WHY MUSIC IS HARAM - Animated Islamic Video

[@adilsaifi8446]

I addicted to music but I'm trying to give up plz. Pray for me

[@nahilismail9619]

Adil Saifi may Allah help you brother 👏👏

[@clappedoutmotor]

I'm interested in talking about this. I am an agnostic musician and I am very interested on why you could give up the most beautiful arts that humans ever created.

[@hudaabintahmud701]

Adil Saifi May Allah make it easy for you. Aameen. Read Qur'an with translation more often and listen to nasheeds at first. It'll be hard at first because we're so exposed to music these days in public etc but with time you'll get rid of the obsession .. I know coz I've been there too 😩

[@nahilismail9619]

Fidmark1 to prove to allah that you are worthy of his love trust and blessings Also it's not as hard as you described really

[@tayyabprince5693]

Allah pak apki madad kray

[@jaio7190]

Never once have I thought about sinning or changing my faith or even felt slightly misguided from Allah when I listen to music.

[@anjazure]

It's like saying don't work for a living.. the stress will make you forget allah

[@mennat-allahh]

Quran and music do not meet in one heart Either you choose the Word of God or Satan's musician Music will make you forget God gradually

[@salafisalaf2639]

Menna Ghreeb very true

[@ahorshi7246]

It depends on the frequency of the music and the words of the music This days music usually play music at 440Hz which is harmful to our bodies because it doesn't match or reasonate with our body's vibrational frequency this causes u sometimes to feel moody depressed or too hyperactive depending on the words However when u play music at 432Hz our body's frequency matches the music frequency therefore a harmless song But beware u should avoid songs with bad lyrics play clean music

[@ahorshi7246]

@Mjellma Isufi we are like 3 in my school that know about this😂😂

[@damdama2001]

I threw away an enormous box of music 15 years ago after I realized my addiction and how it was destroying me heart. alhamdullah. will never go back

[@wonderlust5043]

Qᴜɪᴄᴋ Sᴀɴᴅ there is no loophole. The entire video is a loophole.

[@shayaanbawany7337]

damdama2001 masha Allah, may He guide me too and us all!

[@adelisapalic5]

you guys... por Allah... u guys r stupid to belive this.. this man is gaining money and attention for a part of Quran he read and he misunderstood

[@Susanc06]

damdama2001 You are a dumb person. Who do you think 🤔 invented musical instruments?? Go ahead be an idiot 🙄

[@user-or1tp5bo5q]

I did that with my entire playlist (300+ songs) of Apple music, and I'm tempted to bring them all back, do you have any tips on how to avoid temptation?

[@kaylaleave]

Honestly music hasn’t mislead me from god but I see that people who are weak minded have been mislead

[@lemonade9715]

Narrates Salama Ibn Al-Akwa‘: ‘We set off for Khaybar in the company of the Holy Prophet (sws) at night. A man from the group said to ‘Amir: ‘O ‘Amir, would not you let us hear your poetry?’ ‘Amir who was a Hida poet got down and started reciting for the people [the following verses]: ‘O God, were not it for your guidance, we could not have been able to offer the Salah and pay the Zakah. So please forgive our sins that [we have committed] and the ones we may commit in future. We are ready to offer our lives for your cause. Grant us perseverance when faced [with the enemy] and pour down your mercy upon us. [We are the people] who refuse to surrender when the enemy challenges us to fight. And [we leave them] to cry for help against us’. The Holy Prophet asked: ‘Who is that singer?’ They replied: ‘‘Amir bin Al-Akwa‘’. ‘God bless him’, prayed the Holy Prophet (sws) 9. (Bukhari, No: 3960) Narrates Anas Ibn Malik: [Having entered the city], the Holy Prophet (sws) passed through a certain part of the town. Suddenly some slave girls appeared singing on the Daff the following ditty: ‘We are the slave girls of Bani Najjar. 7 How lucky! This day the Holy Prophet (sws) has come to be our neighbor’. At this the Holy Prophet (sws) remarked: ‘God knows that I love you people’ (Ibn Majah, No: 1899)

[@rafathsultana5436]

Never doubt on hadees if u are true Muslim

[@shaggyrogers7986]

@Aisha _88 Wrong, I listen to music I am never mislead. I always seep help and pray to Allah.

[@stinkyjimmy9336]

Kayla Leave preach

[@wabfaj1507]

@@shaggyrogers7986 mans admits to sinning openly, than says I have never been mislead, that's a bruh moment

[@muslimgroup9892]

He is right, When I was listening music then I forgot Quran but when I left music then I started reciting Quran. Now Mashallah, I recite around 30 minutes Quran with translation and I record it and send to my friend.

[@yes_no____________________5883]

@@monke5125 no

[@muhammad608]

This video has so many lies without giving crystal clear evidence that music is haram. You provide me with evidences from these questions, then we will see if music is forbidden and we'll see who the real liar is. 1. Provide crystal clear evidence from the Quran that Allah prohibited music in one verse like he did with shirk, pork, alcohol. 2. what countries music is banned in history of mankind?, like some countries banned alcohol, pork. 3. If music is haram, then Why do birds sing? 4. What is punishment for listening to music, like there is punishment for zina?

[@gentlepengua5651]

Music isn't haram. This video is talking nonsense, and it generalizes music by saying "oh, this music is bad so ALL music is bad". This is the same logic people use when islamaphobes that Muslims are bad. "well, these Muslims did wrong things so ALL Muslims are bad".

[@n0o0ne]

@@gentlepengua5651 the video clearly had enough proof by stating an “ Ayah “ so it’s not the video who said it’s haram it’s Allah words it’s more logical if you take it as it’s Allah orders rather than questioning about it because Allah knows what’s best and he already replaced it with the holy quran so idk bout u but i rather look for relaxation in Allah words

[@n0o0ne]

@@gentlepengua5651 and be careful of giving fatwa have a great day.

[@junkandgunk]

correct me if I'm wrong, but music is just a background instrumental condiment and there's nothing satanic about it. music with lyrics is called a song, so don't jump up and scare people immediately like that.

[@indhirasarahadam]

Iblis created music. Listen to the story of Prophet Seeth AS

[@mastergaming4787]

Nah you need to study why it is wrong

[@user-cp6mt7cz3s]

u are so stupid

[@mujeeburrahman6543]

Bro, watch the video.

[@GrimFate08]

You are all decieved by shaytaan

[@leah2308]

Allah (swt) has opened my eyes, and I am deleting spotify and now listening to videos on Islam while working out and taking walks. *Alhamdulillah* ❤

[@relchan489]

same, it changes(good) me in some.ways compare to before,( wish muslim understand that spending time for hereafter worth is better than wasting ur life,(refer surah al-Asr)

[@user-ky6yr4tu3w]

Leah You’re letting yourself be brainwashed

[@juggernaut2726]

@@user-ky6yr4tu3w how so

[@skhafijurrahaman9204]

One question, What do you even linten in Spotify??

[@jane1002]

Dumb bitch

[@shery3840]

I have deleted all the songs I used to listen to all thanks to this brother guiding people.I'm very thankful to you brother.

[@North7809]

music isnt haram this vid makes nosense

[@AC-mp7cx]

It’s nuanced

[@Betelgeusewaitforit]

Okay delete them from memory.. you will loose track of what you are. You're deleting yourself.

[@moehatim3754]

Wallahi I used to be that guy who thinks music heals and makes you comfortable and subhanallah it’s crazy how I deleted a whole bunch of music albums and tracks on my phone at one night and never listened to any of it again alhamdulilah

[@sampar6920]

Subhan Allah... Jazakallah brother, for this excellent presentation... it such an important thing to know... May Allah bless our Ummah...

[@lolll1922]

i have anxiety,music has been a life saver because it’s a way of coping. it never took me away from faith and it in fact has been very helpful,i have so much free time so i never know what to do and just end up overthinking. but that doesn’t happen when i listen to music,it makes me happy and doesn’t keep me away from faith

[@lolll1922]

@Muhammad Allaiwal Yes,now i know. All i want to do is please Allah SWT and stay close to faith,when i wrote this comment i was confused and sad but now i’m better Alhamdulillah.

