INTERESTING! | You Can't Do That (Anthology 1 Version) - The Beatles (Reaction)

ROAD TO 25K SUBSCRIBERS!!!
Reacting to You Can't Do That (Anthology 1 Version) - The Beatles
I have officially launched a patreon!! For those of you who were asking how you can support the channel and in what ways you can give, this is it!!
⚠️⚠️⚠️ / jmboytv ⚠️⚠️⚠️
Subscribe to the channel if you enjoy the content!
#YouCan'tDoThat #TheBeatles #reaction #classicrock
For all business inquiries please contact;
[e-mail]
FAIR-USE COPYRIGHT DISCLAIMER:
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, commenting, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.

[@JMBOYTV]

Guys I am fully aware that this is not the final version. I was asked to reaction to this version specifically because of that reason. Just something interesting to hear.

[@nthdegree1269]

I actually think more people should react to some of the anthology and compare it with the studio versions that were put out... it opens up a greater understanding of the music and the creative process involved

[@AndyMakesPlaylists]

Good for you, @JMBOYTV. I think this alternate version is worth the attention because it has qualities that the "official" version lacked. John is looser. Plus, and I rarely say this, but I'm not even sure the backup vocals add all that much if anything on the more familiar version. P.S. Hey can I suggest ANOTHER reaction to still ANOTHER version of this song? Harry Nilsson: kzbin.info/www/bejne/o6DGaKWFrtRqY9Esi=ZfBKj7cVo8rWoss7 #JMBOYTV

[@mgonzales56]

Was just about to let you know what you already knew. Lol. Thanks for the reaction. This version sounds great also.

[@bobcorbin3294]

I think this version is cool because it lets you supply your own background vocals

[@lauraallen55]

I love the more raw versions of vocals from the songs on Anthology - especially John's because he had his vocals disguised any chance he got on released versions of songs.@@AndyMakesPlaylists

[@user-pf7jm9go6o]

Pretty damn good for '63 or '64, huh? This is why the Beatles were so huge when they started, the writing was so clever, tunes so catchy, excellent musicianship, great vocals. Then they blasted off and took music into a whole new dimension.

[@1967PONTIACGTO]

There is a great live performance of this song in Australia in 1964

[@BritIronRebel]

YES!! That's a terrific version. The only drawback in that video is that the cameraman ignored John doing one of his very rare lead guitar solos in the middle. Otherwise... Outstanding!

[@yacava]

@@BritIronRebelI suspect that solo was at least augmented in the studio. Maybe explains the pull-away.

[@docgonzales]

@@BritIronRebelJohn would get Brian Epstein to tell the tv directors not to film his solo’s , he was a bit self conscious of his playing , you never see a close up of john playing lead in any tv appearance

[@NotData]

The Anthology CDs were mostly early takes and rarities. The final version of this song added backing vocals.

[@jamessullivan5860]

First time hearing this version and really enjoying it.

[@janetnadeau690]

They can do anything!

[@lmkeniston216]

A demo! Very cool. Thanks to you & your patron for sharing. I like your thoughtful, detailed reaction, thanks for that too!

[@patticrichton1135]

Not really a demo, it was when they were working on the recording of it.

[@faithnyou1732]

Love the early Beatles, and this was an interesting version I've never heard, but it's a great song! Thanks for another great reaction, JM! ✌💙✌

[@patticrichton1135]

You would have heard it IF you had the 3 anthology CD's which are WELL WORTH THE MONEY to own!!

[@faithnyou1732]

@@patticrichton1135 Thanks for the tip! ✌

[@bugvswindshield]

I've been partial to Harrison. He was my distant cousin. Me and 6,000 other people haha. Harrison is a pretty big clan.

[@rainpain3655]

Did you ever meet him??

[@bugvswindshield]

@@rainpain3655 oh no. On my mom side 4 times removed. Our family left England 100 years ago, moved to Canada.

[@rainpain3655]

@@bugvswindshield would have been amazing if you meet him. Still, cool stuff that you're technically related 👍

[@franksullivan1873]

Raw Beatles from back in the day!

[@dgator3599]

Makes me want to get up and do The Pony! Anyone remember that dance? LOL

[@smartenuphumans]

This is Lennon writing a song and singing like Wilson Pickett who he fondly admires

[@jessicalee7119]

Love this version ~ clean and hearing John's voice, alone, is a treat!

[@jrspike2ya]

The great rock-n-roll voice of John Lennon. Nice version on Anthology 1 and nice reaction. Thank you for the reaction.

[@lauraallen55]

I got Anthology before it was released to the public and I loved hearing all their different takes and other songs that never got air play or made it to albums. Big fan of John's raw vocals any chance to get to hear them as he double-tracked and tried to otherwise disguise his voice on so many of his songs. (He didn't like his voice, shockingly enough!)

