Is Academic Scholarship on Hadith Legitimate

Is Academic Scholarship on Hadith Legitimate | Dr. Shabir Ally

Рет қаралды 18,821

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер

@QuranSpeaks 3 жыл бұрын

Dear friends, please subscribe to our email list for updates on our Ramadan content. Visit QuranSpeaks.com to subscribe. Thank you!

@gavinjames1145 3 жыл бұрын

Assalam alaikum! I very much appreciate your honest and open look at Islam, it's history and texts. Very refreshing! Please could you advise me any English language books which explain Ahadith and Isnaad(s) for those of us who are exploring Islam? Thank you!

@nayemkhan3732 3 жыл бұрын

Use this handy guide to easily dispute every normative claim Islam makes that violates modern liberal secular values. Using these rebuttals, you can justify virtually anything and make it seem like the Islamic scholarly tradition is on your side! With this guide you can undermine those pesky traditional Muslims and champion your reform Islam all the while coming across as a nuanced, learned scholar in your own right. Traditionalist: “There is consensus on this topic.” Modernist Rebuttal: “Actually, consensus is a highly contested issue.” Traditionalist: “These narrations are mutawatir.” Modernist Rebuttal: “Actually, tawatur is a highly contested issue.” Traditionalist: “This is the relied upon view of the four sunni schools.” Modernist Rebuttal: “We don’t have to limit ourselves to the schools because we live in a different context today.” Traditionalist: “This is an established position in one school.” Modernist Rebuttal: “Well, the majority of scholars say otherwise, so we can trash the minority position.” Traditionalist: “This is the majority position.” Modernist Rebuttal: “Well, there is a minority position that says otherwise, so we can safely ignore the majority.” Traditionalist: “This ayah is qat`i.” Modernist Rebuttal: “No it’s not.” Traditionalist: “This hadith is unequivocal.” Modernist Rebuttal: “But it is an ahad hadith, so we can safely ignore it.” Traditionalist: “This is the strongest position within the school.” Modernist Rebuttal: “But there is a solitary narration relaying the statement of a Sahabi that contradicts that position, so we can safely ignore it.” Traditionalist: “Most of the tafasir on these ayat convey the same interpretation.” Modernist Rebuttal: “Yeah, but there is one tafsir that says something slightly different, so that proves that the other tafasir are the result of cultural bias.” Traditionalist: “The fuqaha are agreed on this.” Modernist Rebuttal: “The fuqaha are limited in their knowledge of hadith. We have to look at what the muhaddithun said.” Traditionalist: “The muhaddithun are agreed on this.” Modernist Rebuttal: “The muhaddithun are limited in their knowledge of fiqh. We have to look at what the fuqaha said.” Traditionalist: “The fuqaha and the muhaddithun are agreed on this.” Modernist Rebuttal: “But we live in a different context, so our own ijtihad is necessary. Islam is a living tradition, etc.” See how easy it is to weasel your way out of anything and everything? When you aren’t beholden to standards of consistency and basic intellectual honesty, you can justify pretty much anything and look good doing it! Enjoy!

@hassanabdur-rahman1559 4 ай бұрын

I have been a Muslim for over 30 years. I have never believed in the hadiths. I studied and learned about Islam by studying the Quran and the history of Islam for 2 years before I became a Muslim. When I first became a Muslim, I didn't know any Muslims at the time. Several months after becoming a Muslim, I was given Bukhari's Sahih hadith compilation. I studied them and the more that I read them, I noticed how they were in many cases opposite to the Quran. I also noticed a lot of superstitions and illogical things in them. Whereas the Qur'an was logical and always appealed to reason. While the hadiths sometimes had some good moral teachings, they also contained some very harsh and cruel statements. They basically made the Prophet appear to have multiple personalities or be bipolar. After comparing the Quran and the hadiths. I concluded after studying the hadiths that they contradicted the Quran and must have been fabricated, although at the time I didn't know why. It was later after learning more about the history of Islam when I learned why hadiths were fabricated in the first place. After my conclusion regarding the hadiths, I decided that I would follow the Quran alone, which was several months after I became a Muslim. Although I never really followed the hadiths while learning about them anyway because I was still in the learning stage. Around this time I began to meet more Muslims from different parts of the world. After several encounters and discussions about our faith. I learned that they were really grounded in the hadiths and had very little knowledge of what was actually in the Quran. This was even true of Arabic speaking Muslims. I was shocked that some of them treated me like I was some kind of scholar or sheikh. After learning the condition of the Muslim world. I decided that I would seek an approach of unity and try to unify the Muslims who I encountered by focusing on the commonality and avoid discussing differences and promote the Quran without mentioning that it was the only guidance that I strove to follow. I always tried to unite all Muslims such as Sunnis and Shias by emphasizing the fact that they have far more in common than they have differences. I also would quote the Quran where Allah subhanahu wataala told the Muslims to tell the People of the Book to come to common grounds, when they didn't even believe in the Quran. I reminded them that Sunnis and Shias both believe in the Quran and Tawheed. That has been my approach for the last 30 years. However, there were times that I felt very lonely until now, because I followed the Quran alone. However it is refreshing to see that I am not alone these days. As I am seeing so many bright and intelligent young people discovering this path. In fact there is a brother on KZbin who brings me joy about the faith. Dr Omar Ramahi. He provides a very rational approach, which is scripturally based. He uses the vocabulary of the Quran, and the Quran itself to explain the Quran.

