Is Hip Resurfacing Surgery Better Than Total Hip Replacement Surgery?

[@bobmilo2786]

Excellent video. I had a resurfacing done at the age of 43. The other hip underwent a resurfacing at age 52. Age 60 is right around the corner. I have not had any issues over the years and glad that I underwent the resurfacing. Opinions of physicians are just that. The first doctor I went to said I needed a new hip but had to wait because I was to young. The second doctors I went to looked at me like I had an eyeball in the middle of my head. The second doctor was a good surgeon but basically said he didn't do resurfacing because they don't last. The first two doctors were 100% WRONG!!!! They were both older and didn't want to learn something new. I found the third doctor in the Chicagoland area. When I first found him I was skeptical because he wad in his 30's at the time. I opted to go with his because of his thorough explaination. I feel n like I hit the lottery when I met him. He performed both of my procedures about 9 years apart. The first one was relatively smooth. The second one I experienced a much faster recovery, likely because he had more procedures under his belt. Long story, short. Do lots of research and don't believe just any doctor. They are not all equal. Additionally check with younger doctors because they are more likely to be knowledgeable of newer procedures. Wishing everyone well on their hip journey. 🙏

[@salhernandez3910]

Who were the doctors in the Chicagoland area? I have seen dr Shane no and Jorge charla Please keep me updated

[@goChina33]

Crystal clear, articulate, informative thank you soooooo much for sharing ! How I wish I was in your area!❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@epmanualphysicaltherapy]

Hi Jen Yu! ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ Thank you so much for your support!! We truly appreciate you! 🙌🏽

[@gazzar2722]

What about Metal Ions, it is suppose to be bad for your kidneys, can you let me know if this is true

[@elmarthost233]

Super informative! Had my first BHR two years ago, the second 10 weeks ago done in Germany, am 57 years and average sportive, best decisions ever, only advice to "potentials": don't wait too long and use your potential "second" life! All, stay healthy!

[@epmanualphysicaltherapy]

Hey @elmarthost233, it's great that you've been able to get your 2nd life now with your new hips!! We hope they help keep you active for the rest of your life!!!

[@Iwoasasaned]

May I ask you where you had the surgery? This might be my route in the not so far future and I am looking for a good surgeon here in southern Germany.

[@salvadorsepulveda6415]

Thank for this insight to hip replacement. Good information 👍 Blessings 🙏

[@PianoMatronNeeNee]

Excellent video! You covered all my questions. I thank you so much!

[@epmanualphysicaltherapy]

YAYYYYYYY!!!!!! This is fantastic to hear @pianomatronneenee!!!! Thank you for letting us know this was helpful for you!!!!

[@sheiladonofrio7933]

I recently had hip resurfacing 3 months ago with Dr.Gross in SC. Best thing I ever did. Waiting a ywar to recover and get the other hip done.unfortunately, I found out I have osteopenia thanks to Dr. Gross ordering a bone density. I just turned 62. Bones need to be strong for this surgery.

[@lmh8642]

does osteopenia disqualify you as a hip resurfacing candidate?

[@justabill5780]

I'm 51 and I had a total hip replacement 5 years ago. I'm a martial artist and runner so I originally asked about resurfacing. My surgeon said he would do a resurfacing but recommended a Total Hip, instead. Mostly because of the Metal-on-Metal problems that have been reported. While it is "uncommon" to have such reactions, I didn't feel it was worth the risk.

[@aaronkindig8016]

How was your recovery? And is your practice still going well? Low kicks I assume. I'm going through PT for hip arthritis might need replacement if it doesn't help.

[@justabill5780]

@@aaronkindig8016 : My recovery has been astounding! Low kicks? Sure, but also head kicks and everything in between. I also run 5-6 miles at least two days a week and do lots of weightlifting. I weigh about 190lbs (6' tall) and do weighted bridges with 600lbs (3 sets of 12).

[@aaronkindig8016]

@@justabill5780 Great to hear. What materials did they use and which approach? I read Ceramic on Poly, anterior approach would be best for continued martial arts. Thanks

[@justabill5780]

@@aaronkindig8016 : They used the Zimmer-Biomet Taperloc Microplasty. With Titanium stem and socket, Cobalt-Chrome ball with Highly Crosslinked Polyethylene liner. Direct Anterior approach. If KZbin would let me, I'd post the X-Ray.

[@kirsten7152]

Wow I just learned the best surgeon in the world for hip resurfacing is located in my city of Columbia, SC.

[@MrPhoenix803]

Midlands Ortho?? My husbands Dr Fowble his surgery is scheduled is 7/19 for his resurfacing at 47.

[@kirsten7152]

@@MrPhoenix803 I think it’s Dr. Gross at Midlands.