[@charliecochran3035]

It just sounds like a live take in the studio, and a damn solid one. Its really close to the album version. Add in some backing harmonies and it's done.

[@lauraallen55]

Ticket to Ride for some great John vocals and an off beat from Ringo that makes the song just killer!

[@phillydog57coupe]

Great choice!

[@AliasMark69]

Our Boy John... My Favorite.

[@AliasMark69]

"It's Actually Really COOL".... Yep

[@mikecaetano]

That was raw. But cool. The Beatles in the garage trying out a new sound, a heavier r&b sound. Paul, if that was Paul on bass, was cutting up. And they were grooving pretty well too, until around two thirds in when they slipped around a turn. But they kept going anyway and finished out the song with a wack guitar solo too. Perhaps if they had more time they might have released a polished up alternate take more in line with this groove.

[@bobbybrettel5422]

Could you play The Beatles song Long Tall Sally....... it's a Little Richard cover and Paul really kills it

[@DJBilodeau]

I would totally love to hear The Beatles doing "Long Tall Sally"! So central to their live act in the early years! And, yes, them reaching for it to match Little Richard's energy makes for an amazing listen!

[@craigreid7178]

Never heard this version before without backing vocals. Like the studio version better.

[@patticrichton1135]

As you can see from the photo of the album cover this is on the Beatles ANTHOLOGY #1 album. ALL 3 "Anthology albums are well worth buying.

[@tigerpinky]

I love these ones that show how songs developed. So cool

[@AliasMark69]

JM.. do the tunes you want, that your supporters ask for. Ignore the small minds, as I'm sure you do.

[@DJBilodeau]

Wow! Sorry I missed this one! Yes, I specifically asked for this one because I thought it was very interesting with just Lennon on the lead vocals. And, as someone mentioned below, there is a version of them live in Melbourne Australia which is a great film of the Beatles live performance of this song.

[@nthdegree1269]

Now compare it to the version they put out at that time. Lot's of alternative takes on Anthology of various songs.

[@retiredfirelt586]

The Anthology albums are worth owning. 😎

[@richardjacobs7632]

No backing vocals? That makes it for me!

[@sammybeck7794]

I'm missing the backing vocals. This is a different version

[@nthdegree1269]

The beauty of it is you don't have to listen to one version. You can listen to both versions, and it's a great way to see the creative process... like, for example....I'm looking through you.... on Anthology. It's recorded really well. It sounds great. It's a fantastic other version from the time period.

[@markszawlowski867]

Another great vid. Love your reactions brother. How about trying out Bowie's Moonage Daydream, or even, the last Ziggy Stardust concert version of Width of a Circle (live). You'll never forget Bowie's performance. Unsurpassed man.

[@Tuesdays_Gone]

❤❤❤❤

[@lauraallen55]

You love John's vocals too?! My favorite of all of them, even though I adore them all. John really disliked his voice, and asked their producer George Martin to do all kinds of things to cover it up. You should listen to all of Anthology. It's a real treat for the ears of John Lennon vocal lovers. :) Oh, search out 'sugar plum fairy sugar plum fairy' on YT and there should be a very short video showing John counting in to A Day in the Life saying that. It adds to the haunting quality of the song.

[@debjorgo]

There are some good versions in the Anthology series. Can't Buy Me Love is more bluesy. Come Together, Get Back, Tomorrow Never Knows (Take 1), .... I'd say you should listen to the official versions first though.

[@AliasMark69]

Name another person more important to modern music than John Lennon.

[@raymann7998]

Okay maybe I'm lost in the world wind. But this is all new to me too and I'm 62 hey there's a rhyme in there somewhere but you know

[@user-oq5oh3jb7w]

Listen to the one that got released in 1964

[@OneRaxy]

Anthology versions are a whole new beatles catalog. Please react to others songs too!

[@leemcintyre9490]

Not Bad I guess. But I Prefer the Original! With Paul & George singing back up.

[@user-mo6tz6oh9i]

A better version is with the other lads singing backup.

[@patticrichton1135]

He KNOWS that, this was requested to him from their ANTHOLOGY #1 album I guess you don't have the 3 Anthology albums, because if you did, you would know that this is what it is from. They are fabulous albums, full of alternate takes, working on them in the studio, mistakes, funny bits, BBC radio live performances, etc. There are NO "finished songs" on any of these Anthology albums. IF you are a BEATLES Fan you NEED to include these 3 albums in your collection

[@lugwrench9832]

1964

[@patticrichton1135]

JMBOY TV IGNORE all these negative comments that some of these people no NOTHING about as they OBVIOUSLY have NEVER heard any of the 3 BEATLES ANTHOLOGY ALBUMS. Any Beatles' fan worth their salt would know and HAVE all 3 albums. PLEASE DO MORE reactions from ANTHOLOGY, especially "AND YOUR BIRD CAN SING" (which is HILARIOUS) and "ROCKY RACOON" (also funny) and how they originally tried a different intro to "Eight Days a Week" There is a LOT of good stuff on here. But I would DEFINATELY listen to the FINIISHED recordings on their albums that were released through the years and THEN listen to their counter parts on the ANTHOLOGY albums. Perhaps to AVOID further nasty comments, do a reaction where you FIRST play the RECORDED version on their usual album releases, and THEN play the SAME song from the ANTHOLOGY album, so they can compare!