@osheenkelana 3 жыл бұрын

MALAY SUBTITLES Part 4 of 4 14:35 Dan ditambah, pada masa ini kita bersenjata dengan komputer. 14:37 Anda tahu, jika anda memikirkan bagaimana pendahulu kita 14:40 dalam iman itu berhasil dengan pen dan dakwat dan, anda tahu, cadar 14:43 dan semua itu, dan bagaimana mereka membawa sejumlah besar. 14:48 Sekarang tugas kita mudah kerana kita mempunyai sistem komputer. 14:51 Semua hadis sebenarnya telah didigitalkan, 14:54 mereka ada dalam bentuk e-bentuk. 14:56 Sangat mudah untuk membandingkan, dan membezakan, dan memilih, 14:59 dan potong dan tampal, dan sediakan penerbitan baru 15:03 yang akan memberi sekurang-kurangnya populis Muslim, 15:07 satu set hadis yang mereka boleh yakin, 15:11 bahawa ini tidak bermasalah, 15:12 mereka sesuai dengan masa dan tempat kita, 15:14 ini akan menjadi sumber, 15:18 dan jumlah yang berguna untuk membimbing kami 15:20 dalam kehidupan seharian kita sebagai umat Islam. - Kami akan membiarkannya. 15:24 Lain kali Apabila kita meneruskan siri kita, kita akan melihat 15:26 bagaimana umat Islam biasa dapat mendekati Hadis 15:28 dan menerapkannya dalam kehidupan mereka. 15:29 Terima kasih Dr Shabir. 15:30 - Sama-sama. 15:32 - Lihat Safiyyah, peti masuk saya penuh. 15:34 Saya mempunyai soalan daripada penonton kami. 15:35 - Wow, itu agak banyak. - Yeah. 15:37 Soalan anda keluar dari telinga saya. 15:39 - Itulah sebabnya kita mendapat sesuatu 15:40 sungguh menarik dirancang untuk anda. 15:42 A dan siaran langsung KZbin 15:44 Anda boleh menyertai kami secara langsung dan Dr.Shabir 15:46 akan menjawab soalan anda semasa mereka masuk. 15:48 - [Dr.Shabir] Acara ini akan bermula 15:49 pengaturcaraan Ramadan khas kami, 15:51 serta kempen penggalangan dana kami. 15:54 - Semuanya berlaku pada hari Ahad, 4 April, 15:56 pada 12:00 PM. Timur di saluran KZbin kami, Quran Speaks. 15:59 - Dan itu tepat sebelum Ramadan. 16:00 Saya tidak sabar untuk melihat soalan apa yang akan kami terima. 16:03 - Saya juga, akan senang berbual dengan anda, 16:05 dalam masa nyata. 16:06 - [Dr.Shabir] Langgan dan aktifkan pemberitahuan anda, 16:08 supaya anda tidak terlepas acara ini. 16:10 (muzik optimis)

@fatimaxo4885 3 жыл бұрын

So why aren’t more scholars shedding light on this issue? This is literally so important and can turn the tide... are they so insecure that their understanding will be questioned because we are now doing a double take on these traditions? It seems like Islam was also hijacked by scholars, but they’re also the ones accusing the Bible of that. I’m so confused!

@user-k229 2 жыл бұрын

You are correct. Quranic Islam was hijacked and we have been taken away from the Quran. Please see the book CONSPIRACIES AGAINST THE QURAN By Dr Abdul Wadud. It is an eye opener. The Golden Age of Islam occurred because the Muslims truly adopted the Message of the Quran. Today we have turned Deen Islam into Mazhab. Nowhere in the Quran will you find Allah swt using the word Mazhab!

@Glotisverdiamerdorifkelmzvur Жыл бұрын

It's the polticalism of it that exists within it, the suggestion to reform the tradition that has been used to elucidate the hadeeth is part of a system that has existed for hundreds upon hundreds of years, challenges not only the correctness of practices and attitudes, but the very status quo upon which hinges the authority and dignity of these sheikh and scholars who are used being the top of the muslim world.

@kennethwilliams4371 Жыл бұрын

@@GlotisverdiamerdorifkelmzvurI can't really grasp it, don't we already have the sahih bujhari and muslim for example, aren't these quit confident enough to present, why weed out more and compile in new publication as dr. Shabir ally suggested

@phiuzu5487 Жыл бұрын

@@kennethwilliams4371because unfortunately even sahih bukhari has problems. I would suggest to watch mufti abu layth's videos on this. If you're further interested, you can watch his respectful discussion with dr majid who disagrees with him to know the perspectives of both differing scholars.

@tasrifkusuma5265 Ай бұрын

@@kennethwilliams4371 that is the problem. no hadith book is 100% authentic.

@islamicclarity7062 3 жыл бұрын

I hope this can help the people calling Dr. Ally a heretic, rethink their approach. Muslims deserve to know the background of these important questions.

@hiddenwobbler9890 3 жыл бұрын

wahhabis/salafis call everyone a heretic. Their movement is imploding lol

@inbb510 3 жыл бұрын

@@hiddenwobbler9890 , is there ever a time when the salafis were at peace lmao?

@saimtanweer5720 3 жыл бұрын

Now you have more sources to makes videos 😁 Tell me how do you earn doing this ???

@DrWoofOfficial 6 ай бұрын

He's more of a heretic for preferring secular law in a modern context to Sharee'ah

@ultrapearl7938 3 жыл бұрын

Dr. Shabir Ally, Masha Allah, your channel attracts many non-believers. What a success!

@kalijasin 3 жыл бұрын

Masha'Allah

@saulien3675 3 жыл бұрын

Hello Ultra Pearl, It is important to keep learning. Please do not think affluence is a reflection of acceptance. Quite the contrary, it explains more of this ill faith theology and Dogma. You would be amazed in reading the angels such as John's, much more wisdom. The truth will set you free. Come to Jesus.

@fataltruth6000 3 жыл бұрын

What is concerning is that like most things in Islam, Muslims are cherry picking what suits their agenda and then base their faith thereon instead of seeing it for what is written. Sahih means authentic doesn't it? So why cherry pick if the literature in found authentic?

@fataltruth6000 3 жыл бұрын

@@ish8891 so you believe the Sahih hadith where your prophet calls black people raisin heads?

@saulien3675 3 жыл бұрын

@@fataltruth6000 I agree

@Hamza000h 3 жыл бұрын

Jazakallah Dr Shabir as always. Absolute legend.

