Investigating the Creepy Minecraft Cave Sounds

[@BillyStyler]

subscribe or herobrine will haunt your minecraft server

[@lisavillalta2030]

Jokes on you I didn't summon him and I made an aether portal, btw why won't the portal work?

[@KyleumTheIdi]

i would like to see him haunt my server

[@lobster4636]

AHHH HEAROBRRAIN AGHAHHHHH

[@CherriiiBlossom]

Minecraft

[@Chalkerz]

Meh, I'll just call the Herobrine Removal Team.

[@Communist_Cranberry]

Seeing him mine wood with a pickaxe is painful

[@mario-bro-64development86]

Agreed

[@Drpepperyuh]

Very

[@magicmage5356]

I know!!

[@thebatman8103]

Yes

[@dutchvanderlinde7081]

Yes it is

[@thestickopia4619]

The scariest thing in the video isn’t the cave sounds. It’s him using a pickaxe to get wood. 1:20

[@captainquacknsnow4565]

Yes

[@zeebur]

Yes

[@jackshark3271]

Yes

[@romanticals]

Yes

[@ashreprobite3774]

Yes

[@deangeloenriquez1603]

The top six scariest things in Minecraft 1: cave sounds 2: The warden 3: discs 11 & 13 4: creepers 5: endermen 6: Nether ambiance 7: other things within this comment thread that have not been listed on my list

[@ballball7223]

Herobrine bruh

[@atonedudeatsnotsubscribed8313]

That's backwards

[@deangeloenriquez1603]

@@atonedudeatsnotsubscribed8313 It wasn’t ranked it was just a list I decided to rank the list

[@ImWhyMortalsCry]

Warden is number 1 for me They basically are jumpscares

[@max8784]

Enderman looks creepy af

[@botttproductions150]

Minecraft cave sounds are the embodiment of "you aren't scared because you're alone, but because you know you arent"

[@MassiveDisaster]

That’s overly true

[@aidan46294]

Unless you play on peaceful

[@maximeleninja4029]

@@aidan46294 *You are still not alone.* *Someone is always there, staring at you.*

[@flinguine6049]

“Im going to play the 19 cave sounds now” me: NOOOO

[@imkeybored1238]

Lmao same

[@wolflexz]

yes

[@cybercritterowo]

@@wolflexz look :awesome: luckily you have commented this before it was gone. you are one of us now.

[@wolflexz]

@@cybercritterowo :awesome:

[@wolflexz]

@@cybercritterowo awh man :oops:

[@gaminganimators7000]

Why does everyone forget about the dark sounds that play underwater. They sound like the echoes of sea monsters attacking prey

[@skywoofyt5375]

cause no one likes the ocean XD

[@skywoofyt5375]

@@cantcomeupwithabettername5423 You're higher than a god

[@nobodyinparticular3606]

Why did you guys have to choose the phantom? The sea monster would have been terrifying with those sounds playing in the background.

[@skywoofyt5375]

@@nobodyinparticular3606 everybody thought the Phantom was gonna be a fish XD

[@ImN0tT0BeF0rg0tten]

Oh i here it all the time i made a house next to it

[@cayde-649]

Theory: Steve is the sole survivor of the crash. Disc 11 and 13 are recordings of him leaving the crash badly wounded, which is why you hear coughing. When Steve returns to the mines or caves. He gets vivid flashbacks of the crash. It would also explain why there aren't any others with Steve.

[@chimknnuggied6109]

And since the other non-hostil mobs are Villagers, everybody was once a villager. And so Steve’s nose broke off, and his arms broke apart

[@masahirosakurai3733]

@@chimknnuggied6109 no they are a different species

[@masahirosakurai3733]

Herobrine isn’t real also. He is a figment of Steve’s imagination because if the guilt he has for being the only survivor of the crash.

[@Varxiii]

Oh damn

[@chimknnuggied6109]

@@masahirosakurai3733 I am just saying it could be true, it’s a theory ma dude

[@AcBlu1]

"because there is something much, much more chilling that haunt- *James Dyson has reinvented the vaccum again*

[@stormdesertstrike]

Nursebat shit, where's my vacuum?!

