Is Pakistan headed for Military Rule (Again)?

[@theconqueringram5295]

We've learned time and time again that the military shouldn't have too much influence over the state. It always lead to issues, just look at Myanmar/Burma and Thailand!

[@gideonhorwitz9434]

It’s not just the military the ISI Pakistans intelligence service is essential a state with a state

[@daniyalbbd5281]

Or look at India , their paramilitary is ruling the country also

[@stormstriker2000]

@@daniyalbbd5281 in india, post office department has more power then the military, which universe's india are even refering brother🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣. In india, our miliatary gets almost no money at all.

[@alexlehrersh9951]

Mitlitary should have very mutch influence. The countries you named are good

[@oihanlarranegi472]

​@@alexlehrersh9951 if you want to troll at least have the decency of writing correctly lol

[@djoys7738]

Saying in Pak "Army never won a war and never lost a election". Army is actually a big business conglomerate, produce milk to real estate. Nowonder you find many billionaire generals only in Pak.

[@doctornochu3092]

we dont say that,bloody troll

[@Seth9809]

Sounds like Egypt.

[@enissay9950]

Wrong, same scheme in many other countries, I can think of Egypt where the army has control of over 70% the economy. They don't pay taxes, have free labor from mandatory military service which creates unfair competition to private companies... Now the country is at the brink of bankruptcy after the president, who headed a military coup in 2013, has doubled the countries debt after repetitive loans of billions with no result, actually he was building palaces and buying expensive planes, their currency crashed over the last few months and is expected to crash even more... Long story short, when the military get involved in fields where they are not supposed to, then that field is doomed!

[@fg4peace]

Never won a war? Now, that claim is questionable. If it's India that you are referring to, then know that despite all internal turmoil, then know that Pak army is resilient enough to defend an Indian incursion.

[@avinashtyagi2]

​@fg4peace India has never invaded Pakistan, Pakistan on the other hand tried four times, and lost each one

[@woozy7405]

How is it that a country has never had a leader serve a full term

[@kth6736]

Not that hard. They always fall out with their bosses who appointed them.

[@thatindiandude4602]

Not that hard. For example, look at the number of Prime Ministers Australia has gone through the last 15 years just through ibrernal party coups.

[@Yasinburak1992]

Trust me as a turk that knows military coups all too well, I feel bad for the Pakistani people, military rule is the worst thing and a cycle that takes way too long to be broken

[@skp8748]

The US deals with the military not the politicians. As soon as he wanted to cut the military budget and downsize the army he was removed from power. Look at your country... You chosen to be legally obligated to put your lives on the line in defence of the US but when you tried to purchase an air defence system they said no... even though Greece, Romania, Spain, Kuwait, Netherlands ect ALL have it. There is a LITERAL war on your border where not only genocidal Assad, Russia, Iranian militias, Al qaeda and ISIS operate but also a terror group that directly wants to destroy turkey... A terror group the US fund, trains and arms. Why would the US say no? What is the logic? So when you buy the next best option not only does the US impose sanctions on you they also kick you off the F35 program which you have already invested a non refundable $1billion dollars. Turkey has been asking to buy the upgrades for F16s since 2009.. upgrades that Greece received in 2007... only in 2023 have the US agreed. Everyone in NATO had recieved this by 2011 even all the Arab states from Egypt to Qatar already had it but Turkey was being denied.... And then they not only host Gulen but they support the coup against the Turkish govt via the military. ONLY thanks to Putin who said he recieved intelligence from Mossad which Russia confirmed allowed Erdoğan to be saved before it happened and the US denied they had any knowledge it was going to happen.... which is IMPOSSIBLE. WHICH MEANS THEY AT THE VERY LEAST ALLOWED IT TO HAPPEN IF NOT ORGANISED IT.

[@zt3gaming796]

@卐 T H A N O S 卐 least Pakistan obsessed Pajeet

[@Akrafena]

LOUDWARD

[@Char444]

​@卐 T H A N O S 卐 This guy is an Indian troll. Please don't pay attention to him

[@ritikshaw5868]

@卐 T H A N O S 卐 bruh you're struggling to hold on to the territory you hold and have already lost territory like 50 years ago.. What empire are you talking about?

[@kirandeepchakraborty7921]

When it comes to fighting their own people, the Pakistan Army has always won.

[@TheGreatMarathaArmy]

This is where Pakistani Generals won medals which they proudly showcased on their military uniform.

[@kirandeepchakraborty7921]

@@TheGreatMarathaArmy Yes. Because when it comes to fighting other professional militaries, the Pakistan army has a bright history of surrender.

[@tauceti8060]

​@@kirandeepchakraborty7921 The army seems to be the cause of most of the problems in that country so maybe it should be disbanded.

[@web_devs]

@@tauceti8060 Army runs this country... They aren't going to disband themselves

[@UniDocs_Mahapushpa_Cyavana]

Not to the extent it want a to. 😅

[@recon17]

When the military has a country.

[@shayanansari6372]

As a Pakistani, I'm scared to express my opinion on this subject right now they way the army is cracking down on people

[@Edward4Plantagenet]

Your Re।!gion is fake, aIIah didn't help you. Mugumamad 53 ® apist 6 year child khod hatyara wahshi darinda jhootha. Pls, Come to True religion of Peace 🕊️, Buddhism.

[@Char444]

They can't crack you down on KZbin

[@AdvikTekkieTalk]

@@Edward4Plantagenet Racist.