@osheenkelana 3 жыл бұрын

MALAY SUBTITLES Part 2 of 4 04:47 dan mengesan asal-usulnya. 04:50 Dan selalunya hadis dapat ditelusuri kembali ke pautan biasa. 04:54 Jadi, jika anda mempunyai sejumlah rantai yang muncul, 04:56 katakanlah Nabi saw, 04:58 kononnya memberitahu sesuatu kepada seseorang, 05:03 dan kemudian orang itu memberitahu satu orang 05:05 yang kemudian memberitahu satu orang, 05:07 baiklah kita mempunyai satu rangkaian perawi 05:10 mengaitkan satu ucapan Nabi saw ini. 05:13 Tetapi katakanlah Nabi saw, 05:15 memberitahu dua orang, yang kemudian masing-masing memberitahu dua orang, 05:18 yang kemudian masing-masing memberitahu dua orang. 05:20 Jadi kita mempunyai percabangan sekarang, 05:24 banyak rantai pencerita, pada akhirnya ia akan menjadi, 05:28 dari dua menjadi empat, kemudian lapan, kemudian 16, kemudian 32. 05:32 Akhirnya anda mempunyai 64 cawangan yang berbeza 05:35 pada dasarnya sama sama diceritakan 05:37 dari satu orang ke orang lain dalam rangkaian perawi. 05:41 Oleh itu, dalam kes ini, semua rantai kembali ke belakang 05:45 kepada Nabi Muhammad saw. 05:47 Tetapi apa yang dijumpai oleh Juynboll ialah, dengan kebanyakan hadis, 05:52 rantai tidak semuanya kembali kepada Nabi Muhammad, 05:54 salam, mereka kembali kepada apa yang disebutnya 05:57 Pautan Biasa. 05:58 Dan dalam alat itu seolah-olah orang itu 06:02 bertemu dengan Nabi saw, 06:03 memberitahu satu orang, yang kemudian memberitahu satu orang, 06:06 yang kemudian memberitahu banyak pelajarnya 06:10 - Puan. - Dan kemudian 06:11 peminat di luar sana. 06:13 Jadi, apabila kita melihatnya dari hujung yang lain, 06:16 kita melihat bahawa pelbagai rantai tidak menyatu 06:19 kepada Nabi Muhammad saw. 06:21 mereka bertemu dengan satu orang yang mempunyai ramai pelajar. 06:25 Dan selalunya orang itu adalah Al-Imam Al-zuhri, 06:28 yang meninggal pada awal abad kedua 06:31 pada tahun 124. 06:33 Jadi itu masih lebih dari seratus tahun 06:35 setelah wafatnya Nabi kita, saw, 06:37 masih kadang-kadang dikeluarkan, tetapi dengan cara ini 06:41 mengesan semula naratifnya 06:44 ke pautan umum, sama ada Al-Imam Al-zuhri 06:47 dan kadang-kadang bahkan kepada seseorang yang lebih awal daripada dirinya sendiri, 06:50 para cendekiawan lebih mendapat jaminan 06:52 bahawa itu semua tidak dicipta seperti 06:54 beberapa ratus tahun kemudian, 06:57 tetapi mereka mempunyai asal usul yang lebih awal. 07:00 - Mmh - Dan kemudian ia tidak berakhir di sana 07:03 kerana kita mempunyai sarjana lain yang mengusahakan ini. 07:05 Contohnya, beberapa sarjana Jerman, Gregor Schoeler, 07:11 dan Andreas Gorke, dan Harald Motzki. 07:15 Mereka melakukan analisis teks dan teks yang sangat terperinci 07:22 rantai perawi teks Hadis. 07:24 Dan mereka lebih banyak lagi 07:29 keadaan yakin bahawa mereka boleh sampai 07:33 dengan lebih yakin 07:36 penilaian hadis 07:37 kerana mereka dapat mengesan beberapa naratif kembali 07:41 ke pautan biasa yang lebih awal. 07:44 - Puan. - Dan kerja mereka melibatkan 07:47 bukan hanya melihat rantai naratif, 07:49 tetapi melihat naratifnya sendiri, 07:52 dan lihat bagaimana naratif dapat berkembang 07:54 dari satu generasi ke generasi yang lain. 07:56 Dan dengan kerja keras ini lagi, 07:59 mereka dapat menunjukkan lebih yakin pada hadis, 08:02 jauh lebih banyak daripada yang dilakukan oleh Joseph Schacht satu generasi yang lalu. 08:07 - Mmh, saya melihat banyak sarjana ini bercakap 08:09 teksnya, dan itu tidak mencukupi 08:11 analisis teks yang dilakukan oleh para sarjana ini pada masa lalu, 08:15 para sarjana Islam pada masa lalu. 08:17 - Ya, jadi salah satu 08:19 cara melihat hadis dan menilai itu 08:23 adalah dengan melihat kandungan ini, 08:26 Hadis itu sendiri, seperti teksnya, 08:28 apa sebenarnya yang dikatakan ini? 08:30 Jadi, seseorang memberitahu orang lain memberitahu orang lain 08:32 bahawa Nabi saw, berkata X. 08:35 Begitu juga X yang kita bimbangkan 08:37 yang disebut teks, teks ini yang ada 08:40 dihantar dari satu orang ke orang lain. 08:43 Oleh itu, apa yang dinyatakan dalam teks ini? 08:45 Dan dalam keadaan sosial apa yang sesuai? 08:49 Dan fungsi apa yang dilakukan pada masa itu? 08:52 Katakan seseorang mencipta teks. 08:54 Atas sebab apa, tujuan apa? 08:56 Apa yang disajikan pada masa itu? 08:58 Apa keperluan masa yang muncul 09:01 kepada orang yang mencipta teks seperti ini? 09:04 Jadi analisis teks yang teliti ini digabungkan dengan 09:08 isnad, atau rangkaian perawi 09:15 menganalisis isnad atau rantai bersama teks. 09:17 Inilah yang digemari oleh para sarjana Harald Motzki 09:20 telah melakukan. 09:21 - Mmh, jadi Dr.Shabir, adakah anda berfikir bahawa 09:23 kritikan ini merosakkan ilmu hadis? 09:27 - Baiklah, ya dan tidak. 09:29 Sekiranya kita boleh mengatakan ya itu merosakkan 09:31 kepada persepsi tradisional Muslim 09:34 bagaimana hadis harus dipertimbangkan, 09:36 kerana selama beratus-ratus tahun sebelum itu, 09:39 Umat Islam telah terbiasa dengan adil 09:41 menerima hadis sebagaimana adanya, 09:42 mengambil Corpus sebagaimana adanya, kitab-kitab utama Hadith 09:46 dan memperlakukan mereka seolah-olah seperti suci,

@99bogatyrs99 3 жыл бұрын

Thank you for your inspired insight. I just watched this for a second time since it is so important. I look forward to the next installment. As a new revert (2017) I have been confused and challenged with the Hadith. Many times on my journey brothers or sisters have given me advice based on Hadith that I later found out, after talking to my Imam, that they are not authentic or at least questionable. This series is most helpful. Jazakallahu khayr!

@hassanabdur-rahman1559 3 жыл бұрын

@Dark Dawgs, please read, study and follow the Quran. Any hadiths that contradict the Qur'an and its spirit, reject them, because they are false. In fact the safest way to go is to follow the Quran alone.

@kennethwilliams4371 Жыл бұрын

@@hassanabdur-rahman1559thank you! As a born, coming-of-age Muslim, I've recently challenged with this also

