Is Music Haram in Islam?

#islam #music
I hope you learned something from this video. It is an Ijma or consensus in Islam that music is haram and anyone who argues it is halal would be doing so with their desires as all the evidences point towards its impermissibility.
Here is the video that explains all the scholars in the last 14 centuries that have stated the consensus among the ummah: • Music | Difference of ...
It also explains the "differences of opinion" in detail
Insha Allah replace music with nasheed and Quran, poetry is good as well and eventually you will not even care about music anymore and realise how bad it is and how dumb it is
Follow: / farhanahmedzia
Discord: / discord

[@muslimguts]

👤: As-salamu alaykum Brother/Sister Did you do zikr today? 👤: No!? Make sure you read with your heart ❤ 👤: Ok, let's go it will take 1-3 minutes. 📿Astagfirullah ×5 (أَسْتَغْفِرُ اللَّهَ) 📿Subhan Allah ×5 (سبحان الله) 📿Alhamdulilah ×5 (الحمد لله) 📿La ilah illa Allah ×3 (لا إله إلا الله) 📿Subhan Allah hi wa bi hamdi hi ×3 (سُبْحَانَ اللّهِ وَ بِحَمْدِهِ) 📿Subhan Allah al adheem ×3 (سبحان الله العظيم) 📿Allah huma ini asaluka al jannah ×7 (اللَّهُمَّ إِنِّي أَسْئَلُكَ الجَنّةُ) 📿Allah huma ajarni mina naar ×7 (اَللَّهُم أَجِرْنِي مِنَ النَّارِ) 📿Allahummaghfir lil muslimina wal muslimati wal mu'minina wal mu'minati x1 (اَللَّهُمَّ اغْفِرْ لِلْمُسْلِمِيْنَ وَالْمُسْلِمَاتِ، وَالْمُؤْمِنِيْنَ وَالْمُؤْمِنَاتِ اْلأَحْيَاءِ مِنْهُمْ وَاْلأَمْوَاتِ) Well done! (أحسنت!) InshaAllah you will be rewarded spread for good deeds (وإن شاء الله لك الأجر في نشر الخير.) Farhan Mind Pinning This For Good Deeds?

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

JazakAllah Khair brother - I made dhikr just now because of your comment

[@faris.m17]

Love for music and the Love for the Qur'an cannot fit in the same heart.

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Exactly - well said

[@Fckterrorism-vr2kq]

If all music is degenerate for you then you have only tried to seek out degenerate music.

[@keeperkeeper1510]

Exactly

[@cyberyousef7519]

great video, this channel will grow inshallah my advice to the people who deny the prohibition of music and say theyy wont stop it, is to at least listen to music without sharing it to othes or make what is haram halal

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

JazakAllah Khair brother, Insha Allah. Definitely - there is a huge difference in striving privately and sinning publicly - which in its turn multiplies the sin and itself is an even bigger sin

[@Hamza_Zeb_Khan]

According to many Muslim, music with no gossip, haram, nutidity, bad talk etc is halal but today's Muslim(child, mother, sister, son etc) is also listening to haram Music😢

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Yea but there is strong evidence according to Rasool Allah ﷺ, the Sahaba, and the 4 imams - all music is haram even with clean lyrics Only Quran, nasheed and poetry are halal without musical instruments

[@Hamza_Zeb_Khan]

I meant according to many Muslims I also don't even consider any type of music 'halal' ​@@FarhanAhmedZia

[@DifficultyEnjoyer]

@@FarhanAhmedZiai thought that poetry without instruments is halal? Correct me please

[@EarCandyContraption]

SubhanAllah, even some nasheeds nowadays teeter on the edge of haram with all the editing softwares freely available. Drum remixes, pitching up/down, reverb, etc. If you're seeing this kind of problem already purported in the ummah, just imagine how limitless the haram music's effects can be on the heart & mind of the believer.