[@lolll1922]

@Muhammad Allaiwal Thank you for your kind words,Inshallah. (i’m a girl by the way) Yes i do watch Mufti Menk sometimes,i also watch LovUAllah and channels like that,ill link you an interesting video that i think you should watch if you haven’t already

[@lolll1922]

@Muhammad Allaiwal kzbin.info/www/bejne/bZWUZ3amjNVgpc0. This is the video,i found it really interesting

[@lolll1922]

@Muhammad Allaiwal it’s fine

[@gentlepengua5651]

@@futurebigbank8719 Quran is amazing, however it doesn't have the same effects in suthing the mind as music does in these cases.

[@juweriyahxxx8673]

Subhanallah may Allah (swt)guide us all💗

[@yeeet5795]

You had music in the intro i dont understand please answer

[@muslimgroup9892]

Why they are using quranic verse as songs. This is the book of God not lyrics of Songs

[@poofyfish9436]

what's wrong with reciting the words of god with rhythm?

[@muslimgroup9892]

@@poofyfish9436 There is nothing wrong but there should be no use of musical instruments.

[@poofyfish9436]

i believe that's mostly likely a software based music or something like that, besides if he has used any instruments then it's his mistake.

[@muslimgroup9892]

@@poofyfish9436 don't try to give excuses.

[@Babbaboeyy]

I dont understand why people say music drove you away from islam because some song does not even include such stuff

[@alexojideagu]

It's a Wahabi Salafi interpretation. Not a single Islamic country bans Musical Instruments. The UAE has a huge musical traditional dance using music.

[@aspirewot8408]

Because you don't understand music and doing drugs are similar it gives you temporary false pleasure takes you away from this reality . That's why it's haram

[@saimahhussain7723]

Singing is allowed in weddings. Hazrat Daud had a beautiful voice and sang Allah’s praises. Islam is the middle line, everything is allowed but with moderation and limits

[@aiza3378]

never ONCE has music distracted me from my faith. it honestly depends on what type of music. i listen to certain artists and they never have vulgarity in their music but they promote self love!!

[@taeilstoes4875]

Lmao bro- I don’t understand, Litteraly when I listen to music i appreciate it because it sounds good but idk when I listen to music I don’t think about leaving my religion or go abs murder a family.....I’m lost. I don’t even worship music or my fav artist 👁👄💀

[@miriaichan1471]

I mostly listen to music in japanese german or korean wich are languages that i dont know much of and they are mostly about depression and wanting to kill yourself and dealing with it .. but i was listeneing once and understood some words wich was kami sama nanadakara meaning god doesnt exist and then i earased that song ... I feel something is.missing tho

[@Aki-us3el]

people just don’t use common sense

[@gentlepengua5651]

Music isn't haram. This video is talking nonsense, and it generalizes music by saying "oh, this music is bad so ALL music is bad". This is the same logic people use when islamaphobes that Muslims are bad. "well, these Muslims did wrong things so ALL Muslims are bad".

[@TopNotch78]

Music is an art form. And the Arts, such as music, poetry, painting, sculpting, are all great examples of human creativity and genius. Whoever wants human life to become a dull, caveman-like existence can just go live it that way for themselves. Look at the achievements of the people outside of the muslim world and you will see where life is celebrated.

[@Youman-tu8wr]

Mashallah, I love watching your videos! Keep up the good work!

[@shahisthabegum7435]

Masha Allah so nice to hear a msg abt the music which is haram in islam. Insha Allah v will leave the music and start connected to Allah subhanataala ....

[@huzjezbuzrezbazraznphez2379]

Depends on what type of music...music is such a broad term. I don’t believe all music is haram, but there are some forms that definitely are.

[@mylordtakemeaway]

all music with instruments or foul language or indecent speech is forbidden

[@extrimanil]

@@Sysop70 rap music or pop music that has swear words is definitely haram but most music that doesn’t have any bad words is halal

[@Isosceles12345]

@@extrimanil Yup.

[@Edward-bm7vw]

@@mylordtakemeaway What's wrong with instruments??

[@mylordtakemeaway]

@@Edward-bm7vw Allah says it is forbidden - “And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allah…” [Luqman 31:6]

[@rachelelizabeth1986]

I have listened to music of all types my whole life and never once has it caused me to sin. this is ridiculous. it's very therapeutic and gives strength and joy. it has helped me thru some hard times, and God has been with me. he uses music just as he uses so many other things for good. music itself is not bad. it's what kind the person listens to and takes seriously.

[@samrao1981]

rachel elizabeth he is talking collectivly .. Most peole rush into sins just bkz of muzic .. Over all he iz talking n Allah says ..

[@cindynovaria8326]

enjoy your music then.

[@gcsparts]

rachel elizabeth ot diverts your precous time my dear. U forget God and His remembrance

[@xux4670]

You shouldn't listen to Music you know 😕. We all should follow the example of our Holy Prophet (P.B.U.H) and you can help yourself by listening to Quran, it'll help for sure. I became a Music addict but left Music a while ago and started listening to Mishary Al Afasay reading Surat al Baqarah or any surah. His voice is very beautiful and I think you should listen to him then listening to those singers out there who basically have no life if they aren't believing in God. Hope you understand

[@cagan1357]

God or allah just dont exist

[@joshuaperkings5155]

See all these declarations about music is haram, entertainment is haram, having fun is haram etc. Islam is a religion of ease and moderation. I studied and have faith enough to know this is not a religion that makes ones life void of entertainment (that doesn't clearly lead you astray) Not all music leads to evil, yes some does. In the same argument you make, your smartphone and computer can lead you to evil (pornography, witchcraft), does that make your computer evil in and of itself? Hence the whole "Because it leads to evil, its prohibited" logic does not make sense. The Prophet Muhammad peace and blessing upon him was ok with singing and beating of drums before him. The one hadith that refers against music is questionable but even taken in translation it associates people who will drink alcohol, commit adultery all the while listening to music (Which we clearly see today). Does it make any sense to say music that puts babies to sleep, that makes the hardworking men of labor work more efficient, melodies that come out of the birds and animals is somehow evil? brothers and sisters we must be very careful to call haram what is not haram, Allah almighty warned us from doing this Say: Have you considered what provision Allah has sent down for you, how you have made of it lawful and unlawful? Say: Has Allah permitted you, or do you invent a lie concerning Allah?”(Yunus: 59) . Allah knows best

[@Sunny-ie9kf]

Are you a Muslim?

[@adamuk8199]

I agree with you brother, being a Muslim is not meant to be a burden, my phone distracts me, but listening to music has never made me commit sin.

[@ahsenkhan5386]

@@Sunny-ie9kf are you ?

[@daniyalmehdi5409]

Jazakallah:) inshallah from today i do my best to get rid of this music addiction:)😇...

[@safwannttentater739]

We need to stop supporting clickbait videos like these, verse 31:6 is not talking about music. Remember making halal haram is a serious matter!

[@asslicker2107]

Wait so what is it?

[@aliceswan9562]

Safwan Zilla are you trying to say that music is halal or something???!!!

[@saraqostahterra4548]

@@aliceswan9562 It is Halal.

[@slaveofallah8355]

@@saraqostahterra4548 (interpretation of the meaning): ‘And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allaah…’ [Luqmaan 31:6].” (Hasan hadeeth) The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Among my ummah there will certainly be people who permit zinaa, silk, alcohol and musical instruments…” (Narrated by al-Bukhaari ta’leeqan, no. 5590; narrated as mawsool by al-Tabaraani and al-Bayhaqi. See al-Silsilah al-Saheehah by al-Albaani, 91

[@ahsenkhan5386]

@@slaveofallah8355 ....and in that verse how does that mention songs ? That verse means anything News Newspaper People gossiping Ineterent

[@Herman47]

*Please explain why "Allah" regards listening to the music of Chopin and Tchaikovsky as sinful*

[@dansouzainsha]

I'm slowly detaching from music. In rare occasions when really stressed but NOT home yet, I put my headphones and listen to a Islamic lecture, or else Qur'An, but unfortunately at rare times, some instrumental music. Allah, all praise be to You O Allah, forgive me and allow me to fully forget about the distracting things of this world. A'oodhu Billahi min ash shaytanir rajeem

[@muhammedramzigohar5179]

The sad thing is, some Muslim students in the USA, Canada, UK, etc. are forced to do a specific subject called "music". I was as well

[@youssefa.2251]

Real Madrid MRG In such situations we are tasked to stay strong and never lose sight of our religion ♥

[@apustus8819]

it happen in my country too

[@MrEvldreamr]

Real Madrid MRG What's sad is that they think they can have a career in music, not the fact that they study it. Music is not haram, that's ridiculous

[@adj9271]

Real Madrid MRG Happens in Islamic countries as well such as UAE.