@osheenkelana 3 жыл бұрын

MALAY SUBTITLES Part 3 of 4 09:49 hampir seperti Al-Quran. 09:50 Oleh itu, apa sahaja yang datang dari sana, kami mengambilnya. 09:52 Sudah tentu selalu ada dikotomi 09:55 antara pengetahuan ilmiah dari buku-buku hadis ini 09:58 dan pengetahuan orang ramai. 10:01 Orang jahat hanya di sini hadis yang dipilih. 10:03 Katakan seorang sarjana sedang membaca buku hadisnya, 10:06 dia sedang menyediakan nota untuk memberikan khutbah, 10:08 dan dia menjumpai sebuah hadis yang baginya kelihatan bermasalah, 10:11 nampaknya semuanya betul mengenai perkara ini. 10:15 Atau, dia merasakan bahawa ini tidak akan diterima dengan baik. 10:18 Jadi apa yang dia lakukan ialah dia membiarkannya sahaja. 10:20 Dia memilih dari, anda tahu, ia seperti gudang, 10:23 dia hanya dapat mengambil apa yang dia perlukan. 10:25 Dia memilih apa yang dia perlukan untuk membentuk khotbah yang baik, 10:28 dan dia menyampaikannya kepada orang ramai. 10:30 Apabila orang ramai mendengarnya, semua yang mereka dengar adalah hadis 10:33 yang telah dipilih dengan teliti 10:35 dan itu tidak bermasalah. 10:37 - Puan. - Dan mereka mendapat kesan, 10:39 orang ramai mendapat gambaran bahawa hadis itu baik, 10:42 itu sahaja yang kita tahu. 10:44 Setiap hadis yang pernah kita dengar adalah baik. 10:47 Jadi, ia mengatakan tidak ada masalah dengan Hadis. 10:50 Sekarang, ketika para sarjana Orientalis ini mula bekerja 10:54 dengan cara mereka bekerja dan menerbitkan hasilnya, 10:58 ini menyebabkan rona dan tangisan yang hebat. 11:00 Oleh itu, ini adalah, di satu pihak, 11:03 kita boleh mengatakan bahawa ia merosakkan persepsi orang Islam itu 11:07 bagaimana hadis harus dirasakan. 11:10 Tetapi sebaliknya, sebahagian karya ini bermanfaat 11:14 kerana itu memberi amaran kepada umat Islam akan idea itu 11:17 bahawa mungkin kita secara tidak sengaja menyebarkan ucapan, 11:21 seperti sabda Nabi Muhammad saw, 11:24 sedangkan, itu bukan benar-benar ucapannya, 11:26 mereka mengatakan orang dari beberapa generasi selepasnya, 11:29 atau kadang-kadang, bahkan ucapan dari generasi awal, 11:33 tetapi mereka sebenarnya bukan ucapan Nabi Muhammad, 11:36 salam sejahtera. 11:37 Mungkin itu pepatah seorang sahabat Nabi 11:39 yang secara tidak sengaja mendapat kembali arah retro 11:42 seolah-olah ini adalah sabda Nabi. 11:45 Dan anda akan dapati sebenarnya dalam kajian hadis hari ini, 11:48 katakanlah para ulama hadis berurusan dengan sebuah pepatah 11:51 yang sangat popular di kalangan umat Islam, 11:53 atau untuk satu sebab atau yang lain, 11:56 dianggap bermanfaat untuk menggunakannya sebagai asas 11:59 untuk undang-undang Islam, dan yang terbaik yang dapat mereka lakukan adalah mengesannya 12:02 kepada seorang sahabat Nabi saw. 12:05 Sekarang, jika pepatah itu ada kaitan dengan sesuatu 12:09 katakan kehidupan di sini selepas, 12:12 mereka akan berkata, walaupun ia berlaku kepada sahabat 12:16 Nabi, tidak mungkin perkara semacam itu 12:20 bahawa rakan itu akan mencipta sendiri. 12:22 - Puan. - Jadi dia mesti mendapatkannya 12:24 dari Nabi saw. 12:26 Itulah satu-satunya sebab dia tidak akan menceritakan perkara ini. 12:28 Oleh itu, hadis ini dapat dirawat 12:31 sebagai pepatah Nabi, saw. 12:34 Dan itu hari ini. 12:35 Itulah hari ini para sarjana melakukan ini. 12:37 Jadi, jika ini adalah jenis andaian kerja 12:39 bahawa para ilmuan bersedia menjalankan, 12:42 dan sekarang, anda boleh bayangkan pada masa lalu juga, 12:45 bahawa orang kadang-kadang mungkin mengaitkan sesuatu 12:48 kepada Nabi saw, bahawa dia tidak mengatakan. 12:51 Oleh itu ... - Apa pendapat anda, 12:53 apakah peranan anda yang boleh dimainkan oleh para sarjana Islam 12:56 dalam membantu memperbaiki keadaan ini, 12:58 dan menghilangkan hadis-hadis palsu? 13:00 - Baiklah, beberapa sarjana Muslim telah menggunakan pemikiran mereka 13:04 mengenai masalah ini. 13:05 Dan salah seorang sarjana tersebut adalah Kamali Hashim. 13:12 Bukunya berjudul "Metodologi Hadis," 13:18 telah diterbitkan semula di United Kingdom. 13:20 Saya mula-mula membeli salinan di Malaysia, mungkin sedekad yang lalu. 13:24 Dan buku itu telah diterbitkan semula, 13:28 pertama kali diterbitkan di Malaysia kini diterbitkan semula 13:31 oleh Pusat Islam di Markfield di United Kingdom, 13:35 dan diberi tajuk baru, "Buku teks pengajian Hadis." 13:38 Sekiranya, hingga akhir mungkin bab terakhir buku itu 13:43 memberikan cadangan bagaimana kita terus maju dengan kajian hadis, 13:47 dan profesor mereka Hashim memetik beberapa sarjana penting 13:51 seperti Dr. Yusuf al-Qaradawi, yang mengatakan bahawa 13:55 sekarang kita perlu kembali melihat Corpuses of Hadith, 13:58 koleksi Hadis yang kita ada, 14:00 dan kita harus membuat kajian baru yang akan 14:04 pilih dari Corpuses the Hadiths yang boleh kita sampaikan 14:08 kepada orang ramai sebagai hadis yang kami rasa yakin. 14:13 Jadi kerja itu perlu dilakukan. 14:14 - Kedengarannya seperti tugas yang sangat menakutkan. 14:16 - Ini tugas besar, 14:18 tetapi kami mempunyai pengetahuan ilmiah di luar sana. 14:25 Bukan saya sendiri, saya hanya pelajar yang hebat 14:27 badan biasiswa, tetapi sarjana ada 14:30 siapa yang boleh melakukan ini jika mereka bersedia, 14:32 dan jika mereka cukup berani untuk memikul tugas itu.

@Chandransingham 3 жыл бұрын

Very helpful. The Study Quran only refers to Ignac Goldziher's classification. Dr Shabir tells us more and points to the way forward. The term 'Orientalist' should be deprecated.