[@AdvikTekkieTalk]

@@AbdulRehman-ie9tg Racist.

[@mirzahamzabaig5667]

@@Char444 They literally arrested people for tweeting against them on twitter lol. They are using ISI (intelligence agency) as well as voice and facial recognition to crack down on people.

[@ro45fan70]

As if Pakistan isn't ruled by Military already?

[@banditonehundred]

I am hoping for Khan to win this battle with military. A democratic government is responsible for feeding people , the military doesn’t care

[@tiglishnobody8750]

You mean ISI the agency who is de facto ruler of Pakistan and they control Military

[@CENTRIX4]

Pakistan Rebuilding The Economy Blue eyed Aryan aristocracy return to Pakistan to rebuild the economy? Pakistan politicians have failed and must step aside and allow the Aryan blue eyed aristocracy to take control of the Pakistan economy and political system. ====== Blue eyed Gods? Blue eyed Aryan aristocracy is the correct description. Blue eyed Aryan aristocracy migrated across the Northern Hemisphere as proven by DNA evidence and the dispersal of the Proto Indo European languages. Aryan Invasion or Aryan Migration? Aryan Migration is the correct description considering the number of people and the technology of the time. DNA evidence is overwhelming supporting Aryan Migration theory. R1a1a Z93 Indian Cline Aryan Migration. ======= Blue eyes the most attractive? Why do people consider blue eyes the most attractive? ======= Strange times are these in which we live when old and young are taught falsehoods in school. And the person that dares to tell the truth is called at once a lunatic and fool. - Plato 347 BC =======

[@badluck5647]

Bit of an oversimplification

[@skrai081]

I wonder why The US isn't saying anything about human rights violation and "democracy" of Pakistan right now

[@AzanKhan-oq8tr]

If anything aligns with west's and US interests, then human rights is not an issue.

[@BookwizardQ]

When they do you tell them to shut up and bring up oil and the 1980's with no context; when they don't it's suddenly their fault for what people do or don't do.

[@ajitsen6927]

​@@BookwizardQ Of course , because why should there be double standards.I mean sure USA doesn't even have one standard , but still it's the principal of the matter.

[@Nobody-pv9jt]

​@@BookwizardQ give one example where they did condemn it

[@anonymouslyopinionated656]

because pti youthiyas aren't humans. imran goes from crying amreeka ki sazish na manzoor to please help me amreeka papa

[@DennisTheInternationalMenace]

As soon as he says how the world is getting more complicated, that's when I know the video is done and time to move on. Lol

[@anonymous-yf6ur]

The funny thing is, World isn't even that complicated as it was some decades ago. Except the Russia Ukraine war there is not many wars. Compare it to the 90s or 00s. So much violence

[@tamberlame27]

Pakistani Army: Never won a war and never lost an election.

[@sauravyadav6191]

pakistani army always wins a war against their election candidates .

[@cityboylarry2521]

Funny country with nuclear bombs

[@Akrafena]

@@cityboylarry2521 *funni country with nuclear bombs

[@huddstudent2009]

Beat India in 65 and 47 and 99. India always had to run to UN or US got help.

[@tamberlame27]

@@huddstudent2009 🤣🤣🤣 keep smoking the good stuff 🤣🤣🤣

[@soumyamaitra6132]

all this ruckus caused from a single confusion on Khan's side. He thought that being the prime minister, he has become the father of Army... unfortunately he got the relationship wrong... Army is the father.

[@ordinaryperson-my7qr]

wtf did i just read...

[@jtgd]

⁠​⁠@@ordinaryperson-my7qr Subby Khan thought that he was the daddy dom of the army, and the daddy of the people. He then realized the army is the daddy and Pakistan is the army with a country, not country with an army What didn’t you get about it? Seemed very clear to me Creating political controversy and constitutional instability creates damaging factional tensions, and threatens the stability of the nation. Thus, the army takes control. Relating to the US, our military didn’t step in during January 6th because generals did not believe they needed to assume there is a breakdown of executive power, and waited for order, and assured other governments that we weren’t going to resort to emergency military activation to get things under control

[@doctornochu3092]

@@jtgd bro you butchered his words even more lmao

[@jtgd]

@@doctornochu3092 that’s the joke. I gave a normal explanation in the comments for those who just wanna read the opinion

[@priyan605]

Soumya, what kind of fetish is this?

[@aalokjoshi6839]

TLDR - Yes. They’ve been under military rule this whole time. It’s just hasn’t been as open as it is now.

[@mahidhussain1631]

thats why Bangladesh became a new country because of army

[@usmanqureshi08]

This(separation of Bengal) is only good thing happened in Pakistan because of Pak army

[@doit2810]

@@usmanqureshi08 dw, more good things ie separations will happen soon enough

[@Nobody-pv9jt]

​@@usmanqureshi08 it happened despite the army not because of it

[@abhimanyunath2001]

And Now Pakistan has beat Bangladesh in population and Bangladesh beat in terms economy...😅😅😅 Kudos to Pakistanis for that extraordinary achievement bro . U guys are 50 percent ahead in population and we are 50 percent ahead in economy.

[@abik8847]

Pakistan Army is the richest company in Pakistan and the generals and officers are millionaires, no wonder they possess much more influence than government can ever have

[@CAHA6]

Millionaires in dollar term btw.

[@badluck5647]

Half of Pakistan's issues would be solved if the military's monopoly on certain industries were privatized and split into competing companies.