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Yea exactly - we have to be careful, unfortunately music is a drug that many Muslims are addicted to and it causes you to forget the Quran and the remembrance of Allah. SubhanAllah these people are copying the kuffar and have hifz more songs than Quran

[@SonDiegoJr1]

Mashallah great one.

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

JazakAllah Khair brother

[@Servant.Of.TheMost-Merciful]

Very good video brother❤

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

JazakAllah Khair brother - may Allah guide people away from music and May the strive hard to remove this filth from their lives for the sake of Allah - it was easy for me to quit music because I never care about it even when I was very jahil - some things are easier for people to give up and some things are very hard for people to give up

[@DawahLogic]

Allahu akbar

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Allahu Akbar

[@Twin_cia]

does the sin depend what type of music, yes I understand music is haram but if your listening to music that mocks god and religion it’s a major sin but if it’s something like instrumental it’s a minor sin

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Yes there are different degrees of haram, that is correct But all music and musical instruments are still Haram

[@Seanain_O_hEarchai]

@@FarhanAhmedZiawould you guys be allowed to listen to Gregorian chant or some other forms of Catholic non-instrumental music?

[@IliyaMorady]

​@@Seanain_O_hEarchaiwe probably are but we should consider what is music and what's rhythm and what's tone

[@yusufblaik2599]

May Allah SWT protect us and forgive us all Allahumma Ameen BarakAllah feek

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Ameen

[@yoshitaxfraudosaurus]

What if its just instrumental

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Musical instruments are haram by consensus Sometimes I’m with people and they play music - I advise to just play a vocals only version of the song instead if it has clean lyrics and is closer to poetry than modern day music

[@shahsaudzamaan]

Keep it up Allahumma barik

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

JazakAllah Khair akhi, I will

[@sayankabir7958]

informative video as always. may Allah bless you. also one suggestion, rather than adding these stock photos, you may make these videos with your video speaking and add the references to the screen. you may refer to mohammedalsaed's yt channel, his video editing style is very engaging

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

JazakAllah Khair brother, I will take a look at your recommendation Insha Allah

[@user-qu1lr7ys2e]

بارك الله فيك. ازيد بعض البدائل: القرآن الكريم الاناشيد الشعر البودكاست

[@Mohamed-kq2mj]

The hadith I know said ما يرن وما يطن So guitars and anything alike, and anything that rings is haram. I know that the flutes being haram is true because flutes heighten your sexual desires. Most of the music nowadays is completely different from the times before, they are manufactured by machines that do impossible sounds and are manufactured for the highest dopamine possible, which causes addiction throwing any bass or phonk or electric songs away. I turn off music while playing games because I don't want unnecessary sins. I don't know about using musical instruments for sound effects, but sound effects are usually noise like cracking, swishing or whatever. Zakir Naik has stated some hadith that says that daff and tambourine are allowed on certain occasion like eid. So generally most musical instruments are haram, except for maybe the daff and tambourine. Anything else that falls under ما يرن وما يطن

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

There is a video that deep dives the topic with ustadh Abdurrahman Hassan you can watch he discusses it in detail with all the evidences

[@infinitebeast5517]

Even if someone would argue that musical instruments are not haram the problem today and for most of time is that the majority of music usually has themes and lyrics that promote haram actions, relationships, etc. So by that most music would be off the table anyways. And I've noticed a lot of the people that ask these question will listen to that music without thinking about this side of it

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Yea the discussions of the scholars were from the last 14 centuries saying it’s haram. Music in todays time has devolved so much, even al ghazali and ibn hazm would say it’s haram now

[@BlondBarely]

Assalam alaikum brother, i just have question, as we know the prophet and the sahaba were under the flag of islam, not the flag of sunni or shia islam, so why does people nowadays call theirselfs shia and sunni, shouldn't we just be muslim?

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Because shia curse the sahaba and we need to differentiate ourselves from them and have clear understandings what we believe is different and only follows the Sunnah

[@BlondBarely]

@@FarhanAhmedZia Oh, now i get it, our shiekh never told us that, thank you

[@ShrekGKSPrivacy]

Mandem went straight to the point. Well done.