@osheenkelana 3 жыл бұрын

MALAY SUBTITLES Part 1 of 4 00:00 Dr Shabir, selamat datang di "Biarkan Al-Quran Bercakap". 00:02 - Saya gembira dapat berada di sini. 00:03 - Kami meneruskan siri hadis kami. 00:05 Dan sekarang kita akan melihat apa biasiswa akademik 00:08 dan khususnya Orientalis, 00:09 telah mengatakan mengenai Hadis dan cara bertindak balas 00:12 kepada kritikan tersebut. 00:13 Oleh itu, Dr. Shabir, apa yang telah berlaku 00:15 kritikan utama Orientalis. 00:17 Jadi saya faham bahawa mereka adalah yang paling kuat, menentang, 00:21 mereka adalah individu yang paling kuat 00:22 yang nampaknya menentang Hadis. 00:24 - Ya, jika anda tidak keberatan, saya rasa sedikit latar belakang 00:27 sebelum Orientalis datang ke tempat kejadian 00:29 mungkin penting di sini. - Baik. 00:31 - Oleh itu, Hadis dikumpulkan dalam buku-buku utama 00:35 pada sekitar abad ketiga era umat Islam. 00:38 Dan selepas itu, biasiswa Muslim 00:41 cenderung menerima buku-buku utama ini sebagai sahih. 00:45 Mereka menggolongkannya sebagai buku yang sahih. 00:49 Sahih al-Sittah menjadi istilah umum di kalangan umat Islam 00:52 merujuk kepada enam buah buku sebagai sahih. 00:55 Dan selama berabad-abad kemudian para sarjana 00:58 menulis ulasan mengenai buku-buku ini. 01:00 Oleh itu, kita mempunyai ulasan 01:01 "Sahih Al-Bukhari" oleh Ibn Hajar Al-Asqlani. 01:05 Kami mempunyai ulasan mengenai "Sahih Muslim" 01:07 salah satu koleksi hadis yang lain, 01:10 salah satu buku hadis lain oleh Imam al-Nawawi. 01:12 Dan kita mempunyai cendekiawan 01:14 yang berfikir secara teori mengenai Hadis seperti Ibn al-Salah, 01:17 dan mereka menulis buku dan jilid tentang ini, 01:20 mempertahankan hadis dan memberi jaminan kepada umat Islam 01:24 bahawa kita tahu hadis-hadis ini, 01:27 kita faham semuanya, ini adalah hadis sahih, 01:29 inilah yang kita ikuti. 01:31 - [Dr. Safiyyah] Mmh. 01:32 - Jadi, datanglah Orientalis. 01:33 (Safiyya terkikik) Baiklah 01:34 dengan Renaissance Eropah 01:37 para cendekiawan mula-mula melihat agama Yahudi dan Kristian. 01:41 Mereka mempelajari Alkitab secara terperinci dan mereka menggunakan semua 01:45 alat sejarah kritikal moden 01:49 bahawa mereka dapat menguasai, 01:51 dan mereka membawa kesaksian ini kepada Perjanjian Lama dan Baru 01:54 dan mengenai sejarah dogma Kristian. 01:57 Dan mereka cuba menguraikan dan menguraikan bagaimana, 02:00 tidak dengan niat buruk, 02:02 kebanyakan dari mereka adalah Yahudi dan Kristian sendiri, 02:05 tetapi mereka berusaha untuk mencapai perkara yang paling penting 02:07 dari sudut sejarah, 02:08 melihat semuanya dengan mata kritikal 02:11 bukannya melalui mata iman. 02:13 - Puan. 02:14 - Dan ketika mereka telah melakukan banyak pekerjaan ke arah itu 02:20 akhirnya sebahagian dari mereka berpaling ke arah 02:22 akidah Islam juga. 02:24 Dan mereka ingin mempelajari Al-Quran, sejarahnya, 02:26 mereka ingin mengkaji hadis dan riwayatnya, 02:30 mereka ingin mengkaji sejarah dogma Muslim dan sebagainya. 02:34 - Begitu juga dengan terjemahan yang baik 02:36 kerja yang mereka buat, anda tahu, 02:38 dengan sumber Kristian dan Yahudi 02:39 dan kemudian menerjemahkannya kepada analisis hadis mereka. 02:43 - Nah yang menjadi topik kontroversi 02:46 di kalangan umat Islam, tetapi dari sudut pandangan mereka, 02:49 mereka sebahagian daripada komuniti ilmiah, 02:53 dan itu, anda tahu, sedang membuat kajian 02:55 dan mereka menerbitkan kajian mereka 02:57 dalam jurnal yang dikaji rakan sebaya, untuk diuji dan disahkan 03:01 dan sama ada diakui atau ditolak oleh sarjana lain 03:05 yang berkebolehan sama. 03:07 Dan, mereka menggunakan kaedah yang 03:09 biasa diterima antaranya 03:12 untuk mengkaji karya sastera atau sejarah, 03:17 sama ada sejarah dan sastera Muslim, 03:19 Sejarah atau sastera Kristian, 03:21 Sejarah atau sastera Yahudi, 03:22 Sejarah atau sastera Buddha dan sebagainya. 03:24 Jadi, dari sudut pandangan mereka ada yang berusaha 03:27 yang terbaik untuk mereka menggunakan kaedah neutral 03:33 dan untuk mengelakkan bias dan menggunakan mata kritikal 03:39 untuk memeriksa perkara dan kembali kepada asal-usul perkara. 03:44 - Jadi mari kita mulakan dengan mana-mana sarjana ini, 03:45 mungkin Joseph Schacht, dan anda boleh memberitahu saya apa 03:47 hujah utamanya adalah. 03:49 - Ya, jadi Joseph Schacht dan sebelum dia Ignac Goldziher 03:54 berpendapat bahawa, pada dasarnya hadis-hadis itu 04:00 diciptakan oleh orang Islam sendiri 04:03 untuk membenarkan amalan tertentu. 04:07 Mereka tidak mempunyai maklumat yang boleh dipercayai 04:09 dari Nabi Muhammad saw, 04:11 kerana dia sudah lama mati pada waktu orang datang 04:15 dengan hadis, beberapa generasi kemudiannya 04:18 dalam masa dan keadaan baru. 04:21 Oleh itu, mereka mencipta sesuatu untuk membuktikan perkara-perkara tertentu. 04:25 - Adakah anda fikir masuk akal, hujah mereka? 04:27 - Nah, Joseph Schacht tidak mempunyai kata terakhir mengenai ini, 04:30 kerana ulama lain datang setelahnya 04:32 dan mereka tidak begitu ragu dengan hadis, 04:35 - Baik. - Sebagai contoh, 04:36 G.H.A. Juynboll, dan dia telah melakukan banyak kajian 04:41 dan dia mengambil lebih banyak jalan tengah 04:44 dalam menerima bahawa kita dapat mempelajari hadis-hadis ini

@Deekamebangag 3 жыл бұрын

Alhamdulillah Islam was given and completed. It was kept and preserved.Nobody can take that away.

@hassanabdur-rahman1559 4 ай бұрын

@EdinaKamel 3 ай бұрын

For many years I have wanted to be a Muslima, but something always stopped me(my husband is a born Muslim), he always told me that God stamped my heart, and I always argued, but I just did not understand things(like everything is haram, like killing, hating, the hell is full of women, Aisha age, hating dogs, killing lizards, etc). Some weeks ago, inspired by a TikTok video, I finally understood that all my problems were the hadiths, man-made rules. Now, I am on my way to understanding the Quran alone, praying to God to help me find the right way. I am not Arabic and not even an English speaker, so it is very hard.