[@doctornochu3092]

i would explain how its more then that but you seem a tad bit dense to underrated

[@blackkn1ght]

So a bit of correction, while debt was a problem under Khan, the economy was doing very well. Manufacturing and exports were at a record high due his policies, poverty was reduced, as well as Healthcare was improved. The GDP grew by 5-6% YoY under his rule. Since his removal GDP is now -0.5%, losing over $33 billion in terms of gdp. Manufacturing has declined double digit, debt has increased, Pakistan is the most at risk of defaulting in the world, and exports have declined by double digit as well. To say that Shahbaz Sharif's government is on par with Imran Khan's government is just bad research. Shahbaz Sharif's government has been one of the worst that Pakistan has ever seen.

[@heyyo6050]

Also talk about the imports and amount of record shatering debt that was taken by regime.

[@usmantariq7997]

@@heyyo6050 What about imports?

[@pm6127]

It is on par with imran.. except for the fact that when Khan left, he left a time bomb in the form of petrol subsidy.. which the current government is paying for.

[@pm6127]

How do you even assess the GDP growth has 5-6% when 2 years were under COVID with GDP contraction in south asia. Imran changed 4 finance ministers in his tenure.. and didn't have a clue about economy.

[@abhimanyunath2001]

Bro when Punjab election is happening. .😅😅😅

[@thestraw8271]

"The government needs to keep the military happy" to stay in power? What in the dark ages?

[@parvadhami980]

India's neighborhood is scary, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Sri Lanka and China. Broken down economies,. Brutal dictatorship

[@aalokjoshi6839]

Yup. That’s why we need to keep an eye on every single one of them and make sure they aren’t sending illegals, terrorists, etc into the country.

[@Edward4Plantagenet]

Bangladesh

[@kushagraverma4943]

@@Edward4Plantagenet Nah,bangladesh is fine for now.

[@AABraun]

india is itself scary with its daily human rights violations against minorities.. indian democracy is in serious threat due to modi's fascist tendencies sadly..

[@aalokjoshi6839]

@@Edward4Plantagenet Bangladesh is also radicalizing. They’ve forgotten how their “Muslim brothers” kept them in chains and subjugated their culture and people. They’ve forgotten how the Punjabis looked down on the Bangla people as less than human. Slowly they are becoming radicalized by the teachings spread for the barren wasteland of Arabia.

[@khurmiful]

Breaking news, Pakistan has always been under a military rule.

[@arwing20]

I mean Pakistan is as much of a democracy as Russia is. Technicality is the best you're going to get in that case

[@runajain5773]

Difference is party rule russia nad military rule Pakistan like myanmar and other some African country

[@carkawalakhatulistiwa]

In Russia pople united against western imperialism.

[@questionmaker5666]

@@carkawalakhatulistiwa And created their own, even worse, form of Imperialism.

[@abdimalikelmi729]

@@carkawalakhatulistiwa Ah infamous western imperialism , when was the last time a western country invaded a state in order to take land?

[@HemantKumar-id3jg]

@@abdimalikelmi729 Take land? A few decades. To kill people and cause destruction directly or indirectly? It's still doing that. Those countries are built on loot and plunder and that's how they are will be defined.

[@killer62477]

Every country has a army but Pakistani army has a country 😂

[@argaandri1077]

Prussian reference

[@Silver_Knee]

Props to the editor to have the self control to not put in the Star Trek Khan clip into this video even once.

[@pm6127]

It's kinda funny that Pakistan has Army chief with a tenure of 3 years and a PM with a tenure of 5 years.. But the last army chief held office for 6 years and saw 4 prime ministers come and go.

[@KRawatXP2003]

Democracy in Pak 🤡

[@explosivereactionstv7414]

It’s not a matter of if but when. It’s been overdue for military intervention in Pakistan governance since it’s a national tradition at this point.

[@magma9000]

Least delusional Indian 😂🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@explosivereactionstv7414]

@@magma9000 I’m not Indian at all actually

[@me0101001000]

And that's what I think is scariest. So many people could die or be displaced. Military dictatorships have a pretty horrid reputation, which I'm more than certain that you know. In all honesty, I'm shocked that Pakistan is even around today. I see all of the issues in the country and just wonder, "how are you still here!?"

[@GwainSagaFanChannel]

​@@me0101001000seems way to common in LATAM, South East Asia and South Asia regions sadly

[@osheridan]

​@@me0101001000 incredible resilience or flogging a dead horse? Who knows

[@foxyboiiyt3332]

KZbin getting confused. I got an ad in Pakistani before this video! I'm watching this from Ireland, no idea what the ad was saying!

[@magma9000]

Bruh ok

[@anshagrawal254]

That's not a language

[@jameslegrand848]

Lmao, I spent half of last year in Ireland as an Erasmus student, and I still get a shit ton of charity videos for dying kids in Asia (some of who were probably Pakistani kids).

[@janhumiecki2827]

Same

[@onurturhal6814]

Lol me too

[@blazerorb]

Can I just say how much better the TLDR Global guy/team is than the other guy? Keep going man, you’re great. Hopefully the other guy gets better.

[@SELFF]

It's quite bewildering that in this country, leaders repeatedly fall short of completing their full terms in office. It's a puzzling cycle that keeps repeating itself, leaving people perplexed and uncertain. Even though everyone desires stability and continuous leadership, this persistent disruption in governance remains a perplexing mystery, leaving both the nation and the world scratching their heads in confusion.

