Is Spencer Rattler FAVORITE To Win Saints Backup QB Job? | Future Replacement For Derek Carr?

After Further Review On Demand is powered by BREC Golf
Matt Musso fills in for Matt Moscona. We break down the Saints backup QB battle and debate if 5th round pick Spencer Rattler is the favorite to win the number 2 job behind Derek Carr.
Photo Credit: Getty Images, Orlando Ramirez-USA TODAY Sports, South Carolina Athletics, Cleveland Browns

[@kenfox22]

Fun Fact. Saints have 3 QBs that were Senior Bowl MVPs

[@kaordon504]

No joke a new OC is going to bring in a few QBs that he may feel fits his scheme. He didn’t draft Haener and probably won’t get a good look at him until minicamps start. Haener will be the backup followed by Rattler. Those other guys are just other guys

[@Andrew26997]

Unless Spencer is leaps and bounds better than Jake, Spencer will be Qb 3. You don’t want a situation where Derek goes down with an injury and Spencer has to play and not be ready

[@SenorJuan2023]

QB3 probably means practice squad and other teams can pick him up.

[@Andrew26997]

@@SenorJuan2023 the Saints carried 3 last year on the active roster. Will probably just do the same again this year.

[@SenorJuan2023]

@@Andrew26997 True dat, I forgot.

[@LilRedRasta]

i doubt that. Rattler wouldn't make it to the practice squad. Jake would. Jake is the odd man out.

[@user-px7fb6ss1z]

Jake is trash bro please

[@user-du9qi9cb6g]

I like Jake Hanner he looked great n the preseason last year

[@KTthaSouthernGent22]

I don't know about all that. He had an okay game, and he was trash in the other preseason game. He also was on performance enhancing drugs, so pump the breaks on Haener.

[@KTthaSouthernGent22]

The guy took peds to play against guys who were going to be out of the league following the game.

[@LilRedRasta]

you should go revisit those games. He struggled.

[@TheStacanova]

How big was Jameis Winston when Carr went down? They LOST all 3 of those games🤦‍♂️

[@Richardjou]

Because they were WAY BEHIND in points when he came in. Watch the games.

[@shoneythomas9215]

Ok I’m a Winston fan so what did Carr do, how was he in the red zone, ok Winston in eyes he lost Green Bay game, what did Carr do better 150 million for a used Carr why we didn’t make the playoffs, and when was the last time the raiders went to the playoffs under Carr, not raiders I’m a saints fan

[@1993muth]

​@@shoneythomas9215Packers game 2023. Enough said

[@shoneythomas9215]

@@MosheGoldbergTheKing lol 😂😂😂

[@shoneythomas9215]

So the Oline is the the problem lol every excuse for Carr but Drew never did

[@kevinweeks-ci2rr]

If you bring up Hill playing AS A BACKUP and your other options are two players that never took a snap in a NFL game sure give them a shot but if they don't workout Hill can and has started at QB and won in the NFL no one is saying he's even the #3 QB but he's good to have on your team

[@LucasLeCompteMusic]

Watch spencers game vs Georgia last year. That was as close to a NFL game you can get in college. He has pressure in his face almost every play.

[@exomake_mehorololo]

I hope the Saints Oline is not as terrible as the South Carolina one

[@LucasLeCompteMusic]

@@exomake_mehorololo we got a good line coach this year.

[@craigtrapp7313]

I am very intrigued with this pick. Im not sure hes the favorite but I think the saints hope he'll take it. Im sure Kubiak had some input in this descion and felt he was a qb thatd work in his system

[@kevinweeks-ci2rr]

ya'll just need something to talk about it alway has been and will be wait and see collage means nothing even coming from one pro team and going to a new one means nothing I hope both do good but if not Hill can do it he has before one thing for sure it's all new and who ever can pick it up the fastest will be #2 Carr has been in a new system almost every year he's been a pro

[@Near_08]

Hill isn't in the QB plans for the saints, If he was we wouldn't have signed carr. People need to get off of the hill can play QB, He is a gadget guy and good at that job but already proved he can't be a full time QB.

[@kevinweeks-ci2rr]

@@Near_08 Hill has won most games he had to start

[@Near_08]

@@kevinweeks-ci2rr so why isn’t he the starter?

[@kevinweeks-ci2rr]

@@Near_08 same reason Jameis Winston isn't not good enough but good enough to be a backup it was never a starting QB questions Carr is that who can step in for a game or 2 that's on the team right now Hill is like 9 -2 in the NFL when he had to start what are the others combined in the NFL

[@Near_08]

@@kevinweeks-ci2rr Bro who said anything about winston? He wasn't even in this talk and not even on the team. Quit letting that man live rent free in your head. geez move on already.

[@gregorygerber9627]

Rattler has a chance if he does a couple of things. This first year he needs to work with strength coaches and become stronger especially in the leg area, second he needs to learn the new system. Second year he needs to perfect the system and the timing needed with first string receivers. If he does this he could start midway through the second year and take Carr's job. Carr won't be financially tradable till after this year anyway.

[@corbynhughes6945]

Here we go w this mf again.

[@jasonk9020]

🤣🤣🤣

[@PvtNunchuck]

Would be surprised if Rattler ends up being like a Brock Purdy for the Saints

[@Wheelofbibfortuna]

Haener looked really good during preseason last year. May have been the PEDs but none the less

[@warlord435]

💯

[@DVDCDD]

This host is so much better

[@yoronola3270]

😂😂

[@0Shane13]

lol

[@WHODAT.A.C]

Facts Matt is too emotional

[@MrThobias711]

Facts

[@frankcortez2070]

🫵🏼🤫

[@williamlaprarie3007]

i wished saints would get Joe Burrow before they end his carrier early, no O line your going to end up like QB's in Carolina.

