Is TEMU the real problem here?

[@thefrugalcrafter]

After hearing concerns about products created with forced labor and child labor out of China I did some research on the US Department of Labor website where they list suspected products from all regions of the world made by forced (slave/prison) labor and child labor. Suspected products from China made by forced labor are Artificial Flowers, Christmas Decorations, Coal, Fish, footwear, Garments, Gloves, Hair Products, Polysilicon, Nails, Thread/Yarn, and Tomato Products. Probable child labor products are Bricks, Cotton, Electronics, Fireworks, Textiles, Toys. That's why we hear so much about sweatshops in the fashion industry because from picking cotton to making fabric and then sewing garments it is heavily reliant on human labor and they need cheap labor for the low prices. But don't think because you buy brand-name clothing from American stores you are fine, Nike is on the list of sweatshop-using brands along with 80 other famous brands. So as crafters, we should probably avoid purchasing Silk flowers, Christmas decorations, yarn, thread, and fabric made in China. As I suspected the paint and colored pencil manufacturing is more automated and not reliant on massive amounts of labor. It was good to have it confirmed tho. Don't take my word for it. Research it for yourself. You can download the 2022 List of goods produced by child labor or forced labor and read for yourself: www.dol.gov/sites/dolgov/files/ILAB/child_labor_reports/tda2021/2022-TVPRA-List-of-Goods-v3.pdf It will probably ruin your day because China is only one country on the list and not the biggest offender. You might be surprised how your food is harvested, where your clothes come from, and the true cost of your iPhone. It's a hard pill to swallow but the more we know the better we can do. You can find more info on the US Department of Labor website: www.dol.gov/agencies/ilab/reports/child-labor/list-of-goods/ Let's do our best.

[@BeginnersMind-ArtMind]

Such valuable and important information!! Thank you for all of your research. 🙏

[@kateryan190]

Thank you for this info Lindsey. I have a habit of immediately turning off ads & temo is so adamantly obnoxious that I generally end up clicking the X to get out of any article I’m trying to read because their ads quickly cover up everything I’m trying to read!! I feel like it’s primal scream time when it comes to ads like theirs. And they’re everywhere. It’s getting to the point that I may actually have to pay whatever Robokiller is charging a month to escape this increasing onslaught of garbage on my screen! I knew about the problem with temu & the forced/slave labor & I had serious concerns about them stealing my info as well not to mention the old adage that I grew up with “You get what you pay for”. Something people may want to keep in mind when shopping these sites. Just sayin’ !

[@bekind3509]

Then you add in animal abuse into the mix, an example is make-up testing. Children and animals are so innocent and dependent on others. Your info is invaluable as is the list of cruelty free produced good on Leaping Bunny site. Thank you for your research.

[@tamathaan77drews40]

Not to mention cobalt and lithium mines. Tennis shoes and sporting clothes famous athletes endorse.

[@jamietipton5743]

Look at the things you own. Made in China. I’m a artist, I freehand my paintings. I buy from a lot of online stores.

[@sparrowsfriend]

Lindsay, just to let you know, Joe Miller, founder of Cheap Joe’s Art Supplies, just passed away. He was the pharmacist in the town where I grew up. As I got older, I watched his pharmacy become less pharmacy and more of an art supply store until he opened Cheap Joe’s. Wonderful man!

[@thefrugalcrafter]

I am so sorry to hear that. Condolences.

[@monicacassidy1355]

Rip joe

[@dorothyminor7581]

Thanks for letting us know! Makes me sad!

[@Ceares]

Aw! I watch their tip videos all the time. I always appreciate people that genuinely love their products

[@thurayya8905]

That's too bad. Condolences to his family and friends 🤍.

[@NinaRibenaMixedMedia]

Hello Lindsay. I was offered a paid for collaboration with Temu. They were very strict about how the content and information in the description box should be presented. Hours went into producing the two videos I prepared for them. (There is a disclaimer in my video informing my viewers it was a paid for collaboration). To this date I have not received a penny in payment despite contacting my representative numerous times. I have to say I am happy with the products I received, but I will never deal with or purchase from Temu again as all trust has gone.

[@recoveringsoul755]

When I try to inform or warn content creators about this company, they delete my comment. Clearly they are making money and don't want the truth out there. I watched a video about the history of the company and their motives on the China Uncensored channel recently and it really laid it all out. If you're the kind of person with high ethics and morals, it's difficult to buy from them in good conscience

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Oh wow! Thanks for posting this! Hopefully others will see it. How shameful! I'm extra glad I turned them down now!

[@Dee_B23]

@@recoveringsoul755 Thank you for posting your comment. In the beginning I tried to inform Influencers that Like Lindsay did not need to get caught up in Information gathering amongst other nefarious stuff they do and to promote that crap. I simply left my comment of disappointment, then unsubscribed to their channel without hesitation. I watched the channel you mentioned back then and confirmed what I knew. Thank you.

[@recoveringsoul755]

@@Dee_B23 thanks for being receptive to it. I mean, how can they stay in business? Pay their employees? Even if the products they sell were all donated to them, there would still be overhead costs and payroll. It doesn't add up. Which means their motive is something else

[@Dee_B23]

@@recoveringsoul755 Absolutely! They are all owned by that country's government. So much to say but not on this channel. Let's say I hope people have more respect for our country, however, they're so many that have no clue what is going on in the world...so sad. Thank you again for being informed and your comment.

[@jenthulhu]

My theory about Temu is that the platform allows them to eliminate several middle men between Chinese manufacturers and the Western marketplace. Think about it--there are importer/exporters, distributers, retailers all between the manufacturer and consumer. My guess is that Temu takes a much smaller cut than Western retailers, allowing manufacturers to sell very nearly direct to consumers. I used to be a buyer for a small locally-owned greenhouse in the midwest. Because we were so small and buying in such small lots, we were stuck buying our stock from overpriced distributers--and then we had to double the price WE had paid for the goods and hope it would sell to loyal customers who just wanted to buy locally from a place they trusted (the standard retail markup is 100% because of overhead). My guess is that in every step along the chain from manufacturer to consumer, there are usually several steps along the line where the price is doubled. THAT is how Temu can sell stuff so cheaply. We all know that Chinese factory workers are underpaid. They are probably dangerous places to work. And under those conditions, they can churn out a lot of product for cheap. The real question isn't Temu or no-Temu. It's buying products made in China or not. If you buy the same cheap product from Amazon or Target or Walmart you're still supporting the same paradigm--you're just paying more. And in many cases it can't be avoided. Sometimes it's impossible to tell if something is made ethically or not. I'm sure there are good manufacturers in China-- just as sure as I am that there are bad ones here in the West. And perhaps some companies push for good practices while other ignore how their products are made and only concentrate on the bottom line. The problem is--it's nearly impossible for us to know when we buy a crochet hook or a marker or a pad of paper--what were the conditions like in the factory that made it. It is hypocritical, in my opinion, to criticize someone buying goods from Temu, but then buying something made in the very same factory from Walmart, Target, or Amazon. A bigger problem with Temu is that the products aren't well-described. And even bigger--the bald-faced push to buy-buy-buy. I would be surprised if there aren't people addicted to buying on that platform. They know what they are doing.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

I am sure you are right!

[@thurayya8905]

That sounds like it could well be the case. Thank you for what sounds like an experienced opinion.

[@marionemberson]

I’ve looked at Temu, thought, no, I mustn’t support these companies, then see exactly the same product, down to packaging etc on Amazon at triple the price. I really think you’ve got a point there !! 🥰🥰 at the end of the day everyone has different depth pockets, do we criticise someone for shopping at Lidl as opposed to M & S (sorry I’m in the UK, I’m not sure of your comparisons, but I’m sure you can get the drift) my problem is, so I’ve heard, our government supplements the Chinese to send products with no shipping charges, as they are classed as a third world country 🙈🙈 REALLY ???

[@Kins_things]

I now see many items on Amazon that I’ve seen on Temu using the exact same photos! Buying on Amazon lately is no different from buying from Temu, you are just paying more via a third party! This is about more than the price we pay, if anyone wants to buy sustainably or ethically, knowing workers are paid a living wage, the answer is simple, don’t buy anything “Made in China”.

