NEW SERIES! How Should Muslims View Hadith? | Dr. Shabir Ally

[@asgar_ali_263]

Shabir Ally, respectfully, you're literally a genius in bringing complicated concepts such as Hadiths and Quranic interpretations in a very concise manner.

[@bodymind195]

Congrats for your concern and comment

[@YSl11]

The overlords of Sunni Islam will not dare to remove a hadith with questionable content. If people begin to question the authenticity of the chains, then the whole narrative falls apart. They can’t let go of their control and let the Quran free people as it is meant to!! Thank you Dr. Shabbir Ally!! It’s time to break the chains!!

[@peterhwang352]

But who will free people from the chains of the Quran?

[@YSl11]

@@peterhwang352What chains are you referring to?

[@batlefieldproes]

@@YSl11 dont worry about him he is ignorant person

[@mekhimkl2702]

Who are these "overlords"?

[@YSl11]

@@mekhimkl2702the Islamic University’s, the scholars, wahabis and salafist

[@QabilAGhor]

I have researched this subject as much as I could with my limited knowledge. Here is what I have discovered: The oldest and the most authentic book of Hadith is Imam Malik's Muwatta. Shah Waliullah Dehlawi considered it to be more authentic than Bukhari and Sahih Muslim. After reading it, I agree. It doesn't have much of the nonsense that you find in other books of Hadiths. Muslim scholars don't take it seriously because it doesn't have "isnad." But, amazingly, many of Hadiths reported in Bukhari and Sahih Muslim are actually copied from Muwatta. So if Isnad is truly important, a good solution would be to standardize Muwatta and borrow Isnad from Bukhari and other books. That's a huge effort, which might take many years, but it would be worthwhile. Having said that, Muwatta does have some flaws, which inadvertently found their way into other Hadith books. Imam Malik quoted some Hadiths using Hisham Ibn Urwa and Abu Huraira. I think both are highly suspect. It seems that Hisham had gone senile [people in Iraq took advantage of it] and Abu Huraira simply wasn't trustworthy. Either they or their names were used to create Hadiths in order to "reconcile" facts which were hard to justify. One of these was the issue of a report of Ayesha having figurines, even though other Muslims were forbidden form do so to discourage idol-worshipping. In those days, when Islam was in an existential struggle against paganism, this was scandalous. This was handled by lowering Ayesha's age to 9, because children 9 and under were allowed to keep figurines as toys. Yet, it did not fully resolve the issue, even though they tried to cover it up There is evidence that Aisha kept dolls even when she had grown up, and it can be found from this Hadith: Abu Dawud Book 41, Number 4914: Narrated Aisha, Ummul Mu’minin: “When the Apostle of Allah (peace_be_upon_him) arrived after the expedition to Tabuk or Khaybar (the narrator is doubtful), the draught raised an end of a curtain which was hung in front of her store-room, revealing some dolls which belonged to her. He asked: What is this? She replied: My dolls. Among them he saw a horse with wings made of rags, and asked: What is this I see among them? She replied: A horse. He asked: What is this that it has on it? She replied: Two wings. He asked: A horse with two wings? She replied: Have you not heard that Solomon had horses with wings? She said: Thereupon the Apostle of Allah (peace_be_upon_him) laughed so heartily that I could see his molar teeth.” [Abu Daawood, An-Nasaa’iee as-Sunan al-Kubraa, Albani (ra) says the chain of narrators of an-Nasaa’ee is authentic (Saheeh). As for the chain of narrators of Abu Daawood, Albani (ra) has also declared it to be authentic (saheeh)] The expedition to Tabuk took place in 9.A.H and to Khabar at 7 A.H. If it is assumed that Aishah got married in 1 A.H at the age of nine, then even at age of 16 or 18 she must have still kept her dolls. Therefore, using dolls to establish her age doesn’t make any sense. In Sahih Muslim, there are two Ahadith but it says that they are narrated from Hisham, See Book 31, #5982, which I believe came from Muwatta and Iraq (the epicenter of fake Hadiths). That the keeping of figurines and the hadith above have been a topic of discussion for Muslim scholars. And because of obvious contradictions, the ulemaa have either glossed over it or have tried to explain to by making Aisha (r.a.) seem like a little girl. The following are some examples of this flawed thinking: Al-Haafidh Ibn Hajar said in Fath al-Baaree (Fath al-Baaree, no. 6130, Kitaab: al-Adab, Baab: al-Inbisaat ilaa an-Naas): This Hadith has been used as a proof for the permissibility of possessing (suwar - of) dolls and toys for the purpose of the little girls playing with them. This has been especially exempted from the general prohibition of possession of images (suwar). Al-Khattaabee said: From this hadith it is understood that playing with dolls (al- banaat) is not like the amusement from other images (suwar) concerning which the threat (wa’eed) of punishment is mentioned. The only reason why permission in this was given to Aisha (RA) is because she had not, at that time, reached the age of puberty. [al-Haafidh says:] I say: To say with certainty, (that she was not yet at the age of puberty) is questionable, though it might possibly be so. This, because Aisha (RA) was a fourteen year old girl at the time of the battle of Khaibar, either exactly fourteen years old, or having just passed her fourteenth year (and entering into the fifteenth year), or approaching it (the fourteenth year). As for her age at the time of the Battle of Tabook, she had by then definitely reached the age of puberty. Therefore, the strongest view is that of those who said: “It was in Khaibar” (i.e., when she was not yet at the age of puberty), and made reconciliation (jam’) [between the apparent contradictory rulings, of permissibility of dolls, in particular, and the prohibition of images, in general] with what al-Khattaabee said (all young girls). This, because to reconcile (make jam’) is better than to assume the ahaadith to be in contradiction (at-ta’aarud). [End of quotation from al-Haafidh Ibn Hajar]. (Fath al-Baree) So from these notes, you can get an idea why her age was adjusted!