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

JazakAllah Khair akhi

[@idontknow1630]

dont force the slang ur not that guy 😭

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

@@idontknow1630 u talking to me or the guy who said mandem?

[@ShrekGKSPrivacy]

@@FarhanAhmedZia Me. You did not say any slangs.

[@daniakhiradfunsisters230]

We can listen to acapella/ only vocals songs ,right?

[@Bolt305]

As long as there’s no haram in the lyrics

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Singing is usually related to music and most singing is singing of songs that have music If it’s poetry or nasheed it’s fine But generally singing nowadays is of songs which comes under idle talk and is related with music There are some Pakistani singers whose songs are like beautiful poetry. I play them with vocals only because the lyrics are beautiful

[@cate_enthusiast]

ive been struggling against music, this ruling should be publicized to all ignorant muslims in shaa allah

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Insha Allah - May Allah make it easy for you - if you still need a bit of music - keep trying nasheeds and Quran - listening to the vocals only over time will make you less interested in the beats playing in music nowadays - it did for me. Insha Allah keep striving.

[@Fansha_Institute]

I have 1 question, How about halal bi halal which recites shalawat with drums and sticks, is it haram to use drums when reciting shalawat?

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Yea generally all musical instruments are haram - there might be more detailed and complex answers in Fiqh I’m not aware of - I’m a jahil and leave that which I have doubt on. From what I’ve seen so far all instruments are haram.

[@sheferey]

jazakullahu khairan

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Thank you, JazakAllah Khair

[@laulaksiddique6160]

Haram is not by interpretation. Haram is very clearly stated in the Quran, does not need interpretation.

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Do you know what fiqh is? Lmao smoking is not mentioned as haram in the Quran - doesn’t mean it’s not haram - that’s not how studying the deen works

[@k00lmoh]

Most tafsir include singing along side music, does singing lawful lyrics change anything or is it still not halal?

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

There’s a video podcast by ustadh Abdur Rahman Hassan titled “is music haram” he goes in detail the types of singing etc allowed and what’s haram Generally speaking even if the lyrics are halal singing in a song like melody is haram and only poetry is Halal

[@alexanderkaminski]

Hadith is not authentic and Imam Shafi said it’s makrooh. I don’t want to explain here why did Bukhari put this hadith in his work, but to say it short, he wanted to proof that wine is haram. And BTW why are you ignoring all hadith that say music is halal? Also those Quranic verses are overinterpreted, everything can be idle talk or waste of time and singing is considered as permissible by most of scholars (excluding hanafis)

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

These are Tafsir of ibn kathir and as sadi which are widely accepted Send the source of Shaf’i saying it’s makrooh Send the Hadith that say music are halal

[@alexanderkaminski]

@@FarhanAhmedZia Sahih Bukhari 952 Narrated Aisha: Abu Bakr came to my house while two small Ansari girls were singing beside me the stories of the Ansar concerning the Day of Buath. And they were not singers. Abu Bakr said protestingly, "Musical instruments of Satan in the house of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) !" It happened on the `Id day and Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "O Abu Bakr! There is an `Id for every nation and this is our `Id." I know that many people say it’s because of the Id. But what does it even mean? Music is haram, but halal on Id? If musical instruments came from Shaytan (according to Abu Bakr), why did Prophet pbuh let people play it even sometimes? Another hadith: Sahih Bukhari 4001 Narrated Ar-Rubai bint Muauwidh: The Prophet (ﷺ) came to me the night my marriage was consummated and sat down on my bed as you (the sub-narrator) are sitting now, and small girls were beating the tambourine and singing in lamentation of my father who had been killed on the day of the battle of Badr. Then one of the girls said, "There is a Prophet amongst us who knows what will happen tomorrow." The Prophet (ﷺ) said (to her)," Do not say this, but go on saying what you have spoken before." It didn’t happen during Id, but Prophet still didn’t forbid them to sing and play musical instruments. If certain action was haram, Prophet would surely condemn it. If we are talking about the fours Imams and music, opinions are very contradictory. You used a source which said that all fours Imams forbade music, but Ibrahim ash-Shashi and Al Mawardi (who lived before Ibn Taymiyya) said that Imam Shafi and Malik permitted music. I tried to get deeper into the research and I found only one source which quotes imam Shafis words (aadaabul qadaa) and it says that he declared it makrooh. Imam Ahmad also said music is makrooh, here we’ve got a source directly from his son: Imam Ahmad's son, Abdullah, asked his father about music. His father said, "It grows hypocrisy within one's heart and I dislike it." Also you talked only about two scholars which permitted music, there were many more. For example: Ibn Daqeeq, Izz al-Din ibn Abd al-Salam, Abdul Ghani al-Nablusi, Ibn Qutaybah, al-Maqdisi, al Dhahabi, Abu Talib al-Makki, Ibn al-Arabi al-Maliki and Imam al-Shawkani.