[@moemanley2579]

Not every factory in China has the same ethics, and reputable companies research this. I used to be a purchasing agent and we met with reps. Big big reps, Binney & Smith, Winsor & Newton, Liquitex etc. Some buyers ask hard questions because they care about where things come from others don't and are concerned only with profit. America decided long ago they didn't care about morals or anything else all they wanted was a good price. Now you have uneducated inexperienced people who only stock shelves in stores, experienced sales people no longer exist nor do morals. You should try selling things at artists shows and having people compare your goods to mass-produced crap from China. It's abhorrent and so are people!! Quality is an antiquated word sadly. 90% of the crap people buy off those sites will be in a landfill in less than 5 years... that's the truly sad part.

[@frand9174]

Bottom line for me is what can I afford? I've been buying from Temu lately and have no issues with either the quality of their items or their customer service. Sure. I like Stampin' Up, Altenew, Tim Holtz, and lots of other name brand name products sold online. But, I'm trying to indulge my artistic, creative nature without going over my budget. I'm 76, retired, on a fixed income. Creating cards for family and friends, experimenting with mixed media, and watercoloring, are what I get joy from. When I see $50 price tags on stamp and die sets, or just stamps alone, or dies alone for $25, I know they're out of my budget. And that's before shipping charges which add $7 to $11 on average. It makes me sad to not buy what I can envision using for a new project I've planned in my imagination. When I see $50 items on Temu, selling for under $5, with free shipping, I get angry. I'm being forced to choose between supporting US businesses over buying what I want at a price I can afford... especially when almost all of those US businesses have their products made in China anyway. Those companies are not supporting US manufacturers and US workers. For those big brand companies it's a matter of profitability. All companies need to make a profit to stay in business. The lower their costs the more money they make, so they turn to China for their production. I'm sure they're paying Temu prices or less for their products, then spend money on promotion, pay their designers, and cover all other overhead. They sell their items at exorbitant prices to cover that overhead, passing that cost on to consumers. I think their markups are over the top, though. I'd be willing to pay more for US made products knowing I'm at least supporting the US's economy, not China's. So, if I buy from a US company who contracts with a foreign manufacturer, and I'm supporting that economy anyway, I'm going to buy directly from the foreign suppliers and cut out the Chinese-supporting middleman and save money. It makes me feel like a traitor of sorts, but it's a situation I'm being forced into if I want to keep up with the hobbies that mean so much to me. At 76, I don't have a whole lot of years left, and I want to spend those years doing the crafts that give me joy. If buying from Temu or AliExpress let's me do that, so be it.

[@Optasia22]

That's what gets me, too. The VAST majority of craft supplies are MADE IN CHINA!! I wish we made our own stuff, but why don't we? The big dogs won't make as much money, pure and simple. Jobs for US citizens if we made our own?? WHAT A CONCEPT!

[@priscillalabranche5203]

I am 73 and retired and a stamper and journaler. All my friends have either gone south or just gone permanently. Crafting is my fun place for whatever time I have left. I agree with what you say. I recently paid 25 dollars for stencils (it's a set that makes 1 flower) way too much. I want to buy USA but something has to give. A sale, free shipping, reduced price closeouts. I buy temu, aliexpress once in a while but not often. Mostly I try to use what I have and now and then buy name brands. Between the excessive shipping prices, and no known return policy's and Amazon pushing belong to prime for $$$ it takes joy out of a hobby.

[@deborahgoodwin3426]

Fran, you have quite succinctly stated all of the factors that I would have said myself that leave me to make the purchasing decisions that I have made as of late. Having just celebrated my 67th birthday, it was my intent that when I began my watercolor journey as well as creating lovely cards to share with family, friends, my church groups, our local friendly kitchen, local nursing homes and anyplace else that I thought might be in need of a bit of sunshine in their day.... that I could look forward to many happy years of doing something that gave me so much joy. As life would have it, things aren't always as we expect them to be. Unfortunately, my health has taken a turn for the worse. It is time for me to speed up my watercolor journey and rather than leisurely painting once a day, I shall be painting twice or perhaps even thrice a day. It is still my intent to grasp as much joy as the powers that be choose to bless and bestow me with. But, it is quite apparent that I had better make the very best use of each and every day in this coming year. Should I find myself in need of any additional art supplies, particularly 100% cotton paper (most likely Baohung) or the boxes of watercolor cards with their envelopes, you can bet your bottom dollar that I will be ordering them from either Temu or Amazon. I am disabled and live alone on a fixed income. My budget is as tight as my grandmother's Playtex girdle. Such is life. Having said that, I couldn't agree with Lindsay more. She is brilliant and has my endless admiration. You go girl! Best wishes to you Fran and to all of the rest of us 'eldsters' who have found joy in our painting and crafting in these blessed Golden years! ❤️👩‍🦳🖌️🙏

[@pupawupagus]

i buy from temu all the time because of cost and the quality is shockingly good. that’s all the explanation you need my dear fellow artist my favorite under eye concealer is $26. the exact same brand name product is $3 🤷‍♀️

[@51andhappy44]

You made some points that I initially intended to make, but forgot as my comment was getting quite long with what I did remember to say! I'm with you!

[@HPNana-]

I use Temu for everything except the ink pads and will continue to do so. I'm 68, retired, live on a fixed budget. I was my parent's caregiver and both passed within 2 years. I took up cardmaking at the end of May and it's my happy place. One of my daughters gifted me the Ohuhu alcohol markers, which I couldn't afford and the Copic markers are way out of my league. I am me and my circumstances, so I need to watch my pennies.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

I am so sorry for your loss. ❤️

[@HPNana-]

@@thefrugalcrafter Thank you. They were 91 and 91. They had a long life, nevertheless the loss is always present. Cardmaking was and is my life jacket. My 3 girls and my grandchildren live in the States. I'm back in Puerto Rico when I decided to come care for mom and dad and craft supplies down here are rare. So I have to use the internet for my supplies. And I can't bring myself to pay $15 $20 or more for an embossing folder or stamp sets w/o the dies. So I'm grateful cardmaking has pulled me out of my depression and makes me feel the exhilaration I feel when creating. I donate them to my church and to Senior homes. It makes me happy, happy, happy!

[@ArtBrain]

I think you need to do what you need to do to afford your hobbies. And FYI, I have a whole lot of Copics (bought on a huge clearance) and a whole lot of Ohuhu markers and I can't really tell much difference. So I'm sure you make astonishingly beautiful art with the supplies that you can afford. I am sorry for your loss. I see from your reply that your parents lived long lives which is great, but it's still a huge loss. I'm glad that you have your art to give you joy.

[@Madam.H]

The problem is that those so called American companies have to get their products made in china giving the designs over to be manufactured and stolen …people have the right to spend their money wherever and on whatever they choose…

[@deborahgoodwin3426]

Nana, I am so very sorry for your loss. If your card making is bringing joy to your life during this most painful time then, by all means, you do whatever it takes to get those works of art to your church and those Senior homes. I am very sure that your cards are bringing joy to all of their very fortunate recipients!! 👩‍🦳🖌️🙏

[@rhondasavage8590]

I have talked with others regarding Temu and they are very anti-Temu. Which is fine we all make our own choices. But what gets me is they will use Amazon to purchase the same thing, coming from the same company but pay three times the amount. What’s the difference other than price, nothing. I have purchased some things from Temu and have been really happy with the items, stickers, junk journal supplies. I’m more confident in using Temu than Wish, aliexpress, and Shein.

[@AutumnMoonArt]

Agree. I thought the same. It’s very trendy to attack Temu but it’s the same products sold on Amazon (from the same companies) & Amazon has a documented history of serious issues (like millions in tax evasion). But Amazon is easy, everyone shops there, and then there’s the Affiliate program, so nobody says a word. I appreciate the non-judginess in this video.

[@ChelleStamps]

The difference for me is the same as for Lindsay. I don't want to put my credit card info out on a questionable website. Not to say that Amazon hasn't done anything shady. But I do believe my credit card info is safe on the site. And also, there are no safety standards for anything you're buying directly from China. Like Lindsay says in the video, when we import items, they are still subject to safety standards and customs inspection. And if a company sells them here, they can be sued for safety issues. So, at least in my mind, it feels a little safer to buy things from an American store even if it is imported. I hate the copyright infringement from all of them (overseas, Amazon etc) but I do realize it will happen. I just report as I see it, but I don't go seeking it out. It would drive me crazy. but I think it's wrong to buy something, especially something I don't NEED (just crafting items), just because it is cheaper if I know the design is stolen. It feels wrong to participate in that. I try not to judge other people for doing that. You do you. I just don't want to.

[@starrwilson6818]

Exactly. 3 of the 4 things I ordered from AliExpress were a rip off. I’ve been very happy with my Temu orders. If I have a problem they immediately refund my money.