[@thetruth27786]

Ive been waiting again for this....the last series on hadeeth use did couple of years ago has truly helped me and i make dua for use whenever i can.Cant wait for more vids on this

[@Hassan_Omer]

Thank you Dr. Shabir and Dr. Safiyyah for talking about this subject, jazakAllah khairan.

[@doneracer5994]

I hope one of the topics you cover is music because I am a classical musician and member of an orchestra. As an orchestra member, I do not choose what I will play, and therefore I have played pieces such as Handel's 'Messiah', Bach's 'Christmas Oratorio', and Vivaldi's 'Gloria'-- all Christian music. I have been investigating Islam but there are so many "hidden" laws and opinions about what is and is not permitted that I am awash in confusion about what Islam is really about regarding music. I hope you will talk about Western classical (Baroque) music, c.1600-1750. Thank you.

[@abdar-rahman6965]

*On this subject, first of all we must raise these questions, and answer these questions:* 1- Did Rasool leave behind any manuscript of Sunnah or Hadiths? No 2- Did even 4 Caliphs leave behind any manuscript of Sunnah and Hadiths? No 3- Did Rasool place ban on his hadiths during his life? yes 4- Did 4 Caliphs place ban on hadiths during their Governments? Yes So, it is very clear that extra-Quranic Hadiths and Sunnah are illegal in Islam, and faith cannot be built on those illegal books which were concocted much after the death of Prophet, after the death of 4 Caliphs and after the death of all Sahaaba (companions of Prophet). *Because, neither Rasool nor even four caliphs "IN PERSON" certified any story of hadith, therefore, morally, logically, rationally and legally, we cannot classify any report of hadith as Authentic (Sahih). If not Authentic, then is Inauthentic. Now a rational question arises, which is: should we Muslims build our rituals and faith on this kind of Inauthentic stories? No.* *To Sump Up:* *Because Rasool and even 4 Caliphs left behind only written Quran, therefore; after landing of Quran, Islam=Quran; Full Stop. Any Sharia law (Islamic Law) or Rite or Namaz Ritual which does not have roots in Glorious Quran is absolutely not part of Deen al-Islam.* Besides; Quran declares those people Unbelievers who make Sharia laws from other books than Book of God 5:44, 6:114, 28:85. According to Quran 5:44, 6:114, from past 1200 years, those people who have been making Sharia laws from other books save Quran, were/are unbelievers. Quran never permits sects 3:103. According to Quran, sect followers are OUT from the fold of Islam 6:159, and Hell is waiting for Sect Followers 3:105. God has named all true followers of all prophets only MUSLIMS; not Shia and Sunni 22:78. Quranic Salat has nothing to do with those five Zoroastrian Namaz Rituals (Idol Worship) which were imported from Zoroastrians, and then were validated through forgery of Hadith of Flying Horse "Buraq". Quran does not ordain to kiss black stone during Hajj. So, kissing black stone is not rite of Islamic Hajj but was part of Hajj of Pre-Quranic Pagans. Quran never ordains to prostrate to Kaaba during Rituals. That kind of Prostration (Idol Worship) was done by Pre-Quranic Pagans. During Hajj, Quran never ordains to walk seven rounds around Cube made of Stones and Cement. So, that is not part of Islamic Hajj but it used to be a part of practices of Meccan Pagans. Meaning of *"Obey Allah and Rasool"* is nothing else but to follow that Divine Book which Allah Azza wa Jal delivered to people through his Rasool, and name of that Book is Quran 6:19, 6:114, 28:85, 15:9, 17:88, 41:42. Rasool was bound to follow only Quran 6:114, 28:85. so, we Muslims are also bound to follow only Quran for the matters of Deen al-Islam. Quran has made very clear in several verses that Job assigned to Rasool by God was *NO MORE THAN* to deliver Quran Clearly. Nowhere term "Sunnah of Rasool" appears in whole Quran nor Quran ordains to follow Sunnah of Rasool. Quran tells that Rasool could not guide people toward RIGHT PATH 2:272, 28:56, 72:21; then what Sunnah and what Hadith? When a Mortal man 18:110 was unable to guide people toward Right Path (72:21>Rashada); then how could he guide people through his Sunnah and Hadiths which he never left behind in the form of manuscript? Quran talks about Oswat-Hasana of Prophet Ibrahim and Prophet Mohammad but did those two prophets leave behind for us any manuscript of Oswat-Hasana? No. They were not in need of leaving behind such manuscript because their Authentic Oswat-Hasana is incorporated within Quran. This is why: Aisha RA said: The Quran is Akhlaaq of Rasool-Allah القرآن فإن خلق رسول الله *A True Muslim is absolutely not in need of to know about Prophet Mohammad PBUH more than what is given in Glorious Quran 68:4*

[@waymilky442]

Go away Quranist!