[@kth6736]

Heres a simpler explanation - "we will eat grass if we have to but will build a nuke if India has built one"

[@y.u.so.]

They had the nukes even before India had a nuclear program. Thanks to overseas Pakistanis who stole one of important the technology from Danes.

[@xijinpig8982]

​@@y.u.so. a simple Google search tells me India obtained nukes and conducted nuclear tests before Pakistan 🤔

[@flavouredcorn2018]

​@@y.u.so. while the point about foreign Pakistanis stealing nuclear technology seems to be true I would argue that India did in fact test with nukes before Pakistan. I believe the test was called Smiling Buddha.

[@redbaron9029]

​@@y.u.so. Not stole but recovered. We had the right to that information. Just like amerika, UK Russia and France.

[@johnxina5126]

Military rule is unlikely, in 99,77 and 58 the military had the populace behind it. This time around the political instability is fueled by anti-army sentiments (justified).

[@UniDocs_Mahapushpa_Cyavana]

What the Hell 🔥🔥🔥 are the people going to do against a competent and cruel army? 😅

[@muhammadmahd6429]

In 77 , Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto won 90% of the seats and he was way more popular than Imran Khan but was still overthrown

[@johnxina5126]

@@UniDocs_Mahapushpa_Cyavana the people will stop sending their sons to the army. The Pakistan army has India to the East,Afghanistan to the West, do you really think it can afford a war against it's own people? If that day were to come it would mean the collapse of both the military and the state

[@johnxina5126]

@@muhammadmahd6429 the 77 elections are arguably the most dubious in our entire history. In the aftermath of the elections the PNA went to the streets NOT PPP, infact the army was deployed by the government in response to the protests (riots in some places). Martial law was declared after things got out of control. For comparison between 1977 and 2023, think of the PNA as PTI and PPP as PDM. As much as I prefer Imran Khan over the likes of Cherry Blossom,Diesel amd Bilo Rani, please don't make a martyr out of Bhutto.

[@UniDocs_Mahapushpa_Cyavana]

@@johnxina5126 Yes. Mostly because most its people are kinda useless due to lack of education and welfare over the years. Also, Afghanistan and India are not stupid and know the populace of Pakistan aren’t their friends.

[@seanb.6793]

They’re hostages of their own military by having to give them so much of the country’s budget. What if they asked the military to help recover those costs? Maybe the military should take over being firefighters, ambulance drivers, and be responsible for building wind power turbines and desalination plants.

[@skp8748]

Lol he tried that... The US wasn't happy. He recieved a nice coup, a couple assassination attempts and criminal charges for his efforts.

[@kth6736]

Military makes cereal boxes and runs restaurants and also sells ready meals. What more do you want. 😂😂 Oh and they run sugar mills and cement factories too.😂

[@seanb.6793]

@@kth6736 Wow! That’s amazing!

[@Char444]

The military runs corporates responsible for many industries. They even have a big real estate business (Defence Housing Society)

[@mirzahamzabaig5667]

@@seanb.6793 Military literally runs real estate, land ownership, agricultural industries, steel mills, farmlands and more in various areas of the nation.

[@demolilyofficial]

My first thought when I saw this headline: "When are they not?" It's depressing when nations are perpetually in a state of Military rule.

[@napoleonibonaparte7198]

This decade is a decade of democratic reversal, truly.

[@lakshaysingh2160]

Shut up Napoleon ,you also stole the power from the French people.

[@kth6736]

Especially in france where new napoleon is crushing descent without a peep from self proclaimed guardians of democracy in west.

[@cgt3704]

Unfortunately its true

[@Edward4Plantagenet]

Why no one is talking about People disappearing in Balochistan, Sindhudesh, Pakhtunistan.

[@sleepyjoe7518]

There is no such thing as "Balochistan". It is actually Mehrangarh when the British occupied it in 1876, they changed it into Balochistan to compnesate their "Balochi" collaborators and reduce Persian suzernaity which the previous "Baruhi" rulers used to do. "Balochis" are actually Kurdistanis( haplogroup y20) who are not indigenious but outsiders.

[@ahmadimran6231]

Maybe they are focused on the real news like, 100 killed on sight in manipur?

[@nonadmoon]

You are forgetting a fact that Khan was (s)elected by Army and then unselected by the army whrn Knan pushed back on ARMY. NO goverment in pakiatan is formed (and destroyed) without Armys blessing.

[@rizkyadiyanto7922]

things will change.

[@nonadmoon]

@@rizkyadiyanto7922 It won't, as long as Pakistanis continue their obsession with seeing the destruction of India (which the majority of Pakistanis do), the Pakistani Army will get away with anything. To make Army accountable the Pakistani citizen needs to differentiate between propaganda and real threat! Unfortunately, the boogyman of India is too big of a made-up threat of Pakistanis to realize that Pak Army is using that as a shield for literally anything.

[@zico739]

Exactly, people ignore that fact. Khan accepted that gambit until the opposition and military were tired of him.

[@skp8748]

​@@zico739 huh what do you mean

[@tauceti8060]

But it was the people in parliament that iniated the no confidence vote so how is the army responsible for kicking khan out?

[@ycplum7062]

The IMF should not bail out Pakistan and let the Pakistani people know the long term impact of lack of austerity.

[@tauceti8060]

Thinking about it the army seems to be the main source of the problems in that country.

[@stephenjenkins7971]

Problem is that Pakistan collapsing means problems for their neighbors; a refugee crisis is likely.