[@yasminhassan1560]

Random Doesn't Equal Funny why are you even watching this video then

[@ZeeshanAhmed-gz3sn]

100% Correct because whenever I listened to Nasheeds then finally ended up with listening 🎧 Music 🎶

[@TechNaf]

listen to vocals only

[@gentlepengua5651]

Music isn't haram. This video is talking nonsense, and it generalizes music by saying "oh, this music is bad so ALL music is bad". This is the same logic people use when islamaphobes that Muslims are bad. "well, these Muslims did wrong things so ALL Muslims are bad".

[@MGLOL]

@@gentlepengua5651 don't talk about something in Islam with no knowledge

[@fatounjie6193]

Me too

[@zeeshanbinnaushadnujjoo1389]

​@@MGLOLthe question says listening music songs is not haram because not all music is haram

[@hadialzayer4834]

Thank you for changing my life

[@AdanMohamud-z7w]

he is right i didnt know music was haram i already did try to stop i used to listen to eric clapton sometimes and then i had to stop listening to it so instead i switched to somali music and see if it would make a difference but no its still music so i had to switch to quran and see if it makes a difference because all the musical istruments like i hear it from the bus a few days ago and my heart didnt like it so i tried my best to stop subhanallah

[@Theonewhodanceswithwolves]

There are muslims who left islam for the love of music, alhamdulillah i will do my best to quit listening to music for the love of my deen.

[@hamzaibrahim5830]

The drawings are amazing!

[@mohamedkoraichi2124]

he doesn't draw it's an app called videoscribe

[@ExposingEvil_]

To further add on to my point, Music has helped me in a way where I really have lost a lot of the pain that I've gotten from being bullied. Nirvana and Linkin Park all are on the base of emotional pain from one's childhood- These songs have helped me avoid doing bad things such as drugs, self harm, which are haram. Before I got into Rock Music in general, I wasn't active in Salah or Prayer. I try my best now to pray as much as I can, and I feel guilty when I don't pray. Whether or not my prayers are good, I still try my best to bow down to Allah.

[@user-jn1vm3vn4t]

Salam Sami Sami, So sorry for what you have been through and what you are ensuring as a result of it, first of all here's a hug 🤗 In Shaa Allah I have good news 4 U! You say you feel guilty when you don't pray... That in it of itself is a clear indication you have strong faith!/Eeman in ure beautiful heart. Also... It means you are God conscious... So you have/are experiencing taqwa. HOW DOES THAT WORK! Well, when you felt guilty for missing the prayer what is actually happening, is you are saying: "Ya Allah, I miss my prayer, I really want to pray, I'm sorry for not praying" so you have even included without realising istighfar/seeking forgiveness from Allah SWT. I hope you feel better after reading this. Take care 🙂

[@North7809]

music isnt haram btw

[@zafarmahmood4734]

The point you are misunderstanding is, music is haram because the creator said it's haram, and in Islam everything is not based on just one or two or 1000 personal experiences, it is based on overall consequences of the actions you are taking. As a whole music always promotes drugs, alcohol, sex and you name it.

[@aua8742]

@@zafarmahmood4734 do instrumentals promote sex drugs and violence? And do they count?

[@ayaancvukisurally1063]

Why don’t u try to read quraan and speak with ur parents

[@venomvideos855]

I'm not a Muslim, I just find it important to learn about different cultures. Also I wish someone could forbid our gym class teachers making us dance.

[@porrnesianparrapio1842]

Great! Wish that someday you will find the right path and become a Muslim. Allah will give hidayat to you

[@cubicyt9441]

Astagfirullah dancing is haram in islam

[@ahsenkhan5386]

@@cubicyt9441 why and how ?

[@LBH15]

@@cubicyt9441 he has to follow the gym class teachers

[@sabrazira]

I listen to kpop (bts), and most of their songs is recovering of love that wasn't successful and they don't have lyrics about sexual things, alcohol, drugs, or anythings like that. They actually try stopping it, so would that be haram?

[@RaanaGolzar]

Ouissal Ziyech agreed people who are addicted to music have better chances to fall for shaytaan tricks

[@randomdumbass4447]

Raana Golz I’m addicted for 8 years and I haven’t gotten a single doubt of Islam being a fake religion. Music is haram only when U don’t read qu’uran

[@syedsaad1594]

@@randomdumbass4447 Dude, are you serious? Don't make your own interpretations, for GOD's sake. Music is haram when you don't read Qur'an?? How on Earth did you reach that conclusion? Literally no scholar ever made that conclusion. So if I read Qur'an daily should I also be allowed to drink alcohol (since it has benefits too)?? Where has your intellect gone, bruh

[@SapeHallward]

@aqsa mohiuddin no he's not @Saad Ahmed disproved him lmao

[@SapeHallward]

And listening to music isnt an addiction.

[@Otome_chan311]

Just an FYI, the intro and outro to this video are music.

[@humi7835]

Are u dumb? That is NOT that kind of music, its only voicve! Thats why nasheeds are good cuz they only have voices in them, the actual thing is about instruments like drums, guitar etc,

[@Otome_chan311]

@@humi7835 I'm not muslim. I'm just pointing out that the tirade against music is ironic, since there is music in the intro and outro. IIRC the video also criticized nasheeds so if those are nasheeds then it is still hypocritical, yeah? The whole opposition to music just seems odd anyway. If the point is to avoid the emotional manipulation, then that's the musicality, not the instrument.

[@ahsenkhan5386]

@@humi7835 Are stupid the narrator said its haram Still Hypocrite

[@amongyou6419]

I am going to delete all my music stuff and Allah will help me to recover from music addiction inshaallah like he did to recover from porn and musterbation addiction

[@Susanc06]

👌 okie dokie 🙄

[@Susanc06]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/mHuco2uCgrpsmLM

[@prowrestlingnewsbite4434]

I understand this, I mean when I see everyone listening to music around me I think like what so good about it, it’s just so similar and they clearly show bad ideas in music and it actually encourages depression and anger and a unreal atmosphere

[@Swaggcee]

For me, I would just instantly quit music instead of thinking: Should I quit it? This music doesn't included sex, alcohol, money etc. So is it haram? This song's for learning, is it ok? I'm listening for fun, it is ok? I'll quit later... And many more.. I just quit it. I don't want to think anymore. :D

[@shahdtarek8200]

I listen to acapella songs

[@hadishams5732]

This is a really good dimecision my brother, may allah keep us on the right path

[@karimtit4897]

"I don't want to think anymore." It's the whole point of Islam no ? 😉 Guess you are the good muslim.

[@joed.9273]

@@person10 👎👎👎👎👎👎 Get your filthy hands off people! Good music doesnt harm anyone. Show some empathy. I know 3-4 muslim people and they all listen to music ,people like you in the commeny section are simply radicalized.

[@gentlepengua5651]

Music isn't haram. This video is talking nonsense, and it generalizes music by saying "oh, this music is bad so ALL music is bad". This is the same logic people use when islamaphobes that Muslims are bad. "well, these Muslims did wrong things so ALL Muslims are bad".

[@ally7018]

My dad recently passed away and I'm trying to get away from music, but shaytan keeps telling "just a little bit won't harm." " It's OK it just a few minutes." I keep trying to find reasons to stop and keep holding myself from it. It's a tough journey.

[@hadishams5732]

Listen and read some quran brother, read about all studies that proofed music is harmful for your health, Trust me brother I,am just like you and Im trying the same thing and remember, no thing in this live worth wasting the after live for it. May allah show us the right path

[@alexojideagu]

That's a Wahabi Salafi interpretation. Not a single Islamic country bans Musical Instruments. The UAE has a huge musical traditional dance using music.

[@aspirewot8408]

@@alexojideagu they're not real Muslims . They don't even help Palestine Yemen etc . They only care about money . Music is haram n there's scientific reason too

[@naveedmohammed6077]

So the mobile ringtone is haram. The alarm sound is haram. The door bell is haram. Since the sound is generated by a musical instrument?

[@R17..]

Change mobile ringtone to "Nokia arabic ringtone" it is very halal 😇

[@clappedoutmotor]

This makes me really sad. I think music is beautiful and healing.