[@bodymind195]

Along with dr Sabir we must appreciate the contribution by this woman scholar in enlightening the Ummah in this difficult times

[@walkingwith_dinosaurs]

Dr Safiyah is one of the best repsentatives of Muslim women🤍

[@defeatedpoet6377]

Looking forward to this new series. Thank you for making it happen.

[@sarahalhulail4928]

Thank you both. You are doing very crucial work at this time in our Islamic history in such a gentle reasonable manner.

[@blumachine]

It was very telling when I grew up and realised all the islamaphobic talking points were from Hadiths and not Quran. And any Quranic verses were misconstrued with the help of Hadiths.

[@ahmedbaseer1]

Dr Shabbir Ally specifically mentions Ayesha RA age at marriage as 9 Hadith problematic. I used to be confused on this as well. In another book I read her age was around 30 same as Hafsa RA as she was present in a battle helping wounded soldiers and 9 year old would be too young to be present in the battlefield. Just sharing my opinion here as I came to another conclusion. This is just my own personal opinion you may use it if you like to reconcile it. The Arabs had a different method of counting ages for females. The 9 years refers to years after her period or when she became adult. The way they measured ages for females was different back then. So if she got her period at 18, her actual age was 27. Or period at 14, her actual age was 23. Keeping in mind story of her presence in battle period at 21 actual age 30. In essence her real age is unknown and definitely not 9 as mentioned in the hadith. Allah knows best!!!! Excellent series this will be. And much needed.

[@oversteer6771]

Reading Hadiths in bukhari is why I am no longer Sunni

[@oversteer6771]

@@hm4084 no I just don’t accept nonsense and degrading things said about my prophet

[@blumachine]

What was the last straw? For me it was the pointing at the black stone and saying Allahu Akbar. And women being created ungrateful and dumb, lol.

[@batlefieldproes]

@@blumachine what is about black stone ? hadith says kissing it is only doing it because the prophet did but it is not obligatory and does not benefit you in any way shape or form. that is what the companion Umar bin khatab said after he kissed the black stone. And about women prophet said he saw more women in hell than men. why do you have problems with this ? are you Allah? you dont dictate what happens in the world.

[@blumachine]

@@batlefieldproes why isn't it mentioned in the Quran if it's been there since before prophet muhammad? also, thats not the only reason why people kiss it, they also believe it wipes away your sins. astaghfirullah. source: (8) Touching the Stone is one of the things by means of which Allah expiates for sins It was narrated that Ibn ‘Umar said: I heard the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) say: “Touching them both [the Black Stone and al-Rukn al-Yamani] is an expiation for sins.” (Narrated by al-Tirmidhi, 959. This hadeeth was classed as hasan by al-Tirmidhi and as saheeh by al-Haakim (1/664). Al-Dhahabi agreed with him). now onto the women hadith, the narrator doesn't even remember which eid it occured on. also, women being created with deficiency in religion because of their menses is an insult to Allah's creation and justness. if we are obeying Allah by not praying during menses, why then are we classified as "deficient"? you and eveyrone else who follows such hadiths are guessing at the unseen, the prophet did not leave us hadith, he left us the Quran and anything beyond that is unseen. Only Allah knows for certain what was said.

[@batlefieldproes]

@@blumachine thats the problem with the internet today makes everyone a scholar .... If you kiss your mom on the forehead out of love allah may expiate your sins for that action. Does that mean you are now worshiping your mom's head? the answer is no . likewise kissing the black stone. May allah guide you to islam anyway. you are making up your own version of islam now .

[@muhammedkadiri2028]

Excited!

[@rayfranklin5783]

Looking forward to this new series!!

[@RAF0769]

Looking forward to digging in to this series! Thank you

[@mekhimkl2702]

I appreciate the way that your thinking continues to evolve on this and other matters. It shows that you do as we are commanded to do: READ. STUDY. THINK CRITICALLY. and ALWAYS ORIENT BACK TO THE QURAN.

[@larryhassan2889]

Allah bless Dr Sabir and am happy finally this topic is here for us to learn

[@negeto2460]

Another question for Traditional Muslims: Which hadeeth or Ahadeeth did prophet Muhammad (a.s) follow? Since the Qur'an is described as the BEST HADEETH (ahsanal hadeeth) and instructs the prophet to follow what was revealed to him, which hadeeth did he follow and adhere to? The Qur'an even goes further to say: "" Do they not look into the realm of the heavens and the earth and everything that Allāh has created and [think] that perhaps their appointed time has come near? So in what STATEMENT (hadeethin) [i.e., message] hereafter will they believe? "" {7:185} "" These are the verses of Allāh which We recite to you in truth. Then in what STATEMENT (hadeethin) after Allāh and His verses will they believe? "" {45:6} "" Then let them produce a STATEMENT (hadeethin) like it, if they should be truthful "" {52:34} Is there any evidence from the Qur'an that Muhammad (a.s) recieved Hadeeths other than this Qur'an?? We have the following posibilities: A) - the prophet followed the Hadeeth of Allah (Qur'an) ALONE. B - the prophet followed the Hadeeth of Allah (Qur'an) and also his own hadeeths. The choice is yours 😊 Peace