[@wlee9888]

Pakistan has nukes...India, China, Iran, US will not let Pakistan "fail" and fall into the others' hands. Seems the military and elites know this too well.

[@yashraut421]

The world can't let a nuclear armed country go through such economic collapse. That's the reason financial institutions try to keep the country afloat.

[@nihalpathak3407]

@@tauceti8060 Not completely true. It was Zulfikar Bhutto a civilian leader who was responsible for partition of Pakistan in 1971 after genocide of more than 3 million people in now Bangladesh. Imran Khan himself has supported Taliban and arrival of Taliban was celebrated by his party workers and many Pakistanis all around the world.

[@Hustlémon]

Imran Khan is attempting to reduce the military grip on the nation, as they are the ones really in charge. It’s not going to be an easy road ahead. But, Imran Khan has a good heart, and even the first leader that wants to publicly apologise to Bangladesh and recognises the faults Pakistan is in rather than turn a blind eye. End of the day, the Generals of Pakistan are not good business men. They own a lot of state services like energy and transport, but, all those are useless if the country economic status is poor which they don’t seem to understand 😑

[@wexqlp3863]

The aim of army is not just to go and fight but to keep the system and the status quo to continue. Imran Khan is trying to do coup by destroying the army in Pakistan. So he can control it and become a dictator like Erdogan. Do not fall for popularism.

[@kth6736]

It does not matter if generals themselves are rich.

[@ahmadimran6231]

Khan is not. He is/was a stooge of the army, specifically Gen Bajwa and Faiz Hameed. The current Army chief is trying to root out such anti state elements from Army as well because Khan is actively in contact with them. The fact that he allowed previous army setup to hurt Pakistan, Pakistani's and their economy will never be forgotten. Also, history lesson. Pakistan and Bangladesh did exchange words of apology for 1971 events. What mukti bahmi did to Pro Pakistani and Bihari's in bengal will not be forgotten.

[@moviesunified6746]

Pakistan military i think have asked the govt to tranfer 1 million acre of land to the military, so that they can use it for "FARMING" . The military in Pakistan is not just military its a corporate entity that runs various business in the country. The government has no option just to give what is asked being the military, cause they obviously dont wana upset the general, because the military is the king maker. It is military who decide who will sit on the ruling chair

[@roberthoyt7921]

Perhaps it should be time for the military to step aside from power and undergo lots and lots of reform.

[@kth6736]

Why. How will they live lavish lives in Dubai, London and LA if they step aside?

[@Haxerous]

National Accountability Bureau isn't a security service, it's more of an anti-corruption bureau. A lot of stuff in Pakistan is run by general and retired general that doesn't make all those establishments related to security.

[@NeoHomoSapien]

Democracy and rule of law totally dead in pakistan. Indirect army dictatorship establishment in pakistan. Now nobody can save pakistan. God bless pakistani citizen 😢😢

[@despacito2]

It was already ruling it hidden

[@cgt3704]

Pakistan is like Prussia: an army with a state (but in a bad way)

[@Rhomcom]

Apt comparison. Though Prussia at least had functional institutions despite its rampant militarism.

[@cgt3704]

@@Rhomcom thats what i meant when i said "in a bad way"

[@RajSharma-ow9dh]

Good analysis. Let's not forget Khan was shot at injuring his leg.

[@daniyalbbd5281]

It has never been proven that he was shot though, he never went to any hospital. It was all just planned

[@ahmadimran6231]

That was a drama. He got hit on a critical part in the leg and instead of going to a hospital 2 minutes away by drive, he went to a cancer research hospital 1 and a half hour away.

[@CAHA6]

I haven't watched the video yet but as a Pakistani I can tell you this: WE already are. Edit: Just finished watching. Excellently explained the economy part at the start (some key detail missing though). The IMF situation from the public's eye is a result of demonization of the institute by everyone. If one actually bothers to read the IMF recommendations (other then the austerity) ones then they will realize that it's what Pakistan truly need (this topic plus the economy topic is too long to discuss). Khan's three targets mentioned were... a train wreck. The covid part is well not accurate to be exact. We had some good things and bad things happen at the same time but their contribution to politics is next to zero. The coalition partners didn't leave due to Khan's economic policy but rather the money and influence of Khan's opponents. Khan's response to vote of confidence was delayed that it became destined to fail and it was same with local bodies election in Punjab. The current government delayed the election but this level of delay came from Khan and PTI who delayed the Punjab local bodies election for three years right after when PTI brought in new local government law. NAB isn't a security service, it's a corruption watchdog. How this will go: PTI has been skinned alive and slaughtered as of this moment. Also what the hell happened to Jack's voice at end segment (the ad part).

[@CENTRIX4]

Pakistan Rebuilding The Economy Blue eyed Aryan aristocracy return to Pakistan to rebuild the economy? Pakistan politicians have failed and must step aside and allow the Aryan blue eyed aristocracy to take control of the Pakistan economy and political system. ====== Blue eyed Gods? Blue eyed Aryan aristocracy is the correct description. Blue eyed Aryan aristocracy migrated across the Northern Hemisphere as proven by DNA evidence and the dispersal of the Proto Indo European languages. Aryan Invasion or Aryan Migration? Aryan Migration is the correct description considering the number of people and the technology of the time. DNA evidence is overwhelming supporting Aryan Migration theory. R1a1a Z93 Indian Cline Aryan Migration. ======= Blue eyes the most attractive? Why do people consider blue eyes the most attractive? ======= Strange times are these in which we live when old and young are taught falsehoods in school. And the person that dares to tell the truth is called at once a lunatic and fool. - Plato 347 BC ======= =======

[@stephenjenkins7971]

IMF is an easy scapegoat since its what people turn to to drag governments out of the holes they drove their countries into; so people can point at all of these major collapsing countries associating with the IMF as proof of bad faith. And people who would prefer to fear the foreigner over the domestic elites will lap it up. No way to really fix that, tbh.