@pwdrhrn 6 ай бұрын

A wonderful series. I haven’t heard yet about disputed claims that either the Prophet, Abu Bakr and/or Omar forbade the writing of Hadith. As a non-Arab revert, it is obvious that Hadith contain some true and surely some lies. The best lies contain some truth. It is best to discard them as ‘archaic Arabic politics’, and accept the Qu’ran alone and determine how to best live in our times.

@alihijazi2655 3 жыл бұрын

How about the Ahal Al Kalam and the Muatazilin. They were Muslims in the beginning of the Islamic era that questioned Hadith?

@khurramkhurshed9427 3 жыл бұрын

ALLAH BLESS YOU ALL AMEEN

@shazgq 3 жыл бұрын

Thanks for shedding light and may Allah reward you.

@thetruth27786 Жыл бұрын

Im jealous of this father and daughter,they have so much respect for each other

@androshah365 3 жыл бұрын

Hadith has corrupted the words of Allah!

@androshah365 2 жыл бұрын

@I agree with you, but read Quran and you will find the answer.

@hzhz4768 3 жыл бұрын

Let me make a prediction about this "daunting task" of revisiting the hadith collections that lies ahead of muslim scholars: the outcome will be that all more or less embarrassing hadiths will largely be dismissed as being unreliable because the starting point that Mohammed is untouchable will inevitably lead to such an outcome

@laylaali5977 4 ай бұрын

Most Hadiths are unreliable this has been known by the early Muslims

@linkup901ify 2 жыл бұрын

Shabir is jumping the gun here, especially in the case of Motski's and Schoeler's analysis of hadith. From reading Schoeler's work I didn't get the sense he is as much as an expert as Shabir is painting him here. At one point he confuses a narration that is well known to be from an event that happened later...Ignac Goldziher was doing the same nonsense. Is this forgiveable? Sure, but it also removes any doubt that their grasp of the hadith corpus is less than a beginner student of hadith. Also I have to question why did Schoeler choose those hadith that he selected from the collection of hadith? Why didn't he choose one that is of the Prophet pbuh in front of a group and look at the concept of mutawattir hadith? The ones he choose are historical background and as such why is he asking for such a high level evidence? Also what happens when we uncover more hadith collections from those early years? It seems like they are playing games until those manuscripts can be analyzed and published. Like the Quran before it, they will just keep changing their tone while at the same time looking for ways to confuse and fool people.

@SAli-yb9us Жыл бұрын

So why don’t we have contemporary hadith compilations of authentic hadith?

@asathelogiclaman637 3 жыл бұрын

Much Love Dr Shabbir Ally ❤️❤️❤️

@zozoconde4623 3 жыл бұрын

Brother Shabir, why don't you debate with Imam Karim Lewis with his partner Lost Blues on Quran and Hadith. Imam Lewis did invite people of knowledge to debate with him about Hadith. Go on youtube and put the name Imam Karim Lewis. Your job as a person of knowledge should correct people when they are wrong, if Imam Lewis is wrong. The debate is a sharing of knowledge and not a fight where there is a winner or loser.

@hadiashhar7111 3 жыл бұрын

assalamualaikum ,why is channel showing the ad of the urdu thinker it is misleading kindly plz keep track of ads that are showing on ur videos thank you!

@phenomenal17playz 3 жыл бұрын

By the way why Sura 4:157 is controversial?

@kennethwilliams4371 Жыл бұрын

Isn't it already done, I don't know what more need to do, isn't sahih Bukhari already good enough?

@hp6308 3 жыл бұрын

After seeing how derogatory, dehumanizing and mysogynistic hadeeth is, how can you accept anything in these books?

@ahmedharris4746 3 жыл бұрын

You’d have to expound upon your comment because it’s merely rhetorical otherwise.

@revivalist355 3 жыл бұрын

Is the ahadith supposed to conform to your liking and opinion for it to be authentic

@josipcolic5304 3 жыл бұрын

The problem is in your understanding of hadith, not in the hadith itself

@jamescook4402 3 жыл бұрын

These are loaded terms and are meaningless without an objective view of morality.

@DuaNoorKitchen 3 жыл бұрын

Very ma sha ALLAH sharing

@mdmahmudhasan9786 3 жыл бұрын

MashaAllah, this word cannot be used with "very". If you use "very", the word sounds ridiculous.

@mdmahmudhasan9786 3 жыл бұрын

🤭🤭🤭🤭😀😀😃😄😅😆😂🤣😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

@binabina7801 2 жыл бұрын

the biggest problems we have is with some hadith. so hadith are definitive not all good!

@robertblake9892 10 ай бұрын

The picture of Joseph Schacht is actually of Hjalmar Schacht, prominent German banker, Third Reich official.

@mashrurmollick 3 жыл бұрын

How can I ask a question to Dr shabir ally?

@Simarodra 3 жыл бұрын

How ordinary muslims can approach the hadith and apply it in their life ... I am looking forward for the episode. Thank you Dr. Shabir ...

@nayemkhan3732 3 жыл бұрын

@Simarodra 3 жыл бұрын

Interesting approach there ... I will consider using them ... thank you

@user-k229 2 жыл бұрын

Stick with the Book of Allah, The Quran. Allah does not tell you to go and start following man- made hadith, on the contrary!!

@luisgatmaitan512 Жыл бұрын

Shabir ali how do u pray?how do u pay zakah?how can u compute inheritance?

@specialagentorange4329 Жыл бұрын

Do you need a hadith that shows you how many times to chew your food, too?

@luisgatmaitan512 Жыл бұрын

@@specialagentorange4329 counting how many times you chew your food is not the same as how much percentage you need to pay for zakat or how much inheritance should 1 take after the death of parents or what action would a muslim do during prayer. Your argument is so shallow and childish.

@jimmybeam1550 Жыл бұрын

@@luisgatmaitan512you think 2.5% is eternally applicable? Qurans guidance is eternal. There are many many verses regarding charity. Yet you need a specific %? The hadith method is flawed, it doesnt take into account inlation and purchasing power. Quran states to give as much as you can and as often as you can and from the excess so its not a burden. Today muslims wait till end of year for 2.5%. Didnt the hadith state zakaat in gold and silver? What happened to that?

@alTursi05 2 жыл бұрын

Dr. Mustafa A'zami wrote amazing responses to these orientalist. So did Jonathan Brown. Seems like Dr. Shabir should do better research. If he did come across these books which I'm pretty sure he should have then why is he not mentioning these works that literally buried the orientalist arguments against Hadīth?

@laylaali5977 2 жыл бұрын

Some Hadiths are sound but large majority of Hadiths are not reliable

@BEGOOD20081 2 жыл бұрын

ASA, any Hadith should be connected to The Quran itself. And verified through the Quran.

@MrPolarbear1961 2 жыл бұрын

Javed Ahmed Ghamidi has so far analysed about thirty thousand Hadiths and published the results in his monthly magazine,Ishraq...