[@jad4693]

I got a mrbeast ad

[@mogiemoogie]

This is why playing with friends in minecraft is 10x better than being by yourself.

[@cybercritterowo]

true

[@Zer0Delayy]

The thing that makes minecraft kinda scary is that you dont think you are ALONE in that endless world

[@Ediellee1]

Playing with villagers

[@mogiemoogie]

@@Ediellee1 YEAH when you’re in a village you feel safer BUT THEN AGAIN it’s still different when multiplayer 🤡

[@iamfrisk3606]

also its really boring by yourself

[@sw_________]

The scary part is when you hear a cave sound and your are not in a cave

[@Zip_runingback5]

That happend to me

[@samriddhipramanik4212]

@@Zip_runingback5 me too

[@George_Harris_SR25]

same

[@TheRagingRodentGaming]

It's the worst in biomes like DarkWood forests and deserts, am I right? . _ .

[@StormRye982]

@@samriddhipramanik4212 me too

[@angiem3177]

This scares me more than anything in any video game, and IT'S NOT EVEN A HORROR GAME!!

[@oksharks358]

♿️

[@PROPHET-60091]

♿

[@samfigo]

♿

[@hotrod4206]

♿️

[@tonypeppermint5329]

It's powerful.

[@MarcyTheKindaCoolWizard]

I love how this community went from fearing Herobrine to fearing the very thing they wanted updated

[@sleepy_b0i]

Imagine you’re going through a giant cavern, and hear a cave sound, it’s going to be so chilling, and I love it.

[@Lepend0K4287]

@@sleepy_b0i I think being in small cave is more scary because you feel like if something is gonna attack you you cant escape because there is only one way out.

[@neptune1564]

I feel like the “However” and “but there’s something far more sinister than this” is gonna become a meme.

[@QPGH]

Yea...

[@kimberlyjames556]

Ya

[@_chopper_]

What the f do you mean lol

[@AspiringD3v]

Notch and the devs: "hey you finished the cave sounds?" "Yeah i just rubbed a couple of stuff on the mic with echo on"

[@Mateo-qw9px]

_seeing him chop wood with a pickaxe already gave me anxiety_

[@mattsnows7971]

"Ay, I thought you said cave12.ogg was scary?" "no, no, no, you got me wrong, I said cave13.ogg" *"amateurs..."* "what?" *Disc 11:* _I SAID AMATEURS!_

[@UnhingedZombieBear]

Pig Mii Fighter: *_h I._*

[@armin1500]

cave10.ogg and cave18.ogg in my opinion are the scariest/coolest

[@iliketocopycomments7393]

Trash meme

[@armin1500]

@@iliketocopycomments7393 ok boomer

[@TheExperienceYT]

Seeing someone in an empty server: Am I a joke to you?

[@Sporedude135]

To this day, every time I hear a cave sound I go "Hey Herobrine my dude" and go on with my trek.

[@katt-nokjoke3688]

I cannot play the game with sounds on alone because of cave noises but this might fix that

[@MadamLava094]

He appreciates it, he just wants to say hi

[@SmartoDoggo]

OMG Herobrine show me show me show me show me show me show me show me show me show me show me show me show me show me show me show me show me

[@fbgeetown6273]

Fr I just keep on mover after the sound pass by

[@roachfarm]

I fear no man, but that “thing..” (insert cave sound effect) *It scares me..*

[@sosman64]

i like how you put "" on thing because a sound effect is not a thing that you can see

[@thebreakfastman4638]

Imagine if they added even creepier ambience to the deep dark biome

[@roachfarm]

@@thebreakfastman4638 that would honestly make it even more terrifying.

[@sosman64]

@@thebreakfastman4638 stop it you are giving them ideas

[@KeatonPlaysGames]

Ok cave sound 16

[@ChaosFrenzy]

Minecraft veterans: I fear no man, but that thing *Minecraft cave sounds* Minecraft veterans: It scares me.