[@billcarson818]

The IMF is just a tool of imperialism, by putting countries in debt and therefore dictating what they should do in their own country. Making the country sell their own ressources cheap, selling public services like water, schools, police, prisons, public transportation etc etc, to foreign companies. Basically selling out the country, without any say of the people of the country. Its another way of gaining a lot of power in that country, invading it. Of course with interest attached as well to the loans. They did that many times in history. Only someone who isnt informed about their practices would support the behavior of the IMF. Or someone who lacks morals, of course.

[@BionikleFG]

Was hoping to visit family with my dad this year but its looking like that’s not gonna happen 😭

[@George_M_]

The military needs to be put in it's place. I fear that'll only happen, Russia style, in a conflict.

[@_kartik_chauhan]

they say between two military dictatorships is the world's largest democracy

[@abirjha1503]

As an Indian I hope all of this ends peacefuly Full support to Pakistan 🇮🇳❤🇵🇰

[@evildragon1774]

i am no pakistan or indian, but this warms my heart

[@saptarshisengupta8235]

Traitor spotted!

[@themcfunnel]

Wow thats rare

[@prometheus7387]

@@saptarshisengupta8235 Supporting Pakistan isn't a tacit disapproval of India, as you might not know due to being a fervorous, overzealous nationalist.

[@xijinpig8982]

​@@prometheus7387 Stable Pakistan ---> Mumbai bombings, cross border terrorism in Kashmir, 4 wars against India, all started by Pakistan. Unstable Pakistan ---> no money to destabilise India, Indian economy experience high growth, minimal terrorism, etc. Is it a coincidence?

[@LuisRomeroLopez]

Seems complicated (if not impossible) to root for one or the other.

[@nabeelahmedkhanofficial]

Imran Khan's political struggle and evolution spans over 27 years. I dont think he will back down any time soon. Govt and military may try all the tactics they want but Khan is fighter for sure.

[@tommymarciano]

Hey there's a mispelling at 1:08 "Problmes"

[@raafeyplayz7015]

It already is

[@mayurk8697]

Everything in pakistan is under authority of military Law,land, & Lives

[@RandomDeforge]

how did he "flip flop with IMF" ? you couldnt even passingly describe it at a high level?

[@billcarson818]

The IMF is just a tool of imperialism, by putting countries in debt and therefore dictating what they should do in their own country. Making the country sell their own ressources cheap, selling public services like water, schools, police, prisons, public transportation etc etc, to foreign companies. Basically selling out the country, without any say of the people of the country. Its another way of gaining a lot of power in that country, invading it. Of course with interest attached as well to the loans. They did that many times in history. Only someone who isnt informed about their practices would support the behavior of the IMF. Or someone who lacks morals, of course.

[@ahmadimran6231]

Pakistan in 2016-17 parted ways with IMF. Khan, unfortunately, is an american stooge for the acts he performed. He purposefully tanked key revenue generating projects and kept stalling proceedings with China on CPEC. When Pakistan entered IMF programme again, IMF wanted details on CPEC. China and Pakistan had agreed to that prior that such information is confidential, but khan's dilly dallying caused both anger from China and america. The last problem is that he created an energy crisis in Pakistan by not purchasing fuel in timely manner and used reserve money to keep PKR afloat artificially. In short, the bastard tried to zimbabwe Pakistan.

[@c4knowledge562]

As a Indian I hope that the Pakistani people get the government they really want and the economic situation improves 😊 all the best

[@human8454]

To send some terrorists to kill our army jawans

[@tamberlame27]

No, Pakistan should stay in this weakned state. Weak economy means weak army means less terrorism in India

[@skp8748]

Imran was the best chance they had the Indian FM said so even before imran praised modi

[@PakistanZindabad19828]

Thanks alot. Your optimism for our country is really something especially given you’re an indian. ❤

[@alamgir5553]

Youre going to upset all the Indian extremists who think that a collapsed Pakistan is somehow to the benefit of their country.

[@ThatOneGuy7550]

Lmao wrong description

[@titan1286]

Lol

[@Brakvash]

Man seems Pakistanis can't catch a break.

[@ashhadsaeed9898]

We just want to overthrow this dictatorial army regime. They ruthlessly decide our country's and our fate in the most undemocratic way possible. But its not really easy, this would require a lot struggle and may be sacrifices

[@thermostance1815]

The description is wrong guys

[@doitdifferent2629]

Pakistan army is a business. They have a yearly income of 26$ billion dollars from fauji foundation. Fauji means Army. 26$ billion on top of the 13$ billion they get from the annual budget. When army generals retire they get 240 acres of land. Every serving or non serving army servant gets free electricity, free gas, 50% discount on groceries, free medical for him and his family too till death. They simply buy loyalty by giving huge benefits. And the houses they live in! Normal civilians aren't even allowed close to army cantonments. It's basically a state within a state! We will fight. It's now or never

[@Lee_303]

By military rule, do you mean casually walking round, whacking people's legs with a cane? 😅

[@kth6736]

That is police state...