[@youssefa.2251]

Fidmark1 Don't worry about that friend. I also agree it can be healing and beautiful. This video is more about the foul lyrics or any other thing that can lead us 'astray'

[@youssefa.2251]

Side Note: We believe music is soothing ti the mind, and that the quraan is soothing to the heart/soul

[@jihanekukushi5984]

Fidmark1 The Quran IS the only thing beautiful and healing so shaytan wants us to listen to music

[@zarzaman]

Mugiwara Seisero shaytaan wants us to listen to the songs which are encouraging drugs, alcohol. Shaytaan wants to influence that to go astray with *that* music

[@relchan489]

+Mugiwara Seisero thats the point,soo on point bro,

[@abdulkhaderhussainabba1076]

I stopped listening to music 2years back and alhamdulliah am very thankful to Allah I still not listening to any filthy types of music

[@Salman-tf2cs]

Not all songs encourage seductive stuff ????

[@moealib]

^^?

[@user-xm5le5ok2r]

There’s nice music all around the world. The majority of people in the world don’t even listen to bad music. Your religion make it seem like they do, but they don’t. So enjoy life and some good music!

[@x0amna]

@@user-xm5le5ok2r um, don't call them idiots . if u disagree, then it's fine but dont say they are idiots

[@user-xm5le5ok2r]

@@x0amna You are right. My apologies for calling them idiots. I use to be part of a religious group that warped my thinking about life. So, I didn’t want this person to fall in the same trap, especially about the joy of good music. Life is to precious to allow closed minded people, especially from religious leaders from any group in our world who enforce their lack of knowledge in the name of God upon their followers. I was in a class tonight were a young lady told the story of her brave dad who decided to leave their country so she could get an education. I celebrate her dad for not allowing his leaders to pursued him that women can’t be educated. Thanks for the humanity check. I took the word out...Have a great one!

[@joed.9273]

@@immylatif7207 nazist logic

[@abiade9614]

This is so strange to me. Music is an art form as well as part of many cultures that people grew up around. It’s so vast in its genres, lyrics, meaning, sounds, and composition I cannot fathom why the concept of it would be haram. Ask this video explained was a certain TYPE of music. Maybe clubbing music that’s upbeat and vulgar in concepts and use of words. "Dubstep". What about the musicians that use music to praise Allah? What about the slow emotional songs that talk of self love, familial love, love for a husband/wife, the joys of being alive and generally happy?? Even songs that are sad but make you feel less alone in your struggles? All of that is haram?? Why- because some songs are vulgar? It’s a fallacy.

[@meliora99]

obviously Muhammad had no idea what music would become

[@abiade9614]

@@meliora99 this still doesn’t explain why the whole concept of music should be considered impermissible.

[@yasin65]

I haven't listened to music for at least 6 months, but I still fail to see any problem with listening to music when you don't act like the artists that you are listening to. I feel like listening to music had no 'satanic' effect on me

[@fireball7198]

I think ur right there may be some good to music but its still haram just like in the quran, Allah says that there is some benefit to alcohol but the disadvantages outweigh it and then he made alcohol haram.

[@justray1958]

@@fireball7198 you make sense

[@Edward-bm7vw]

@@fireball7198 There are no disadvantages to music. Literally NONE. Not an ounce.

[@fireball7198]

@@Edward-bm7vw its very addictive

[@Edward-bm7vw]

@@fireball7198 There is no evidence music produces any dependency issues or withdrawal symptoms. Stop lying. Try again - what are the disadvantages?

[@nadiyatariq9816]

Sir Ur way of explaining is awesome... May Allah keep u always happy and always keep u on ryt path

[@kamihussain1414]

When I was a teenager I never really listened to music and even after I got married. But it's been about two years I've started listening to music and trust me I can feel how satan is trying to mislead me. I feel as though I'm starting to lose myself. I feel as though I'm losing my character. Satan is really making my life miserable. I dont know how to control myself. I swear down satan is a bastard

[@mylordtakemeaway]

do not curse satan because he becomes more arrogant but instead mention Allāh and satan flees away

[@R17..]

Music is haram 😡👎. If you listen to music you will go to hell. Yesterday I accidentally listened to music, now I don't know what to do. Should I finish myself off for listening to music. I don't know what to do.

[@eybros]

@@R17.. Repent brother. Allah is the forgiving, he forgives all sins.

[@Isosceles12345]

@@R17.. Nah you have no right to say who goes hell. Only Allah SWT does. There are way worse sins than listening to peaceful, calm music.

[@R17..]

@@Isosceles12345 I listen to "Cannibal Corpse" it is very peaceful music 😇

[@ashah8656]

*Its easy to deny the Truth but eternally, it’s unimaginabley rewarding to Accept it*

[@Susanc06]

@The Billionaire Club kzbin.info/www/bejne/nGLImYtqrJ1jh6s

[@Susanc06]

@The Billionaire Club He's on a watch list actually. He's dangerous and preaching hate I found the link.

[@Susanc06]

The Billionaire Club What link? I put a few links. There is this one. m.facebook.com/watch/?v=909522939542439&_rdr

[@Susanc06]

The Billionaire Club There is another site where children are going and they tell me they are not allowed to listen to music. Go tell them the woman is a deceiver. kzbin.info/www/bejne/eWOtiGyJhc-tp9U

[@Susanc06]

The Billionaire Club Can you imagine this poor souls life without music?

[@mohamedasjad3390]

Jazakkallahu Khairan. Much useful.

[@mgonzo3881]

If Muhammad wasn’t a fan of something, then it’s haram. Example: music, dogs, etc. There is nothing wrong with music or dogs. The Quran doesn’t forbid music either.

[@abdullahiahmed9718]

May Allah (swt)guide as in the straight path

[@stancars9359]

Allah is god in Arabic so how are they the same?

[@sweetsoul3169]

Ameen

[@matin3034]

May I ask for some guidance please. I am a frequent watcher of lots of youtube videos and lots of them have back round music in them with no lyrics. Is it ok for me to watch these videos or is it not permissable? Also is music with no lyrics permissable? I'm not sure as the video mostly talked about the terrible words in rap and other types or music like that.

[@ibniloveitmushtaq6925]

Ameen

[@r1self973]

@@matin3034 they will lead u away from Allah swt better not to watch it more than needed...... I'm a muslim too but I don't get away from Allah while listening music cuz I sometimes listen islamic songs which are halal

[@mrzq6028]

I like music. It us beautiful and am intrinsic part of human beings.Thats why most cultures have their own kinds of music. Its really moving

[@addisonxoxo947]

Same I love music I don't understand why it's haram

[@uzia2913]

@@addisonxoxo947 u just said why its haram

[@elftower907]

@@uzia2913 how

[@blackpalacemusic]

Music transmits culture, binds people together in fellowship and communicates their aspirations. If you intend to subjugate people, one of the first things you do is remove their music.

[@deanyilmaz8090]

I see where you are coming from brother, however, I do not believe all music is haram. As there are many Muslim Imams & scholars (also reputable ones here on youtube) who would argue that there is Halal music, as there has been in Islamic history for ages. From very small Muslim nomadic tribes, to Islamic empires, kingdoms, countries etc there has been Halal music within these Muslim civilizations during there time. So all due respect to you brother, I do not believe everything is black & white, I believe there are reasons to things being haram & halal. Even at the start of the video the recitation is being sung.

[@dadadoooo1412]

Music is haram, but nasheed is mubah

[@aspirewot8408]

All music is haram . Neuroscience has proven that it manipulates our neurotransmitters lmao

[@aspirewot8408]

@Keysar Efes Yeah n after this go eat pork and drink alcohol too 🤣

[@slaveofallah8355]

(interpretation of the meaning): ‘And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allaah…’ [Luqmaan 31:6].” (Hasan hadeeth) The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Among my ummah there will certainly be people who permit zinaa, silk, alcohol and musical instruments…” (Narrated by al-Bukhaari ta’leeqan, no. 5590; narrated as mawsool by al-Tabaraani and al-Bayhaqi. See al-Silsilah al-Saheehah by al-Albaani, 91

[@kalkansizviking]

@@slaveofallah8355 kzbin.info/www/bejne/gaC2oqSOod11lZI is this type of music haram? it doesnt have lyrics

[@broke-depressed-lonely]

All these people saying that *Music is not misguiding me from the path of Allah* I just want to say that I used to think this way too. But what Allah has said, what Rasool (SAW) has said we have to follow it. Speaking from experience... When I used to listen to songs I was aggressive, addicted and depressed. That addiction isn't healing. Its just a trap of shaitan. Now that I left music ... I feel calm now, I don't get angry and only Allah comes to mind other then music. Please try to back away from music and you will feel the difference.