[@johannconway9363]

We are not going to let go he's going to win the back up job

[@paradiseliving271]

Would have loved haener to have had a chance

[@Bayoucisco]

No the hell he did not draw comparisons to Drew Bree’s MATT COME BACK!

[@user-mw4mp1vx2w]

We almost drafted Mahomes back in 2017, hopefully Rattler is half as good as Mahomes

[@SenorJuan2023]

Backup QB's are more important when you have a lousy/mediocre offensive line.

[@SenorJuan2023]

@@MosheGoldbergTheKing Guess you missed the draft. SMH

[@SenorJuan2023]

@@MosheGoldbergTheKing Never claimed it was solved. Just better. Wish they drafted another OL in the second round.

[@SenorJuan2023]

@@MosheGoldbergTheKing I'm assuming Ram won't be available and Fuaga will start at right tackle.

[@SenorJuan2023]

@@MosheGoldbergTheKing Should re sign Peat for LT.

[@SenorJuan2023]

@@MosheGoldbergTheKing Yeah, I saw that about an hour ago.

[@lesforet4495]

Would be nice if he beats out that bum they have starting.

[@jamesvancourt3877]

I'm hoping that happens as well please expose Carr this is the closest we will get to warranted pressure on Carr!

[@davidsellers3639]

😂😂😂he’s better than you think

[@Da-Boo33]

If he beef n muscle up no peds .. strong legs 🦵 he may start who dat

[@JCream561]

He is qb2 better than Haener

[@merlin-ju6fu]

Perhaps the college adversity helped Rattler. Didn't Rattler win the Senior Bowl MVP ? I am okay with the 5th round selection because it avoids the QB drama.

[@goldenking562LBC]

Rattler is a sleeper and if Carr continues to struggle Rattler will take his job you watch! 💯

[@beverlynBarnes]

400 billion At the f******association 200 million people need food The showing up treat me to treat me❤😂🎉add ❤😂🎉

[@JOHNSTALCUP-dm7vf]

Best QB wins the Job ! This Staff chose Purdy over Trey Lance even though Lance cost them 3 First Round Picks ! If Carr struggles with the New Offense / Staff don’t be surprised if change is made !

[@michaelcdarby]

Matt is gone again? He was just out for like a week… lol

[@stew-dent1922]

How good is rattler arm strength

[@sweeabn6736]

Yes - and he will play when Derick Carr gets hit.

[@yoronola3270]

What if he out performs Carr

[@DerekwhodatCarr111]

He won’t. He won’t beat out Jake Haener. He will be lucky to make the practice squad.

[@uptownstudd2010]

Derek Carr is that you?!!😂😂😂☝️

[@jamesvancourt3877]

Hoping he does!!

[@davidsellers3639]

He won’t WHODATT

[@Near_08]

@@DerekwhodatCarr111 Want bet $50 bucks on that? He will be on this team he might be 3rd QB to start season but he will jump Haener at some point. But I will gladly take that bet about practice squad.

[@patrickcrochet8590]

Rattler would be QB1 if it wasn't for that horseshite contract they gave Carr...

[@davidsellers3639]

😂😂😂WHODATT

[@emmitatkins4518]

lol look at cousins contract and tell me is Carrs “horseshite”

[@Warrior93x]

Your crazy lol

[@Warrior93x]

@@emmitatkins4518😂😂😂😂💯💯💯

[@Warrior93x]

Lets see what he does pre season

[@tonybaggett6922]

Rattler put the team on his back and carried them for 2 years

[@DerekwhodatCarr111]

It’s comical how some of the Fans are hyping Rattler. Peterman and Mond are camp bodies and are brought in To help teach the new system. Rattler will be lucky to make the practice squad. Jake will be Derek’s backup.

[@SenorJuan2023]

uh, they wouldn't have drafted Rattler in the first place if it was that clear cut. LOL

[@MrThobias711]

Yeah I don't agree with any of that.

[@robertgillis2697]

i agree with sentence 2, about the camp bodies Kubiak needs to implement the new offense. The QB battle of Jake and Spencer will be settled by how well they perform. Both guys are talented- Spencer probably has the physical edge- but all 3 QBs will be starting from scratch with the Kubiak offense-- hopefully all three of them will excel and Klint will just have to rank them and we can be Next Man Up, if the starter goes down. They all need to be inspired by Purdy- I saw his first game and immediately thought he was very good in that system- and he hasn't disappointed since.

[@Near_08]

You guys are comical that he won't make practice squad cause you are right he will be on the team. DA came out and said that rattler has starter potential, You know who DA did not say that about? I don't think DA would make that comment if he didn't plan on keeping rattler. Hell wouldn't be surprised if rattler was a kubiak pick.

[@goldenking562LBC]

The only thing is that Carr will do everything in his power to not help Rattler develop into a starter! Don't let the nice guy act fool you! 💯

[@checkboy8]

He has the tools to taken carrs job

[@YouDontKnowMebro69]

How about favorite to be the starter? Carr is not good

[@1993muth]

Carr hit his stride torwards the end of the season. If it wasnt for him getting hurt in the Greenbay game. We would have won our division and had a playoff berth. Poor oline play is the reason we didnt make the playoffs.