[@Char444]

No there's indirect rule.

[@AhmedIbrahim-hs7kk]

Well made video

[@AzizGC]

You should make a video about Bangladesh politics and how Bangladesh next election matter in global politics

[@thecreepers3478]

"Never won a war never lost an election"- Pakistani army

[@cyberverse9141]

1948 and 1965? Pakistan kicked India's ass 🇵🇰

[@HemantKumar-id3jg]

@@cyberverse9141 Yeah of course😂😂. In 1948, You entered an independent state of kashmir, got pushed back from much of the territory that you had already occupied and the state became (legal) Indian territory. We only stopped because the idealist Nehru took the matter to the UN. In 1965, we defended the territory you attacked. We lost a 1000 against your 6000. How did you win anything? "Kicked India's ass" 😂😂.Dude, we literally ripped you into two, the new nation is 50 years old. Learn to live in the real world.

[@ParthPant25]

@@cyberverse9141 source: pakistani tea and aata

[@cyberverse9141]

@@ParthPant25 "Tea was fantastic" 😂 🇵🇰

[@water9097]

​@@cyberverse9141 Yes But you drink Sattu 😂

[@doctornochu3092]

idk y ppl outside of Pakistan think of it as such a big deal lol.the army has one way or another always been in complete control of pakistan

[@anixes]

People outside of Pakistan care because Pakistan has nukes and they spend most of their budget on military spending. If Pakistan falls, it will become nuclear Somalia.

[@IndiaTides]

Any government in Pakistan is simply representative of military. As long as they follow them then they are in power.

[@c4knowledge562]

In the ranking of Most powerful person in the world, the first Pakistani is a general, not the pm

[@quantumality0084]

Hope not

[@jim2376]

FUN FACT: No Pakistani prime minister has finished his or her 5 year term. Gotta love that Pakistani political stability.

[@bartomiejmarciniak4034]

The amount of times this Channel gets the description wrong is shocking.

[@zarakzia]

First of all great video. Although some details are missing. Imran Khan and PTI party has been the brainchild of the military since the mid-90s as a third alternative to Pakistan mainstream parties. This project was only intensified in the 2010s with the help of courts and other politicians to unseat Nawaz Sharif by disqualifying him on an absurd legality. If that wasn't enough, the military systematically curtailed Khan's opponents to increase his chances of forming a government. When Khan was PM, he was one of the most vocal defenders of army's influence within the government. However, disagreements on the appointment of ISI's chief strained relations with the army and the subsequent VONC. Another thing to note is that Khan directly confronting the army can be considered suicidal. As of now many senior members of PTI have left the party and either retired (forcibly) or joined other parties. Khan is also at risk of being disqualified for elections. Rumours are that Bilawal Bhutto Zardari may become next PM in October 2023 although there is no guarantee. All in all there is no risk of a coup because there is no need to and the army isn't stupid enough to inherit this mess for themselves. The current hybrid regime will readjust to new realities. In the long-term Pakistan will eventually evolve into a proper parliamentary democracy.

[@davidbilla8063]

Yep good detailing timeline

[@ordinaryperson-my7qr]

If the things are going like this...then how tf will pakistan magically become a proper parliamentary democracy???, isnt it gonna be some sort of dictatorship republic with the military as the holding figure

[@mahive2097]

Agree on everything But Pakistan will evolve into proper Democracy that's never going to happen Army will never let it happen.

[@davidbilla8063]

Bro u should took asylum in western countries don't Live there👍 you sound intelligent u may have good life there

[@m-w-y7325]

Yeah, Nawaz was ousted not due to military but due to Panama Papers scandal which rocked world leaders globally, resulting in his disqualification. Imran Khan took the advantage of this and came into power since Nawaz is still in self-imposed exile in London. Nawaz Sharif's the biggest demand is PTI+Imran Khan must not be allowed to contest elections and be declared an Terrorist organization and only then Nawaz Sharif will return to Pakistan and lead the country as he wishes.

[@tauceti8060]

Military seems to be the souce of most of the problems in pakistan.

[@saptarshisengupta8235]

Yeah right Pakistan's army should just be disbanded. 😇

[@caniblmolstr452]

Short answer : Yes

[@hklamb5687]

At first glance, I thought that was Maaaark Wahlburg on the thumbnail 🤣😅

[@LordInquisitor701]

7:50 because of his popularity such a outcome is not predetermined it’s the military they got guns it doesn’t matter how popular someone is it’s easier to dictate terms when you’re pointing a gun at someone’s head

[@sonicmeerkat]

i got no high opinion of kahn but defunding the army would be a great way to both avoid imf loans and cut down on their influence. honestly i'm surprised the imf never pointed out the fucking 20% military budget in their reports, like that seems like the obvious thing needing to be cut down noting nukes already remove the posibility of invasion.

[@mdeac48]

2%? Those are rookie numbers

[@Miamcoline]

Great plug. I'll probably actually get it.

[@marym7104]

Within 3 hours!

[@goldengold8568]

Yes and please mention that all of these "democratic parties" were made by the Military. PPP heavily supported by Gen Yahya Khan, PML-N by Gen Zia ul Haq and PTI rose to power by the help of military.

[@SlayTYT]

Good to see you back🫵🏻 How come we don’t have you reading us the material all the time? Didn’t people come to this channel because of your reporting? Give the Tory boy doing them all a long break ;)

[@prateekbhurkay9376]

Ikr! I missed Jack!