[@dayibabdi781]

“GOD took a covenant from the prophets, saying, “I will give you the scripture and wisdom. Afterwards, a messenger will come to confirm all existing scriptures.” [3:81] “Just as We have sent among you a messenger from yourselves reciting to you Our verses and purifying you and teaching you the Book (ie Quran) and wisdom (ie.sunnah) teaching you that which you did not know.” (2:151) “We raised the Messengers earlier with Clear Signs and Divine Books, and We have now sent down this Reminder (ie..Quran) upon you that you may elucidate to people the teaching that has been sent down for them,and that the people may themselves reflect.” Allah informs us he has given the prophet the Quran and the hikma ie…the sunnah of the prophet on how to follow Islam

[@user-k229]

We have abandoned the Quran in favour of man-made hadith! The hadith to the Muslims, without realising it, are. just like the Gospels! The Gospels are according to Mathew, Mark, Lake and John. The hadith are those according to Bukhari! He was born, in what is modern day Iran, Persian.

[@amanaashraf1899]

could you do marriage series-how to choose a spouse,purpose,Islamic way of nikkah,fiqh of mahr etc

[@zainpowell4202]

Great stuff.Looking forward to it.Thanks

[@Sum_Ting_Wong]

Musims have subconsciously elevated the hadith onto the same status as the Quran and have also venerated Muhammad SWS to something beyond a prophet also. Look at Mawlid for example.

[@danielacevedo647]

There's nothing wrong with mawlid . You can honor the prophet pbuh, without venerating him past his station. Hadith is not equal to the Quran and never will be. anything that goes against what the Quran says is blatantly false and must be rejected.

[@waymilky442]

If you hate Mawlid you are the problem! Wahabist!

[@ahmfarooq1823]

How is it possible for a man like Imam Bukhari who is from Uzbekistan, 4500 km from Mecca to collect 6,00,000 hadiths and sorted these out, prove thieir authenticity in those days of rough communication systems? If he had to do this he would have to live thousands of years. And most importantly those were not written documents. However, he rejected 99% of those hadiths. What the hadith followers term ‘science of hadith’ is absurd. There followed no scientific process there. And why they don’t believe the hadith where the Prophet(pbuh) prohibited hadith writing?

[@abu.goldjunge]

I am delighted that Dr. Shabir Ally has created such a video. It undoubtedly takes a great deal of courage, as it also provides a platform for Islamophobes. However, considering the widespread dissemination of such views, it becomes all the more important for someone like Dr. Shabir Ally to confront them and provide answers to us young Muslims. May Allah reward him abundantly and grant him a long life to continue enriching us with his knowledge. Barak Allahu feek. Greetings from Europe.

[@grahamashe9715]

Please tackle the question of the compulsory nature of the daily prayers and fasting in Ramadan. Muslims and non-Muslims alike dare not ask it. It seems to me that it would make more sense if these rituals were optional so that people are more sincere when they do them. People cannot be “forced” or feel pressured to meditate or pray. It’s a red flag for me as far as religions go. Furthermore, medical science has shown that dry fasting (like in Ramadan) is NOT recommended for most people. Again, the one true God would most likely not make such things compulsory such that people have to do them whether they like it or not, whether they want to or not… all under the threat of punishment for committing a grave sin.

[@littlecouchpotato]

Fasting and prayers have been established since the time of the prophet. No one is forcing you to do anything. It is up to you whether you submit to Allah or not. Allah speaks about the importance of prayers and fasting in the Quran multiple times through out. We as Muslims follow the Quran and try our best to follow what Allah commands of us. May Allah guide us and make us strong in our faith.

[@walkingwith_dinosaurs]

Finally the Aisha's age hadith will be defeated! Yay!!!🤸‍♀️💃🕺

[@deliranteotaku]

Thank you for the new series❤

[@choolaimedudude6284]

Assalamualaikum Warahmatullah Wabarakatuh, I am a New Revert. Me & my parents are facing lots of problems due to Black Magic by my Uncle & Aunties. How do i handle Black Magic? Plz advise.

[@choolaimedudude6284]

@user-uo9on4kk3m Thank you Brother. I wish Allah bless ur kindness

[@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411]

Read ayatul kursi after every prayer. It protects you. Also stop following up this KZbin channel and find an actual Islamic scholar to follow.

[@user-k229]

Dr Ally and Dr Saffiyah you are both truly a breath of fresh air. To highlight the major issues with hadith is a momentous task and I applaud you for your openess and bravery. For too long our uneducated mullahs and Peers have held a tight grip on the nonsense that is contained in many man-made hadith! Allah swt ONLY SENT US QURAN! HE DID NOT SEND US OTHER hadith. ITS TIME MUSLIMS WOKE UP AND STOPPED DOING WHAT THE CHRISTIANS ARE ALSO BLINDLY DOING, THAT IS ACCEPTING MAN MADE GOSPELS. The hadith of Bukhari, etc are MAN made Gospels. ✨️✨️✨️✨️✨️✨️✨️✨️

[@Fareeha_Saleem]

10:38 waiting for series

[@davidbates3353]

5:20 So he's saying that they're trusted when they're viewed as benign but discard them when they present difficulties? What kind of standard is that?! Are they trustworthy or not? You can't just assume they're okay as long as they're not presenting anything troubling.