[@StoneWolf99801]

You know you can use paypal with temu so your not giving them your direct credit card info. If you have a paypal account... Then paypal is your safety net between the company and your card info.....

[@maryshaw737]

I'm 84 and on a very fixed budget with all my insurance and utilities increasing at the speed of lightning and in order to be able to do any purchasing for my craft at all have been buying from TEMU since January...keeping price to under 30 USD per purchase and no more than once a month. Sorry about the run on the sentence...anyway...I have had 2 items fall far below standard, but under $5 each item, so I guess that isn't too bad. We all have to do what we have to do. I bought off ALI and Amazon prior to TEMU...so, no idea what the problem might be...more people than I can count buy from these market places. Blessings and happy crafting everyone!

[@MaryYoungblood-xy8vg]

My friend de-stashed all of her old stash of stamps, blocks, and paper with me. Some of the papers were twenty years old or older. I thought it was Christmas and a hundred birthdays all rolled into one. I loved it. Who needs the newest, brightest, newfangled whatever.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Sweet! The older stuff us better quality too!

[@sandyfranklin1123]

The old red rubber stamps have no competition from the awful clear ones that deteriorate over time!

[@eBookHoarder]

2nd hand art supplies are my jam. I have gotten some deals and some gems.

[@selbermachenguru]

❤❤❤

[@janebrown3587]

I get excited all over again when I excavate my stuff and find something I had forgotten about for too many years. It's like shopping again and seeing it for the first time, lol! Without having to pay a penny. Say, has anyone ever done a craft supply swap party kind of thing like some groups do with clothing ala Dust Bunnies or something?

[@TrueLoveX1027]

Looking at the number of views and comments for a video posted just 8 days ago, you’ve obviously hit on a hot topic. I found this to be thought provoking on a number of levels. Given your long standing experience as a KZbinr, I think you have a unique perspective to share and you did it in classic and appreciated Lyndsay style. ❤

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Thank you:)

[@tracyguillemette6255]

Someone is always being exploited if it is cheaper than you would charge to make it! Buy used, recycled, upcycled, antique or do your research for you buy new! Thank you for doing this video (the risk, the research and the emotions)

[@ReneTheJeepGirl]

Well said Lindsay, especially the part about everything you buy has intangible costs. I have so many craft supplies that I need to actually use before I buy more. So I'm on a mission to watch videos for inspiration and then substitute products I already have. I love when content makers use their old stuff. Half the time I'm like "Oh wow, I have that, I'm going to finally use it."

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Absolutely!!

[@JordanHunter333]

Brilliant. And this is the core of the issue, being thoughtful about our choices. Taking our share of the responsibility for how our consumerism impacts people and our planet.

[@starrwilson6818]

I love Temu. No one complains about dollar tree. Where do they think that stuff comes from? The beads are incredible! The miniatures are awesome! Thanks for this. 💜🙏🏽

[@beckypetersen2680]

I remember the first time I walked in a Dollar Tree. I felt like I had left the USA and walked right into a Chinese shop! Many years ago now.

[@dottygin]

This is very true.

[@benamisai-kham5892]

This was exactly my thoughts from the beginning. I've shopped at dollar tree a majority of my life because it's what fits my small budget to find at least a small amount of happiness. Dollar tree is just as bad as temu in the sense, and so are many other stores. Why are we shaming people for having a budget, especially when many of the items are the same item on other sites like Amazon. Aliexpress/Alibaba and wish are also similar; wish was huge online.

[@AnnetteGreen]

I hope you'll read my comment regarding this. It's about much more than saving money.

[@farmwife7944]

Dollar stores do not collect and sell my personal info as long as I pay with cash. It’s difficult though, trying to be a good citizen of the world.

[@GinaBadeaux]

i not only love your art videos ,i love you as a person

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Aww:)

[@SewingReport]

Really appreciate you talking about this Lindsay! To date, I have received at least *56 (yes FIFTY SIX) emails* from various people claiming to be with TEMU with an offer for sponsorship / collaboration. This just was a huge turn off and sketchy AF. Like you, I got a weird vibe from this and never responded to any of those emails. I've never bought anything from TEMU, but wouldn't judge people who choose to purchase from there or influencers who promote TEMU. It's just very difficult in this day in age to avoid mass produced items overseas, and I understand the average person probably doesn't have the luxury to source products that are 100% ethically made. As far as the TEMU haul videos getting tons of views, I am wondering if TEMU may be taking out ads on these videos? Unless the KZbinr specifically unchecks that option while uploading, *anyone* can run your video as an ad. While I personally shop Amazon a lot, I do not accept free products or do collaborations with Amazon-only storefronts. I do think we should be a bit skeptical about any random company that suddenly pops on the scene marketing to us makers. Several months ago, I had a rather weird experience with the folks behind the Loklik Crafter electronic cutting machine (Cricut knockoff) and decided to look into the company. That's the same company behind HTVRont. What I found out is that they're under a much larger parent company headquartered in "France" but most of the business activity actually appears to be out of China. The parent company just runs dozens of sketchy ecommerce websites and attempts to appeal to certain audiences. EDIT: On a few occasions I accepted free products from Arteza but stopped working with this company because they tried to exert an unreasonable level of control over my content, like asking me to change the titles of videos with specific verbiage.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Yes, the temu people are persistent! I am still getting daily emails from them. I have spent a lot of time on the Department of Labor website, leaning about what products are from what countries are likely to be made with forced or child labor and its heartbreaking. My morning cup of coffee is not tasting as nice. Luckily most of the craft products I used can be sourced from ethical companies in the west and the Chinese ones are automated factories with little labor and none of the products were on the forced/child labor list. Cotton, textiles, thread, and yarn as well as electronics are likely culprits of bad labor practices, so it must be hard to know what to do with a sewing business. Thanks for chiming in. I've enjoyed your coverage of Craftsy and Cricut during their shenanigans. Thanks for shedding some light on that.

[@PatriciaPageMosaicArtsCrafts]

I recently started using temu, the craft supplies are ridiculously cheep in price and i have no problems with the quality so far, to buy large die cuts for a couple of dollars that actually works is a dream come true.

[@sabinelloyd8532]

I have ordered a few times and am happy with the quality and they were excellent at giving updates on the order.

[@theresa_lili]

I've purchased also. I have somethings that I wouldn't recommend. However, way more I am happy with. Stamps, dies, etc.

[@kimberlysiddons]

I’ve bought a few things from Temu, but it was two dresses, a pair of Halloween shoes and an shirt with a cat on it. So far everything I have purchased from Temu has been good and I have no complaints. I love to craft and I craft everyday, but I have not bought any craft supplies such as stamps or dies in several years. I don’t even watch videos anymore showing new products because they are really nothing more than an advertisement. Someone who gets a product for free from a company and tries to get me to buy that product at an outrageous price, just makes me mad. So I’m done buying stamps and dies. I have heard from my IT person that putting the Temu app on my phone or iPad is not safe……just like tic-tok. I always love to listen to your informative videos and I love that you do not judge anyone for anything they do.

[@robinsutton4952]

I was just going through some of my unopened/unused stamps. Key word here is “some”. When I look at the space they take up and what I spent, certainly not worth it. Now that I’m retired, I have to listen to my husband asking when I’m going to use all the “crap” I’ve accumulated. He has his own stuff, tools, books, shoes, clothes that he’ll never use again. You’re correct in saying we each have to weigh what our needs are.

[@janieb7319]

I absolutely love your input. Thank you for taking the time to share! I pride myself in not buying retail to keep items out of the landfill and our oceans.

[@tj8114]

Thank you so much for your in depth video. I love that you take into account the fact that socioeconomic factors definitely impact one’s ability to take or turn down offers. I occasionally shop on TEMU only bcuz the price of so many things are out of control, making art supply purchases impossible. Art has become both a passion and therapy, a true life saver, but to purchase supplies means not purchasing necessities, or postponing doing so. Thank you for providing food for thought without judgement.

[@starlaarts9385]

Thank you for trying to look at these sales platforms from all angles and letting people know it alright to make the best choice for yourself and your life.