@user-k229 2 жыл бұрын

Man-made hadith are what has taken muslims away from true Deen Islam. Javed Ghamidi is a great scholar but in order not to offend the mullah he treads a careful path. The Quran is the Best Hadith, a Book fully consistent with itself, as it states clearly.

@sundaremmanuel2843 3 жыл бұрын

What is he basically saying is that just me must get down and get away from uncomfortable Hadiths . Isn’t that censoring .? The biggest problem of prophet

@lastdayswebcom 3 жыл бұрын

الله اکبر

@justaminute3111 3 жыл бұрын

Interesting idea, refine the Hadith, again. Given that the standard narrative about the Hadith is that only just over 7,000 were kept out of over 600,000 collected. Besides I thought that the current collection had already been graded as weak vs strong. Nice discussion, though.

@samsungkartit 3 жыл бұрын

Ma sha allah brother Shabir

@user-k229 2 жыл бұрын

Dr Ally, a brilliant overview of the man-made hadith. It is definitely a case of Chinese whispers! In fact I would say the hadith are equivalents to the Gospels... the sayings of Mathew, Mark, Luke and John. But we don't even know who these people were and whether they wrote them at all. The Gospels are " According to John" etc etc. The hadith were developed to take us far, far, away from the Quran. They were put together nearly 200 years after the Prophet passed away!!! Another important fact is that at the time of Abu Bakr Siddique r a he ordered the burning of ALL hadith! So how and why did they resurface? Conspirators got together and put together man-made sayings to take us away from the Quran. They could not destroy Islam from the outside. Instead they destroyed our Deen from the inside! The Quran calls Itself, The Best Hadith. A Book fully consistent with Itself, i.e it needs NO OTHER SOURCES TO SUPPORT IT. Allah swt tells us that it is written in Clear, ARABY MUBEEN. The Quran states: 77:50 in what hadith after this, will you believe. It also states: Woe unto those who exchange hadith for petty gains. People were buying and selling hadith. The Quran also says: Do not go visiting the Prophet and wanting an hadith. I have done a calculation that shows that there are 1.6 million hadith, narrated by nearly 500,000 different people. If we assume an average time of say 5min to read out a hadith, then it would have taken about 15 years, DAY AND NIGHT for the Prophet to have said and dictated all the hadith. How was this humanly possible, when the mission of Rasool to give us the Quran lasted 23 years? We need to have Scientific and Scholarly books about the Quran. Why all this emphasis on man-made hadith??? We have lost the importance of the Quran and this is the reason why we as Muslims are not even second rate citizens!!! WE CONTRIBUTE NOTHING TO THE WORLD OR SCIENTIFIC COMMUNITY. Jews are a small nation but they are a dominate force for Nobel prizes. We lost our Islamic Golden Age!

@alTursi05 2 жыл бұрын

Many many mistakes in your statement. The verses you quote do not even speak of the Hadīth as how we have it today. Hadīth just merely means speech. The word Hadīth developed its technical meaning afterwards. The same way Quran has been passed down from centuries to centuries. Is the very same way Hadīth has been passed down from Centuries to centuries. By way of isnād chain of narration. It has been memorised. If it is as you say that Abu Bakr R.A burned the Hadīth that was written down, then still if they memorised it then bunring it won't cause them to have completely erased from them. Same like the Quran. Both were memorised. And the Reason Abu Bakr did that is so that it does not get mixed up with the compilation of the Quran.

@user-k229 2 жыл бұрын

@@alTursi05 mmmh, interesting reply. Your answer as to why the hadith were burnt: " So that they didnt get mixed up with the Quran." Is the typical reply brother. But have you not read the Quranic verses that challenge anyone to even produce one Surah like the Quran? So you are saying that man-made hadith are of the same supreme calibre of the Quran?? So Allah swt Sent Messengers so that they could deliver there own hadith and you are saying that they were the same as the Quran?

@alTursi05 2 жыл бұрын

@@user-k229 Hadīth is man-made? The Quran itself says : وما ينطق عن الهوى. ان هو الا وحي يوحى Chapter 53 verses 3-4. Translation is And he (The Prophet Muhammad SalaLlahu alayhi wa sallam) does not speak out of desire. He speaks whatever has been revealed to him. So Hadith is also considered as revelation as this Verse of the Quran testifies to that. The Quran is recited revelation The Hadith is revelation not recited (i.e in Salah) Another difference is Quran is the revelation revealed ad verbum from Allah. As for Hadīth it is revelation revealed paraphrased by The Prophet Muhammad SalaLlahu alayhi wa sallam. And Allah knows best. May Allah grant me and you guidance brother. And guide us to his path.

@user-k229 2 жыл бұрын

@@alTursi05 Astaqfirrullah, Astaqfirrullah. The verse you are quoting is referring to the Quranic revelation only!! Allah swt does NOT endorse any other saying!! 77: 50 In what hadith after this ( Quran) do you believe. Look for me on Yaum ill akhira, I pray that you will have changed your thoughts by then, insha Allah.

@alTursi05 2 жыл бұрын

@@user-k229 what about verse 48 in the same chapter? What is prostration is that?

@Lonelyahk30 3 жыл бұрын

Please just follow the Quran this is confusing and pushes people away from Islam. The religion is suppose to be simple , peace

@asiemmalik736 3 жыл бұрын

Interviewer should really come in better prepared, no real scrutiny or probing. No mention of common link in Hadith, no mention in changes to Hadith content over time, no mention of political influences over Hadith collection and no mention of lack of documented narrations in the prophets era?

@nayemkhan3732 3 жыл бұрын

@younescontemplates2845 3 жыл бұрын

This is almost exactly like what it seems with many Modernists these days!!! If they can't even trust primary Islamic sources, how on Earth are we supposed to even know what Islam is??????

@revivalist355 3 жыл бұрын

@@younescontemplates2845 Simple don't take knowledge from them

@azeez3911 3 жыл бұрын

@@younescontemplates2845 yeah hadiths somehow are the primary source . throw away the quran , am i right 🥱

@phiuzu5487 Жыл бұрын

Going by this line of reasoning, the hadiths such as in "sahih" bukhari that the prophet (nauzubillah) sexually assaulted a woman and told said woman "give yourself to me" is true because it's considered sahih. There major heavy flaws in tradition even tho said tradition has a lot of good. Don't you dare justify the disgusting evil in tradition

@hyrunnisa997 3 жыл бұрын

Loving these videos. I haven't heard of orientalists. Interesting

@AbdulaiMohammedSadat 2 жыл бұрын

this show is awesome

@Jhsgdfikhfsd 4 ай бұрын

Bismillah 🤲 AsselaamAlaykoem Greetings,.. Practice 5 Pillars of Islam,..let all scholar's and researchers do what they like/love to do,..😊,.. People who want,..Peace,.. Tranquility,..Structure,..and want to be Blessed/Guided,..and know the TRUTH,.. PRAY,..Salah/Namaaz,..make Dua after prayer,..ask everything you want/need to know,.. ALLAH SWT will answer,..believe you me,.. Be Proud (healthy pride) Practicing Muslims,..we are already privileged being born Muslim,..be Grateful/Thankful to ALLAH SWT,..for every Breath,.. Ordinary hardworking ,..raising children,..people don't have the time/luxury to examine all hadith etc,.. That's why my advice to ordinary hardworking people,.. Practce 5 Pillars of Islam,..be Truthful,..Respectful and Humble,.. ALLAH HU ALAM,..🍀,..