[@tradelayer]

I hope the Qudsi Hadith are covered later in the series.

[@suratunbegum7506]

Good video.

[@scaleartsg]

sometimes the context of which the hadith came about has been lost, making it difficult to fully understand the rationale behind the hadith

[@Quran_Alone_Dawah]

Dear brothers and sisters who think the the Quran is insufficient and follow the hadith, read these ayahs. The Sunni mushriqeen run from these ayahs: And in anything over which you disagree - *its ruling is [to be referred] to Allah.* [Say], "That is Allah , my Lord; upon Him I have relied, and to Him I turn back." 42:10 "One day We shall raise from all Peoples a witness against them, from amongst themselves: and We shall bring thee as a witness against these (thy people): and We have sent down to thee the *Book explaining all things* , a Guide, a Mercy, and Glad Tidings to Muslims." 16:89 "O People of the Scripture, there has come to you Our Messenger making clear to you much of what you used to conceal of the Scripture and overlooking much. There has come to you from Allah *a light and a clear Book* ." 5:15 "Alif, Lam, Ra. These are the verses of the *Book and a clear Qur'an* ." 15:1 "Shall I seek other than Allah for judge, when He it is Who hath *revealed unto you (this) Scripture, fully explained* ? Those unto whom We gave the Scripture (aforetime) know that it is revealed from thy Lord in truth. So be not thou (O Muhammad) of the waverers." 6:114 " *A Book whose verses have been detailed* , an Arabic Qur'an for a people who know," 41:3 " *Thus do We explain the signs in detail* ; and perchance they may turn (unto Us)." 7:174 "And when We read it, follow thou the reading;" 75:18 "Nay more, *it is for Us to explain it (and make it clear)* : 75:19 "For We had certainly sent unto them a Book, based on knowledge, *which We explained in detail* ,- a guide and a mercy to all who believe." 7:52 "And they do not come to you with an argument except that *We bring you the truth and the best explanation* ." 25:33 " *Allah has sent down the best hadith* : a consistent Book wherein is reiteration. The skins shiver therefrom of those who fear their Lord; then their skins and their hearts relax at the remembrance of Allah. That is the guidance of Allah by which He guides whom He wills. And one whom Allah leaves astray - for him there is no guide." 39:23 "These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. *Then in what hadith after Allah and His verses will they believe?* " 45:6 "Then in what *hadith* after the Qur'an will they believe?" 77:50 So obey Allah, and obey His Messenger: but if ye turn back, *the duty of Our Messenger is but to proclaim (the Message) clearly and openly* . 64:12 "Say, "Obey Allah and obey the Messenger; but if you turn away - then upon him is only that [duty] with which he has been charged, and upon you is that with which you have been charged. And if you obey him, you will be [rightly] guided. *And there is not upon the Messenger except the [responsibility for] clear notification* ." 24:54 *The most merciful* 55:1 "It is *He* Who has taught the Qur'an." 55:2 " *The guiding of them is not thy duty* (O Muhammad), but Allah guideth whom He will. And whatsoever good thing ye spend, it is for yourselves, when ye spend not save in search of Allah's Countenance; and whatsoever good thing ye spend, it will be repaid to you in full, and ye will not be wronged." 2:272 "And We have certainly diversified in this Qur'an for the people from *every [kind of] example* ; *but man has ever been, most of anything, [prone to] dispute.* " 18:54 "Say, " Allah is most knowing of how long they remained. He has [knowledge of] the unseen [aspects] of the heavens and the earth. How Seeing is He and how Hearing! They have not besides Him any protector, and *He shares not His legislation with anyone.* "" 18:26 “You worship not besides Him except [mere] names you have named them, you and your fathers, for which Allah has sent down no authority. *Legislation is not but for Allah.* He has commanded that you worship not except Him. That is the correct religion, but most of the people do not know.” 18:40

[@negeto2460]

The Mushriks (Sunnis and Shia) are blinded by their traditions akhi. They have tossed the Book of Allah behind their backs and exchanged it for their scholars and hadith books.

[@mixedup2917]

Hadiths are the Islamic Knowledge furthest away from being actual word of Allah a lot of it just talks about mundane situations. It’s the weakest link in our sciences it’s the one most often attacked and often the reason why people leave Islam . It’s interesting Knowledge it’s a book of reports that’s all it’s not even .000001 comparable to the Quran and that sounds cliche but it’s not often practiced in everyday Islamic outlook

[@mc1042]

verry professional

[@Kzam19-ux8wg]

Albani came after 1000 yrs and reclassified bukhari. They said he was a mujtahid. And they said mujtahid has no timeframe. Who knows maybe they will be another mujtahid in the future who will reclassify bukhari. And furthermore did every scholar agrees with albani?

[@haroon420]

Ok. I’m excited about this lecture series but if I may just give some positive criticism.. you can’t leave us hanging. You need to provide us with the first episode and not just an introduction. Maybe two videos should’ve been launched on the same day.