[@marit4660]

Hi Lindsay! One of the things I love about you and your channel is that you're not just sharing in-depth product reviews or tutorials (which are so helpful!). But you also give us opportunities to reflect, to live life with more intention, to broaden our empathy, and want to be a better person than we were the day before. Thank you for sharing this video. It's definitely giving us a lot of good food for thought. I recently gave Ali Express a try bc I couldn't find a specific brand of oil pastels on Amazon or anywhere else (I'm a little obsessed with oil pastels! 😅). It was Kuelox's artists grade OPs in 3 different 48-piece "mini" sets (cute square shape that reminded me of Holbein's artist grade OPs). I think it was from one of the stationary stores you mentioned. Shipping was fast, and they packaged the boxes really well. What you shared about not judging ppl based on our own situation is spot on. Thank you for reminding us of this truth! PS - I was able to go back and finish watching the "buffering" alcohol brush marker video the other night, yay! 😀 Thanks for the tip on how to tell the difference between a water-based vs alcohol marker!

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Thank you for your kind comment.

[@frand9174]

I pay for Temu purchases with PayPal, just as I do for purchases on any US online site. I haven't supplied Temu with my credit card info.

[@MummyBrown]

Same here! I kinda use PayPal as my gauge for my purchases. You have that added protection. PayPal doesn’t work with just any site so I feel safe if the site in question offers them as a payment option.

[@DontTakeItPersonall]

I have shopped feom temu, and I don't see it any different than shopping at dollar tree, Amazon, (never shopped aliexpress or wish) small edge dies, stamps & stickers. You get a few from dollar tree vs. 50 from temu (numbers are fictitious), but you get the drift. I'm retired & still work 2 jobs, because not old enough to get social security 😂. I try to budget accordingly, because I have a need to eat.

[@Dani-ICU-RN]

I mean I've ordered from Pottery Barn and Macy's and gotten broken or poor quality items so I don't really see the difference if you shop at Dollar Tree or at the grocery store and you get the same item what is the difference

[@gretchenmariee]

Thanks for posting this. I won’t use Temu, one because it’s a new company and the prices are scarily low. There also isn’t a way to track exactly where these products are made and there is some suspicion that the Uyghur people taken into internment camps in China may be forced into labor to make many of these products. I also have heard and seen far too many legitimate companies and artists’ intellectual property, designs and product lines stolen and copied. They won’t be getting my patronage.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

I think the prices are artificially low (sold below cost) as part of a land-grab. They are buying market share. I'm sure they will settle near Amazon prices once they have acquired as many customers as they can. It's like a black Friday doorbuster, get people in your store so they will also buy other things.

[@gretchenmariee]

Agree!

[@dawnjames151]

I really appreciate this conversation, and respect everyone's thoughts and opinions surrounding the complexity in buying or avoiding this company. However, I do want to comment on the intellectual property or copying design issue. I have seen US online art/craft company's copy there own vendors designs, yet complained about Wish, Ali, and now Temu!?! For example, when Waffle Flowers came out with the watercoloring media mat, literally 6mos later...Simon "created" their own, as well as many other recreated products. Competition is what it is, but it's the hypocrisy that chaps me the wrong way. I do always try to support small, local, female-owned businesses, but that too comes at a price not always in my budget. But I would challenge anyone to go throughout your entire home to confirm that although you bought said items from a US middleman, the vast majority of said items were manufactured in China. And anything that comes from them, do you really trust what they say they use to make the item? All that said, IMO, people are going to do what's best for their situation...but I will not judge them until will all hold the incessant greedy corporations to the same high minded thinking we are using for Temu.

[@LollyPalooza]

So many good points, Lindsay! It's a complicated situation. We all need to learn to practice critical thinking skills and still have compassion.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Yes!

[@boyjrr]

I do shop Temu, but I pay with PayPal or Apple Pay, so I’m not giving them my card info. They have lots of cute stuff for junk journals- paper products and stickers. And cute everyday pens for writing. I wouldn’t buy anything from them expecting it to be super high quality or professional grade. But for junk journals it’s a good site.

[@janasher4940]

I agree. I buy all my junk journal stuff from TEMU. I don't see these products anywhere else either uness a USA company has started selling the same stuff for 4 times the price (and not any better quality). Just because you bought it in the USA does not mean you are supporting US workers. I have used my Discover credit card for AliExpress and for TEMU. I have never been hacked or stolen from. I watch that card closely. In all the years I have been shopping, it has never happend. But if you are scared of it happening, then using a prepaid card or other method of payment will help you sleep better at night.

[@lynmer41]

I also buy all sorts from Temu, twice I have had to return goods within 5 days I receive a credit through my Pay Pal account. I only use Pay Pal for ALL on line shopping very very safe

[@grannysmithart]

Thank you so much for this video! Shortly after i first started seeing Temu ads, i read an article on Bloomberg News which really turned me off the company. The article claimed that many of the companies selling on Temu use child labor. I now delete any recommended video that is a "Temu art haul". As i have been a watercolorist and colored pencil artist for over 20 years, i have a large supply of materials, so i don't really have "needs", mostly "wants". I buy almost all my art supplies from Blick, Cheap Joes and Jerry's; i rather spend a little more and know i am getting a legitimate product. I rarely use Amazon as some of their practices are suspect.

[@rxstrmom]

100%…everything you said, I agree 100%. Thank you for this video. Patti 🌷🍃

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Thanks Patti! Long time no see, I hope all is well!

[@lindanewcomer830]

OMG!! Thank You! Thank you for looking into this. I refuse to be shamed into stop buying off of Temu. I'm not on a fixed budget but I won't pass up inexpensive craft supplies. The beads I've bought are every bit the same quality as those I buy from Michael's or Hobby Lobby.

[@CynicalSim]

@lindanewcomer830 Absolutely! Your creativity is far more important than the lives of slaves and children. I mean, who cares about them anyway, right? We don't know them. It's not OUR children, so it's perfectly acceptable to flip our fingers to them as we continue to push out good people in favor of bad in pursuit of our own happiness. Carry on!

[@DGiarrusso]

I love these well thought out videos. Thank you!❤

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Glad you like them!

[@susanhansell3435]

I use PayPal to pay for my Temu orders, so I feel comfortable with that. They have excellent watercolor paper at a great price. I've also gotten some great watercolor brushes.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Good to know!

[@LaylaPayton]

Be careful with PayPal. We were scammed (not by Temu) and PayPal did nothing to protect us.

[@lorinoe2023]

I do as well.

[@timeglass777]

Me too. Online shopping always comes with certain risk. It just like using your credit card in a foreign country. Temu is not a problem. Everyone shopping online should be aware of the risk and be vigilant, monitoring their credit card bills for any suspicious charges. If you are overly concerned, I suggest you using a professional fraud protection service (many banks offer it for free nowadays).

[@CynicalSim]

Sure, as long as you don't have any problems with your order. I was double charged and tried to dispute with my CC company as was recommended to me, and all of the mess ended up freezing my Paypal account, so I've never gotten my money out of that account.

[@Bridgton1]

And yet another cute hairdo What you said about single moms working was wonderful! Besides being a great lady and artist you are all savvy business woman. You could have a side gig as a motivational speaker ❤

[@thefrugalcrafter]

You're the best!

[@thejournalconnection4755]

Lindsay, thank you so much for having the courage to make videos such as this one. Your honesty and candor is refreshing. I was on the fence about ordering from Temu. I know people who have gotten very cheap mixed media supplies from them; but that very cheap price is what makes me leery. Temu is making their money somewhere/somehow. It might not be by selling dirt cheap products, but it might be by selling people's information or other shady practices (as you mentioned, selling knock offs). And I'm also not judging those who do shop there. EVERYONE is challenged by something - from my six year old nephew who is having a hard time adjusting to school work, to my 71 year old friend who had a stroke, and to everyone in between. Buying from Temu is just night right for me because, even though I have some challenges, being able to support my art supply addictions is not one of them. Love to you and all your followers. 🙂

[@thefrugalcrafter]

😊

[@robinallen8841]

It really doesn’t cost much to make products. Western world factories have to charge a lot because the cost to run facilities is insane and over priced. Not the same in China.

[@lynnnasal4451]

Lindsay - I love your videos and classes. If it sounds too good to be true - it is most likely not true no matter how many ways you try to rationalize it. On another subject - how the heck do you do that hairdo that you have. It is adorable! Is there a video that I can watch to see how it is done.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

@lynnnasal4451 here is a tutorial kzbin.info/www/bejne/j5uqdWWVh8iSosUsi=xf4M5vrgsaJyk5Rz

[@zeldacheri]

The Chinese government heavily subsidizes international shipping so that these Chinese companies can aggressively compete with American companies (primarily) but also other countries' companies. Trade war in action.