[@BIGDADDUI]

as a veteran I agree

[@dantdmfangamingrich9802]

☭Ddarkon☭ me too

[@addictivechemicals5045]

@@dantdmfangamingrich9802 same here i remember I was playing Minecraft in my basement and a cave sound played and I got scared shittless

[@kebab_hill]

as a veteran also yea scary

[@godzillamaster08]

I think the scariest thing about these sounds is the fear of the unknown. Like, when u hear some shit like that, YOU try to imagine wtf did that noise, and thats why it makes us so anxious

[@Xiga1980]

Agreed

[@KeatonPlaysGames]

“That can only play in caves” Bedrock Edition: “ *YOU SURE ABOUT THAT?* “

[@freedom-man]

WHAT it can play in houses too?

[@CJ-nj2dm]

@Shrimp The God yeah same I just randomly hear it when I goign on my way to mine🧐

[@-howtomake999]

I once heard a sound in the night that sounded like the FNAF 2 animatronic in the hallway sound

[@bormby_jones]

Jesus Christ tell me about it

[@thenormalgamer6096]

i hear it when im near caves. and im near caves

[@zarthy4169]

Imagine if you were the one who was in that crash. You didn’t die but went into a coma and are now having visions of being in this blocky world. These sounds in the caves are occasional memories flashing in your mind.

[@Drpepperyuh]

I mean in the crash theory one of those miners was steve and he was the only survivor

[@shnubdawg7730]

Reminds me of the cut impact time sounds in Burnout 3 that also have a dark theme to them, Burnout 3 could’ve been one of the first horror arcade racing games and this was back in 2003.

[@KorporalKReephdmkiytrecv69]

This is what Little Mac is now hearing in his nightmares

[@strangent404a7]

*here comes the block man*

[@jordancasillan5965]

We definitely need a new punch out game

[@average_pyro]

His nightmares are cave noises and herobrine

[@cpt.calvin6380]

Let's go to Africa and find love in the jungle

[@susclod2663]

*Everywhere i go* *i see his face* Korporal K.Reep

[@Nekoszowa]

Cave sound 14 is the most terrifying to me. That "record scratch" makes it scary... Especially if I have some mods installed...

[@thischanelisdeleted3780]

Cave.ogg 17 is the scariest one to me

[@SmartoDoggo]

11:13

[@YUN6_V3NUZ]

"some have theorized the player to be chased by an enderman" "WHAT WAS THAT DAMAGE MY GUY"

[@logan_in_4k]

"AAAAAAAAA"

[@Randolorian230]

“OOOOOOOOO”

[@yoboikamil525]

OOOOOOOOOOO

[@c7o2]

Don't you EVER in your LIFE do that door knocking thing again.

[@mysteriousman4790]

@Stesidios at 0:56

[@mysteriousman4790]

@Stesidios ahhahahahhahhahahahahhahahahahahhahahahahahahhaha

[@mysteriousman4790]

@Stesidios yeah

[@grieferoncamera4600]

why am i scaring myself at night

[@criminal8768]

it’s just part of the music he used.

[@billcipher3180]

the only survivor of the crash was supposedly the man in the "11" disk which is actually supposed to be a continuation of "13" which consists of the original cave sounds in the actual order they are supposed to go in so this isn't really a mining incident as much as it is "HEY JOHN MIKEY LEFT THE DOOR OPEN AND A BUNCH OF MOBS GOT IN"

[@billthedorito3201]

Yo wanna make an army?

[@revenantree1232]

Oh , cool! A Minecraft video that can’t be that scary... Billy: H O W E V E R....

[@OK-zo3cq]

Ok.

[@sporeham1674]

@@OK-zo3cq Ok.

[@totalorganfailuregaming3252]

@@sporeham1674 Ok.

[@clintfritz3482]

@@totalorganfailuregaming3252 Ok.

[@choccymilk2508]

@@clintfritz3482 Ok.

[@pwn3r1]

oh my god, i remember playing on my xbox 360 when i was 7. i was alone home, and i decided to play some minecraft. i load a new world, get wood, and go mining. i found a cave but i heard a cave sound from 5:27, turned off my xbox right after this, and didnt play minecraft for the next week.

[@robotkiller325forlife7]

Me:casually playing Minecraft trying to dry out a ocean monument Bill:never know what kind of creature can be breathing down your neck

[@nobodyinparticular3606]

"Without further ado, let's dive in." Me: *Turns up my volume so I can hear the sounds* Loud F***ing Ad: YO WADDUP YOU WANT SOME CAR INSURANCE?

