Is now the time to sell? (American Eagle 2019 One Ounce Silver Enhanced Reverse Proof Coin)

[@rocketfighter8]

With a mintage of 30,000 compared to a whole lot more collectors of silver eagles worldwide (not counting the ones who will become collectors) the demand for them will always be there to complete people's collections. I failed to get one from the mint, like most people, but bought a PF 69 on ebay for $595 the very next day. Four days later similar ones are selling on ebay for $850. I'm keeping mine as part of my silver eagle collection.

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

rocketfighter8 At first it seemed like people were overpaying with 5-600. I don’t think that’s the case anymore, you got a good deal! I agree, I just wonder how high the price will go.

[@Mark-yf7ql]

The 1995 w silver eagle proof peaked at $50k. Mintage was 30,125 for the 95 w. So i would expect a repeat of that price with this one but it didnt peak in price till around 2005. This info came directly from pcgs. Im surprised noone on youtube is talking about this.

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Mark H I believe it was partly due to the quantity of ms70’s being rare. I think the minting process wasn’t as great. I don’t it will be the same scenario, but having #1 of the signed could go for very big money.

[@abraham3981]

NGC also encapsulates the COA. I sent mine to NGC on Monday.

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Abraham V Good to know, is there a significant price difference vs PCGS?

[@abraham3981]

@@coinsilverjourney3581 only for 70. NGC and PCGS 69's cost around the same.

[@abraham3981]

@@coinsilverjourney3581 PCGS is more costly to grade but not by a lot. It may be worth it if you get a 70.

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Abraham V they charge more for a 70? Interesting, I’ve never had a coin graded, this will be a learning process for me. Thanks for the info!

[@abraham3981]

@@coinsilverjourney3581 What I meant to say was that PCGS charges more for grading than NGC. PCGS does not charge more if you get a 70. PCGS graded 70's for this coin seem to go for a higher premium than a NGC 70 based on eBay presale prices.

[@yeehaw94]

I think it will be worth a heck of a lot more in coming years. Especially the 70s encapsulated coas and a lot more for the signed ones. The market will dry up and prices will skyrocket.

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Nervjiggy I have to agree, I’m curious to see prices in the coming months. I’m hoping mine comes back a 70, but I’m really hoping I get a signed one, along with everyone else.

[@raginggamer2109]

Once availability on the market is gone, the coins value goes even higher. Supply and demand.

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Optimus Locust This hold true with just about everything. Thanks for the comment!

[@JasonParker_114]

Took ten years for the 1995W to peak at 50k smackaroos.

[@raginggamer2109]

@@JasonParker_114 An i will hold it for 20. It will go to my son, so im not worried.

[@ebernationtro9489]

Mines a keeper!

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Fitzroy Samuels no wrong decision here, glad you were able to snag one! Thanks for comment!

[@mykittenisagrandmaster4381]

I have been keeping a eye on how much these coins are selling for. And it seems that each day the prices get higher and higher

[@mykittenisagrandmaster4381]

I'm going to be hanging on to mine I only paid 70.90

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Food Stamp I think either way you can’t go wrong, I only hope it holds its value 10 years from now.

[@mykittenisagrandmaster4381]

@@coinsilverjourney3581 it keeps going up each day

[@thomasjr1434]

Yes the first week or 2 but I’m 3 years? Who knows

[@tyliful]

am keeping mine, keeping it for the kids. thinking of grading.

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Tylor G I’m sure they will appreciate it years down the road, thanks for the comment!

[@scorpmusic2625]

I’m going to have mine graded by PCGS and then hang on to it.

[@VictoryPedalCab]

That's what I'm thinking about doing too

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Do they offer to grade the COA also?

[@scorpmusic2625]

Coin & silver Journey yes, they do for an additional $15.00. Just make sure on the submission form in the Service category check the “other” category and write in Reverse Proof COA in addition to the service level you choose.

[@scorpmusic2625]

Vincent Victory, you can also Google PCGS 2019 Enhanced Reverse Proof submission for a good article explaining all the details.

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

I thought your comment said NGC, if I remember correctly PCGS said you can’t open the box in order to get the COA certified. Tricky thing I think a lot of people will miss.

[@SilverStacker56]

I received mine today. No signed coa. I’m sending in to NGC tomorrow. Then I’m gonna sit on it for years before selling.

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Stack'n Silver that was quick, opted to open it and not sent it to pcgs? Could be the right call, only time will tell.

[@SilverStacker56]

Coin & silver Journey Im sending mine unopened to NGC and encapsulating the coa too.

[@SilverStacker56]

The way mine was packaged i was able to get into it and put it back like its unopened.

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Stack'n Silver hopefully they can’t tell.

[@brianbroussard4433]

mine went from the mailbox straight to my safe in the sealed box and there it will stay. Still got coins I ordered 15-20 years ago still in sealed boxes. It's the old adage...the tortoise and the hare. I am DEFINITELY am the former. And to all of those people who opened theres and to all 700 at the Baltimore show, thank you. That's around 1,000 less slabbed COA'S out there, which makes it even MORE valuable.

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Brian Broussard I think that’s a good way to handle these coins, save it in its original state. Who knows you could have one of the 100! Thanks for the comment!

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Brian Broussard Also I like when I see people are opening up their boxes, since I sent mine away without opening it.

[@brianbroussard4433]

@@coinsilverjourney3581 yup, they don't realize that they can NOT get the coa slabbed

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Brian Broussard Actually I believe they can, but the matching number won’t be on the slab holding the coin. Will hurt the value later on for this coin, especially for a collector wanting everything just right.