[@yosefmekouar]

Tory boy? Lmao in videos a few weeks ago he said he went to Downing Street, and bro was deadass looking at Rishi Sunak like he killed his whole family. They then edited it but it was soooo funny. Btw don’t say stuff like that, « Tory boy » unless you want the Uk to be as divisive as America.

[@SlayTYT]

@@yosefmekouar don’t tell others how they can express themselves, maybe you do need America

[@EinFelsbrocken]

@@SlayTYT Very american answer; I like it! Visa's on the way! 😄

[@SlayTYT]

@@EinFelsbrocken ‘Murica🤘🏻🤘🏻 cool channel btw

[@kokuyocamlin07]

Pakistan's messiah complex.

[@fuuaar]

"Pakistan is not a country with an army, but an army with a country"

[@mightyx5441]

Prussian situation

[@guzz114]

you left out that khan had two assainattion attempt one where he was shot

[@WalterSobchack-s8n]

Appropriately named NAB 😂😅

[@swedichboy1000]

Why money is an artificial limitation.

[@arcane3464]

The country which was founded because of hate and fear can never be successful.

[@asonofmre2]

The wardrobe change was jarring 😂😂😂

[@serifini2469]

I'm sure the military will prove excellent in sorting out the country's economic crisis, right?

[@ordinaryperson-my7qr]

Militaries are KNOWN to be good diplomatically AND long term economic policy...so ofcouse

[@aftabhussain4741]

Pakistan is under Martial Law since inception, the IMF and other Arab countries when give loans or grants they only make military more strong so it can impose Martial Law indefinitely. This is reason we Pakistanis consider IMF and Arab countries our enemies that help Army's Rule.

[@kausikgupta6846]

🌩KHAN⚡vs.☄ARMY🔥vs.💧JUDICIARY 🌊 vs.⛄OPPOSITION ❄vs.🌪TALIBAN 🌬 🥺Pakistani citizens😭

[@mustafakhattak83]

Added info: the new govt has not only been ineffective at it dealing with the economy, they have been terrible. Weekly inflation has it records of over 40% with GDP growth of 0.3%(more likely -0.5% according to reports) after 6% last year. Also the police has not been able to arrest because of him staying at home but also because he has received bail in all his cases. Over 10,000 supporters have been picked up, PTI’s MPs are being forced to leave the party under pressure to leave the party through torture in prison and closing down of their businesses, etc.

[@abhimanyunath2001]

The PTI era is end bro ....

[@Mr.Haque01]

Imran Khan's popularity and vote bank is around 78%, due to their geopolitics and conspiracies of the establishment and current government against Pakistani citizens and against PTI.

[@hjalmarfreidenvall1655]

Neat

[@Edward4Plantagenet]

Freedom for #Balochistan, #Sindhudesh, Pakistan occupied Jammu Kashmir and #GilgitBaltistan.

[@E3ECO]

Some countries just can't handle democracy. Western democracy isn't the greatest, but it has led to some of the highest standards of living in the world. Pakistan needs to decide what it wants to be.

[@Edward4Plantagenet]

Nuclear Begger Prank-istan. Prank with the world 🤣

[@worldview730]

Nobody can win, but only the poor always loose in these cases.

[@yasirshah284]

In the realm of armed forces, a stark contrast emerges between the noble institution of the professional army and the malevolent presence of dacoits. Though both wield the power of firearms, the distinction lies not in their weaponry, but rather in their adherence to the principles of law, discipline, and honorable conduct. A profound elegance sets the professional army apart, transcending mere physical prowess to embody a profound commitment to righteousness. The professional army, as an embodiment of order and righteousness, operates within the bounds of a just and structured society. Each soldier, a stalwart guardian of the nation, willingly submits to the rule of law, recognizing that their duty is to serve and protect. In the face of danger, they embody a resolute discipline, forged through rigorous training and instilled values. Their conduct adheres to a code of ethics, upholding integrity and respect for human life. Like a symphony of purpose, their synchronized movements on the battlefield exemplify the culmination of tireless preparation and unwavering commitment to a higher cause. Contrastingly, dacoits emerge from the shadows as renegades of society, propelled by lawlessness and devoid of the virtues that guide the professional army. Driven by self-interest, they wield their guns as instruments of chaos, heedless of the devastation they sow in their wake. Their actions are a testament to a decayed moral fabric, where the principles of justice and honor have succumbed to the darkness. Far removed from the symphony of the professional army, their every move is a discordant note in the symphony of civilization, perpetuating a cycle of fear and instability. In this stark dichotomy, the beauty lies not in the possession of firearms, but in the preservation of humanity's highest ideals. The professional army is a testament to the triumph of order over chaos, embodying the elegance of discipline, honor, and the pursuit of a just cause. Its soldiers, guided by the light of virtue, harmonize their actions with the principles of righteousness. Theirs is a calling elevated above the mundane, forging a path where strength is tempered with compassion, and the power of arms is wielded for the greater good. So let us marvel at the profound distinction between the professional army and the dacoits. One stands as a pillar of societal order, a bastion of righteousness, while the other embodies the disruptive forces that threaten the very fabric of civilization. In their juxtaposition, we find a poignant reminder of the enduring power of discipline, virtue, and adherence to the rule of law. The beauty lies not only in the strength of arms but in the resolute commitment to honor and the pursuit of justice that sets the professional army apart.

[@Edward4Plantagenet]

Super rich , super power Prank-istan