[@smaxain8537]

in Sha Allah........we all will get hidayat very very soon!

[@saadms07_]

Mashallah, thanks for letting us realize about the reality

[@gentlepengua5651]

Music isn't haram. This video is talking nonsense, and it generalizes music by saying "oh, this music is bad so ALL music is bad". This is the same logic people use when islamaphobes that Muslims are bad. "well, these Muslims did wrong things so ALL Muslims are bad".

[@North7809]

music isnt harm

[@17g37]

@@North7809 source for that claim? what's surprising is that your one of those who try to legalize music which is quit shocking and embarrassing

[@17g37]

@@gentlepengua5651 why do you say its haram even tho the prophet said its haram. give me a source which says music is not haram

[@zakishaheen1539]

Music is beautiful people, it’s not haram don’t be deceived by this nutcase. Allah gave you music. Enjoy it.

[@Kim_Jong_Un_.]

Hahahaha so who's your favourite artist ? Jay Z, Rihanna , Eminem , Beyonce ? Their all Satanists 🤣🤣🤣 you are truly misguided, but please don't try to misguided others with your addiction of music, scum bag

[@koishiinfinity2125]

@@Kim_Jong_Un_. Try listening to Beethoven and Mozart, imbecile...

[@zaujimaveinformacie4008]

@@Kim_Jong_Un_. listen to 70s and 80s music they are awesome yout boring cult called Islam is shit

[@SlamboSVV]

@@zaujimaveinformacie4008 May Allah guide you to Islam, ameen

[@ayeshaameermaliha]

@@zaujimaveinformacie4008 and you are so cool saying someone's religion is shit? smh

[@tufail1823]

One of my favorite KZbin channels. Love it Akhi keep it up. May Allah grant you success in this world and the hereafter, ameen

[@mryayayify]

This is from Amos in the bible "Take thou away from me the noise of thy songs; for I will not hear the melody of thy viols."

[@avocatdo8393]

"among my ummah there'll certainly be permit who permit zina, silk, and music instruments..." bukhari 5590 according to Imam al-Ghazali is of the view that all the hadith about the prohibition of music are not because music itself is forbidden. Rather, it is due to external factors (amr kharij) such as dancing girls, alcohol, gambling, and others. This identicality is what ultimately triggered the Prophet Muhammad PBUH to prohibit listening to music. So according to the rules of fiqh, if these external factors are not found when listening to music, then music becomes permissible. Even if music can bring us closer to God, it becomes sunnah. That's a glimpse into music and fiqh. On another page, al-Ghazali builds another argument this way: if there is a snake and a baby listening to music, then these two creatures will dance. This means that music is a kind of divine nature in humans. "If listening to music is haram," al-Ghazali writes, "then surely the sound of birds will be haram too." the quran verse that is used as evidence for the prohibition of music is Q.S Lukman verse 6, Ibn Hazm says that this verse has nothing to do with singing (music). This verse explains that those who want to mislead others from the path of Allah and make fun of the Qur'an are disbelievers. Another reason why some scholars have forbidden music is that it is often mixed with haraam things such as alcohol and other abominable acts. Imam Al-Ghazali's book also explains several types of music that are allowed, including: 1. Music that evokes feelings of longing to visit holy places. 2. Music that stirs up the spirit of fighting in defense of faith and country. 3. Music that commemorates the services of important figures who have passed away. 4. Music that depicts joyous and fulfilling moments. 5. Music that depicts divine greatness by mentioning attributes. The hadith about the prohibition of music are ahad hadith, none of which are authentic and therefore cannot be used as proof. Even if there is a sahih hadidth narrated by Bukhari, its sanad is broken (muallaq). In this explanation, Imam Ghazali concluded that music is permissible for the following reasons: 1. There is no clear evidence that explains the prohibition of music in either the Qur'an or hadith. 2. Allah does not reproach His servants who try to entertain themselves to help do their obligations. 3. Many music songs have noble meanings. 4. The existence of bad aspects in music is not absolute. So if the music is free from things that are forbidden then it is okay. Thus the music in Imam Al-Ghazali's book on the ruling of music. Waallahu a'lam bisshawab.

[@thewedge8823]

I listen to death metal. I love cannibal corpse.

[@oopsiedaisy6096]

Cradle of filth

[@hikari27506]

@@oopsiedaisy6096 Brainwashed low IQ believer

[@oopsiedaisy6096]

@@hikari27506 Never heard of that band. The name sounds interesting. Gotta check 'em out

[@henryphilippeaux3566]

Yeah cannibal corpse has some good music, I've been obsessed with gallery of suicide

[@lazysoda1672]

Plz dont listen to music it is haram my brothers and sisters

[@uk4725]

Says music is haram. Plays intro music. You people are delusional.

[@Userwhatever317]

It’s literally a nasheed. It has no instruments only humming which is not haram

[@uk4725]

@@Userwhatever317 Haha, bending laws till it suits you. Keep up.

[@sdk6247]

What the hell, without music life is boring, without, without dance life is depressing. Music is the very important part of the human's history and civilization.

[@gentlepengua5651]

Completely agreed. Music isn't haram. This video is talking nonsense, and it generalizes music by saying "oh, this music is bad so ALL music is bad". This is the same logic people use when islamaphobes that Muslims are bad. "well, these Muslims did wrong things so ALL Muslims are bad".

[@hythamfares4963]

@@gentlepengua5651 Yeah true, plus how does music increase hypocrisy, prophet Muhammad never mentioned such a thing

[@gentlepengua5651]

@Noah Fanhos The fact that you went out of your way to compare music to coke is funny. You can't possibly compare the both, because music not only doesn't harm you, but music is actually good for you. You can listen to Quran and music, nothing saying you can't.

[@gentlepengua5651]

@Noah Fanhos Yes. However, It's not.

[@wolfieafo]

this is why many people have stopped believing in the religion of Islam! the music, singing, is one of the best things we can do, feeling the music is the best thing in the world FOR ME!

[@raharazakther8965]

Alhamdulillah very informative, Jajak Allah Khairan brother

[@MrSaveersinas]

Alhamdulillah... Now im not listening to music,im proud of my self

[@ibniloveitmushtaq6925]

Don't be proud... We don't deserve to be proud

[@lazysoda1672]

My brother i am so happy for you

[@lazysoda1672]

@Keysar Efes I am sorry , but I dont understand the complicated words you are speaking

[@gentlepengua5651]

Music isn't haram. This video is talking nonsense, and it generalizes music by saying "oh, this music is bad so ALL music is bad". This is the same logic people use when islamaphobes that Muslims are bad. "well, these Muslims did wrong things so ALL Muslims are bad".

[@samuelvimes7686]

Life without music would be a mistake

[@gentlepengua5651]

Agreed

[@khalil42]

youre the same people telling us not to enforce our beliefs on you just by practicing our religion? the hypocrisy.

[@louxjoh]

Life without Quran would be Hell

[@aymen_15968]

May Allah guide u to the right path

[@Edward-bm7vw]

@@louxjoh Hell doesn't exist. Quran is just a fairy tale

[@kaizarkthetitan0]

I can never live without music Good thing I’m catholic

[@klinkerkk]

Jesus bless you, brother

[@regon2786]

I can live without music you are forbidden

[@amirkhakimov6535]

music makes you away from god

[@joed.9273]

@@amirkhakimov6535 You are not just a clown,you are the entire circus

[@amirkhakimov6535]

@@joed.9273 i will not waste my life on shaytaans tricks better sell for truth

[@SwornInvictus]

As a former musician, songwriter and audio engineer of about 15 years, may I share my experience? Look at the lifestyles of musicians and not just today but in historical accounts even in Ancient Rome.. 'S*x Dr*gs and rock n roll' isn't a new idea. We might realize but imagine a child gets into music and its decent sure, but who is to say they won't migrate to the 95% that isn't? It's a gateway. I was sucked into it as well and it lead me astray. Even music without words can bring about unnaturally powerful emotions and longing, or trance states that lower our resistance to careless attitudes. It seldom brings about true contentment and if it does, prayer does it better. Look at the effect music is having on most people today, the filth and negative messages, is music doing good for us as a general rule or not? If the answer is no then shouldn't we lead by example?