[@WhiskeyBrewer]

The True Horror

[@Samuel_Buckley]

Damn.

[@freedom-man]

BILLY MAYS HERE

[@izoneateeztxtforever369]

hahahah

[@chasethemaster3440]

Ha

[@ghost-dg6tj]

God nothing worse than being 6 and hearing these

[@dudemydude4969]

I was 4 When i first played minecraft

[@masahirosakurai3733]

@@dudemydude4969 even worse

[@izzyofficial.]

I was like 4 when I played Minecraft lite. Played it for a couple years but my dad got rid of the phone with it

[@skywoofyt5375]

bruh I am 15 and I am still scared shitless listening to those XD

[@mrmattyoboi1555]

First time I saw a spider i jumped so bad and tried to pause the game. The first time I heard a cave sound I was terrified and didn't wanna touch the game again, or go into caves or dark areas. I don't remember how old i was but I was pretty young and man it made me fly in creative a lot of the time from the ground just because of it lol.

[@jcn2028]

i thought the knocking in the beginning was real and i completely shit myself. well done.

[@Bani0000]

Same here but It was even more scary because it was 4am when I was watching the video and the first knock sounded like it was coming from my window (I sit directly next to my window)

[@eggcelentname3131]

The actually scariest thing is having your volume all the way up then going past a ocean monument and crapping your pants from the elder guardian, that crap is terrifying

[@luckysonuvagun]

I honestly just love how Billy completely strays away from the KZbin algorithms to pursue his interest in horror. Instead of streaming popular games (i.e. Among Us), he stays true to his channel and delivers amazing videos that scare us all crazy. I don't know if he'll see this, but keep up the scares, Billy!

[@srduce]

Edit: I fgured out the name, it is called the "Stone Tape Theory" check it out since it is interesting. I can connect something to the crash theory. There is a theory in real life that I don't remember the name of, where when you are in a haunted area that could also possibly be abandoned, and the backstory is tragic (murder, suicide, etc.) the walls record those or hold in the sounds, and basically releases them at random intervals. Which can maybe explain stuff like voices, walking, and other paranormal sounds in real life. So maybe that could be happening in Minecraft. Some "recordings" could be of the crash, some could be of mobs dying, and some could be of players dying. But that's just something I thought of.

[@chimknnuggied6109]

The first player in a cave Ahh these caves aren’t so bad afterall

[@BillyStyler]

This is actually very interesting. Thanks for sharing! Definitely looking more into this.

[@gamingseizure]

I believe this is called residual energy

[@approximated_nerd]

How could a minecart crash be fatal? I mean besides going off course into a large drop, I’m not too sure. I don’t think they were that fast. Just curious.

[@srduce]

@@approximated_nerd Well there’s many things. Such as a creeper exploding a top floor of a mine into the bottom. Or just the breaks or whatever they had failing causing them to smash right into the wall. Or a head on collision with another cart or something else.

[@KlynerKaiOffical]

Me: *Peacefully mining in a cave* Cave Sounds: I’m gonna do what’s called a pro gamer move

[@armin1500]

thats why i stopped playing for nearly 2 years

[@nicogachaz1097]

Me: freaks out and accidentally falls into lava like a dumbass.

[@toastoots2474]

6:45 the chattering is probably an unknown creature that came across them causing the crash or they possibly came across a warden and it killed them while they either tried escaping it or got ambushed by it

[@toastoots2474]

The discs (11 or 13 or both) are probably miners recording there final moments before death or that screaming at the end of 11 is probably the warden or an unknown creature and another theory is the enderman getting killed the enderman was recording us the player and we killed it causing the disc to be broken. My theory is we are a survivor of a minecraft crash caused by an unknown creature and we are trying our best to unveil the secrets of this land we are on and survive while being hunted by something.

[@attorneygamer8095]

Honestly, this should be on Spotify so that we could listen to this.

[@fluxcptndavey4378]

On the Topic of Cave Sounds: Markiplier had his editor Lixian slow down and reversed the cave sounds and then overlayed Siren Heads noises and it was terrifying.

[@corvusgalvorne3863]

Where

[@gittonsxv126]

which vid?

[@heyitsamy1771]

Show me

[@theanarchist1572]

Give us the link please!

