Quinlan yah was glad I found rebuild kits for aircat, I was then 100% sold on their product

[@ghostbuilder3187]

You can rebuild the 2235 yourself

[@bryandavis341]

Nitro cat , Aircat, have been rebranded by MAC and Matco. The rebuild kit for IR is about the same as Nitro cat. If you like nitro cat that's fine but you are mistaken about your information.

[@G5Hohn]

You honestly think they run a separate test for the longer anvil model? An anvil is not infinitely stiff. Nothing is. That means that more metal between the actual impact mechanism at the fastener MUST cause some of the impact force to be diverted into deflecting (twisting) the anvil. This is because the of the impact mechanism. If you were talking a torque wrench, the anvil would be meaningless. But because of the irregularity of the applied torque, the anvil DOES matter. Now, does it matter? Probably not. It's short enough in most cases to not be a major factor. But if you want max torque, you use the short anvil-- and you use it with a short (not deep) socket for the same reason-- less torsional deflection.

[@muddyriverdogz]

@@G5Hohn It also changes the harmonics.

[@7RELLIK7]

Look at where the needle goes on the last 2 tests they were almost identical in placement. How did it go 2.5k higher? ......

[@RealToolReviews]

Well.....that's why I do an average of three runs.....check out any of the impact vids that I've made & you can see the exact same methods.

[@andrewbarrett7106]

Try the regular anvil on the IR...

[@finneassblakley1927]

oh man i sure love nitro cat air impacts, been using them for a long time with very few problems

[@dejvjakubczak5492]

I can not wait for your reviewr mg725 and ct8850 :)

[@leeeon666]

+David Jakubczak mg725: noisy, too heavy, low torque (reverse 700), mechanism makes vibration, that's it . Working In the tire rush with mg 725 is a sin.

[@smitty03281964]

I have the Aircat but how do you think it ranks up there with the Mac and Matco. They both have impressive guns. Have you ever compared them?

[@smitty03281964]

Do you work for Mac and Matco and can testify to that. I never heard of such and if that is the case then maybe they are all doing it.

[@RickTrajan]

smitty03281964 there had been rebranded tools on mac, the new one seems to be different.

[@smitty03281964]

RickTrajan I actually talked to the Snap-On dealer the other day and he did state that Aircat is also rebranded and with Snap-On. At least I thought he said Snap-On but he may have said Mac. I will probably see him again tomorrow. Rick thanks for taking the time to enlighten me.

[@jjfrockets2]

smitty03281964 you can tell by checking on power tool repair and checking the part numbers for replacement parts

[@weldingjunkie]

A father and son started Nitro cat it's not rebranded man people need to do thier homework.

[@stephen8385]

nice review man.. if u have to choose one, which one wil u choose milwaukee 2763 or ingersoll rand 2235? i know one is air tools and one is battery..

[@RealToolReviews]

I would not buy the regular 2235.....it is way too loud. I'd get the quiet version. If you aren't in a shop setting though, the cordless 2763 would be ideal.

[@stephen8385]

+Real Tool Reviews thanks man for fast respons.. is the battery drain fast on 2763?

[@RealToolReviews]

It depends what you are working on......tire changes constantly --- yes. But for typical use, it should last quite a while......most of the kits sold are coming with 5.0ah batteries now, so they have a lot of capacity.

[@stephen8385]

+Real Tool Reviews okay.. i think i will go with milwaukee 2763.. thanks alot

[@aceseightsazhvacsparkyandg8138]

Is Ingersoll and RAM better than the Snap-on or Mactco ?

[@slickjames1]

This guy talks like a newscaster, but I like his little torque tester.

[@shizzel122]

what about the weight difference, makes a big difference the ingersoll rand is way lighter

[@mark97213]

Which one is built to last?

[@OdinsCloud]

I wonder what the difference in toque is between the quiet version of the TI2115 and the normal version.

[@RealToolReviews]

+OdinsCloud Minimal torque difference.....maybe 5% less power & half as loud. I think the quiet versions are always the best choice.

[@OdinsCloud]

Thank you! Appreciate that. I wish some of the top German companies would send you their impacts. I am looking at the Hazet 9012M for example. The 9012 seems to be very powerful for it's size but i do not know anyone in the US that uses one. I may pick on up when next go overseas.