[@JordanHunter333]

Thanks so much for this, Lindsay - and for so many, many reasons beyond the question of Temu. With more and more of every purchase I make, I am asking myself about the need, use, enjoyment, weighed against the environmental and human cost of manufacturing, production, and shipping. For example, and this one happens to be Temu, in watching an unboxing yesterday, I was stunned at the amount of plastic packaging in just one order! It set me back, and I'm grateful for the conversation you are adding to our consumer decisions, and for the additional info here re: labor sources. So well done.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Thank you!

[@bethcrane5780]

I appreciate you raising and promoting values-based, informed consuming. I try to practice my values in every aspect of my life, and what and where I purchase is a HUGE values statement over time. I don't patronise W-Mart, $Tree, fast food etc., for the same reasons you shared. It's worth it to me to pay a little more to know that workers were more closely fairly compensated for the product or service I'm purchasing and I'm especially concerned about access to health insurance for American workers and carbon footprints. I appreciate your non-judgemental posture because everyone is coming from a different place, and it's helpful for influencers to raise ethical consuming so that purchasers begin or continue to consider these issues as we build the local and global communities for the future. Take care Lindsay. You do good work.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Thank you!

[@24get24give]

thanks for throwing walmart in there it is shocking to me how poorly they treat their employees and communities, and so little is said or known about it. where would we be without Roger Moore keeping us informed?

[@thefrugalcrafter]

@@24get24give do you mean Micheal Moore? Love his work!

[@patriciawages8187]

I have to admit, I purchased once on Temu, mostly craft items that I found no where else. Some vintage stickers, wax seals and wax, a few art journals, etc. Some things were fine others were junk. I may shop again just for the papers and stickers, maybe. What scares me is I watch the Temu hauls ( they are fun to watch) and I see people buying makeup and clothing and you don't know what goes into those products. Lead and all kinds of contaminants have been found in products coming directly from China. I saw one UTuber in the UK that bought a prisma color set from Temu. She tried to figure out if they were real and wasn't sure after she compared them to the known real set.

[@mewsli]

I saw the same video . Its a poser for sure.

[@MileinaJuarez]

Most clothes at target and old navy etc., is also directly from China. I know the factories and they are no different than Shein and Temus, sadly, they just upcharge more . These days I’d advise everyone to buy from brands that you really know where they produce and the conditions. But I think a lot of people, specially my age and younger just want a massive amount of trendy clothes that gets thrown out soon. I rather have good quality staples but my style is not very trendy, more pieces that suit me, not the current trends. I am shocked how many people put their babies and kids in Temu and Shein clothes, since the lead is concerning. I really understand, since you can get organic cotton at places like Kate Quinn for ten dollars per piece for basics and even dresses for 20 and they have sales for 40%off regularly. The impact it has on the environment that all this lead heavy clothing gets discarded constantly is horrible. I wonder though, if papers and craft items have more toxic materials as well, since China doesn’t have the safety standards we are used to. But at least you don’t put that on your skin and body and contact is minimal.

[@karenl8837]

If you’re unhappy with anything from temu just request a refund, they’re really good with that

[@jenofevedesigns]

I agree with absolutely everything you said in this video!!!! Even the side notes lol!! Thanks for taking the time to put together a well thought out and considerate video on a very touchy subject. You are amazing and I appreciate you💜

[@thefrugalcrafter]

You are so welcome!

[@wendyscolouring]

Interesting video, I have bought art stuff from Temu, and Ali, I always use PayPal so I’m happy I’m financially protected. I think generally if the price is too good to be true, then I know something isn’t going to be right. I have got some great porcelain palettes (median ones) from Temu, they were lovely, and all my Kalour pencils have been fine. (And much cheaper to the Uk than Amazon) As you mentioned there are some decent sellers mixed in on all of these platforms, it’s just finding the right ones. I don’t buy something that I can see is a design that’s been stolen, but paint/palettes/brushes etc can be ok, and a bit cheaper. 👍🏼

[@patriciaschoenberg1261]

Thank you for the informative video! Your hair is so cute! It is very tempting to want some of everything when starting a new hobby, especially card making.

[@jackiemuller813]

If I lived in the US, I would buy more US products, but shipping from US to my country is horrendous. Not all companies have products available here. I rarely buy craft products now due to costs. I use what I have and feel less guilty and am using some stamps that I haven’t used before!

[@creativebeanart]

Interesting and thought provoking video Lindsay. I didn't have a great experience with Temu, so won't be using them again. I think the wider issue we face is rampant consumerism and the need to have stuff. I've seen in a lot of craft groups recently people posting their hauls from various places and it seems to me there is more focus and collecting of the supplies rather than doing the craft. My focus has always been re-use and recycle, and being thrifty, but even I'm not immune to the temptations to get the latest products and colours. Its also getting harder and harder to find KZbinrs that teach and educate rather than promoting products, usually their own.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

It's probably because haul video do better than tutorials. I don't know if it's because that's what viewers want or what youtube reccomends.

[@JordanHunter333]

I'm with you, creativebeanart - well said.

[@marilynanderson7792]

This was a great video, I'm glad you decided to take the time to make it. You helped me think about some things related to my craft purchases I hadn't thought about before.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Glad it was helpful!

[@nancyethridge5213]

99% of all my dies are Anna Griffin dies because I love the quality. But sometimes I need a junk die for a specific card and I cannot find it here. Temu has products that you can’t find on amazon. I’ve been pleased with their products and will continue to do so.

[@CynicalSim]

@nancytheridge5213 Absolutely! Your creativity is far more important than the lives of slaves and children. I mean, who cares about them anyway, right? We don't know them. It's not OUR children, so it's perfectly acceptable to flip our fingers to them as we continue to push out good people in favor of bad in pursuit of our own happiness. Carry on !

[@jimflack9462]

I buy from Amazon because I trust them with my info, I don't have to go in a store that may or may not have what I need, and because I am a prime member, I get the 2 day, "free"shipping! I am also helping to provide jobs for people in my own community at a nearby warehouse and its delivery people. Besides, I am 78 yrs old, and it's easier. I've been scammed, and had my debit card info stolen, so I'm very cautious about buying anywhere else on line. I HATE all the ads interrupting my favorite KZbinrs, but right now, Temu is the worst! Ok, I'm done ranting. Thank you, Lindsay, for speaking up! More of that is needed.❤

[@thefrugalcrafter]

I hear you, good points!

[@smitachengappa]

Really interesting topic Lindsay, and also interesting to read the comments and see what other people's experience with them has been. I've bought a little novelty watercolour palette from TEMU and a couple of pencil pouches, all of which were good quality. Having said that I don't feel like going back to shop from them. Im not feeling great about fast fashion etc, i feel like we have way too much stuff and I'm feeling a need to declutter and refrain from buying anything that isnt essential!. I haven't completely made up my mind about TEMU, but for now i think im staying clear.

[@gabrielleannacormierart]

Thank you for making this video for SO many reasons ❤️ As a content creator, I often get approached to promote products and I share many of the views you have expressed here. I appreciate what you said about trusting your intuition to help you decide whether or not to work with a brand or company. I find it hard to accept products from companies in exchange for a review. And then at the same time, this is my job and it’s important for me to also make a living. So, I often feel caught between a rock and a hard place. I don’t want to compromise my integrity, so for now I’m mostly holding off on brand and product promotions. All this said, I understand how people want to pay as little as possible for art supplies because they can be so expensive. You offered a lot of food for thought in your video and I appreciate that you made the time to share your perspective with us. ❤😊

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Thank you. I think if you are interested in a product you are offered and you can be honest when evaluating it and you disclose you got it for free to your viewers it's fine. The more opinions on products the better. It will keep the bad stuff from being bought and inform people of the good options too.

[@gabrielleannacormierart]

I appreciate you! Thank you for making the time to connect ❤@@thefrugalcrafter

[@ChantelleArts]

I haven't purchased from temu yet for this reason. That being said, I would like to get a ton of stickers etc to start bullet journaling next year and the prices that temu offer is unbeatable. I bought art supplies from shein before and it seems very similar

[@lynne9360]

Lindsay, I love your honesty. Was a pleasure to listen to you.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Thank you so much!

[@vadabirkheadhopper4302]

Lindsay, the thing we subscribers love about you is your ethicality and morality. It just shines. And paired with your ability not to judge others, it’s always fair and balanced. I’m with you - when someone (on-line or in person) starts finger-shaking and preaching, I tune out. And I’m jealous!!! Even at my thinnest as a teen, I was not shaped for men’s jeans. Waist much smaller than my hips. They weren’t worth the alterations I had to do to be able to wear them. As you say, you have to consider all the factors. And altered jeans never look anything but…altered.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

So true!