[@NoName-xc4hk]

Link??????????

[@earthmagicyt]

The scariest thing of this video was him mining wood with a pickaxe

[@user-oj9yy1el3w]

Stop copying

[@hollowtrappedinaelevator320]

Haha 69 funny numbers

[@earthmagicyt]

@@hollowtrappedinaelevator320 bruh

[@hollowtrappedinaelevator320]

@@earthmagicyt yes?

[@aubren6456]

The scariest part of the video: He breaks a tree with a pickaxe

[@PB-N-Jenny]

Lmao

[@rojoscostanada8685]

1:27 The terrifying thing is the tool he is using.

[@rickie-89]

You bet

[@mr.noobtophat3012]

im gonna die

[@Ventixwine]

"Hey guys let's mine!" *Hears cave sounds* "See ya tomorrow guys"*leaves fast*

[@reimuhakureiforsmash6115]

10:05 Ah yes "The Warden" will perfectly fit in with that statement when 1.17 comes out.

[@super_9063]

Unsupported theory: what if these aren’t ghosts or anything but what if they’re Steve’s ptsd... maybe of a crash or incident in a mine.?

[@neversafefromwaluigi8853]

This can be very true from fact that Steve suffers groundhog day,eveytime he dies. He wakes up on his bed,he remembers and knows how he died. But yet can't actually die and always wakes up in his house,on the bed only to die and return. The sounds can possibly represent steve loosing his sanity knowing that he can't actually die,being paranoid of when he think he'll die,but not.

[@TheJoeWhoSoldTheWorld]

steve has nam' flashbacks and has a panic attack while in the mines

[@methmonster]

@@TheJoeWhoSoldTheWorld I’m now imaging Steve with a pixel M16 strolling through the jungle

[@TheJoeWhoSoldTheWorld]

@@methmonster **fortunate son but its playing on note blocks**

[@missmichelle1290]

@@neversafefromwaluigi8853 this all makes sense like the that one theory I can’t remember

[@HidinginmyHome]

Scary voice man returns

[@christianparker7681]

Scary ARG man in comments (Love your series)

[@2XVGAMING]

12418 is just C418's signature, because he made the sounds and music for minecraft

[@shopnil4]

Legit, Mojang was evil adding this. Plus, with the underwater noises and the new cave sound coming in the cave update, Minecraft might as well be a horror game.

[@Ghosthiee]

"Wait.. Minecraft was a horror game?" *"Always has been"*

[@rickie-89]

You bet

[@MilkIsTheOne]

Alpha with low render distance

[@MilkIsTheOne]

@̣ *Blue screen of death appears*

[@LegacyCat386M]

@@MilkIsTheOne install windows me

[@joanofaardvark6129]

I think that you should examine either: Old movies (like the dark crystal) Hollow knight deepnest More trevor Henderson beasts Pikmin

[@buffor-664]

The scariest thing in the universe, scarier than siren head, scarier than the bridge worm, minecraft cave sounds

[@windows2785]

There’s also sounds inside of the water, MUCH, MUCH, more scarier than cave sounds.

[@windows2785]

@People who care about you equals your IQ or 0 it’s not that scary.

[@orango1759]

"After listening to the 19 tracks let me know what you think" *zaxbys ad plays* Me:*intense screaming*

[@ImmaLittlePip]

In every abandoned mineshaft there's this one room a large square room with a dirt floor that's mostly empty I like to imagine that's the spot where the creeper blew up and many of the miners died

[@covidnugget5594]

Billy: without further or do, let's dive in *ad of takis hot nuts pops up*

[@ImWhyMortalsCry]

I would drive into hot nuts No wait that sounds wrong lmao xD

[@covidnugget5594]

@@ImWhyMortalsCry i would to

[@armin1500]

the lord has spoken and you shall obey lmfao

[@Funktastic_Official]

lmfao

[@polyminutes8788]

lmfao

[@brad9343]

Billy Styler should elaborate on who Herobrine is, I would like to hear him narrate the original 2010 Herobrine.