[@primtones]

I think you're right, it's about finding true contentment (=peace, God). I don't think the video managed to get that across. Music is passing ecstacy, a kind of drug really. You feel hung over and empty after indulging in it too. With age I'm finding that quietness makes me feel better than any music ever did. Without music, a space opens up which is far greater than any sound.

[@AdanMohamud-z7w]

i heard some scholars have opinions about music some say its permissble some say its not permissble to listen to music so yeah there are opinions

[@aala2968]

Yes! I've been looking for this answer for SO long! Articles saying that it was okay as long as they didn't have bad words or meaning while others said it was completely wrong! Jasak'Allahu Khairan!

[@fancyloafwinifred3897]

For those who have given up music, MashAllah! I tried a few times. I researched it. I felt guilty and sad because I am disobeying Allah. And I hope one day I will be able to give it up for His sake. My husband said, that music is makroof - it's disliked. It's hated by Allah. But is it the same as doing a bad deed? If it doesn't influence your worship of Allah, it is a sin, but you are not harming anyone or yourself. (Although, music could be bad for our health. Allah knows.) Have taqwa (fear) of Allah wherever you may be, and follow up a bad deed with a good deed which will wipe it out, and behave well towards the people. - Prophet sallalahu aleihim waselem. Also, your sin is forgiven when you say AstafiruAllah as if it never existed. And, your sins between the prayers are forgiven in the prayers. It's always best to obey Allah completely, and Allah knows what is best for us. And if there was a better way that worked just as well for me, I would drop it like a hot potato. I am yet to find it. May Allah give us time to improve our ways and take us to Him in our best state. ^^ InshAllah. Hopefully, in a muslim country, I can find plenty of activities to avoid music. :) That are better than music!

[@fancyloafwinifred3897]

@@peace2033 The beauty of this life. You are allowed to do anything you want because you are given choice.

[@user-xm5le5ok2r]

Please open your eyes to see the destructive ways you see Allah/God. You really believe Allah said music is bad, hell no. That’s a man made written in the Quran in the name of God. All of creation creates. And one thing we create is music. It’s sad how religious you are. You attempts to please Allah from a fear based structure have robbed you of life. Just look around you and look at nations that enforce strict Islam. Most of them are underdeveloped, poor, have the worst quality of life for its people, and still in the Stone Age. All text like the Quran and Bible are truly written, but not truly stated from God. See the world and you will realize quickly how blind people really are who call ALL music haram.

[@nosir4707]

@@user-xm5le5ok2r The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said: “Among my ummah there will certainly be people who permit zina, silk, alcohol and musical instruments…” (Narrated by al-Bukhari ta’liqan, no. 5590; narrated as mawsul by al-Tabarani and al-Bayhaqi. See al-Silsilah al-Sahihah by al-Albani, 91) Funny on how you become the people that Prophet Muhammad saw talked about and condemn Allah says in Surah Luqman (interpretation of the meaning): “And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allah…” [Luqman 31:6] Allah prohibit it, stop changing Islam to fit your desire.

[@user-xm5le5ok2r]

@@nosir4707 I’m not changing Islam to fit my desire. Travel the world for once and see God in all aspects of creation as others in developed nations and parts of the world. Music like all things can be used for good or bad. You all only focus on the negative, or the so called evil aspect of music. But open your heart, hears, and eyes to see the peace, love, joy, hope, laughter, healing, and life that GOOD music can bring! We played nice children music last night. Guess what, it put our son to sleep. Now was that evil? I think not. We all came together as a family, laughed, sang, and danced last week with some good music and friends. Was that evil? I think not. I’m sure God enjoyed watching us enjoy life. Looking at how fucked up most Islamic nations are, you all could use some good music. Get a life and realise, like all religious text. All things are truly written in religious text, but all things are not truly stated from God. And music being HARAM is not from God, it’s from a man trying to please God through works!

[@user-xm5le5ok2r]

Furthermore lady, this boggey man, fearful dread of Allah is sickening. Get a life and realise that God wants you to enjoy life, not endure it. Travel the world and come to your senses and see the fullness of God.

[@clappedoutmotor]

I am a musician and a lot of the musicians I associate with are very good, humble and peaceful people. I don't mean to disrespect Islam but I feel strongly about this.

[@youssefa.2251]

Fidmark1 You ain't lying. Appreciate your politeness. You didn't disrespect Islam in *ANY* way otherwise you'd feel something feels off. Just keep doing what you love

[@clappedoutmotor]

Thanks for replying man! That's a wonderful comment for you to make. You must be a good person.

[@youssefa.2251]

I think the same about you!

[@gcsparts]

Sleep well pls investigate the music industry and what it involves then comment

[@clappedoutmotor]

Hello, I am in the music industry. I am not involved in commercial pop music or anything like that. The commercial entertainment sector in itself is a pretty nasty place.

[@aAnubis7281]

i don’t understand why music is such a problem it’s literally something people do , or listen to for fun. it has NOTHING to do with shaitan or it isn’t horrible i understand if you don’t want to listen to it because of the lyrics, but their are so many other songs that don’t have explicit lyrics, or it’s just instrumentals. you people act like music is something horrible

[@anandv1391]

Yahh

[@Nomad_eg]

brothers! i was an electronic music producer, had many famous songs (unfortunately) that went around and sadly still going (i cant stop it legally) .... i totally left all of this for Allah, the potential of fame and everything associated with it. i totally stopped that, even stopped listening to anything at all! please pray for me that Allah forgives me for the music i cannot stop spreading! pleaaase! thank you

[@hanaa1776]

Biggest nonsense of this century....

[@itiswhatitis2100]

Your comment?

[@moonchit9818]

When you play music you move your feet your finger and eventually your body...and you move your body like saying "yes this is my body,, sexy right? Funny right? Beautiful right?" And shaitan is whispering to you.. you see when minor sins get many in the process you will eventually get to the next level to major sin... you see in the clubs? Why do you think there is music and people dancing to each other and touching each other? Why do you think so?

[@ayukamirayuime7050]

tbh i think it depends on what music you listen to because believe me, there are some songs tht changed me for the better, ( example, no more dream - BTS which is a song that encourages me to find sth i want to do with my life and to study. MAMA - Jhope , a song that makes me appreciate my mother more. spine Breaker -BTS a song that makes me feel ashamed for being spoilt to my parents and so therefore i do chores more often, listen to my parents more, and respect them more) this is why i'm pretty selective of the songs i listen to, esp when it comes to lyrics, though i must admit, its pretty tough to find songs that have meaningful lyrics. but i think as long as it doesnt distract you from Allah and does not make you forget Allah, ( some of these songs actually remind me of Allah believe it or not) its ok, but make sure to listen to the quran more as it is for the better. May Allah guide us all, ameen

[@vsilligirlbestie3973]

Ayuka Mirayuime Completely agreed to you.....

[@vsilligirlbestie3973]

iNinja Man wow.....! Hi!

[@shahidajabeen8199]

i too agree with you on this point since their songs have no ill meaning to them rather their songs reprimand us from some of the bad things were doing Im a huge fan of BTS and have listened to all of their songs and they all hold a deep meaning to them.

[@relchan489]

hai i just want to tell u with good intention ,did u know that whistling in(bts-DNA)(the whole song have whistling, no wonder that single is so explode the chart, did u ever wonder about that, i agree with u about some of their song,do help us beign better human.(im a BTS fan 2 )but, since i repent,...Allah show me things that i don see when im blind in (entertainment) its is satan's(whistling) entertainment,if u know the general muslim knowledge,(may Allah open the eyes of all muslims,ameen) assalamualaikum(enough u answer when u read it)*regarding my salam*

[@ayukamirayuime7050]

waalaikumsalaam~ thank you for voicing out your opinion on what you think, but i'm abit confused on what you're trying to say... :')) is whistling considered a sin? i thought it was just women that are told not to whistle as much, especially in Maghrib... honestly, i feel like people misunderstand the ban on music in islam..when they try to say music is haraam they always go to the verse saying its haraam. but in the qur'an it also said to kill ourselves for repenting and alot of other things, but that was for back in the days, and does not apply to now, in fact, it is haraam to kill ourselves now. so what i'm trying to say is, i feel like music was banned back then because people WORSHIP it SOOOO much to the point the neglect Allah and make music as their God, which is performing shirk. But nowadays, only people who are REALLY crazy would actually worship music and other things. I understand where you're coming from, but i feel as if as long as it doesnt make me shirk. and as long as it has no bad meanings and it doesnt corrupt me, as long as it does not make me turn away from Allah, it is fine. We also shouldnt listen to too much music anyway. There are some music that pulls me closer to Allah actually, this is why i'm pretty selective of my music, but no matter how much i like the artist, i would not 'worship' , heck i wouldnt even go to their concert. i just take the good meanings in their songs, to push me closer to Allah.