[@Dannyd534]

IR's 2235 is 50% off at Amazon right now! Everyone go pick one up! Even worth it for Canadians!!

[@chasedavid2596]

I love my nitrocat had it a week so far an it's still going strong

[@RealToolReviews]

+WRX Chase Nice! I keep hearing good things about them!

[@DumbCarGuy]

The problem with the nitrocat 1250 is that after a while the trigger is very un user friendly. more like full on or off. variable speed is out the window with such a stiff trigger. plus the snap ring on the end that holds the sockets tends to fall off.

[@dansilva501]

is there a big difference when using an 1/2 inch air line and using a 3/8 inch air line ?

[@RealToolReviews]

Yes.....you don't have nearly the same pressure drop from the tank to the tool --- meaning you can set your pressure lower at the regulator. Check out this video that I made about air pressure to see more ---> kzbin.info/www/bejne/g3nbY3iLjL6tq68

[@dansilva501]

Real Tool Reviews thanks for the link .. great video

[@TractorWrangler01]

Whats the strongest overall reverse available on all available half inch Impacts?

[@toomanymachines]

Would it not be much more fair to compare a short anvil to a short anvil? you stated that it makes about 100 foot pounds torque difference. That would make the Ingersoll rand much more powerful.

[@toomanymachines]

I used both long and short anvil guns a fews years back. huge difference in torque. I only use short guns now with deep sockets to give me the extra reach in my tire shop. The other advantage of the deep socket is that it has better contact with the nuts.

[@tomyee1336]

I like the twin clutch in the nitrocat better than twin hammer design in the IR or Matco rebrand. Snap on is a joke compared to IR.

[@TylerJD60]

Have you tested a Snap On MG725? I'm just curious how it compares. And what its actual output is. Thanks

[@bighunterman77]

+TylerJD60 prolly somewhere around 700ft/lb on this test, and it cost well over 2x the ir...they are junk haha

[@BlackLabel7345]

TylerJD60 Snap On air tools are overpriced garbage. They are VERY picky about the air. A drop of moisture will kill them very quickly. Every IR tool I have ever owned and any of my co workers/friends owned have been beasts.

[@froilanbinayug2201]

Mg725 are the biggest pile of crap in the automotive world. Have that and the nitro cat and i do alot of rear differential rebuild and they sucked. Only good for tire business every 6-9 minthsvyou need to get it sent out cause they start acting up. Kevlar had it for 9 years my only issue is the anvil gave up on me. Couldn't find a replacement so i got me a new one. The best part is the price compare to all name brands too good of a deal for the price of the tool

[@joshuavisser8022]

Hello there, I just want to say great job with the work you do, in gathering data/numbers for each impact. I will be blunt though in saying that I am rather irritated or pissed off that you are comparing two different tools in this particular video though. It would be ideal if the nitrocat had a 2" extended anvil or vice versa. I would appreciate it and am sure others would too if you revisted this comparison with both impacts having the standard anvil or both with a 2" anvil. Hope my feedback is constructive, I just think it wasn't a right or fair comparison.

[@Denkha94]

Hi. I like your videos they are informative on tool reviews. I watch them when I am in the market for a power tool. But now I have a question I am getting ready to buy a IR 2235 ti max 1/2 impact wrench. I want Ingersoll rand to honor my warranty when tool breaks under normal conditions. should I buy it from ebay brand new or amazon prime? I just don't want IR company to avoid my warranty. or as long the tool is brand new, and registered with ir it should be ok? please get back to me thank you I appreciate it.

[@RealToolReviews]

Call the 1-800 # & say you have a broken impact that you bought last year from eBay.....see what they tell you. That is how I research warranties. Check out the FAQ video that I made --- kzbin.info/www/bejne/pGrOooeZi86Eask

[@rusohv1]

I'm not agree SR. You need to try the regular Ingersoll rand IR2235QTIMAX 1/2 ,, that one you using on this video has an extension,, you will lose torque with it. Even if some IR guns models come with it. You will lose some torque with any gun if u add a extension.

[@RealToolReviews]

Yes, ADDING an extension would lower torque.....the anvil is not the same as adding an extension. Check out the specs that IR publishes on these if you dont believe me.....they rate them 100% the same.