[@bruhmomentum4601]

I just want the newer Minecraft players to know him, to revive his legacy

[@catrosalina4948]

There aren't any good videos accurately recalling the history of herobrine. We need this

[@BlueRogueGuy]

"That can only occur in dark or underground areas" Me hearing a cave sound in daylight and in the middle of the plains: *_Hmm_*

[@_grunebohne]

This actually happens because you are near an unlit cavern, in case you didn’t know.. unless that was the joke..

[@sharkstargames3930]

Billy: I'm going to play all 19 cave sounds for you Satan: I just gotta say, I'm a huge fan

[@AlphaUru]

The sounds have never scared me...but whenever one of my tools break I get startled by the sound lmao

[@L8NightJ]

Me too lol! I thought I was the only one😂

[@potatronripe]

sameeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

[@conductorpineappleicecream8777]

:(

[@masahirosakurai3733]

Herobrine isn’t real, he is a figment of Steve’s imagination because of the guilt that he was the only survivor.

[@warning7555]

hahah steve man go brr

[@magicl3o]

ahah alex go brr

[@warning7555]

haha creeper go brr

[@masahirosakurai3733]

Hahah minecart go brrrrr

[@endmepls9196]

hahah villager go brrrr

[@probablyonawatchlist9485]

Nothing is scarier than casually mining and getting your ears assaulted by a cave sound

[@BlackDogsAndLadybugs]

Your pfp is a strong contender though, lol.

[@yeetyeetuspateetus7444]

why does this comment make me feel less scare

[@isolated_alien2996]

I always imagined sound 16 as a miner crossing an uncompleted track over a ravine and it falling to the bottom

[@aluz2236]

0:54 You scared the hell out of me, I really tought that someone was knocking at my door, and even the walls, outside the house. Nice effect man.

[@Sacrow]

I shouldn't have watched this around midnight. That knocking sound during the intro sequence almost gave me a heart attack.

[@JebusbeDevelopmentOFC]

in my Opinion this is what the Cave Sounds Means... Cave Sound 1: Distant Zombie Sound Cave Sound 2: Wind inside the cave Cave Sound 3: Wind inside the cave Cave Sound 4: Distant Scream Cave Sound 5: something scraping stones... Cave Sound 6: Distant Zombie Scream Cave Sound 7: Something Falling and hitting a iron or stone Cave Sound 8: Distant Breath of something... Cave Sound 9: a minecart moving... (Guess this one is right in the Crash Theory...) Cave Sound 10: something moving at high Speed (probably a minecart...) Cave Sound 11: a Stone Block being dragged by a Enderman Cave Sound 12: a Stone falling into pieces Cave Sound 13: Echo of the Wind... or Echo of a Scream Cave Sound 14: Multiple mobs breaths... Cave Sound 15: Something falling in lava (probably a minecart with Ores inside, the ores make that sound of "Cristal") Cave Sound 16: something falling of a Mine's bridge Cave Sound 17: a Creeper explosion Cave Sound 18: Rocks falling inside a minecart with Tools inside Cave Sound 19: something hitting a rock, multiple times but they could mean a Crash or something...

[@epicdude6719]

Yeah, I always thought the cave sounds were scary, and also disc 13 or the broken disc, it sounds like Steve running away from something....?

[@JebusbeDevelopmentOFC]

@@epicdude6719 yeap... I remember having fear of caves just because of the sounds... and yes, it does sounds like steve running from...something

[@epicdude6719]

@@JebusbeDevelopmentOFC yeah

[@LuigiXGamer]

Cave sound 5 sounds like a 1000% slower version of a bell.

[@foxxbaker]

Cave sound 1: that sounds nostalgic Cave sound 2: never heard that Cave sound 3: that can be scary in the dark Cave sound 4: I never heard this, I have too many torches Cave sound 5: that’s a classic to me when it comes to scary Minecraft Cave sound 6: once again, have too many torches Cave sound 7: I think that’s too quiet for me to hear Cave sound 8: now that I think about it, I swear I heard sound 1 above ground or not in a cave Cave sound 9: remember my first survival mode encounter with a endermen was deep underground Cave sound 10: horror violins, STAP! Wrong game! Cave sound 11: reminds me of a sound mine carts normally make Cave sound 12: yeah I’ll definitely be looking around, I don’t know what you mean, I-I-I’m not scared Cave sound 13: NOPE NOPE NOPE NOPE NOPE NOPE!!!! I’m fine with getting new gear!!!!! Cave sound 14: Minecraft.exe has stopped responding Cave sound 15: no, just no Cave sound 16: How many are their?!?! Cave sound 17: not sleeping tonight Cave sound 18: not bad Cave sound 19: image if this was a normal mob noise

[@silent_clarinet]

19 sounds like Predator clicking

[@liviwaslost]

To be honest, I don't remember these sounds. Plus, they don't creep me out at all.