[@lynnabao6082]

This guy needs to learn how to philosophically argue. His arguments are full or errors and way too emotional.

[@yub2.045]

Lynna Bao Since this video is directed to Muslims, philosophical arguments are of no value. We Muslims obey Allaah and the Prophet with no question, for we believe it is the best for us, even though we may not know the reason behind it. As for non-Muslims, their scientific "facts" tell them music is beneficial and good. We Muslims disagree. It's pointless to attempt to convince them, because even if the video were to argue philosophically, they most likely won't listen because they have their science and they believe in it. Moreover, a large population of the world thinks Muslims are barbaric extremists and terrorists, which just narrows down the chances of them listening to our views even more. So, do you think there is any point in changing the style of the argument?

[@rimbax9752]

Muhammad798 well said brother 👌👌

[@fatimaachy5764]

Muhammad798 most Muslims are good people but not Islam

[@gamingbad5820]

Fatima Achy If you only knew the true Islam, you’d find peace and success. لا إله إلا الله

[@joed.9273]

@@yub2.045 You sound like a nazi ,just a religious one.

[@user-ev4lq5fr1o]

How music damaged me? Well it made really lazy...and distracted...there will be times when I would be upset about something...I would see red and I would see the need to take an action, but then I would put on my headphones, play Coldplay or selena, and then all of a sudden, the storm inside me would leave...the urge to take action would die with single beat of the music because music would calm everything inside me...and after listening to 20 or 30 songs, I would be back at my regular shallow lazy "everything gonna be okay" attitude...its been a month since I quit music...I know I still listen to music that is present in the background of a video...or the music in tiktoks, but at least I broke a terrible pattern...I deleted all songs from my phone...instead I downloaded some podcasts of my fav speakers...I listen to them while working, while going out...and it's more dope than My previous playlist...tbh, Russell brand is more interesting than selena or taylor...sandeep maheshwari is more interesting than Coldplay or sia...Jordan poeterson is more interesting than Billie eillish...I also downloaded Ted talks...you can easily quit music ...all u need is a better alternative...if u need a music dopamine...sami yusuf made really soothing Islamic tracks...(with and without music) there are several naats and nohas which give me goosebumps...so all you gotta do.....is decide....now when I have upgraded my playlisit....Im finally resuming the thesis that was pending for 1 and a half year....also I'm discovering other research ideas that will add value...I can focus way better on whatever I am reading .... (previously, reading was a torture to me because music was more appealing to me than articles) try this...you ll have a positive change in your life...

[@lililoves6920]

Thanks.....I needed this😊 Subscribed just after seeing this

[@bushra1414]

please pray for me to follow the way of islam

[@LeviPaladin]

Jesus died for your sins and was raised for your justification. Eternal life is found with Him.

[@ohyeahyeah2698]

Everyone is brainwashed anyway

[@LeviPaladin]

@@ohyeahyeah2698 Maybe you're brainwashed into thinking everyone else is...

[@LeviPaladin]

@Susan lol yep

[@LeviPaladin]

@Susan It's Christ or eternal suffering. gl

[@gcsparts]

Music will fight against the words of God in your heart. The one thats got more influence over you will overtake u i guess

[@lordgainz5192]

So if you suffer from depression and a song tells you not to commit suicide you should not listen to the song and go ahead and commit suicide?

[@ashah8656]

Lord Gainz you should use the aql your lord gave you, in Islam suicide is haram. So you do not commit because you care for your lord and the hereafter, not for the song.

[@outgunss]

Music says just dont, because you dont need to... youre a beautiful people. İslam says if you suicide god will burn you forever. I prefer music

[@rasheenaalfaro3833]

Masha Allah, very well explained. May Allah reward the speaker and everyone behind this channel. I really needed this. SubhanAllah. Alhamdulillah.

[@Sunny-ie9kf]

Okay what about EDM. Now days it's popular where we just listen music without words or singing vocals. Is it okay to listen that kinda music? Please ghuide me

[@nelson1485]

You can listen to any music you like, if god exists I'm sure he would have given us the ability to enjoy and create music for a reason.

[@zeeshanbinnaushadnujjoo1389]

​@@nelson1485and you can to listening music songs but not too much because if you listening music songs too much you feel sad

[@zeeshanbinnaushadnujjoo1389]

​@@nelson1485But i do listening music and listening quran

[@stellarose8186]

Right now I’m on the verge of not listening to music iv stopped listening to heavy hip hop / pop music Some time ago But now I’m also trying stop stop listening to kpop even through its doesn’t have really dirty heavy lyrics it’s really hard to give it up especially my favourite groups like itzy and twice I’m trying to give it up but what it helping me is that every time I always remind myself of that this world is a test and it’s all for the sake of ALLAH that you should stop trust me it’s not easy but remind ourself of ALLAH’s promise of those who listen to him and those who ignore him Remember that it’s all for the sake of ALLAH and Music is one of the easiest traps shaytan uses Always remember ALLAH and listen to the Quran it’s much better

[@hadishams5732]

Allah will reward you in akheera with something even better brother, lower your gaze from haram and keep your ears save too, I wish all the best👍✨

[@stellarose8186]

Hadi Shams Thank you so much 😊

[@alexojideagu]

That's a Wahabi Salafi interpretation. Not a single Islamic country bans Musical Instruments. The UAE has a huge musical traditional dance using music.

[@taeilstoes4875]

I listen to music when I’m doing me school work or in the car with my family because fun times but once it’s time for maghrib we put Quran. I listen to kpop and collect albums but never have I thought about leaving my religion or doing something sinful, you know? Idk I don’t worship music. I tried listen to Quran while doing school work but it’s so peaceful that I end up falling asleep and not completing and of my schoooooool work😔. Idk bro this is very hard because idk it’s not backing me away from my religion, y only know? It’s like a hobby

[@stellarose8186]

@@taeilstoes4875 Yh I know how you feel but every time you listen to music and can’t stop the temptations you are falling into shaytan’s trap That is what he wants you to do he wants to to leave the religion remember what he said about sitting in the path of everyone blocking them from Turing to ALLAH Music is easily one of the easiest traps he can use ever against Muslims Trust me it’s hard at first but you would get used to it. And every time you want to listen to music remember the punishment of ALLAH and the PROMISE of ALLAH

[@vivaciouslyla9294]

There is this song called "Youth" by Khalid and Shawn Mendes that came out very recently. I've been listening to it because it is completely clean, melodic, and at the end all the music stops and a man starts praying and saying "SubhanAllah" under a rising sun. The scene is incredibly beautiful. Is this type of music halal?

[@MS17123]

No because musical instruments ur haram except the duff on some on some occasions becAuse the duff is only allowed on eid or ramadan

[@AC-mp7cx]

This is a difference of opinion

[@mylordtakemeaway]

totally forbidden - any sounds that take place instead of the Qur'an is Satan deceiving us

[@MS17123]

Also nasheeds without instruments are also aloud

[@salma1491]

Thank you for opening my eyes

[@gentlepengua5651]

Music isn't haram. This video is talking nonsense, and it generalizes music by saying "oh, this music is bad so ALL music is bad". This is the same logic people use when islamaphobes that Muslims are bad. "well, these Muslims did wrong things so ALL Muslims are bad".

[@salma1491]

@@gentlepengua5651 I think acapella is fine but I get what you mean not all songs have bad meanings

[@TowardsTruth191]

Dear practical Islam, I would like to inform you that you posted a video about singing and music, with nasheed mentioned and described as a part of music, you might not realize but this is hypocrisy brother.. Please be aware and remove it, you are spreading the message of Allah and his messenger Mohammed peace be upon him, others will not trust your channel, they will think that you are not true to your words. Fellow sisters and brothers, please like my comment, so it can be recognized by this beautiful islamic channel. و السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته.