[@spitfirenutspitfirenut4835]

I’m a fan and think that this version is the best. The released version is also amazing

[@waynecox3958]

No. The final version of this song has Paul and George's harmony response vocals. Nothing without them.

[@patticrichton1135]

This was requested to him and it is from BEATLES ANTHOLOGY # 1 album (he has a photo of it next to him) which contains some of their BBC live radio performances, working on their various recordings, it's GREAT. You should listen to all THREE Anthology albums. They are FANTASTIC and cover all their periods during their time as the Beatles.

[@kenford4798]

It sounds great but the released version was much better as you get all the backing vocals with it.

[@gidion4004]

Please listen to the original song with the choir ! kzbin.info/www/bejne/bIGuY2SrbL6to6s

[@patticrichton1135]

There IS no choir on the "original" song, it's just Paul and George doing backups and call and response. This album is the first of 3 Beatles Anthology albums, which are working on their songs, isolated tracks, funny "outtakes" different versions when working on them that are different from what ended up on their recorded albums that every one knows. This is giving you MORE interesting Beatles in the process of making their music. You need to LISTEN to all 3 ANTHOLOGY albums. IF you are a Beatles fan, you need to get these. I LOVE them and listen to them often

[@roydownes2458]

this take is missing the backing and chorus vocals. very strong nonetheless. interesting.

[@patticrichton1135]

Yes and THAT is why it is on ANTHOLOGY #1 All 3 Anthology albums do NOT have ANY of the "finished" product. That was the WHOLE purpose of those albums, to give us fans something interesting and FUN things during their creative process

[@roydownes2458]

@@patticrichton1135 i have none of these albums, and havent heard them. i didnt know this.

[@lauraschwartz1077]

This is just John singing. You're missing half of the song. Not sure why Anthology included this unfinished version.

[@spitfirenutspitfirenut4835]

Just John is the whole point. It’s amazing with just him. Take the cotton out of your ears and appreciate the instruments and John’s voice.

[@martinrenzhofer8241]

This is just another insecure Lennon rant. He wrote several with this tone.

[@markb3186]

ALWAYS do the original not some other version NO ONE HEARD OF -what is the point of listening to a different version than the original that made it a hit? fu** anthology versions no one heard of - released a hundred years later -versions rejected for the album!!! do the REAL SONG THE ACTUAL SONG IT IS STUPID STUPID STUPID TO DO ANTHOLOGY VERSIONS AND NOT THE REAL THING STUPID !!!!!!! WHY NOT HEAR WHAT EVERYONE HEARD????

[@patticrichton1135]

EXCUSE ME???? "anthology version no one heard of" REALLY??? I hate to tell you this but REAL BEATLES FANS HAVE heard ALL THREE ANTHOLOGY ALBUMS and LOVE them. They aren't SUPPOSED to have the "finished" versions, which all of us fans already have and know. THIS gives us alternative versions and SOME we liked even BETTER than what they did eventually! Plus, mistakes, working on them in the studio, the whole process, and LOVE the funny things that also happened when they were in the process of recording (giggling through "And Your Bird Can Sing" is PRICELESS. EVERYONE LOVES seeing "outtakes" from movies and TV shows. WELL this is the SAME thing for recordings. You are MISSING A LOT by NOT having these albums. DON"T DISS them UNTIL you LISTEN to them. GEEZ!

[@faithpearlgenied-a5517]

Beatles fans have heard them, what are you talking about? 😂 Stick to a Beatles 'greatest hits' collection and actual Beatles fans can enjoy this.

[@spitfirenutspitfirenut4835]

This is a great version of the the song. You don’t always have to have the other guys singing. Those people who have criticized this version don’t know what they are talking about. Are the other Beatles singing with Paul on Yesterday?

[@patticrichton1135]

and giggling through "And Your Bird Can Sing" which I just LOVE, also when doing a take on "Rocky Racoon" Paul sings "Rocky Racoon SCHMINKING of Gin" and then he stops and says "SCHMINKING??" and goes on. I love these 3 albums.

[@FuturologyTheMusical]

There is a slighter better version by the Beatles.

[@patticrichton1135]

@FuturologyTheMusical, SEE my comment above yours here, responding to @markb3186 ridiculous comment