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

If you think Ibn Al-Arabi is a good scholar to take views from, your whole argument goes in the bin and it’s clear you are following your desires. Also yes surprisingly the only times the music was allowed was exceptions with only women on exclusively celebratory days. I’m pretty sure the scholars mention these exceptions in detail. But again they are exceptions and not the rule of what is common everyday. Also the source you quoted from Imam Ahmad is incomplete, I used that same quote in the video which goes on to say Imam Ahmad reference Imam Malik saying only fasiqs listen to music. You also still didn’t send the source of where Imam Shaf’i says it’s makruh - you just referenced who said it and what he said - send the source that it’s from so I can check and reference the source for myself

[@alexanderkaminski]

@@FarhanAhmedZia What’s wrong with Abu Bakr ibn Al-Arabi? He was a student of Al Ghazali and followed Maliki school. The second hadith says that music was played by women not during the Id. This argument is pretty weird considering that if musical instruments are really from shaytan, why would they be used even if some occasions. Quote is complete, the part of Imam Malik’s words is not part of the quote. Imam Ahmad's son, Abdullah, asked his father about music. His father said, "It grows hypocrisy within one's heart and I dislike it." And, then he said Imam Maliks quote that only fusooq (astray) do it. It doesn’t change the fact that Imam Ahmad said „I dislike it” he didn’t say that it’s prohibited. My bad, here is the view from Imam shafi. It was mostly used by people who tried to proof that music is haram: In the book, Aadaabul Qadaa, Ash-Shaafi’ee is reported as saying, “Verily, song is loathsome [makrooh]; it resembles the false and vain thing [al-baatil]. The one who partakes of it frequently is an incompetent fool whose testimony is to be rejected.” The problem is we don’t now whether he’s talking about music or singing. He still said it’s makrooh.

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Ok brother I will study this and ask a brother I know who is knowledgable in fiqh what he knows

[@gergelymagyarosi9285]

It's very hard for an outsider to comprehend the absence of Islamic music, even more religious music. I always though there may be some loopholes. Like the singing of a muezzin.

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

There’s plenty of nasheeds to fill the void - you grow to like them more than music lol If I hear music now it sounds garbage and I just want nasheeds instead

[@ShrekGKSPrivacy]

Also with the sources involved in this video, does this mean singing is also haram?

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Singing is usually related to music and most singing is singing of songs that have music If it’s poetry or nasheed it’s fine But generally singing nowadays is of songs which comes under idle talk and is related with music

[@ShrekGKSPrivacy]

@@FarhanAhmedZia hmm. Interesting explanation.