[@myst717]

The fact that they used music in this video

[@ygkitten8810]

The only problem with this is that not all songs are like that and that some talk about real problems and raise awerness over problems people deal these days with

[@fzzablue7638]

May Allah keep us away from things that distract us from our purpose and may Allah help purify our heart so we become closer to Him ameen.

[@skeptical_citizen]

No, music is a universal language, it is what human beings have used to connect to one another. One can listen to music that doesn't go against their beliefs, there is so much variety. You talk about fornication, but everyone doesn't believe that is wrong. There are countless songs that are about marriage. Stop looking through the world through the lens of what you believe in, everyone doesn't have to believe in what you do.

[@globalislamicreminders]

Ya Allah music is everywhere in our homes and even our cars! I hope I can let go of it .. because I have also been guilty of listening to music . I am 19 ☠️😖

[@mayshar6583]

Amir Khan May Allah help you in your way 🙂

[@xux4670]

Even like when you turn on your televisions, every single ad, every single drama is full of Music. It's hard for us Muslims as everything nowadays has Music. Some Idiot people started using instruments and singing Allah's name with it and stuff. They shouldn't but I don't even know how to stop them. 😕

[@LegendarySieni]

Brother, you can listen to whatever your heart desires. These are just the words of scared little children refusing to grow up, making up rules for others to hide their insecurity. Music is a part of humanity and our legacy. The teachings of the quran are man made, just like the bible and tora. You can respect them for what they are, but they do not represent our current times

[@xux4670]

LegendarySieni Quran is not man made. Bible and tora have stuff edited into them but Quran is so not man made. It has things written inside of it that were from the future, how do you think that man knew so much deep about the future? It has heaven described in it. It has the day of judgement described in it. If you haven't read it, you have no right to mutter bullshit about it. Better to keep quiet rather than speak shit about The Holy Quran as you've probably never even touched it or seen it. Kindly get your brains into their right orders. 😡 P.S. God said that Quran is the only book that will remained unchanged til the end of the world.

[@Bazzemboi]

@@abdosoleiman4228 this only applies for music because music makes you want to dance.

[@shush5719]

I am confused... Are you allowed to listen to songs that are not Islamic and don’t contain lyrics such as drugs, alcohol, and girls.

[@aspirewot8408]

There is also a scientific reasons why music is haram or bad for us . It has been proven by many neuroscientists that music manipilates and effects our brains neurotransmitters like dopamine . And this is why music makes us feel euphoric, emotional and sometimes addictive . If you don't believe me you can search on internet

[@potatolord2354]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/r4m6hKRrit54iNE

[@no.username.available7831]

I was reading comments and I'll not say anything about anyone because i don't think i have right to say so ,but for me its like i am a person who get depress in winters , at dim light or in evening , i feel anxiety and feel like stressed out I can't even explain the feeling. I listened music to get rid of all these feeling but all music do for me is make is more cry amd depress than i already is , than i started listen Surah Rehman for my depression.....Arabic is not my first language but ofc i have read the meaning of alot of Surah so i listen the Surah Rehman and I feel this different feeling run in my body like my heart feel like i can't explain it feel like relax and peaceful ,like my body tickles, sometimes due to this feeling tears left my eyes but then next minute i feel like i did it! I don't know what i did but i feel like i did it. I feel Happy and relax after listening this Surah more than music

[@karimtit4897]

"Why Islam is haram to music lovers (or anyone with an IQ higher than 90)" 😉 I choose Mozart, Bach, Debussy, Beethoven, over bigotted religion anyday. In fact, I never felt so close to God as I listen to Mozart's Requiem. The true God let his truth shine not in old religious books, but in the beauty of nature, mathematics and profound music. God is much better than all your little human religions and petty laws. The Universe is made up of 100 000 000 000 galaxies. And each of this Galaxy contains about 100 000 000 000 stars. God does not care about you.

[@aspirewot8408]

There is also a scientific reasons why music is haram or bad for us . It has been proven by many neuroscientists that music manipilates and effects our brains neurotransmitters like dopamine . And this is why music makes us feel euphoric, emotional and sometimes addictive . If you don't believe me you can search on internet

[@karimtit4897]

@@aspirewot8408 "manipilates" How about learning some proper english first ? From the Neuroscience of music article, written by expert in the field: "According to the National Institute of Health, children and adults who are suffering from emotional trauma have been able to benefit from the use of music in a variety of ways. The use of music has been essential in helping children who struggle with focus, anxiety, and cognitive function by using music in therapeutic way. Music therapy has also helped children cope with autism, pediatric cancer, and pain from treatments. " Music can cure your emotional problems, it's called music therapy en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Music_therapy. Food and sex also trigger dopamine you ignorant. Anything that gives you pleasure passes through dopamine. Shoud sex and eating be haram too ? There is not one neuroscientist in the world who says music is bad for you. It's the opposite. Neuroscientists showed that listening to classical music like Mozart or Bach increases your intelligence. Listening to certain type of music, like jazz can relax your brain and increase your creativity You need to start reading other books than the Quran, and expand your mind. This is pathetic and sad.

[@aspirewot8408]

@@karimtit4897 food and sex does trigger , but it doesn't effect as much as music does . People listen to music often . We only eat food or have sex when we need to ( unless you're addicted to that too ) . This is why when people are sad or depressed they smoke weed or do drugs they live in a fake world ( fake pleasure which is temporary ) . But people who don't they just listen to music . It's same thing it effects your neurotransmitters in a bad way if you over do it and that is why you get bored of listening to the same music and you crave for good music . And about the research you searched it's a different one , remember meth was allowed few decades back ? Pilots and army men used meth to stay alert lol , but people over abused it and it had side effects so they made it illegal and the reason we read Qur'an is because it's a word of our creator who created this beautiful universe . If you don't read Qur'an that means you're disrespecting our creator duh

[@karimtit4897]

@@aspirewot8408 "Evidence suggests that music therapy is beneficial for all individuals, both physically and mentally. Benefits of music therapy include improved heart rate, reduced anxiety, stimulation of the brain, and improved learning. Music therapists use their techniques to help their patients in many areas, ranging from stress relief before and after surgeries to neuropathologies such as Alzheimer's disease. One study found that children who listened to music while having an IV inserted into their arms showed less distress and felt less pain than the children who did not listen to music while having an IV inserted.[3] Studies on patients diagnosed with mental disorders such as anxiety, depression, and schizophrenia have shown a visible improvement in their mental health after music therapy."

[@karimtit4897]

Music litteraly improves your heart rate, brain functions and happiness. Islam is haram to people who love life.

[@angelacute4340]

this channel is the best 👍👍❤❤❤💟💟

[@yadashisui2964]

Angela Cute!!! Yeah

[@arifnizam3673]

Angela Cute!!! Invite more peoples

[@nusratmasood]

mavsa

[@nusratmasood]

moves and pekcar

[@sajidmoiz3587]

Nusrat Masood sana moiz

[@TimSoden-p6w]

I play a banjo was never interested in music until the age of 73 years, one attribute of music is that it can be used to celebrate the existence and praise god, a song called “amazing grace” celebrates the experience of finding God through grace and returning to praising him so I wonder why this could be wrong. If god gave us a voice surely he meant us to use it. Kind regards ~Tim

[@xpertaab7261]

Inshalah this channel will help me become a better muslim every day

[@idrissnaciri7062]

i listen to music but not the dubstep or hiphop and other i think there is no probleme listenin to Fayrouz,kadhem saher or muhammed abdelwaheb there is meanings in those songs (u can't generalize all the songs cause if this is the case why did they sing to our prophet PBUH Tala'a albadru alaina) i totally agree abt songs who encourages sex,drugs....

[@enikob2766]

Idriss Naciri i agree with you, being halal or haram depends on the lyrics 😊

[@Mobslayer-dp3nu]

Yes I also agree

[@abdulkhaderhussainabba1076]

U know whether the music is in nasheed songs or haram songs music is haram.Because u know I was also listening to nasheed with music and my mind was diverting to haram things by this we come to know that werever the music is it creates fitna and a black spot in our heart