[@bodymind195]

Brother..sorry to say a large part of so called educated Ummah perhaps doesn't know..what is Hadith..how came..plus and minuses of science of Hadith and how it has understood the test of times for long ages.. hundreds of years still being relevant..so a short introduction is all welcome.. finally I want to say these people v given perhaps their lives in the service of Ummah so we must be cautious in even

[@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411]

If you thought the series was going to be a deep technical critique of the Hadith you were wrong. It's just Shabir sitting with his daughter giving his opinion on what Muslims should follow. Based on nothing but vibes. Literally gave an example of a Muslim talking to a coworker about Hadith and the non Muslim finding it disagreeable. So a Muslim should just say Hadith is made up to appease non Muslims 🤷‍♂️ It's the most shallow and lazy attempt at denying Hadith.

[@bjmuhyideen5749]

Different Groups different Hadeeth is there. Tabliq, they have theirs own Hadeeth, they Refer the Quran to support their Hadeeth. Jamate-Islam included Hadeeth In The Quran like the Bible corrupted adding people Talks. The Quran says: “That is the Scripture there no doubt guidance to Mutthqeen (those who fear Allah)- 2:2. Again Allah said: “And Hold fast Rope (the Quran) of Allah, don’t become groups.

[@Islamandpeacedawah]

Main is Hadith shoul be in harmony with Quran or match Quran.

[@m.e.e2878]

Love the Seriesssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss.

[@mazeerahamed1956]

OBEY ME’ is not a term reserved just for Prophet Muhammad. 26:108 - Prophet Noah said to his people “Fear Allah and OBEY ME” 26:126 - Prophet Hud said to his people “Fear Allah and OBEY ME” 26:144 - Prophet Salih said to his people “Fear Allah and OBEY ME” 26:163 - Prophet Lut said to his people “Fear Allah and OBEY ME” 26:179 - Prophet Shu’aib said to his people “Fear Allah and OBEY ME” They were commanding obedience to Allah swt’s commands. Just like Prophet Muhammad was. So this term has got ABSOLUTELY NOTHING TO DO WITH SECONDARY SOURCED HADITH like you guys are risking your aakhirah over. Please fix your shirk up

[@negeto2460]

Exactly rite akhi! These misguided fools are brainwashed to think that 'obeying' and 'following' the Messenger means to following external sources. Ignorance is bliss 😊

[@ZIaIqbal]

Salamun Alaikum, What an interesting subject "Let the Quran Speak", but as soon as we get into the discussion, there is no context from the Quran, instead it is all about the traditions, that were collected by people 300+ years after the fact. Let's be honest, if you are talking about the traditions, which include forgeries as you have discussed yourself, let's not do the "Switch and Bait" by using the "Quran" as your topic listing. You are following a religion that is based on the narratives documented by people, which according to your own admission have problems, it is not the religion described in the Quran!

[@negeto2460]

Answer: Hadiths should be viewed as: 'Biased' and inconsistent 'historical' information - Nothing more! 'Biased' because as you know Sunni's have their own hadith collections and the Shia have their own. So, which ones are correct?? It's like a football match - pick your side! There maybe some truth in these hadiths but they are filled with contradictions, superstitions, and outright absurdities. I certainly DO NOT take them as revelation (wahi), nor as a source of guidance (hudan), nor are they authoritative, nor legislative. The ONLY truly authentic hadith is the Qur'an itself my friends. Just go ahead and read what the Qur'an says about Hadith and Sunnah. You will be shocked to find that there is no sunnah or hadith of the prophet! But rather, we find the Hadith of Allah and the Sunnah of Allah! How come no sheikh or Mullah ever talks about the Hadith or the Sunnah of Allah?? Let that sink in...

[@DannyDingobat]

pick and choose whatever you want and call it the only true religion.

[@fatipahad]

COULD YOU GIVE ME A SINGLE HADITH THAT DESCRIBES SALAT FROM BEGINNING TO END.

[@jimmybeam1550]

They used to come at me attacking, yelling, screaming, fatwa decreeing just because i questioned the hadith in narrations i found flawed, absurd, blasphemous and contradicting. Apparently all sahih are 100% undoubtedly sahih even if 2 narrations on same subject contradict between eachother, its all 100%. Weird. They would then say their famous saying: show me how to pray from Quran. They would also say show me zakaat, wudu, hajj. As a convert i did my due diligence and thoroughly went thru the aspects of the religion prior to accepting and i regularly read Quran because i love it. Zakaat, wudud are in Quran, how can they question it. Quran states establish prayer, as in left to people to establish. Prayer is living tradition taught by masses, all hadith discusses prayer as in already established at the outset of the faith and all hadith inventors also prayed, howd they learn? I then read every narration in Book of Prayers in Bukhari n sahih Muslim. The reuslt is this: its impossible to reconstruct prayer thru hadith. So when they ask me 'show me how to pray from Quran, you kufr', i reply with, i cannot, if you're saying you have the source, please list all hadith detailing complete prayer requirements from SBukhari or SMuslim. Out of roughly 50 people i flipped this back on, 0 have replied. 0%. They make us run around with prove this, show me that..... which is great because im getting more n more knowledge n memorizing Quran because of them but its amazing how they comfortably question the Quran, how quick to pounce on anyone upholding Allah alone. This is a phenomenal verse: Muḥammad is not the father of [any] one of your men, but [he is] the Messenger of Allāh and seal [i.e., last] of the prophets. And ever is Allāh, of all things, Knowing. If one studies the events that transpired at the onset of Prophet (PBUH) demise, theyd realize the layered meaning of this verse. Absolutely Phenomenal. Pc

[@fatipahad]

I agree with you totally

[@mishaob646]

How should Muslims view hadith? unless you want to turn everything into pigeon like repetition and superstition, view them with skepticism...