[@gothfather8741]

Vocals alone can also generate the same musical notes as instruments and acapella can have the same effect as instrumental music. Think about it for a minute. It is not music or its instruments that are addictive and bad but the fact that people have weak minds and are susceptible to being addicted...and no it's not the same as drugs. I am able to listen to music, enjoy it and then shut it out of my mind when I am done and move on to other activities. I don't have songs stuck in my brain all day long. Mohamed likely saw people drinking to excess, fornicating with prostitutes, while wearing silk and listening and dancing to music and he thought the combination of all these things were bad...and so decided to ban all these things; basically throwing the baby out with the bathwater. I will not tell you how to live your life and people are free to make their own choices, but I am just respectfully stating my opinion on the matter.

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

This is a cope

[@gothfather8741]

​​@@FarhanAhmedZiaI only speak the truth. There's no reason to have to "cope". Take care.

[@armand9120]

​@FarhanAhmedZia How is your whole armchair psychology section in the video not a cope? Music does this and that but don't expect me to provide any evidence!

[@LemonKalao]

Does nasheed count as music?

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

No. Nasheeds are halal and not the same as music

[@LemonKalao]

@@FarhanAhmedZia ty

[@sincereman6939]

But Nasheeds are singing..

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

No it’s not the same

[@haidernaeemmalana8601]

very well said, unfortunately i disagree. music is an art form. if it was so bad, the quran wouldve mentioned it a bit more. everything else sounds exactly like the kind of killjoy Islamists somehow seem proud of. One should be careful where religion ends and cults start. If music is wrong, may Allah guide my heart away from it. Ameen

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

If you disagree, you are disagreeing with the sahaba, all 4 schools of thought and the imams. The majority consensus of the ulama of the Ummah from every century of Islam. If you still disagree, then if anything, you prove the Prophet ﷺ and his Hadith true that in the future people will come and say music is lawful. Just because something is an art form doesn’t make it right or wrong. Movies and modelling, even nudity to an extent can be seen as an art form. Whether or not they are art has nothing to do with their permissibility. May Allah guide you to the truth, Ameen.

[@idontknow1630]

bro really said 'Despite being presented with evidences from the Qur'an and Sunnah, I still think music is permissible'. Who are you for your opinion to be taken over the four imams who dedicated their whole lives in studying the deen? I'm pretty sure they knew what they were talking about, unlike some liberal like yourself. Companions of the prophet (saws), such as Abdullah ibn Mas'ud also made it clear music is not lawful in Islam, which the brother covered in the video. Stop trying to make the haram, halal. May Allah guide you

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

@@idontknow1630 exactly lmaoo

[@haidernaeemmalana8601]

@@FarhanAhmedZiai do not see movies as a wrong. Niether modelling. being sexual outside of the privacy of your home is strictly wrong, whether that is in a movie, or in modelling or in nudity.

[@haidernaeemmalana8601]

@@idontknow1630​​⁠you are right. i only have two weak rebuttals. firstly, my own heart. i am liberal and commit many sins, but my conscience tells me to repent from them, wven the lighter ones. for music, i do not feel the same way. For a lot of music i actually feel spiritually closer to God. so confused in that way. also second issue. We didnt meet any companion of the prophet ourselves. we are being told this by people who cant even agree who is right about history sunnis or shias. somehow they are 100% accurate on quotes 300 years later. i am sunni but sunnis seem to have a history of "simplifying the truth" for the sake of convenience and often adding thier own whims for branding purposes. If the quran said "singing" it could just said singing, im sure there were words for singing back in the day. We didnt need an onslaught of NOT PROPHETS offering thier advice via transmission 300 years or so later. Sorry but i have little trust on the hadith compilations because of the many inconsistencies. Sahaba are better than me but are a million levels lower than the prophet and they never come even remotelt close to a prophet and we should put them in thier own place. Ahadith are good where valid but they are nothing compared to the Quran because the Quran was from Allah and Ahadith are just a collection of saying from some guy. mind you the "Sahih" Ahadith collection were not taken seriously and ridiculed by the people of the time they were published and had no significance for at least another 100-200 years after publishing. Imams are not Gods. Imam Malik, Hanbal, Shafi, Hanif, Bukhari and Muslim were not Gods or Prophets and thier written collections are not safeguarded by Allah for authenticity like the Quran. They are just like a university thesis. i didnt even mention politcal pressure to bend religious edicts and translation issues from the HEAVIEST language on the Earth (Arabic) and other languages of the later Islamic empire (persian and Urdu)

[@KalpYedi]

Bro, now there's a channel called "testify" too, which lies about Issa's (ra) crucifixion. If you can refute him and clarify the truth. May Allah bless you.