[@DBYNOE]

I think the extension power loss is mainly when you snap one on, as there is impact power lose in the additional connection. There is probably very little lose when it is that super stiff extended factory shaft.

[@weldingjunkie]

JAVI HV lol seriously

[@ghostbuilder3187]

Only a dumbass would choose nitro junk over ir

[@Mikeracing2005]

@@RealToolReviews maybe this is just my experience, but on my 2 IR impacts in reverse turning the knob to the left significantly increases the torque output. And you can hear it significantly pic up in rpm and not labor.

[@blackop1990]

you yourself said their ratings were off. so why would you trust them??

[@RealToolReviews]

+Blackop1990 This conversation is going no where. If/when I get a regular anvil unit, I will try it again.....until then, thanks for watching.

[@michaelfair9336]

could you put those on the digital torque meter ?

[@iantaylor4380]

love my nitrocat 1250k, glad i bought it.

[@paulwatson3318]

What are your thoughts on the cp7748? I spotted one in your tool box in a previous video ;)

[@RealToolReviews]

+Paul Watson I like it a lot & I think for the average mechanic.....(i.e. --- someone who doesnt need to have the best & most powerful), it is a great choice. A lot of power, very affordable price, and the CP reputation.

[@paulwatson3318]

Thanks for the quick reply and kudos for the great review videos! Up in Canada the IR's are crazy expensive. I just picked up the cp7748 as it looks like a great starter.

[@RealToolReviews]

+Paul Watson I would suggest watching the videos I made about Air Pressure & Torque vs Torque Loss.....you can do a couple minor upgrades to your air setup & get much better performance out of it.

[@indigophox]

Love your exhaustive reviews! Seriously aching to see an Earthquake XT against these!!

[@RealToolReviews]

+indigophox thanks! And stay tuned....I've got the XTs coming soon....

[@indigophox]

Awesome! The XT and the new compact Earthquake are right at the top of my list, as is the IR 35MAX. All things being equal I would take the 35MAX for ergonomics, but depending how it maxes out when it only claims 450ft-lbs it's probably not going to be my eventual pick. That little CP gun you reviewed in the "Stubby -vs- Stubby" review is also a decent candidate.

[@AlexD-fq5zm]

I just had to also state you used an extended anvil vs a short anvil. The short will always have more power. = un equal test

[@RealToolReviews]

Check their own specs on them.....100% identical.

[@AlexD-fq5zm]

The short anvil has less torsion applied by length of shaft. The long shaft has twist.

[@jacobbreen5160]

Is the 2235 the most powerful 1/2 inch impact?

[@RealToolReviews]

It is "one of the most powerful"......I wouldn't say it will win all the time.....in this vid, the Nitrocat won.

[@jacobbreen5160]

+Real Tool Reviews If the Ingersoll didn't have the extended anvil it probably would've won

[@weldingjunkie]

Jacob Breen no it would not it was spec the same. No one reads

[@Bydand-dt3ct]

I own the ingersoll rand and A snap on mg725. The snap on destroys it as far as power goes. They are both excellent tools but in my personal experience the snap I hits harder. Although I prefer the build and design of the rand. However if I can’t budge a stubborn nut I will always grab the snappy and it has never failed yet.

[@muddyriverdogz]

I notice you gave the SO number but not the IR that you were comparing it against.

[@masonfamily6124]

@@muddyriverdogz Yeah I always had Snap On guys borrowing my IR gun. My model number is worn off now but it was the first model of the titanium series. It's about 12 to 14 years old and was never rebuilt. Nothing came close until Aircat came out years later.

[@xaipaivanlee]

How did you find one with that grey color..? Thanks, Xai.

[@RealToolReviews]

+Xai pai van Lee The impact wasnt grey....that was the protective boot (slips on/off to save the finish). Thanks!

[@xaipaivanlee]

+Real Tool Reviews thanks, what type of add-on is yours? Just the 2inch anvil extension only right, because you said that the one with the quiet sound is less powerful. But they have a quiet with the 2inch anvil extension available. Is there a difference? Thank you again.