[@brianbroussard4433]

@@coinsilverjourney3581 yes you are correct. Thank you for correcting me. But having that number on their helps eliminates counterfeits

[@smokeyblizzard]

i am sending in all of my coins to pcgs to get graded then put them for really high in price and just let it sit there. i dont care if it sells or not someone will eventully by it even it it does take years

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

smokeyblizzard win win situation either way. Thanks for the comment!

[@patrickm8877]

I plan to get mine graded. I wasn't at first, but have recently decided to get the COA encapsulated to. How would some of you get yours graded if you was submitting one these 2019 S Enhanced Reverse Proof silver eagles? In order to get the COA graded you have to send in an unopened box of the product.

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

This will be my first time getting a coin graded, so I don’t want to give you false information. I would recommend NGC or PCGS, although there are others less known. From my research the costs add up and you need to keep that in mind with your selections. Hopefully I helped a little!

[@brianbroussard4433]

and does anyone know how many of the 100 have been found..LEGITIMATELY??

[@PlataStacker1]

just subbed. $$$$$ take the money and buy quantity.

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

PlataStacker 1 Could be the right call, won’t know until years later. I might sell for the right price. Thanks for the comment!

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Also thanks for the sub!!💪

[@PlataStacker1]

@@coinsilverjourney3581 I'll buy your coin if your looking to sell. What r u asking?

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

PlataStacker 1 Too early for me to consider any offers, still haven’t received it. Also I plan on sending it for grading and then going from there, but who knows if I decide to sell it or not.

[@bmp804]

eBay is the real winner!

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

BMP804 I’m sure they are loving these big sales. Thanks for the comment!

[@bobbytucker6274]

I will be selling for $20k if i get one thats signed and i will sit on it if it takes 20- 30 till i die so be it idgaf :)

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Bobby Tucker if you get one that’s signed, that may be a reasonable number. You can only sell something for what someone is willing to pay. Thanks for the comment!

[@bobbytucker6274]

@@coinsilverjourney3581 well thanks for the reply

[@bobbytucker6274]

@@coinsilverjourney3581 i actually just might just might idk if its a good idea but mabe just leave my box completely unopened for 5-10 years and sell it that way that might bring a premium the fact this coin will be rare and to have a unopened box 5-10 years later might just be the rarest hahaha idk

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Bobby Tucker I think that’s an interesting way to go, as long as you can keep it out of harms way.

[@chadwolfeschledgelsteinhau9697]

On the back of the box just look for the numbers u can tell if its signed now say its signed should i open it?

[@jshortstacks6884]

Im looking to sell or trade mine....I feel like the mints had a big hit here and will have a super special limited ASE next year....

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

J Short Stacks I think you can’t really go wrong. That’s an interesting point, personally I think if they did, they would make more than 30,000. That way they make more money that way. Which would still make these the rarest. At the end of the day it’s all guessing. Thanks for the comment!

[@jshortstacks6884]

@@coinsilverjourney3581 they will just lower the mintage and raise the price!!!!!!!!!!! THen they will get a celebrity to sign the thing.......Im thinking HULK HOGAN

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

J Short Stacks haha. I would definitely be a buyer then, BROTHER!

[@savannahbrigman2618]

The question is, would you sell it?

[@natalieleveque]

Savannah Brigman I too am curious if he would sell it 🤔

[@savannahbrigman2618]

Natalie LeVeque I guess we’ll find out!

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Tough decision, depends how crazy prices get!

[@chadwolfeschledgelsteinhau9697]

Every man has his price

[@generalstack6540]

I think this is a coin for the permastack.

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

General Stack I’m still undecided at this point. If someone offered you 10k today, you wouldn’t sell it?

[@generalstack6540]

Coin & silver Journey this is the key coin to the silver eagle series ... the most popular silver coin series in the world . Do you understand what that means ... this is a treasure that should be passed down generations not flipped for a couple g’s

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

You make a valid point, I guess it’s all relevant to where everyone is at in life. That’s a large return for a 65 dollars investment, could make a big difference for someone hurting for cash. I guess I’m even happy to have a got a coin and be having the conversation. Thanks for the comments!

[@generalstack6540]

Coin & silver Journey i would rather slave away at a fast food job than sell this coin . It might get very expensive to replace this coin in the coming years. Certainly not $1000-$2000 . It will be worth far more imho

[@mykittenisagrandmaster4381]

I know some people are getting close to 1k just for the none graded ones.

[@elifoust7664]

Stay tuned to HSN,They score many in 1st min. Of sale,

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Yeah, who knows how many they really got. Thanks for the comment!

[@richardc488]

Trade for an ounce of gold

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

richard c Wouldn’t be a bad decision, almost a no brainer if you could get 2 ozs of c gold out of it. Thanks for the comment!

[@COPPERMOUNTAINCOINS.]

Waste of money, they sell them for crazy money but you go to sell them and you'd be lucky to get half of what their asking. An ounce of silver is an ounce of silver.

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Robert Waterman 9/10 times an ounce of silver is silver, but in this case it has value in another way. Something is only worth was someone is willing to pay. Thanks for the comment!

[@COPPERMOUNTAINCOINS.]

@@coinsilverjourney3581 I was lucky, I had a complete eagle set ngc 70's including the 95w and sold it just before the price dropped, it made a huge difference, it would have been a 70000 dollar difference, eagles have lost favor I can buy most 69's for 25 dollars or less and the price that the mint and dealers are gauging for it are only going to hurt the collecting industry, another nail in the coffin.

[@coinsilverjourney3581]

Robert Waterman that’s cool you had the whole collection at one point. I know my dad did too, I believe he sold around the same time. Social media really makes a difference, word of mouth travels faster now. I’m more of a stacker then a collector myself, I just saw the opportunity and managed to snag one.