[@watedgamer5372]

@@liviwaslost you must have heard them atleast once?!

[@liviwaslost]

@@watedgamer5372 maybe sometimes, it's been a while though. Plus, I always have lots of torches.

[@Kentucky_Caveman]

The first 2 are very nostalgic

[@robertls7151]

*_Ambience and Being Alone is much more scarier than a Minecraft Girlfriend Jump Scare_*

[@Galaxy-ke9mf]

Minecraft girlfriend jumpscare? Make sense...

[@CrazyMonkey-wm5hz]

I'm happy this vid had ads in between, gave me time to recuperate...

[@CubeCraftedAlt]

4:04 billy making a house is probably one of the best things I’ve seen today

[@silvertheelf]

Billy:”I’m sure you’ve been spooked at some point...” Creeper:”I make sure they get spooked at one point.”

[@vgstudio3588]

Who remembers when you do not have the courage to play by yourself?

[@vgstudio3588]

Cuz since I did, I can’t play Minecraft in my old Xbox anymore

[@sosman64]

i did and i still do everytime i am on minecraft i am like:"yeah lets go to servers"

[@sidknoop6381]

I always played on peacefull untill i got full iron everything. Good times.

[@vgstudio3588]

@@sidknoop6381 Yup good times

[@islaisland3366]

Never bothered me but maybe because I fucked my brain up from playing Silent Hill 2 and Siren Blood Curse when i was like 9

[@lifesgoodbutilikecrying5231]

Hearing these in old Minecraft as a kid WAS TERRIFYING

[@jhy275]

:I’m not scared of anything :But these cave sounds :They scare me

[@H20869]

I fear no sounds... but that sound... it terrifys me

[@kasenv57]

I'm hurt seeing him mine the worst type of wood with a wooden pickaxe

[@thestickopia4619]

The cave update is coming. Oh god, not more cave sounds

[@sourzedits5266]

Mincraft is a kids game Me: liminal spaces

[@babychomper273]

Dude why you faking cory?

[@YumiiOGT]

- sorry but it's just so FUNNY WHEN YOU START SAYING MINECRAFT

[@learninganimate3181]

My theory is that disc 11 Is a person slowly crawling to his insanity bc of ambient noises haunting him where he eventuslly loses his mind starts to run everywhere before accidently falling into cave and die

[@manbearpigss2840]

Billy Styler: talks about creepy minecraft noises and sounds At the end: dont forget the merch! gotta have those

[@NotSoGenesiz]

I love how sometimes the most simple of games have the most terrifying secrets

[@theclonestuds5946]

i was too scared to venture into caves because of those noises when i was 7, thats why i always just strip mined (i always had less cave sounds doing that)

[@TheCrunchyGamer]

At least you can turn off the cave noises

[@Person-ex4bx]

Why didn’t you just turn off the sound lmao

[@theclonestuds5946]

@@Person-ex4bx 7 year old me's iq was lower than a potato

[@KrakensLifee]

I didn't even mine. I just had my older cousin do it 😂

[@hingehubert4901]

I remember when I first heard one of these. It was like a Minecraft jumpscare, for a split second I thought mine could be haunted Ö Also love the new text for patron names at the end!

[@bbkdr]

Wait. For me this vid was posted 38 seconds ago, but this comment to me is 44 minutes old? Bruh?!?!