[@kimjohnson1675]

Appreciate this. As a seasoned crafter, I appreciate this. I have a lot of stuff and am very judicious how I plan to spend.

[@christinesheppard5759]

Thanks for this valuable info Lindsay. You pointed out things I haven’t considered. I greatly appreciate your honesty. I trust you completely because of your candour 💕

[@thefrugalcrafter]

You are so welcome!

[@joyceperry3729]

Lindsey, you have mentioned several things I was totally unaware of in your video. Thank you for your honesty and refreshing point on view.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

You are so welcome!

[@rcelestefelix9299]

I find that some of the older red rubber stamps and other "old" products are better made than some of the newest products. I kept my old rubber stamps, and each time I use them, they are new to me because I can make a modern card with an old stamp. You are right: the die companies burned us out with their redesigned new products that were similar to their old ones but cost more, like 33% higher. They made me run to AliExpress and buy their copies, that, in many cases, were just as good as the brand name ones when I made the comparisons.

[@tarachan6284]

As a former economics teacher I appreciate your mini lesson on opportunity cost

[@charisse5287]

Thank you so much for your comments and thoughts on this, Lindsay. And thank you for all that you do and share!

[@ramonalee1]

Thank you Lindsay! One of my favorite things about your videos aside from your vast art knowledge of lots of different things is your knowledge of how the retail and discount businesses work and how you share that with us. I have absolutely zero knowledge of where things come from and how they get to my door! I’m like the kid that thinks meat comes from the supermarket, what? They kill animals to get it? Just an analogy, grew up on a small farm, but I didn’t take any of the courses in high school or college that explain economy or business. You help me a lot. I have ordered from Temu 3-4 times and I like them but I always spend so much because everything is so cheap and you feel you can’t pass it up! I have seen stamps and dies that look suspiciously like knock offs and I didn’t know how to feel about it. I didn’t go hog wild on those but have bought a few. They seem good quality to me but I don’t think I’ve actually used any of them yet. The clothes I’ve gotten have been a bust for the most part, though they allow returns very easily. The material is weird sometimes and the sizes are all off. I’d advise not to buy clothes there.

[@krisicooper9155]

What a breath of educated fresh air. Thank you Lindsay!

[@thefrugalcrafter]

You are welcome!

[@dianaromig732]

Every crafter/painter/ shopping enthusiast needs to watch this video. I almost ordered from Alli Express until I got to the payment method and I got that sick feeling which told me that the Holy Spirit was pulling me back. It didn’t feel safe. I too enjoy watching Temu hauls but who needs all this cheap merchandise!!! I prefer to purchase quality merchandise from reputable retailers/ manufacturers plus if I don’t like it, I can return with no hassle. Personally, I appreciate a product that I’ve bought for at a fair price. I’ve seen other KZbinrs complaining that Temu is doing knockoffs. With all the craft stuff and paint that I own, I’ll never get through it all. So I really appreciate you speaking out about this latest issue of us with OCD and impulsive shoppers being targets to part with our money. God bless you for your honesty 🎉❤

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Thanks 😊

[@KatieDarden]

My main issue with Temu (and I've used them about 8 times) is the packaging. Not only is everything shipped in bags (which means the contents can be broken or damages), the contents are often very dirty. I use a baby wipe to wipe down everything that I take out of the bag. Some items are useful, some a good price, but I won't be purchasing very much more from them. The problem with child labor issues is that WE have no control over that practice. Even Amazon and several retail stores purchase those items for resale to the public - without disclosure of the facts. I would LOVE to see the US bring back manufacturing to North America. However, now that Cali has given fast food and restaurant workers $20/hr, just imagine what the costs would end up being - and that doesn't even begin to consider insurance, supplies, shipping, etc. I also don't eat at fast food restaurants, and now there is even less of a reason to do so. Raising wages raises costs to the consumer = inflation. And more graft.

[@ThunderStruck15]

$20 is a living wage. Do you want them to not have a house? Food? If not, then are you willing to supplement the big companies to pay for these things?

[@KimberlyLetsGo]

Glad to see your funky, fun hairstyles back!

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Glad you like them!

[@judyoger]

I fell over laughing, there is a Temu ad for ladies sneakers, to the right of your video. And me living in the old fashioned age, I have only brought on line a couple of times. I prefer to purchase local to help keep people employed. I always enjoy your perspective on any subject. Even with a discount code I seriously can't afford most products offered by any market, I must pay my utilities, mortgage, food, insurance etc. Family first is a hard and fast rule in my home, no matter what, come what may.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Yup!

[@albertgriffin7901]

Thank you Lindsay for this information.

[@meridadiane]

Stepping in just to say my Cap 1 card has TEMU as an affiliate offering me 3% cash back when I charge on that card. Also, I put in my wrong zip code without noticing it until my order was about to go out. I notified them as soon as I noticed before it was actually sent, and they stopped the shipping and also credited back my card. Their service department was very responsive. Just wanted you to know what my experience has been. 😁

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Thanks for sharing!

[@claudeyaz]

Uh usually companies have third party dude that kind of support and shipping work...right? So it isnt temu doing well. But who they hired?

[@thefrugalcrafter]

@claudeyaz temu is just a platform that connects manufacturers to customers directly. Temu doesn't sell products but it will warehouse them. Temu makes its money from advertising fees from sellers. It's more like the Etsy business model or Amazon fba 3rd party sellers.

[@kareneaton433]

I had no idea that popup ads from a company offering a discount erased the profit from person producer whose link you were using. You provided a lot of good information to think about in this video, thank you

[@siggybenedict-shields3883]

I’m a senior on a fixed income and a hobby crafter. Stamp sets cost me between $2.00 and $4.00 at Temu. I checked Tim Holz, a set there is $60.00, something I could never afford. Crafting is good for my mental health and helps me deal with severe chronic pain. It’s either buying cheap stuff or not crafting. The stamps work well for me as do other craft supplies. For the few items that didn’t work I received immediate refunds.

[@CynicalSim]

@siggybenedict-sheilds3883 Absolutely! Your creativity is far more important than the lives of slaves and children. I mean, who cares about them anyway, right? We don't know them. It's not OUR children, so it's perfectly acceptable to flip our fingers to them as we continue to push out good people in favor of bad in pursuit of our own happiness. Carry on! (Also, I have very little personal income, am in such chronic pain I was prescribed cannabis. I save or do without.)

[@lookup8297]

What about nike shoes that sell for hundreds and they haved child laborers!…just sayin’

[@lindacastro2688]

Hi Lindsay. I appreciate you pointing out that at least some of the paper crafting products from Temu are stolen designs. (I think a long time ago we had the same discussion about Ali.) I'm happy you put that out there so people know who they're dealing with. These products cost less for the reasons you mentioned, and also because the people who should profit or be reimbursed for their development work are cut out of the loop. They have the expense and time of coming up with these things, and then someone else steals the idea and the profit. I have decided I don't need anything they're selling enough to support thievery. You're not telling anyone what to do; I'm just glad you're making people aware.

[@sarahlouwolfe8302]

oh, second comment, sorry. Such a good video Lindsay! I have always appreciated your honesty. Just to throw this out there if anyone's interested. AliExpress and Temu both have Baohong hardbound Journals. They're not as pricy as Etchr, for example, but they're pricy enough I've not bought one. On Temu they have rolls of Baohong paper. My next order from there will be that so I can cut pages to make my own little sketchbooks. I'm not a youtube creator, not any kind of affiliate to anything, but just sharing a decent find at a decent price other watercolorists on a budget might want to look into. Have a good evening 🙂

[@thefrugalcrafter]

I've never bought paper in a roll. I wonder if it's a pain to deal with.

[@cherylbarrel9966]

Thank you for laying it out, Lindsay!

[@thefrugalcrafter]

My pleasure!!

[@debbiegallett1125]

This was a great video. I feel the same way about TEMU and will not order from them. I was wary about how they popped up all of the sudden and their prices were so cheap. I felt they had to be copying designs and making them out of cheaper materials. I was glad you explained about the affiliate program and how the company's can redirect you with a coupon code. I will now go back to the original link to purchase.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Awesome!