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Haha JazakAllah Khair- you are now the 2nd person asking me to refute him. I will check it out and probably make one Insha Allah

[@KalpYedi]

@@FarhanAhmedZia insha'Allah, may Allah help you in your work and in your Da'wah, brother. Thank you

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Just uploaded a vid refuting one of Testify’s vids now

[@Ahmedadvemtures125]

Mmm Where is the video on child marriage?

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

I have everything ready just waiting for a knowledgeable brother I know irl who has been studying fiqh for years to get me a response on something very specific but everything else is done It will be uploaded either next or the video after the next one Insha Allah

[@Ahmedadvemtures125]

@@FarhanAhmedZia Could I help?

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Nah Allg I have everything already probably more than anyone has online because I’ve known this topic for years- if u want to send anything anytime DM me on twitter @FarhanAhmedZia

[@Ahmedadvemtures125]

@@FarhanAhmedZia Kk

[@Historylover140]

Mashallah, can you also explain the Aisha marriage?

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Definitely, will be one of my next videos if it’s not the very next one Insha Allah

[@infinitebeast5517]

There is also a fantastic video made by Fullmetal theist that I highly recommend.

[@Fckterrorism-vr2kq]

@@FarhanAhmedZia Brother can you also explain these? ▶(1) Aishah replied, "I used to wash it (semen) off the clothes of Allah's Messenger and he would go for the prayer while water spots (semen) were still visible" [Sahih al-Bukhari 230] ▶(2)Narrated `Aisha: "The Prophet used to lean on my lap and recite Qur'an while I was in menses" [Sahih al-Bukhari 297] ▶(3) Narrated Aisha, Ummul Mu'minin: "The Prophet () used to kiss her and suck her tongue when he was fasting." [Sunan Abi Dawud 2386] ▶(4) A person stayed in the house of A'isha and in the morning began to wash his garment. A'isha said: In case you saw it (i. e. drop of semen), it would have served the purpose (of purifying the garment) if you had simply washed that spot; and in case you did not see it, it would have been enough to sprinkle water around it, for when I saw that on the garment of the Messenger of Allah (). I simply scraped it off and he offered prayer, while putting that on [Sahih Muslim 288a] ▶(5)Aishah narrated: "The Messenger of Allah married me when I was six, and consummated the marriage with me when I was nine, and I used to play with dolls." [Sahih al-Bukhari 230] ▶(6) "A guest came and stayed with 'Aishah, and she ordered that he be given a yellow blanket of hers. He had a nocturnal emission on it, and he felt too shy to send it back to send it back to her when it had the traces of that emission on it, so he dipped it in water and then sent it to her. 'Aishah said: 'Why did he spoil our garment? It would have been sufficient for him to scrape it off with his finger. I often scraped it (semen) from the garment of the Messenger of Allah with my finger.' Sunan Ibn Majah 538] ▶(7) Aishah said : "I used to wash the semen off the clothes of the Prophet and even then I used to notice one or more spots on them" [Sahih al-Bukhari 232] ▶(8) Aishah said: "Semen used to get on the garment of the Messenger of Allah and he would wash it off his garment, then he would go out to pray wearing that garment, and I could see the marks left on it by washing." [Sunan Ibn Majah 536] ▶(9) Aishah said: "The Messenger of Allah and I would take a bath from a single vessel." [Sunan Ibn Majah 376] ▶(10) Narrated `Aisha: "The Prophet and I used to take a bath from a single pot while we were Junub. During the menses, he used to order me to put on an Izar (dress worn below the waist) and used to fondle me. While in I`tikaf, he used to bring his head near me and I would wash it while I used to be in my periods (menses)" [Sahih al-Bukhari 299]

