Is it possible to prove the birth of 12th Imam using chain-based methodology? | Sayyid Kamal Hayderi

[@Al-Islaah]

Some of the viewers having emotional bias have been writing to us suggesting that this video of Ayyatullah Sayyid Kamaal has been deliberately cut at the end. This is a completely false allegation. We have not cut or edited the original video of Ayatullah Sayyid Kamaal or tampered with it in any way. We have simply added subtitles to it containing an accurate English translation undertaken by our team of professionals working at the translation wing of what the learned Sayyid has said in Arabic. Other than that we have not done anything, and we have not cut out anything the Sayyid has said in his original video on his channel. We resent the false accusations and invite those who doubt us to view the original clip which is available on Ayatullah Sayyid Kamaal al Haidari's official channel at the following link: kzbin.info/www/bejne/moCkpqiwn5qgabs You will be able to clearly see that we have taken the clip exactly as it appears on this official channel and presented it with English Subtitles without modifying its length or cutting out any parts. We would advise such accussers to at least do some home work and preliminary due diligence before raising baseless and unfounded accusations. We hope rest of the fair and knowledgeable members will see through any such accusations circulating around such videos and against our way of working without any prejudices. Shukran

[@daodwali3654]

Brother your channel deserves a million times the views. But Allah is watching your work. May Allah bless you all

[@smiqdad]

Your channel has given me so much hope. I had been shunned due to my questions on Shia beliefs I was raised on as I saw major contradictions between them and the Quran. It is sad to see people who claim to be the followers of the one who welcomed questions from the pulpit to discourage a critical examination of the fundamental beliefs in the shia community. I often feel that the Shias today are hiding behind the Grandeur of Imam Ali (a.s) and the Martyrdom of Imam Hussain (a.s).

[@aliirtiza4619]

Basically he is not castig doubt on the birth of the Imam, but showing the inadequacy of the methods used by a few Shia scholars. You are misusing an example to promote your own sinister views.

[@abdulrafaykhan5252]

JazakALLAH

[@rahildean8280]

When I accepted Shiaii Belief system after leading a Sunni life since birth, I'm quite shocked to the amount of falsified stories introduced in the religion by the Ghulaat.

[@RRiaz-np4lr]

Thanks again. Very informative.

[@ArslanMaLLlik]

Kash yh chanel urdu me kuch translate kr deta , mery jaisy bandy ki zindgi hi badal jati

[@ShahidHussain-qg7ob]

Please request...this programme should start...In Urdu language.

[@PlayGuy200]

So why are u stull referring to him as a hujjah?

[@ayeshajan899]

Pls post some more videos with English subtitles.

[@aliirtiza4619]

Why don't you mention that Syed Kamal al-Hayderi does not consider the chain-based methodology to be adequate?

[@nooral-firdaus7144]

So, in a nutshell: It is not possible to prove the birth of the 12th Imam, right?

[@Al-Islaah]

The scholar has demonstrated how it cannot be proved using the Manhaje Sanadi (Chain Based Methodology) that is followed in Ilmur Rijaal.

[@mutazilite-n6i]

The only way to prove his existence is reason. That's it... 😂