[@AnnetteGreen]

You hit the nail on the head. They DO copy designs and make them cheaper. I am a designer who has fallen victim to this very unethical situation. 🙁

[@debcarroll8055]

I won’t shop with Craftamo again either. I tried it because the Lindsay brushes where half off. Turns out it was because they were damaged. They also don’t get back to you when you use their contact us area to notify them of an issue.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

That shouldn't have happened. I have turned down other projects with them. I was disappointed to see they didn't use the UK brush factory to make the collab sets, when I agreed to do the set I assumed they were made in the UK like the samples they sent me. That's on me, tho. I should have asked, but it didn't occur to me. Anyway, the 50% off sale was supposed to be on first quality sets, and it was sitewide. They shouldn't have sent a bad quality product. If you email me at [e-mail], I will reach out yo them on your behalf. The brushes are sold out, but maybe they will issue a partial refund for the damaged brushes. This has been so disappointing, they started off being so great and responsive. Ugh.

[@debcarroll8055]

@@thefrugalcrafter I ended up with a replaced brush that was in worse shape than the first one. In the end they reimbursed me for the damaged brush. I believe they acted only because you included on my communications at the end. I believe that because they did not take responsibility for either instance of shipping off damaged goods. They wanted to blame the warehouse people. I wish luck to all of the artists that are coming out with brushes these days. I hope people will hold Craftamo accountable if they receive damaged items, or they will just take advantage of people. It costs money, it isn’t free. Thanks Lindsay for your help with this situation.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

@debcarroll8055 I am glad you looped me in, that treatment was unacceptable. Thank you for your patience.

[@Mirrigold]

I've bought Boahong watercolour paper twice from TEMU because I'm in the UK and it's outrageously expensive here for multiple reasons and, as it's a Chinese manufactured product anyway, I'd rather buy it from a seller based in China on TEMU than through a third-party seller on Amazon UK who is charging more than triple the actual retail price. But I wouldn't purchase anything else from there and I used PayPal not my credit card so they don't have my direct banking information. I think, as always, you argue a great set of points and I have always appreciated your lack of judgement over what any individual person's circumstances are and why they make the decisions they do. Oh and I refused to sign up for any of their emails, SMS etc so I don't get any marketing garbage from them 😉🤣

[@kimberlybillotte9191]

Thank you for calling it out for both sides of the coin. We have the freedom of many things and your own choice is absolutely a great freedom to enjoy😊

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Well said!

[@nadeaner.cowley513]

Great video! I agree with everything you said!! I get you! Thanks for bringing all this to the table to get people talking. ❤

[@thefrugalcrafter]

You are so welcome

[@Miastrong930]

Amazon is notorious for counterfeit products. They sell for a few dollars less but it is a poor quality or the ingredients are different. I discovered that with name brand high price products. I discovered it because I wanted to repurchase a product i had been using for a few years. The product that arrived was not the same. Then I noticed that the Logo was slightly different. So I ordered the product directly from the manufacturer and it was easy to see there was a difference. Always research the return policy in detail. Take a screen shot of the return policy. Trust me return policies can change dramatically.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Good to know!

[@kathyjames9796]

I appreciate the thought you put into this video. I am curious about the company that makes your brushes. I didn't quite understand the shipping information, but it looked like they came from another country. I am confident that you picked a manufacturer that reflects your values. Thank you for putting some good reflection and critical thinking into this conversation!

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Well, that is an interesting story. They are a UK company and make their regular stock brushed in the UK but what I didn't realize until the brushes came out was that all of the brush sets they make with youtube artists are made in China so I felt very stupid for assuming all of their brushes were made in the UK. The brushes are good, I approved my samples, but I felt bad about it and misled to be honest.

[@kathyjames9796]

@@thefrugalcrafter --you did the best you could with the information you had at the time!

[@jenniferoneill8040]

As a new viewer, I must express how well you present in this video. You are honest, but not judgmental. Love it! You have a new subscriber.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Welcome aboard!

[@craftingforalmosteveryone]

I was SO glad you brought up that Amazon sells counterfeit stamps/dies, as I've seen it to be so easy for KZbinrs to give Amazon a pass from the counterfeit discussion and they should be held to task as Aliexpress/Wish and Temu are... My channel isn't affiliated with anyone and is non-monetized and I like to try new stores like Temu, so my viewers know if the product qualities are there, and I try very hard to avoid buying counterfeits. Sandy

[@thefrugalcrafter]

I think anytime you have many sellers you have to look at each one as its own store. You can't trust every seller on amazon just like you can't demonize every seller on tumu or aliexpress.

[@craftingforalmosteveryone]

So true.

[@KellyTaylorCards]

Hi Lindsay. Long time subscriber, first time commentor 🤣 First, I have nothing but respect and admiration for your forthright delivery. I appreciate honest people as I am pretty similar. A few things of note after watching the video. 1. I am one of those people who was "Don't shop at Temu" and I still hope people don't. However, I appreciate you calling me out on being judgy. I'll be working on that. 2. I know several stamp company owners that are all American made that still have their stuff stolen from sites like Temu. It's not just companies making in China. 3. I don't have an affiliate on Amazon but I think the reason it's complained about less is because it's not as prevalent as it is on Ali and Temu. The companies are paying employees whose only job is to find these knock offs and report them. 4. As someone who makes a living doing this, you are correct starting a stamp channel to make money is a poor decision 😂 5. I have had people complain I used an old butterfly. Doesn't keep from using old stuff but I do frequently mix it with new as well. Thank you so much for the refeshing conversation. I appreciate you! Oooh oh and cookie washing is real and it's trash. Kbye.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Hi Kelly! Thanks for popping in with your comment. Great points. The issue with counterfeits is huge. I don't know who amazon hired to police it, but anytime I look at new releases in the art, crafts, and sewing section, I see a seller with 20 counterfeit stampin up stamps and die sets. That's without searching specifically for designers or companies. It's nuts! I think people are becoming aware that the quality of stamps are different and if they choose to buy stamps that are counterfeit they can say they are tricked and I guess those shoppers would be unlikely to purchase the real deal. Like how someone buying a knockoff purse is not the same customer that would buy a luxury bag. It's tough out there for sure. Interesting about the butterfly. Thanks for stopping by!

[@CreativePhenomenonArt]

I won’t knock TEMU but Tbh when I first saw them all I thought was. “I already have my sketchy website the I get my unique art supplies on”😂 As for what you said about Amazon I agree with all of it. Preach woman In all seriousness I’ve been shopping on aliexpress probably over 7 years (first clothing then art supplies) you have to know how to shop on the site tho. I just agree we’ll said Lindsay. I would never knock anyone promoting wish/ shien/ or temu but I won’t promote it on my channel because it made me feel just like you did when I asked myself that same question as you did.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

😆

[@debityger4458]

Question? Where did your marker storage come from. Does each square connect to the next one. I am moving into a smaller house and smaller craft room

[@thefrugalcrafter]

I got it from a scrapbook store that was closing. I can't find them anywhere but I have a diy tutorial here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/jWTThJd-qpt7fs0si=ziAa-UTFrSlUIGkK

[@debityger4458]

Thanks for the tutorial! It will be very useful

[@PamelasPassionforPencils]

They offered me a paid collaboration and were very specific about what they wanted me to say/post in my description box. After a couple emails back and forth with them, I decided against it and never responded back to them. I had been tempted to purchase from Temu prior to that, but never did because I just had a bad feeling about adding my personal information to their app or website. After my communications with them, I don't think I'll ever purchase anything from them or work with them in any way, especially for a business collaboration. I didn't get to sit and finish watching your whole video, but will finish it a bit later when I have some time to sit down because I'm really interested to hear your thoughts on this.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Thanks, Pamela! Another viewer did the paid temu sponsorship, but they never paid up. Super sketchy.

[@PamelasPassionforPencils]

@@thefrugalcrafter I’ve heard that a lot! It’s definitely sketchy.

[@debi_rodriguez]

I really enjoyed this video and agree with a lot of what you have said here. My mother is always talking about Temu and like you I am skeptical about how these things can be so cheap and where are they coming from. I trust amazon and i like to shop with them. Thank you for sharing the info about affiliate links because i use a lot of the links posted by youtubers that i follow and i did not know they could lose their commission in this way. I specifically use their links because i enjoy their videos and want to support them.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

It's nice to support people you enjoy while you buy normal stuff!

[@jaynereed4028]

Life is grey and convoluted. I so appreciate you, Lindsay, and the way you think, and your heart, and for taking time out of your schedule to impart your wisdom for us. I learned a lot from this video and have a new perspective, especially about how youtubers make money. I don't shop those places you mentioned for a lot of the same reasons but it's interesting anyway to hear you go in depth about it.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Thank you so much!