[@fatimaxo4885]

What about hadiths on the women brow shaping, nail polish, perfume, etc. these matters are magnified to the extent that a woman wearing perfume around non mahram is said to have committed zina… I don’t believe it but would like your views.

[@thetruthwithproof8802]

⚠ For all those who REJECT the Old testament Jesus said do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfil them ( Matthew 5 : 17 ) ( Abolish means cancel, nullify, ) ( FULFIL means deliver ) ( LAW means rule ) JESUS SAID I HAVE C0ME T0 DELIVER THE RULES SET BY THE PREVIOUS PROPHETS, NOT TO CANCEL THEM. If a new manager takes over at a shopping store & this manager announces 👉🏻 l have not come to abolish the previous law, l have come to fulfil the law of the old manager. The message is very clear, no changes.

[@fatipahad]

Bhukhari etc, were born long after the PROHET died. Quran is complete and fully detailed, so we should follow the Quran. Quran is AHSANAL HADITH

[@najmussaqib7542]

Give an ayah which tells us how to pray?

[@fatipahad]

Give a Hadith that explains the salat from beginning to end

[@shafeequeahmed4272]

Because of Hadith, especially hundreds or thousands of Duas in it, My faith became stronger and stronger. Yes, a few of them are problematic, among thousands. What I, as believer do is, keep it aside without commenting until I get a proper explanation from scholars, which I did many a times.

[@purplerain2205]

Dr Ally. I respect your knowledge however you've completely misconstrued these issues of applying hadith, etc...

[@sumitomoO0O]

X1 heard from X2 who heard from X3 who heard from x4...who heard from x8. The problem is x2,..x8 already died within the last 200 years, how the heck you determine how reliable x2,..x8 were? Even if you somehow determine that how do you know the context Prophet said those things? For example I tell my son "do not eat eggs" because he has high cholestrol. The context is this statement is valid only for sick people, not valid for healthy people. The initial narrator may have just heard without knowing the context. Most hadith should be banned, just like Prophet banned that nobody writes anything from him except the Quran. For some people Islam died and Buharism was born

[@JohnSmith-pd2dq]

You only tell us the opinon of the Sunnis about Hadiths and ignore the opinion of other Muslims such Shia, Zaidi, Ismali etc. Shouldn't you also include all Muslims in your discussions ... after all your channel is called "Let The Quran Speaks" which should include all Muslims ....

[@mohammedmassaquoi3444]

They're even worse.

[@byip2415]

Due to the all the different authors of the earliest Qurans, futile attempts were made the burn all but one Quran . Subsequently,there remains over 24 different Qurans circulating around the world today. None of these Qurans are consistent with each other and cannot be understood without the use of hadiths. The hadiths are also inconsistent and as convoluted as the Qurans. Please refer to the scholarship of Dr. Daniel Brubaker to confirm my comments, thank you.

[@drLIZ-bs5ei]

Everytime i read hadith my belife start become full of questions,, and when i see some nuslim justify some extremiss using some hadiths my belief really looks wead, i am a convert and i convert by reading the quran, so everytime a hadith makes my belief week i just come back and read all the quran again, and everytime, after finish the reading if quran, alhamdulillah my belief become fulk strong again, so i belive in the prophet but my real trust is always the quran that was what make me convert at frist, and the hadith i belive in ehat makes my bekive sttong, and what makes it questionable i just levave, and Allah knows i do like this to keep my belive strong ❤

[@Islamandpeacedawah]

Best is when the hadith will match Quran. To accept.

[@Dante3X]

🔥💯✊🏾

[@shadab917]

With due respect to your daughter... in Islam it is prohibited to make up your eye brow..then why you have done the same???

[@Hamza000h]

❤

[@walkingwith_dinosaurs]

🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤

[@maliksajidip99]

Dear sister plz try to first yourself,if u hv studied the Quran without reawayaat or tafseers? Bcoz Quran don't need such sirk ,millawat(insertion of man made books). My Q to u,do u find any provision from Quran for such induction? Certainly not.Allah strictly forbidden such practices and vehemently condemned and warned even Rasool ayat 69/40 For your ready ref. Dr Shabir is a sect based mullah,who preaches Shirk,shirk only.Quran is not his priority nor he follows true teachings of Quran. In the name pf nabi such mushrik betrays the Muslim from true Quranic teachings. Just imagine,after the death of Rasool Mohammad till 250 years,in dark,remote time,how Muslims were following Quran without Bukhari & co evils books? Think twice before going on more.Otherwise Allah will punish u for this shirk?