@aleefmohammed244 3 жыл бұрын

Dr Shabir , can good non Muslims enter heaven ?

@QuranSpeaks 3 жыл бұрын

He addressed that question in this video: kzbin.info/www/bejne/b4eohaBti7ChpLM We'll also be releasing a new video on this question soon.

@aleefmohammed244 3 жыл бұрын

@@QuranSpeaks thank you 🙏

@CaliphForCaliphate 3 жыл бұрын

@@aleefmohammed244 "good" according to whom? how can anyone be good if he associate partner with god? check where you get your morality from? where you get your right, wrong, good, bad get? if no from islam you will be lost

@CaliphForCaliphate 3 жыл бұрын

@@aleefmohammed244 dont listen to this heretic modernist hadith rejecter.

@hassanabdur-rahman1559 3 жыл бұрын

@@CaliphForCaliphate Jews are monotheists and they don't associate partners with God. Also there are some Christians who are monotheists who reject the doctrine of the trinity and they don't associate partners with God.

@ridesandshine6406 3 жыл бұрын

Almost all the hadiths are perverted towards the Prophet. How can you want any part of that.

@irfanyr 3 жыл бұрын

What do you mean by all the hadiths are perverted towards the prophet?

@ridesandshine6406 3 жыл бұрын

@@irfanyr they imply he’s a racist, sexist, and everything else under the sun. Just read them. They’re absolutely disgusting and shameful and should be thrown out as a text. Especially because they have nothing to do with Islam and everything to do with Judaism and Christianity.

@irfanyr 3 жыл бұрын

You mean to say every Hadith and there are thousands, that they portray him that way? Please read them again. The Hadith complement the revelation but the Hadith are not revelation and that is why the science of Hadith is there to weed out the ones which are are true

@sambayanzai Ай бұрын

I’m a Muslim but I reverted back to true Islam which is Quran alone

@hp6308 3 жыл бұрын

Trying to out a wild fire 🔥🔥

@smguess361 Жыл бұрын

Is the orientalist who does not believe in God and His Messenger and does not master the Arabic language a source from which we take our religion?

@CrazyBeams1 Жыл бұрын

The Quran itsself commands us all to think, we should never reject any real knowledge just because of a source.

@Think_pls 3 жыл бұрын

If you you put your trust in the scholars, or apologist, then get ready for filtered information, all red flags will be removed, then your at there mercy, that's how all religions thrive, think please, thank you

@iansaliheen110 3 жыл бұрын

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

@ridesandshine6406 3 жыл бұрын

The question is... why you don’t study the Quran instead of the fabricated hadiths!?!

@oaia-mcn-429 3 жыл бұрын

Because he's a scholar...not you

@ridesandshine6406 3 жыл бұрын

@@oaia-mcn-429 lol 😂 That’s the most ignorant thing I’ve ever read. Hadiths are fake and fabricated. All you need is Quran.

@oaia-mcn-429 3 жыл бұрын

@@ridesandshine6406 you triggered? Seems I strike a nerve 🤣 Way of transmitting hadith is the same as transmitting the Quran If hadiths are fabricated then so is the Quran end of story you closet atheist 😂

@ridesandshine6406 3 жыл бұрын

@@oaia-mcn-429 Allah says in the Quran that the Quran is the only hadith. But you wouldn’t know that because you don’t read it or understand it. May Allah guide you.

@oaia-mcn-429 3 жыл бұрын

@@ridesandshine6406 lol O believers! Obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. Should you disagree on anything, then refer it to Allah and His Messenger, if you ˹truly˺ believe in Allah and the Last Day. This is the best and fairest resolution.

@Mr-in3mv 3 жыл бұрын

Unbelievable

@esfanintan 3 жыл бұрын

the way you talk Hadith is as though Prophet Muhammad is more important than God himself. you have the Quran that is the word of God then why bother what his prophet says.

@bobyford8051 3 жыл бұрын

because he is the role model on how to be a proper muslims. His actions, words, manners are what muslims should follow. He was set as an example. It's obvious

@josipcolic5304 3 жыл бұрын

1. Allah ordered in Quran to follow the prophet. 2. Prophet and his companions knew the meanings of the Quran better than you do

@esfanintan 3 жыл бұрын

@@josipcolic5304 I am not questioning the knowledge of the Prophet and his companion and I understand that God tells us in Quran to follow the prophet. What I am saying is that we do not know the authenticity of the Hadith which has been collected for may years by many people through word of mouth. these are all stories past on by one person to another or many people and by the time we receive them it may not even be remotely similar to what the original person uttered. Hadith and stories about the the prophet saying and doing are not all reliable. people change stories to benefit their own agenda.

@josipcolic5304 3 жыл бұрын

@@esfanintan, the Quran is transfered also by the same people in the same manner

@esfanintan 3 жыл бұрын

@@josipcolic5304 It very well may be but Allah promised he would protect the Quran from corruption. He never promised that about the Hadith. All I am saying one must take Hadith with the grain of salt since they are not protected by Allah. One source like Quran is better than 10000 Hadith.

@almulakimaalimalriadiat9068 3 жыл бұрын

This is saddening.... what we have of our beloved prophet then? Its like the image we holding on to so dearly is dissipating. saddening...

@Hamza000h 3 жыл бұрын

This is untrue. Dr Shabir clearly says most of the authentic hadith are authentic, only a few went through the seive

@almulakimaalimalriadiat9068 3 жыл бұрын

@@Hamza000h thank you!!! I would listen more carefully.

@dontgetmewrong4317 3 жыл бұрын

Don't listen to shabir. He is misguided and will misguidee others.

@Hamza000h 3 жыл бұрын

@@dontgetmewrong4317 oh be quiet. Everyone is misguided other than your little wahabbi sect?? Grow up and open your eyes

@revivalist355 3 жыл бұрын

@@Hamza000h and who on earth is he to determine which is authentic and which is not

@carolnoble4615 11 ай бұрын

I don't know what Islam says about Hadith but I do know when I look at this man's eyes I would never trust him. They say the eyes are the windows of the soul and I can say that many people's eyes have shown me who is the most untrustworthy. It is rare that I have been wrong. I am sorry, but I truly do not think this man here can be trusted at all.

@MaryamMaqdisi 2 ай бұрын

What if your gut is just racist. Your reaction proves nothing.