[@ductape723]

When it comes to cheap stuff online I’ve always said “somebody’s loosing somewhere”. And that applies to Amazon and Walmart and Temu and Shein and so on and so forth. Whether it’s laborers in the global south, the environment, the customers receiving inferior product that requires frequent replacing, the customers getting their info stolen, or the US tax dollar subsidizing cheap shipping costs and welfare because companies refuse to pay their employees a living wage. The money we might save is being paid for somewhere else by someone else. It always is. But the problem has never been the person on the fixed income buying three or four items with whatever money they have left. It’s the people buying entirely new wardrobes every season, and the $1000 Temu hauls and the clothes that get worn once and the art supplies that get used twice and the garages and spare rooms and storage containers filled with stuff that hasn’t been seen in years much less used. The problem is overconsumption. We need to use less and use what we have. Temu is just the newest cog in the consumerist machine. And the lesson about Temu shouldn’t necessarily be to evaluate where you shop (though most of us could do some good by eliminating a few of the more egregious retailers), but to evaluate what you’re buying, and do you really need it at all? Or do you already have a perfectly good butterfly stamp? Whether you buy it from Temu or from some fair trade ethical retailer, excess is excess. And in the end my biggest beef is gonna be with the retailer, not the buyer. Yes we have a personal responsibility, and we always will, but they’re the ones using all the tricks in the book to get us to buy buy buy, using every loophole to save themselves money, and mistreating their workers to maximize profits. And that’s one of the reasons I’ve always loved your videos, you still test out the new fun stuff and give good reviews so we can make informed purchases and at the same time always remind how if we already have something we probably don’t need this new thing. Whenever some art product is tempting me I always come here to check for a review because you do such a good job laying it all out there and being honest about the product that even when it’s a product you love 9 times out of 10 you’re the one untempting me cause I realize I just don’t need it and I’ve got something else already that’ll do the trick just as well.

[@PlayfullyPainting]

I love what you said about diversity and making own decision and not listening to those who try to tell others what they should do or not. We all have different opinions and should respect each other and its really ok to disagree and stay in a place of kindness. It doesnt offend me where people choose to shop or not. I love my sundresses I got from Temu. Temu is cheap because its direct buying that cuts out all the middle man and up pricing and retail cost. Just because something is cheap doesnt mean its a knock off, its just knocking off the big suits who buy in bulk the same stuff with mark ups after they put it in a pretty branded box. However I do love supporting local as well when can afford to do so.

[@ReverseConfetti]

I think you are mistaken about “cutting out the middle man.” Temu literally steals designs that other companies have worked and paid to create, has them manufactured and then sells them.

[@Stroggoii]

@@ReverseConfetti Royalties on industrial products are rarer than an astatine unicorn. The money TEMU et al are "stealing" is the loan shark's dividends and the multiple cuts customs take just for watching a ship pass through their waters. Buying from them we're ironically fighting corruption in the west with corruption from China.

[@MelanCholy2001]

You're always so nice. You're being too nice: I've SEEN people unintentionally hurt their pets and even young children with poison from that Temu place (clothing and pet supplies that literally cause hives and other skin reactions). I don't know if it's due to the orange packaging (Temu is "new to me"; I'd never shop there, or Sheen Shine whatever it's called). Temu is taking advantage of economically-distressed people all across the board (supply _and_ demand), who NEED to buy items (or work "under the gun" in whatever sweatshop Temu uses) and potentially get harmed making or using Temu items. #JustSayNo 🥺#NoTemu Thanks for doing this message, Linds!

[@Marilynlovesebiking]

I will not ever use Temu. I was not comfortable giving my info to such a company. It seemed too sleazy to me. But as you said, we do what is right for us at a certain given time. I do not like companies who steal designs and make knock offs.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

It's just like Amazon, lots of sellers. Some bad, some good.

[@jewelsauls3103]

Great topic. I agree with your points. Thank you for your ability to see both sides and articulate it.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Thanks for watching!

[@attorneycarissa]

I like getting baohung wc paper and ceramic palettes and blank temu painting tins. I've been happy with those items and they're a lot cheaper in the US. They had cute spinning pencil holders that I use for paintbrushes. AND they've never overcharged me or did anything shady. And returns are free and easy. I've been using them for 2 years now. But like I said, I'm limited in what I buy bc they can be hit or miss sometimes. Still, the price point is amazing. And they've never scammed me and they always accept returns.

[@shellgarrow]

Always appreciate your honesty- thank you

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Always!

[@lynnephelps2370]

I just want to say the $30 spent on my paint puck is the best money spent on at supplies in a long time! Amazon had knock-off versions around $12 and I thought about it long and hard then spent the $30. They deserve the rewards for designing such a great product and bringing it to market. I am very suspicious of TEMU. They are selling well below cost so they are gaining some other way. Yes it's a US company but that US-based company is wholly owned by China. Personally I suspect data harvesting for hacking and malware attacks but that's me.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

We have to be cautious for sure. Id rather pay a bit more on amazon or blick and nor worry.

[@RaindropLila7]

Hi Lindsay, I just wanted to say that I appreciate your balanced view on the subject and agree with you.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

I appreciate that!

[@wanderingstar5673]

Thank you for explaining how the affiliate can be cut out on their commission. As to items in other countries rewarding poor labor protections, low wages, no benefits, it is getting more complicated. Many of the raw materials and parts and pieces are manufactured in these countries even if assembled and finished in the USA, as well as many other first world countries. I recently discovered that the drug cartels in Mexico are targeting avocado production for takeover as it is a very profitable business and provides a legal business for money laundering. The cartels also extort legal businesses. There is probably many unsavory practices in the items we purchase , we are just unaware. 😢

[@anneross5679]

I don’t trust these countries where they almost give you everything for free. They have to be getting something out of it somehow. I read something the other day that said Temu is stealing your information.

[@lesliev7874]

I got caught up in the "I have to have every new thing" mentality. My cupboards were full. So, I did a huge purge. I kept what I used and loved but gave the rest to my grand kids, donated items, and threw away some too. I've changed the way I craft. I now mostly draw and color my own artwork and feel more fulfilled with the results.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

Great job!

[@Shines-On]

I don’t use Temu and never will for my own reasons. I’ll just leave it there. Hi, I don’t know you but thanks for the info!!! I am subscribed however cuz I’m a new artist and I will take any advice right now. I just haven’t had time to watch a video yet. Until this one. Pls everyone always go with your gut!! If something seems too good to be true, it probably is. That’s another reason I’ve stayed away from Temu.

[@kitbotbot4778]

I LOOOOVVVVVVVVE YOUR ETHICS AND THOUGHT PROCESS. I TOO AM SLOWING DOWN; TAKING EVERYTHING INTO ACCOUNT BEFORE MAKING ANY PURCHASES!

[@CallMeGailyn]

I believe, at least according to what I tried from Temu, that they sell mostly seconds or items otherwise not worthy of full price. Two identical dresses arrived with one being 3" longer than the other. A paint brush in a blister card was opened to reveal it had been damaged by being run over or twisted so badly that in order to put it in water, I first had to seal the feral to make it waterproof. Coloring books were tiny, printed on both sides (rendering them useless,) and so small I couldn't have colored them even with a fine point dip pen. That said, I did discover a terrific set of brushes meant to be disposable for doing acrylic nails, and they are perfect for painting hairlines. 6 brushes for spotting/fine lines, cost under 2.00 , and as others have mentioned, if you are retired and on a small fixed income, there are temptations. I have since stopped buying from them, because of the garbage-to-good-stuff ratio that makes me sure that all I will be doing is adding to the landfill problem. I don't judge others for using such services, I totally get it. But, if I can support someone more locally, that is where I will go.

[@adriennecollett3937]

Salute for pointing out the differences and challenges of the crafter’s world…

[@LuGam-vf1yi]

Excellent video. BTW i am a plus size woman and I have been buying my shirts/tops in the men's section for many years. They are bigger, plain coloured (flowers are not for plus size women) and most importantly a lot less expensive! Definately something wrong there in pricing the same shirts higher for women than for men. I think I have said it before, I am getting very tired of these art haul videos. We should not keep buying things because of youtubers saying it is the latest great best thing. Use what you have. Thank you for your honestly Lindsay

[@pattybell7108]

Well spoken Lindsay. Thank you.

[@thefrugalcrafter]

My pleasure!