[@saulien3675]

So it is pick and choose. This makes very problematic. Come back to Jesus!

[@dom3073]

some hadiths are problematic... so come back and worship god along with 2 other partners. One of which came from the womb of a woman and got killed by his own creation.. yeah makes perfect sense... to anyone without a brain

[@mx3126]

Where Jesus? So many Christian sects

[@consolefragging9392]

The problem is that it’s not the youth perse that take hadeeths out if context or use problematic hadeeths. Its the scholars that don’t have the guts to look at these problematic hadeeths critical and even use them or even defend them with most dubious arguments 😅😂.

[@negeto2460]

Akhi, the scholars will defend their Lahwal-Hadeeths with their lives! Otherwise, they wouldn't have a job! They're to busy tossing the Book of Allah behind their backs and exchanging it for their man made traditions.

[@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411]

@@negeto2460 so you're thinking is that the companions and Islamic scholars unanimously followed Hadith for 14 centuries because they were getting paid? You Hadith rejectors are even more gullible than QAnoners 🤣🤣🤣

[@Loveydoveyl]

@@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411it was never unanimous. There have always been debates about Hadiths and the authenticity of many passages. Stop acting like Islam is a monolithic religion, when there are varying opinions, interpretations, and arguments against Hadith

[@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411]

@@Loveydoveyl You're confused about my comment. I've made the claim that for 14 centuries the status of Hadith as binding has been unanimous among scholars of Islam. Directly refuting negeto2460's claim that scholars are somehow self serving by adhering to Hadiths which he believes are wholly fabricated. There being differences on opinion on certain Hadiths has nothing to do with the status of the Hadith in Islamic sciences. If you disagree with my claim about the unanimity of scholars on the status of Hadith then simply disprove me by naming a pre-colonial scholar who thinks Hadiths aren't binding. If you can find a single scholar who lived before colonialism who has that opinion on Hadiths I'm happy to retract my claim.

[@slickrick2420]

​@@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411Not 14 centuries. Umar banned hadith. Hadiths were added to Islam after nearly 2 centuries.

[@negeto2460]

Salaam, The host said: "Hadith are an important source of islamic rulings and law" Please check yourself before making such misguided statements sister! Please take a look at the following verses: "" Say, "I DO NOT FIND WITHIN THAT WHICH WAS REVEALED TO ME [anything] forbidden to one who would eat it unless it be a dead animal or blood spilled out or the flesh of swine - for indeed, it is impure - or it be [that slaughtered in] disobedience, dedicated to other than Allāh. But whoever is forced [by necessity], neither desiring [it] nor transgressing [its limit], then indeed, your Lord is Forgiving and Merciful. "" {6:145} The Mesenger is commanded to tell the people that he does not know of anything FORBIDDEN (haraam) except 4 things! How does your Hadith & Sunnah (which are filled with haraam foods - domestic donkeys, animals with claws, etc) fit into this verse?? Let me guess... you TOSS the Book of Allah behind your backs to exchange it with your Sahih Hadiths?? What about this verse: "" Say, "Allāh is most knowing of how long they remained. He has [knowledge of] the unseen [aspects] of the heavens and the earth. How Seeing is He and how Hearing! They have not besides Him any protector, and HE SHARES NOT HIS LEGISLATION (hukmihi) WITH ANYONE. {18:26} Allah does NOT share His LEGISLATION / LAW / RULINGS (hukmihi) with anyone! Not even prophet Muhammad: "" O Prophet, WHY DO YOU PROHIBIT (tuharrimoona) [yourself from] WHAT ALLAH HAS MADE LAWFUL FOR YOU, seeking the approval of your wives? And Allāh is Forgiving and Merciful."" {66:1} Even prophet Muhammad did NOT have the authority to make HALAL and HARAM! How on earth then do you take rulings and law from your hadiths / sunnah?? Would the prophet dare to make rulings (halal / haram) outside of what Allah revealed to him??? Please read your Qur'an people and reflect on the verses of Allah!

[@waymilky442]

Please address also the problem of Quranists!

[@charlesmuhmanson3928]

I saw the movie, "Sound of Freedom". I couldn't help thinking about Muhammad as a perpetrator in this behavior.

[@hadesthedarkhelm]

Yeah keep using anti-muslim hysteria and find yourself defenseless against woke mind virus. you are welcome.

[@charlesmuhmanson3928]

@@hm4084 It specifically talked about abuse of 9 year olds. I made the connection. I hope many more do. I don't wish you evil. May your heart heal from following a false prophet.

[@skepticalzostrianos9875]

@@charlesmuhmanson3928 Wake up, its been said numerous times. That story about Aisha being 9 years old had already been disproven many times by a lot of different oulemas (Shabir Ally included). Find a new argument buddy.

[@charlesmuhmanson3928]

@@skepticalzostrianos9875 No, it hasn't. It has been denied because you can't deal with the truth about it and 65:4. Do you want sahih hadith that support Muhammad's ideas and behavior with little girls?

[@dom3073]

@@charlesmuhmanson3928 you do know that women can be past puberty but still not menstruate, right?

[@MuftiMasala]

This segment is brought to you by the lupe fiasco, fiasco

[@YSl11]

Yes it time to break the chain!