[@bestboy1285]

The power of billys discord notifications

[@CreepyADeepy]

This is one hell of a anomaly

[@alexb859]

Awesome video!!! Also I subbed :) I also have my own theory on the cave sounds as well :) and I respect yours as well :) it's the same as this but there are a few differences. The 1st and main difference is that the caves sounds are tied to a minecart crash, but is the first part of a 3 part story, while the second part being Disc 13, and finally Disc 11 being the final part, and 2 I believe sound 2 is an Allay sound due to how similarly they sound, maybe an Allay wishing the Miner luck on their Journey through the caves not knowing what will happen next, and the player in Discs 13 and 11 is a Scout looking for the Miners, the rest of the story goes Disc 13 starts, and we first hear sound 1 twice before hearing sound 2 (an Allay) before hearing Dripstone, then at the 1 minuet mark I hear the scout using a flint and steal to light a candle then we hear sound 5, 43 seconds later we hear a Creeper explosion as the Scout falls into a lake into the deepslate layer, going through some tight tunnels later he hits a mineshaft and that's when 13 ends, we walks through this mineshaft for a little bit and comes across a minecart chest, he walks over to it and that is when 11 starts, he lights his candle again, then he opens the chest to grab a book, before looking at the book an Enderman and a Warden try to communicate with him, he looks through the book to find any information on them, then we hear wind behind him and a strange figure poking through the darkness, he takes his candle to see what it is, and it's a Zombie, then he runs a certain direction and comes across some gravel, he tries to break it but the Zombie caught up to him and infected him, and that's when 11 ends, I feel like the Cave sounds, Disc 11, and Disc 13 show us something more dire, and that is how the Zombie Virus started in the Minecraft world, and that is my theory on the Cave Sounds, Disc 13, and Disc 11

[@Howzer296]

0:53 I hate you. I genuinely thought something knocked on my wall and I jumped.

[@user-oj9yy1el3w]

We hate you too

[@vinnywhyte4264]

Omg same i had earphones and i got jump scared

[@zapthebird8141]

Cave Sounds have literally never scared me and I don’t know why.

[@zephyrprime8]

Correction: cave sounds appear when a dark area is nearby, you don't have to be inside the dark area. This can be tested by searching for a large cave close to the surface, then standing on the surface directly above it.

[@ShameTooShame]

Yep the cave sounda sometimes plays on my house for some reason

[@zephyrprime8]

@@ShameTooShame There's a cave underneath your house

[@anomalyofcwx]

The way the cave sounds are ghostly & echoing, I feel like they are actually flashbacks to the minecart crashes.

[@acidrivers]

I was genuinely scared of Minecraft cave sounds but as a Minecraft veteran, watching Billy mine wood with a Pickaxe was scarier.

[@nimbizol811]

Yes me too.

[@pamelavalencia7334]

It would be a nice touch if you rearrange the sounds according to the theories.

[@5spec]

Billy: **mentions Herobrine** Me: bruh.

[@aaaaa5886]

This man can make anything scary than it is.

[@adetunjigilliam2488]

Billy Styler: Proceeds to break tree with a pickaxe Me as a Minecraft player: Ah yes true horror indeed

[@raysyndrome7209]

I feel like its even more creepier on peaceful mode. Imagine playing with no mobs because you want to set up a world how you want to set it up and then suddenly hearing cave sounds.

[@dorianguzman2025]

this reminds me of a time when i was playing with friends and I decided to go into a cave to mine alone. I was for some reason anxious, which I never am, but this time was different. So while I was mining I heard one of these sounds and it really put me on edge, then a few seconds later, a creeper shows up and I screamed for my life and I ran so fast out that cave. Just a pure flight response

[@GodzillaFan8889]

Crash theory: The cave sounds are echoes of a tragic past accident where several minecarts crashed into each other, killing numerous miners In-game: Minecarts harmlessly bounce off of walls, mobs and other minecarts

[@Horrorloserrrr]

This may sound dark but I feel Minecraft is in some sort of post apocalypse area. This would explain the weird villagers, every being else abandoned, and mobs

[@Pyth0n_]

I think about minecraft as sort of a castaway thing, you just wake up in the middle of no where, no other people, just you, and you have to survive.

[@KlynerKaiOffical]

Can’t believe I’m just now getting this notification!

[@mr.noobtophat3012]

0:43 the council will decide about your fate

[@crinak5608]

Fun fact: the most 76% relaxing and 24% scary is angelic humming BUT: The 90% scary and 10% relaxing is deep ringing, which plays in dark deep area caves, the rarest cave sound is known as creeper breathing.