[@munkki2700]

De Smet and ceramic resurfacing. Hip feels now amazing 👍

[@AG-hy5pp]

Did you have ceramic on ceramic ? Did you go to Belgium to have done? Im interested

[@munkki2700]

@@AG-hy5pp yes. He knows what he is doing. After 6 weeks of bilateral CoC no crutches and walking nicely, now 6 km per day. No pain. Light weights on gym for leg exercises.

[@rjb7569]

Is there a reason that an older guy, like myself (71), could not get a resurfacing done, rather than hip replacement? Very physically active with sports until hip acted up 2 years back. Would like to play softball, golf and be totally physically active again, working on the house, etc. Losing mobility is unacceptable. (I know you've already answered some of this in the vid).

[@scyven1]

Osteopenia and osteoporosis for one and the data we currently have suggests the THA is better for those 65-70 and above.

[@rjb7569]

​@@scyven1 Thank you for the reply.

[@munkki2700]

Check with good resurfacing doctor if you are a candidate (send xrays to him)

[@biamarcu4389]

@@munkki2700 Hello! how are you now?? can you squat?? doing gym?? did it hurt a lot after the surgery?🥲i will do the recerf in this month! thank you

[@magicunicorn6535]

I'm in the same boat. I'm almost 75. I rollerblade in the streets, ride mountain bikes, and used to ski and ride horses. I just want to be able to keep doing all those things, and to be able to survive the inevitable occasional falls associated with them. My hip is making it so I can't stand up straight anymore -- back hurts and walking is getting difficult. 3/4 of my body still feels like it's 40 years old; the right leg feels like it's 85. VERY annoying!! I also hate the idea of having to wait a whole year before returning to high activity. I want to heal ASAP!

[@agnescrentsil3838]

Doc do you have a clinic in Dallas? Or know of a Chiropractor doctor with the same philosophy as you in Dallas? I like the idea of focusing on the root cause of muscle imbalance. Thanks

[@ms.sharon.7581]

Is the recuperation and pain the same as a total hip replacement? I’m 8 wks post op. and doing well and back to work.

[@epmanualphysicaltherapy]

Hey Ms. Sharon, typically recuperation and pain tends to be less for a resurfacing compared to a hip replacement. It varies from individual to individual though. Congratulations on getting back to work!

[@robinshepard4571]

Thank you 🌎💫🇺🇸

[@epmanualphysicaltherapy]

Hi Robin! 👋 You are very welcome! 🧡

[@christopheclugston]

Only resurfacing allows pro level sports, running, sky diving martial arts. Reality is that few surgeons have the skill and experience for hr. You need a surgeon with over a thousand surgeries not a sometime thing. In the USA the best are Su, Pritchett, and Gross. Only if they say a hr is not for you would it be true to do a thr

[@AEVMU]

Brooks too. Has over 4k and been doing them longer than most. His surgical approach is also beneficial for patients who also present with lower back pain.

[@scyven1]

The market is not there, it’s meant for younger folks and let’s face it not that many people under 55-60 need joint reconstruction…also the surgery takes approximately 2x the time and costs the same as THA so docs make half the amount. I’m a physical therapist in Southern California, and I actually need replacement at the age of 41 and I am in contact with Dr. Su, Gross, Pritchett, Calander and Ball. All of the surgeons except Dr.Ball I believe have done >1000. All of them except Pritchett perform the Birmingham hip aka metal on metal. Pritchett uses a cup with cross linked poly surface with metal ball with a ceramic coating I believe. I’m guessing the reason is to cut down on the chance of metalosis…but less data on his prosthesis choice but the theory on why he uses that combo is sound. I want to continue martial arts, working out, some running and biking…some THA people do return to running but less compared to resurfacing. Chances are I’ll need a THA at some point, it’s better going from resurfacing to THA than a THA to a revision, longer stem prosthesis required usually.

[@christopheclugston]

@@scyven1 wrong, it's USA orthopedic propaganda for thr. The Mafia insurance control doesn't exist in other countries. And costs are far lower. The commentary you had doesn't change what I stated, few surgeons have the skill. Lots of Cessna pilots not many F18 fighter pilots, get it?

[@scyven1]

@@christopheclugston I agree with you largely, rather confused about the aggressive nature of the response though haha…ur 100% right not many skilled surgeons perform in the US, which is why as a socal resident I’m looking in Seattle, New York and South Carolina…I hate insurance companies as I deal with a lot of them (they suck)I’m not 100% convinced it’s just down to them why the surgery is not more popular. I really do think the economics I stated is a major factor, surgeons don’t want to get paid 1/2 the amount a year for a more complex surgery.

[@christopheclugston]

@@scyven1 Gross and pritchett charge the same for resurfacing as they do thr, it's about being an elite surgeon to them