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

I’ll respond later Insha Allah after work

[@therandom3523]

I noticed that the Quran verses brought up only mentioned music/singing as haram when it tries to deviate someone from the path of righteousness. How does that lead the scholars to the conclusion that all music is haram, and not just music with lyrics that involve haram things? Also, I was wondering what separates nasheed from music, since they are both rhythmic tunes with lyrics.

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

You can watch ustadh Abdur Rahman’s 3 hour video on is music Haram - he goes in detail into everything Nasheeds are not the same as singing songs - they are clearly different

[@user-rb8tb3fk3x]

​@@FarhanAhmedZia How are they clearly different?

[@DroidEnaamo]

Singing is also haram? 😮 I thought only musical Instruments were haram

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Well singing is related to music or singing music or musical songs If it’s poetry or nasheed etc it’s fine But general singing nowadays is of songs which can be classified as idle talk

[@user-dt9qo3sm4z]

But then poetry and nasheed also is 'singing'

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

No it’s not the same Even the sahaba used to recite poetry and there is a huge Islamic tradition of poetry Singing is usually related to music and most singing is singing of songs that have music If it’s poetry or nasheed it’s fine But generally singing nowadays is of songs which comes under idle talk and is related with music

[@user-dt9qo3sm4z]

@@FarhanAhmedZia but then nasheeds is also idle talk because it wastes time -_-

[@user-dt9qo3sm4z]

@@FarhanAhmedZia and if nasheed is not idle talk because of good lyrics, then why is music wrong with good lyrics -_-

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Because the religion is based on what Allah said and what the Messenger of Allah said, not what you logically feel makes sense or not

[@user-dt9qo3sm4z]

@FarhanAhmedZia yeah, that's true, but if the idle tale thing is about a specific person who was telling Persian tales, then interpreting it as 'singing' isn't wrong? If it's okay to interpret 'idle tale' as 'singing' instead of the more classical 'Persian tales by specific person' then anyone can interpret verses any way they want. Anyone can just make multiple meanings of the same verse. Isn't that a bit... uhh... problematic... 😑

[@aashaykadu6549]

So sufi singers are kaafir?

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

No lol

[@sursumkorda]

music is haram

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Yep 👍

[@sursumkorda]

@@FarhanAhmedZia f islam then

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Good for you 👍

[@SUPERSAMAOBAMALADEN]

Oh yes! Music is Haram! But beating your wife, child marriage, Mutah (Temporary marriage to the woman, paid by money) is not Haram

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

Tell me you don’t know anything about temporary marriage without telling me 😭

[@SUPERSAMAOBAMALADEN]

@@FarhanAhmedZia You tell me then

[@spiritofobserver]

What about KZbin? Shouldn't you all delete your accounts to avoid haram?

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

KZbin isn’t haram lol

[@Naklier]

W

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

JazakAllah Khair brother

[@cate_enthusiast]

can i add you on discord to have a conversation with you about this? id love an in depth talk❤

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

I never use discord but I’m chronically on twitter 24/7 @FarhanAhmedZia and we can send voice messages in DMs You will need to reply or like something so I can follow you first because twitter changed its rules where you can only DM who you follow Insha Allah we will be able to have a chat ❤️

[@cate_enthusiast]

@@FarhanAhmedZia i dont have twitter :( let's have it here i dont understand why nasheeds is mubah but music is haram, when nasheeds are basically softcore music they're rhythmic and use vocals to an extend to feel like musical instruments

[@FarhanAhmedZia]

It’s okay - add me on discord @farhanahmedzia we can talk there - it’ll be better than going back and forth on yt comments and I can send voice messages instead

[@cate_enthusiast]

@@FarhanAhmedZia 👍