[@RealToolReviews]

+Xai pai van Lee Yes, the quiet version also has a 2" option (model 2235Qtimax-2). The power levels are slightly less, but without a tester like the Skidmore, I dont think you would ever be able to notice a difference. The benefit of saving your hearing is much more appealing that being extremely loud with a few extra ft-lbs of power.

[@xaipaivanlee]

+Real Tool Reviews Yes that's true and thank you for your reply.

[@Gregg0112]

Does the ir lose torque with the integrated torque stick? Lol

[@dosbox907]

Excellent video my man.

[@RealToolReviews]

+dosbox907 Thanks!

[@TheChadRules]

Reverse on the IR is full power

[@30nieto]

Both are great guns. Matco claims 1600 breakaway torque on their new gun

[@blackop1990]

Ir is definitely stronger. Put a 2 inch extension on the nitrocat and it won't touch the ir

[@RealToolReviews]

Yet IR rates the standard & extended version EXACTLY the same.......so who is right? You or IR who makes them?

[@SteveRobReviews]

Nice review Daniel....

[@RealToolReviews]

+Steve Rob Thanks Steve!

[@hedrick5286]

I have the nitrocat. It’s great

[@hurtus86]

Test 2 with short anvils and my money goes to the Ingersoll , anyone who has used this stuff much knows that an extended anvil hurts you on power lol

[@krislizana2017]

ir also has a higher free spin rpm

[@d-s-ll2378]

good or no good, test on german cars freese wheel bolts!

[@creativecreative9582]

Love your reviews ,but its not fair to compare a long anvil against a short anvil.

[@RealToolReviews]

Check the torque specs on IR's website....they show EXACTLY the same torque specs on the regular & extended version.

[@smitty03281964]

You definitely cover your bases

[@creativecreative9582]

keep them reviews coming your one of the best.

[@bighunterman77]

where's my dcf899 review????? haha, but seriously, good review on these as always, and i still prefer the ir

[@subcomandante77]

make a review on air drills!!!

[@andybub45]

2235 is a beast

[@natecranmer4816]

Thank you for the video.

[@RealToolReviews]

+Nate Cranmer No problem!

[@bosomofvictory]

negligible differences. buy the one with higher build quality and available parts

[@BlindMansRevenge2002]

What the heck happened? I haven’t seen a Real Tool Review in over six months. Come on Mr. Dan! I R has put out their new W 7152 and now those bogus 5133 and 5153 brushless tools. I’m sure you would have a lot to say about these.

[@DaBurntToaster]

rubbers grips tend to fall off so Id say the IR wins here, but if you dont tend to get your tools dirty I guess the 5% more grip could be helpfulbutnotreallythisisanimpactgunitsnotgoingtomakeyourhandflyaroundinacircle no points here being an inch shorter, I dont think the IR takes a win there, its an impact gun, it doesnt go in tight places. no points here variable speed triggers dont really matter to much on air powered tools, especially impact guns, you use them mostly for removal, and when you install with them your working on something its not going to break to begin with. and if you really NEED to lower the power you should probably be using a torque wrench, but if your lazy or dont have one just turn down the compressor output pressure. no points here the torque values you got were from a single product at far less than a 1% variance which would be considered statistically insignificant so it means absolutely nothing, both guns with the setup you provided are EXACTLY the same torque, you will have ABSOLUTELY NO guaranteed increase in torque by choosing the nitrocat, product to product deviation on your test platform with the right binning could make either platform win, theres no conclusive answer here. that being said you are testing an extended anvil vs as short anvil so the test is moot to begin with. assuming the torque value isnt effected in the IR by the anvil length the ONLY differentiating factor for performance of the tool is the rubber grip on the nitrocat, which as stated before is hardly an advantage but could be REALLY annoying if it falls off. nitrocat loses 0.1 points here pick the one that looks cooler

[@AlexD-fq5zm]

Who uses a low power setting? 10+ years max power

[@Lukeo2412]

Reverse on the IR does not have levels of power.

[@bbaaspencer1]

The other advantage is the nitro cat cost less.

[@eghty8fox780]

Ingersoll rand only has one speed in reverse, no point in adjusting power in reverse

[@beswelltools]

You should use the same length anvil version in compare to air cat type tools.longer anvil version torque will be lower.